1 - 20 of 21 Works in Sister Paxton (Heretic)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Kinktober 2025 by 28spoons
Fandoms: Yellowjackets (TV), Heretic (Movie 2024), Companion (2025)
23 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A collection of Kinktober 2025 prompts.
Ships and prompts are outlined in chapter titles and summaries.
Every fourth day is skipped for a total of 24 days worth of fics.
-
i'm waiting for it, that green light, i want it by UnfridgedProphet
Fandoms: John Proctor is the Villain - Belflower, House of the Dragon (TV), Yellowjackets (TV), Heretic (Movie 2024), Bridgerton (TV), The Brutalist (2024), Heartbreak High (TV 2022)
22 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Sometimes you see a play. And then sometimes that play takes over your brain. And then sometimes you decide to throw all your favorite characters into that play. And then this happens.
Series
- Part 1 of Helen County
-
The Girl Who Was Left Behind by nataliescatorccio_superfan
Fandoms: Heretic (Movie 2024)
26 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
It has been 8 years since the kidnapping of two Mormon Missionaries.
Sister Paxton has tried to move on. She has a husband, a daughter, a new house. But once she starts noticing changes, she starts seeing who has been visiting her. -
Tags
Summary
sister paxton doesn't know how to masturbate, sister barnes does
-
Tags
Summary
What if sister Paxton didn’t stab Mr reed when he was attempting to sa her?
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 114
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 8
- Hits:
- 458
-
Tags
Summary
"Sister Barnes, what is it like to kiss someone?"
-
In spirit you were there, Well maybe next time by snnopluto
Fandoms: Heretic (Movie 2024)
13 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
Sister Paxton thought her punishment was over when she got out of there. But when she feels the presence of a familiar companion at random times, she begins to wonder if this is another punishment — or a form of salvation?
Sister Paxton’s POV
-
i’m back into a holy state (i don’t taste the shame) by pocketsofposies
Fandoms: Heretic (Movie 2024)
08 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
The miracles God had sent her all share one face.
-
Tags
Summary
After a stressful day's work, Sister Paxton and Sister Barnes come home to their shitty, freezing cold apartment.
-
Tags
Summary
anal doesn’t count, or, that’s at least what barnes told paxton.
-
Tags
Summary
“You know you want to,” Sister Barnes murmurs from beside her, her low voice curling deliciously around Hannah’s ear, a shiver running all the way down her spine before she remembers herself.
“I shouldn’t,” she croaks in a far less convincing voice than she’d like, before she swallows again. “You wouldn’t,” she adds in a steadier voice.
-
Tags
Summary
“I’d like you to try not to speak from now on, unless I ask for it explicitly,” he said, rubbing her back. “With the exception of one thing, which you will say if you simply can’t take any more and you want me to stop.”
“What thing,” she murmured.
He leaned down beside her ear. She stopped her struggling.
“Magic underwear."
---
Sister Paxton decides not to stab Mr. Reed in the cellar.
School is back in. -
I saw god, they said they're not keeping score by davethefish
Fandoms: Heretic (Movie 2024)
06 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Sister Paxton is alive, and alone, and doesn't know what to do. Sister Barnes is dead, and Sister Paxton's sense of religion is dead too. But she still cries out to God.
-
Tags
Summary
Barnes and Paxton's lives, separate, converging.
-
and i’m bleeding and i’m bleeding (right before my lord) by pathetictransfucksleeve
Fandoms: Heretic (Movie 2024)
30 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
in which sister paxton comes clean about some ungodly past practices and barnes offers a special type of brief comfort
-
Tags
Summary
The months and years following two Mormon missionaries entering the home of a spiritually curious man and only one leaving.
Or,
Sometimes it's not always the butterfly that Paxton sees.
Series
- Part 2 of hysterical and useless
-
Tags
Summary
Where Sister Paxton goes, a butterfly follows.
A post-canon au.
Series
- Part 1 of hysterical and useless
-
Tags
Summary
Paxton realizes over and over that Barnes is gone.
-
Tags
Summary
Four times Sister Paxton asks for the thing she wants.
-
Tags
Summary
Mr. Reed finds a new convert.
AU where Sister Paxton, upon discovering one true religion, loses the will to fight and agrees to be a prophet.
Contains spoilers for the climax!- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 387
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 16
- Hits:
- 275