Chapter 1: Chapter 1
Chapter Text
The Orpheum Theater was alive with golden warmth, its vintage chandeliers casting a soft glow over polished wooden seats. December 1995 in Los Angeles felt crisp, yet the air inside the theater hummed with anticipation. Luke Patterson adjusted the strap on his guitar, his fingers brushing over the strings nervously. For a moment, he felt invincible—like nothing could touch him in that moment—but deep down, a small voice whispered uncertainty.
Reggie Peters tapped his drumsticks on the edge of his kit, bouncing with energy and excitement. His family always seemed to be in a state of tension, arguments bubbling just beneath the surface, but here, in this moment, he felt free. Alex Mercer, quiet and slightly anxious, adjusted his keyboard settings, his fingers brushing over the keys with a nervous rhythm. Julie Molina, standing at the side stage, smiled at him reassuringly, though her own chest felt tight.
Bobby Wilson, sitting a few rows back, watched quietly. He hadn’t touched the street hot dogs earlier—something in his gut told him not to—but now he couldn’t shake a gnawing sense of guilt. He had eaten differently, but maybe that mattered in ways he didn’t understand yet.
The performance began, and the crowd roared. Luke’s guitar soared, Reggie’s drumming pounded with precision, Alex’s melodies intertwined perfectly, and Julie’s voice filled the theater like sunlight. Bobby’s hands tightened around his soda can, silent, unnoticed, invisible.
The set ended in triumph. The applause thundered. The boys laughed, exchanged glances full of unspoken camaraderie. And yet, in the back of Bobby’s mind, a small, nagging dread began to grow.
Chapter 2: Chapter 2
Chapter Text
The first knock came at the Patterson home around 1:15 a.m. Emily Patterson’s heart leapt into her throat. She bolted upright, her breath quick and sharp. Mitch, stirring beside her, rubbed his eyes.
Officer Ramirez’s voice was careful but firm. “Mrs. Patterson, Mr. Patterson… I’m so sorry. Your son… Luke… he’s been brought to the hospital. He… he didn’t survive.”
Emily froze. Her hands flew to her mouth. “No… no, this isn’t real. He… he was fine tonight. He was… home.”
Across town, Miranda Peters’s hand clutched Stevie’s tiny shoulder, shaking as she tried to protect him from the words she already dreaded. Jared’s face was pale, rigid, his usual anger and control dissipating into sheer disbelief. Marcus sat on the edge of the couch, fists clenched, jaw tight. Liam leaned against the wall, staring at the floor, retreating inside himself.
In Seattle, Allison Mercer’s phone rang. She picked up immediately, the voice on the line breaking her world into fragments. “Alex… he’s gone. He didn’t make it.” Her knees buckled, her hands clutching the chair arms as though she could hold herself together through sheer force. Alex, her brother, her confidant, was gone.
Bobby Wilson remained in his car outside the Orpheum, frozen, the weight of survivor’s guilt pressing down like a boulder. If he had eaten the hot dog… if he had…
Chapter 3: Chapter 3
Chapter Text
The drive to the hospital was silent, thick with despair. Emily clutched a worn photo of Luke in her hand, tears streaking her face. Mitch’s knuckles whitened as he gripped the steering wheel, trying to contain the sobs that threatened to shatter him.
Miranda and Jared arrived with their three remaining children, the atmosphere tense and suffocating. Stevie buried his face in his mother’s arms, Marcus’s hands clenched into fists of restrained rage, Liam sat silently, his mind shutting out the world.
At the hospital, doctors were blunt yet empathetic. Battery acid poisoning from street hot dogs. Words that should have been incomprehensible suddenly became painfully real.
Emily sat beside Luke’s body, whispering apologies. “I should have… I should have been there. I should have kept you safe.”
Reggie collapsed in Jared’s arms, Stevie clinging to his mother. Marcus gritted his teeth, the rage of helplessness simmering inside him, Liam silent and withdrawn. Allison held Alex’s hand, letting her tears fall onto her journal, recounting memories, conversations, moments that now would never happen.
Bobby sat alone in his car, guilt crushing him. He hadn’t eaten the hot dog. He had survived while they didn’t. He had taken music for granted. He had been careless.
Chapter 4: Chapter 4
Chapter Text
Returning home was like entering a vacuum of silence. Phones rang, calls were made—to friends, relatives, schools. Los Feliz High would prepare a moment of silence, offering counseling to those who needed someone to talk to.
Emily and Mitch grieved quietly but with sharp edges of guilt—regret for the choices Luke had made that Christmas, for their inability to prevent his runaway. Miranda and Jared’s arguments resurfaced, more tense than ever. Allison turned to journaling, speaking to Alex through her words, keeping his presence alive.
Stevie painted furiously, expressing anguish in swaths of color. Marcus abandoned college, wandering, seeking freedom in the unknown. Liam retreated into his room, isolating himself. Bobby spiraled into drugs, alcohol, and theft, trying to replace the lost music of his friends with his own hollow copies.
Chapter 5: Chapter 5
Chapter Text
Funerals spanned several days, each an intricate dance of grief, anger, and memory.
Luke’s was filled with music, soft piano, friends’ anecdotes, tears and laughter intertwining.
