Actions

Work Header

Power of Will

Summary:

Mark Hoffman is a good cop gone bad; he was never afraid to bend the rules.

Wilhelmina Maddox is a fresh detective, transferred to be partnered with Metropolitan Police Department's Detective Mark Hoffman. She prefers going by the book while Hoffman prefers to throw it out the window.

Over the twenty years of Hoffman's police career, they stand at odds on ideologies of delivering justice and cleaning up their corrupt city. When Maddox and Hoffman are assigned to investigate the Jigsaw murders, she would have no idea that the man she trusted the most was one of Jigsaw's apprentices the entire time.

This is a deep dive into Mark Hoffman's life from before, during, and after the SAW series with the Metropolitan Police Department as well as explorations on the lives of other SAW characters.

Current Progress: Hoffman now serves Jigsaw. But does he hate it as much as he thinks? The MPD have assembled a Serial Killer Task Force to catch the serial killer.
Smut Shortcuts! Located in Chapter 23, 28, 35, 46.

Notes:

Thank you so much to @WhisperDan for providing feedback/editing.

Rated Explicit for future chapters.

Peter the waiter is NOT Peter Strahm. Peter the waiter has a purpose, though.

These came from collections of one-shots of my headcanon surrounding Mark Hoffman and everyone in his life, along with this OC. I'll have intervals of Pre-Saw, Saw, and Post-Saw as well as explorations in Peter Strahm, Lindsey Perez, and all those involved with Mark Hoffman. I will attempt to stick to the movie lore as closely as possible, but may tweak things to fit into the narrative. I'll try to keep it all chronological, which is quite the challenge.

Each chapter is like an "episode" that can be read standalone, though there will be a long-term plot. I hope you like it!

Chapter 1: Pre-Saw: Death in the Family

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

“I’m going... you will need to take care of each other,” Darcy Hoffman squeezed Mark’s hand. Her grip was shaky, her skin dry and cold. Bandages covered one of her eyes while they were stained like red wine on white sheets. The beeping of the heart monitor was the only noise heard through the tense hospital room. His mother, strong and unafraid, had to pause in between words with ragged breath. “I’m going… to be with your father soon. I’m sorry I can’t… stay. You only have each other. Don’t ever turn your back... on your family. I… will always… be with you.”

“We will,” Angelina Hoffman was grimace-smiling through teary eyes, lips squeezed in a tight line. She leaned forward and put her hand over her mother’s, sandwiching Mark’s large fist. Small hands, both of them had such tiny digits. Delicate hands. When did they become so small? “I love you, Mom. Please don’t go.”

It had only felt like yesterday that his mother towered over him, the one in charge. She had been the one person he always looked up to; but at this moment, she looked so frail. Weak. Who knew a fucking tweaker behind the wheel could take down such a powerful woman. It’s not fucking fair, he clenched his fists tightly at the tops of his thighs. Not like this. He felt the dangers of tears breaking across his vision, blurring his world. No, not like this.

“Love you, mom,” Mark said, holding back the lump in his throat as he forced his composure to stay straight and strong. His eyes burned but he clenched his jaw and forced them dry. He squeezed her hand, willing his warmth and life into her. He didn’t want her to go. He wasn’t sure how he could hold on without her to guide him. Their father had died on impact. His mother was barely hanging on. It must have hurt. He knew it must have hurt more than he could have imagined. “I’ll look after Angie. Don’t worry, I promise. Tell Dad… I’m sorry.” He blinked to realize that a tear had escaped, sliding like ice down his cheek.

Darcy’s eyelids were beginning to flutter. Her labored breathing rattled outward, sighing out her final breath. The heartbeats were irregular. Slowing.

Angelina’s sobs crescendoed as the monitor wailed. He put his arm around her, letting her hang onto him as she broke down. His shoulder had a warm damp spot growing on it. He hung onto that sensation, distracting him from shedding any more tears of his own. She can cry for both of us. He stared at a generic picture hanging on the off-white painted walls. Flowers in a vase. He tried to keep himself focused on the pale blue ceramic and the cream-shaded petals.

It’s just us two. He returned to his younger sister. She was only eighteen. Still a kid, finishing up high school. She was planning on going to college in just a few months. She needed him, and he’d take care of her. She’d stay with him. He had just finished his time at the Academy and had a good job lined up. Sure, he was only on a rookie’s salary. But they’d make it work. He’d work hard. He’d get promoted. He’d do what he needed to do, so Angie could go to school and have the future she deserved.

“It’s going to be okay, Angie,” He told her, rubbing her back as her weeping lulled into hiccups and gentle crying. He reached towards the nurse call button, pressing the plastic down while keeping one hand on the back of his sister’s delicate spine. He’d take care of her. He promised.

(Power of Will)

It had been a week since the funeral and Angie still hadn’t eaten anything. He got to their apartment early that morning, having finished his shift to find Angie sitting on the couch, staring at the wall. No dishes had been in the sink. The trash can was empty. He had told her to eat something when he left twelve hours prior and she said she would. This had gone long enough.

“Angie.” He took off his policeman’s cap and sat down on the recliner across from Angie’s sofa, eyeing her blank expression.

She turned to him, shadows under her eyelids, hoodie hanging loosely over her emaciated shoulders. He could see her neck bones. Her harrowed face pulled the trigger in his skull, making him decide to take some action.

“We’re getting breakfast.”

“I’m not hungry,” she muttered, looking away again.

“Hey.” He leaned closer to her, his chest tight as he willed her to just look at him. To just try. “Angie. Please.” He waited a few moments, his mind reeling with desperation. “I haven’t eaten yet and I’m starving. I need a hot meal but don’t want to sit alone at the diner like a loser. Will you at least come with me? Keep your brother company?”

She blinked, turning her face to him with a pained expression. “I’m sorry,” she whispered. “I should have made you something.”

“No-,” he resisted the urge to smack his palm to his face, backpedaling. “You don’t need to do any of that. Just - have breakfast with me. Let’s go to Druther’s. Like we always do. Come on, Angie, please?”

She seemed to ponder this, her light brown eyes unfocused. “Okay.” She nodded. “I need to take a shower first.”

“Do that. I’ll change.” He felt his heart skip in excitement when she stood up and went to the bathroom. This was progress. This was good.

He heard the water running. The apartment he got them had been what a new policeman could afford and was certainly enough space for just the two of them, but it was run down and worn. He had wanted to move closer north to be near Angie’s college, but they couldn’t afford the rent. The money from their parents’ life insurance went straight to funeral expenses and the rest to Angelina’s tuition. They weren’t in debt, which frankly, was more than he could have hoped for. They would be okay, at least. Sure, it wasn’t the Ritz, but they had each other. They just needed to take it one day at a time. In his new bedroom, he slowly took his uniform off, wincing when he went to shrug out of his unbuttoned shirt. His ribs stung; his thin undershirt didn’t do much to conceal his bruises. His chest was a barrel of patches that brought agonizing aches every time he took a breath. He studied himself in the mirror.

His shift had been a shit show. He had been called over a domestic dispute that had escalated into a full-on pursuit and tactical response. He had to run several blocks and tackle a man about his build just a few hours prior and had gotten into an altercation where the suspect resisted. And happened to be an underground boxer. A dirty fighting cage brawler. It was rare coming across someone in his weight class that knew how to fight and though he smirked at the memory of knocking the guy out, striking the teeth off his jaw like it was T-ball, he had to walk away with a limp and in desperate need of some ice for his shoulder.

He had gotten the bastard pinned down after taking several heavy blows to the ribs and chest. Thankfully, the bruises on his torso were easily hidden with a t-shirt. Angie didn’t need to see them. She was a total hippie. A pacifist that cringed at the sight of guns, covered her eyes during fight scenes in movies and paled at the sight of blood. Sometimes, her naivety made him roll his eyes. But mostly, he wanted more than anything to keep her that innocent for as long as possible. The world was dirty and cruel. She was like a candle in a cave and he was desperate to not have the light snuffed out.

After struggling into some fresh clothes, he went back to the living room to wait for his sister, turning the TV to the news. The anchorwoman was discussing the opioid epidemic riddling the city. His lip twitched in a sardonic sneer before he switched the channel, switching it to some talk show he didn’t care about. Some outdated celebrity was talking about a kitchen appliance that would change the entire home cooking experience and the course of history. Oh boy.

His throat felt dry and he had a strong urge to go to the fridge and pop open a cold one to help take the edge off. But he knew Angie never cared for his drinking. Instead, he opted for a glass of water, downing it with a couple of pills of aspirin crushed between his teeth.

He slowly lowered himself onto the sofa, leaned deeply into the back of the sunken cushions, head tossed back to stare passively at the stained ceiling. A water stain had begun to seep across the cracked surfaces, rotten and beginning to blacken with mold. It made his nose itch. He needed to get them out of this shithole as soon as possible. He either needed to start climbing the ladder like an ape on steroids or transfer to a department far from the cesspool of this city. It wasn’t likely Angie would want to leave, though. She was already set up to start classes in a month. She was about to begin her life, in the very city she was born in. Where her parents were born. Like it or not, for her sake, this was where he was stuck. He’d make do.

He just had to get promoted to Detective and things would improve. At least then he wouldn’t have to wear the uniform every day. He closed his eyes, counting the months it was likely going to take before he’d even be up for a promotion.

The rushing water had ceased and after some distant rustling, the door creaked open. “Ready?” Her voice was soft.

He opened his eyes and slowly rolled his head to study her. She had put on a black hoodie and some faded jeans. Her face was pale and lined with more stress than her age should have allowed. She looked older than he felt.

“Yeah,” he half growled from sleep deprivation. Despite how tired he was, he had to keep going. She was trying, for him. The least he could do was try as well. “If I don’t get some coffee in me soon, I think I’m going to pass out.”

Angelina Hoffman

They sat at a booth by the windows at a corner of the diner, allowing Mark the comfort of keeping his back at a corner while Angie could gaze out the large windows and watch the people going about their lives. The windows were thin and let the cold chill bleed through their panes. She shivered in her clothes, not remembering feeling this frigid from the typical dreary autumn morning.

The waiter approached, kind hazel eyes surrounded by long lashes and a wide white smile greeting them. “Well good morning, beautiful. To what do I owe the pleasure of serving you this morning?”

She blinked up at the man, taken aback by the brashness. She knew she looked like a mess. She smiled at him sympathetically. “Thanks. You really know how to earn those tips.”

He winked at her. “Coffee?”

“Yeah,” Mark’s voice was heavy and sluggish but his eyes were sharp and lightning blue, pulling attention to them like a homing beacon. “And mind yourself around my little sister.”

“Mark,” Angie let out a warning groan, “He’s just goofing. Lay off.” She returned to the waiter, noting his nametag. “Peter. I’ll have orange juice.”

“Coffee and OJ, coming up. By the way, our breakfast specials today are-”

“Not interested,” her brother waved him off, still giving him a stare of passive hostility, like an oncoming storm about to wreck a little sailboat’s Sunday float.

The young man let out a half-smile-half-sympathetic-wince to Angie before turning awkwardly away and fleeing behind the counter. She spun to him quickly. “What’s your problem?”

“My problem is I don’t want to watch some creep try to pick up my kid sister right in front of me when I just want some breakfast and a cup of goddamn coffee. Is that too much to ask for?” He turned his frustration to her, mouth pursed into that pout that Mom used to tease him would get all the girls if he just learned to tone down the temper.

“He wasn’t picking me up, Mark.” She threw one fleeting glance in the man’s direction, feeling a slight tremor of disappointment. She turned back to her brother, noting arms were both splayed on the table in front of him, his shadowed eyes watching her incredulously. “What?”

“Oh my god, you like him? That prick?”

“Shut up,” she looked down at her hands, casting defiant eyes back up in between batting her lashes. “You’re just cranky because you need to sleep.”

“I’ll sleep when I’m dead,” he droned, pawing at the sugar packs at the side of his table and shaking the paper packaging. “Besides, how can I sleep when I have to fight all these pricks off my sister?”

“You’re the one being the asshole,” she whispered back, feeling the Hoffman family rage come to her. It helped warm her up and bring awareness to her limbs. She wanted to smack him. It felt good, this anger. It helped distract from the pain.

“Yeah. I am. You’re right.”

She started up to see Mark had a smirk on his mouth, the anger from before having melted away. “Well, maybe I’d rather see you throw Bambi eyes at some average guy with a steady job over just staring at the wall in that shit apartment. Lately, I'm starting to see that there are worse ways people deal with their grief. As long as he's not strung out and treats you with respect, fine.” She blinked slowly, realizing he was giving his approval. “But Angie, focus on school. Guys like that are a dime a dozen. As soon as you start classes, I'm sure you're going to have your choice of idiots once you live on campus. Unless - you know.” His cheeks went slightly pink. “You’re always welcome to stay with me. You know that. But I know you want to start living your life. I just don’t want to see you trapped. Getting distracted with the first guy you've seen after...” He shook his head. "Nevermind, I'll just shut up."

Well aware that she had been letting herself simply fall apart while Mark had to watch the show, her eyes stung. It had just been too hard. She hadn’t been able to cope like Mark had. He was always the tough one. He was able to go straight to work as soon as the funeral was done as if Mom and Dad weren't buried under all that dirt. “Yeah, you’re right. I’m sorry.” She felt like it was unfair. That she didn’t have any time to grieve.

“No, don’t apologize.” Mark dropped the sugar packs and pointed his finger at her as he quickly backtracked. “You did nothing wrong, you understand me? I’m not saying that-,”

“Coffee,” the waiter interrupted, placing the white mug in front of Mark and the glass of orange juice in front of Angela. “Orange Juice. With a little extra-,” He pulled out of thin air a paper umbrella and placed it in her glass. “-flair. I’m also a magician part-time. I do birthday parties and bar mitzvahs. In case you know anyone throwing one anytime soon.” She couldn’t help but giggle at that. He beamed at her and with another flick of his wrist a small notepad appeared in his hands. “So, what’ll you have?”

“How about you make with the magic and disappear.” Hoffman waved him away, unimpressed. “And take your time in coming back, we’ll need at least ten.”

The waiter retreated once again. Angelina let out a sigh, touching the little green umbrella with her fingers. “I’m thinking of taking a year off. I don’t think I’ll be up for hitting the books right away. I just need time to think. You know?”

“Yeah. Take whatever time you need, Angie.” Hoffman was pouring sugar and cream in his coffee, sipping it despite the billowing steam pouring off the top. “No rush. I just want you to at least eat something. Get out and just go about the motions. Even if it's hard. That's what I'm doing. Faking it. I know it sucks. But it’ll get easier, the more you keep going. One foot in front of the other. You know.”

“Yeah,” She gave him a small smile. “I know.” She shifted the subject, forcing herself to try to be a little less of a downer. “You know, you keep pouring all that sugar in your coffee, you’re going to get diabetes. Or worse, a dad bod.”

Hoffman let out a deep chuckle. “I hear that’s what the ladies like these days. Maybe that’s what I’m going for.”

She let out a groan. “Ugh, who told you that? Nooo.” She began to giggle, imagining Mark built like their Dad, who had been a large man. He had been as tall as Mark, but built wide and bulky. Her brother had the bone structure but was lean; he had always been on the skinnier side growing up, but he was beginning to resemble the warm, analog pictures of their father when he was a young man. It was around his age that their father got married. “What about you, Mark? Any gorgeous tall blonde vixens working in your department?”

Hoffman choked on his coffee, coughing and hacking, making Angelina sigh and get him some napkins to mop up the brown spray that covered their table.

“No.” Mark kept clearing his throat. “The ratio of male-to-female cops isn't really in my favor. Besides, who'd like this ugly mug? No, that's not what I'm looking for right now.” He was speaking hurriedly, embarrassed.. He looked suddenly younger, reminding her that he wasn't much older than she was, though he certainly acted like he was.

“You’re a handsome guy, Mark, I bet there's tons of ladies that are just dying for a chance to talk to you.” Angelina raised an eyebrow. “Is that the only reason?”

“I don’t shit where I eat, Angie.” Mark’s face was grave and serious. “I’m not at work to get laid. I don't have time to date. I want to build a career.”

Angie shrugged. “Still, one day you'll need to start a family. Can't let the Hoffman legacy just..." she cleared her throat and quickly side-stepped from that thought. "Well, any ladies you meet on cases? Damsels you've saved that fall madly in love with Prince Charming?”

Mark’s expression had gone cold and he began to wall himself off. He tended to do that when he didn’t want to talk about something anymore. “None that I’d want to ask out. It's not exactly a Disney movie out there, Angie. Most of the women I've met on the job are victims. They're not looking for some big tough guy in their life. Usually that’s what they’re trying to get away from.”

“Okay, then I guess I better just hurry up and get to college. It’s clear my brother is going to die an old miser without my help.” Her brother looked flustered, face pink and scowling at her. “What? If I’m not able to date it looks like I need to find some other use for my time. I think you are overdue for a girlfriend, Mark. I mean, if I’m going to have every cute guy get scared off, I’ll just need to go find you a nice, liberal college professor to court you and get you off my hands. Some social justice goddess to keep you in check, since you've gone and donned the blue. I don't want to see my brother on the news involved with, god forbid, police brutality. I think a nice left-leaning perspective is just what you need.” She was only joking. She knew Mark would never be in that situation. He was a good man. A kind, compassionate man. But she loved to tease him.

Mark had opened his mouth to respond, but was silenced by Peter, the waiter. “Hey,” the man shyly approached their table. “Have you two decided?”

“Mark?” Angie smiled sweetly at her older brother, waiting for him to make his decision.

He glared at her, half bemused, half furious. He turned to the man and calmly ordered, “Farmer’s breakfast. Extra hash.”

The waiter scribbled away. “And…” he seemed to have been half-hearted, casting nervous eyes to Mark as he waited patiently for her.

“Blueberry pancakes, a side of eggs,” she smiled up at him. “And your number.” She cast defiant eyes at her brother while he stared glumly at her.

Peter blinked, shot a glance at her brother and then let out a short laugh. “Well, how about you come by after twelve? I get off work. We can grab lunch. And real lunch, not breakfast food, if that's alright with you. That is, if your brother isn’t going to bury me in your backyard?” He shot another concerned glance towards Mark.

“Oh, he’ll behave. Right, Mark?” She locked eyes and stared at her brother, the two of them silently in a test of willpower.

“If you eat everything on your plate today, fine,” he growled. She broke into a triumphant grin. “Peter, it’s a date.” The waiter walked confusedly while Angie giggled. She turned to her brother. “Thanks, Moshy,” she drawled out the thanks, the way she used to when Mark would eat her peas when their parents weren’t looking.

“And please don't try to set me up with someone. I really don't have time for that. That’s part of the deal. And I want you to be home by the time I'm up for my next shift. Or I’ll be looking for that guy with a shovel.”

She shook her head solemnly. “Mark, I swear, one day your humor is going to get you in trouble.”

“Who’s joking?” He shot her a surrendering grin. “He seems harmless, though.”

“You can tell?”

“It’s the magic shit. He’s a fucking nerd.”

“Yeah, well he’s got a cute butt.”

Mark let out a groan. “Please stop.”

Chapter 2: Pre-Saw: Start of Something New

Summary:

Detective Hoffman and Maddox are assigned to work on their first case together. They stand at odds. Can they learn to put their differences aside and work together? Or are they doomed to fail at the start?

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

“Hoffman,” Captain Grissom called out to the new detective, coming out of his office towards the floor of desks on the main level of the Metropolitan Police Station. It was a typical Monday morning, the smell of burnt coffee, shoe polish, and aftershave greeted the senses. Hoffman slugged back his first morning cup of coffee, got to his feet and strode towards his supervisor. It was his first day in plainclothes, the shirt and tie feeling looser and alien after five years in the uniform. He had just been promoted that Friday to Detective. It took five long years, but he finally made it.

Angie had baked him a cake, it was a good weekend.

“Sir,” He waited expectantly, looking down at the shorter man. Captain Grissom was five foot six, stocky, and full of sass. The man had a mustache that gave him a walrus-like appearance. The big round glasses didn't help his case.

“In my office,” Grissom went in, striding to his chair behind his large desk piled with mountains of case files. A small woman with reddish brown hair was standing in black dress slacks and a light blue button-down, a badge dangling along a chain around her neck. A Smith & Wesson was at her hip, small caliber, probably because her thin wrists couldn’t support the recoil of a gun with thicker ammunition.

“Who’s this?” Hoffman wasn’t in the mood to wait for either person to explain.

“Detective Wilhelmina Maddox,” the woman introduced herself, holding her hand out. “Everyone calls me Will.”

“Detective Mark Hoffman,” he warily studied her face. She was barely reaching his shoulders, and he wasn’t that tall. She had thick red curls tied back into a bun that gave her a frizzy helmet look. Amber eyes looked up at him, large but sharp with attention. She had a firm handshake, surprisingly strong for her size. She at least had muscle. He saw the tendons in her arms flex, biceps that were more impressive than imposing, but at least they existed.

“Maddox is from California. Folks out west have said good things about you, Maddox.”

“Thank you, sir.” She broke eye contact first, pulling her hand out of Hoffman’s grip and placed the hand on her hip, next to her gun. He kept watching her, already feeling a tightness in his chest of where this was going. “I look forward to being part of the team.”

“Excellent. Well, Hoffman is one trustworthy son of a bitch. He’ll show you the ropes. This city ain’t the suburbs and you’ll need someone who will have your back while you get your bearings out here as you transition from handling cartels to our shade of crime families.”

“I understand.”

“Good.” Grissom flashed warning eyes to Hoffman. “Bradshaw is the blond to the right.” He pointed outward toward the windows that showcased the chaotic sea of desks just outside his office. “Closest to the windows. He’ll take you to your desk.”

“Thank you, sir.” The woman nodded her head towards the Captain and left.

“Shut the door, Hoffman,” Grissom leaned back on his chair.

Hoffman did so and quickly turned to the man. “She can’t seriously be my new partner. She’ll break like a toothpick in two days.”

“She’s got a cool head and a track record that’d put all you oafs to shame.”

“It takes just one time. One time for someone bigger to have the drop on her. And everything’s bigger than her. She seriously can’t expect to work the city. Why was she transferred here?”

“She made the request.”

“Get out. She’s delusional.”

“She has yet to not solve a case put in front of her. Though," he held his hand out, "they've been small change compared to what we get here. She's hungry for more. And she’s a professional. Hasn’t caused her supervisor any headaches with the paperwork that you’ve been fucking me with. She doesn’t use excessive force. She keeps her nose clean.”

“What, I don’t?” Hoffman gave a smile. “Come on, Grissom. I get results.”

“And so does she. Look. I’m not happy about getting another pretty face in here to distract all you knuckle draggers from your jobs. That’s another reason I’m putting you up with her. You keep your eye on the prize. Like a bull in a china shop, but you never get distracted. I think you two will work out. Just give her a chance. You’re brute force and raw muscle. She’ll be the brains and your leash.”

“That’s fucked,” Hoffman shook his head, folding his arms. “You expect me to watch that kid’s back and leave mine open for a knife?”

“I expect you two to look out for each other, in your own way. She’s been trained, just like you. She better hold her own, but don't just leave her to hang and dry when the going gets tough. I expect you both to do your jobs and work together. You may still be too rookie to get the big picture, but I can’t just put two heavy-handed bastards out without some moral setbacks. Why’d you think I separated you and Matthews as soon as you two swaggered through here from the Academy? Think of her like that angel on your shoulder that tells you not to pull the trigger.”

Hoffman smirked at this. “You make me sound dirty.” Besides, I already got one of those.

Grissom sneered back, good-humored. “Not at all. You’re a damn good cop, Hoffman. One of the best, though I’ll deny ever saying that if you go swinging your dick around to the boys outside. I expect you’ll go up the ranks fast, so long as you keep that goddamn temper in check and use your head. And she,” Grissom nodded off to the woman in the distance, “will join you up there. My gut is telling me she’ll be healthy for you. Just don’t fuck her.”

Hoffman let out a breath of disbelief, imagining the possibility. “Yeah. Wasn’t planning on it. I prefer blondes.”

“Yeah, that’s why I don’t hire any,” Grissom and Hoffman let out boisterous laughs.

“Fine. I’ll give it a trial run. But if she starts slacking, I’m requesting a different partner.”

“I’ll deny it.”

“Fuck you.”

“Get out of my office, Hoffman,” Grissom was looking at paperwork, having lost interest in their camaraderie.

Hoffman stepped out into an echo chamber of telephone rings, loud drunken arguments, and the rushed policemen walking about their business. He looked towards his desk coolly, noting Maddox was seated at the once empty desk right across from him. She was seated to face him. Fuck. He did not want to work with her.

She turned to look up at him. “Bradshaw got me caught up to speed.” She had opened a manila folder, the pictures of a child splayed out on the pavement with blood running down his face. “Hit and run, on 3rd and Bronson. What did the cameras at the intersection show?”

Hoffman went to his seat and slowly sank into the chair. He tried not to glare at her but knew he was failing. “Cameras haven’t been functioning in years. City budget’s been tight.”

She let out a breath through her nose, blinking rapidly and flipping through the paperwork. She was chewing her lip as she studied. “Any witnesses questioned?”

“No one we spoke to can ID the car. Or even give a description.”

“I see. Any homeless around?"

"Yeah."

"None offered anything?"

"No."

"Um… were you the one asking the questions?” She asked with a passive tone, though her eyes seemed to bore into his skull.

“Yeah. Why?”

She leaned back, tapping her finger against the file. “Call it a hunch, but mind if we go and question the witnesses again?”

He narrowed his eyes at her. “You think you can get them to remember something I couldn't?”

“Can I be brutally honest?” She raised an eyebrow and gave him a small smile. He noticed she had freckles on her cheeks. She looked younger than Angie. She shouldn’t be here. She didn’t belong here, in this trash city. “Hoffman?”

He blinked. “Shoot.”

“This is a first impression, so bear with me, but you seem kind of intimidating. A little scary.”

How the fuck have you made it this far in the force if I scare you, Maddox.

“So… imagine how someone from the street feels if you came up and just started asking them questions. If I was a witness, I think I'd be a little more stressed out answering questions from you than say… some unimposing person like me.”

At least she’s self-aware.

“So let’s take a drive. I’ll treat us to some coffee. You can wait in the car and I’ll take a shot at it.

He doubted she’d make progress, but he wanted to see what she could do. And if she failed, at least he’d get front row seats to the show. “Fine.”

When they went to the parking lot, he walked to the left of her side, though she seemed to want to outdo him as she walked faster strides to outpace his long gait. He kept his eyes straight ahead but watched her closely at the corner of his eye. He noticed a plain gold wedding band that swung at her side with a cheap sports watch at her wrist. Her fingers were unmanicured, the nails short. She looked practical, from her black shoes that weren't actual dress shoes but running sneakers and her dress slacks looked elastic-as if they were just yoga pants with pockets. He let his eyes finally wander from the bare nape of her neck and let his gaze lower to the skin-tight lycra of the curve of her backside. At least the view’s decent, he thought in passing before slamming the door on that mental room. He needed to focus. Not get distracted. It was a sure way to get them both killed.

He noted she took the driver’s side, sliding in and already starting the engine, making him go to the passenger’s side. This disoriented him, seeing her take control of the steering wheel. He didn't like that. She turned and backed out of the spot. As soon as they were off the police lot she slammed her foot on the gas and the sirens went on.

His head flew back and hit the seat headrest as she sped down the road, cars moving out of the way as the car roared through. “Jesus, Maddox,” he hissed as he gripped the sidebar of the door holding on for life.

“What’s up?” She seemed oblivious as she dodged cars, driving on the left side of the road to get around traffic jams.

“This seems excessive, the witnesses aren’t going anywhere.”

She let out a giggle, prickling his ears with the unfamiliar sensation during his working hours. That dainty laughter just wasn't something he heard when the sun was up. “Maybe. But are you telling me you city slickers don’t pull this once in a while?” She turned to him briefly before returning to study the road, dodging around more cars. “By the way… you need to give me directions.”

He scoffed in disbelief. “Seriously?”

“Yep. Sorry. I don’t know the best coffee spots yet. I only arrived last month. Where to?”

He figured she was flexing her driving skill, trying to earn some brownie points by flaunting her competence in her offensive driving abilities. She wasn’t bad, but it seemed unnecessary. Too showy. “Grissom said you’re a professional.”

She let out a small “Ha!” before turning the emergency lights off and silencing the siren. She stopped at an intersection red light. “Damn, I guess I’m just proving him wrong, aren’t I?”

“What’s your game?” He didn’t like whatever it was she was doing.

“Just wanted to shake things up a bit. Besides, you’re cute when you’re scared.”

He stared at her, his ears ringing. “What?”

She turned to him with a raised eyebrow. “I’m busting your chops, partner. Chill.”

He didn’t like her. He decided it.

She shook her head and continued the drive, stopping at the curb in front of a nearby coffee chain. “I guess it’s basic brew, unless you have a spot. What’ll you have?”

“Just a coffee.”

“Not a pumpkin spice latte type?” She waited for him to respond. He had decided to just glare at her in silence until she took the hint. She went unphased by this, instead shrugging her narrow shoulders. “Fine, I’ll surprise you.”

She went into the cafe and he continued to watch her over a distance. She yawned and stretched, the action showcasing her feminine form and aggravating him more. This wasn’t going to work. He already knew this would end badly. He watched her wait for the drinks, her back to him the entire time. His mind was reeling with the possible options. He could request a new partner. But Grissom would give him grief. Maybe he could find someone to request her as their partner. Who? Bradshaw? Michaelson? Bates? Bradshaw needed a partner. Maybe he could put in a request. He'd talk to him. The guy would probably get on his knees and thank him for the opportunity. Wait, Bradshaw was married, wasn't he? Fuck.

Hoffman knew that was one of the biggest reasons he was paired with her. Grissom would never admit it, but it was obvious. Not many of the guys would want to explain to their wives that their partner, who they spend more time with than their spouses, would be a member of the opposite sex. It was too complicated. No one was that trusting. Cops already had high divorce rates. So he was the best option.

He noted she had ordered a box of pastries, which she supported with her forearm while holding a sealed cup in each hand. She arrived back to the car, going around streetwalkers, handing one through the passenger window towards him. “You seem like the white chocolate matcha latte type,” she passively mentioned as she went to her side of the car and sat back while taking delicate sips of her drink. The white box of pastries smelled sweet and made his stomach growl. He wasn’t going to ask her for any, though.

He glared at her, knowing she had gotten him the most prissy drink out of spite. He decided to return the favor. He held the cup out of the car, tipping it just a few degrees at an angle, waiting for her to respond. She kept her face stoic, their eyes locked dead. He gave her a dark grin as he began pouring the drink out, then wincing when some of the scalding liquid burned his hand.

“Wow,” she sarcastically murmured while handing him a napkin. “I heard you were a little thick, but--”

“Shut up,” Hoffman hissed. It was plain black coffee. Simple. Straightforward. She had thrown him off with all those yuppie lattes she kept describing. His fingers stung but he salvaged the rest of his drink, taking sips while keeping the fragments of his dignity tight to himself.

“Fine. Let’s just have a truce. Let’s just get this case done, head back and figure out what the hell we’re going to do with each other then.”

He nodded. “Yeah.”

Wilhelmina Maddox

Will knew he didn’t want her around. He made it painfully obvious, with the scowl on his lips, the squaring of his broad shoulders, and just the overall unpleasant way he treated her. She had observed his interactions with all his other colleagues - all male - and had picked up that he was giving her the double standard treatment. Typical.

That’s what gave her very little sympathy when he burned his hand when he tried to get a rise out of her by wasting a perfectly good cup of coffee like an asshat. Sure, she had acted a little brash when she decided to go full cowboy with her first time driving through the city in her assigned car. But fuck it, she never got to have the chance when she was just a suburb cop. She loved the city and how everything was so compact. It made it fun to dodge obstacles and find the narrowest alleys to brave through.

She was hoping to get a fresh start in MPD but it looked like it was going to be an uphill climb. No one knew her, which meant no one had a reason to trust her yet. She needed to prove herself, once again, to all these new faces that valued strength and power over wit and passion. She had to find ways around her limits. She had found throughout her earlier rookie years that people tended to underestimate her, which was a dangerous mistake for anyone to make. She found that the more people underestimated her, the easier it was to prove them wrong. Hoffman seemed to be making that very same mistake. She just hoped he was just passively sexist and wouldn't try to prove himself a man by other typical means.

She sighed as she made her way down towards the crime scene. It had long been secured, with no remnants of perimeters being established. Pedestrians were walking around, the intersection looking ordinary. She pulled out her notepad and flipped through the notes she had jotted down while Hoffman had been chumming it with the Captain earlier that morning. The names and descriptions of nearby witnesses were mostly the local homeless. She looked off in the distance and saw a few vagrants slumped against the dilapidated bricks, cardboard signs with sharpies begging for mercy and help, pleading out to the people who pointedly ignored and walked over them.

“Okay. Wait here. But back me up if things get dicey?” She shot him a questioning glance. “Hoffman?”

“I’ll keep my eye on you,” Hoffman muttered, avoiding her eyes.

“Thanks.” She took the box and left the car, clearing her throat and taking a leisurely stroll towards the vagabonds.

“I come in peace,” she called out as they looked up to her approach. They eyed her weapon and badge. One got up, squatting in preparation to run. “I’m not here to arrest anyone. I just have some questions about a hit and run. I know none of y’all had anything to do with it, but I just want to help his mom find closure. And there are some fresh muffins right here, all for you guys.” She squatted down to their level and opened the box, holding it out to the gaunt men, waiting for them to make the next move.

“We ain’t seen nobody,” one skinny, dirt-caked hand shakily reached out and grabbed a pastry. He looked down at it and then back at her. “Who’re you?”

“My name’s Will. I’m investigating a hit and run that happened,” she pointed at the intersection, “right over there Wednesday night. Little black kid was hit. His mom is heartbroken. Can anyone tell me about it?”

“Was he riding a bike?” Another man took one of the muffins, taking hungry bites and reaching for another in his spare hand. She placed the box in the middle man’s lap.

“Yep.”

“I saw it.” The third man shook his head. “It was a fancy car. Some rich guy.”

“Did you have a color?”

“Yeah. If you got twenty dollars.”

She smiled at the guy. “What’s your name?”

“None of your business, doll.”

She sighed. “Well, if I have information that is useful to this investigation… there is a reward.”

“Oh yeah?”

“Yeah. But I’ve got to hear the right information.”

“Sure. How do I know you’re telling the truth.”

“Well, I brought muffins. Doesn’t that make me trustworthy?” She smiled sweetly, her heart skipping a beat as she felt herself grow nervous. This could be a dead end.

“A little. Better than that partner of yours. You ask nicer than he does.” The man nodded towards her car, where Hoffman made no effort to hide or look as uninvolved as possible. "He broke my sign. I had to find a marker to make a new one. You have any idea how hard it is to come by one legally, miss?"

She sighed.

“Yeah, tell me about it. He’s kind of an asshole.”

The group laughed at this, snickering at the woman calling the big scary cop names. “Aight. Because you’ve been so nice, maybe I have seen something. But I want some proof that you’re going to keep your word about that reward.”

She pulled a wad of cash out of her sports bra. The men whistled, elbowing each other at the show. She counted the bills and handed him the money. “Here’s a down payment. There’s more in it for you if what you tell me is useful.”

“Honey, I’ve got some juice for you.” He leaned forward, his breath smelling of old liquor, onions, and baked goods. His fingers were yellow and melted to the bone. “It was an orange Mitsubishi. License plate was from this state. Said ‘sunrise’ on it.”

She raised both eyebrows. “You’re not yanking my chain, are you?”

“Not at all, Will. Not at all. Thought the car was a little loud. That plate sure stuck in my mind. Name’s Bryce. I’ll be here. Don’t you forget about me, girl.”

“If what you’re saying is good, Bryce, I’ll be back.”

“I like chocolate chip scones. Bring me some of those next time.”

She smiled at that. “I’ll remember.” She put her hand on his arm and squeezed it. “Thank you.”

He nodded and took another muffin from the box in his lap, chomping down. She got up and walked back to the car, ears humming. This was either one lucky break or a huge waste of time. But she was an optimist. She got into the car, letting out a breath.

“Well?” His deep voice was dismissive.

“They said the car was an orange Mitsubishi with the license plate, ‘sunrise’.”

“Sounds like they’re full of shit.”

“It’s the only lead we’ve got.” She looked at him. “Let’s check it out.”

“Fine.” He looked out back at the three men. “You gave them money.”

“Yeah. Only way to get them to open up.”

“Still, you shouldn’t have done that.”

“Well, it doesn’t hurt to have some people on the streets in our pocket.”

Hoffman seemed to ponder this, then dialed on his phone. “It’s Hoffman. Run a registration check on an orange Mitsubishi. Local plates that say ‘Sunrise’ on it. Yeah, guy sounds like a real douchebag. Call me or Maddox when you get the results.” He hung up and nodded to her. “All right, let’s go.”

As she started the car and pulled out, he turned to her. “It’s lunchtime.”

“I can eat. What’re you hungry for?”

“I know a place. Take a left on Bronzeville.” She obliged, following his gruff instructions until they reached a hole in the wall. It was a gray brick building with no signs or indication it was a place to grab any food or do anything besides continuing to drive away. Hoffman didn’t say much, he simply got out of the car. She followed Hoffman’s lead, following him behind the unmarked door.

It was a smokey den; the smell of cigarettes, the sound of pool cues clacking, and large men turning their eyes on her greeted her as she entered.

She quickly shielded herself mentally, keeping her eyes straight ahead to Hoffman’s back. This felt like one of those machismo tests. Another way to make clear that she was not in her element. That she didn’t belong. This was not new for her. She kept her calm and joined her partner at the bar.

She noted Hoffman ordered a whiskey on rocks. The bartender raised an eyebrow at her. She ordered a coke. The bartender shot Hoffman a smirk and looked at her. “You new?”

She smiled and nodded, and the man handed her a greasy menu for her to admire and went off to serve some biker-looking types further down the bar. She turned to Hoffman, the urge to remind him that he was on-duty arose, but held her tongue. She had given him enough pain for the day. She simply swirled her straw in her drink, admiring the levels of condensation dripping down the glass as it pooled on the dirty bar top. This place sure is humid.

"So... what's good here?"

"The Jameson's cheap and hasn’t been watered down."

She sighed. "Food, Hoffman. What's good to eat?"

She looked through the list of lunch options. It was typical bar fare. Burgers, fries, sandwiches. She opted in for a chicken sandwich and fries, and Hoffman ordered a burger. He had taken a swig of his drink and was watching a football game on one of the TVs..

She smiled in her soda, enjoying how basic bro Hoffman was. He seemed to notice, blue eyes flashing at her. He glowered, his lips pressing his plump lips together in a way that made her ears feel warm. She kept her smile as their eyes locked. He had a decent face. He would almost have been considered attractive if he relaxed the hostility. She rested her hand on her cheek and let out a frustrated groan. “Come on, Hoffman. Lay off the scary guy routine. I’m not your enemy.”

He turned. “Look. I’ve got nothing against you. I’m sure you’re a hardworking, honest person. But this isn’t like out west. This city is going to chew you up and spit you out.”

“I’m counting on it hitting me with its best shot,” she responded, sipping her soda. "I think I'll manage."

“Look. We can put you with forensics. Let me talk to Grissom. We’ve got positions that will be more suited for your... stature.”

She kept smiling. She had seen this coming. Despite Hoffman’s aggression, it was far from abnormal of a reaction. “I get it. You probably could literally kill me with one punch. But I can handle myself, Hoffman. During this grace period, I’m sure there will be plenty of opportunities where you’re going to see this.”

“You’re not listening-”

“No, you listen,” she slammed her glass down. “I’ve spent eight years onin the force. I’ve seen my fair share of loss and death and I’m still here. I’m not going anywhere, Hoffman. You can either accept it and we’ll make one hell of a team, or you can drag your feet and only screw yourself in the process. I’ll keep my head above water. I’ll take down the bad guys in my way, just like you have your way of serving justice to the public. I’ll fucking thrive, like I always do. I’ve made it this far and I intend to keep going. And you don’t want to know what life will be like for you if you get in my way.” She realized she was practically jabbing her finger into his chest and curled her extended finger into a fist. “Shit, you made me lose it.” She grit her teeth and turned back to her soft drink.

She hated feeling the heat of triumph pouring off him hot enough to burn. She could tell he was positively brimming with exuberance at her outburst. The bartender arrived with two baskets of sandwiches, putting their respective orders in front of each other. She huffed and angrily chewed on the french fries, staring intently at the rows of liquor bottles lined up in front of the mirror that reflected herself and Hoffman who had his head turned to her with a teasing, shit-eating grin.

“Grissom said you could keep your cool. I guess he's full of shit.”

“Yeah, well Grissom said you were a decent person worth a rat's ass, and so far you haven’t proved that right, either.” She snapped, sipping from her soda again. The sound of the straw sucking and snapping from lack of liquid to siphon through reminded her that she had already finished her drink. She was suddenly too angry to eat. “I’m going to the head. Don’t eat my food.”

