Archive of Our Own ^beta

Chapter Text

Daylight is fading to dusk as you hurry to meet Sirius so you can head home. You are walking by a secluded alley when you are stopped by a familiar voice. 

“Alice” You turn your head, recognizing the haughty tone immediately. 

“Good Evening Jonah,” You greet the Queen of Hearts and you feel him come up behind you, perfectly manicured hand wrapping around your waist and his teeth scrape your neck. 

“You smell like dog” He hisses, hands clenching into your skin pressing his lips to your neck. 

“Jonah-” You protest at his reaction, but you don’t pull away. It isn’t a secret that the two Queens both like you, and you try to stay neutral, but your attraction to both of them is so strong. A voice pulls your attention from the vampire behind you. 

“Little Lady- “ The voice starts but stops as he gets closer. Jonah turns around still holding you and pressing kisses to your neck. 

“Hello Sirius, is something wrong?” Jonah’s voice holds a smirk as anger flashes through Sirius’s eyes and you know something is about to go down. 

“Sirius” You protest as he stalks closer to the two of you, his eyes constantly glowing brighter.

“Get your hands off her Jonah” Sirius’s voice was darkening and you can see his fangs and claws coming out, but the hands don’t leave your waist. 

“Why? So you can put your hands on her instead? Do you really think I would let a feral animal like you touch her?” Jonah asks, and you can feel the air shifting as both of the men size each other up. 

“Having her with me is better than having her in the hands of a bloodsucker” Sirius growled and Jonah doesn’t respond, just moving his hand up from your waist to your breast and running his nose along your neck. A soft moan escapes your lips and you can’t help the pleasure pooling in your core. “ It seems like she wants me.” Jonah continues and you silently curse your body and the reactions, know that Sirius can smell how much you are enjoying Jonah’s touches. 

“She would be much better with me” Sirius responds, eyes meeting mine. “Wouldn’t you Little Lady?” The tone in his voice and his nickname for you leave you weak and you feel thoroughly torn by having to choose one of the Queens. 

“We could always have a competition, we can see who is the better lover, whoever she chooses will be the one to take her heart.” Jonah proposes and you feel your eyes go wide and Sirius smiles smugly at him. 

“Do you really think that you have a chance against me Queen of Hearts?” Sirius asks as Jonah leads you down the alleyway to your house, Sirius is following right behind. 

“Do you think you have a chance against me? “ Jonah retorts and suddenly the three of you end up in your room before you can even process what’s going on. The door to the room is locked and both men look at you expectantly.

“What are you guys talking about?” You ask confused and Sirius is the one who explains. 

“Well Little Lady it’s simple, I want him to fuck you, just so you know I can do it better,” Sirius says and Jonah glares at him before adding his two cents. 

“We are going to both please you, and after we are done you can tell this pied piper jerk how much better I am.” He declares, walking forward and catching your waist in his hands. You look up into his glowing amber eyes, starting to feel entranced. Sirius sits down on the sofa and takes off his shirt, watching the two of us. Jonah catches your chin with his fingers before kissing you. The taste of strawberries and something you can’t place causes you to sigh. He deepens the kiss, intertwining your tongues as his nimble fingers your dress. Backing you up to bed Jonah helps you out of your dress and unsnaps your bra letting it fall to the floor forgotten. You hit the bed, allowing yourself to fall against the soft blanket and Jonah crawls on top of you raining kisses on your neck, collarbone, and down to your breasts. He sucks a nipple into his mouth as you moan, breaths starting to get heavier as the desires start to pool in your core. Jonah teases your nipples as his finger trails down and snaps your underwear against your core causing another rush of desire. 

“Jonah Please,” you beg, completely forgetting about the other Queen in the room, your eyes only on the gold eyes Queen of hearts above you. A smirk graces his features as his fingers enter you and stretches you out,  his thumb finds your clit, rubbing circles as you feel your orgasm build. 

“Oh Jonah, please, don’t stop” you beg, feeling your orgasm rapidly approaching. Jonah’s mouth leaves your breast and trails down to your core, tongue replacing your thumb as he sucks on your nub, groaning when he feels your core clench around his fingers and your hand clenches his hair, pulling him into you. He lets you ride his face, the smirk of hearing you cry his name not fading, even as you come on his face. He reemerges to pull off your panties and line up with your core. With a firm passionate kiss, he enters, muffling your scream as you get used to the intrusion. Growls from the sofa reveal a jealous-looking Sirius, his eyes are a dark purple, the room casting a slight glow to them. His fists are clenched as he watches Jonah pound into you, cries of his name falling from your lips. You can feel the thrusts from Jonah starting to stutter as he grows close, his face falling in the crook of your neck. With a low hiss he pierces the soft spot of your neck, drawing a little blood and forcing your body into a powerful orgasm. Your vision goes white as you clench completely around him, drawing his orgasm out of him and forcing him to come deep in you. Thrusting slowly, he withdraws his fangs and kisses the rest of your neck, waiting for you to come down from your pleasure before withdrawing from you. 

“Move Queen of Hears, it’s my turn.” Sirius can’t contain his growl and you open your eyes to see Sirius has pushed Jonah out of the way. He sits next to you on the bed and pulls you into his lap resting your head against his chest. 

“Easy Little Lady, you need to calm down before we continue” he shushes you, one finger running along your jaw and the second runs through your hair. Pleasure pools through your core as his finger traces your curves, his lips following down to your breast. You let out a moan, shuddering when he sucks a nipple into his mouth and tugs on your hair. Whines of his name encourage him as he lifts you, slowly lowering you down onto his cock and you tilt your head back, your hands finding purchase in his hair. Sirius kisses you as he starts to move faster, his hips thrusting up into yours harshly. Cries of his name fall from your lips, the pleasure is building stronger and stronger. 

“Want me to go faster?” He whispers huskily in your ear, nipping the lobe to elicit a cry from your lips. 

“Yes, yes, yes” You beg, eyes rolling back in your head as he quickly flips you both over so he is hovering over you and raises your legs up to his shoulder. Your hands are brought up above your head and you stop trying to muffle the pleasure as Sirius fucks you as hard as he can into the bed. You hear angry hissing from the sofa and can tell that Jonah struggling to watch you get fucked by another man. A nip to your neck guides your attention back to Sirius and he kisses you again. Your pleasure comes crashing around you fast and without warning as stars bursting in your vision. Sirius helps you ride your orgasm before speeding up and chasing his. Sirius’s hips stutter as he grows near his orgasm, his face finds purchase in your neck and he breathes in. 

‘Mine, all mine” He growls into you as his thumb hits your clit to bring your pleasure crashing down around you. You come around his throbbing cock and you can feel him growling into your neck, his shoulders and thighs tremble as he slowly pulls out with one final kiss. He collapses next to you on the bed, massaging your hips where he dug in. Kisses along your shoulder brings your attention to Jonah who has reappeared on the bed, a washcloth to wipe away the mess you’ve created and you give him a slow sweet kiss brushing his minty locks from his face. With both queens on either side of you, their hands running over your body soothingly you feel exhaustion tug at your mind. 

“Rest Little lady, when you wake up you can tell us who you choose” Sirius soothes me and you sigh, closing your eyes and falling asleep, knowing exactly who you’ll choose when the time comes.