Reggie’s combined chaos and love: storms of emotion, arguments simmering alongside heartfelt memories, friends performing his favorite songs.
Alex’s was intimate. Allison read from her journal, recounting shared moments, his humor, his courage in coming out, his life that would never fully be lived.
Bobby attended, silent and hollow. He watched, unable to cry, unable to forgive himself, a spectator of the loss he had survived.
Chapter 6: Chapter 6
Chapter Text
The garage smelled of old wood, faintly of paint and dust, sunlight streaming in through high windows, illuminating scattered instruments and faded posters of bands long gone. Julie flipped through sheet music, eyebrows furrowed. Something wasn’t right.
Luke, Reggie, and Alex—still vibrant in their ghostly forms—hovered beside her, tense. Their fingers traced familiar chords on guitars and keyboards.
“Julie… these songs,” Luke said softly, his spectral fingers hovering over the notes. “Someone’s been… taking them.”
Julie’s eyes widened. “What? Who—”
Bobby Wilson stepped into the doorway, hands shaking. “I… I didn’t mean to. I thought no one would notice.” His voice was hoarse, heavy with decades of guilt.
Reggie’s eyes narrowed, hurt flashing across his face. “You… you stole our songs?”
Bobby looked down, unable to meet anyone’s gaze. “I was… lost after… after you guys died. I didn’t know how to cope… I thought if I made the music mine, I’d feel like I could survive. I—”
Alex’s jaw tightened. “You… you weren’t supposed to survive that night, Bobby. You knew it was because of the hot dogs.”
Bobby swallowed hard. “I didn’t eat them. I didn’t know it would—God, I didn’t know it would hurt you all. I… I couldn’t stop myself from trying to live through the music.”
The room fell into a thick silence. Julie looked between them, her hands trembling slightly as she considered the weight of decades of betrayal and grief.
Chapter 7: Chapter 7
Chapter Text
Reggie’s expression softened slightly, though the hurt remained. “Julie… could you… could you look up my family? I need to know how they’re doing. All of them… after everything.”
Julie nodded, turning to her laptop. Moments later, she read aloud:
Stevie Peters now lived in Napa, California, with his husband, a part-time school psychologist, and their dog, Coco. He was a well-known artist, painting vivid, emotional pieces.
Liam Peters lived in Austin, Texas, married to a banker, with two children. He stayed home to care for the kids while maintaining strong ties with his family.
Marcus Peters lived in Las Vegas, single, sharing a two-bedroom apartment with a roommate and co-owning a bar/music venue. Their mother lived in a retirement home in Palm Springs, divorced for over two decades.
Allison Mercer lived in Seattle, divorced for five years, a single mother of three, and worked as an assistant manager at a local diner. Her parents retired to Georgia, attending church nearly every day.
Reggie’s face tightened as he processed the information. “Stevie… he’s… gay?” His voice was quiet, a mixture of surprise and realization. “I… I didn’t see that coming, but… I just… I’m happy he’s happy. That’s what matters.”
Julie nodded. “It’s a shock, yeah, but he’s been living his truth for years. Everyone’s had their journey.”
Alex’s face fell slightly. “Allison… she has three kids now? And they’re divorced… it’s… it’s good to know they’re okay.”
Luke reached out to touch Julie’s shoulder. “It’s been 25 years. People survived in their own ways. Some better, some… not so much. But they’re still here.”
Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Chapter Text
Julie paused, reflecting on what she knew of the others:
Bobby had lived decades drowning in guilt, using drugs, alcohol, and theft to cope with surviving the night that had taken his friends.
Stevie turned grief into art, painting every feeling he couldn’t say aloud, finding love and stability in Napa.
Marcus left college, seeking freedom in the unknown, exploring the world and running a music venue that reminded him of the boys.
Liam isolated himself, finding comfort in the quiet of family life and routine.
Allison had poured her grief into journaling, creating a bridge to Alex through her words and raising her children while navigating a difficult divorce.
Emily and Mitch had carried their grief quietly, with regret shadowing their days, always wondering if they could have done more to prevent Luke’s runaway.
Julie could feel the weight of 25 years compressed into that garage, the echoes of loss resonating in every note, every corner.
Chapter 9: Chapter 9
Chapter Text
Julie gathered everyone, including Emily and Mitch, who had flown out to see the boys. The air was thick with emotion, every heartbeat echoing the years of sorrow, love, and memories lost.
As the ghostly boys and their families met in the garage, there were tears, tentative hugs, and quiet words. Stevie showed his paintings, Liam’s children ran around the instruments, Marcus spoke about the bar and the music venue, and Allison shared stories of Alex’s life through her journal.
Bobby, standing awkwardly, finally spoke. “I… I’m sorry. For everything.” His voice trembled. “I thought… I thought I could live through music… but it wasn’t the same without you.”
Reggie, placing a hand on Bobby’s shoulder, nodded. “You hurt us… but we’re alive now. That matters too. And we can forgive, in time.”
Julie smiled, tears streaking her face. “This… this is closure. And maybe a beginning, too.”
The garage, once a place of rehearsal and joy, became a sanctuary—a space where grief and love could coexist, and where memories could be honored without pain consuming them.