He let out a harsh laugh and she stormed down the narrow hallway nearby, the only bathroom around a corner. The smell was awful. God, I can’t believe this is what he considers a good spot for lunch. She shivered at the sight of the toilet and proceeded to do her business, squatting over the seat. After washing her hands she looked up to the cracked window to see that a hauntingly angry woman glared back at her. She looked like a banshee out for blood. Shit, he got to me. She gripped the sink and let the sound of water running help soothe her nerves. He had found her sensitive spot. It was an obvious one, but she had hoped that she could keep that insecurity in check, just long enough for him to be bored and find some other way to piss her off. But she had let him see her dirty laundry. She let out a laugh.

“He’s a fucking challenge, all right,” she muttered to herself. Grissom had told her as much. She shut her eyes, recalling the conversation before she officially met Mark Hoffman.

“He’s the biggest pain in my ass, honestly. But your boys back west say you’re good to work with. A real peacekeeper. I want you to keep an eye out for him. He’s a good man but he loses himself sometimes. It’s going to be a challenge working with him, but I’ve got hopes for you.”

“May I ask why me, specifically, sir?”

“Well, really it’s partially because I think you two would be a good fit if you both can look past each other’s major character flaws.”

“Which is?”

“He’s a bit old-fashioned. He’s not going to like you being a woman. And from what Rex told me about you, I hear you can be a bit of a pain yourself. That you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder with guys like that.”

She made her reflection soften her features into a pleasant smile. Just another challenge to overcome. This was doable.

She went to leave the restroom and jumped when there was someone standing right behind the door, waiting for her. It was a stranger. Hulking, bald head glossy under the fluorescent lighting, and oily goatee framing a crooked smile, the man had intent in his eye and sausage fingers wrapping around the open door frame. “Hey.” He pushed into the bathroom and closed the door behind him.

“Really?” She let out a scoffed admonishment. “I’m really not in the mood right now.”

“Come on, baby,” the stranger went to touch her cheek. “Why you here if you’re not looking for fun?” His hand was down to his jeans, beginning to unbutton his pants. His words were slurred. He smelled of liquor. And she was pissed.

She shook her head slowly, adrenaline pumping through her veins. She raised her hands in a defensive stance. “I'd say I really don't want to hurt you, but I'd be lying.”

He laughed. “Baby, you can’t hurt me.”

She swung her foot up to his groin with as much force her hips could swing. He let out a yell, doubling over. She jammed her knee into his nose, feeling the cartilage shatter. She let out a scream as she took her gun and pistol-whipped him over the back of his head, slamming the metal onto his skull.

He collapsed and fell onto his face. She wanted to swing once more but stopped herself. She took a deep breath. Control. She huffed and walked over the man’s body, pulling handcuffs off her belt and securing the man’s arms behind his back. Her fingers itched to strike him one more time, but she resisted. He moaned so she muttered the potential charges he'd suffer. “Drunk and disorderly. Assaulting a police officer. You just fucked yourself, asshole.” He didn’t get up and she wasn’t going to try to pull him up. She left him on the floor of the bathroom, pants down to his knees and strode down the narrow hallway back out to the bar.

The commotion had attracted attention. Everyone was staring at her, Hoffman included. She narrowed her eyes at him. He must have known that fucker was back there. Either that, or he was shit at watching her back. She shook her head like a disappointed parent, walked over to him, and said, “Bring the trash to the car when you’ve finished drinking on-duty, prick.” She stormed out, the typical whistles and catcalls chasing after her. She bit her lip as hard as she could, fighting the tears that were pressing out of her eyes.

 


Mark Hoffman

She had done a number on the bastard who was currently delirious as he hoisted him up to his feet and forced him out of the small bathroom. His mind was replaying the last five minutes desperately, hoping against hope that this situation hadn’t just happened. That he hadn't just let some random drunk march under his nose to attack his, technical, partner.

He admitted it was ironic that the very reason he protested their partnership was thrown in his face. He was the one who dropped the ball. He had been watching the game, having a drink, while she had to beat this guy down by herself. He never imagined he would be the one not having her back in this dynamic. It was one hell of an existential mindfuck. Though he hadn’t been present in the altercation, judging from the jeans that had drooped down the oaf’s thighs, the visual gave him a clear indication of what happened. It made him even less sympathetic when the creep complained about his broken nose. Be happy it was just her that broke it. Blood was pouring down the guy’s chin as he coughed and sputtered.

“Put it on my tab,” he called out to Larry, the bartender who merely nodded and continued wiping the dust around on his bar. The sunlight burst as he pushed the guy outside, half blinding him. The air was warm and humid. This car ride back was going to suck.

He pushed him into the back of the car, slamming the door before taking his spot at shotgun. He dreaded having to apologize. But he knew he had to. It was only right.

She was on the phone, talking to what sounded like someone at the station. "Is that with two 'r's? Gotcha. All right, thanks a lot, Pike.” And she hung up. She kept her eyes straight ahead, waiting for him to close his door and buckle up. Her hair had come undone from its careful pullback, falling over her cheeks and framing her face in a delicate way that seemed alien to the front of the Crown Vic. She was pensive and unresponsive.

Once seated, she took the car and it soared ahead, careening around the city swiftly while they sat there in silence. The man in the back seat moaned and cried.

“Shut up,” Hoffman snapped at him. The car lurched suddenly into another lane, making his soul partially leave his body. It felt like she was intentionally driving more erratically than earlier. She’s pissed. He cast a glance at her; her jaw muscles clenched and the tendons and veins in her neck were standing out. Her shoulders were tense and her arms tight. “Maddox.”

No response.

“I should have been watching out for you. I fucked up.”

She kept her eyes on the road, lips pulled tight. She looked angrier than he’d ever seen a girl - no, woman - act. She didn’t scream or wave her arms. It was a simmering kind of hate that felt more uncomfortable than if she just got it over with and started yelling at him. He’d never seen Angie do that before. This was a foreign kind of rage.

“I’m sorry.” He wanted more than anything for her to just crack some lame joke and move on. To give him a hard time. The silence disturbed him. After spending the day with her, this new angry silence made him nervous. Especially after seeing firsthand the aftermath of the violence she could unleash when needed. It wasn't particularly brutal, not by a long shot. But it had surprised him. He didn't think she had it in her.

“You really did a number on this guy. I didn’t think you had it in you.” He licked his lips. “You… sure proved me wrong.”

She blinked and pulled into the parking lot. They had already arrived. She parked the car, turned off the engine, and simply left him alone with the moaning drunk in the backseat. He looked at the dashboard, tapping his fingers in uncertainty. She had simply walked back into the building, leaving him alone.

He took the man to the drunk tank. “Have him booked,” he instructed, “for assaulting an officer, attempted rape. And public intoxication. And whatever else you can come up with.”

The officer at the desk raised an eyebrow. “Attempted rape?”

“Yeah. It was the newbie, moron, not me.” He snapped when the man’s lips curled into a disbelieving smile.

“Oh. Well, have her fill out this, then.” He slid the form over.

Hoffman took the paper and walked up the stairs towards the main floor. He noted their desks were vacant. He looked around for that bundle of red hair, but it was nowhere to be found. He dropped the police report form on her desk and looked around.

“Hey,” he grabbed Bradshaw. “Where’s Maddox?”

The man raised an eyebrow. “She’s your partner, Hoffman.”

“She rushed in here while I was booking someone. Where is she?”

Bradshaw nodded towards Grissom’s office. Hoffman’s heart sank. Fuck. He was in deep shit. She was probably talking about his drinking. Or worse. How he had left her to take on a man over twice her body weight by herself.

He knew it was better to face this head-on, so he walked straight to the office. He barged in, bracing himself as though he would jump in an ice bath. “Look, I know I fucked up.”

Grissom and Maddox both stopped their discussion, looking up at Hoffman. Grissom had his reading glasses on. “Hoffman. What did you do?”

Maddox kept her back to him, hovering over Grissom’s desk, pointedly ignoring Hoffman’s entrance. “Sir, it looks like the vehicle in question is registered to a Forrest Rinder. We’ll need a warrant for his arrest and to seize the vehicle.”

“I understand. You did good, Maddox. Hoffman. First day on the job together and already set to close. I’m impressed. Excellent work.”

“Thank you, sir. If there’s nothing you need from me, I’m going to head home. It’s getting late.”

“See you tomorrow, Maddox.”

“Good night, sir.” Maddox pushed herself out of the office, brushing against Hoffman.

“Rinder?” Hoffman asked, feeling out of sorts.

“If the bums are speaking the truth, then it looks like the case is just about closed.” Grissom pulled out of a drawer of his desk a bottle of scotch and two glasses, pouring them in each glass. He leaned back into his chair. “Shut the door, Hoffman.”

He did so. He stood waiting for his ass chewing. He assumed it wasn't going to be about drinking on-duty, unless Grissom was going for an ironic tactic. He took the offered glass and smelled the oak. He took a sip, the warmth going down his throat like fire.

“What happened out there?” Grissom had cool eyes that would go analytical and probing with the passing of a stare.

Hoffman shrugged. “Maddox already informed you.”

“I want to hear your side. Tell me.”

Hoffman shook his head. “She did well.” His face flushed, recalling bits and pieces of the day. “I admit, she can handle herself.”

Grissom nodded, unsurprised. “Doesn’t seem like she’s a fan of yours anymore, Mark.”

Hoffman glared at him. “Was she before?"

"She had said as much. Said she was excited to work with you just this morning."

"Does it matter?”

“I’d like to know my partner doesn’t hate my guts, wouldn’t you?”

“Well, it’s too late. Probably best to just have her work with someone else.”

Grissom smiled and shook his head. “You’re going to need to start learning to either stop making messes, or clean them up. This precinct isn't going to keep bending over backwards to appease you, Hoffman. Remember that. And grow the fuck up, boy.”

Hoffman stared back at his boss. “Understood.”

“Good. Now get out of here. And make peace. No one else wants to work with her, and they all have reasons I can't ignore. Their wives wouldn't hear of it. So do this for the precinct, at least, Hoffman.”

He stopped at the door. "No one else?"

"I didn't want to start you off with that impression, but it seems you came to that conclusion already. Yes, everyone has expressly refused to work with her. And don't think she isn't aware of that either." Grissom looked tired. "We need more female detectives."

Hoffman looked out the window. He saw Maddox collect her belongings and disappear out the front doors. He looked back at Grissom. "Maybe we need less assholes."

Wilhelmina Maddox

“You fucking bitch.”

Will had ducked just in time to avoid a beer bottle shattering over her head. She kept her eyes forward, locking on the threat in front of her. “You’re drunk Frank.”

Her husband laughed harshly. “Why’re you late?”

“Work. You know how it is.”

“How many men hit on you today?” He stumbled forward and grabbed the back of her hair, pulling her head back. A part of her wanted to respond. To grab his arm, spin around and force his elbow to bend in the wrong direction. But she resisted. Control. She clenched her jaw. He doesn't mean this. He's just drunk. She let him pull her hair. It would all be over sooner the less she resisted. Or at least that’s what she thought. She closed her eyes as she felt his rough unshaven chin brush against her neck and he licked her skin. He took a bite and she let out a hiss of pain.

“No one. We keep it professional. This precinct is better than out west.”

“You’re full of shit.”

“You hungry?” She tried to shift his attention. "I could order us a pizza." He was stumbling and reeking of beer. He had started day drinking when he lost his job. And now he couldn’t seem to be able to find another. Why was that? Bad economy, he said. Totally had nothing to do with the fact that he was more drunk than sober these days.

“How’d you know?” He pushed her onto the couch. “I’m hungry for that pussy.”

She internally rolled her eyes. He wasn’t that imposing of a man, but he was larger than her. Stronger. He had been the perfect husband just that morning. He had been sweet, making her breakfast, kissing her as she went off to work. He told her they’d watch a movie together.

She had been looking forward to that movie. When she came home, she realized that movie night wasn't happening. And she craved the familiar comfort of going to work.

“Look at me,” he hissed gripping her cheek and pulling her face close to his. His eyes were wild and hateful. Beady gray eyes. He was practically panting, his breathing labored and erratic. She smoothed her hand over the back of his.

“Please. You’re hurting me, honey.” She pleaded with him to come out. The real him. The him that she fell in love with. He was in there. He had to be.

Otherwise, she was a fool and just a textbook victim of domestic abuse. And that couldn't be her. She knew better. She was supposed to know better.

Her phone rang and she internally sighed in relief. She went to reach for it but her husband grabbed it, flipping it open to answer it. “Who the fuck is this.”

“Frank!” She snapped in horror. She quickly swiped the phone and ran into the master bedroom, locking the door. Frank had been too drunk - too disoriented - to follow her in time. He was pounding on the door, calling out to her.

“Will! Let me in! WILL!”

“Hello?” She felt her cheeks burn with humiliation and hope. Please let there be work.

“...You all right, Maddox?” She narrowed her eyes at the sound of his voice.

“Hoffman. Fine. What do you want?”

“Let’s talk. I’ll pick you up. Where are you?”

“Will! Let me in you fucking bitch!”

“Where are you, Will?” Hoffman’s voice called at her, his deep voice beckoning. "You sound like you're in danger."

"I'm not. It's a long story." The pounding on the door was distracting. It made it hard to come up with an excuse. She wanted more than anything to not be where she was. No matter how much she hated Hoffman, he was still more preferable than what was on the other side of the door she was pressed against.

“The corner of Parkinsons and Gorge. I’ll meet you there.”

“...Are you all right?”

“I’m fine, Hoffman.” She pushed the dresser in front of the door in order to buy herself some more time. She went to change, taking off her sweaty work clothes and slipped into a baggy black T-shirt and a hoodie. She kept her work pants and shoes on. She looked out the window, studied the fire escape. They had moved a month prior, into this apartment on the west side of town. She was still unfamiliar with her surroundings.

She and Frank were supposed to go explore, but he preferred to take detours to the nearest liquor store. Instead, she just went to work. He had promised things would be different if she moved. If she just transferred away from the men she worked with. He just needed a fresh start. They needed a fresh start, he said. He had promised so much.

She waited half out the window, trying to ignore Frank’s weakening pounding. He sounded like he was tiring himself out. He would hopefully pass out and not remember what happened the next day.

Her phone went off. “Yeah?” She breathlessly answered, her heart slamming.

“Where are you?”

She looked down below, at the six stories under her feet. She recognized the grayish-blue hood of the Crown Victoria far below. “I’m coming out. Give me five.” She hung up, put her phone in her pocket, and began going down the narrow spiral black metal staircase, scrambling down ladder wells as they alternated. When she finally reached the concrete pavement she looked up to see Hoffman staring at her behind the steering wheel, his face expressionless.

She didn’t plan to explain anything to him. She got into the car. “What is it?”

His eyes scanned and flashed across her face, her neck, her chest. He reached his hand to push her hair aside to see more of the skin of her neck but she quickly grabbed it and tossed it back at his chest. “Don’t.”

“You have something on your neck.”

“Yeah, well it’s none of your business.”

His eyes narrowed. “Fine. Want to go somewhere specific?”

“Just away from here,” she exhaled. Her phone was ringing. She checked the caller ID and silenced it.

Hoffman thankfully didn’t ask any questions. He didn’t need to. It was obvious. The humiliation she was used to feeling returned. It was worse when it was in front of the man she hated at that moment. A man who was probably judging her at that moment. “Fuck,” she whispered, putting her hands over her eyes. “I was hoping to keep this shit under wraps for at least a few months. Not on the first fucking day.”

He didn’t respond. He kept driving, silently. Patiently. He turned on the radio, letting some classic rock play in the background while she covered her face and pressed on her eyes, feeling tears sneak past her fingers. She turned her head, hoping he wouldn’t see. "My husband is an alcoholic. Okay?"

"Okay." That was all he said. The silence was deafening.

"He's not always like that. He's actually very sweet. He can be kind and is a good person."

"Okay."

Fear rose up her chest. "Don't tell anyone. Please."

"I won't."

She didn't believe him. Her eyes watered and she sobbed. "Fuck. I bet I've just proved you right. I bet you're loving this."

"I'm not. Not even a little bit," he growled. She looked at him, his face contorted with rage. "The only reason I'm not up there knocking his teeth out is out of respect for you. And I do respect you, Maddox. After today, you've earned your respect."

She blinked and sniffed. "What changed?"

He looked at her. "You didn't go tell Grissom about what happened today. Though you could have. You keep things in house. I get that. You're doing that with your husband. Trying to deal with it yourself. In some cases, it's commendable. But concerning... Frank, is that his name? I think that's poor judgement."

She blinked at that. The embarrassment she felt was morphing into a shell-shocked state. She glumly stared at her lap as he drove on. She wanted to evaporate and disappear from existence. This was a new level of humiliation she couldn't bear.

She felt the car turning and continuing for a couple of minutes. It bought her time to collect herself. She inhaled deeply, exhaling and finally showing her face. They were at a park. Or really, a graveyard.

“Where are we?” She blinked, turning to Hoffman.

“The Lady of Perpetual Sorrow Cemetery.” He got out of the car, went to the trunk and pulled out some fresh flowers, and took a walk. She watched him as he strode down the grass in a direction, standing in front of a tombstone. She watched him replace the flowers of a vase, the dead flowers replaced with the small bundle of red and yellow flora. They were just outside the city. They must have been driving at least an hour from her apartment.

She blinked, confused. He stood there, looking down, as though waiting for something. Curious, she went out to him. She slowly approached his form, looking at the name of the tombstones.

Mark Hoffman.

Darcy Hoffman.

She blinked, studying the dates. Five years ago from today. “I’m sorry for your loss,” she said, feeling out of place. She stood next to him looking up at his expressionless face. “Your parents?”

“Yes.” He turned to her. “It was a DWI. Someone on PCP decided to go for a joyride. They were good parents. Supportive. They encouraged me to become an officer of the law. They always wanted to see the good in people. And then they died the same week I graduated from the Academy.”

Her eyes widened. “That must have been hard.” She wasn't sure if she should try to put her hand on his back. She instead put her hands clasped in front of herself.

“Yeah. They left me and my sister out here. In this city.” He looked out towards the skyline in the distance, the skyscrapers cutting through the gray haze of the evening fog. The sun was setting, shining golden light through the silvery mist. “This city changes people. It’s a terrible place to live. Justice is just a pipe dream here.” He turned to her. “But we can't just give up on it. Otherwise, everyone who was ever good died for nothing. It needs all the help it can get. I’ve chosen this life. And so have you. It wasn’t fair to disregard that choice. And I realize that now. You want to help. And you can.”

She looked at him, hugging herself. “Thank you. And… thanks for sharing about your parents.”

He gave her a gentle smile. “There are no secrets between partners. I know your family life. I'll tell you mine." He took a deep breath, exhaling through his nose, looking down at her with a cool, amicable gaze. "I know I’ve been difficult. I’ve been skeptical and didn’t trust you. But you didn’t rat on me to Grissom. And you did your job. You’ve given me nothing but reason to trust you. So I hope we can start again, Will Maddox.” He held his hand out and she took it, his handshake less of a tight anaconda squeeze this time and now full of warmth she welcomed to her cold fingers.

“All right, Mark Hoffman, then let’s start.”

Chapter 3: Pre-Saw: Losing Control

Summary:

After being partners for eight months, Detective Mark Hoffman and Detective Wilhelmina Maddox are assigned to investigate a string of murders occurring in one of the roughest districts of the city. As Will continues her career in Metropolitan Police Department, she begins to see beneath the surface where corruption rots within their precinct.

Chapter Text

Angelina Hoffman

“How come I haven’t met your new partner yet?” Angelina Hoffman rested her chin in her hand and glowered at her older brother, who was in the process of devouring the grilled steak she had prepared for him.

Mark Hoffman’s skewered fork hovered above his plate, his eyebrow furrowed at the sudden question. He had been enjoying the food while he tuned out the small talk that Angie and her long-time boyfriend, Peter Acomb, had been sharing. He had to let his mind return to the present, wondering how the hell this subject had come up. “No reason to.”

“It’s been eight months, apparently, right, Peter?” Angie pulled Peter into the gang up.

“Uh,” Peter shot a glance nervously at the man, cracking a peace-giving grin. It had taken a while, but Peter had finally won Hoffman over, after the second year together. He saw the man like a brother, his only shortcoming was wondering when the hell he would finally propose to Angie. “Well, if he doesn’t think it’s appropriate, that’s his call, Angie.”

“I want to meet your partner, Mark.” Angie always had such skill at selective listening. She smiled at him, brown eyes sparkling. His kid sister was used to getting what she wanted. He couldn't stop her. “You know how I learned about your new partner?”

Hoffman didn’t answer, though he narrowed his eyes and went down the list of choices mentally.

“I ran into Tracy Rigg. She’s met your partner. Will? Is that it? How come I haven't yet?" She pouted playfully. "Invite him over, I’ll cook everyone dinner Friday night. Please?”

Hoffman’s brain sputtered. Shit. “Um. Angie.” He took his sister’s hand and mustered up all the concentration he could into putting on a genuine act. “I like keeping work at work. You know that.”

She shook her head. “That's baloney. I’ve been to all of MPD’s functions. Cookouts, award ceremonies, and, unfortunately, the funerals. Mark, you live at work. And you can’t even pull that excuse when the last partner you had, I’ve cooked for. Invite Will over. Please. Peter,” Angie shot a predatory gaze at her boyfriend, instructing him to come to her aid.

“Uh-geeze, Angie.” Peter’s face reddened. “Don’t pull me into this.”

She let out a sigh. “Mark,” she drawled his name out, batting her lashes. “For me.”

Hoffman inhaled sharply. He closed his eyes. “Fine. I’ll invite Will over. But that doesn’t mean… it’s happening. I’m likely going to get turned down. You think I’m antisocial? Will goes home as soon as the day's up. Like clockwork.” He would give up his firstborn to not have Will accept. He didn't want Angie to start getting the wrong ideas.

“Oh, well then tell him that I’m a great cook,” she bragged. “And let me know what he likes.”

“Uh,” Mark didn’t want to confirm or deny his partner’s gender, knowing that was a highway he didn’t want to cross unless he had to. Besides, Will wouldn’t accept. She was good at keeping her distance from socializing outside of work.

“And if Will’s married, invite his wife!”

Goddamn it. “Fine.”

“Don’t look so upset,” Angie beamed at him. “I’m so excited! Ooh, I think I’ll bake something special. How about a croquembouche?”

“What?!” Peter was pleased, a toothy smile in a large crescent moon. “Oh, I can’t wait.”

Hoffman paused at this. Angie had chosen to study culinary arts and worked as an aspiring gourmet chef. And she had spoiled his pallet with her weekend dinner parties since she graduated from cooking school. Her croquembouche was such a rare treat, he reconsidered his reservations on bringing Will into his personal life. Maybe the hell Angie would give him when she found out his partner was a woman would be worth it. Maybe. At least, this once. Fuck, he liked that dessert so much, he was torn over what to do.

“Will they be with chocolate cream?” Hoffman quietly asked, keeping his stare focused on his steak. He might as well haggle to swing the scales in his favor.

“If Will comes, yes,” Angie enthused. She giggled. “And I’ll make another one of your favorites. Ravioli. From Scratch.”

“Damn,” This almost convinced him. “What if - Will - doesn’t want to go?”

“Well, then guess I’ll just have to cancel. I can’t make all that food for just us three.”

“Now, hold on,” Peter protested, “We can always freeze the leftovers.”

“Do not say the f-word in this house,” Angie teased. “Besides, why would Will say no? I can’t wait to meet him! Oh, and his wife. He’s married, right?”

“Will’s married.” To a scumbag no one here needs to meet.

“Great! I’ll make sure there’s enough for five.”

Hoffman suddenly lost his appetite as he realized the hell he was in for if his partner, Will Maddox, did happen to decide to accept the invitation. But why would she? Especially since she was keeping her husband, Frank Griffin, far away from him and everyone else at the precinct. Hoffman was comforted by this idea. Disappointed that he’d be missing out on Angie’s blatant bribes, but there would always be future opportunities for her to make croquembouche and ravioli. He was a patient guy.

With confidence that nothing would come of this, he returned to enjoying his meal and tuning out Peter talking about some story of a magic gig gone wrong, likely the cruise-ship story, and enjoying the rest of his Sunday night.

Wilhelmina Maddox

Will’s alarm went off a Monday morning, jostling her dreamy state as she fumbled to silence the shrill disturbance.

The smell of pancakes and coffee beckoned her to get up.

She stretched, naked and cold, but eager to grab breakfast. When she crawled out of bed, she went to the bathroom to brush her teeth. The reddish hickeys on her neck grabbed her attention. She let out a bemused, “Fuck,” as she pulled her wild bedhead out of the way to study the damage.

It had been their anniversary the night before. It had been a magical night. Definitely one for the books. Frank had taken her out of the city where they had a picnic and watched the sunset over the cliffs of the national park. When they got home, they drank wine and at first, the love-making had been gentle and sweet, before growing into a rough passion that Frank tended to get as he had progressed through the bottle of red that night. It hadn’t been bad, though. Really.

She honestly had enjoyed the wild night, not remembering the last time she really got off with Frank. Or even with herself. It was just a while since she woke up as satisfied as she did at that moment.

When she got changed, she wore a black turtleneck and black slacks, glad it was a cool autumn morning. She already dreaded the shit Hoffman was going to dish her, always with his hawk-like eyes and attention to detail. He had made a habit of passively pointing out when she had a bruise or some minor injury that she tried to play off as nonexistent. She’d try to be cool about it, but he always seemed to know the truth; demanded she admit what she normally pushed in the back of her mind.

She entered the kitchen, smiling at Frank, who wore an apron and winked at her with a domestic smile painted on his lips. “Hey, beautiful,” He was flipping flapjacks, the batter hissing and steaming. She reached out and kissed him on his cheek, resting her head on his shoulder. “Are these for me?”

“Of course,” He nodded at the table, where two plates were set. “Have a seat. I’ll pour your coffee.”

She sat down in the chair, a tender soreness reminding her of the crazy night they had. She blushed and looked out the window to the forest of skyscrapers and the lavender light of pre-dawn just barely glowing on the horizon. It was going to be a pink sunrise. Nice.

The sound of coffee pouring made her spin her head but she smiled pleasantly as coffee poured in the mug. “Tonight, when you get back, we can go out to a movie,” Frank plopped pancakes on both plates and after returning the frying pan, took his seat across from her. “They’re doing screenings on classics. Casablanca is showing over at the Promenade.”

“Ooh,” Will raised an eyebrow. “You hate Humphrey Bogart, though.”

“Eh, he’s all right. Besides, I want to make it up to you.” He reached out and squeezed her hand resting on the table. “I know I’ve been… awful this past year. But I hope I’m proving that I can change.”

She blinked through blurred vision. “Yeah. I see it. You’re really trying.” Besides the wine the night prior, he had not had a drink in a month. It was progress.

“And I’ve got an interview today,” He twitched his eyebrows flirtatiously. “At a call center, which sucks, but it’s something.”

“That’s great,” She squeezed his hand back. “Good luck. You’ll do great.”

“Thanks.” They ate their breakfast, Frank watching her carefully while she kept smiling back at him. A month ago, she had given him an ultimatum: marriage counseling, that he begin going to Alcoholics Anonymous, or she would file for divorce. She had braced for everything to go violent. She had a night bag packed, under her desk at the station, ready just in case. She had made this ultimatum in public, at a lunch bistro one Saturday. She had been ready for him to scream. To attack. She had been ready for anything, she had thought. But instead, he had broken down in tears. And she had grossly underprepared for that.

She had not expected the emotional vulnerability. It touched her and made her reconsider. So she compromised. If he could just get his act together, then she’d stay. And so far, he had. It gave her hope.

“Okay,” she checked her watch. “I’ll get home as soon as my shift’s up. I’ll call if something changes. I love you.” She got up and kissed him. He had quickly put his hand to the back of her head and pushed her closer to him, deepening the kiss.

“Here’s to you, kid,” He quoted, gray eyes intense and stormy. “Get home safe.”

She waved, grabbed her coat and bag, and was off, sighing in relief. The heavyweight on her shoulders lifted noticeably as she descended in the elevator, as though she was escaping a magnetic force that kept her compressed and tight. She could breathe, just a bit easier and deeper.

When she reached the station that morning, she had been humming to herself a light tune and tossed her purse onto the desk where Hoffman had his legs propped, the headline of the newspapers blocking his face read, “Four Walls Build A Home”, with a picture of two older men smiling back at her.

Hoffman had slightly lowered the paper, his nose just poking up from the headline. “You’re in a good mood.”

She smiled back. “Had a good weekend.”

“You’re serious.” He was watching her intensely. “That turtleneck disagrees.”

She rolled her eyes, taking a seat. “Actually, the turtleneck can attest. Things are looking up,” she volunteered the smidge of personal information, looking at the tray of her inbox. Folders needing her signature were already collecting and the week had only just started. She sighed and began going through the paperwork.

“All right, this is a first. You’ve got me. What happened?” Hoffman rested his elbows on his desk and leaned forward, lips pursed as he considered her. “You have this look about you that just… glows.”

She cringed, trying not to laugh. “Uh, well, it was our wedding anniversary yesterday.”

His face contorted in disgust. “Gross, Maddox. Sorry I asked.”

“Oh, fuck off. You’re the one who pried,” She began scribbling her signature, confirming she had been the investigator to various legal documents.

“So good ol’ Frank’s staying? You told me weeks ago that it was over.”

She kept her smile frozen. “Well, he’s made some changes.”

“You think he’ll stick to them?”

“Well, it’s none of your business, Hoffman. I don’t want to talk about this!” She had raised her voice suddenly, instantly regretting the hostility. He rarely inquired about her marriage and surprised her with his level of respect towards her need for privacy over the course of their partnership. Throughout their many months together, she had been relieved with how little Hoffman intervened. He had picked up on her need for him to stay back and look the other way, and he complied, even though it clearly pissed him off.

Hoffman was silent, the pause a relief as she tried to focus on her paperwork. But that day, he was talkative for some reason. “You like ravioli?”

“What?” Her head shot up, confused. She must not have heard him correctly.

“Ravioli. My sister found out through the union wives that I have a new partner. And wants me to invite you to her house for dinner this Friday. And to mention that she is a damn good cook. And will go all out if you come.” He sounded like he was forcing himself to say these words, droning them like a checklist in his head. Like they were rehearsed. His eyes seemed to plead for her to do the complete opposite of what his words were asking.

Will blinked slowly. “You have a sister?”

“Yeah. Oh, and she thinks you’re a man. So… you don’t have to go, of course. I told her you don’t like doing these things.”

Leaning back in her seat, she contemplated this. Her curiosity piqued. What sweet poetic justice that Hoffman's personal life was opening up for her to poke through and sniff around. “You know, I’d love to meet her, actually.” She smiled maliciously, “Consider this payback for all the shit you give me. I’ll ask Frank and get back to you on that.”

He looked bewildered. “Seriously? He'd go? You'd want him to?”

“Yep. I think we’ll go.” She briefly considered what Frank would say. He knew she had a male partner. Maybe meeting him would help calm his nerves. Put to rest any insecurity he felt about it. “I think it’ll be fun. Who else will be there?”

“Her boyfriend. And me.” He folded his arms across his broad chest. “You don’t have to feel obligated to do this.”

“Oh, I’m going. Because I want to. I can’t wait to meet your sister and tell her all the shit you pull at work.” She wanted to let out an evil laugh to rub salt in his wounds, but before she could tease him any further, a stack of papers slammed onto her and Hoffman’s desks, making both of them jump.

“Having fun, Maddox? Hoffman?” Grissom and two of his lackeys had appeared out of nowhere.

“Sir,” Maddox looked up at the Captain. “Good morning.”

“Good morning,” He smiled at her before frowning at Hoffman. “Why aren’t you reporting to the scene?”

“Sorry, sir, what case is this?” Will ruffled through her papers, trying to find any hint to what he was talking about.

“I briefed Hoffman before you arrived. There’s been a few murders southside. Hookers in trunks and dumpsters, the bodies are piling up. It’s getting to the point that I’m getting chewed out by topside about this. It’s triggering a women’s protest.”

Maddox shot a hostile glare at Hoffman who passively looked up at Captain Grissom. “We’re on it, sir. Hoffman, the file?” She held her hand out. Grissom nodded, pleased, and went to another desk where his assistants proceeded to drop more cases off while he castigated the other detectives for dragging their feet as well.

Hoffman opened a file cabinet, pulled the thick coffee-stained file, and tossed it towards her. She thumbed through the various forms and images, eyelids stretching open. “Hoffman, what the fuck? Why didn’t you tell me this as soon as I got here?”

“Didn’t think Grissom was going to be breathing down our necks,” He calmly drank his coffee. “The man’s up for promotion. Only reason he’s riding us so hard.”

“It’s also his job,” She reminded him as she got up and pulled hercoat back on. “Dibs on driving today,” she rushed past him, power walking to the door.

“Maddox!” Hoffman called out to her, the sound of his pursuit had her picking up the pace. She practically ran out to the parking lot. It was the little things that made the job tolerable. Making Mark Hoffman nervous with her driving was one of those small pleasures she savored.

Mark Hoffman

Hoffman was too late in stopping Maddox from sliding into the driver’s seat. He sulked while holding on for dear life as she careened and sped down the interstate, screaming down towards the worst side of town. The suspension on their assigned unmarked car was starting to go, his back ached for being jarred so often by her penchant for taking steep hills at top speed.

“Read the latest victim to me,” Will kept her eyes on the road while taking a sharp right to dodge a cluster of cars and continued down an alley.

He felt like he was going to lose his breakfast but kept his stare on the most recent report. “Woman, dyed blonde hair, early 20’s. Dressed like a sex worker. Found bloated in the back of an old sedan registered to a Nicki Malone. He’s got a long rap sheet. He’s also one of Toni Rosello’s goons.”

“Who?”

“Toni Rosello.”

“Never heard of him.”

“Seriously, Maddox? He’s made. You know, classic mobster. Leads one of the biggest crime families in this city.”

“I see.”

“He’s a real charmer. His family is suspected of drug trafficking, human trafficking, arms distribution… a real piece of shit.”

“What else is new?” Maddox made it to the location, underneath a rusted bridge of the city’s public transit train system. A squad car had its lights on while uniforms guarded the yellow taped perimeter. A run-down vehicle with its trunk popped wide open beckoned.

Will parked the car and they made their way to an already rank smelling crime scene. Hoffman was relieved it was Fall and early enough in the day that the sun hadn’t baked the corpse further. But a few days in the trunk had probably already done all the damage required to ruin his lunch.

Maddox was eager to witness the scene, nodding at the uniforms who watched her intently, waiting for her to faint or throw up or gasp. She would disappoint them. She was pulling gloves on as she bent over the body, to study the mess.

Hoffman could barely recognize the lump of greenish-gray flesh and bone as human. Flies and maggots writhed on the rotting rib cage, its skin patchy with missing tissue. It was an ugly sight but he kept his gaze on it, burning the gore into his brain. The face was surprisingly intact. She was young, younger than Angie. Anger was hot from his chest up to the back of his throat.

“Victim ID’d?” Maddox reached into the trunk with her gloved hand. She pulled out a small bracelet with a flower dangling off it. One of the Crime Scene Investigators took it from her and put it in a clear evidence bag. “I’ll hold onto that,” she smiled at the woman as she took the plastic package out of her hands.

“Nope. No one around wants to talk, either,” The uniformed officer was looking towards the cluster of young women, under-dressed for the cold morning and huddled together. Hoffman knew they wouldn’t talk. At least not to him or the other officers. He looked at Maddox expectantly, who was staring at the young women, as though formulating a plan as she took them in.

They continued to scan the scene while the officer continued, “We can’t get a hold of Malone. Apparently, when we knocked on his door, he'd already been incarcerated for three months. The family reported the car stolen last week.”

“All right. You good, Maddox?”

She nodded, her body turned to the next block. “Let’s have a talk with the kids,” she suggested. “You just stay in the distance, Hoffman.”

He nodded. “All right, get her out of here,” Hoffman told the man as he nodded at the trunk. “We’ve got everything we need.”

Hoffman stayed a healthy distance from Maddox as she waved and strode to the group of girls. He felt uncomfortable seeing their bare backs and the majority of their legs. They looked like they should be in high school. Or maybe he was just getting old. Likely, both.

He stood by a brick building across the street, keeping one hand just touching his gun while the other leaned against the brick to make him look as harmless and uninterested as possible. He knew it did little to ease the concerned faces, all eying him like gazelles realizing a lion was watching them.

He watched Maddox hold her hands up, the bracelet visible. She said something that resulted in some of the girls scattering, but one took a step up. The girl seemed emotional, pointing at the bag. His partner nodded and let the girl hold the evidence and look at the jewelry closely. He tensed at this, straightening. That was a reckless move. After a few seconds, the girl began to cry and handed back the bracelet, her sobs distinct over the passing sirens and sounds of traffic in the area. Maddox put her hand on the girl’s thin shoulder, soothing her.

He admitted Maddox had made his investigations significantly easier with her methods. She was good at getting people to open up. It definitely helped save all the paperwork he was used to filling. They tended to find more open and willing witnesses to take them out of the dead ends these cases normally came with.

After a bit of more talking, Maddox waved goodbye and returned to Hoffman. “Her name was Effie. No known last name. She had been working the corner for a little over a year. She was a runaway from Georgia, apparently.”

“That will narrow down finding family,” Hoffman congratulated. “What else?”

“She had a pimp. A real mean one.”

“Are there nice ones?”

“Nicer than this guy. He’s our likely suspect, from what Regina told me.” Maddox looked haggard. “Guy likes them young. He sounds like he’s got a system where he collects from schools out of state and forces them to work for him here.”

“Jesus.” Hoffman had the sudden urge to spit. “What’s the fucker’s name?”

“T-Rod. Quaint, aint' it? He’s got a VIP spot every night at the Velvet Rush.”

He snorted. “Of course he does. Well, looks like we’re staying up tonight.”

“Yeah,” she looked worried all of a sudden. “I need to make a phone call, real quick.” She handed him the evidence bag and took her cell out, flipping it and going off. Her shoulders had tensed, her head bowed as she spoke quietly.

Asking Frank for permission to do your job? He shook his head, shoving the plastic into his pockets, keeping his hands fisted in them. He didn’t get Maddox. She was far too forgiving in the worst kind of people. As though she could sense he was watching her, she turned to him briefly to give him a pregnant stare before showing him her back again. The look had said plenty. She knew he knew. And her eyes were practically growling at him to not even think about saying anything about it.

He had noticed she had seemed in higher spirits the past month. She was the happiest he had ever seen her, lately. Maybe the fucker got his shit together. Maddox was a big girl. Only she knew the whole story of her life. He had to trust her on that. Or really, it was none of his business. Like she always said. He kicked at some imaginary pebbles with his shoes, trying not to get so worked up. He instead let himself take in her silhouette. The sun was bright and strong, casting her shadow long across the concrete. Her reddish curls caught the sun and burned orange. He liked that color. It was like fire.

She got off the phone and returned to him, a relieved smile on her face. “Well, I’ve got good news.”

“Yeah?”

“Frank is looking forward to dinner Friday.”

He blinked. That was what she had been asking. “Really.” He quickly recovered. “That’s great.”

“Yeah.” She let out a nervous laugh. “He also got a job offer today. I’m going to head off. Meet you at the Velvet Rush tonight? We’ll confront this T-Rod.”

“Yeah.”

“Oh. Dress like you’re going clubbing. I think we should catch him off guard.”

Hoffman smirked. “You can’t be serious.”

“You know, button-down. Wax your hair a little,” she eyed him up and down. “Just… try not to look so blatantly cop-like. Like right now.”

“Besides these clothes, I’ve got jeans.”

She nodded but had little faith in her smile. “Just. Dress like you’re ten years younger.”

“And you? What are you going to wear?” He countered, looking back at the remaining streetwalkers shivering across the street. “Any inspiration from them?”

She let out a low laugh. “Don’t worry about it. I'm sure I’ll blend in. I’m good at that.”

He couldn't argue with that.

Wilhelmina Maddox

Will sighed as she readjusted her clinging halter top, shivering while her bare shoulders were struck by a sharp icy wind blustering through to her bones. She stood in line for the club, hugging herself tightly while she impatiently shuffled back and forth, as though the movement would restore body heat into her numb hands. She should have brought a jacket. She should have just worn something more practical.

There was some comfort in the fact that every other lady around her shivered in their attractive but skin-exposing outfits. She envied how they huddled with their dates, some fortunate enough to get a blazer slung around their shoulders or a big arm draped around them to help ease the pain.

Her brain was egging at her to just follow suit as soon as her partner got there. Professional bearing, be damned. She was too fucking cold to care if it would be inappropriate. She just needed to stop feeling so cold.

“Hey,” The familiar deep growl made her turn around. She smiled in relief. He stood there, tall and surprisingly fitting in, his brown hair combed and wetted back, emphasizing his cheekbones and jawline. She didn't stop to admire for too long, though. Her joints stung too smartly.

“Oh, thank God. Give me your jacket.” She desperately gripped the cuff of his windbreaker, hands shaking.

