Comment on Harry Potter and the Respawn

  1. Chaos_Snow_Kitsune on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 09:11AM UTC

    Alright then. Both kinda glad and sad about that. On one hand Hermione won't be in it which is nice, On the other hand other loveable characters like Luna and Tonks not being in is a bit of a shame.
    I'll still give it a shot when I have a bit more time though

    Comment Actions

    1. Cleddyf on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 12:31PM UTC

      TTGL

      Yeah, I rarely do harems or enjoy harems. Often, the focus is odd and you end up with one 'main girl' and the others are just there for titillation. Which I hate.

      I have one harem idea that may see the light one day, but yeah. I /may/ use Luna in a story I'm idly outlining now, though, for when I finish this one.

      Comment Actions

      1. Chaos_Snow_Kitsune on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 01:55PM UTC

        Yeah that is one of the most annoying parts about harem fics and I actually like reading them. Kinda why I like it when the harem is no more then 5 unless it is either smut or a crack fic. Sometimes I wonder why some stories are a harem because as you said there is one main girl who gets most of the spotlight.

        Seeing as you mentioned Luna and not Tonks I'm take a wild guess and say you aren't a fan of the Honks pairing

        Comment Actions

        1. Cleddyf on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 03:08PM UTC

          TTGL

          Actually, I rather am. She just doesn't fit the next story I'm probably writing after this one, which is a cracky "Harry is Athena's Child" fic. Basic premise of that is Lily really wants a child but can't have children due to something I won't talk about yet. Both she and James have attracted Athena's interest, so Athena has a child with James so Lily and James can have a child (remember, in the PJ universe, Athena literally creates brain children, no sex). Anyway, it's going to focus on Ravenclaw a fair bit, thus Padma and mebbe Luna.

          Tonks is a possibility in a different one I may write down the line, though I only have a very basic outline. Thinking about it, that one might shift ahead of the Child of Athena one, simply due some of humor possibilities.

          Last Edited Tue 15 Sep 2020 03:20PM UTC

          Comment Actions

          1. Chaos_Snow_Kitsune on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 03:43PM UTC

            I personally know nothing of PJ never read the books or watched the movie that everyone seems to hates. Though from what little you've told me Luna fits very well. I can just see that happening.

            Nice to hear that about a possible Honks story in the future. Never enough of those. I'll be the first to admit to being a Tonks fanboy so I'd definitely give that a shot when/if it comes out.
            Though I'd like to think I'm not as nuts as other fanboys. XP

            Comment Actions

            1. Cleddyf on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 03:48PM UTC

              TTGL

              Heh. Well, we'll see which I do. I want to complete this, but I tend to plan another story while writing one, just to keep a fresh head for ideas. My main issue with the Tonks story is it has elements that are quite similar to another story, and I don't want to feel like I'm copying another author, so am playing with ideas.

              Comment Actions

              1. Chaos_Snow_Kitsune on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 06:03PM UTC

                If you don't mind me asking what story does it share similarities with?

                Comment Actions

                1. Cleddyf on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 06:11PM UTC

                  TTGL

                  Wakefan's Harry Potter and the Dance of Death. Details would differ, but both involve Harry getting knowledge and power from his parents' spirits. :)

                  Comment Actions

                  1. Chaos_Snow_Kitsune on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Sep 2020 10:58PM UTC

                    Hmm... that sounds a interesting

                    Comment Actions