“You cold?” He thankfully didn’t argue, unzipping and shrugging out of his jacket and handed it to her. She pushed her stiff fists into each sleeve, sighing from the lingering warmth he had left it. It smelled like his deodorant, a rich woodsy musk filled her nose and gave her stomach butterflies.

“Freezing,” her teeth chattered. “Wow, you smell good.”

He gave her a look. “You all right?”

“Just been standing in this fucking line for an hour,” she shamelessly leaned into him. “Sorry, but I’m literally dying of hypothermia here. Otherwise, I wouldn’t be doing this. Just pretend this is part of keeping our cover.” She took in slow and pleasurable breaths. The smell of him freshly showered caught in her lungs. He was so warm, like a fireplace.

He stood there awkwardly but thankfully without comment. She continued to tremble violently until he put an arm around her, pulling her under his arm and against his side. She felt herself surrounded by his heat, like a ring of fire that burned into her back. He continued to say nothing as they stood there but his distinct feeling of awkwardness was clearly pounded into her ears. His heart rate was accelerating as she pressed the side of her cheek into his lower chest. His arm was rigid as he patted her back shoulder heavily and mechanically. She giggled at this. She was picking up the vibe he was not finding as much comfort in this situation as she was, his form stiffening like a mannequin.

“How are you this warm?” She tried to stop the tension from growing, her voice soft and incredulous but not really complaining, pulling back to spare his embarrassment. She felt instantly reborn, the jacket letting her hold onto the newfound energy and shielded her from the cold wind. She took in the rest of him. He had worn white jeans and a deep cerulean silk collared shirt, unbuttoned to show just a bit of his broad chest and shoulders. He had some body hair, rough brown hair that poked where the shirt opened up.

He had even done his hair. Thick brown locks were slicked back, bringing attention to his strong cheekbones and jawline. She admitted he looked like a tasty snack, not quite the disgruntled detective she was used to seeing every day. She had never pictured him as handsome until then, often his personality made his face twist into a sour expression that would mar the impression. It was as though she was glimpsing into an alternative reality, seeing him out of place amongst the eager patrons who were out for a fun time.

She finally broke away from admiring his body, seeing his face was grimacing and his ears were a dark shade of crimson. He knew she was eye fucking him. Her cheeks began to share that color palette and she cleared her throat when she pretended she wasn’t drooling. “Thank you. I needed that.”

“Yeah. Don't mention it." He folded his arms, clearly cold, but kept a healthy step back from her as the line progressed further. Now she just felt silly. They were working and she was just being unprofessional. After a few moments of shuffling, his voice went back to the deep and perpetually antagonistic. "I’m surprised you left the house dressed in just that. Angie used to do that, too.” He let out a smirk while adding, "You chicks sure love to not dress for the weather."

“Summer was like a month ago, this is a nightclub, and remember asshole, I didn't realize it gets so fucking cold here so fast.” She felt her regular dose of annoyance flood into her, helping keep the heat that she had absorbed from Hoffman. The corners of her smile curled up, though, glad they could just move on from the moment like it never happened.

“Oh yeah. You’re from San Diego, right?”

“Yeah, up in La Jolla. It’s literally seventy and sunny all year round.”

“Just wait until it starts snowing. You should buy some decent boots soon if you haven’t already.”

“Noted.” The line continued and they were almost at the bouncer.

“I’m surprised Frank let you leave in that.”

She looked up at him, seeing he kept his gaze focused on the large man checking ID’s. “Well, he knows it’s undercover work. I explained it.”

“I never realized he was so understanding,” there was sarcasm there, rough around the edges, but clear as day. "The makeup doesn't cover up your neck well."

Her hands darted up to her neck, touching her neck lightly, realizing her foundation was starting to run. "Shit. Sorry, I'll have the jacket cleaned."

"Don't worry about it. Not the first time." He looked away, frowning and furrowed. "So you're really giving him another chance?"

“When he’s not drinking, he’s actually pretty understanding,” she defended. She quickly shifted gears. She scanned Hoffman’s outfit, desperately looking for some feature or flaw to poke fun of and turn the hard time back to him. It was only fair. Thankfully, she had kept her true opinions of his appearance to herself. It made lying a lot easier. “I see you’re going for the ‘I’m totally not a cop, everyone, really’ vibe.”

He shrugged, his face passive. “This is the best you’re going to get.”

“At least it’s not just a white shirt and suspenders,” she teased, easing the pressure. “And good call on leaving the shoulder holster at home. Though… did you bring your Glock?”

He looked down at her, his face like an eclipse in the sky. She realized that they were up close and personal, the shortest distance in proximity they had ever been before. Her cheeks grew hot as she couldn’t help but take in the way his full lips curled into a smile that looked as dangerous as it looked sweet. “Well, I have pockets.”

“Yeah, must be nice.” She was in a mini skirt and halter top, her only weapon held in place at her inner thigh holster. It was a tiny peashooter, still a fatal weapon, but not very intimidating. If she needed to get it, she was going to have to just reach in between her legs, but she wasn’t planning on drawing tonight. Hopefully, she wasn’t going to have to flash the entire club in the next few hours. “But remember, we’re here just to get information.”

“You’re no fun.”

They reached the bouncers who took their ID’s and waved them in. The security was lax, just waving them in without a care in the world. Once they stepped into the warm building they were wrapped in darkness. The room smelled of smoke and thumped with bone-rattling bass beats. Electronic music and the yells of hundreds of voices hurt her ears.

Returning the windbreaker to Hoffman, she stood on her tiptoes, trying to scan the crowd. She grabbed Hoffman’s sleeve and pulled at him to bend over so she could put her mouth to his ear. “Where are the VIP Tables?!” She shouted. He stood up straight and looked around, standing a good head taller than most of the crowd. They were getting bumped into and nudged, so Hoffman pushed his way through the throngs of people, his hand gently pushing her upper back to guide her.

She felt herself struck in the shoulder and they separated, with Will shouting, hand outstretched, “Mark!” and Hoffman turned quickly and grasped her hand. He pulled her back to him. It happened so suddenly that she face planted into his solid chest and pushed herself off of him in frustration. He looked uncertain, clearly out of his element. She mouthed, “Over there,” towards the other side of the building where black tables and lounge cushioned seats draped in blacklight and strobing colors. She pointed out a single man with tattoos on his face and sunglasses covering his eyes.

She figured the only guy on a Monday night in VIP was their T-Rod. She took the lead, grabbing Hoffman’s bear paw of a hand and pulled him through the masses of people grinding their bodies and teeth to the sound of the music.

There was a guard at the VIP section, a big bald man that looked like he would give Hoffman a run for his money, folding his arms at her approach. “You got a wristband?”

She shook her head. “I want to talk to T-Rod. Tell him it’s Trish.”

The man looked uncertain but turned to the lone lounger and shouted, “Hey T.”

The man turned his head, black shades blocking his expression. The bouncer thumbed at Will, mouthing, “You know her?”

T-Rod got to his feet, a slimy smile crawling across his cheeks. He had glittering diamonds and gold wrapped around his neck, in his teeth. His hands had more letters and symbols than a keyboard. “Hey there, baby,” He slurred, leaning into Will’s ear. “You looking to ride the rod?”

She refrained from bursting out in laughter but instead gave a coy smile, putting her hand up to the man’s cheek. She felt the stubble, thumb caressing his chin. “Maybe, sugar,” she shouted into his ear. “But first, can we have a seat? Get to know each other better?” She pursed her lips. “I need a favor.”

An eyebrow poked above the wayfarer shades and the man shrugged, waving her in. The bouncer stopped Hoffman and pointed at him.

T-Rod shook his head, flicking his wrist to shoo him away. Will cast a glance and mouthed, “Wait,” while pointing at the floor as she made her way to T-Rod’s table. She knew it was risky in the crowded space to break from Hoffman, but it was necessary. Besides, he was right there.

Once she sat, T-Rod beckoned for a buxom waitress in tight leather and a champagne bottle with lit sparklers and placed the bottle at the table with two champagne flutes.

T-Rod poured the drinks, scooting close and personal to Will. She could smell the sweet, dank smell of weed and his body spray as he draped an arm around her shoulder, his fingers tickling her skin. She resisted the urge to shiver, her neck hairs standing on end from discomfort. Ugh. She kept smiling sweetly back at him.

“I’m trying to find my sister,” she yelled into his ear, making sure she sounded southern with a drawling accent. “I hear you may know where she is?”

“Baby, if I saw a hot redhead like you running around, I wouldn’t be here,” he let out a chuckle.

“Well, maybe you’ve heard of her? Her name’s Effie.”

The man flinched slightly, lowering his glasses to reveal pale eyes with pupils so dilated that they were mostly black holes boring into her. “Effie, you say?”

“Yeah. You know her?”

The man recovered but pulled his arm away. “Maybe. I heard she left town.”

“Can you tell me where she went? I’ve been looking all over for her,” she leaned forward and tried to get the pimp to give eye contact. She put her hand onto his lap. “I’ll do anything to know what happened to her.”

T-Rod seemed to forget himself, looking down at his lap. “Baby, you wanna know where your sister is that bad?”

“Yes,” She nodded, playing the naïve, small-town girl. “I’m desperate.”

T-Rod smirked, rubbing the back of his neck. “Well, maybe we can work something out. But we got to go somewhere more private.”

Will gave a dazzling smile, while internally felt her anger build. This fucker is about to fuck the sister of the girl he killed. And then what will he plan to do? Kill me?

“Aight. Come with me.” He took her wrist and pulled her up to her feet. The man led her out a back entrance from the VIP area, and suddenly she was in a hallway. The noise had muffled. She turned to see if Hoffman had followed to only see a flash of his alarmed expression, mouthing, 'wait', as the door was slammed shut.

She felt the blood drain from her face when T-Rod went to deadbolt the door. She spun around desperately, not seeing another door in the narrow hallway.

Mark Hoffman

Hoffman tried to push past the bouncer but was stopped from stepping over the line that separated VIP, despite yelling, “I need to talk to her.”

“Sorry, back there’s restricted. Only staff.”

“And her?” Hoffman waved, holding in as much rage as he could. His heart was pounding, his instincts spinning in place. She just went off on her own with that creep. That's a whole new level of stupid, Maddox.

He reached into his pocket to pull out his badge, flashing it in the face of the man. “Metropolitan PD. Let me through.”

The bouncer’s eyes widened but shook his head. “You got a warrant?”

“I don’t need one,” He yelled into the man’s face and pushed him out of the way. The bouncer backed but still looked uncertain. Hoffman reached into his pocket to pull his Glock out, keeping it pointed at the floor. He heard a woman scream and there was chaos behind him as the patrons of the club began to scatter and flee the scene. He moved across the restricted floor and pushed the door open, but it was locked. He pounded on it, his heart sinking. Fuck.

The door was made of old heavy oak, heavier than the typical bedroom-hollowed-plywood type. He kicked and shouldered into the door, anyway, feeling the resistance bow slightly against his body weight. After a few heavy kicks, the door finally cracked until it crumpled, a portion of the lock casing itself splintered. He pushed the hunk of wood forward and entered a hallway. He looked both ways, desperate to detect where Will had gone from.

“Will!” He shouted, then paused when he heard a man curse and a sudden slap echo off the brick. He sprinted towards the source of the noise, turning the corner to see Will pressed against the wall with T-Rod holding a blade against her neck.

“You fucking bitch,” the man slurred, not noticing Hoffman pointed a gun at his back. His mouth was against her cheek and ear, oblivious to his surroundings. “I’ll make you beg.”

“Drop it!” Hoffman roared, “Or I’ll shoot.”

The man froze, then slowly turned to Hoffman. “Nah, pig. You drop the gun, or I’ll slit her little throat right here.”

“Don’t, Hoff-meh,” Maddox choked the last part as T-Rod slammed her head against the wall. Her hands that had gripped his arms flopped to her sides as her eyes rolled up under fluttered eyelids.

“Shut. Up.” T-Rod whispered against her face.

Hoffman glared daggers at the pimp, looking at his stance. The pimp seemed experienced with scenarios such as this. The blade was already embedded partially into Will’s skin. He could take a headshot but the pimp had pressed his face and head against Will’s cheek, thus using most of her face as a partial shield to his. If he went for the head, he could miss and hit her, instead. He hadn't been going to the range as often as he'd like lately.

It was too risky.

“I’ll fucking do it,” T-Rod, without flinching, slid the blade across Will’s throat and she let out a gasp as blood began to trail down her neck. “Put that piece down, slow.”

Hoffman pointed the gun upwards, turned the safety on, and slowly lowered it to the ground. He didn’t want to, but there was little choice.

“Good. Now kick it over here.”

Hoffman kicked it over, hard but in a direction that was intentionally inconvenient for the pimp. T-Rod pulled back and looked at where it went, the blade lifting away from Will’s throat as well. This gave Maddox the opportunity to knee him sharply in the groin while ducking out of the knife’s bite. The knife struck brick, scraping the stone. Some of her hair had gotten caught in the crossfire, a small lock of red curls floated to the floor.

The criminal collapsed partially, screaming but slashing the blade. Will crab-shuffled backwards away from T-Rod, leaving him open to attack Hoffman. Hoffman moved fast and grabbed the man by the ponytail and slammed his forehead against the other brick wall. Once T-Rod crumpled onto his back, the fight was over, but Hoffman didn’t care. He continued to throw punches square in the man’s cheek and nose.

He saw red. Red blood. Red floor. Red brick. The very light had gone red.

He kept pounding the fucker’s face, while hearing his name chanted in his ears.

He felt cool, soft hands on his neck, pulling him backward. He was caught off guard and froze, realizing the chanting was feminine and shrill. Her hands had fallen onto his shoulders and her arms were pulling him, a weak force that more tickled than caused him any dislocation.

“Mark! Mark! Stop it!” She screamed, trying to pull him off of the perp. He blinked and got to his feet, catching his breath. His heart was blaring in his ears. His pulse pushed in a fast rhythm up his neck, his temples twitching. His chest heaved in and out rapidly.

“It’s okay,” She appeared in the red sea, eyes wide and afraid. “It’s okay. We’re fine.”

He turned to T-Rod, who had gone very still. His face was a bloody mess. It looked like he had knocked out some teeth. As the adrenaline ran its course, his knuckles began to throb and sting. He saw the skin had been torn off most of them. His fists were vibrating. Shaking.

“Mark. Let me handcuff him,” she held out her hand, avoiding eye contact as she stared at the bloody mess at their feet. He didn’t understand until he realized she was asking for his handcuffs. He pulled them out of his pocket and handed them over. He fought the urge to squeeze his fingers through the hard metal rings and slam them onto the fucker’s neck.

“T-Rod, or whatever your name is,” she grunted as she rolled him over and reached for his wrists. “You are under arrest for the murder of Effie Rhyne. You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.”

Her words, reading the Miranda rights, helped calm him. Restored him to normal. It was her voice. She was speaking. She was fine. She was alive. He eased the grip of his fists, remembering to relax them. Lost control.

“Mark. Check on if back up’s been called. Maybe a 131’s been called already.`` She was calm and giving out orders clearly, nodding at him to snap out of it.

He pulled out his cell phone and made the call. The pimp wasn’t going anywhere anytime soon.

She stood up and shivered, her shoulders returning to the same trembling vibrato earlier in line. “You okay?” She put her hand on his upper arm, face wrought with worry.

“Are you?” He gently thumbed the stain of bright red blood on her neck, a fresh addition to the welts on her skin. It looked wrong seeing her so damaged. "This may scar." She felt cold to the touch and it reminded him to take his jacket off and put it around her. He had the urge to put an arm around her like before, but remembered himself. “That was stupid, Will. You can't just go off on your own like that. Stupid.”

“It just happened so fast,” she pulled the oversized parka around her, shaking her head. “Sorry, I didn’t realize that door was the only one here. It won’t happen again.” She was fascinated with her heels, kicking her feet as she kept her head low.

“It better not,” Hoffman muttered. “He could have-,”

“Let’s not dwell too long on the possibilities,” she snapped, then softened her tune as she quickly surmised. “Well, I don’t know about you, but as soon as he’s booked I could go for a drink. Or two.”

He smirked. “Yeah. You owe me." He, too, didn't like to dwell on things that could have or could not have happened. What happened happened. She was alive. "Larry’s?”

“Ugh. It’s so gross there.”

“Fries are good.”

“No, the cheap liquor is what’s good to you,” she shook her head. “Your cheap ass better not worry about buying. You saved my ass tonight. Drinks on me.”

“Oh goodie,” he snickered. "Top shelf brands." She punched him playfully on the arm. Relief washed over him, cool and soothing, as he reveled in Will goofing and smiling up at him.

His heart was still taking a while to slow down and he frowned as he replayed the last few minutes in his head. This was exactly the kind of situation that made him question whether she should be working in the field or not. It was just too dangerous and they had gotten to the point of their working relationship where he cared what happened to her. Cared too much. And that was bad. A liability.

If anything bad happened to her, would he respond properly? Follow protocol? He had seen what happened to partners that were close - so close that when the inevitable injury or death happened, it wasn't just the desire to save people. It wasn't the need to do the right thing that had them obsessing and incensed. What spun them out of control, lost them their badge and gun, didn’t emerge from a sense of duty. It was a deep and terrifying rage that just wanted to inflict pain;to hurt as much as possible.

It was a familiar feeling. It was something he had thought he had locked down and under control. He had almost let the beast out. That scared him.

"Ugh. Great. This will take forever to grow back," Will studied the uneven part of her hair where a cluster of curls were clearly missing. She pouted at him, making his insides twist in ways he didn't want them to.

He forced a smile back. "Just shave it all off, Maddox."

"Fuck off," her eyes flashed and nostrils flared, making his throat dry. He liked making her angry. Fuck. This is not good. His head hurt. He tried not to think about it.

When the cops arrived, they had pulled the unconscious suspect up roughly and dragged him to the exit. Maddox followed. Hoffman hovered around where bits of her hair still sat discarded on the floor. He didn't think things through when he knelt down and quickly shoved them into his pocket.

Wilhelmina Maddox

“I’m telling you, I don’t know,” T-Rod’s nose was bandaged up, his eyes swollen and purple. He didn’t look so intimidating, what with the shit kicked out of him the night before.

Will Maddox leaned forward from her stance, pressing her palms into the backrest of the chair she had been resting in just earlier. Freshly showered and dressed in her suit, she felt more in control than she had just the day before. She smiled gently, playing her role with ease.

At her side, her partner muttered, "You're full of shit." Hoffman was playing the bad cop, arms folded and throwing in threats and insults every few minutes while she played the good cop.

“Now, Terrance, we can’t just let you go. I’d like to, really, but after assaulting a police officer, it looks like you’re getting at least five years. Now, I know you’re a good person and can do the right thing-,”

Hoffman let out an extra loud snort, the show meant to be disruptive and anachronistic. “This piece of shit should just rot.”

“-and the right thing is to do good with Effie’s family. They want to know what happened to their little girl. They can’t sleep, not knowing what happened to her.”

“Bitch died. End of story,” Terrance “T-Rod” Rodders had a congested voice from both his nasal passageways being clogged up with bandages and dried blood. His eyes were bloodshot and shadowed, not having slept since the assault took place Tuesday morning. His face had gone stoic and expressionless as the hours dragged on. It was now Wednesday afternoon. Will and Hoffman had gotten their six hours of sleep and were fresh enough to begin interrogation procedures. Rodders, according to the jail security, had been kept up with loud rock music and regular police baton strikes against the bars. This was to their advantage.

They wanted Rodders to confess to the murders, especially after his guilty behavior of trying to kill her Tuesday. He held out, though, the interview having gone on three hours already. It was going to be a long night.

“All right, T-Rod,” Will went back to her seat, opened up a bottle of water, and took leisurely sips. She had herself stretch and let out a yawn, giving the pimp a lazy smile that looked completely at ease.

This was Hoffman’s cue. He slammed his fist hard onto the table, making the wannabe badass flinch, wild eyes flashing up at him. The criminal was scared of him, which was fair, considering he would need a nose job to get his sniffer looking like it used to. “I’m going to make sure we throw the book at you,” Mark growled, hate flaring out of him. “You’re lucky Detective Maddox is here and she's such a stickler for the rules. I don’t give a fuck about this murder. If I had it my way, you'd be shoved in the same trunk you stuffed those girls into. Getting locked up would be a mercy, after what you did to my partner. If I had my hands on you, it'd be a lot worse. She’s the only reason you’re sitting here in one piece.”

She couldn’t help but glance over him, his intensity making her uneasy.

Easy, Mark. We need him respondent.

“I didn’t know she was police,” he softly whined, lips trembling. He was starting to break. Good.

“Terrance,” she tried to sound maternal and warm. “Look at me. I’m here for you.”

He began to cry. She slowly slid a box of tissues towards him. “You can tell me what happened,” she whispered back. “I just need to know.”

He looked up, blinking tears. “Ya know, I liked Effie. But - she saw something she wasn’t supposed to.”

“What did she see?”

He shook his head profusely. “They’ll kill me if I tell.”

“If you tell me, Terrance, nothing bad is going to happen to you. I promise.” She lied. She didn’t know exactly what would happen to Terrance, good or bad. But she just needed him to spill the beans. Until he provided enough information, she wasn’t sure exactly what hypothetical danger he would need protection from. She was just glad he never asked for a lawyer. That was the last thing they needed.

“I didn’t want to kill her. It’s bad for business. You understand.” He looked at her imploringly, as though killing young girls he forced into prostitution was just standard capitalist practice.

“Of course,” she sympathized. “That’s why I know you didn’t make the call. Why screw yourself like that?”

“Exactly.” He cleared his throat. “Okay. I got the order from the top, Toni Rosello himself. Apparently, some of his trustees hired my girls for a party. But something went down. I don’t know what, and then I was given the order to keep ‘em silent. Real silent.”

She nodded, her heart beginning to flutter. “And the other girls?”

“All collateral. The ones you've shown me were most of them. We can always get more.” He looked up, the disconnect to the fuckery he was saying not registering as bad or ill-conceived. Just business. She looked forward to locking him up.

“Where can I find Toni?” She had Mark in the corner of her eye. His arms were flexing, his entire body rigid as he restrained himself in his seat. He had his hands folded in prayer and resting on the table in front of him, mean-mugging the pimp with as much venom as his scowl could throw.

“He likes hanging in Tagliatelle, his first business. The one in Little Italy.”

“You’ve been very helpful, Terrance. Thank you.” She kept the good cop bridge open, in case they needed to cross-examine him later.

“You’ll keep me safe, right?” He reached out to grab her arm and her fingers twitched at his touch.

Hoffman grabbed the guy’s wrist and threw it back. “Yeah. You’ll be safe. Safe in prison.”

The man paled. “But Rosello’s got guys inside. I’ll be chum for the sharks.”

“Not our problem,” Hoffman got to his feet and made his way to the door. He looked at Will expectantly but she shook her head.

“Let me figure that out, Terrance. For now, you’ll be just across the street. You’ll have your own cell. We’ll keep any Rosello-connected inmates away from you.” When she left and they closed the door, she turned on Hoffman. “We need him cooperative, Mark. You can’t just burn everything to the ground after one lead.”

“He’s not going to have much more to give,” Hoffman griped. “If Rosello's involved, this is about to be a shitshow." He rubbed his temple as though a headache was forming.

"Who's Rosello?"

"You know. Toni Rosello." He shook his head. "I wouldn't waste time on Rodders anymore. He's not going to be able to help much. I'd put money on it. And after the shit he pulled, it’s going to feel real nice leaving him alone at Blackwell Corrections.”

“What’s the likelihood he’s going to die prematurely in there?” She folded her arms and looked at the shut door.

“Guaranteed. Before the week is up.”

“Shit.”

“No shit, Maddox. The fucking guy’s a pimp. He’s an animal that needs to be put down.”

“Rehabilitated,” she countered as she made her way out of the interrogation wing. "We shouldn't be putting people in prison to just die."

“People like that can’t be rehabilitated,” he argued, his voice getting huskier with frustration. "Don't go bleeding heart on me, Maddox."

“Whatever happened to second chances?” She looked at him, then, frowning as she looked up to find him stubbornly glaring back. "What's the point in paying to have incarcerations?"

“Yeah, second chances on a fender bender, drug offense, I get that. But he’s a repeat offender. Lost cause. A fucking murderer, Maddox. He's taking kids, Will. Leave him to rot.”

“Obviously, I think he should go to prison. But unless he’s sentenced to death by a court of law, we are obligated to keep him alive. It's up to the judge."

"The judge would agree with me. Let the fucker die."

"You know we've moved beyond Hammurabi's day. Justice is not vengeance, Mark.”

Hoffman laughed, rough and loud, trying to shake off his disbelief. “How cute. You’re so naïve, Maddox.”

“Maybe we need more of that here,” she muttered, storming off. “Otherwise, what’s stopping us from just eating each other in this godforsaken city?”

Mark Hoffman

She was mad at him again. He drove the car with the radio blasting sports numbers, hoping she’d comment on the poor performance their baseball team was doing that day, but she merely kept her arms folded and stared out the side window as she sulked in the passenger seat.

He didn’t get why she was so angry with him. Well, he figured why, but it was a dumb thing to be mad about. Maybe it’s that time of the month, he passively smirked, before shaking his head. Better not even suggest that. Her punches are starting to sting.

He drove them through the many historical Italian businesses that neatly lined up the district. He loved taking Angie out to these restaurants. This was where she first got inspired to cook. He parked on the curb, to Tagliatelle.

He had rued the day they would have to have this talk. But he knew it was time.

“Maddox,” He spoke to her softly, waiting for her to speak up. She shot him a look, honey-glowing eyes heated in the late afternoon sun. “Follow my lead when we talk to Rosello. He’s not... known for handling the female cops well.”

She shot him an incredulous look. “What, so keep my mouth shut and look pretty?”

“That’ll get him to open up more, likely. I know him. I think we can work to an understanding.”

“We’re arresting him, Hoffman. I’m not sure how much understanding we can provide.”

He held back a scoff. “Will, we’re not going to arrest him.”

“What do you mean?” She turned on him, confused and alarmed. “Why are we here?”

“To cover our bases. But if this is leading to where I think it is, we’re going to have to close the case with Rodders taking the fall.” He went to open his door, hoping this was enough information to satisfy her.

Of course, it wasn’t.

“Why?” She gripped his arm before he could open the door, her grip tight like a pressure point on his bicep. “We need to at least take him in on suspicion for conspiracy to commit murder.”

“We can’t, though.” He leaned back and stared straight ahead, thinking of the right way to break this to her. He gently pried her hand off his arm. “He’s… untouchable.”

“Mark. I swear to God you better not be going ‘big city cop’ on me now.” She shook her head, like a kid who was told Santa Clause didn’t exist.

“You can try, Maddox. Bring him in. I won’t stop you if you decide to do that right now. But you’re going to hit more roadblocks trying to process him than it's worth. He’s got a team of lawyers ready to tear apart any charge we throw at him.. We’re underfunded as it is, Maddox, you know that. And he’s only going to be held for 24 hours before we have to release him. All evidence we had on him will vanish. And just to spite us, everything related to this case will simply get lost.”

“You’re fucking kidding.” She sat back and shared his numb expression as she looked off to the restaurant’s front windows. “How many of us are dirty?”

“All of us, if you look at things black and white. But it's more complicated than that. Plenty of guys take bribes to afford their kid’s leukemia treatment, not for a downpayment on a supercar.”

“Who? Or at least give me a number.”

“Griggs. Fenton. They’re the most obvious. Griggs’ daughter is the one with leukemia. Fenton has a gambling problem.”

“How many of us?”

“At least half the department is culpable. The other half just turns a blind eye.”

“And you?” She looked at him warily, as though seeing him for the first time.

“I haven’t taken money from Rosello,” he defended but clenched his jaw. His chest tightened. “But I’ve gone with some coverups. I’m not going to lie to you, Maddox. I’m just being a realist. This is a force out of your jurisdiction.”

Her eyes brimmed and flashed, her voice wavered. Fuck. He really pissed her off this time. “Have you ever tried to stop it?”

He gave her a piteous smile, his stomach flipping slightly. “Maybe when I was a rookie. Knowing you, I have an idea on what you'll go for. If anyone would try, it’d be you. But if you go down that road, I can’t protect you. You’ll get shit from all sides. And your job will get real hard.”

“I don’t need your protection,” she snapped. “Damn it, Mark, what have you done?”

He shook his head. “Doesn’t matter, Maddox.”

“It does, though.” She punched the side of the car in frustration. “Damn it! It does! What is this job to you? Just a paycheck?” She sounded tired. Frustrated. "What's the point?"

He laughed to push down the familiar feeling he knew she was experiencing. “You asking if I started off wanting to be a hero? Yeah. We all do. We think we’re going to change this city for the better. Just like you. But then reality hits you, that the problem goes beyond the city. That your morales mean shit. You’ll get knocked down a peg, sooner than you know it. Maybe it’ll be watching the scum here go too far and you lose it. Maybe it’ll be one of your friends who had some of Rosello’s goons come and knock on his front door and shake hands with his wife - hold his goddamn two-year-old in his arms - and ask for this favor. So he goes to shred a document here or lose some paperwork there, just out of preservation for his fucking family. The next day, all his debts - just like that - have been paid off. And he doesn’t report it. Why would he? He’s more than culpable now, he’s knee-deep in Rosello's shit. Shit happens.”

“Jesus, Mark.” She hugged herself. “If this is the norm, then why are you even here? Why am I here?”

“Because the people here are good people deep down. Flawed, but good people. And we look out for our own. And we’re trying. We aren’t Jesus Christ, Maddox, not even you. But we’re not just blatantly siding with the mob. We try to clean up his messes and try to make some changes in spite of him. It’s an uphill battle, but we’ve been waiting. As soon as he’s vulnerable, we’re going to get him. But that’s not today, Will. You understand me? If you try to take on the bull today, when his horns are nice and sharp, it’s going to just screw all of us.”

“You want me to just standby,” she muttered, disgusted.

He leaned toward her. “You’re going to have to make choices like this, working here. It’s time you get the brutal truth. Hard choices that aren’t so black and white. So, it’s up to you, Will. We’ll get one of his goons locked away. He may throw us another, out of his fucked up sense of respect. We can either take it and continue on with our lives without much pushback or he’s going to make shit real hard for us.”

“I can’t just go with this.”

He ran his hand through his hair. He had said the same thing back when he first started off. “The best thing people like us can do is focus on getting promoted. That way, we can start getting the power to make some changes. Clean house. But it gets political, Maddox. I hate politics. Grissom tries his best. So does the Commissioner. But that’s above your paygrade for now. ”

“Who can we trust? Are you saying Grissom just lets this happen?”

“Don’t go holier-than-thou on me, Maddox. Grissom does the best he can. You’ll find he’s promoted only the people who show some restraint and aren’t at risk of being targeted by Rosello. Kerry is one of them. Tapp. Sing. Matthews. So clean, they’d squeak if you stand too close to them. A fine bunch of detectives.”

She let out a laugh. “Get off it, Hoffman.”

“You’re another one. He hired you and brought you here for a reason. He could have brought on any other beatnik who submitted a transfer application. Try to see the big picture, Maddox. All right?”

They stared at each other until she nodded gravely. He could have hugged her at that moment. She was handling it just fine. “All right," she whispered, composed but unhappy. "Fine. I trust you. I don’t like it, but I’ll follow your lead. Just don't make me regret this, Hoffman.”

“Good. It's for the best, I promise.” Hoffman went to open the door. “You’ll do just fine here, Maddox.”

“Don’t pretend that’s a compliment,” she grumbled as she made her way out of the car. He followed suit and led the way to the restaurant to confront Rosello.

Chapter 4: Pre-Saw: Toni Rosello

Summary:

Detective Will Maddox and Mark Hoffman meet one of the worst crime bosses in the city.

Hoffman comes across the woman of his dreams.

Maddox joins up with Detectives Steven Sing and David Tapp.

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

Toni Rosello had eyes like a shark. Will had decided she didn’t like him as she quietly watched him from across the red and white checkered tablecloth. He sat with a stained handkerchief stuffed in the front of his shirt. A big suited man stood behind him, a gargoyle of a bodyguard that glared down at them as though he wished to eat them. Hoffman had his hand resting on the table, moving his digits fluidly as he calmly explained to the godfather why two Metropolitan Police detectives had decided to disturb his meal of baked ziti and salmon. She was impressed with how well he had been handling it. It was a first for her, seeing him speak smoothly with charisma.

“A couple of broads get capped and you guys think you can show your face?” The man had a slight Yankee accent, his vowels ending with a 'wuh' sound that Will crinkled her nose every time he sounded it. He noticed. “What’s with you, Red? Allergies?”

Hoffman had gently nudged her with the side of his foot. “Yeah. Sorry.” She needed to remember herself. It was out of place, being the one having to remember to stay in character. She gave him a small smile, blinking slowly, letting her face relax as though she was a ditzy space cadet. The shark eyes eyed her hungrily, wondering what type of fish she tasted like. “You need some Benadryl, honey?”

“If it’s no trouble,” she let herself keep the charade, running her hands through her hair, fluffing it out, and getting comfortable. Her collared shirt had the top button undone, so she pulled her shirt down as though to fix her outfit. Really, she just wanted to let the skin of her lower neck and chest begin to peak through.

Rosello snapped his fingers at his lackeys. They straightened in attention and went to the kitchen, disappearing behind the white swinging doors.

“Mr. Rosello,” Hoffman’s voice was patient and respectful, “the victims were found in trunks of cars registered to men who work for you. Now, we don’t want to cause you any headache. I know you have better things to worry about than the killings of a couple of girls. We’re just concerned that there were more involved than the man we apprehended.”

“Who you got, Markie-boy?”

Will fought the urge to let her eye twitch or give Hoffman a look. Markie-boy? She wondered where that name came from. In fact, she was beginning to wonder about Hoffman's early career with MPD. He never spoke of it.

“Guy calls himself T-Rod. Some thug.”

“Who’s a rat.”

“Well he’s facing life in prison. He was hoping for some leverage. Or maybe he felt some regret.”

Rosello’s laugh was high and whiny, like a nasally mad scientist. “That’s cute. Yeah, a quick death is probably better than life. So how many pounds of flesh you need?” The man’s eyes darted from Hoffman to Will. “Lemme guess. You’re new, aren’t you, Red?”

“I’ve been working with Hoffman for a little over eight months.”

Rosello whistled. “He kept you from me for that long? Markie-boy, she’s stunning. I always have a thing for a woman with freckles.” He licked his teeth, letting out another donkey giggle. “I bet you’re pretty hurt about all those girls. You lady cops always get extra sensitive about ‘em.”

She let him bore into her, taking in the black beady irises, his long face, and the tomato sauce-stained teeth that grinned in bemusement at her. She had the urge to pull her gun out and shoot him point-blank. She never had felt that, in her life, and it scared her. This man was toxic. “Truthfully?”

“Of course, honey.”

“I’m very upset about what happened to Effie. I’m sure her family’s very upset too.”

“I understand, Red. You’re a family type. I respect that.” He scratched his cheek, finally looking away from her. “You remind me of this dame I was attached to. She tried to talk me into retiring.”

“She sounds lovely,” Will folded her arms, as a hunk of ice grew in her stomach. “Why not listen to her?”

The gargoyle returned, placing a pill bottle in front of Will with a glass of ice water. The humidity had caused the glass to sweat, dripping down onto the tablecloth as she stared at it.

“She’s in a barrel somewhere. She started getting a little too naggy. One day, I just had enough. Quicker than a divorce, eh, Markie-boy?” He let out another laugh, tossing his head back. Hoffman smirked back while Will smoldered at the two of them. After the fit was over, Rosello let out a low, “Hahhhhh. Well, I bet you’re doing everything you can to stay civil, Red. I respect that. You know what, because you’re such a well-behaved young lady, I’ll be a gentleman. T-Rod? He’s out. All his boys? I ain’t supporting anymore. You want to take ‘em? Or you want me to clean house?”

“We’ll take them,” Hoffman smiled and got to his feet. “We appreciate your time. Go in good health.”

“And you as well,” Rosello took his fork and stabbed his salmon, taking a big bite. “And Red?”

Will had gotten to her feet and was standing patiently. “Yes?”

He winked at her. “If you ever want a taste of danger, you know where to find me, okay, beautiful?”

She blinked back at him. Just be polite. “Goodbye.” She went to leave but Hoffman’s hand gently wrapped around her wrist. She looked up at him alarmed but he nudged his chin back to the mob boss.

“Goodbye, what, young lady?” The man was chewing violently, watching her closely. The gargoyle had folded his arms, eyes narrowing.

She hated him, more than she ever hated a man before. But Mark, with his shoulder blocking view of the criminals, took her hand in his. His grip squeezed.

“Goodbye, Mr. Rosello.”

“That’s a good girl,” The man winked again. “I’ll think about you tonight, when I go to bed, Red. I hope you think of me.”

As soon as she stepped out of the restaurant she flung herself to the nearest wall, holding herself up as she contained the desire to let out a scream. Her head was spinning and her heart thudded in her ears. She had never felt so angry before.

“Will,” Hoffman put his hand on her shoulder but she shrugged it away violently. “Don’t. Touch me.” She cast a hateful look his way. “He’s a monster.”

“Yeah. He is. But he’s given us something. He just willingly gave up a whole branch of business, just like that. That’s more than I’d ever have hoped for.”

“What, so he’s suddenly a saint?”

“No. But you did good there. He likes you. He wouldn't have done that, otherwise.”

“Ugh. Don’t remind me.” She shivered at the thought. Hoffman’s phone rang as she walked back towards the car. She got into the driver’s side and watched him as he spoke, their eyes locking as he moved his lips. After a while, he got into the car.

“That was Riggs. He needs some backup on this domestic abuse call. Mind dropping me off at Lakeview Elementary?”

“Sure. Want me to sit tight?” She’d prefer to just go back to the station and drown herself in work.

“You don’t have to.” Hoffman was quiet. “Rosello’s a piece of work. You probably want to take off and recover. I’m proud of you. You handled him a lot better the first time than I did.”

“How did you handle it?”

“I tried to deck the son of a bitch.”

“Really?” She started the engine and began driving, only going the speed limit to keep him talking. “Tell me more.”

“My old partner had warned me to behave. Gave me the same spiel I gave you. Wanted to talk to him about the latest drug lab we uncovered. We had some decent evidence. His fingerprints, even a video of him at the scene. But then I lost my cool. The bastard likes pushing buttons on rookies. I think he just enjoys seeing us lose our shit. You not giving him anything is probably pissing him off.”

“How did he take the punch?”

“I didn’t make it to his face. That oaf, Boris, took the brunt and then tossed me out. After that, all hell broke loose. People got hurt. The entire case got thrown. Suddenly, there was a whole thing about the evidence being faked. Tampered with. Who knows, some stupid conspiracy bullshit. Internal Affairs didn't even bother with an investigation on that end. I got taken off the case.”

“You’re serious.”

“Why you think I’m still just a Detective, Will?” He smirked at her. “Really shot myself in the foot over that.”

“Well you’ve come a long way,” She gave him a small smile. She punched him gently on his shoulder. “I guess I should thank you for helping me not blow it in there.”

“Yeah. Although,” his voice went low with concern, “I didn’t like how he looked at you.”

“Plenty of guys look at me like that.”

“Not Rosello. It gave me more creeps than he usually does. Just keep your eyes open. He’s not known for being… gentle with women.”

She let out a small, sarcastic laugh. “Very funny.”

“I’m serious. Keep your gun with you. Don’t take the same route. Frank know how to take care of you?” He had serious eyes, concerned eyes.

“Fuck, Mark, I already have enough on my plate. I don’t need the godfather trying to take me out.”

“It seemed like more than that. Just a gut feeling. Have one of us take you home, at least for the next few weeks.”

“Great. Just great,” she muttered as she approached the elementary school. She didn't plan on following his request. She sighed and tried to think of what to do. All she wanted was to change the subject and pretend it wasn’t a new problem. “By the way,” she turned to Hoffman. “Who was your last partner? Does he still work with us?”

Hoffman lowered his face, eyebrows furrowed. “No.” He got out of the car and slammed the door, not bothering to look back as he entered the school.

Will went back to the station, parked the car, and slid into the uproar that was her paradise. The large, old building had character that she appreciated. Yellowed marble pillars, cracked concrete floors, and peeling walls; the station had quickly become a comfort to her so far on the job. Familiar faces nodded at her as she fast-walked towards the detective floor. The smell of burnt coffee greeted her as she walked by the break room.

“Hey, Maddox!” A vaguely familiar voice called out to her. She stopped and turned back toward the shabby kitchenette. David Tapp and Steven Sing were sitting back, ceramic mugs steaming. Tapp waved her over. “Still here?”

“Well, can’t let you two have all the fun,” she smiled at the two detectives. Detective Lieutenant Tapp was someone she admired from a distance, always hard at work. He was one of the oldest veterans in the precinct, with a track record that had him lined up to take Captain one day. She rarely saw his personal parking spot empty when she came and left the station.

“Where’s Hoffman?” Sing asked, sipping his drink.

“Out with Rigg.”

“It’s weird seeing you on your own. You two are usually stuck like velcro,” Tapp smirked up at her. “Good to see he's kept his nose clean with you. What’s been going on?”

“Oh.” She paused, then folded her arms. “I finally met Toni Rosello, just an hour ago.”

Tapp’s eyebrows went from intrigued to harrowed, his dark eyes going cold like steel. “Yeah? Sorry to hear that.”

Sing looked around before leaning in, “I know he’s got a lot of people here on his payroll, so it’s probably best if you keep any strong opinions to yourself.”

“Yeah. Hoffman enlightened me.” She sighed, resting her hip on the nearby counter. “He also told me that you two were some of the good ones trying to clean house.”

“Hoffman said that?” Sing’s incredulous expression and the tone of his voice puzzled her. Sing was one of the newest detectives in MPD, younger than her, crowned Prince Rookie of MPD, last she checked. By a month, she admitted, but still. One of the reasons he was with Tapp was because their experience gap was so wide, as was why she and Hoffman had been paired together. So what did he know that she didn’t about her partner?

“Yeah. Why’s that surprising?”

Tapp and Sing exchanged looks and gave her a wary stare. “Look. We’re not trying to stir the pot,” Tapp slowly explained, “but Hoffman has a history of not being exactly by the book.”

“Care to elaborate?”

Tapp kept eying her. “How loyal are you to your partner, Maddox?”

“At least as loyal as Sing is to you.”

“Then I’ll say this as respectfully as I can. You could do better. Have you considered getting reassigned?”

“I don’t see why, though. Hoffman has never let me down. He's good, though kind of an oaf.” He hasn't let me down yet. Not really. She didn't count their first day together. That was old news.

“You probably should hear it from him. I’m not going to gossip,” Tapp leaned back. “I like Hoffman. I think deep down, he’s just a little troubled. But he has a temper and struggles to keep it in check.”

“Yeah. You’re right,” she admitted. “But I don’t get why you think I should get reassigned.”

“It’s just… dangerous working with him, sometimes. He's got this reckless streak, where he hits first and asks questions late," Tapp let out a laugh, "I’ve said too much. You wanted to talk about Rosello. What do you need to know?”

She blinked and unfolded her arms. It was best to let things go, for now. She’d figure it out. One of these days, Hoffman was either bound to trust her enough to tell her or she'd find another way. “I was told you two were trying to take Rosello down. I want in.”

Sing smiled wide. “Nice. I did not see that coming.”

Tapp raised a brow, humming to himself as he tapped his coffee cup. Sing looked at him expectantly. “Well, Grissom always speaks highly of you. In fact, maybe you can help us out. We need to pick up several parcels of evidence across town. Whatever forensics finds from this old slaughterhouse we checked out today may give enough for a warrant. The place is supposedly a big heroin lab of Rosello’s. We were getting ready to go in about,” he checked his watch, “seven minutes from now. You free?”

“Actually, yes,” she ignored the image of the stack of files on her desk, not wanting to miss this opportunity. “I’d be happy to help.”

“Just - do us this one favor,” Sing’s face was stoic, his mouth frowning.

“Sure, what?”

“Keep this just between us. Hoffman doesn’t need to know. Just in case.”

Her throat tightened but she nodded. She couldn't pass this up. Besides, Hoffman probably wouldn’t care. The man wasn’t exactly eager to take on more assignments outside of what Grissom slammed on his table. Besides, he was out with Rigg. He'd probably be gone for the rest of their shift.

Mark Hoffman

What a fucking trainwreck. Hoffman was pulling Rigg off of the man, forcing the uniformed officer to stand down. “Get the fuck out,” Hoffman snapped at Officer Daniel Rigg. “Leave!” Before Grissom takes your badge away, you hot-headed fuck. It was just perfectly ironic that he was the one maintaining composure in this situation. He impressed himself.

“You’ve just made the biggest mistake of your life! Cocksucker!” The man was cradling his hands in front of his nose, blood profusely dripping down onto his pale blue shirt. He screamed at the retreating backside of Rigg.

“Calm down,” Hoffman had his hand on the hysterical man’s shoulder, his adrenaline pumping as his mind flipped through the mental pages of his emergency response. Fuck, this was going to be another mess he was going to have to clean up. And the paperwork. Where the hell is Will when I need her? “We’ll have someone take a look at it, all right?”

The man glared up at him. “You guys are going to be hearing from my lawyer. You hear me? I’ll have his badge.”

Hoffman bit his lip, desperately trying to come with the right words. He had used all his suave talking with Rosello and was coming up short. “Let’s get you to a hospital.”

He looked up at his wife, her eyes wide with fear as she stared at her bloodied spouse. “Can you take him?”

“Yeah,” she whispered, lips trembling. Hoffman didn’t really care, though he was getting strong vibes that she didn’t want to be left alone with the man. But he wasn’t in the mood. “If he wants to make a complaint, tell him to call the station downtown and come in to make a statement.”

He walked by the couple and left, hearing Morgan’s hostile yells, “You’ll hear from my lawyer! You hear me? You sonsofbitches?!”

Hoffman practically kicked the exit door out of frustration, searching the streets for Rigg’s marked car. The squad car was parked. Rigg sat in the driver’s spot, gripping the steering wheel tightly. When he got into the passenger’s side, he let him have it.

“You really just fucked yourself, you know that?” He glared at the fresh rookie, contempt in his voice. “You knew there was little we could do. I told you. The girl wouldn’t speak.”

“But I know he hurt her,” the man’s eyes were wide with conviction. His mouth was curled in regret. “I just - lost control.”

“Yeah. I know.” He didn’t just know. He understood, more than Rigg could imagine.

“So this is it. I’m getting fired, aren’t I?” His voice sounded like a young boy, caught stealing candy and thought this was the end of the world.

Hoffman wanted to laugh. “No. You’re not getting fired.”

Rigg looked at him, confusion and disbelief painted on his face. “What do you mean?”

“He attacked first.”

“What?”

“You were defending yourself.”

“Hoffman, but you can’t just-,”

“Don’t worry about it. You did nothing wrong, all right, Rigg?” He stared at the man’s eyes, wide like a puppy dog. The guy was still just a rookie. Barely a year in the force. Hell, he was newer than Will was. He would learn, in due time. He’d learn to control that itch before it got out of control. If Hoffman could do it, anyone could. Though the job sucked, the coffee was crap, and his career was currently on ice, he didn't plan on making it worse for this guy. It was the one thing he could do, was take care of his own. “Just remember. He attacked you first.”

After a few seconds, Rigg finally nodded. Hope glinting in his face was enough to make him feel like this was the right thing to do. “Whatever you say, Hoffman.”

“When you get called to talk to Internal Affairs, just remember. He attacked first. And tell them to call me. I’ll take care of the rest. If the fucker does lawyer up, we'll have to meet with him. Be ready for that. Now drop me off at Barneby and West Sutton Street.” Hoffman rolled the window down and let the wind blow on his face as Rigg drove - sanely, thankfully - towards the liquor store across the street from his apartment.

Hoffman nodded to Rigg a farewell and went inside the corner liquor store. The cashier was new. He almost paused when he saw her. Time had stood still.

She was tall. He picked up long, golden hair shining under the fluorescent lights. He let his head turn to get a straight view of her. She was chewing gum, looking bored. Her blue eyes lit up and waved at him. Smiling. His stomach did a somersault.

“Hey,” he greeted, letting himself smile back at her. She’s a looker, that’s for sure. He went to the far back, for his standard Jameson and stopped to grab two bottles of wine for Angie’s dinner party the next day.

When he went to check out, the cashier looked at his selection. “Pinot Grigio?” She gave him an exaggerated look of disbelief. “You don’t seem the type. Girlfriend?” She scanned the bottle.

“Sister,” he quickly corrected, “it’s for a dinner party she’s hosting.”

“You going alone?” She chewed her gum and scanned the other bottles. “Now this,” she held the whisky up, “so you. Now, I know you must be at least over 21. But you look under 60 so….” she leaned forward, letting him get a nice look at the top of her swelling chest. “I’m going to need to see your ID.” She stuck her lower lip out, her voice going soft in that seductive way that just hit right.

Christmas came early this year.

After he flashed his ID and paid, she handed him the brown paper bags. His heart skipped a beat. “What’s your name?”

“Natalie,” she kept smiling at him like he was her favorite person to see.

“You want to grab a bite sometime?” He felt lame being so direct, expecting her to tell him to piss off. Shit, I should have introduced myself first. Fuck. He waited, his nerves tight, his face feeling warm. She wouldn't accept. There was no way.

“Well, it’s about dinner time. And I get off in just ten minutes if you don’t mind waiting a little.” She checked her watch before beaming back at him. She looked at him eye level, an experience that he rarely enjoyed.

He felt his breath catch slightly. This was an unexpected turn to the day he’d been having. “How about I drop these off and come back to pick you up?”

“Yay,” she cooed, “I’ll be waiting.” She let out a laugh that was flirty. Throaty. “What’s your name, handsome?”

“Mark.”

“Well, Mark, see you in ten.”

He never moved faster from the liquor store to his apartment in his life.

He had gone off with a noticeable pep in his step as he practically jogged towards his building, impatiently stomping on the elevator button to come take him to his floor. The woman of his dreams had just arrived. She was exactly what he’d fantasized, from her blonde head down to her soft playful voice. He had to change. He should shower. Fuck, there wasn’t enough time.

Where was he going to take her? The elevator doors opened up and he stabbed his floor number. The doors closed. His mind kept going through each option like an old projector reel.

Larry’s. No, Will said it smells like ass. And she always complains about it. He was only a third of the way there.

The Copper Sink? Nah, Will had pointed out the waitress didn’t wash her hands when she saw her in the bathroom. Halfway there.

Where, then? The doors opened and he ran to his door, bottles clinking their liquid sloshing in his arms.

He let out a small curse and finally pulled out his phone. He held the number two, waiting for his speed dial to go through. Fumbling with his keys, he unlocked and pushed open his door.

“Y-ello?” Angie cheerfully answered, the sound of pots and pans and shouting in the background. A male voice yelled out French words he didn't recognize. “What’s the emergency?”

“What’s a good place to eat near my house?” He had practically dropped the bottles on the counter and was running towards his bedroom, shrugging out of his work suit.

“Ha! Since when have you needed my opinion on the local eateries? Can’t wait for tomorrow?”

“I don’t have time for this, Angie. What’s a good place? A place you gals like? Something that’s not going to make you run screaming.”

“Oh. Oh!” Her voice got high-pitched with excitement. “Uh, wait - Tipton Tea on Broadway is decent. Oh, shoot. It’s closed on Thursdays. Give me a second.”

“You’ve got thirty.” He had tossed his open cell phone onto the bed and went through his closet to grab a clean shirt. He was going to be sweaty. Great. He ran to grab his deodorant and sprayed it under his arms, looking himself briefly in the mirror. He needed to comb his hair. He fixed himself as well as he could with so little time.

When he at least put on something fresh he took the phone back and was exiting his home. “Where, Angie?”

“Reggies. It’s literally right across the street from your place. Perfect last-minute stop. They’ve got safe food, American eats. The decor is fun. Get the portobello swiss burger, it’s so good, I know you'll like it! They have vegan options, too.”

“Thanks. Love you.”

“Love you too! What’s her name?!” He was in the elevator trying not to keep up a sweat, breathing heavily as he lowered down to the first floor.

“Natalie.”

“She must be something to get you this flustered,” she laughed. “Tell me about it tomorrow, okay?”

“Yeah. See you tomorrow Ang. Bye.” He hung up and headed back to the store where Natalie was already standing outside and smoking a cigarette. She looked at him again, kissing the air as clouds slowly poured out of her lips.

“Hey, Mark,” she gave him a smile that made his knees feel weak.

"Hey."

Wilhelmina Maddox

When she got home late that night she had been smiling to herself, her chest warm and fuzzy at the progress they had made. They had him. Or at least, they had something that would burn a hole in his wallet, if all went well. Tapp expected a warrant by Monday. He had even invited her to come with to execute the warrant, the thought giving her butterflies. It would be so perfect to just ruin that piece of shit Rosello’s morning, she surmised as she unlocked her apartment door and got in.

“Frank?” She called out, eager to share the news.

The lights were all on but he hadn’t greeted her at the door. Her smile quickly flipped to a frown and she tensed her shoulders. She could feel something was off. It was too quiet. No TV played. Nothing. She needed to prepare. She braced herself as she slowly walked down the hallway and turned into the kitchen.

The bottles on the counter were the first thing she saw. Her heart sank. Frank, shirtless, stared at her with bloodshot eyes. He sat at their dingy kitchen table while pouring himself another healthy glass of what looked like vodka.

She didn’t speak. She stood and waited, her hands balling into fists. She was beyond tears. “You promised.”

He blinked at her, hiccuping. “What’re you looking at me for?” He slurred, his head lolling as he took another big drink. He burped and slammed the glass on the table, his movements unbalanced. His tolerance must have been so low. He had been so good until then. So good. Why did he start this back up again?

“Frank.” She took a step forward, her voice going soft. It seemed he was just going to be a peaceful, doped drunk that night. She counted her blessings. “We have a dinner party to go to tomorrow, remember? You should get some sleep.”

“Yeah!” He let out a half-burp, half-yell. “I ‘member. Gonna meet your bigshot partner. Finally.” He hiccuped again and pushed himself to his feet, his body rocking as though he was a sailor on a ship in a storm. He walked towards her. “You didn’t come home on time. I got tired… waiting.”

“I’m sorry,” she put an arm on his shoulder. “I had gotten so caught up with work, I forgot to call.”

“You always forget… about me.” His eyes were haggard and he sobbed. “You just hang out with your partner-all day. And never care… ‘bout me.”

“That’s not true, Frank. I love you.” She put her arms around him and held him tightly. “Let’s go to bed.”

She waited for him to move but instead felt her hair being pulled as she was shoved backwards. She fell, off-guard, hitting the corner of the archway into the hall. It stung, knocking her to her knees as she tried to recover. Even piss drunk he was strong.

“Fuckin’ liar!” he coughed and ran to the sink to throw up. She heard him retch, her eyes stinging with the tears she had tried so hard to push back.

She covered her face with her hands. She needed to cancel tomorrow. “Frank, don’t worry, we don’t have to go. You're not ready.”

“We’re fucking going!” He declared. “You’re just trying to cover your ass. ‘Cause when I meet him I’ll know. When I shake his fuckin’ hand. I'll see it in his eyes.” He pointed wildly, talking to the sink as though the faucet was her face. He pushed himself away from the counters and managed to find her, turning back to her with a hand held upwards. “You-fucking-bitch.”

She got to her feet. Her heart was picking up the pace and she took a step back towards the front door. “If you get violent and I get bruised up, you know we can’t go. What would they think if they see me all banged up?” She held her chin up, almost hoping he’d go for it. She didn’t want to subject Mark and his family to her drama. She should never have accepted the invite. “So, go ahead, if it’ll make you feel better. But I’ll definitely cancel.”

He let out a laugh. “Oh, you always call the shots. You’re lucky,” he paused and swallowed, “you’re lucky I’m in such a good mood.” He stumbled to the living room and plopped on the couch, breathing heavily as he stared at the blank TV. "Lucky...."

She didn’t bother to turn it on for him. Let him figure it out himself. Her throat felt tight and stung as she forced herself to swallow. She wanted to cry. She wanted to scream.

She instead went to the bedroom and took a long shower, crying to the white noise of water splattering on tile, and then crawled into bed, hoping she’d wake up and everything would only be a nightmare. The back of her head still prickled until she finally blacked out.

Chapter 5: Pre-Saw: Just A Normal Dinner Party

Summary:

Will finally meets Angie for the first time.
Mark meets Frank for the first time.

Drama ensues.

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

Will had a headache. She winced as she walked into the station, hoping Hoffman still had some aspirin for her to mooch off of. She was surprised to see him going through his mountain of folders, squinting down with pen in hand. How cute, he’s trying new things.

“Who are you and what have you done with my partner?” She announced herself as she took her seat across from him. “What’s up? You never do paperwork unless Grissom is right over your shoulder. I expected you were just going to one day get crushed by the inbox avalanche.”

“Got to make sure Grissom doesn’t keep me here late,” he didn’t look up, his nose to the grind while he frowned in concentration. “He’s been pulling that shit the past two Fridays. Remember, dinner tonight.”

“I know,” she raised an eyebrow, mildly impressed. “You’re so serious. Is Angie that intense? Oh! What does she like? Drink-wise?”

“White wines, but I already got some. Just make sure you’re there. With Frank.” He finally looked up, his blue eyes piercing through her. “How’s it going?”

Her words caught in her throat and she looked away. “Honestly, I don’t know.”

“What happened?” He closed his folder and leaned back, folding his hands across his stomach. He was being surprisingly attentive. Something was off.

She felt her eyelids flutter as she recounted the past few hours of thrown glass bottles and the neighbors knocking to complain about the noise. “He’s relapsed.”

“Sorry, Will,” his voice sounded genuinely grave. He pursed his lips in pity. It made her feel a swell of frustrated grief and she let out a huff.

“Forget it. He better behave tonight or he’s only going to make a damn fool out of himself. I made that ultimatum. I’m seriously thinking it’s time to go through with it. But not tonight. Don’t worry, I’ll try to make this as painless as possible.” She rubbed her temples. “You got any more aspirin?”

He opened his drawer, took out the pills, and placed them near her. “I’ll get you some water. Keep it together, Maddox.”

She nodded, fingers pressing into the meat of her face while she clenched her teeth to try to shove away the migraine crashing through her like a wave. She took slow breaths, wishing she could go somewhere quiet and dark to lie down.

“Okay, Maddox?” A feminine voice, clipped and sharp, called out. She looked up to see fellow Detective, Allison Kerry, smiling down at her. The woman was cradling a steaming mug, a bulletproof vest on her small frame.

“Yeah, just didn’t sleep well.” She blinked through the pain and forced a smile. “Thanks. What’s with the vest?”

“About to head south. I like the extra protection. Don’t let Grissom work you too hard. I know you’ve been spending extra hours with Tapp and Sing. Glad you’re on board. Let’s grab coffee sometime. I’ve been meaning to get to know you. Nice to have another pretty face around.” She smiled down at her before her eyes darted towards something behind Will.

“Kerry.” Hoffman sounded passive and cool.

“Hoffman,” Allison’s face had gone from friendly to stone cold. She quickly walked by with a curt, “‘Morning.”

“Didn’t know you two talked.” Hoffman handed the styrofoam cup to her on the way back to his seat, and returned to his work. He didn’t seem perturbed, his focus completely at the tasks on his desk.

“First time,” She took double the recommended dosage and chewed the bitter pills, grimaced, and washed them down with the cool water. She hoped they’d kick in fast. Thankfully, she wasn’t swamped with work like Hoffman was.

The morning was surprisingly slow for a Friday. The cooler seasons were like this. Most people wanted to bundle up and stay indoors rather than cause too much mayhem. It was a nice break.

The two of them sat in silence, the station’s main floor full of the typical ambient telephone rings and footsteps. It was their background music. As Will continued to cradle her face in her desk and wait for the drugs to take effect, there was a sound that seemed… extraneous to the standard symphony of police business. Something soft and out of place. A song.

It was low, barely heard over the typical buzzing of their workspace. But she picked it up, a frequency that she could just detect. Her eyes darted up, watching her partner, who was responsibly reading through a police report. The sound seemed to resonate right in front of her, but that couldn’t be right.

And yet. She noticed his nostrils flared slightly as he inhaled to continue the melody.

“Are you… humming?”

“What?” The music stopped and he looked up at her in confusion.

“You were humming,” she finally declared, eyes wide with disbelief. She felt a triumphant smile spread on her face. “Oh my God, Hoffman, you’re…” she looked him up and down, realizing she had missed the details earlier. His hair was combed back and held with product. He was wearing a freshly ironed, clean shirt. He was secured with a deep crimson set of suspenders, flashy, for him. His face was freshly shaven, something she rarely saw. He tended to just perpetually have a five o’clock shadow. “...you’re like a different person.”

His clear face quickly shut down into a scowl as he closed off. “Don’t know what you mean.”

Will went through the options in her head. What could it be? Her eyes darted around his cheeks and neck, noticing his collar was pressed and carefully buttoned all the way up. He normally didn’t care too much about keeping his suits in place when he was at the station, often leaving the top button undone or his tie uneven and pulled loose.

It can’t be. “What’s her name?” Will smiled widely, confident she was right.

Hoffman cleared his throat and looked around, almost nervous. “Natalie,” he softly admitted.

“Oh my God, Hoffman,” She was gushing. “She must be stunning to have gotten you to sing at work on a Friday.”

“Shut up.” He pointedly ignored her and stared down at his desk.

“Uh-uh,” her troubles melted away as she sat forward and leaned on the desk. This was just the type of distraction she needed. “You always get to hear all the juicy details about my problems. I’ve got to hear something sweet for a change. How did you two meet? Let me guess - coffee barista? Did she make the first move?”

“Uh, actually, she works at the liquor store by my building. And I asked her out.”

“Huh.” She blinked but pressed on. “Didn’t know you had it in you. And I know how high your standards are,” she felt her smile grow like the Cheshire Cat's. “She checks all the boxes? Does she tower over you in heels?”

Hoffman squinted at her but the faintest smile broke on his full lips. “You’ll see tonight.”

“I get to meet her?” She sat up and clapped her hands together. “Yes! You know how to brighten my day.”

“You’re a goof,” he snapped, not enjoying the moment like she was.

“Yeah and you’re totally in looove,” she pulled the last word out, savoring Hoffman’s discomfort. He continued to pretend to not hear her as she giggled, her migraine just barely throbbing as she giddily imagined what Natalie was like. She was absolutely going to get close to her, just to fuck with Hoffman.

She was pleased with how red his neck got under his shirt. “You’re picking her up after work, I’d bet, judging from how cleaned up you look. You’d wear sweatpants on Fridays if Grissom would let you.”

“If I don’t get this shit done with, Grissom’s going to keep me late,” he gruffly stated. “So save the roast for tonight.”

“Say no more.” She leaned forward and lifted a healthy stack of files from his mountain peak. He looked at her in aggravation until she dropped them on her desk, held a hand up in the “stop” signal, and went serious. “Chill. Normally, I’d just watch you struggle, but you’re not going to get this all done in time. I don’t want to miss tonight now, not for the world. Oh, and you totally owe me.” Frank won’t get out of hand, she assured herself, now humming the very same tune Hoffman had been earlier. It had been Mi Vida Loca.

If Hoffman brings a lady friend tonight, this could just be the type of thing that’ll make Frank see that there’s nothing to worry about.

With high hopes, she and Hoffman dug deep into the neverending sea of court proceedings, testimonial confirmations, and subpoena documents.

Angelina Hoffman

“Mark, can you stir the sauce?” Angelina was dutifully turning the red sauce with a wooden spoon, the steam billowing into her face.

“Sure thing,” Her older brother wasn’t much on his own in the kitchen, but she had been patient with him and had got him to at least be capable of making his own meals that he didn’t hate. He was always a responsive and obedient sous chef.

Her big brother went to her side and took the large saucepan’s handle and began pushing around the bubbling tomato paste. He cast a look back to Natalie, who locked eyes with him and smiled behind her wine glass as she took a long and thoughtful sip. Angie was ecstatic, seeing the two of them share such cute looks at each other. It reminded her of when she and Peter had first dated.

“Natalie, can you peel the garlic?” Angie was back and forth in her own kitchen, checking the various pots and pans, adding seasonings while referencing her timer. She was head cook, giving orders and tasting the various dishes that steamed the most aromatic and delicious fragrances.

The space was relatively small compared to what she was used to at work, but it came with an industrial gas stove, granite countertops, and an overhead lighting fixture that also held the various quality kitchenwares she had collected since she began her career. Peter had renovated their apartment kitchen himself, even shifting the island counter back to give the stove area more wiggle room for her.

Angie retrieved a bulb of garlic and brought out a bowl. She handed it to Natalie with a gracious smile.

“Will do,” Natalie dutifully put her glass down in a free spot on the island and began peeling. “Mark says you’re an amazing chef.”

“He’s right, though I’ll let you be the judge of that. I hope you like Italian.”

“Love it.”

“I’m so glad you could come. I know it’s probably a little fast meeting family but know you’re always welcome,” She put a hand on the woman’s shoulder, squeezing it warmly. She admitted Natalie was gorgeous. She could have been a model, with her full cupid’s bow lips and slanted, almond eyes. Mark was clearly smitten with her, casting love-struck-puppy-dog stares towards her every couple of minutes. She already had an inkling that she was going to need to drive the conversation when Mark’s partner got there.

“Nice to finally meet you two!” She heard Peter in the other room. She wiped her hands on a nearby kitchen towel and quickly exited the kitchen.

The man was surprisingly thin. Wiry, but cute in a boyish way. He had a long nose and an awkward grin on his face. “Will!” She came up and pulled the man into a warm hug. She was hit with a mix of cologne and alcohol but she pushed through. “I’m so happy to finally meet you. Thanks for coming!” She broke the hug, noticing how stiff he had gone as she looked at him. He looked confused and laughed nervously.

“Uh, actually, I’m Will,” his wife waved awkwardly and Angie slowly turned her head. She had completely missed her at first, her short stature eclipsed by the man.

“Oh!” She felt her cheeks burst in heat and she covered her mouth. “I’m sorry-I had thought-,” She looked towards the kitchen, her brain short-circuiting as she tried to process what had just happened. She felt quick anger rise up her chest. She was going to kill Mark. She spun back around and gave an apologetic grin. “Okay, Mark did not tell me you-sorry, I really messed up.” She felt mortified, embarrassment making her limbs go stiff. Way to be passively sexist, Ang.

“No, you didn’t,” Will shook her head and quickly held her hands out for a make-up hug. “Don’t worry, I get it all the time. It’s totally understandable.” Angie sighed in relief and hugged the woman, noticing she felt surprisingly firm and tight on her back. She was ripped. She was shorter than Angie and with a wild mane of red hair that reminded her of a halo of fire.

“Will! You’re…” Angie trailed off, “totally going to have to go shopping with me sometime. I’m so happy to have a new girlfriend.”

Will laughed and introduced her husband. “This is my husband, Frank Griffin.”

“Hi,” the man’s grimace grew tighter as he looked around nervously. He looked to Peter who held up his beer.

“What’ll you have? We’ve got Corona, Heineken, wine,” Peter trailed off, looking back and forth to the guests. Angie noticed Will’s shoulders had squared and had a nervous energy around her. Frank looked relieved. “How about I just show you two? Everyone’s in the kitchen?”

“Wait-Peter, the kitchen may get a little cramped,” Angie’s protests were ignored as everyone made their way into her domain. She strode in, not about to back down. “Maybe you can turn on the game until dinner’s ready-,”

“-we’ve got some various beers, pick your flavor.” Peter had the refrigerator wide open, showcasing their stash to the guests.

“You got anything stronger?” Frank was squatting in front of the chiller, surveying his options.

“Frank!” Will had her arms crossed, shaking her head.

“Is this the man himself?” Mark’s voice was loud over the sound of the stove’s overhead fan. “Hey, Nat, take this, won’t you?” He held the wooden spoon out towards Natalie, giving the newcomers a warm smile.

“Sure thing.”

Mark wiped his hand on his pant leg and held it out to Will’s husband. “Mark Hoffman. Will’s told me a lot about you.”

Frank looked at her brother as though dazed, taking in every inch from Hoffman’s forehead to his knees. “Frank Griffin,” the two men shook hands, a chill suddenly blew through the warm kitchen. Will was watching the two while biting her lower lip, her fingers tapping on her folded arm. She seemed nervous. How odd.

“So you’re the reason Will’s always missing dinner,” Frank joked, flashing teeth. “I hope you’re keeping her safe while she’s out there.”

Mark blinked then chuckled. “She’s decent at taking care of herself. But I’ll look after her.”

“I bet you will.” The way he said it seemed off. Aggressive. Angie’s attention sharpened at this, noticing Will looked pained while Mark’s eyes had narrowed. Natalie had turned at this, eyebrow raised in interest.

“Okay,” Natalie fanned herself. “It’s getting a little steamy in here. Do you all mind letting Angie have her kitchen back?” She smiled at her, tipping her wine glass in her direction. “Everyone who’s not actively helping, grab your drinks and get out.” Angie already knew this woman was a keeper.

“Right,” Peter had picked up on the hostility as well. He cleared his throat. “Let’s all give the chefs some space. While everyone grabbed their beverage of choice, he held the kitchen door open. The cooler apartment helped ease the sweltering heat.

Will, beer bottle in hand, took Frank’s fingers and pulled him out. Mark gave Angie a, ‘Can you believe this?’ look.

Peter, always the good host, went out, saying loudly, “Did Mark tell you that I’m a magician?”

Angie sighed as soon as the doors were closed. “What did you do?” She gave Mark a suspicious, accusatory look. “And don’t even get me started on how you just kept me in the dark on the fact that you’ve been working with a.... Will, your-,” she abruptly paused, “-partner, and you didn’t correct me once when I kept referring to her as a ‘he’.”

Now Mark looked uncomfortable, rubbing the back of his head. “Well, it just didn’t seem like it was ever going to matter. I didn’t think she’d come.”

“It matters. This whole time,” she waved her hands and wanted to raise her voice but kept it level, “I could have gone out to watch romcoms with a buddy, since you know that Peter never takes me to see them, and you deprived me of that?"

"You don't even know if Will likes romcoms," Mark countered and she rolled her eyes. He was being the petulant brother who would do something wrong and pretend he was justified in doing so.

"Not the point. You’re so lucky we’re entertaining guests. I swear,” she crossed her arms tightly and gave Natalie a sympathetic smile. “Be ready to pull teeth with this guy. I have to beg him to tell me when his work holds their potlucks. He's so private.”

Natalie laughed softly while stirring the pot. Her voice was relaxed, but her tone had a knife’s edge to it. “I’ve noticed.”

Mark looked at both women, outnumbered. “Well, what do you need me to do?”

“You’re done in here. Go entertain. Don’t leave Peter alone. And make up with Frank, I don’t know what you did to piss him off, but fix it. I want tonight to go smoothly.”

She pointed at dessert, the tall chocolate cream puff cone against the kitchen table, golden caramel sparkling in the light. “Or no croquembouche.”

“No!” Mark half-sarcastically, half-seriously whined as he took his beer, gave Natalie a kiss on her cheek, and gave Angie a salute. “I’ll do my best. But no promises. If there’s any drama, it won’t be my doing.”

Angie raised an eyebrow as her brother disappeared behind the door. What the hell is going on?

"Sounds like tonight's going to be fun," Natalie commented, smiling at her with an awareness in her eyes that made Angie nervous.

"I guess so."

Mark Hoffman

Hoffman took in a breath as he approached the living room. Frank had his arm wrapped around Will, his grip looking tight and possessive. He watched him through half-lidded eyes as he took long healthy gulps of his beer. Will's focus shot from watching Peter’s magic trick to the TV to Hoffman and back to Peter. That instant, he had seen her brown eyes wide with panic and then back to its passive mask. He nodded at Peter who was currently showcasing one of his cliched stunts.

Peter held the quarter in his hand and then with a few flashy moves of his fingers, the coin disappeared. When he reached behind Frank’s ear, he pulled out the very same quarter.

“Cool,” Frank commented while Will clapped her hands enthusiastically. Peter gave a deep bow.

“And now, prepare to be astounded. Mrs. Maddox, if you would check your pocket,” Peter’s voice was deep with booming showmanship.

Hoffman couldn’t help but smirk at the goof as he sighed into the recliner closest to the TV. He propped his legs up by leaning back and enjoyed watching the game. He took slow sips from his Heineken while watching their city’s baseball team score a homerun. He tried to appear as unimposing as possible. He didn’t give Will a single glance. He had a hunch that Frank was already wound up a little tight. The fucker had some insecurities he needed to work on.

Judging from how he reeked like the drunk tank did on a Saturday morning, he kept his ears sharpened to any trouble while making sure he wouldn’t help start any.

Peter continued his parlor tricks and their team was winning by a wide margin. The evening was off to a good start. He felt Frank stare burning holes into his face but he wouldn’t engage or look back. He wanted to, oh hell yes, but he wanted to do more than just mean mug the fucking prick. But he kept his composure. He wasn’t going to go off and make things harder for Will. The gal didn’t need any more shit on her plate.

“Yeah, you’ve already made stuff disappear,” Frank sounded unimpressed, “but do you do anything else? Like saw assistants in half?”

“Well-,”

“Frank, how would he be able to do that here? Right now? Peter, I enjoyed your show. Thanks for sharing.”

“Yeah.”

Hoffman finally stole a gaze towards his fellow guests. Frank had already finished his beer and was waving it up to Peter. “Refill?”

“Sure thing,” Peter took the empty green bottle and kept smiling. “I’ll be right back.” He retreated to the kitchen, walking by Hoffman with a quick glance that looked unhappy. Great, so it’s just us. He already knew Peter would be taking his time getting that fresh bottle.

The three remaining sat in that awkward silence. He could have cut the tension with a knife. He kept his eyes on the TV screen.

“So, Mark,” Frank was the first to break the silence. “You look like you’re in decent shape. You work out?”

“Yeah. Part of the job.”

“How much can you chest press?”

“Enough to get by.” He finally turned from the game to face the prick. He looked at the man’s narrow frame and didn’t bother to ask how much he’d chest press. “I don’t keep track,” he lied.

“That’s a shame. You and Will ever work out together?” Frank looked over to his wife. “After all, you two work late all the time. I bet it’s hard to keep yourselves in shape without making the time.”

He remembered to breathe long and deep through his nose but it did little to hold his anger at bay. The mandated anger management training was crap. He already knew what the fucker’s angle was. “There’s a gym at the station. I’m sure Will’s told you.”

“Yeah, but partners do everything together, right? Even working out?”

The piece of shit just wouldn’t let it go. He barely refrained from rolling his eyes. Yeah. We even shower together. Wouldn’t you love to hear that? “We work out at the same time occasionally. Not necessarily together.”

“Interesting. Because if you two go to the gym together, wouldn’t you effectively be working out together?” Frank’s smile looked triumphant and he took his arm off of Will. “So just the two of you, working hard. Keeping yourself lookin’ good. Must be sweaty work.”

“What the fuck, Frank,” Will’s hand went to her temple and she rubbed it with eyes cast down to the wooden floors with intense interest. “Please. Stop.”

“Heyyy,” Peter came in with an arm wrapped around frosty glasses and an equally fogged bottle of green spirits. “Who wants some Jäger?”

He would have smacked Peter on the back of his head if he didn’t love Angie so much. He couldn’t be too mad at the guy, though. He just didn’t have a lot of good sense in his thick skull. Pete is probably thinking he’s going to save the night with this stunt. He shook his head solemnly. This was all on him. He should have warned Angie and Peter that Frank was an alcoholic. Will had dropped hints and he had figured as much. But he didn’t realize Frank Griffin was not just an alcoholic, but a worthless piece of shit who couldn’t keep his mouth shut sober. This was going to be a long night.

“You’re a godsend,” Frank let out a relieved sigh of pleasure as he took his glass. He downed it and held the empty cup back to their host before Peter had made the rounds.

“Whoops!” Peter poured him another. Peter handed Hoffman one with a hopeful smile and Hoffman wished he could communicate with his eyes that this was literally the worst thing he could be doing. Will looked defeated. “A toast!” Peter held out the glass. “To new friends and good food!”

“Here here,” Will was always courteous, smiling sweetly up at Peter, despite the sadness lining her face. “Thank you so much for having us.”

They downed the frigid licorice water with hearty gasps.

“So, Peter, how long have you and Angie been married?” Will asked, putting her empty glass on a coaster on the wooden coffee table at their knees.

“Oh, we’re not married. Yet.” Peter let out a small laugh.

“Oh. How long have you two been dating?”

“About six years.”

“What are you two waiting for?!”

“That’s what I ask,” Hoffman interjected, smirking at the sweating man that could have been his brother years ago, if he just got off his ass and took the knee. Though Peter was an idiot, he was good to Angie. He made her happy, and he was an honest man. “My sister can’t be expected to wait forever.”

“Wow, gang up on me, why don’t you?” Peter had taken a seat on the couch next to Frank, tapping his hand on his knee. “Well, I can’t just propose without a steady job. The magic industry isn’t quite as stable as it used to be.”

“No shit,” Hoffman muttered as he took another swig of his beer.

“But I was talking to a recruiter for the Marines. If I can get through the physical fitness assessment, it’ll be a stable job with decent benefits.”

Hoffman spun to stare at the man. “You serious?”

“Yep. Angie and I talked it over. She doesn’t like the idea of me getting deployed but we’d make it work. We’d get married before then, of course. They're offering bonuses right now for infantry. They're desperate for people. If I enlist, Angie could open up her own restaurant. But before all that, I just want to make it through Bootcamp first. Got to prove I can do it.”

“Wow. That’s wonderful you’re looking into that. Very honorable.” Will gushed, “I’m sure you’ll make it. Good luck to you.”

“Thanks.” Peter laughed while Hoffman felt his gaze go back to the kitchen door. Was Angie really fine with Peter just up and leaving? He felt a tinge of concern. She hadn’t told him that. He wasn’t the only one keeping things from the family.

“Dinner’s ready!” Angie’s voice called from the kitchen. “Mark, come help me bring things out.”

“That’s my cue,” He got to his feet with a grunt, the beer and Jager starting to make his head go soft.

He went to the kitchen where serving platters of ravioli, salads, fresh-baked bread, roast, and vegetables greeted him warmly. His mouth watered as he took the heavier foods to the dining room table in the adjacent room, Natalie and Angie following his lead. Peter was at the head of the table, seated already.

Once the table was loaded everyone took their seats. Hoffman and Natalie sat across from Will and Frank, respectively. Hoffman and Will locked eyes and she smiled at him, flashing her eyes to Natalie and back to him, her eyebrows dancing up and down playfully. He couldn’t help but smirk back at her, pleased she approved.

“Now, before we begin,” Angie took her seat opposite Peter and stood like a queen in her court. “I want to thank you all for coming. It’s always so wonderful to meet the people in Mark’s life. He means everything to me and anyone who’s a friend of Mark’s is dear to me as well. I hope you enjoy the meal. It is a porcini mushroom, beef, and spinach ravioli with goat cheese and port wine marinara. The focaccia was taken out of the oven two hours ago. And just you all wait ‘til dessert.”

Peter raised his fist and lowered it close down his side in a triumphant motion and a pleased expression towards the ceiling. Hoffman’s stomach growled.

“I hope you all enjoy your meal,” Angie took her seat and everyone began to break bread. Hoffman helped pass the side dishes around the table, putting a generous portion on his plate before handing it off to Natalie.

While everyone took their first bites, there were soft moans of pleasure and delight that made Hoffman feel a swell of pride for his sister. She always impressed with her food.

“Wow, Angie, this is amazing.” Will had her hand over her mouth, eyes wide with awe. “I don’t think I’ve eaten anything so good in my life.” She fidgeted slightly when Frank turned to her gaping, a hurt expression her way. They locked eyes but Will shook her head. “Don’t get me wrong, Frank, I love your food too.”

“It’s fine,” Frank let out a forced laugh and was cutting into his food quickly. “This is. Very good. Amazing.” His smile was more of a grimace as he bowed his head to Angie. “If you are selling any cookbooks, I’ll buy one.”

“Thank you, Frank,” Angie beamed at him. “I don’t have one yet, but I’ll get onto that. As soon as I open up my own restaurant.”

This caught Hoffman’s attention. He never realized she was so ambitious; he wanted her to talk more about it. “You can do it,” he commented in between savoring mouthfuls. “You’d be the best.”

“I don’t know about that,” Angie was swirling her wine and smelling it. “But I’ve always wanted to start a business. Maybe a bistro. It would be nice to be the one calling the shots. But it’s hard to get started.”

“I’d absolutely pay to eat this,” Will commented, grinning through the meal. "When you get started, we'll be eager customers."

“So Will,” Natalie had been quiet at the start, her expression dreamy, “What’s it like, being a detective? It must be hard, being one of the only women at your job?”

Will pondered this question as she chewed, took a sip of beer before answering. “I think it's a lot better than it was just a generation ago. It's not so bad, in that aspect. Though I do have to prove myself a little bit more than the next guy. But the job is a thrill. Every day’s an adventure,” she gave a small smile, “I always go home with a story to tell.”

Frank let out a small crow before blinking and looking up at everyone staring at the sudden outburst. “She doesn’t tell me any stories.”

“You never want to hear them,” Will quipped, squinting at the man. “I’ve totally tried telling you about my day.”

Hoffman’s eyes flickered to the couple, noticing that Will seemed fatigued from Frank’s bullshit. Her voice was irritable.

“Oh, I get it, honey,” Natalie didn’t seem perturbed by the bickering, her voice smooth and sweet. “I dated a guy who never wanted to hear about my day. And he’d always get so confused as to why I stopped talking about my job. It’s a guy thing.” She was full of sympathy, nodding to his partner.

“Oh, so you’re just going to chock all our problems off to me being a guy?” Frank snapped, redirecting his meanspirited tone towards her.

This caused another pause in the room.

“Hey.” Hoffman interjected. “Cool it. We’re just having a conversation. No need to get so worked up.” He kept his voice level but pushed the steel coldness into his glare, daring the pipsqueak to do something about it. Give me a reason.

“You’re just going to sit there and let us be insulted by these-,” he waved his hands at the women at the table but cut himself off. It didn’t matter, though. The damage was being done.

“Frank,” Will softly soothed but flinched when he slammed his fist on the table, shaking everyone’s world. The sharp clink of silverware against porcelain was jarring.

Hoffman took action. “All right, guy,” he got to his feet. “Let’s take a walk. Cool down.”

Frank glared menacingly up at Hoffman, uncowed. “Make me.”

He felt his lips curl into a malicious smile and he leaned over the table, hunched over to not hit the lighting fixture, bracing himself for a fight. He squared his shoulders and leaned close to the shrimp’s face. “You’ve got three seconds and I will.”

Angie and Peter looked like deer caught in headlights. Natalie had her eyebrow raised, an amused smile on her face as she propped her chin with her elbows and took it all in like it was reality TV. Will’s face and neck were as red as her hair, her grimace full of humiliating pain. And Frank seemed immune to the discomfort he spread to the room.

“Maybe it’s best if we go,” Will softly whispered and took her napkin from her lap. She placed it on the table and rose to her feet. “I am so sorry,” she bowed her head in sorrow. “Thank you so much for having us-,” she had her hand on Frank’s shoulder but he shrugged out of her grasp and stomped to his feet. He stalked off out of the room with Will quickly going after him.

“Frank!” The door slammed sharply, followed by a softer reopening and closing.

Hoffman straightened his back, readjusted his shirt, and took a seat with a calm sigh. He returned to his food, pretending nothing was amiss. “Can someone pass the ravioli?” He asked the room of stunned patrons, taking another bite.

The rest of the meal had been quiet, everyone somber. Hoffman didn’t let it bother his night too much. He didn’t like seeing Angie look so troubled, her eyes brimming with tears from the stressful event. But she wouldn’t need to worry. Frank was not welcome back. That was for sure.

Natalie tried to help keep the night going well. She was a real champ, talking about how she was a painter. An artist. Angie and Peter took in all her words religiously, clearly trying to distract from the intensity that had stormed through their evening.

Once the meal was done, dessert came and went. Hoffman didn’t find himself enjoying it as much as he’d like, a flicker of thought on Will making his appetite flatten. He hoped she was fine. He should probably call her later that night, to check up on her. Unless that prick takes her phone. That could make things worse.

Finally, it was time to go home.

When Peter and Angie said their goodbyes, he took Peter aside and whispered in his ear. "You have your revolver?"

Peter's face was shocked. "Yeah-why?" He whispered back, casting a nervous glance at Angie.

"If that fucker comes back, don't open the door. Call the police. Call me. And keep your gun handy. Don't let him anywhere near Angie."

"Is he dangerous?" Peter was slow on the uptake but his eyes were all serious and prepared.

"Yeah. Just keep an eye out."

He and Natalie said their goodbyes, descending down the stairs of the apartment building.

“So…” Natalie had trailed off for a moment but stopped their descent midway down. “What was up with that guy?”

“Frank?”

“Yeah.”

Hoffman shrugged. “He’s a fuck.”

“Yeah. I got that. But-I got some creepy vibes from him. He doesn’t… hurt Will or anything, does he?”

Hoffman looked up at her, blinking. “It’s not really your business.”

She let out a harsh laugh. “Oh. I see.” She folded her arms and leaned against the railing, looking cool and distant. “Well, it’s your business. Isn’t it?”

He didn’t respond to this. He didn’t like this conversation. She was still a stranger. A bystander. She wasn’t involved. Why was she being so upset?

“The fact that you’re not saying anything is telling me everything I need to know.” She sighed and continued down the stairs. He had driven her there, but she didn’t make a point to return to the car when they stepped outside. He stood waiting at the passenger side, holding the door for her. She shook her head, a sad frown on her lips. “Mark, I think I’ll take a cab.”

He blinked, confused. “Are you sure? You want me to hail you one?”

“I’m sure. And no.” She started walking away, bewildering him.

“What’s wrong?” He called out to her, not understanding the sudden shift in her demeanor. She had dismissed him, all her beauty and grace shelled off and shutting him out.

She stopped and turned around. “Look. I’m sure you mean well. You clearly care about your sister. But I’ve been getting some mixed signals from you. And red flags. I don’t think this is going to work out,” she shook her head, hands in her pockets.

“I don’t get it,” he bit his lip. “Can you explain?”

“Well, you’re very private. You don’t tell your sister your partner’s a woman. I get not telling me. It’s like the second date, why would you? But clearly, she seemed bothered by you lying to her about it. And just that whole,” she waved her hand in a circle, “thing with you and your partner. I get some vibes that there’s something there, something more than just a working relationship. That you two are close, which is fine, I’m not the jealous type. But if you really cared about her like a friend, then what’s with her husband?” She slumped her shoulders. “Oh my God, that guy. I can’t believe you just sit back and let him be that way. You must have known about him before today.”

“Why do you care? You don’t know the whole story.”

“Maybe not, but I want no part in it after what I’ve seen.” She took a step back to him, a solemn look on her face. “Sorry, but I’m just not feeling us anymore.” She put a hand on his shoulder and kissed him on the cheek. “Good luck to you. Take care.”

She turned and walked off, the woman of his dreams disappearing before he even had a chance.

Wilhelmina Maddox

He had punched her in the stomach. It not only pushed the wind out of her lungs, but she dry heaved to the side as she bowed over, clutching her gut and coughed. She was in the foyer, so close to the door. Her purse was drawn across her chest. She had been so close.

It was over. She had told him as much as soon as they had gotten home. She was leaving. She would leave if it killed her.

“You think you can just go?!” He screamed, throwing the nearest object at her back, a picture frame. The glass exploded and her spine shot electric needles on her back ribs. She turned to see it had been the wedding photo she had hung when they first moved there.

“Yes,” she choked out. “I can’t do this anymore, Frank.” She went to reach for the doorknob but felt herself get pulled back by her ponytail. Every inch of her begged for the pain to stop. She just wanted it all to stop.

She spun and punched him as hard as she could in the neck, finally letting her training take over. It horrified and excited her how good it felt. He had released her hair promptly and clutched his neck, gasping with the whites of his eyes growing into giant saucers that stared at her in disbelief. She had drawn her gun from her purse, pointing it at him. She knew she wouldn’t shoot him but if the gun went off, she didn’t think she’d be complaining too much.

He looked at the weapon with a newfound fear in his eye. “Will,” he rasped.

“Back the fuck up.” The safety was on. Her finger wasn’t even in the trigger guard. But she wanted him to just leave her alone. Once and for all. She was so tired of the pain. She was so tired of being hurt by him. Her hand tremored, not from the weight of the gun, but from the adrenaline that coursed through her and from the muscle cramps that came from getting slammed against the wall.

She wouldn’t cry. She was beyond that. She just wanted to make her escape. She backed out the door and slammed it shut behind her, briskly walking towards the stairs. If he chased her, he’d have to do so where plenty of neighbors could intervene. Or at least witness. She didn’t care anymore about what people thought. She just wanted to get away. She heard footsteps behind her and her name, making her begin to sprint down the stairs while her heart thudded in her chest.

The humiliation was too much. This had happened too many times. She had come to this city for change; for a fresh start. And he went and poisoned all of it. All she heard was her scared breathing and her heart in her ears as she quickly descended the many levels of stairs. There was a ringing in her head and she felt as though she was not in her body, but watching it from above. It was like she was a character going about the motions of putting one foot on a step and repeating, until she rushed out to the front doors of the building and gasped in the sweetest, coldest air she had tasted since she had first arrived here.

She looked up at the starless sky and around at the city. She squeezed her grip on her gun. Amber lights illuminated the streetwalkers, who didn't look at her as they went about their business. She looked at her back, at the depressing bricks of the building that she always dreaded approaching when she got home from work.

This was it. She was leaving for the last time.

“Will?” A male voice called to her and she jumped, spinning her head, raising her gun. She immediately pointed the weapon to the air when the figure flinched.

“Hoffman?” She whispered, blinking fast. Her skull was prickling. She felt something wet trickle down her forehead. Was it raining? Was she sweating? Or was it... “Shit. I almost shot you. I thought-,”

“What happened?” He had held his hands up in rapid response to her weapon but lowered them and approached her once she no longer had the barrel pointed in his direction. “Where’s Frank?”

She threw her chin to the building. “In there. I just ended things. I’m done.”

“Sure,” Hoffman’s hand landed on her shoulder. She jumped and spun her face to look up at his, realizing she was hyperventilating. Panic attack. This is a panic attack. She felt the warm metal of her gun get gently tugged out of her grip. He had taken it from her, she realized. She looked up at his face, her vision cloudy. “You’re shivering, Will.” He looked around, checking the surroundings as though scanning for trouble, before taking his jacket off and putting it around her shoulders. “Come on. Let’s get you out of the cold. It’s going to rain. My car’s right over there.”

She nodded, following him numbly. She didn’t recall getting in the car. She didn’t recall the heat being turned on and blasting inher face. She didn’t recall him saying anything until she noticed the car was parked somewhere that was not her stomping grounds. She hadn't even realized he had driven her somewhere.

“Where are we?” She scanned the unfamiliar streets, expecting the station to appear. She figured he was taking her to file a police report. Or maybe he was taking her to Angie’s? Though that would simply be too embarrassing to deal with. She’d get a hotel. Yeah. A hotel would be nice.

“My place.” Hoffman turned to her, eyes serious. “You left Frank. This is the most dangerous time for you. You know that. If Frank tries to find you, he knows where you work. He knows where Angie is. He knows where you like to go. But he doesn’t know where I live. And if he happens to find out, he won’t touch you. I promise. I won’t let that happen.”

She didn’t fully register what he was saying but his words helped soothe her. His voice was deep and rich, confident and strong. He had a hand graze her shoulder, gentle. She just nodded. “Thanks.”

“Don’t mention it.” He got out of the car and she followed, keeping her eyes downcast. Bits and pieces of the next few minutes unfolded in snapshots. She was entering an unfamiliar building. Blue. She saw pale blue. Maybe the walls. Maybe his eyes.

The ding of an elevator. The feeling of ventilation on her face as she walked by some air vents. The smell of cheap cleaning solution and the mustiness of an old building filled her nose. The sound of metal on metal and the sliding of a deadbolt. The creak of a rusty door hinge.

The click of a door closing. The sound of locks being engaged. Darkness. She was in darkness.

And then soft, yellow light shined, throwing her off guard for a moment. When her vision adjusted, she realized where she was.

His place.

Hoffman had gone into the kitchen, tossing his keys on the counter. His apartment was small, much smaller than his sister’s, but had a coziness about it. The kitchen was compact and clean, the only appliance in view a coffee pot. On top of the fridge were various bottles of hard liquor, all brown spirits, and mostly bourbons and whiskeys. There was a small couch and recliner and a tube television that was perched on shelves full of VHS tapes.

The place had a neutral smell. There was a hint of coffee, bleach, aftershave, and a smell that she could only identify as his scent. A mix of musk and oak.

“It’s clean,” she muttered as she stepped deeper into his domain. There was a photo hanging on the wall, a picture of younger Hoffman and Angie, with two older adults that must have been their parents, smiling back at her.

“What, you assume I live like a slob?”

“Judging from your bar choices, yeah.”

He was pouring himself a drink. “Want one? Or am I being insensitive,” though he normally would say this with sarcasm, there was a hint of tactful awareness.

“You’re fine,” she whispered and eyeballed the glass. “I think I could use one. Or several.”

“All right,” Hoffman pulled out another glass, pouring her a healthy amount. “I don’t think I’ve seen you drink much.”

“Yeah. I just don’t like hangovers.” She threw the glass back, not caring if it was brash or uncultured. She just wanted to feel numb, not this hypersensitivity that made her fidget. She let out a gag at how hot her throat felt and tried to resist coughing. She was more of a wine and beer kind of drinker.The firewater burned a hole in her chest. “But right now, I don’t give a fuck.” She placed the glass back on the counter and leaned over it. “Fuck, Hoffman. Fuck my life.”

“Yeah,” was all he said as the sound of liquid pouring trickled through the two of them. He slid the glass back at her and she heard him take a big gulp of his glass. “I feel that.”

She looked up at him, realizing something else was amiss. “What happened with Natalie?”

“She dumped me.” He poured himself another and downed it again with ease, unperturbed by the alcohol content. “Said I should be more involved with-,” he looked at her, then, as though considering his next words carefully, “-the welfare of my friends. She's right.”

Her face felt flush as the heat of the bourbon warmed her toes. "Damn. I'm sorry, Mark. That doesn't seem fair though. She ended it just like that?"

"Yeah." He stared into his glass, stoic but troubled.

"Did you tell her that your friend didn't need your help?”

“No. Because that’s bullshit. I should have stepped in sooner. Instead of just watching you struggle through all of this on your own.” He wouldn't look at her. “I just didn’t believe it was that bad. I didn't want to believe it. I'm a prick who wanted to not be involved. And I’m an idiot. Seeing the way he treats you in public-,”

“Oh, you thought dinner was bad?” Will let out a crude laugh, taking her newly full glass to the couch, and collapsed into it. “Don’t even get me started.” She let out a loud, exasperated sigh. “Don’t start going all guilty on me, Hoffman. I didn’t want you to get involved. I want to handle my own problems. I thought Frank would change. I’m the idiot. You did the best thing, letting me see it for myself. You respected me when I told you to keep out.” She felt herself relax, the toxins she was chugging softening her mind and helped melt away her anxieties. “You’ve been good to me. You-you came to check on me tonight, didn’t you?”

Hoffman took his seat at the recliner, bringing the bottle with him. He placed it on the side table that separated the two of them and he kept both their glasses wetted. “Had to. I know he’s roughed you up before. I’ve seen the bruises. And I got him worked up. I couldn’t let him just hurt you. Not because he was too much of a coward to fight someone his own size. Fuck, Maddox, I let it go for too long.” He clenched his jaw and stared off in the distance. “You need to press charges. File a restraining order. Make him stay far away from you.”

She took slower sips, already her head spinning as she tried to listen to his words. “Yeah. I know.” She hated thinking about it. “Hey. Change of subject. Mind if I take a shower?” She looked down at her dinner party attire, wishing she had a change of clothes. “And… got a spare shirt lying around?”

“Yeah-,” he got to his feet quickly and hurried down the hall, his feet stomping firmly. While she waited, she took in the entertainment center. She noticed some of the titles shelved were old movies. John Wayne. Clint Eastwood. The corners of her mouth curled. He would be into westerns.

“I never wear these,” he came back with sweats and a shirt from one of the Metropolitan Police Department fundraisers, holding it out to her. “I keep some spare toothbrushes. They’re in the bathroom. You can take my bed.”

“Oh, no,” she got to her feet and took the clothes, “You don’t have to do that. I can take the couch. I’d fit on it better.”

“It’s a pullout. And no, take the bed. I changed the sheets this morning. They're fresh.” He gave her an embarrassed smile. “Consider it an extra boundary. For your safety. You can lock the door. Can’t let you just be left out in the open here.”

She blinked and laughed, figuring the alcohol was hitting the both of them quickly. He was going full tactical on her. It helped reassure her, his mind working defensively even so late in the night. “I trust you, Mark.” She crinkled her face at him. “But please tell me you’re not going old-fashioned on me.”

“Maybe a little bit.” Hoffman unbuttoned the top of his shirt. “Hurry up with that shower. I want to take one, too.”

“‘Kay. Just a heads up, though, I’m not that tired. So you can always take the bed. I think I’ll be up for a while.”

“Yeah. Me too. I don’t mind staying up.” He seemed flustered, his face pink. She noticed they were standing close to each other, close enough that she felt his breath on her cheek. She needed to take a step back, wondering how they gravitated towards each other.

“Maybe we can watch a movie? I love John Wayne.”

“Really?” He seemed taken aback. “I’d never guess.”

“‘Talk low, talk slow, and don’t talk too much,’” she quoted, realizing it was a fitting reference. “I’m a sucker for anything on the silver screen.”

Hoffman smirked at her. “All right. I’m impressed.”

“Ah, don’t be. My Dad was just really into Wayne. He got me into old movies.”

“Huh.” Hoffman blinked. “My old man did the same.”

“Small world.” She smiled and slowly went to the bedroom. “I’ll be quick.”

She closed the door and locked it. When she entered and her gaze landed on the pristinely made bed, she felt her cheeks flush as the weight of where she was dawned on her.

Her curiosity drove her to scan the area, eager to get some clues as to understanding Mark Hoffman better. The bed was a queen size, gray comforter and muted blue sheets the color pallete. A dresser was against the wall, just underneath a wall mirror. She put her garments on the bed and ventured deeper into his territory. She noticed the dresser had a bottle of cologne, a comb, and a can of pomade. A picture of Angie and Peter, smiling, was pushed to the far back corner, along with what looked like some loose receipts and work notes that had been tossed half-hazardly there.

A knock on the door made her spin around. “Will-I need something in there real quick.”

She went to unlock the door and let him in. He seemed hurried as he went to the nightstand and pulled out a box. She looked at him with a raised eyebrow, expecting him to explain.

“Shaving kit. I don’t want to bother you tomorrow morning when I need it,” he quickly explained and went to the bathroom to grab his toothbrush. “I’ll get out of your hair.”

She smiled as he retreated and went to close the door again. Once she was locked inside she decided to save snooping for later. Hoffman was a private man and was already going above and beyond to help her out. She didn't want to overwhelm his generosity.

Remembering the reason for her present circumstance quickly pulled her back to Earth. She took a shaky inhale as she made her way to the bathroom and began running the hot water. When she looked in the mirror she had to do a double-take. She looked far worse than she had initially thought. There was blood caked on the corner of her nose and hairline. Fresh red welts were up her neck and the sides of her cheeks. She touched her face gingerly, hissing at how much pain was there.

Frank hadn’t let up on the car ride home. He had taken to throwing slaps and hailing punches at her face with one hand on the steering wheel, screaming and swerving throughout the entire trip. The memory was coming back and she let herself sob while the loud gush of shower water helped mask her weeping.

She went to unbutton her blouse, wincing at the strain it took to lift her arms. Her ribs felt as though she had gotten clobbered with a baseball bat. She pushed through and once she was completely nude, she studied the state of damage done to her. He had gone too far this time. She made herself look at the state of her body, willing herself to never go back to him. To never let him touch her again. Let this be a lesson.

The hot water scalded, the pressure strong and character building. It made the pain worse, but she pressed her hands against the tile and willed herself to have the shower pressure clean off the blood and drill into her that she could never take back Frank. She had done so far too many times. He could kill me, she felt her limbs tremble at the realization. She never considered this, not truly. She always held out hope that he deeply cared about her and would never do that. But he doesn’t. He never did. She was admonishing herself, letting herself softly wail as she grieved for the many years wasted. For believing that he deserved so many second chances. She cried for the life she let get out of control because she just couldn’t cut the cord. She cried until she had no more tears left to shed.

Mark Hoffman

His heart raced as he looked over his shoulder and opened the polished mahogany box. It had just two things in it.

Her lock of hair, from earlier that week, was wrapped carefully with twine. An old note she had scribbled and left on his desk months ago was underneath. The hair; he didn’t know why he had kept it. He knew it would likely get him committed if anyone found out he was keeping it. At least, Will would probably never speak to him the same after its discovery. If at all. But he couldn’t just get rid of it. It was a rich golden red, the curly rivulets like the color of maple trees in Autumn. It would just be a waste to let it go to the trash, like it was garbage. No part of her was garbage.

The note he took out to admire her handwriting. She had left it on his desk one Friday night earlier in their partnership. Grissom had chewed him out for neglecting his administrative duties, having pointed out that Will had gotten all of her work out of the way earlier that week. Apparently, Grissom decided he could have done so as well. He had hated her, then, having blamed her for his predicament of not being able to go home and enjoy his personal time off.

When he had gone back to his desk, ready to slam his fists and throw tables, a small pastry box and a tall cup of coffee waited for him there. The note had been displayed with his name in her penmanship. It had been cursive and elegant, something that was out of place from the chicken scratch he had been used to seeing. He had still been angry, about to toss the contents in the metal bin by his feet, until he decided to just read it.

Donut worry about a thing! I’ve already taken care of some of the workload. Hope it helps.

Also, donut give up.

-Will

The puns had made him groan at first but they had quickly diffused his rage. The donuts and coffee had eased the suffering of that night. The blistering anger in his chest had dampened as though cold water had been tossed onto the flames and a wave of shame had washed over him. He had felt like a real ass for blaming her for his blatant refusal to do any of the boring aspects of his job.

She had been patient with him those first few weeks together, patient on a level he knew was practically saintlike. He had never met a person, besides Angie, who had been so considerate to him. He thought it was just one of those things people didn't do for others unless they were bonded by blood.

She was just so fucking kind that he was at a loss of whether to thank her or to simply go about his business like it never happened. There was no protocol to deal with an overly cheerful redhead that kept doing small acts of kindness for him.

He chose his usual approach, of never acknowledging her actions, but couldn’t find himself strong enough to just throw the note away to be forgotten. He didn’t want to forget. That was the night he decided she wasn’t so bad of company. That note made him decide to go all in with their partnership and give her a real chance. He felt like he owed her that, after all the peace offerings she shoved down his throat.

He carefully locked and hid his secret behind the air vents in the corner by the entertainment center. That was close. Too close. From all the chaos of the day he had completely forgotten to not have it so easy to reach. He hadn’t planned on her coming over and he normally kept the box by his nightstand, to reference whenever he felt particularly hollow and alone.

Everything unfolded quicker than he had been prepared for and he was not equipped to handle Will getting this close to him. He hated not being prepared. He also had thrown back a few drinks, he rationalized, to make Will feel comfortable with helping herself to the booze. But really, he needed as much liquid courage as he could consume, anxiety itching up inside of his lungs as he kept reminding himself that she would be sleeping in his bed that night. It was overwhelming him.

He didn’t like the idea of Will being able to poke and pry through his things like he expected her to do, but he was glad she was there with him. It’s about time she left that fuck. He'd protect her, he was confident on that.

He turned on the TV and continued to nurse his drink, the rhythm of his pulse thundering in his ears. What would she do now? Probably try to live at work, if Grissom would let her. He smirked at the idea of her putting a bed next to her desk. He wouldn't put it past her. He had a feeling she didn’t take the job at MPD just to get away from Frank but he didn't know much about her outside of their professional relationship. Did she have hobbies? Hell, he couldn’t tell, unless it related to her career. She does like old movies, he reminded himself, pleased at the commonality they shared.

The door opened and she came out, hair wrapped in a towel and draped in saggy attire that he couldn’t help but snicker at. She looked like a kid wearing her parents’ clothes, his XL bulk not flattering to her petite frame. She let out a sigh of relief and curled up on the couch, toweling her hair and giving a gracious grin. “I needed that. Thanks.” The sweat pants were not clinging to her hips, clearly sagging down to her thighs. She easily kicked them off her legs, folding them, and tossing them over the armrest. Thankfully the shirt was long enough that it went down to her knees. He made a point to look away, not wanting to come off as scummy. A part of him whined, wanting to admire her shapely calves, but he held strong.

“All right, my turn.” He got to his feet and went to his room, shutting the door and going to rinse off. He made it quick, soaping, scrubbing, and rinsing. He wanted to get back out there fast, not liking the idea of her alone by herself. He noticed there had been some pink water droplets on the white tiles of the far back of the shower. He looked closer, knowing where it must have come from, a tight fury pecking at his sternum. Her blood. He rubbed the spots off with his fingers, letting the water pressure clean his hands as the shade faded to clear. He’d make sure Frank was locked up for this. For everything.

He got out, dried himself, and went to pull on some sweats and a t-shirt, checking himself in the mirror real quick. He pulled his damp hair back, a wave of insecurity making him feel the need to groom himself. He felt out of sorts, unsure of where things would go or what it meant,now that her marriage was ending. He didn’t linger on the thought too long, figuring she’d probably find someone new to spend her nights with, once she healed up and moved on. Plenty of boys in Homicide would come up with reasons to talk to her.

He dreaded how likely it was that those situations would increase in rate, once word got out that she finally left her husband.

He returned to the living room, noticing Will was on her bare knees, at eye level with the lower shelves of his movie collection. She turned to look up at him, not realizing he was taking in the curve of her lower backside. He quickly looked up to her face, hoping she hadn't noticed. The cotton shirt had been pulled taught by the heels of her feet, framing her feminine shape and he was too buzzed and tired to resist admiring it. “Okay… I’m torn between The Searchers and She Wore a Yellow Ribbon. What do you think?”

“-Whatever you want.” He went to find something to do, to distance himself mentally from the seductive domesticity of his living room. He felt himself begin to sweat - he blamed the hot shower. He went to get ice, freshening up his drink. He’d just get blasted and pass out. That was a good plan. He’d be too drunk to move, let alone try to touch her. He hoped he’d fall asleep in his seat halfway through the flick.

She pushed into the VCR the tape and then commented, “Shoot. You don’t rewind your tapes?” She stopped and pushed the rewind button, the tape reeling and winding as it revolved its spokes.

“I forget.” He smirked as she shook her head in disappointment. "I've been meaning to get a DVD player."

“Wow. I always figured you were the OCD type, judging from how organized you are. You hate it when I leave post-it notes on your side of the desks.”

“Because they’re always telling me to do shit. It’s annoying.”

“They’re just visual aids,” she whined. “I’m just helping you remember where to be and what to do.”

“You’re not my mom.”

“Well, I got sick and tired of coming up with excuses for Grissom as to why you didn't go to some meeting or turn in some case file; so, you can just deal with my post-its until you start showing up on time.”

“That’s fair.” He watched her straighten her back and push play once the tape finished, getting up to her feet with a low groan. The large shirt shifted, raising above her knees. He couldn't enjoy the peep show, though. Her right arm had a big welt. The back of her thigh had a dark purple bruise that looked older than a day. It disturbed him that he recognized it was from a footprint stomping onto the flesh. He stepped on her, like she was dirt. The anger kept building, brick by brick, pushing down on his body as he seethed.

She got to her spot and stretched out, her legs draping off the armrest. She reached across the back and pulled off the throw that had been folded over it, unfolding the blanket and draping it over her legs. He smiled at her getting cozy, her head supported by the pillow against the side of the couch closest to his left hand.

He could have reached out and touched her still wet hair if he wanted to, his fingers stretching out just to gauge the distance. His fingertips hovered just above her head. Her mane was water falling off the armrest edge, her head turned to the rolling credits and old orchestral music played as The Searchers began.

They watched the movie but he quickly learned she was a movie talker. He didn’t mind, having seen the particular film enough times that he could replay it with his eyes shut. She made the experience something new.

“Damn it, Lucy. Every time.” She shivered when the girl on screen let out her blood-curdling scream, the realization of her fate bringing chills up his neck. “I’m so happy I wasn’t alive back then.”

He looked at her with a smirk. “Yeah. Probably would suck being you.”

She giggled, rotating her head, and gave him a look. “You, on the other hand, would probably have had a blast. Riding horses under the stars. Saving damsels from invading tribes. I can see you being a Texas Ranger.”

He let out a low laugh. She reached for her drink on the side table and took ice-clinking sips.

The next scene when she spoke was when John Wayne, as Ethan, shot the buried Native American’s remains right in the eyes, to prevent him from moving on to the spirit world.

”Why don’t you finish the job?” John Wayne pulled out his pistol, spinning it and firing two shots into the ground.

“What good did that do you?”

“What that Comanche believes is he’s got no eyes then he can’t enter the spirit land. Has to wander forever between the winds.”

“You can really feel the hate there,” she commented. “It’s amazing how we’ve come a long way since then, but even during that time they still portray his journey as futile.”

“Yeah, well, they killed his family. He wants them to hurt.”

“I get that, but we both know how things turn out for Ethan in the end. I like the lesson in the final scene, it’s perfectly ironic.”

“What are you talking about?” He gave her a bewildered look. “It’s a happy ending. He saves Debbie.”

She looked at him. “But is it happy for Ethan?”

“Yeah.”

“Oh, prepare to have your mind blown.”

He was suddenly hyper-focused on the movie, eyes searching for every detail. He didn’t want to miss anything. She’s nuts, he fumed, she’s probably making things up.

There were more scenes she loved to point out, making observations he never picked up on before.

She laughed when John Wayne pushed the older woman into the house, preventing her from egging on a brawl occurring, shaking her head at the spectacle. “He’s such a buzzkill.” She was one of those intellectual movie buffs, always with something smart to say over some scene as though it was some artistic masterpiece. He kept himself full of booze until he was too blitzed to really care or try to understand. In fact, he found himself enjoying her voice and her quips. It was different from just watching TV alone. The room felt less empty. She watched movies as though she was always finding ways to critique or absorb some underlying intention. He just thought they made those movies because it was cool to see Cowboys and Indians fight. But he figured the Wills of the world probably wanted to add their fancy underlying messages with the violence and action.

Once the movie reached its end, John Wayne put his hand on his arm, bowed his head and his eyes were shadowed from the viewer. He turned and walked through the dusty winds, alone. He thought he figured it out. “So he’s wandering the winds?”

“Yep.” She sat up and stretched. “Despite his saving Debbie, he did try to kill her at first. He’d rather she die than continue to live with the Comanches. They kind of gloss over that, but he was motivated primarily for revenge. Not to save Debbie, but to just hurt the natives.”

He pondered this but his head was swimming and he felt exhausted. It was too late in the night to figure out any messages from some old movie.

He looked at Will, who was yawning with her eyes shut tight. “Thanks for staying up with me. I think I’ll crash now.”

“Good to hear.” He smiled at his partner.

“By the way. Where’s my gun?”

“On your nightstand. I took out the rounds. They’re in the drawer.”

“Thanks. I hope I won’t need them tonight.”

“You shouldn’t. But I’ll be right here. If he comes by, we’ll be ready for him.”

She nodded and reached over the armrest and took his hand. He looked down sluggishly, surprised but not able to jerk his hand away. “Thank you, Mark.” She squeezed his hand before letting it go. “Good night.”

“Good night.” He got to his feet and went to pull out the couch’s mattress. He checked the clock. 4 AM. Damn, they had been up late. He looked forward to passing out.

He heard the bedroom door gently click shut. He checked the front door to make sure all the locks were engaged. When he was satisfied, he got ready for bed.

Chapter 6: Pre-Saw: Here Enters Allison

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

“Hey.”

Will looked up from her desk, her skull a bass drum thumping to the rhythm of her heart. “Hey.”

It was Detective Allison Kerry, brown waves falling over her cheeks as she smiled warmly down at her. “You look like shit.”

She let out a small chuckle. “I started this wonderful hobby called drinking before bed.”

“I can tell. Word on the street is you've been crashing at Hoffman’s for the past few weeks. The man drinks like it’s rush week in college. Trust me, you should cut and run ASAP if you value your waistline. And your liver.”

Will winced as her head throbbed worse, hissing while massaging her temples. “Yeah. I say that I’ll never drink again every morning. But somehow, we both just end up finishing a handle before midnight.”

“Sounds like Hoffman.” Kerry gave a knowing smirk to Will with foggy eyes as though reminiscing a nostalgic memory. Will had never really seen Allison up close and personal and couldn’t help but admire her high cheekbones and long lashes. “So how is it? Living with your partner? And not your legal partner?” Kerry took a seat on Will’s desk, legs dangling off the edge.

Will narrowed her eyes. “Why? You trying to say something?”

“No, honey, not like that. Trust me, I’m not one to judge. I just-,” she looked around real quick and leaned close to speak softer, “-heard that you’re going through some marriage trouble. I wanted to say sorry. And offer you a place to stay that probably doesn’t stink of testosterone and gym socks. I have a spare bedroom and would love a buddy to help split the rent. You know how crazy expensive housing is out here. And I bet you’d love a break from the big lug.”

She blinked up in surprise. “Thanks, Kerry. Yeah. That sounds like a good idea.” She admitted it was time to consider getting her own place. Though she was getting comfortable, she was beginning to suspect Hoffman wanted his bed back.

“Yeah?” The women’s eyes lit up like diamonds. “Great. If you want, I can give you a ride there after work.”

“Sounds like a plan. But wait-,” Despite the pain she felt throughout her body her mind nagged at her that something was off. “-who told you about my situation?”

“I did.” Hoffman’s voice broke through, gruff and loud. Will resented how he looked as he always did, which wasn’t necessarily pristine, but much better than she fared at the moment. His hair was combed back, his suit looked fresh. She had opted to wear the same outfit twice in a row now, her hair beginning to look a little dull and greasy. She had barely gotten through brushing her teeth that morning.

“Looks like she’s in. I’m stealing her from you, Hoffman,” Kerry got to her feet and put a hand on Will’s shoulder and squeezed it. “I need a roommate and she needs a break from your drinking.”

He raised an eyebrow but didn’t seem too offended. “Good. Shit was getting expensive, paying for two mouths to drink. Plus that bra in the sink was the last straw, Maddox.”

“I told you, they were just soaking,” Will softly defended but bowed her head, her lip curling at how he had literally yowled when he had seen the kitchen sink. “But yeah, it would be nice to have a room that’s actually mine.” She figured she was beginning to outstay her welcome.

“Glad to help,” Hoffman was curt and expressionless.

“Damn, honey,” Kerry laughed, “I thought he’d be all shook up about you abandoning him. Anyways, come find me around five. I’ll give you a ride.” The detective left them two and went to walked towards the far doorway, where Detective Eric Matthews was sipping coffee and leaning against the wall. Eric Matthews nodded towards them, having watched Will and Kerry’s conversation. Will awkwardly smiled back and waved in return, not recalling ever formally meeting himthe man.

“Thanks,” Will swiped the aspiring pills Hoffman had begun ritually placing on her desk and swallowed several. “I didn’t know Kerry was looking for a roommate. How did you know?”

Hoffman reached for the morning paper and whipped it open, blocking the view of his face. “Matthews.”

“Oh. You two close?” Will couldn’t help but pester him, partly to see if his lack of hangover was more an act than reality. So far, it seemed he was unaffected. The bastard.

“We go way back.”

“How far back?”

“You’re amazingly obnoxious, for someone who says she’s in pain.” Hoffman slapped his newspaper down to his lap and tossed her an angry leer.

“Maybe I’m especially obnoxious because I’m in pain,” she muttered, cupping her cheeks in her hands while propping her head with her elbows. “Seriously, though, tell me, I never see you two together.”

“He’s busy. Has a newborn at home and works here. We don’t exactly go work out together anymore. We went to the Academy together. Graduated in the same class.”

“Oh.” Will studied her desk, her vision cloudy. She noticed an envelope in her inbox, the paper texturous and her name written in metallic ink. Her curiosity was redirected to the parcel and she went to touch the dry and rough stationary. There was no return label. A gold sticker sealed the letter, a generic crown embossed on the metallic paper.

She regretted opening it. “What the fuck.” The picture fell in front of her and she glared at the hideous image. It was a dick. A literal dick pic. It wasn’t a flattering image. It looked like a mushroom and snake were cross-bred with stray black public hairs growing in areas she wished she’d never known.

“The fuck?” Hoffman reached over and took the polaroid snapshot, disgust in his face as he turned it over. “Who sent it?”

“Doesn’t say.” She read the card, searching for any clues. It certainly wasn’t Frank’s. She couldn’t imagine who on earth would think it was a good idea to be leaving her such a vulgar note. Better not be anyone in the station, I swear to god. She braced herself as she read the handwriting in the blank cardstock.

Hey, Red.

Been thinking about you. Here’s a little something to help your imagination.

Come see me. You know where to find me.

Toni

“Gross,” Will shuttered and tossed the card away from her. It floated down to Hoffman’s side of their desks and he went to study the note.

His lips curled and his teeth showed as he sneered. Their eyes locked and she found him looking more concerned than she felt. “Don’t go anywhere alone. You got that?”

“Jesus, Hoffman, it’s just a stuipd note. Something horny high schoolers would put in my locker.”

“Only Rosello’s one sick son of a bitch. And someone in here put this in your inbox. Seriously, Maddox. Don’t go anywhere alone. Not even to the head. Grab Kerry.”

“I think you’re overreacting,” she sighed and folded her arms, leaning back and crossing her legs.

“I think you’re not taking Toni Rosello seriously. He’s targeting you, Will.”

“How can I take Rosello seriously if I’ve never heard of half the shit he’s done? Can you explain better?” Will petulantly watched her partner, searching for any indication. “What’s he done that’s got you spooked? Come on, tell me.”

Hoffman cleared his throat and pulled out of his desk drawer their latest case file and plopped it in front of her. “We don’t have time.”

She exhaled sharply through her nose, frustration heating up her neck. “Were you seriously just sitting on this all morning?” Flipping the cover of the stiff manila folder, the latest crime scene photos of a battered woman staring back with a pair of blackened eyes added to her intense migraine. The police report summarized that the neighbors had phoned the department, assuming the husband was assaulting the wife. Will chose to ignore the tightening of the tendons in her neck as she flipped through the rest of the pictures. One particular photo of the woman’s fingers made her flinch. The dainty pinky and ring finger were bent in the wrong direction.

“Figured you needed a moment to get your head on straight before dropping this one on you. Domestic dispute, Southside. West of Englewood Park. Grissom wanted you to talk to the vic today.”

“Why me?”

“She wouldn’t talk to the last two detectives, both male. She won’t accuse her spouse. She insists she fell down the stairs. In their single level flat.”

Will sighed. “I see. All right. I’ll talk to her. What else?” Will continued to rifle through the various pages, noting this case seemed longer running than just the past week.

“Her daughter’s been missing for a few months. The school finally reported it to us, after a social worker made a wellness check on the kid. The parents had been making regular calls to the school, saying she was sick with various illnesses but never gave a doctor’s note.”

Her heart already sank. She already felt certain this was not going to be a cut and dry gig. “Fuck.”

“Yeah.” Hoffman stretched his arms up and shot up to his feet, swiping the car keys off his partner’s desk. “You’re in no condition to drive today. Let’s go.”

Mark Hoffman

Hoffman had decided to stop and get some coffee at the department’s favorite donut shop before making their way to the suspects’ residence. There were several uniforms currently enjoying their late morning brews. He locked eyes with one particular uniform who merely looked away in cold disregard while muttering something that made his partner turn to sneak a peak with an unsubtle turn of the head.

He was used to this. He was, after all, the infamous prodigal Detective in MPD. He resisted clenching his jaw as he stared straight ahead as the many fellow line-standers looked up at the overhead menu or spoke amongst each other. They didn’t know shit. Let them swap their ghost stories and stay wearing the blue until their hair went white and they retired with no fucking idea of how the world really worked.

He felt thirsty all of a sudden. He cleared his throat and went to look out the front windows, towards his Crown Vic.

Will was likely huddled in the car, rubbing her temples while whining about how unnecessary it was to take this detour but he had skipped breakfast and she likely needed something in her stomach as well. He didn’t mention this, but he noticed her cheekbones starting to protrude more pronouncedly. Her already lean frame was beginning to shrink in a way that was more dangerous in the field than he’d like.

This was one of the main reasons he had gotten ahold of Kerry. He didn’t need to drag Will down into his bad habits. She had not only begun joining him on his nightly quota of whiskey drinking with enthusiasm but had started getting a little too cozy for him to handle. He had already been toeing the line of ‘friendliness’ to something more with their sleeping in the same apartment. With her passively asking him to open tightly sealed jars of pickles, casually brushing her hand against his chest when reaching over to grab something he was next to, or easily propping her ankles on his thighs when he was watching TV on his own damn couch, she was getting a little too familiar and that was dangerous.

It had been the final straw when she had sauntered out of his bedroom in nothing but her bra and pants that morning, as if they were long-lovers that he decided to cut the cord. He couldn’t focus. She was too distracting. And he preferred not having the urge to take a cold shower or rub one out real quick to keep himself from going insane every ten minutes in his own damn house. Where I pay the rent, damn it, he smirked at that, feeling superior while reminding himself of the fact.

So he gave her the boot. Kerry would be good for her. Hell, they could go to Vermont and get hitched for all he cared. He just wanted some privacy in his life again.

His phone rang, jolting him from his thoughts. “Yeah?” He already recognized the number. It was Ange.

“Mark, what’s Will’s number?”

“Good morning, sis, how are things?” The line was making some progress and he stepped forward. “Can’t talk for too long.”

“Then just give me her phone number and I’ll let you go,” Angie sounded rushed herself.

“Why do you need to contact my partner?”

“Because Rachel’s out of state for work and I need a lady friend to take me dress shopping. Also, it’s totally none of your business since it’s not work related, Moshy,” Angie teased back, using his childhood nickname. “Less talkie, more numbers.”

“I don’t think I like the idea of my work mixing with my personal life.”

“Like you even have a personal life,” Angie never pulled the punches. “Well, if you plan on being this difficult I can always just call Allison Kerry. You know we sometimes get brunch. I’m sure she’d hook me up with Will. Or I can just call any of the police wives I hang out with and they’d be happy to get me this info. And because this will make me use up what little free time I have to get this info - that you could have always given me instantly like a good big brother would do - I’ll just have to make things even between us. Like maybe telling Will about Pooh Bear.”

Hoffman’s heart stopped. “You wouldn’t.”

“Try me, Moshy,” Angelina’s voice had gone icy and manipulative. The hairs on his neck prickled at her using her childhood pet name for him. She only pulled it when she was feeling especially manipulative or drunk. He was confident she wasn’t drunk. He felt himself quickly lose the upper hand. “Oh, and how you thought Michael Meyers was real and you used to barricade your-”

“Fine.” Hoffman knew he couldn’t win and didn’t want to relive the cringe moments of his youth. He told her Will’s number. “And you’ll never mention any of this to her.”

“Of course, Moshy,” his sister’s voice was pure and sweet. Just like her namesake. “Will won’t know about any of the hundreds of embarrassing stories of our childhood. At least for now. Anyways, thanks, Mark, love you!” The familiar click of her hanging up her phone and the sound of the phone call ending made him half smirk and half frown at this.

Jesus. Sometimes, Angelina scared the shit out of him.

When he finally got to the front of the line, he ordered a dozen of various donuts, two coffees, and made his way back to the car with his haul. As he made his way to the vehicle, the vision of a sleeping ginger with frizzy red hair greeted him like a familiar breeze on a hot day. He felt his shoulders soften and his face go slack at the sight of her.

He firmly struck his knuckle against the passenger’s glass and Will opened her bloodshot eyes, rolling down the window and humbly accepting the steaming paper cup. He handed the box of pastries to her too before making his way back to the seat of control and taking a slow sip of his coffee. He helped himself to one of the cream filled cakes, taking a healthy bite while she stared at him with a distracted expression.

“Keep eating those and you’ll get a dad bod.”

“So long as I can chase down a suspect, who cares? And you’re one to talk. You should try one. You’re looking like a skeleton these days, shrimp.”

A gentle grin curled her lips and she took one of the plain donuts. “You flatter me.”

“It wasn’t a compliment. Can’t have backup blown away by the wind.” He wanted his words to sting her but she always let it roll off her back with a smile that annoyed and excited him. “Eat up. We’ll visit the kid’s mother as soon as you’re done.”

“Gee, thanks, Dad.” They ate in silence for a few minutes, the sound of the car engine whirring whining softly, the only background noise amongst them.

“Angie’s gonna call you soon. She wants to do girl shit. She mentioned shopping.” He broke the silence first, wanting to get ahead of this trainwreck before it got too messy for him to stomach. “Just keep me out of any conversation.”

Will snorted. “Like we’d want to waste our time talking about you.”

He sneered at this. “Good. Just so you know, you better treat her right. She’s important to me.”

“I promise I won’t have my way with her, Hoffman.”

He choked on his coffee, opening his car door to let the dribble spill out as he spit as much air and scalding liquid outside and not in his car or on his suit, as best he could. What the fuck, Will.

“Chill. I swear, it’s like you refuse to let me talk like a man.”

“Don’t even joke,” he growled, anger brimming up his chest. The picture of the two of them, deep in liplock burned behind his eyes. “Don’t even make that kind of fucking implication. And if you were a man, I’d deck you right here for saying that shit.” He glared at her, the imagery too horrific and disturbing for him to suppress. It was pestilent, like a mold, rotting his brain.

“Sorry.” Her eyebrows crinkled and her lower lip pouted with remorse. “I’ll just shut up now.”

“You do that.” He wanted to run his hands through his hair but restrained himself. He didn’t want to let her know how flustered he felt. His pulse was pounding in his neck as he gripped the steering wheel. He didn’t bother to wait for her to finish after that. He put the car in gear and began driving to their next destination.

"Shit!" Maddox's surprised cry made him turn his head real quick. He must have caught her off guard when he skirted out of the lot. The smell of spilled coffee and her quickly ripping open her steaming blouse made him punch the brake and pull over.

"You okay?"

"Jesus, fuck," She was already wiping the brown stains on her skin. "Don't worry. I didn't get it on the car." She looked pained, wincing as she fanned her reddening collar.

He didn't hesitate when he took a nearby water bottle and poured it over her front; her tight brow relaxed. "I'll get some ice." He looked wildly around and spotted a gas station nearby.

"Don't bother, worst part is over." She let out a small laugh. "Thank God it wasn't that hot." She was dabbing her cleavage with her shirt, the pristine white fabric now ruined. "You got your gym bag?"

"Yeah." He turned to reach for the duffel bag on the floor of the backseat. Thankfully he had put fresh clothes in the night before. "Here. We can head back to my place and you can change."

"Don't bother. We're late. I have some extra clothes at the station." He watched her throw on the oversized shirt, a wave of disappointment coming over him at the sudden modesty. She put her hands under the shirt as she proceeded to unclasp her bra. "Keep staring and I'll start thinking you did this on purpose," she gave him a sharp smile that looked more annoyed than casual.

He turned to look straight ahead, gripping the steering wheel tightly. He focused on his breathing. "It was an accident. Sorry."

"You're fine. Let's just go."

The Jeffersons lived in one of the shithole apartments that were overdue to be torn down and rebuilt with fresh condominiums for the gentrified-centric elite that tended to buy this sort of real estate. He pulled up behind the patrol car standing watch. He greeted the uniform who looked relieved for his cue to head home.

“About time, Hoffman,” It was Rigg, the man smiling up at him with more warmth than he was used to getting from the rookies.

“Anything strange happen in the last twelve hours?”

“Nope. Neither parent has left since I’ve been here. It’s been dead quiet.” Rigg was tapping his fingers on the open window sill of his door, eying Will where she stood by Hoffman’s Crown Vic in his rearview. She looked like she had just crawled out of bed. “She all right?”

“She’ll be fine. You should get out of here.”

“Yeah. By the way, IA wants to talk to the both of us. Before Friday.”

“I already filled out the affidavit.”

“Yeah, but apparently the guy’s lawyer’s called. I-,” Rigg lickedhis lips and looked up at him with that scared puppy dog look. “-I’m just-,”

“Remember?” He had to remind the guy. He kept his tone firm and his face expressionless. “He attacked first.”

“Right. I’m not saying different,” Daniel Rigg shook his head and spoke rapidly, “I just thought you’d want to know from me.”

“Good. Get some rest. We’ll meet with IA and this lawyer tomorrow. I’ll take care of it.” Hoffman already dreaded the politics he’d have to play. “Go home to Tracy.”

Rigg nodded, shooting his colleague a smile as he cracked his neck and stretched his shoulders. The guy was fit, shoulders bulging against his pressed collar. What a waste, leaving him as a glorified security guard. “Thanks, Hoffman. I owe you.”

“Damn right,” Hoffman let himself smile back. He remembered patrol duty after getting on the bad side of Internal Affairs. It was hard to crawl out of that pit. “How long are you stuck staking domestics?”

“They didn’t say. Sounds indefinite.” There was no resentment, only a weary acceptance that Hoffman didn’t want to hear. “But let’s be real. I’m just happy to still have a job.”

He remembered the feeling. He hated feeling so powerless when he was on probation. The kid was just starting off and already felt like this was all there was for him. It wasn’t. Not even a long shot. “You’ve got potential, Rigg. Have you ever looked into SWAT?” The guy was impulsive and had a hero-complex. SWAT needed more brash boys eager to run towards the action.

Daniel Rigg considered this with a raised eyebrow and a distant curl of his lip. “Sure, it’s something I always wanted to do when I was a kid. But you know it’s competitive to get placed, Hoffman. I’ve caused too much trouble to get a recommendation.”

“You’re not blacklisted. Let me talk to the higher ups. I’ve gotten on Grissom’s good side lately. I bet I can convince him to put you put up for the training. Might as well get you out of the car and into some action. If you can keep your head on straight from now on, that is.”

The man’s eyes shined. “You’d do that?”

“Sure.” Hoffman’s attention flashed back to Will, who was now approaching the two of them with pale green cheeks. “Maddox, you know Rigg?”

“Hey, Rigg.” She had her hands in her pockets and gave the rookie a nod. “We’ve met.” She was relatively cool to him, her normally friendly disposition unimpressed.

Rigg’s eyes fluttered downward, as though ashamed, and avoided eye contact with her. He cleared his throat. “I’ll be heading out.” The man started his engine and pulled forward, leaving them in a plume of exhaust.

Hoffman turned to his partner. “What’d he do?”

“Heard he got off a brutality charge he wasn't supposed to. Word is, you were there?” Amber eyes laser focused onto him. “You two seem to get along.”

“He did nothing wrong. And I was there. The guy threw the first punch. Rigg was just defending himself.” He took a step towards her. “What else did you hear?”

She shrugged. “You know how people talk at the station, Hoffman. They said Rigg broke the guy’s jaw and you’re covering up for him.”

“Who told you this?”

She bit her lower lip, hands folding across her chest. “I know it’s not true. Right?” She looked desperate for him to tell her she was right.

“It’s not.” The lie rolled off his tongue so easy as he stared calmly down into her eyes. “You think I’d pull that shit?”

Relief blinked back at him. “No. I know you wouldn’t. It’s just some of the guys seem to have it in for you. I don’t get it.”

He already suspected who she was mentioning. Tapp. The man had been gunning for him for his own reasons. Reasons he didn’t need to relive at that moment. And lately, the fucker was trying to take Maddox from him. He liked to take the fresh blood out into some suicide mission, the hero he was. This was all according to Matthews, at least. He wouldn't let that happen. Maddox was his partner. His. “Let’s bring in the suspects.”

Allison Kerry

Allison Kerry was staring at the corkboard that had various colored pins tacked on points of interest over the large paper grid of the city. She blew a strand of brown curls out of her face, frustration making her fingers twitch over her coffee mug.

“You literally have been standing there since I went on lunch,” her partner, Eric Matthews, strode in with a brown bag of leftovers he nudged her with. “You’re getting obsessed, Kerry.”

She took the food and put it on the nearest desk. They were currently in Tapp and Sing’s shared private office, a privileged workspace that Tapp had rebranded as their base of operations for taking down Toni Rosello.

Eric Matthews had been hesitant to join their squad, but Kerry always eventually convinced him to join her when she went on her side missions. She had understood his reservations. With the birth of Daniel and Karen’s medical problems, Eric had a lot on his plate already. But she needed him. He was truly one hell of a cop. And there weren’t a lot of those in the department these days. They needed all the help they could get.

Rosello was getting too powerful. The fat bastard kept leaving bodies in his wake and rubbing it in everyone’s faces. Sadly, he paid his taxes, otherwise the Feds would get off their asses and do something about him.

It was just them against the most powerful man in the city. Herself, Sing, Tapp, Matthews, and now Maddox, were the only people willing to take a stand. Rosello owned most of the department already. There weren’t a lot of them who were clean enough, family-free enough, or just plain mad enough to take him on.

“So what did Hoffman say?” Matthews leaned back in an office chair, propping his dress shoes on the desk. He folded his fingers over his head, his groomed hair getting messed from the pose.

“Nothing about wanting to work with us,” Kerry didn’t face her partner, instead opting to take some red string and wrap a connection between one of the brothels they had been monitoring with the latest string of missing underaged girls. “Just wanted his partner to move in with me.”

Matthews snickered. “I can’t believe he let her stay with him for as long as she did. Hoffman likes his solitude.”

“Yeah. You two used to be close.” She never dug with Matthews, waiting for him to get comfortable enough to open up when he wanted to. And he often wanted to.

“Class of ‘82. We graduated top of the class. We were the only ones to get excellents across all our examination categories.”

Kerry smirked. Matthews loved to boast, the pride in his voice and the sound of the truth stretching like a rubber band always tickled her funny bone. “So what went wrong with Hoffman?”

“Well, his parents were killed in that accident right after we graduated. He never talked about it, but I think it was hard for him, you know. He was under a lot of pressure. He had a sister he wanted to help support. Didn’t have anyone he trusted to dump his problems on. He had a lot of pent up anger and no way to let it out. And there was that whole crime wave going through. The budget cuts. We were all just thrown into the fire. Tons of MPD were getting hosed. So we started getting a little heavy handed. I got my rookie ass handed to Tapp who showed me the ropes and kept me straight. And Hoffman got assigned to… his partner. And his partner couldn’t keep him in check very well. And you know the rest.”

“Not really,” Kerry muttered. “It’s just ghost stories at this point. I’ve heard rumors about Hoffman decking Rosello at one point. I’ve also heard stories of Hoffman being Rosello’s long lost cousin and is secretly helping the bastard fuck with us. Oh, and this one’s everyone’s favorite: Hoffman apparently pisses off Rosello to the point that he goes and murders his partner’s entire family out of spite. And then his partner swallows a bullet from his own gun. Or that Hoffman was the one that did the job, since he works for Rosello. Frankly, I don’t know what story to believe. But they all seem to paint this guy like Satan’s buttplug.”

Matthews pulled a pen out of his breast pocket and began spinning it in his hand. “Well, let’s clear the air, then. Hoffman’s partner was Detective Knox.”

Kerry turned to stare at Matthews. “Victor Knox? He was Hoffman’s partner? But he’s not dead.”

Matthews’ eyes darted toward the door and Tapp stood in the doorway. “Yeah,” Tapp whispered ominously. “He’s not dead. But after what happened, most people here say it would have been better if he had died.” Tapp stepped in, Sing at his heel. “Shut the door, Sing.” His understudy obeyed, looking around at the faces with foreboding scrutiny. “Let’s set the record straight. Hoffman didn’t shoot Knox. In fact, those two still meet up once in a while, like old friends. At least, that’s what Knox told me last week.”

“So what happened?” Kerry had never known this story and was dying to know. She leaned against the nearest filing cabinet and eagerly listened.

Tapp shook his head, a jaded frown as he hummed deeply in recollection. “Well, Knox was a good man. One of the finest. He’s a legend here, no matter how scared the younger folks are to mention his name, he’s still a guy who had a hand in every major case when he was on the force. But when it came to Rosello,” Tapp shook his head slowly, “no one could take down Rosello, not even Knox. In fact, Knox had been made an example of early on. It was Knox’s job to… educate the rookies on how things were really run. Remember when Hoffman took you to meet Rosello?”

Kerry shuddered and nodded. “Oh yeah. Still pissed at the bastard for introducing me to him.”

“Well, he didn’t have much of a choice. You see, that used to be Knox’s job. Knox took every new guy over to meet Rosello. And Rosello would do what he does. He likes to fuck with us. Make us feel helpless. And when it was Hoffman’s first time he didn’t like playing the game. He tried to get violent with the fucker. And that was enough for a full out war. Personally, I think the piece of shit was just bored and looking for an excuse to start up some violence to pass the time. Hoffman was just unlucky to be the target. Knox tried to step in but it ended up making things worse.” Tapp rubbed the back of his neck and let out a sigh.

“What happened?” Kerry bowed her head, wanting to hear Tapp’s softening voice more clearly.

“There was a shootout. Knox was hit, several shots in the gut and spine. Knox was bleeding out. Hoffman was scratched, but not badly hurt. Rosello threatened to take them all out, the two cops right there, and their entire families as well, unless Hoffman got on his knees and begged for mercy.”

“So he did?”

“Well, obviously, since they’re all alive and well. Knox’s now paralyzed and lives on his own. He has a kid and - ex - wife, but they left town shortly after he got out of the hospital. Took his boy and moved to a small town in South Dakota. Knox refused to go with them, so she filed for divorce. Rosello leaves Knox alone now, according to the deal Hoffman made with him.”

“Why didn’t he go with them?” Matthews asked this, squinting at the veteran cop.

“Would you?” Tapp gave him a knowing stare, as though the question was just rhetoric.

Matthews nodded, voice forceful and offended at Tapp’s implication. “Damn right, I’d be out. Can’t put a price on family.”

Kerry blinked and turned her head slightly. She hoped no one picked up on the guilt that spread like liquid lead in her veins. Her eyes locked onto Sing who pursed his lips slightly. He knew. She knew they all knew. The shame was her cross to bear.

“But see - Hoffman hadn’t thought things through when he went and pissed off Rosello. See, Rosello likes to keep tabs on the new guys. Who they go home to after work. Where their favorite drinking holes are on Fridays. And Rosello had all the info he needed on Hoffman’s little sister to suddenly make the man his bitch. So part of the deal was Hoffman being Rosello’s errand boy from now on, otherwise not just Knox but Angelina Hoffman would both get taken out. That’s why,” Tapp turned to glare at Matthews, “we cannot - and I repeat - cannot involve Hoffman. I know he’s not a bad kid. But we can’t trust him. He’s got too much to lose to flip on Rosello.” Tapp kept his gaze locked on Matthews who rolled his eyes but kept his mouth shut.

“That’s why he’s been stuck on paperwork duty until Maddox,” Kerry concluded, shaking her head. “His career was sunk until she came along. Grissom was giving Hoffman a second chance by putting him back in the field with her.” Her lips felt dry and she went to apply lip balm on them while considering her supervisor’s motivations. He could have been left to rot in the basement until his pension came in at that rate. The thought of that fate made her want to blow her own brains out. She’d rather quit than be stuck on paperwork duty for twenty years.

“Maddox is key,” Sing commented, as though trying to understand her involvement. “She may work with the guy but she’s not dirty. She hates Rosello and wants to work for us. But still... aren’t she and Hoffman close?” He pursed his lips and shook his head. “She must know what he’s doing.”

“Not that close,” Kerry shook her head. “Sure, they get along. But the sexual tension between them makes it obvious they haven’t crossed that line.” She ignored Matthews’ knowing stare as she added, “I’m sure Hoffman keeps her in the dark. And despite her being an investigator, I get some gullible vibes from her. Grissom swears she’s so clean that she squeaks when she walks. And she seems to follow the book. She sounds like an idealist. If Hoffman has been going astray in front of her and she’d have known it, I bet she wouldn’t stand for it long. Even if she didn’t want to be a rat, she’d at least request reassignment.” Kerry was sure of this, her gut never failed her.

“Well, make sure she’s trustworthy before we give her the combo to the locker,” Tapp thumbed their secret evidence locker where they had been stockpiling the entirety of their investigation pertaining to the crime boss securely where only the people in that room knew the code to access. “I’d hate to lose a year’s worth of work.”

“Yeah, you and me both.” Kerry went to grab her jacket and cooled coffee and made her way out of the room. “I’ll keep you posted. I’m sure she and I will get quite close now that we’re living together,” she gave a passive smirk over to Matthews who raised an eyebrow as she left the men be. “Page me if you need me.”

When she walked down the narrow hallways, she stopped when she recognized the couple of the hour, both going into one of the interrogation rooms with a wiry older woman. It looked like Maddox was going to be a little busy for the next two hours. Checking her watch, Allison decided to head back to the boys and continue searching for patterns in the corkboard map.

Wilhelmina Maddox

“Hi, Mrs. Jefferson, my name’s Wilhelmina Maddox. Can I call you Anna?” The woman nodded. “I just want you to know that I’m not trying to make you feel uncomfortable or scared. I’m trying to understand what happened. So. You’ve been read your rights. Are you aware that you have the right to an attorney?” The woman nodded again. “Can you please say it out loud, for the record?”

“Yes.”

“And you waive your right?”

“Yes.”

“Thank you. Now, if you happen to know anything, please, it would help us out a lot. Or if you know anything about where Kayla is,” Will was playing her usual role as good cop, sliding the blown up school portrait of the young blonde girl smiling back towards the ceiling over to the woman. “I know you miss her. I know you’re a good mother. I know you want her back home, safe. Can you help me make that happen?”

The woman was trembling, eyes watering. She said nothing.

“Yeah, you can sit back and keep silent,” Hoffman had assumed his familiar patterns as the big bad cop. He slammed a fist down firmly on the metal table. “Because I know you’re hiding something. And we have evidence that points to you being involved.”

“No,” the woman began to cry, sniffling and wiping her tears with the meat of her palm. Will nudged the box of tissues towards her, shooting Hoffman a warning glance to back off. He did, leaning back and letting out a deep breath. She bit her lip, feeling how close he was to slipping. His eyes had narrowed and his nostrils flared, making her heart race. She needed him to give them the room.

“Anna, what can you tell me about Kayla? Anything at all will help.” She needed the mother’s guard down but every couple of seconds, Anna Jefferson kept fluttering her wide eyes up to Hoffman’s hulking mass and shrinking even deeper into her chair.

Will tried to keep the room calm but she could practically taste his hostility. He’s always so gungho. Keeping her face on Anna, Will reached and tapped Hoffman’s shoe with three firm taps.

The sound of his chair scraping against the concrete and the slamming of the door left the two women alone together. Will leaned forward and gently tapped the photograph. “Anna, look at me.”

The woman was shaking like a leaf. Looking past greasy hair, Anna softly cried, “I’m sorry.”

“Why are you sorry?”

“Because I didn’t stop him.”

“What did he do?” A shiver. A whimper. The mother began to let out a low wail. “Anna. I’ll make sure he doesn’t hurt you anymore. We have resources here to keep him far away from you. Help me find Kayla. We can bring her back and get you two far away from him.”

The woman shook her head. “You can’t.”

“Believe me. I will do everything in my power to help you.” Will knew it was unconventional to contact a suspect but she took the woman’s shoulder and squeezed it gently. She was bony and cold. “Would you like a blanket?”

Anna blinked, then nodded. Will got up and went to the door. Hoffman was already there, blanket in hand. He had been just next door, behind the two-way mirror, ready to get her whatever she needed. They locked eyes, Will feeling the frustration burn into her. Shaking her head slightly, silently urging him for patience, she took the itchy fabric and closed the door before he let himself back in. He wanted control of the interrogation but it wouldn’t be effective if she let him take the reins.

“Here,” Will unfolded and handed the shield to her, “Anna, I know what it’s like.” She pulled her chair closer to her, leaning until their foreheads were practically touching, like schoolgirls sharing secrets. “You give everything to him. You want to believe that things will be different tomorrow. And he promises things will be different this time. And that if you try to leave,” Will couldn’t help but let her eyes wander to the mirror, looking at their reflection, “that you’ll regret it more than if you just stayed.” Most of her bruises had all but faded away but the person beside her still had her cast on her hand and purple splotches that brought her back to just a few weeks ago. Her throat stung. “But if you keep protecting him, he will still be the death of you. You understand?”

Tears gushed down her cheeks and she choked out, “He took her one night. He said she was going away. To not ask, that it was best for all of us.”

“Did he say where? Why?”

“He owed some money. Kayla was going to work for a family. Pay off the debt.” The woman covered her face with her good hand, shuddering. “But that’s bullshit. I know it’s bullshit. I let him take her away.” She let out a low moan. “But he never told me where. He doesn’t tell me anything. Oh my God, she’s dead. I know she is.”

Will went to her knees and put her arms around her. “You don’t know that yet. We’ll find her.” Over the woman’s shoulder, her reflection mocked her. A clown, fighting tears, stared back.

Chapter 7: Pre-Saw: No Regrets

Summary:

Hoffman lets things get a little too personal.

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

It was his turn. He was ramped up; ready for a fight. Watching the soap opera unfold had been a form of torture he wouldn’t inflict on his worst enemy. He was relieved that they were finally getting onto the more interesting suspect. Because he recognized him.

Hoffman and Will were in observations, looking out at the one-way mirror where Clyde Jefferson, father to Kayla and husband to Anna sat. He was still handcuffed, an intentional accident on the investigators’ part, to instil that feeling of helplessness they wanted the perp to experience. Hoffman was sure he’d seen the guy at one of the gambling dens over in Chinatown, where the upstate horse races were live on dusty screens and tons of greasy goons desperately believed they’d make enough placing their paychecks to be worth something.

What Hoffman wasn’t sure of was how close the guy was to Rosello. If this got a little too intimate, he may be in trouble. Will being there complicated things. Especially if the details they uncovered needed to get misplaced. She’d notice, no doubt about it. He couldn’t come up with a decent lie she’d be satisfied with. He’d cross that bridge if he got to it.

He chose to just focus on the problem at hand.

“Take my lead,” Hoffman commanded, studying Clyde’s face. He didn’t try to look calm or innocent. The man looked miffed, as though this was just an annoyance that he would quickly have over with. “This time, you’re the bad cop. He’ll hate that. Nothing pisses off domestics like a strong woman that bosses them around. Don’t be shy about exaggerating. Have fun with it.”

Clyde Jefferson’s face was starting to twist, as though he had an itchy nose. At that moment, Hoffman thought the fucker looked like Frank Griffin and he felt his entire body burn up. Maybe she shouldn’t go in there.

“Oh boy,” she had one arm over her stomach and the other holding her shoulder, holding herself together. He forced his face away from the glass, observing every detail. She had let her hair down, rusty curls on her small shoulders like cotton clouds. He inhaled slowly, letting her freckled cheeks distract him from his scattered concerns. Her face was firmly uncertain. “I’ve never liked bad cop.”

This made him want to laugh. He smirked. “Because you’re shit at it.”

Her gaze sparkled with ire. “I think I can be pretty nasty when I need to. Asshole.” He liked the way her full mouth curled, cupid’s bow ready to shoot, as if she was any real threat. Cute, like one of those toy poodles. He felt his gut stir. His heart beat faster. She was his little firecracker.

“Yeah, like that. Just be yourself, that’ll piss him off.”

“Do you want a punch in the face?”

He finally let himself laugh, the feeling both straining his ribs but feeling surprisingly good. “Will, I’d like to see you try.”

The way she smoldered at him kept adding to his chuckles. “I swear, if we weren’t on the clock right now…”

“Raincheck that. Until then,” Hoffman returned to Clyde Jefferson, “get him to throw the first punch. If we can get him to try to attack you, we’ll be able to have some real fun. A couple of hits with a phone book will have him singing.” His lips curled wider, the plan getting his blood going.

“What?! No!” She gripped his arm suddenly, making him start. His humor was sunk. He wasn’t used to her getting directly physical and her sudden scolding confused him. “We’re not roughing up suspects in custody, Hoffman. You know better.”

He stared at her, realizing he was forgetting himself. She wasn’t Eric Matthews or most of MPD. And she probably didn’t see the resemblance this piece of shit had with the man she was married to. “Sorry. Just excited.”

“Yeah, I see that. What’s gotten into you?” She looked him up and down, soft brown eyes worried. “You’ve been - extra - on edge since we’ve started questioning the parents.”

He didn’t know how to respond. He thought it was pretty fucking obvious why he was feeling particularly emotional about this. “You know why.”

She blinked. “What, because of Frank? This case?”

“Get off it, Maddox, I know this is hitting you hard too.” He pulled the arm she was still gripping, nodding to it. “You can let go.” When she didn’t, he swiftly took his hand and wrapped it around her wrist. He squeezed it firmly. “We’ve worked together long enough now to not bullshit each other.” He pulled her close to him, close enough that he could smell her sweet hair. She smelled so girly, like sweet things and flowers. He almost forgot those scents existed. He wanted to lean in closer to her and take it all in. But he restrained himself. “You don’t have to pretend that this is just another case. It’s a little too close to home for you not to think about it. Like comforting the suspect,” he shook his head, disgust twisting his face. “She gave her kid up like a lamb to the slaughter. And you fucking started empathizing.”

“It got her to talk.” She was biting her lower lip, not pulling away but not looking particularly happy. They were so close that her chest was brushing against his upper stomach. Her lashes fluttered and her gaze flashed from his eyes to his mouth, lingering. He faltered, loosening his grip on her arm. “Mark. This isn’t the same thing.”

He had always doubted she saw him like that. She was always so fucking professional. He thought it was just all in his head. That he was just a man forced to be around an attractive woman he couldn’t touch, no matter how much he wanted to.

He thought it was just primal instinct, some no longer necessary facet of evolution that he was cursed to endure. So he kept things professional. And she, the married workaholic, just didn’t seem interested in that sort of thing. He was starting to believe she was a lesbian with how little she had expressed interest to the copious men she was surrounded with. A glimmer of hope rolled in his chest and quickly behind, a cold fear he didn’t like. This is new.

She cleared her throat and turned. “We’ve got work to do.” He felt his stomach sink but he knew this had been pushing it. Maybe he’d gone too far. He lost control. For a split second, he reacted and made her look at him. Notice him.

Remembering himself, he let her wrist go, looking at the wall with a cool stare. “Then let’s get this over with.” He brushed by her, his arm grazing her shoulder, a little rougher than he intended, and she bristled at this. Good.

They walked in and Maddox was the first to speak. She tossed the files on the table; roughly dragged the chair up and personal to the piece of shit. “All right, Mr. Jefferson, you’ve been informed of your rights,” she sat and leaned forward, looking back, “and we’ve already gotten all the details we need to convict you of assault and battery. Kidnapping, attempted murder, and endangering a minor. Now, you can make it all go away if you just fess up, or you can sit there and sulk like the coward you are. Your choice.”

Hoffman’s previous anger dampened as he tried not to express anything. But it took all he could not to smirk. Damn, laying it on thick, Maddox.

The man had his arms crossed, his knee shaking with wild energy. He let out a mean toothy smile and jerked forward fast, spittle dripping in her face. “Fuck you, cunt!”

Hoffman started forward but Will grabbed him by the neck and pushed him back firmly. She was faster. And pissed. “...and assault of an officer,” she wiped her chin and lip, “will be added to your file. Please, keep going. Unlike my partner, I love paperwork.” Her voice had gone chilly and sultry, like a siren. He couldn’t help but look at “Bad Cop Wilhelmina” and he liked what he was seeing. He didn’t know he had it in her. If only she stood up for herself like this around that fuckbag she married.

She cleared her throat. “You know, I’m parched. I’m going to get some air. Want some water, Hoffman?” She used his name through gritted teeth, smiling harshly at him with frustration. He realized he hadn’t gone to make any move to steer the interrogation, too busy enjoying the spectacle to begin connecting with the guy like he was supposed to.

“Coffee,” he smiled back, not particularly wanting her to stop the charade, if it even was that anymore. He’d seen her irritable. Hell, he made a point to annoy her on an hourly basis. But this was hateful. Petty. He liked her this angry, it was a sexy side of her he’d never known. He needed to have her take the role more often.

“Sure thing. I’ll be right back. Don’t get cozy,” she put her hand on his shoulder and squeezed it tightly to the point it hurt a little, before storming out. She wanted him to get going already, his shoulder smarting from her grip. Their previous conversation must have bothered her.

The fluorescent bulb above them was going out. The white light in the room flickered, strobing into darkness briefly. It was giving him a headache, the sound of the hiss and click of the poor electrical connection. He awkwardly repositioned himself in his chair. His mind whirled for anything to say, to break the silence. Something guys like this would say. “Women,” he shrugged.

“Tell me about it,” the man was touching his throat gingerly. “Even if I complained about this, it's not like they’d do anything about it. Double fucking standards,” the guy was putting on a good show of playing the poor victim, his little neck mangled by the big scary lady.

The man didn’t have a scratch or blemish on his pale throat. Hoffman resisted the urge to roll his eyes. The lights flickered again and he suddenly imagined the state of Will’s throat just weeks ago. There was rarely a day where it wouldn’t have some new cluster of purple splotches or stray scratches across her ivory skin. And this guy was whining about a five foot nothing pushing him back in his chair.

He clenched his jaw and snapped back into focus. “It’s two of us and only one of her. Just saying.” He had to play things like a good old boy, turning his head to carefully observe his opponent’s facial responses. It did little to keep his cool. Every time the lights came in and out, the man looked like a different person. Clyde Jefferson. Frank Griffin. Then back to Clyde. “I’m just doing my job and that’s to find out what happened to your kid. I’m not looking to give you trouble. I know the way things go.”

“Yeah?” The man kept rubbing his throat and looking up at the ceiling, at the shitty lamp and at the camera that was monitoring the whole thing.

“Yeah. You do your work and get home, expecting things in order. Some fucking appreciation. And what do you get?”

“Shit.”

“Exactly. I know the feeling,” he lied. He’d be happy if he had a wife and kid waiting for him back at home. Hell, he never expected Angie to make him food when he stopped by. She just did that sort of thing. Because she loved him. Because people tended to be more willing to appreciate people who fucking deserve being loved.

“At least I don’t work with a bitch like that,” the guy smiled in sympathy. “Tight piece of ass, though.”

He felt his cheek spasm at this. Don’t lose it. He pulled his teeth out and let out a small laugh. He was the good cop. This guy’s best friend. He needed the guy to spill the beans on whether this missing kid was being groomed to turn up tricks for one of Rosello’s brothels or if she was currently swimming with the fishes. He needed this guy to like him.

He could do this. He sure as hell didn’t want to drop the ball on this one. Will always came up with a way for the perp to talk when he fucked up. But this time, he didn’t want her to go through that. Not because of him. “Well, you know I can’t say that shit. At least not with the recording equipment on.”

“You and her?” The man made a lewd gesture with his hands, cuffs jingling as he let out a raspy cackle.

“No.” Hoffman crossed his arms and tried to give a smarmy grin. “Against the rules.”

“You kidding, right?” The man leaned forward with a lecherous sneer. “If I saw that bitch all day, every day and had to listen to her nag, I’d be just dying to show her who’s in charge, if you know what I mean.” The smile kept growing. “I can tell, she wants it. I bet she’s a filthy freak in the sack.”

Keep it together. The muscles in his jaw were starting to strain. Finally, the lights stayed steady. “I wouldn’t know.”

“Shame.” The man shook his head. “Gimme a night. I’d set her attitude straight.”

“Well,” Hoffman scratched the back of his neck, trying desperately to crawl through mental thorns to connect with the guy. But he really didn’t want to. “Now that she’s gone, maybe we can get you out of here before the night’s out. You can go to bed in just a few hours. We just need you to answer some questions.”

“Yeah, well, sorry. Can’t tell you what happened to Kayla. You see, she just ran away.”

“A nine year old just left? And hasn’t been seen by anyone in months? Come on, Clyde,” holding his hands out he shook his head. “You can do better than that. What about the wife? She know anything?”

“She barely knows where her head is long enough to put dinner on the table. You think she’d know where the kid is?”

“Yeah, probably not. But she mentioned you took the kid out and came back without her. Care to explain why she said that?”

“She’s lying,” the man muttered angrily.

The door opened. Will came in with a steaming cup and a bottle of water. She handed the drink to Hoffman. “Now, where were we?”

“I ain’t talking to you, bitch.” The man went defensive, crossing his arms and staring at her.

“You better talk,” she snapped, slamming her fist on the table. Hoffman’s cheeks relaxed. “You’re a soulless monster, you know that? I don’t see any remorse. Any regret. This is your daughter, Clyde. Your own flesh and blood. And you don’t want us to help find her?” She was tapping Hoffman’s foot like a piano pedal.

“Fuck you. Maybe I want a lawyer.”

She jumped to her feet, theatrical as the chair flew back. She had kicked Hoffman’s heel firmly, the message loud and clear as his leg throbbed from her assault.

“Okay,” Hoffman sighed and finally complied. The suspect wasn’t responding well with her, so she was removing herself from the room. Fine. Good. But he wasn’t sure he was going to do so well with her just watching behind the glass. Her being in the room would help him from going a little too far. He went to his feet and took Will firmly by each arm. “Detective Maddox, you need to leave. We were having a decent conversation until you came back.”

“Yeah,” Jefferson growled. “Bye bye, bitch.”

Maddox put on a show, trying to pull out of Hoffman’s grasp but he kept it firm. He wasn’t completely sure of her reasons, but he suspected she wanted him to assert dominance for the interrogation. Get him on the fucker’s good side.

When Hoffman shoved her out and closed the door he turned back and gave another half-hearted shrug. “Sorry about that. Probably that time of the month.”

The man let out a laugh. The way he tossed his head back brought him flashes of Griffin, chugging a bottle of Heineken. He blinked, not liking where his imagination was thrusting him. “Yeah.”

He went back and leaned back, let out a sigh and looked bored. He could hear his heart pounding in his skull. “So the kid runs off. Why’d your wife blame you?”

“She wants me locked up. Wants my money.”

“Yeah? You rolling?”

The man smirked, proud and full of himself. “Made it big last week on the tracks. I’m cozy.”

“But your kid went missing months ago. How were you then?”

The man’s smile faltered. “Maybe not so hot.”

“Yeah, that’s what she said,” Hoffman extrapolated, a theory growing in his mind. He already knew what had happened. “Said you owed some dough to some mean motherfuckers.”

“What else she say?” The man was licking his lips, concerned.

“You tell me.” Hoffman leaned forward. He was tired and wanted to get far from the shithead before his fists started moving by themselves. “But let me tell you, if it’s who I think it is, maybe we can work something out.”

“Yeah?”

“Maybe. You know how it is here.”

“I heard about you.” The guy crossed his arms and squirmed. “You know some people.”

“We all know some people. Maybe I know the right people. Maybe I don’t. You tell me a name. Who last had your kid. I may know the right guy to make this all go away. We just want the kid back. Too many people asking questions. I’m sure she’s not hard to find. A lot of girls go missing and end up close by. And I’m not implying you did anything or know anything. But we just want the kid back. Again, I don’t really give a shit like my partner does,” The guy was on the hook. He just needed to not play too thirsty to nail him. “But my boss says find this girl. And you know I can’t disappoint my boss.”

“Your boss?” The man’s voice had gone up an octave. Scared like a canary.

“Yeah. And you don’t want to disappoint my boss either, do you Jefferson?”

The man looked up at the camera. “You guys are pretty shameless. This is being recorded.”

“Yeah, well, you know how shit goes down in this city.” Hoffman leaned in close and whispered, “Records get lost all the time. You know how it is.”

“I do. Fine. Look. I made a bad call. I got a run of the mill of bad luck. You know I owed a fuckton of money to your boss. Ask him, he knows, I’m sure. It was so much that I was a dead man if I didn’t pay up. Not just myself but the wife and kid as well. But I was offered a way to pay it off and save all our skins in the process. It just made sense. So I paid.”

The lights began to flicker again. God damn it.

Hoffman kept thinking on his breath and making sure he asked the right questions. The distant sound of the clock’s ticking kept him focused as he pushed the tide of his emotions back for as long as he could.

“So the kid was payment?”

“Yeah.”

“Which of his brothels is she at?”

“I don’t know, I didn’t ask. I just gave her over to one of his guys.”

“The name?”

“Look, I don’t fucking know,” Clyde shrugged and just shook his head. “Like you said, who fucking cares. Just put her down in the books as dead and close this shit.” Everything went dark.

Hoffman had enough. He grabbed the man by the collar and breathed in his face. “The fucking name.” The lights returned but he knew he had already gone too far.

“L-Lorenzo!” The man was taken aback, the sudden outburst making him gasp. “Fuck! Help!”

The door opened and he smelled her before seeing her. Her footsteps approached him. “Hoffman,” she put her hand on his arm. “That’s enough.”

“Fuck, man, chill. We work for the same guy!” The guy’s handcuffed wrists were trying to pull him off his shirt.

Hoffman threw him back into his chair, hissing, “No, I don’t work for that piece of shit.” He got to his feet and stormed off, feeling Will at his heel.

As soon as they were back in the observation room, Will rounded on him. “I don’t understand why you wanted to be Good Cop so bad.”

“The fucker wouldn’t respond well with you.” He wanted to punch the wall but kept his fists at his side. He wanted to grab her and tell her everything he said in there wasn’t true, but he kept his arms still.

“You don’t know that. I could have handled it. I don’t understand what happened. You were doing fine,” she added haughtily, “Jesus, Mark, you were on fire, playing him like a fiddle. You even got him to spill on Rosello. I didn’t know you could lie like that. But then you just snap and grab him, unprovoked. It’s on camera. They can suspend you for that.”

No one’s going to give a fuck what’s on those tapes. “I know you could have handled it. But you didn’t need to. You shouldn’t have to. I got it.” He didn’t look at her, instead glaring at the perp who was currently getting taken to his cell by the guard. He fucking hated what he needed to do.

“Mark.” Her hands were on her hips, looking up at him with confused uncertainty. “You trying to protect me or something? Hey. You’re pushing yourself too hard. Look at me.”

He didn’t answer. He turned away. “It’s just been a long day. It’s late. Go meet with Kerry. I’ll take care of the paperwork and wrap things up from here. I’ll see you tomorrow.” He went to leave.

“Mark,” he heard her call out to him but kept walking as though he hadn’t heard her. “Mark!”

“No, Maddox. Just go.” He wouldn’t face her. “I need to be alone.”

She didn’t chase after him after that. He should have been thankful. So why wasn’t he?

Victor Knox

Victor Knox was always in pain. This was not new.

The firm pounding at his front door at eight in the evening on a Tuesday certainly was. It was the familiar cop-like beating that made him expect it to be an old colleague and not the grim reaper finally coming to collect.

He had fallen asleep on his recliner. As he leaned forward, a coughing fit hit. He desperately needed a cigarette. As he choked on his lungs he pressed the remote control to engage the motor of his seat. The mechanical whir rumbled and raised him up so his ass would be parallel to the wheelchair that waited patiently at his right. Above him were some makeshift metal beams with pulleys to help hoist his old rump up off the cushions and into his chair.

Once he was secure, he grabbed his shotgun that was leaning against the armrest and balanced it over his lap as he steered himself to the front door. “Who is it?” He stopped a foot back and to the side, ready to cock the weapon in case it was his final day on this godforsaken planet.

“I hope you got an extra slug in there,” the deep and familiar boom of Mark Hoffman made him smile and lower his gun. He wheeled forward and unlocked the deadbolt before backing up. Hoffman was familiar with the routine whenever he made his visits.

“Mark, about time you showed up.” Victor looked up at the boy - no, man - always surprised to see more lines and shadows on the once fresh faced young man he first met, years ago. He noted the carton of cigarettes and the big brown paper bag held in the man’s arms. “Wow, honey, you shouldn’t have.”

“Shut up,” Mark closed the door and flipped the switch, letting yellow light rain down on them. “It’s been a while.”

“Yeah, almost a year. You’ve been busy, I hear.”

“Oh yeah?”

“Yeah, Dave just called me last week.”

The boy didn’t respond. Knox hadn’t expected a positive reception. He still resented David Tapp, the blame misplaced, in his opinion. But the kid would learn. Or not. Who knew?

“Well, I’d offer you something to drink, but judging from the size of the bag, looks like you’re paying tonight. I think I’ll just offer my ears.” Knox was wheeling towards the kitchen table, where stacks of old newspapers kept piling up. He rarely left the building anymore, the elevator constantly breaking and his pension barely paid for his little pot of piss.

“Jesus, Knox, you need all this shit?” Hoffman was looking at the various garbage bags and paper stacks, nose crinkled in disgust.

“Well, if you’re offering to take it on the way out, you’re welcome to. Elevator’s been acting up again.” He went to open a window, grunting at the sticking pane.

“Here, let me get that.”

“Back off, boy,” he snapped, anger quick and hot. “I better be able to open a window in my own damn place,” he was grumbling like a sad old man, he knew this. But fuck it. His back was killing him and he had to wait four more hours before he could take another Vicodin. The window gave way and in came the familiar orchestra of sirens, gunshots, and traffic.

He heard the boy move some things around and the clink of glass made him calm down. He knew he had to be patient. He just forgot sometimes. Forgot what it was like to be around people not glowing on his tube.

Knox turned and waited, Hoffman going into the freezer and pausing to punch some thawed-then-subsequently-refrozen ice into jagged chunks for the tall bottle of scotch. The kid’s back was square and his movement was full of pent up rage. Knox whistled low. “That bad?”

He didn’t respond, instead pouring the rich, golden brown nectar out into each glass. Hoffman took a seat and they faced the small window to overlook the nightscape. They silently struck glasses together and took slow tastes of their evening delight.

With Hoffman, he needed to be especially slow. The kid was troubled and struggled to express himself. Not necessarily the worst flaw. In fact, in their line of work, it was easier to just push shit down and carry on. But if you didn’t let the pressure out, shit starts breaking. And the boy sure liked testing his limits.

Victor Knox was just thankful that Hoffman still remembered to visit him, even if it was just to act as his closet therapist. Maybe it was misplaced guilt. Maybe the kid still needed the father figure that was robbed of him when he first started out. Whatever it was, Knox was glad Hoffman turned to him.

“I lost it.”

“How bad was it?”

“Not bad.”

“You still got your badge and gun?”

Hoffman took a healthier swig at that. “Oh yeah. Not even suspended.”

“Good. Break any bones?”

“No. Barely ripped the guy’s shirt.”

Knox turned slightly at that, raising an eyebrow. “Did you hit the guy?”

“No.”

“I’m not following then. Sounds like you kept your shit together, son.”

“Not that kind of control.” He paused. “It’s complicated.” He was staring out the window, as though seeing stars for the first time.

Knox continued to nurse the scotch, smiling into his glass. The kid was growing up.

“I got a new partner.”

“Oh?” Knox was surprised at this. “You’re back in the field?”

“Been that way. For almost a year now.”

“So we’re celebrating,” the man let out a low laugh and went to refresh his glass. “It’s good to hear that. I knew Grissom and Tapp would give you another go.”

“Grissom, yeah. Tapp was against it.”

“Ah, well, Tapp’s an old dog like me, set in our ways. Can’t teach us new tricks, ya know.”

Hoffman snorted and held his glass out for Knox to top off. “You seemed to handle that pull up trick pretty well.”

“You know - damnest thing, son. I know I was against it at first, but you’re right. Those pulleys make it so damn easy to go take a shit in the morning.”

“That’s gross.”

Knox let out an old salty laugh. “Seriously, where’d you learn that mechanical shit?”

“My dad.”

“Ah, well, he did a fine job. It’s good for a man to know his way around tools. Lots of you young’uns these days don’t know a power drill from a drill press.”

“Says the guy who needed this young one to assemble you a pulley system.”

“Yeah, well, I didn’t do so good in math class.”

“It’s simple addition, Knox.”

“I work well with people, not numbers.”

“Yeah. I know.” Hoffman turned to him with pity in his eye. “Sorry I don’t visit more often.”

“Don’t give me that look,” Knox hated pity. It was one of the reasons he rarely left the house. Everyone acted like it was their first time seeing a man in a wheelchair. “No wonder you haven’t visited, you’re back doing real work. Good work. Cleaning up the city. That’s more important than lingering in the past. Besides, I’ve been getting into the game shows and crosswords. I keep busy.”

“Yeah.”

“So your partner? What’s he like?” Knox went to reach for a carton of cigarettes, having waited long enough. Hoffman took the nearest ash tray that wasn’t overflowing and put it close to Knox.

“It’s a she.”

Knox chose to delay his response, wanting to roll it around in his brain before making a decision on how to react. He lackadaisically lit his cigarette, took slow puffs, and inhaled deeply. The warm and tasty smoke was like fresh mountain air. He slowly exhaled, sighing at the habit. “Damn, thanks for the refill.” He took another long drag, knowing Hoffman was watching him intently for his reaction. “She good at her job?”

“Yeah. Damn good.”

“Excellent.” Knox knew the times were changing. But he didn’t envy the kid’s position. “How long have you two worked together?”

“Ten months now.”

Interesting. “That long? You trust her?”

“Yeah. She’s an idealist.” Hoffman let out a low laugh. “Keeps me on the straight and narrow.”

“Sounds like you respect her. That’s important to have in a partner.”

“I know.”

“So why, after all these months of not needing to, you decide to come to this old dog when you’ve got a perfectly good partner you trust and respect to cry to?” He watched the boy in the corner of his eye, wanting to be brutally honest but not scare him away. “I ain’t your partner anymore, kid. I can’t cover you like she should.” When Hoffman still stayed silent, Knox asked, “Is she giving you problems?”

“Not exactly.”

“You two sleep together?”

“No.” There was no hesitation. In fact, there was an almost urgency in his conviction, as though he needed more than anything to insist on this.

“But you want to?”

“That’s-,” The flustered curl of his lip and the pink in his face gave it all away.

“Ah, there you go. That’s expected. Normal, even. I knew two detectives - both men - who had a secret affair that took place their entire careers. I only knew about it ‘cause we were assigned to the same hotel room and I walked in on them one night at a Police Conference. I ate some bad shrimp and wanted to turn in early. They were so fucking scared,” he let out a low laugh, “and begged me not to report them. I had to practically make a blood oath to keep my mouth shut. You see, back then, they would have not just lost their jobs but probably worse. Most guys still don’t take kindly to that sort of thing. I never said shit. Not my business. And I wouldn’t have anyways. It don’t matter who or what they like to fuck - so long as it’s not kids - you don’t betray your fellow cop. Right, boy?”

“Yeah. Right.” It was Hoffman’s turn to sound impatient, probably tired of hearing him rambling like he tended to do.

“But anyways, so you’re getting feelings. Feelings you probably don’t feel often and wouldn’t expect with your partner. That’s normal. So what’s the problem? You tell her and she turns your hairy ass down?”

Hoffman let out a harsh laugh. “No. And I think she’s interested. She’s going through a divorce.”

“Oh, geeze,” he rolled his eyes and continued puffing at his cigarette. “When did I become Oprah fucking Winfrey?”

Hoffman was starting to snicker, his shoulders relaxing. The scotch was hitting. It took to near the end of the bottle now. Knox remembered once when the kid would be puking his brains over half a handle. Looking to top the kid another one, he noticed another two bottle tops poking from the brown paper just out of reach. He went to reach for it but let out a grunt at just barely grazing the brown paper. Hoffman turned to reach and pull out a fresh scotch, taking the liberty to play bartender for both.

“Well, she a looker?” He half-hated his curiosity, but now that the boy was starting to take a load off, this was when he could start getting the more interesting facts out there. Since when did he become such a gossip? “You wouldn’t happen to have a picture of her in your wallet?”

Hoffman’s smile was almost kind. “She’s pretty. Redhead. Freckles. Kind of tiny. And no, don’t have a pic.”

Knox whistled low. “She got a temper?”

Hoffman chuckled. “Not really. But when she does get pissed, it’s fun to watch.”

“Oh no,” Knox shook his head. “You know, if you’d just take my advice and ask out that one gal back in ‘92, maybe you’d have grown out of schoolyard tricks by now.”

He shot a dirty stare back. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

“I mean - do what kids your age are supposed to do. Flowers. Dinner. That sort of thing. Or is that old fashioned?”

“We’re partners. We can’t date.”

Knox let out a mean laugh. “Mark, you and I both know that you’re shit with following the rules.”

“Yeah. But she’s not. She’s so by the book it fucking hurts,” he pressed his fingertips into his eyelids, letting out a low groan of frustration.

“Ah.” Knox bowed his head. “That will do it.” He felt his face go red and his head spun a little. The booze was kicking in nicely. It almost helped with the pain. “How long has she been in? Is she fresh from the Academy?”

“She was in some suburb near San Diego for a while before coming here.”

“You know, I recall a young kid thinking life was so simple for a couple of years. And then he finally accepted that reality ain’t like a fairytale.” He swirled the melting ice in his glass, recalling that very same young boy who was not the weary man. Time brings down the mighty. “Maybe she’ll change her tune one day. But then again, I never got women. They’re so set in their ways. Stubborn. So fucking stubborn.” He downed the glass and let out a low gasp. “My advice? Ask for reassignment if it starts getting to the point you can’t do your job. Unless you care more about her than your career. All I’m saying.”

“I thought you’d have something more than that,” Hoffman mumbled.

“What, you think I have all the answers with my stellar career and perfect family life? You thought I’d give some helpful advice?” Knox let out a bitter smirk. “Sorry, son, but I’m probably the last person to ask about either.”

“Knox. I’m sorry.” Hoffman turned suddenly, eyes dark blue with intensity and regret.

“Mark,” Knox put his hand on the kid’s shoulder, surprised with how large he had gotten. A boy in a man’s body. “This was not your fault. You hear me? I pulled the gun on Rosello that night.”

“To save - me,” Hoffman hissed, pounding his chest so loud it echoed. “Because I couldn’t keep control.”

Knox shook his head, grabbed the kid’s head and pressed his forehead against his. They were both getting a bit drunk. Emotional. “Yes. Because you were my partner. And that’s what partners do. We’ll do anything to keep each other safe. No hesitation. Just as you for me.” He didn’t look up, not wanting to be seen crying. “And I don’t regret it. Never once. I’d do it again. Right now, if need be.”

“Knox.” Hoffman’s voice had gotten lower in a deep croak. “I’m -,”

“No. Don’t say it. Don’t ever fucking apologize. Never. Not to me.” Knox squeezed the back of his neck. “You do what you got to do. Keep yours safe. You doing that?”

He felt Hoffman nod and sniffle. “I still do his bitch work. I fucking hate it, Knox. I’m so fucking helpless. I just took Will’s recent case and shredded it. I had to call it in to his people. And he gave the order. So I did it.”

Knox was breathing hard. His eyes burned and his chest felt so heavy. “I know. I wish I could get you out of this. I really do. But you gotta do what you gotta do. For your family.” Directionless fury coursed up his neck. He knew the feeling of having no power all too well. The only place for the hate to flow was inward.

“And Will - she keeps trying to take him on. Trying to bring him down. He’s going to kill her, Knox. Or have me do it. Or worse. If she doesn’t let up, Rosello may come for Ange. And I don’t know what to do to stop it.”

Neither did he. Knox was at a loss. He felt his heart sink. Complicated, in -fucking - deed.

Allison Kerry

Allison Kerry tried to help Maddox as she frantically dug through piles of paper. She gently lifted some pages of a document that was unrelated to the Jefferson case. She already had a sinking suspicion on what happened but kept her mouth shut as Will went back to the same drawer the third time, searching for a case file that was likely not there.

“I can’t find the file,” Will turned, bewildered. “It was just here. I literally had it just here. Just ten minutes ago.”

Kerry put a hand on her hip, inching forward with the urge to tell her it was likely gone forever. She kept herself in check. The poor girl already had enough on her plate with her divorce. She didn’t need to know that her partner was a scheming piece of shit that was likely fucking her sideways to Sunday and burning all her hardwork. At least not yet. “Hey. It’s getting late. Even if I had the missing child case, Rosello won’t get taken down any faster. Let’s get out of here.” She put her hand on Will’s back. “Hey, Will?”

“I -,” Will stood up straight. “I just don’t understand.”

“I’m sure it’ll turn up,” Kerry lied, “Come on, Will, I’m thirsty. It’s been a long day. For both of us, I hear. Besides, the boys are waiting for us.”

Will was quiet but complied. Kerry tossed a mean glare over at Hoffman’s desk, wanting to pour some cold coffee over his space and throw his organized papers all over the floor. She chose to keep her pettiness locked down and led her new roommate to the car. “Have you ever been to the Green Lion Grill?”

“No,” Will was buckling up and recovering nicely. “Is it good?”

“Yep. Sing raves about it all the time. Hope you don’t mind, I figured it’d be good for you to meet everyone in a casual setting. Just get some exposure on the best of Homicide. You know, in case you’re looking for other career opportunities. Grissom is assembling a task force and wants us to get to know each other a little better, since we’ll be working more on taking down Rosello these next couple of months.” She got the car started and in gear, taking Will through the scenic route towards the Grill.

“Who else will be there?”

“Tapp. Sing. Matthews. Fisk. Oh, and a new guy we think will be good for us, Gibson. And two FBI agents I’m liasoning for. I’m hoping they’ll be able to help us out with taking down Rosello. You’ll like them.” Kerry couldn’t help but smile, thinking about her old college roommate, Lindsey Perez. “This is a good group of people. I really think together, we can take down that sonofabitch.”

“I look forward to meeting them.” Will straightened up. “How come Hoffman’s not invited?”

Kerry let out a sigh. “Look, Will, I didn’t want to be the one to break this to you, but Mark Hoffman isn’t exactly someone I would trust.” She gave the girl a sad look. “I know you two are partners. I respect that. But if you want to work with us, and you truly want Rosello out of the picture, you’d do best to keep everything we do out of Hoffman’s eye and reach.”

Will was quiet at first, then, “Be honest. You think Hoffman did something with that file?”

“Honey, I think it’s long shredded, burned, and the ashes scattered in the river by now.”

“What the fuck,” she whispered. Her fingertips flew up to her forehead. “I don’t understand.” Will was massaging her temples, sighing. “What the fuck. I knew he was acting strange today.”

“Hey. Will.” She didn’t need the woman to have an existential crisis on her. “I’m not saying the man’s scum of the earth. Hoffman ain’t evil. He’s just in a really shitty situation.”

“How?”

“Well, for starters, he has family.” Allison swallowed at this, the lump in her throat suddenly a thick pill that wouldn’t go down. “Family he cares about. Yeah, I’m talking about his sister. That makes him vulnerable. Second, he got himself in this situation way back, making things personal with Rosello. You know what happened with his last partner?”

“No, I don’t. He won’t talk about it.” Will turned to her. “You know what happened?”

Allison cleared her throat. “Well, he should tell you himself. But let's just say that he’s not sucking Rosello’s dick just because he likes the taste, you feel me? And third? He’s lost hope. He’s lost hope for a while now. He has no fucks left to give, except to keep Angie safe from the guy. He doesn’t think Rosello can be taken down. He’s more of a victim in this situation than the villain. And I get that. Maybe Tapp doesn’t. Maybe Sing doesn’t. But I understand. I’d probably do exactly the same shit if I was in his situation. I’m not going to judge. But because of this, I can’t trust him. And you shouldn’t either, if you’re going to work with us. If it’s Rosello related, Hoffman is not on our side. At least, not completely. You cool with that?” Kerry wanted to place her bet on Wilhemina Maddox. Maybe it was some deep rooted need for more badass women to prove that they could do this shit. Maybe she just had this gut feeling that Will was good company. Maybe she was just desperate.

“Okay. I’m in. If taking down Rosello gets Mark out of this - whatever this is - I’ll do anything. He’s my partner,” she turned to her. “And I don’t want him to deal with that shitstain anymore.”

Allison Kerry couldn’t help but smile at that. “Good.” Her heart fluttered at Will’s passion, reminding her of the good old days when she was first assigned to Eric Matthews. “So you and Hoffman. Things getting pretty close, huh?”

Will blinked. “What do you mean?”

“Well,” Kerry was getting close to the Grill. “Long hours at work, seeing the same guy all day and every day, I know what that’s like. It’s hard not to catch some feelings. And Mark Hoffman is one fine piece of man. I’d probably jump his bones if I had been assigned to be his partner. I certainly wouldn’t last ten months.” She parked and turned off the engine.

Will blinked, cheeks reddening. “We’re just partners.”

Allison’s smile grew. She didn’t want to scare the one local lady friend she had away. “Hey, no need to be shy. Just so you know, if you have any questions about things that the guys just won’t get, I’m all ears. It’s just nice to have someone at the station that is easier to talk about this sort of thing than the jocks we work with. Now, let’s get some grub. I skipped lunch and am literally starving to death.”

Will’s cell phone rang. Will checked the caller ID and flipped the phone closed, jaw clenched and looking off in the distance with a lost expression.

“Hoffman?”

“No. Frank.” Will shook her head. The phone rang again immediately and she looked down again, pressing it silent and powering down the device.

Allison eyed Will’s face and her hands. “Frank your husband?”

“Yeah.” Will brushed stray red curls from her face, shrugging and forcing a smile. “I’m fine. Really.”

“Okay, honey. If you’d rather just go home, say the word.”

“No. I want to meet everyone.” Will’s eyes sparkled with intent. “We’ve got work to do.”

“‘Kay.” Leading the way, they entered the dimly lit pub, walking past the hostess to the only large table that could comfortably seat eight people.

“Ally,” Matthews called out, waving at the approaching pair. Waving back, Allison’s eyes fell onto the familiar big dark eyes and crinkled brown curls of her old friend, Lindsey Perez, and her colleague, Peter Strahm.

“Thanks for waiting,” Allison Kerry paused. “You all know Will Maddox, except the Feds, of course.” Perez and Strahm both laughed at this. “Well, Will, this is Special Agent Lindsey Perez, we met in college. She handles human trafficking cases. And Special Agent Peter Strahm, one of Behavior Sciences’ profilers.”

Will shook hands with both, stopping to stare up at Strahm like she was in awe. Allison picked up on this quickly, whispering in Will’s ear, “And he’s single.” Will shot her an embarrassed glower before turning to Strahm with freshly blushed cheeks. The agent hadn’t heard her over the sound of nearby conversation. He smiled down at her with long lashes framing eyes holding an intense energy that Allison thought seemed extra spicy at Will’s direction.

“Hi, nice to meet you two,” she seemed to quickly grab the seat farthest from Peter Strahm as fast as she could flee. So she keeps her distance to men she’s attracted to, Allison couldn’t help but smile sadly at this. It was probably a safe practice. One that kept the personal life drama to a minimum, that’s for sure. Maybe ten months and not jumping her partner’s bones was the norm for Will Maddox. Honestly, Allison Kerry wouldn’t know what was considered normal anymore.

Allison sat next to her secret lover and partner, Eric Matthews, who shamelessly put his arm around her chair with the casualness amongst colleagues you wouldn’t expect from a married man with a son that was only five months old. Maybe Allison was just a slut that couldn’t tell prudence from pragmatism anymore. Again, she wasn’t one to judge. She knew she was just the Whore of Babylon to the nameless drones back at the station, according to the whispers she’d pick up on when she walked by, but she always assumed her work would speak louder than who she chose to fuck in her private bed.

But she knew that was just wishful thinking. Despite getting the brunt of the gossip, she always loved how the station hailed Matthews as a hero and a pussy slayer that could do no wrong - when he was the one with the family he took for granted. She was just lonely. She had no one but him.

And he had everything. He smiled widely, loud and jaunting, captivating the group with his moving hand and story. Cigarette in hand, he waved it around as he relayed tales of his rookie years.

“So there I was. Dead end, only got one bullet to my name. This fucker’s got me pinned against the wall with a fresh mag. He’s just playing with me at this point. Waving his pistol while his boys laugh. Firing pot shots at my toes. I think, ‘I’m so hosed. It’s over.’ And you wouldn’t, believe, my luck.”

Everyone was leaning forward, listening intensely.

“A black fucking cat just flies out from the dumpster and starts clawing the motherfucker on his head. The creep just freaks, drops the gun, and it gives me time to charge and shoot one of the cocksuckers. They all just spread apart. Disorganized. I had nothing to lose, you get me? I figured, I might as well take as many of those fucks as I can since it’s my last night on earth. And the fucker with the cat on his head had dropped his revolver and the others were too busy ogling at the spectacle to notice me running up and pulling the gun on them. I take ‘em all out. Like fish in a barrel.” Matthews pauses to take a drag of his cigarette. “And I walk out of there, and the rest? History.”

Tapp is chuckling. “That didn’t happen.”

Matthews smirked, slanted eyes upturned with amusement. “Well, maybe it wasn’t a black cat. Maybe it was dark brown. But I swear those fuckers are lucky to me since that day.”

“Uh-huh.” Tapp took a long drink from his pint, black eyes twinkling. “A’ight. I won’t steal your thunder, Eric.”

Matthews smiled widely and turned to Allison, giving her one of those smiles that just made her all fuzzy inside. Grinning back, she turned to the rest of the group. Sing was talking to Will, something about tennis. Strahm and Gibson were making small talk about how nice it is to wake up at five in the morning to go fishing. She rolled her eyes at this. And Lindsey, who sat across from her, was watching her with a scrutinizing frown, elbows resting on the table, full lips pressed tightly as her dark brown eyes flickered from Matthews’ arm around her chair backrest to her face. Particularly on the wedding band on his finger. She knew that look and dreaded the lecture that was likely going to follow later.

“Lindsey, how was the flight up here?”

“A lot of turbulence. Almost lost my lunch.” She let out a small laugh. “I’ve missed you. I don’t think we’ve seen each other in person since graduation.”

“Yeah,” Allison felt a sadness weigh on her. “I’ve missed you too. Thanks for coming up.”

“Yeah. We’re happy to help. I heard it’s been hard up here.” This was a politician’s response. A pragmatic, diplomatic response.

“It’s been fucking hell, Lindsey, don’t be shy to tell me. I know.” Allison leaned closer to her friend with eyelids blinking with exhaustion. “This table has the only non-corrupt detectives we have in Homicide right now. It’s David and Goliath up in this shithole of a city.

“Yeah. That’s what I’ve heard.” Lindsey’s voice was soft, compassionate. She was biting her lip. “Well, you’ve got me and Strahm for the next few months. We’ll help in any way we can. Our supervisor is glad for this chance to work with the department, especially if it means taking down one of the nation’s worst crime bosses.”

“Thank you.” She felt relief come over her, a much needed reassurance she didn’t realize she was so hungry for. She then nodded to Strahm. “He ain’t bad to look at. You two…?”

“Ally,” Lindsey scolded, “You know I don’t like to mix work and personal life.” This felt like a personal attack, but she let it slide. She knew she deserved it if it was. “Besides. He’s not my type.”

Allison hummed at this, taking a swig of beer as she contemplated the two FBI agents. It was clear Strahm seemed more invested with talking with Gibson and throwing glances at Will than looking at his partner’s direction. This intrigued her, making the inside of her chest flutter with hopeful zest. “What is your type, Linds?”

Lindsey Perez gave her a knowing smile. “You don’t remember, Ally? Didn’t take you as forgetful.” There was a heat in her voice and an electricity in her gaze that made Allison’s lower stomach jolt and tense.

“Oh, I remember. I was just wondering if your tastes… changed since then.”

“Not changed. Only matured,” there was a teasing in her words, coaxing for her to dive further. Allison felt her cheeks go hot.

“So Perez,” Eric broke into the conversation, “You and Ally go way back?”

Chapter 8: Pre-Saw: Just Another Dirty Cop

Chapter Text

Daniel Rigg

Daniel sat with his hands in his lap. His pressed collar was strangling him. The uniform was stifling and itchy. He kept his gaze downward as the hotshot lawyer’s fancy shoes clicked on the linoleum. He wanted to look harmless, shrinking into his chair.

Hoffman had taken one of the higher ups’ offices for this meeting. He was calm, sitting behind the desk with his jacket hanging by the door, giving an easy expression that wasn’t exactly a smile but wasn’t hostile either. He held himself calmly, shoulders squared with the confidence of a man in charge.

Rigg kept his head down, hoping he didn't mess things up this time. The lawyer hardly gave him his attention.

“My client has a broken nose and a fractured cheek bone,” his voice was low and bored as he studied the bulletins tacked on the wall. “Administrative leave with pay is not acceptable.”

He watched Hoffman who gave him a stern glance. “The IA investigation is underway, Mr. Blank.”

The lawyer smirked at this. “In this precinct, huh? What’s that gonna get me?”

“The truth.”

“The truth? Well I’ll tell you what the truth is. The truth is I have an eye witness.”

“The man’s wife? She gains as much as he does if there was to be a financial settlement. Which is not going to happen because he’s lying. He attacked Officer Rigg first.”

Art Blank’s eyes bored into the top of his head. Daniel struggled to keep his eyes downcast. “According to who?”

“Me. I saw the whole thing,” Hoffman’s eyes had gone soft, almost nurturing. When Daniel looked up he saw someone who cared. Someone who was looking out for him. There was an understanding there that made him feel safe.

“Would you testify before a grand jury?”

“I’ve already signed IA’s affidavit. The charges are being dismissed.” There was almost a smug smile on Hoffman’s face.

“You’re good,” Art Blank rested his shoulder against the wall, cool dismissal sliding off his tongue. “You’re - you’re obviously thick as thieves in this precinct. But you know it’ll come back to you, right? Maybe not today but someday. It’ll come back to you.”

Daniels hairs stood on the back of his neck and he felt the blood rush out of his face. Hoffman stared up at the man, unphased. There was a low rumble in his words, as though daring him to do his worst. “Well, Mr. Blank, what goes around. Is that all?”

“Unfortunately,” the man in the fancy suit slithered out, slamming the door behind him. As soon as his silhouette vanished from the glass windows, Daniel covered his face with his hands and sank into his seat, a sigh ghosting out of his lungs.

“Jesus. That was intense.”

“I told you I’d take care of it,” Hoffman got to his feet and went to get his jacket. “Go home. Spend the next two weeks kicking back. Relax. Tell Tracy that Angie and myself say hi.”

“Thanks, Hoffman. Seriously.” Daniel jumped to his feet, taking the man’s hand and shaking it with overwhelming gratitude. He was in awe. He didn’t understand why people gave the guy a wide berth. He was a fucking saint. “You just handled that so easily.”

“Comes with experience. Trust me, you’ll get there.” He seemed distracted. In a rush. He was already a foot out of the office but Daniel didn’t want him to leave just yet.

“Hey, Hoff,” Daniel grabbed his arm, flinching when Hoffman stopped and stared at his hand. “Sorry. But just so you know. If there’s anything you need that I can do. Just say the word.”

“Sure thing,” there was a pleased pull of his cheek and a calculating stare. “And don’t worry, I haven’t forgotten about the SWAT recommendation. I’ll forward it to Grissom as soon as I get a chance. And I’ll keep you posted if I need anything.”

“Thanks, man. You’re the best.”

“Don’t you forget it.”

Wilhelmina Maddox

“Will, please,” Frank’s voice was pleading over the receiver. “Please come home.”

Why did she accept the call? “It’s over,” she whispered back, still too sleep-induced to think of the right words to end the call right there. Her throat was tight but she kept herself firm. She wasn’t going back. Even if a small part of her wanted to.

She heard his voice and words but didn’t bother to listen. Her eyes wandered around as she considered pressing the red end call button. Times like these, she wished the phone call was on the landline. It was always more satisfying to slam down on the receiver. She sat cross legged on the floor mattress, her new bed until she finally went and bought some furniture. It was her first weekend officially in her new place.

Her bedroom was cozy, the faded floral wallpaper peeling in some corners, but the place was clean and in a good neighborhood. Her new roommate, Allison Kerry, was likely sleeping across the hallway.

He had woken her up that Saturday, not an unreasonable hour, but she had fumbled for the phone half asleep, expecting it to be Angelina Hoffman to talk about their shopping date.

“Let’s just talk. Please.”

She bit her lip. “I want to come by sometime and pick up some things. But we have nothing to discuss.”

“When?”

“I’ll let you know. Goodbye.” She hung up before he said anything to keep her on the line. She shut her eyes tight, unsure of whether it was a good call or not to communicate with Frank at all. But it was early enough that a cool morning run would clear her head.

She got herself up to her feet, stretching out her popping joints. Still half-asleep, she went to pull on her jogging tights and pulled the sports bra over her chest, her movements swift. She had a lot of pent up energy from the past week.

Normally, she’d like to go to her fitness center to let off some steam with some dancing and aerobics. But she’d avoided it out of fear that Frank would be lurking around there. So cardio, it was.

Cardio was reliable, especially when frustrated. And she was wound up tight and extremely frustrated. Hoffman had been difficult to work with after the Jefferson case disappeared. When she had asked him where it had gone, he simply said Grissom had reassigned it out of Homicides and he had already handed over the case. He stonewalled her after that. There was clearly a rift building, a great wall he wasn’t letting her pass.

It drove her fucking mad. She was beginning to get the bigger picture, at least whenever Rosello was concerned. Hoffman was in it - whatever ‘it’ was - deep. And he wasn’t going to exactly spell it out for her. She could only assume this was his fear, but until certain, it was all ruminations with no answers. She hated that.

She was already out of the door with her trainers on, hurrying down the stairs and feeling her limbs start to warm up when she reached the outside. It was late winter now. Her breath was mist and she was already shivering.

She lurched into a long gaited jog, her agitation and anger giving her extra pep in her step. It wasn’t long before she was outright sprinting down the dead streets, the sun just barely showing itself.

Everything was blue. The pavement. The buildings. The sky. It was a shade of blue she saw every morning across her desk. The cool and unnatural shade she could get lost in if she forgot herself.

Her chest cramped from the bitter cold but it was a good kind of pain. Distracting. Her mind kept returning to him. She wondered how she could save him. She wondered if he was thinking about her now or if he was sleeping off another long night of drinking alone.

Today she was going to spend time with his sister. How funny. She wasn’t sure what to make of the invitation. It wasn’t so awkward, though. Allison was going with them. It wasn’t just a one-on-one session.

She jumped over an overturned trash can, hurdling over like her track days and continued her speed. She was already breathing rapidly, having skipped one too many cardio days, having to cut back on her exercise time with how life just kept throwing shit her way. She mostly stuck with heavy weights these days, not just the kind she used at the gym. She needed to work on her strength training. Always.

Hoffman tended to do the foot-racing and tackling when they were in the field. He was just so fucking strong and big enough to bring any bad guy down. It was always a beautiful sight when he’d charge through like a juggernaut and take down anyone that tried to escape in a blur of muscle and rage. It made her heart race; her mouth water.

She swallowed and blinked back to reality. Her legs were tight and burning. She let her frustration out as she kept raising her legs and pounding her soles hard, running as fast as her body could go. She missed this. Her need for speed could only be satisfied with a steering wheel now.

Checking her watch, she realized she had been running for an hour. She had to slow down, her knees begging for some forgiveness. Sweat dripped down her neck and she finally let herself stop and walk. She was wheezing and coughing, her nose running. Fuck, she was out of shape.

She had done zigzags throughout the blocks and was almost back to Kerry’s. But she’d walk the rest of the way. Maybe there was a coffee shop. People were starting to wake up and go about their early Saturday chores. She noticed a familiar back with chocolate brown hair.

“Hoffman!” She jogged up to him. The man turned and she stopped, realizing she had the wrong person. “Sorry,” she proceeded to jog by him, embarrassment adding to her flushed skin. Maybe it was wishful thinking.

She did not look forward to this date with Angelina.

Angelina Hoffman

Angelina had been to Allison Kerry’s place before. She and Ally weren’t besties, but close enough that she felt comfortable to come drop by whenever. Her left hand was itchy with the engagement ring practically burning a band on her finger. She bounced where she stood as she rang at the intercom.

“Yeah?” Ally’s voice came through.

“It’s Angie,” She pressed the button. The buzz of the front door letting her into the foyer was a welcome from the freezing morning air. She pushed through, wiped her feet, and quickly made her way to the elevators.

When she got to the apartment, she always stopped to appreciate the woman’s taste. There were pastels. Nothing too flashy, nothing too conservative. There were tons of books on the walls, a decent DVD collection. And her wine cooler was what Angie envied most of all.

“Hey, hon,” Ally hugged her and took her coat. “Will’s in the shower. So what’s the big news you said I had to learn in person?”

A wide smile on her face she held her left hand up. “He finally did it!”

“Oh, my God,” Ally covered her mouth with both hands and let out a gleeful laugh. “About time. Congrats! When’s the big day?”

“We’re thinking June. We’ll have invites out soon.”

“Was this yesterday?”

“Two days ago. You will not believe what Mark said when I called him.” She rolled her eyes at the memory. “He said I better change my name and get out of town. Like that wasn’t even funny, you know? I swear.” The phone call had been abrupt and cool. He hadn’t sounded particularly thrilled, which wasn’t out of place, but he sounded especially somber. She was hoping Will would give her a better idea when she got her alone later that day. Mark had been off lately, clearly hiding something.

Ally smirked, “That’s tame, knowing him. But yeah, kind of a dick thing to say instead of ‘I’m happy for you’.”

“Yeah. Guess I shouldn’t complain too much, though. At least he and Peter get along now. But still,” she finally pogoed up and down, letting herself feel happy. Mark was likely fine. Maybe it was girl trouble. “I also wanted to ask you and Will something big. Over brunch. And mimosas.” She clapped her hands together, like a kid about to go to the candy shop.

“All right,” Ally, beautiful and serious, tended to smile a lot more when Angelina acted childish, so she played it up a little for her benefit.

“Hey,” Will came out, red hair dampened down in a helmet of curls that she was towelling dry. “Sorry I’m running late.”

“You sure were running early,” Ally’s pun had Will groaning. She turned to Angie, “This lady decided running at sub-freezing weather was a great idea this morning.”

“Oh, gosh,” Angie cringed. “That sounds terrible.”

“Yeah, I paid for it in the shower. I was coughing up a lung for ten minutes straight.”

“Better not make that a habit. You don’t want pneumonia,” Ally went to the kitchen. “I’ll make some coffee. Do either of you want some?”

“Yes,” both Angie and Will chanted. When Will disappeared into her room to finish getting ready, Allison put on a pot and started the brew. She turned swiftly, her big hair swooshing.

“Okay. This is a long shot, but does your brother ever talk about Will?”

Angie laughed. “Yeah, I wish. I’m lucky if I can get two sentences from him over the phone. Why? Is Will okay?”

“Well,” Ally shot a glance over to the direction of the bedrooms, lowering her voice “Will’s been moping lately. I’m not sure if it’s about her divorce, but she’s been distracted. Just so you know, in case you think she’s being weird. Her ex calls her non-stop, all the time. I keep telling her to just get a new phone or call the company to change her number. But I’m worried she’s thinking of seeing him.”

“Oh,” Angie looked over to Will, worry wiggling into her stomach. “Yeah, you think she’ll not want to hear about the wedding?”

“I’m not sure. But she’s a big girl. She’ll be fine. Just so you know, in case she tries to cut from us early, let’s try to keep her nearby. I’ve got this bad feeling, you know?”

“I got you,” Angie felt a slight thrill, like she was helping out on police-business or getting into some action.

“So how’s Pete? I haven’t seen him since the picnic last summer.”

“He’s good. He’s enlisting in the marines. He’s actually due to ship to bootcamp two months after June, which is why we’re looking at that date.”

“Oh, wow,” Allison raised an eyebrow and went to pour them some fresh brew. “I’m surprised, I thought he was going to try to make it big with his magic act.”

Angie let out a small laugh, “Yeah, I thought so too. Well, we were talking about starting a family at some point. He wants to make sure we’re more stable before we do. Military seemed like one of the few options right now.” She took the mug graciously and took a slow sip.

“Ah, gotcha. It must have been a hard call,” Ally squeezed her shoulder.

“I’m ready,” Will came out, her damp hair down and over her puffy coat. Angie noticed she liked wearing greens and browns, her casual clothes reminding her of earthy forests. A satchel slung around her shoulders and knee high leather boots, she looked like an Irish nymph about to go on an epic.

“Great. Let’s go!”

She led the two ladies up the subway stairs towards her latest discovery, humming to herself a tune offkey. Angie was a foodie, obviously. She didn’t just love cooking. She loved to eat. She loved walking by a restaurant’s opening day and perusing their menu. She would consider the flavor profiles offered and decide on whether or not she’d go and try some of their dishes.

“So I discovered this place last Restaurant Week. Amazing french toast. Peter said the salmon benedicts were good. And it’s not too expensive.” When they made their way inside, the heat hit her face. The three women all sighed in pleasure when they finally got out of the cold.

The lady at the front desk recognized her, her eyes lighting up. “Angie,” The woman had menus resting against her hip and wrapped an arm around her. “It’s been months. How’s Peter?”

“Great, Sarah, it’s so good to see you again. Beats hosting back at the Swank?” Angie used to moonlight at a bar and grill where she met Sarah. Neither had enjoyed the late night clientele or the messes they made.

“This is paradise compared. Table for three?” She looked amongst her group.

Nodding, Angie was then brought deeper into the busy breakfast scene, where the scents of cinnamon, cream, and coffee wafted through her nose like perfume at Macy’s. Her stomach growled.

Once they all sat at a table out of the way and close to the kitchen, Angie noticed Will was getting another phone call. She looked at it for a moment before flipping it closed and putting it back in her purse. “Sorry,” she had noticed Angie’s glance.

“No, you’re fine.” One of the servers arrived with a water pitcher and glasses, placing each in front of the patrons.

“You know, Will, you can file a restraining order on him.” Ally looked to her colleague, heavily into her eyes. “It would only take a few minutes to fill out the form.”

“Yeah. But I still need to get some things at the apartment first.”

“Like what?”

“Some photo albums. Some things that can’t be replaced. Family heirlooms.”

“We can always sneak in when he’s at work. I doubt he’s changed the key.”

“He doesn’t exactly have a consistent work schedule.”

“What does he do?”

“ - Hi, I’m Karen, and I’ll be your server. Can I start you off with some macchiatos?”

“A pitcher of your blood orange mimosa,” Ally firmly held three fingers out, “And three glasses.”

“Black coffee,” Will added.

“And I’ll have a caramel macchiato,” Angie smiled at the woman as she nodded and swiftly left.

“No avoiding the question, honey, does he have a job?”

“He was interviewing for a call center,” was the response. Even Angie thought it sounded defeated. “Likely, he’s unemployed.”

“How the hell is he paying rent?”

“I don’t know.” Will was pressing her fingertips into the sides of her forehead. “I opened up a new account and haven’t been putting anything in the old. I’m still working on taking my name off of all shared accounts, but it’s kind of hard when he’s refusing to sign the papers or even listen when I tell him it’s over. I’ll have to wait six more days before the divorce can be filed officially, unless he decides to contest before then. Ugh.” She slumped back in her chair, the shadows of her eyes brought out from their overhead light. “I’m working on breaking the lease at my old place but the landlord won’t return my phone calls. It’s been a brutal week.”

They sat in silence after this. Angie’s mind was wavering with the low mood. It sounded hard. Divorce. A part of her was suddenly feeling dodgy about marrying Peter. What if we ever separated? She wasn’t sure if that was even a possibility. She was sure they’d work things out, no matter what it was. Well, maybe not everything. Angie thought this was one of those rare times that ending a marriage was more than valid. Will deserved better. And Frank needs to go to jail, she fumed quietly.

“Angie,” Will leaned forward, eyes wide open and thrilled. “What’s that on your hand?” She nodded towards her engagement ring. Half-embarrassed, half overjoyed, she showed the sparkling gemstone to her. “Congratulations!” The shadows had faded from her face and was instead replaced with shining merriment. “Wow, it’s beautiful. Way to go, Peter!” She let out a small laugh. “Oh, please tell me Hoffman cried.”

Angie shook her head, grinning. “No, he actually didn’t seem to care.”

“What?” Will suddenly looked furious. “I’m sure he’s thrilled. He must be.” There was a troubled frown on her face. “What did he say?”

“Uh,” she let out a laugh and repeated what she had told Ally earlier that morning. Will didn’t seem to get the joke either.

“Change your name and leave town,” she repeated the sentence, as though trying to write a poem with the words.

“Is something wrong?” Angie cocked her head, suddenly scared. “Is Mark in trouble?”

“No, no,” Will shook her head. “He was fine last time we spoke. He’s just - stressed.”

“About what?”

“Uh…”

“Here are your drinks. Mimosas and coffee. Have you all decided on what to eat?” The waitress had her notepad out, pen at the ready.

“Yeah,” Ally pointed to one line on the menu. “I”ll have the french toast with strawberries.”

“I’ll have the blueberry pancakes,” Angie handed her menu to their server.

“Uh, oatmeal.” Will gave a shy smile. “Thanks.” Angie wanted to protest but firmly pressed her lips together. She shouldn’t judge or even comment, but it felt like such a wasted opportunity.

“You’re welcome to try my pancakes if you want. They’re so buttery and moist.”

Will laughed. “Thanks, but no thanks. I’m a bit of a health nut.”

“When she’s not killing fifths with your brother,” Ally had already poured the drinks out. “I’ve also seen you crush a basket of fish and chips in five minutes. Cut the crap, Will.” Allison Kerry held out the champagne flute. “To the weekend. And finally having a chance to hang out with some ladies for a change.” They made their cheers and after taking a long sip, Ally continued her onslaught onto Will. “What’s with the oatmeal?”

Will shrugged. “I’m just not feeling anything rich right now, is all.” She was already halfway through the first glass of deep red orange and looked anxious. “Besides, my appetite is shot. Sorry.”

“No, don’t apologize,” Angie wanted to wave Will’s troubles away. “No need for the third degree. Besides, there will be more brunches to be had. Right, Ally?”

“Yeah. I’m in. I just like giving crap. Come on, Will, I’ve heard you give Hoffman plenty of shit. You give as much as you take. Don’t go easy on me.” She was resting her elbow on the table, curling her hair around her finger. There was a teasing glitter in her hazel eyes. “And I would bet my left kidney that you started running and eating oatmeal because of Special Agent Peter Strahm.”

Will choked on her drink and Ally pumped her fist in the air. “Called it!”

“What’s going on? Who’s Peter Strahm?” Angelina was fascinated, leaning forward. “You said special agent, like FBI? Ooh, please, details. Please tell me he’s tall.”

“Tall, dark-haired, a cute face I’d love to sit on, and he’s completely taken with our Wilhelmina here.” Ally put her arm around Will, fluffing her red hair outward like a dog.

“Yeah?” Will smirked back. “Who said I went running because of Strahm? Maybe there was another guy on my mind I was trying to get out.”

“Who?” Angelina’s eyes grew wide. “Is it someone I know?”

Will’s gaze fell and she cleared her throat. “Also, way to try to avoid the whole Eric Matthews situation, Kerry,” Will turned and gave the woman a death stare. “You know that’s something that I’ve been trying to wrap my head around.”

It was Ally’s turn to look flustered. “Well - yeah. You’re right. I suck.” She looked up to Angelina like the sinner begging for absolution. She was chewing on her lip before leaning forward. “So - I didn’t tell you, Angie, but Matthews and I have been… kind of a thing for a while.”

“I know,” Angie shrugged. “I knew for a while.”

“What?!” Ally leaned forward. “How?”

“Mark. Eric sometimes has dinner at my place. Mark let it slip. It’s not my business, Ally, though…” She shook her head, the jumble of frustration, anger, and just plain sadness wallowing inside of her. “...I think it’s unfair to Jane. And their son. Danny?”

“Daniel, yeah,” Ally wiped her nose, avoiding eye contact. “I know. I’m not proud of it. But I don’t know what to do. It just happened.”

Neither Will nor Angelina wanted to be the first to answer.

“So… Peter Strahm,” Will tried to restore the conversation. “He’s got these eyes that would make you melt, Ange. And those thick lashes. Ugh. Ally’s right. I, too, would do terrible things to him if given the opportunity.” Ally nodded furiously in agreement, eyes wide with lecherous glee.

“Yeah?” Angelina giggled, wishing she had a picture of the guy. “I’ll need to meet him. Maybe he can strip for the bachelorette party. Which reminds me.” She pressed her fingertips to the table, taking in a deep breath before taking the plunge. “Will you two be in my bridal party?”

Both Ally and Will turned to each other then back at her. “Uh, duh?” Ally grinned widely.

“I mean - of course.” Will bit her lip, “When is the wedding?”

“June. The day’s still up in the air.” She let out a small high pitched squeak. “I’m so happy to hear that. I know we’ve only known each other for such a short period of time but it means so much that you’re accepting. I just want our day to be fun for everyone, not just about Peter and myself.” She paused to inhale, “And I’m going to be blunt: I need your help with Mark. Sometimes he gets,” she stewed over the right word to say, “all broody. And I don’t want him to be like that at the wedding.”

“Yeah, I know what you mean,” Will gave a sympathetic smile. “He can act like a stick in the mud.”

“And I just know this is going to be a stressful time for Mark. You know our parents died when we were younger. So I’m going to have Mark walk me down the aisle. I think that’s going to be asking a lot of him. And I’ve seen how you two are with each other. He doesn’t freeze up, you know? I think you two would be so cute if paired up at the party.”

“I’m confused. Are you asking me to be Mark’s plus one? Then why be a bridesmaid?”

“Kind of both. See, he would never willingly bring you, even for some harmless family function that I asked him to do for me. Trust me, he’d either read too much into it and I need to save all my childhood-blackmail-ammunition for other plans I have,” her voice was getting serious and dark but her excitedness had her rapidly firing off her pitch before Will or Ally could get a word in. “And our entire lives, he’s never been one to stand still in front of a camera for long. He never did prom. He never even wants to do family photos when I ask him to. So my wedding is probably one of the only times I’m going to get any good pictures of Mark. He even somehow made his police academy photos unavailable for printing! Can you believe it?”

“Actually,” Will’s withered grin was full of sympathy, “I totally believe that.”

“It’s so frustrating!” Angie shook her head. “I have like a handful of photos of him, the most recent one back when he was in high school! I want a modern picture, and damn it, he’s going to have to suck it up on my day. And just because I’m feeling petty, I’m going to go all out. I’m hiring the best photographer I can afford and I want all the pictures, ladies. All of them. And I totally want a picture of him, arm-in-arm, with his work partner, you, at the wedding. So, you being a bridesmaid and him a groomsman, would be the perfect opportunity. I think it would be just so cute. And total payback for him not telling me you were a woman for months.”

Angie let herself smile, knowing she was starting to sound diabolical. “I plan on having those copies distributed to all our friends. Everyone he works with will get complimentary copies. Oh, and I’m planning on more pictures when it’s time for the bridesmaids and groomsmen to dance with each other at the beginning of the wedding party. Imagine.” There was a twinkle in her eye and a giggle in her throat.

Will pondered this, light brown eyes squinting while she pursed her mouth in concentration. Then she let out a low laugh that grew with malicious intent. “This would piss him off on a whole new level. Oh my God, you’re so evil. I love it.”

Angie knew she liked Will for a reason. Anyone eager to give her brother a hard time was good company in her book.

“Thank you,” Ally fanned herself, her cheeks flushed with anticipation. “My purpose in life is to fuck with Mark. As his baby sister, it is my divine right to show my love by driving him insane.”

“Please send me a couple copies. I’ll frame one and put it on my desk, so he’ll have to see it every day.” Will let out another laugh. “Angie, I had no idea. This explains why I didn’t see any pictures at your place with you all.”

“I know. I just - don’t get why he’s so camera shy. He’s a good looking guy, he should be more proud.”

“I hope you don’t tell him this to his face,” Ally smirked, “He already has a big head. Also, shouldn’t you be more focused on other aspects of the wedding?” There was bemusement at her scattered priorities. “Like catering and colors?”

“I’ve had my dream wedding planned since I was nine,” Angelina waved her hand away. She wasn’t too OCD on the details of the aesthetic but she wanted the memories captured to be perfect. “And the maid of honor is a professional wedding planner. I’m not too worried, she said she’d comp me in exchange for catering her wedding next year.”

“Nice. So what do you need us to do? Besides antagonizing your brother, which Will already does during normal business hours?” Ally looked over at Will who continued to giggle, raising an eyebrow at the immature woman. “You okay, Will?”

Her freckled cheeks were blushing and her eyes were watering. “Yeah. Don’t mind me. Just. Nevermind.” There was a nervous embarrassment pouring over her tight shoulder and how hard she chewed her lower lip.

“Well, I want you both to come to the bachelorette party, of course. And rehearsals. Oh, and helping me get fitted for my dress. And of course, you get fitted for yours as well. Muted green and gold.” Angelina continued on about her dream wedding, looking forward to her special day with her two new bridesmaids by her side. “I think those colors will look fab for the two of you.”

“I agree,” Ally turned to Will. “Honey, you keep looking at that phone and I’m going to throw it in the river.”

Will’s eyes snapped up. “Sorry. It’s just-,” and was cut off by Ally swiping the black brick and putting it in her purse.

“Uh-uh. Will, I’m doing this for your own good. Forget Frank. Think about Peter Strahm pouring honey down his pants. It’ll at least work up your appetite for that gruel you’re about to eat.”

Angie laughed at the imagery, her curiosity sky high. She had to see this guy.

Mark Hoffman

Mark Hoffman glared angrily at the approaching limousine that inched towards his crown vic. It was late. He wanted to be back at his warm apartment, not standing out at the waterfront waiting for this fuck.

The driver had an awareness that likely meant he was armed and possibly keeping a weapon trained on him at that very moment. Olaf rose out of the far back door, holding it out for Rosello who was slowly pulling himself to his feet.

It was time to go. It took everything he had not to simply put the car in gear and floor it, taking Rosello with his grill and seeing if the engine had enough horsepower to ram through the limo and into the bay. Other cars were beginning to pull up besides their leader and suited thugs made their way out to show their intimidation in numbers. It was an effective strategy.

The harbor stank of seagull shit and rotting fish. He never liked coming out here.

As he took steps towards the crime boss, he took in slow and deep breaths. He felt sharp and strong, unlike earlier that week. He didn’t feel particularly upset. Just tired. “Mr. Rosello.”

“Markie-boy!” Rosello waddled to the detective and placed greasy leather gloves on each of his shoulders. “You’ve been avoiding me?”

“No, sir.” He kept his face blank, his mask perfectly passive. “Just been busy. Your name came up again on a case. I had to fix things.”

“I heard. You did good, Markie-boy.” Rosello had a toothy grin and his beady black eyes bore into his skull. “Very good. How’s Angie?”

He felt his heart sink but held it in. “She’s well.”

“And Peter? I heard they got engaged,” the yellow smile was spreading wider. “I hope you give them my congratulations. I’ll send a fine bottle of champagne.”

“There’s no need,” he quietly spoke, hoping the inner screams his soul wanted to bellow would stay buried deep.

“And Red? She hasn’t responded to any of my letters. You tell her to write back, I miss her.”

“She’s not interested, Mr. Rosello,” he kept eye contact, making it clear he wouldn’t grovel, though his tone was smooth like glass. “I don’t believe I can convince her.”

“Yeah, she doesn’t seem to like me very much. I hear she’s getting recruited by your department’s elites. What does Grissom call ‘em? The Spook Squad? The Rosello Task Force?”

“I wouldn’t know.” Hoffman had his hands clasped in front of him, waiting to hear why Rosello summoned him. Despite dressing for the icy wind, it cut deep into him, making it hard for him to stand still. He fought the urge to shiver.

“Yeah, you’re probably not invited. Makes sense.” Rosello was at ease as he took a step to the side and readjusted his gloves. “How does Red feel about us meeting, Markie?”

“She doesn’t know.”

“No, I’m sure you try to keep her out of our business. I get it. Don’t want her ending up like your last partner. What was his name? Kevin?”

“You know his name,” Hoffman growled, losing his patience.

Rosello’s grin widened. “Yeah. I guess I would. He used to stand exactly where you were, only he had a better smile when he waited. Vicky. Yeah, Vicky. That was his name.”

“What did you need from me, Mr. Rosello?” He tilted his head back, disinterested in this charade.

“A bird tells me that this task force has a lot of people looking into me. People I don’t particularly want involved. I’m just feeling a bit paranoid these days, but I’d like you to personally look into it.”

“What’s made you paranoid?” Hoffman didn’t like where this was going. He was trying to go back through the past few weeks of events to see where he slipped up. He couldn’t think of anything.

“I hear G-men are here. I hear your colleagues back in the precinct rolled the red carpet out for them. I don’t like that.” Rosello’s smile petrified. “And I want them out of my city.”

“There’s not much I can do about scaring off the feds. I’m surprised you don’t have guys in D.C. that can handle this.” He was already dreading the work. The fucking headache of it all. He should just shoot himself and get it over with.

“That’s the problem. They’ve been hush-hush on who’s actually here. I need names, Hoffman. I need faces. I need where they’re staying. Do what you do best. Get me information. Do that, and maybe I’ll give you a vacation.”

“You’re so generous,” he sneered. “But I seriously doubt I’d want what’s on that itinerary.”

“You’ll have to wait and see, Markie-boy.”

“Joy.”

“Keep giving that attitude and you’ll make me mad. Remember, Markie. You’re here because you put yourself here. You best remember that any siesta I give is because I’m a generous man.”

“Yeah.” Hoffman remembered. He remembered the moment he closed the lock on the collar and became this cock’s gimp. This fucker had all the money. All the power. And there was nothing he could do to stop it. These thoughts encased him like the frigid air around him.

And yet. There was something different, this time. If Rosello was this scared, that meant something. If the feds were really there, that is. If all those holier-than-thou assholes actually were making the guy sweat, maybe there was a chance he was in some real heat.

This gave him a rush of warmth. “You think you’ll keep cheating the system?” Hoffman continued to stand his ground, his fingertips heating up.

He thought of Will. He imagined her hair, coppery fire and it filled him with life. She wasn’t going to back down. He knew her too well. If anyone could stop Toni Rosello, it was her.

Rosello raised an eyebrow. “Cheeky, ain’t ya?” Rosello let out a high wheezing laugh. “You drunk, kid?”

“No. Just tired of your shit.”

WHAM. The strike had come out of nowhere. It hadn’t come from his front, where Rosello stood, but to his side, where the big gargoyle fuckbag, Olaf, had pistol whipped him across the cheek. He tasted blood. His ears were ringing. He had his hands on his face, the surprise more painful than the actual assault.

“Still got some fight in ya? That’s good. That’s real good. I’ll remember that. Maybe you’re a bit slow, but let me remind you: I can destroy everything you care about, Markie-boy. Angie? I’ll string her up and let my boys have their way with her while you watch until she’s gangrene and begins to smell. I’ll have her boyfriend eat his own balls while she watches. And you can see her suffer. And Red? I’ll be real good to her. Just you wait. I can make you want to rip out your own eyeballs, you hear me? DO YOU?!” Rosello had let out a shriek and Hoffman nodded firmly. “I’m not cheating the system. I am the system.

With a wave of his hand, some of the bigger guys behind the boss came around and proceeded to punch Hoffman in the face. Another threw a fist deep into his lower gut.

The taste of blood and bile rose up onto his tongue. He lurched forward and fell to the concrete. Leathered shoes stabbed into his ribs and knuckles hailed onto every inch of flesh he had. The beating continued for what felt like hours. He knew it was likely just minutes.

He was dizzy. Nauseous. And everything hurt. But he wasn’t done yet.

Rosello’s feet crunched on ice and gravel and the big man squatted over him. “I want their names, Markie-boy. Soon. You work too slow? You give me shit? You better just pucker up and blow your gun.”

He heard retreating footsteps, the start of engines, and the friction of rubber on asphalt fade away. He was so cold.

But more than anything. He was angry.

Peter Acomb

Peter was vacuuming up the living room when he heard the phone ring.

“Can you get that, Peter?” Angie’s voice called out from the kitchen. She was currently making macaroni and cheese. His favorite.

“Yeah!” Peter rubbed his dusty hands on his apron before picking up the handset. “Hello?”

“Pete.” A deep male’s voice. One that made Peter snap into attention.

“Mark! Hi! Want to talk to Angie?”

“No. You.” He was breathing hard and sounded like he was in pain.

“What’s wrong?”

“Nothing. Just listen. I want you to take Angie and get out of town. Now. Get your gun. And just go. Don’t tell anyone.”

“Mark, what-,”

“Peter. You’re going to marry my sister. That means you need to protect her with your life. You understand me?”

“Of course, Mark. You know I’d do anything for her.”

“Good. I know. Look. I’ve pissed off some bad people. And they’ve threatened you two. And they mean it.”

His heart stopped and his hand began to tremble. The plastic was vibrating against the meat of his ear. “Can’t you - get a squad car or maybe we can call the police?” He hated how his voice went high pitched like that. He knew Mark must have thought him weak. Scared. But he couldn’t help it.

“Pete. I am the police. And we’re no good. You understand?”

“Where should we go?”

“Out of the city. As far as you can go. Somewhere no one would guess. But I can’t know. Just get out of town for a while. Don’t call for a couple of weeks. You hear me? Hell, don’t even call me.” He sounded weary and defeated. A tired man who had already lost everything.

“What?!”

“Tell Ange to call Will. And not for at least a month. I know it’s last minute. I know she may lose her job. But it’s an emergency. You need to get out of town tonight. You hear me?”

“You need to talk to Angie.”

“Yeah. I know. Put her on. And while she’s on the phone, pack. I mean it, Pete. Now.”

Pete dropped the phone. “Ange!” He had panic in his voice as he sprinted to the kitchen.

“What’s wrong?!” Angie came out, face shining from kitchen labor and mildly concerned. “Are you hurt?”

“Mark. Phone. We need to go!” His mind was running a million miles an hour. He was already halfway to the master bedroom, tripping over the carpet and falling on his face.

“Peter!” Angie went to him but he held his hands up.

“Talk to Mark! Oh my God!” He was in the master bedroom when he heard Angie.

“Mark! What in the worl-” and “Slow down!” morphed into, “You can’t be fucking serious. No. I will not. I don’t care.”

Peter was hunched over their bed, two suitcases open with random clothes piled over each. He turned to the doorway when he heard more of Angie’s ruminations.

“You listen here, Mark, I will not just uproot my life, especially if you won’t tell me the details. I don’t care. Oh, I’m sure they’re so scary but I will not let some thugs tell me how to live my life. No, you listen. I said-,” a pause, then, “HOW DARE YOU RAISE YOUR VOICE TO ME! MOM WOULD BE SO DISAPPOINTED IN YOU!”

Oh no, Peter sprinted back to the living room. He saw Angie slamming her fist on the end table where the phone rested, grabbed the telephone firmly in her hand with enough force that the small bell in it chirped pitifully and she paced and smacked the phone against the wall.

That Hoffman rage though, Peter rarely saw Angelina angry, but when she was, there were usually broken pieces he’d have to glue together of something that he used to like. Veins were bulging up her neck and her cheeks were scarlet. She stopped and glared at Peter.

“Don’t you fucking dare pack anything. We are staying. I have too much shit going on right now to just leave. Okay?” Her voice was so high pitched that Peter thought it was akin to nails on a chalkboard.

He put both hands up. “Yeah! Yeah! Whatever you say, Angie. Just-,” he wanted to reach up and take the phone from her claws but she hissed at him when he approached. He jumped back. “I’ll just unpack everything!”

Angie was his Queen. But sometimes, she was just downright scary.

Chapter 9: Pre-Saw: They Sleep Together

Chapter Text

Allison Kerry

The small creature looked up at her with squinting eyes that looked too much like Eric’s that it creeped her out. It was like an alien. An alien that smelled of talcum powder, vomit, and sour shit.

“Aw, he likes you,” Jane Matthews smiled as she wiped the slimy white spit that the infant had upchucked onto her just a moment ago. Kerry gave a polite smile as she tried to balance the delicate baby in her arms. He was so small. So tiny. She was afraid she’d drop him.

“He definitely is Eric’s boy,” she gave a good natured smirk to Jane, who was gushing over her creation. “Got the same attitude, I can tell.”

Eric smirked back at them, fingering his shirt pocket for his pack of cigarettes. He always said he was going to quit but he never did. For the newborn’s sake, he restrained himself from smoking in their apartment.

“I’m so happy you finally came to see him. I don’t know why Eric has been putting it off,” Jane threw a dirty stare at her husband.

Kerry’s eyes wandered to her partner’s and the two of them had that awkward moment where they shared a mutual shameful telepathy. They knew what they were doing was shitty. They knew they were guaranteed front row tickets to hell. But it was still easier to pretend they were just good old coworkers hanging out.

She didn’t know if they’d ever come clean. Lying just was easier. Safer. At least in the short term. She knew one day the downhill snowball was going to bury them. But she hoped they’d find the right moment. The right time.

But after the birth of little Daniel Matthews, it didn’t seem that Eric was ever going to file for that divorce. Maybe he had been full of shit the entire time.

Regardless, Allison Kerry, homewrecker and infamous Jezebel of Metropolitan Police Department, was currently cradling the child of the man she had seduced, right in front of the poor woman’s face. Under her roof.

Truly, Kerry hated herself. More than anything.

“Can you stay for dinner? I can throw something on real quick. Or we can order pizza,” Jane had her hand on Kerry’s shoulder. “I’ve missed you. I never see you anymore.”

This was the extra salt in the cut. She and Jane used to be friends. Close. But after the first mistake, that night, she just couldn’t bear to return her phone calls after that.

And weeks turned into months of radio silence, hoping she would simply cease to exist in Jane’s universe. It was such a delusional and undeserving desire. But if she had a genie, she’d give all three wishes to take back ever having been Jane Matthews’ friend.

Because despite it all, she loved Eric. She loved him and wanted him. She wanted this life, with him. But she would never have it. Though she knew she had no right to, she hated Jane Matthews for having everything she could only wish she had.

The baby began to scream. It was a terrible sound, full of anguish, and it spread its suffering to all who were in earshot.

“Poor little guy,” Jane seemed unaffected by the noise, retrieving her child from Kerry’s outstretched hands. “He’s just hungry.” She proceeded to pull her top down to breastfeed little Daniel.

Kerry retreated to the kitchen linoleum, reaching for her waiting beer bottle that had gone sweaty and just barely cold.

“Probably best if you head out,” Eric was leaning against the island counter, looking at his feet. He hadn’t wanted her there, either, only giving the invite out of the insistence of his marital spouse.

“Way ahead of you,” she muttered as she took a long swig. “We can’t keep doing this, Eric.”

He had taken a toothpick and put it in his mouth, the need for something to placate his cigarettes evident as he rolled the wood across his lips. “Yeah. I know.” And yet he reached his hand to hers, gently placing the calloused skin over her fingers in a passing brush.

She pulled away. Not here.

Not here.

“I’m heading out.” She spoke louder, so Jane could hear. “It was good seeing you, Jane.” She called through the archway where Jane nursed her child, already beelining to the front door.

“But you just got here,” Jane protested, distraught.

“I know, I’m sorry,” Kerry gave a pathetic, forced smile. “But I need to help out my roommate, she’s still moving in.”

“Oh, I see.” The woman’s eyes had gone dull and lowered back to the weight sucking away in her embrace. “Well, don’t be a stranger now. Come again soon, yeah?”

“Sure thing,” Kerry mustered up some fake cheer. Sorry, Jane, but I seriously doubt it.

She fled before she acted out. She felt like she was about to vomit or cry. Maybe both.

More than anything, she suddenly had the urge to give Lindsey a call.

 

Angelina Hoffman

She slammed her fist on the door, hoping it sounded as pissed as she felt.

She heard clicks and for a split second, her heart stopped when she recognized the safety of a handgun being secured. “Mark, what the fuck is going on?”

“Ange?” Bewilderment, the click sounded again. There was the familiar slide of a deadbolt, the rattle of a chain. The door cracked open and the shadowed face of her brother peaked through.

She pushed the door forcefully with both hands, surprised by the resistance he gave. “Seriously? Let. Me. In.” She leaned her body into the door with all her might, knowing she wouldn’t succeed unless he allowed her to. “Mark, we need to talk.” When he continued to be stubborn she slapped the painted plaster. “Damn it! I’m not leaving until you explain yourself!”

She heard him curse and suddenly swung the door open. Though he had no lights on in his space, the hallway lighting illuminated enough.

“Oh my God,” her hand shot up to her mouth and her eyes stung with tears. “Who did this to you?”

He didn’t answer. Stepping back, he allowed her into his home and swiftly shut the door once she was safely inside. She wasn’t going to let him pretend everything was fine though. She flipped the switch to the nearest overhead light, shining yellow onto his face.

He looked like he had gotten face painted by a toddler with a love of blues and reds. She raised her hand to his swollen cheek and blackened eye. He grabbed her wrist gently. “You see? What they did to me was nothing to what they’ll do to you.”

“Who? Is this some macho cop shit?” She jerked her arm from his hand and went to the freezer, digging through the contents to find some peas. She found a bag of corn that she smacked against the counter and handed it to him. “Put this on your face. And answer me.”

“It’s complicated.”

“Stop trying to protect me, Mark. Damn it, keeping me in the dark isn’t going to do that, anyway.” Her eyes lowered and her throat tightened. “Do you owe someone money?”

“No. It’s not like that.” He sounded insulted. Hurt.

“Then help me understand. Please. Clearly, you can’t get work involved. So it must be something worse. But how do you expect me to just drop my career? Leave my home? And my wedding? Just like that, with no explanation, Mark?”

“It’s Toni Rosello.”

Angie blinked, the name faintly ringing a bell. “What, the guy that’s always in the papers?”

“Yeah. Things are getting heated. Now, I’m on his bad side.” He pressed the vegetables to his eye and let out a low sigh. He went to collapse into his couch, the sound of a nearby clock softly ticking through the quiet.

She was at a loss for words. “Please tell me you haven’t been working for some crime boss this whole time.”

When he didn’t answer, she kicked him. Hard.

He hissed and grabbed his shin, dropping the plastic sack onto the cushion next to him. “Jesus, what the fuck, Ange?”

She went to kick him again but he moved his legs out of the way. “You stupid son of a bitch. You no good - stupid -,”

“It’s not like I’m doing it because I want to!” He snapped, having jumped up and was now using his sofa as a boundary between him and her foot.

“Then why? Why would you do something so - stupid!” She threw her hands up in the air. “Oh, Mom and Dad are probably rolling in their graves. They raised you better than that!”

“Don’t use Mom and Dad like that. I did it to protect you,” he growled and she froze.

“Don’t use me like that! What do you mean?”

“What do you think I mean? I mean this guy knows about you. And he’ll kill you - or worse - if I refuse. That’s how it’s been, Ange. All right? It’s been this way for years now.”

She felt the world spin around her. She sank to the floor. “And you never told me?” She felt her cheeks go wet. She snapped upwards to him. “You’ve lied to me all this time. For how long?”

He looked pained. “Five years. Since I started.”

“Did Victor really retire and is living in Florida?”

He let out a harsh laugh. “No. He’s been in a wheelchair, Ange. His wife and kid are gone. I lost my temper, hesitated, and now he’ll never walk again. All right? I’ve been Rosello’s lapdog my entire fucking career. And now, if I don’t fix things, he’s coming for you, Ange. He’s coming for everyone. This has been shit, Ange. Fucking shit.” He pressed his fist to his head, eyes glistening as he let out a gargled sob.

She felt her face tighten and her limbs go cold. “Mark.” She got up, wanting to hold him. To tell him everything was going to be all right. She felt like they had gone back in time and he was just a teenager again, furious and alone.

He stepped back away from her, afraid. “I know I fucked up. I fucking know.”

“Mark,” she let her voice go low. She cooed like a dove. “Come here.” She kept taking steps to him, despite him backing away. “It’s going to be okay. We’ll figure this out.” She put her arms around him and hugged him. He let out a hiss of pain that made her release her squeeze. But she kept him in her embrace. She kept holding on. “It must have been so hard,” she was sobbing too, trying to speak through snot and salt. “Taking this all on your own. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.”

He was stiff as she rested her face onto his chest. His breathing was erratic, his chest rising and falling like a stressed animal. “You shouldn’t be apologizing.”

“No, I should have known. I should have picked up on this.” She looked up at him. “I’ve been so caught up in myself that I didn’t look out for you. I should have seen the signs.” She wiped her face and then reached to thumb brush his tears as well. “We promised Mom we’d take care of each other. We’re going to be fine, Mark. Now that I know, I’ll be ready. We’ll be ready.” She wasn’t completely sure if she was right but there was little fear. Only anger at this fiend. Rosello. “You’ve got to have some people on your side. What about Will? And Kerry?”

“They’re trying. There’s a team at MPD trying to take him down. But Rosello’s untouchable. I think you should just skip town.”

Angie let out an incredulous laugh. “If he’s really so powerful, then it’s not like my running away would stop him from finding me, if I’m going to use that logic. No. I’m not going to let this guy scare me. Okay? I’m standing my ground.”

He didn’t look happy with her statement. “But Ange-,”

“But nothing. Let’s call Will. Let’s call the people you trust. I’ll be smart. I’ll keep my gun on me. Peter will keep his, too. You’ve taught us how to use them. We won’t go walking down dark alleys late at night alone. I’m sure we can get an officer to watch our place. We’ll just be smart. Yeah.” She pursed her lips as she reexamined his face. “You just have to communicate from now on. Deal?”

He was scanning her face, surrender in his frown. “Deal.”

“Do what you need to do to not let him hurt you like that anymore. Okay? Promise me. Promise me that you won’t die until you’re an old man. You’re not allowed to die until you’re gray and with grandchildren.”

“I promise.” It was one of those unfair demands, but she’d live with it. She didn’t care how unreasonable she was being.

She squeezed the fabric of his shirt, pulling him forward. “Seriously. Don’t let this piece of shit kill you. Or I’ll fucking kill him myself. And then I’m going to kick your ass in the afterlife.”

She had expected those full lips to suddenly twitch. She had expected him to laugh at this. She had counted on it.

Mark Hoffman was her big brother and she knew him down to his marrow. No matter how old he got, he didn’t change. Not really.

Relief misted over her when he did, indeed, laugh.

She joined him. The two of them both laughed, the tears evaporating as they giggled like hysterical children in the face of danger.

 

Peter Strahm

Their temporary workplace smelled of dust and new plastic. It was cozy, really just a small rental office with a respectable sized server room to support accessing their databases fast. Despite the decent set up, he missed the bustle of headquarters back in D.C. He knew he shouldn’t complain, though. It sure beat being shoved in some broom closet at the MPD’s downtown station.

He and Lindsey had both practically gagged at the state of the building. The windows had cracks in them. There was chipped paint from, what he assumed to be from, the era of lead-based solvents and crumbling concrete floors. The precinct was run down and in need of some renovations. He wondered what the hell they spent their money on but it sure didn’t seem to be a decent workplace. It sure didn’t seem to be on competent cops, either.

He made an exception for his partner’s sake, who kept insisting that Allison Kerry was worth her salt and was underappreciated where she worked. He’d wait and see, but out of respect for Lindsey, he’d keep an open mind.

But he also kept in the back of his mind the blatant state of the city. Crime bosses were flaunting their immunity as if they were royalty. Corrupt politicians seemed to own half the departments. He never liked this city. It stunk. It was a lost cause.

“Strahm,” Lindsey’s voice pulled him from his depressing mental tunnel, big brown eyes blinking at him and an entertained beam on her face. “You have that look again.”

He straightened and stretched, yawning loudly. “Yeah. It’s been a long day. I can’t believe they have nothing on this guy before the task force assembled. They started a year ago. And everything before then, it’s like Toni Rosello was a fucking boy scout.”

“Yep. It’s just like Allison said. People on the inside just scrub him clean every time something comes up.”

“It’s going to be a lot of long nights, Linds. At least we get overtime.”

“And travel comp. By the way, I never thanked you for agreeing to come up. I know you don’t like being up here.”

Peter was resting his chin in his hand, leaning over his desk. “Yeah, well, what are friends for? Besides, you'd do the same for me.” Lindsey Perez had approached him one rainy evening when he was stuck in Quantico, feet propped on his desk with nothing to do. It had been a slow year. No mass murders. No serial killers on the loose. He had been considering redecorating his office when she had approached with a proposition.
”Want to help me pay a debt to an old buddy of mine and help some urban street cops in taking down the worst crime syndicate since Al Capone?”

With a pitch like that, how could he have said no?

Lindsey was one of the agents he inherently respected, since the first case they happened to work together on. She was devoted to her job. She got results. She was brilliant. And she was beautiful. He would have considered pursuing something more than just a close working friendship with her, if only she was interested in men.

It was disappointing, but Strahm got over it quickly. After a few years of occasional mutual assignments and nothing but professional success, he now saw her like the sister he never had and someone who really helped make the world just a bit better. She even invited him over to her family’s Thanksgiving dinner last year.

Despite their work together, she was technically not his partner. His partner, Dan Erickson, was currently on leave, taking advantage of the slow season. Erickson and himself specialized in serial killings. He worked at Behavioral Analysis, profiling the more violent and sadistic offenders and often stayed in the basement of Quantico or reported to Erickson in the capitol.

Perez was with Human Trafficking Investigations. She rescued kids from terrible existences he’d rather not think about. He listened to serial killers talk about how their moms didn’t love them enough. He knew he had the easier job.

Oh, it sucked. But he didn’t deal with victimized children nearly as often as Lindsey did. He always wondered if her job was why she confided to him once that she’d never start a family. Which was a shame. She’d be a great mother.

When she had called and invited him to join her on the case, he hadn’t understood why she wanted him. Apparently, there was an epidemic of child exploitation and finally the FBI was called to intervene. He wondered why she needed a profiler to help at all. That was, until she explained their target. The fucking brains behind one of the worst human trafficking networks this side of the Missisippi.

Toni Rosello was a real piece of work and that was with just the remnants of information he could gather. If just a fraction of what was collected was truth, the guy was likely a textbook case of narcissistic sociopath. Methodical. Highly intelligent. Insane. And with enough wealth and leadership capability that his servants all followed his orders with swift precision and desperate execution.

The guy didn’t seem to take criticism very well. Or any semblance of disrespect. And he liked playing games, as did most overpowered assholes with way too much money and time on their hands.

“Well, it’s getting pretty late. How about we grab some drinks? Allison invited me out.”

“Hmm,” Strahm kept looking at the one headshot of Rosello, tired, but not particularly interested in getting up. He wasn’t going to admit it but this was the most interesting casework he had done that year. He normally would have pages of generalized expectations of what his subject would be likely to desire, do, believe. But he only had the very basic statements.

Sexual deviance. Needs to feel dominant in every relationship. Abusive and short tempered, with a fragile ego. But not much else. He was worried he was getting rusty. Losing his edge.

“Hey, Strahm,” Lindsey leaned forward, waving her hand over his face.

He looked at her with a bored smile. “You can go on without me. I’m not interested. Besides,” his smile grew, “I don’t want to be a third wheel.” He had picked up on hers and Allison Kerry’s relationship. It sounded like the old college experimentation hadn’t lost its spice after all those years.

“If you don’t come, then Allison’s friend, Will, is going to be stuck with that title, then.” There was a teasing in Lindsey’s voice that he registered.

“Oh? And I care because?”

“Get off it, Strahm, I saw the way you kept eyeballing her when we met the task force. She’s a looker. And technically not a coworker. So you don’t have to worry about fraternization.” She cocked her head to the side and shot him a playful grin. “At least, long term. Got something better to do? You just going to stay here all night? Let your hair down a little. Lighten up.”

He remembered Will. The little freckled redhead with the heart shaped mouth and large brown eyes. He certainly remembered her.

“No point in getting distracted.”

“Rosello isn’t going to just mail us a confession in the next twenty-four hours. And you can’t be effective at your job unless you take some breaks. Mingle with the team.” She got to her feet and was readjusting her hip holster. “Last call for splitting a cab. Oh, and the director mentioned keeping an eye out on the local talent. I’m working on convincing Allison to ditch MPD and come work for us. I hear Maddox’s good people and Allison told me about the work she did back west and what she gets done here. They both sound like recruitable material. Think of it like a service to the Bureau. Bet bringing on some fresh blood will look good in your next performance review. Just saying.”

“Fine,” Strahm would put up more of a fight but he secretly didn’t really want to sit at that desk a moment longer. He got up and went to throw on his suit jacket. He was suddenly craving a beer and some peanuts.

Lindsey seemed to be familiar with where they were going. She led the way as they walked through the stink of garbage lined streets and carefully stepped over the neverending homeless that seemed to just be part of the city’s very infrastructure. It was so damn cold and so many people were shivering in front of flaming trash cans. They coughed out pleas for pocket change.

They made their way into the pub, the smokey den full of cloying cigar plumes was rich with leather and perfume. He was pleasantly surprised. The place was clean. Green glass stained light fixtures and rich walnut paneling on the walls made him feel like he was transported far from concrete, fluorescence, and sirens.

“Linds,” Allison Kerry’s thin wrist pulled their attention, the woman looking foreign with her exposed collarbones and shoulders. She looked like a young co-ed out on the town, not some homicide detective meeting colleagues to talk shop. Strahm rarely felt out of place, but in the company of this yuppie club, he felt stiff in his basic black and white suit. He felt occasional eyes coldly look at him, like a fly that had accidentally buzzed into their house.

They made their way across the various clusters of young professionals who were smoking hand rolled tobacco from South America, eating their lineage veal, and talking of the need to solve world hunger while scoffing at inhumane labor practices.

He rolled his eyes, unimpressed.

The two women were at a booth in the far back corner. Like good cops, they were sitting next to each other and keeping their backs to the wall. From the empty glasses collecting at the table’s center, the ladies were already a couple of drinks in.

Will Maddox, furthest inboard of their booth seat, came into view. He kept his face passive despite how much creamy, bespeckled skin he could see. She smiled, lips a deep maroon that just made her other features roar at him. His throat sealed shut.

“Glad you could make it,” Kerry was waving towards the nearest waiter, who nodded in their direction as they took their seats. Strahm tried to play things apathetically. He looked at Kerry, noting the way her shoulders had hitched up and how she seemed to gravitate her view closer to Lindsey’s direction.

“How was shopping?” Lindsey was playing with her hair, her thick ponytail over her shoulder as she pulled at a strand. “You two look hot.”

“Thanks. Will was in serious need of a makeover. Her wardrobe needed something more than just button downs and dress slacks,” Kerry smirked.

“Hey, most of my clothes are just - inaccessible - right now,” Will grumbled into her glass. It looked like something strong. Bourbon, maybe. Dear Lord. He felt mildly alarmed, seeing her drink something he’d gag at. In fact, there were three empty glasses in front of her. He didn’t want to go full psychoanalytic on someone he had just met but he couldn’t help making conclusions.

Inaccessible? The heavy drinking? Maybe a break up. Or an apartment fire. No, likely a break up. The way her eyelashes fluttered in his direction and faltered away was probably nothing more than the need for a rebound. Defiant reclamation of her autonomy.

He doubted a woman as lovely as Will would stay single for long, unwillingly. Any implication of her interest in him made him a bit more skeptical, now that the initial impression was over. He noticed no wedding band on her finger. He knew she was living with Kerry. Maybe she’s like Lindsey.

“What can I get you?” The waiter arrived, struggling to keep up with the copious tables.

Lindsey ordered some red wine. He ordered the cheapest beer they had on tap. He raised an eyebrow when Will asked for another whiskey. Kerry, not paying too attention to her choice, asked for a refill.

“Are there other files on Rosello you happen to have?” It was the first thing that came to mind.

Kerry slumped and let out a moan while Will perked up. “Actually,” Will rested her elbows on the table, leaning forward. He caught a glimpse of cleavage framed in black lace and he forced himself to look away, his cheeks hot. “I’d be happy to go over everything I’ve gathered about the guy. Most of what we’ve given is all we have. Everything else just,” she held her hand and flicked her wrist, “vanished.” There was emotion in the way she hissed this out, as if it physically pained her.

He nodded, tossing her a grimacing frown. “That must be frustrating.” He had already been briefed by Detective David Tapp about their mole problem. From his understanding, it was her partner. That betrayal alone would complicate things, working with her. It was strange they had her on the case, though a mole for the mole was a decent strategy.

He wasn’t sure if they could completely trust her, though.

“You have no idea,” Will was loose and at ease, animated as she loudly whined. He figured it had something to do with the booze that made her particularly less stoic and uptight. His first impression, back at the Grill, had been that she was closed off and defensive. Friendly to a professional degree but she seemed to keep new faces at arms length. “I still can’t fathom how this fucker just gets away with everything he does. Just a few months ago, we put away one of his pimps. The guy was found stabbed to death in the county jail showers just a few weeks later. And then a few days after that, his case file just vanished from processing.”

She pressed her forehead on the table, letting out a groan. “And it’s like he never existed.”

“Hon,” Kerry put her hand on her back. “Stop thinking about work. And maybe drink some water.” Kerry outstretched her hand again, calling back their server.

“Yeah.” She shot up, red curls flipping upwards, cheeks pink. “I might have gone a bit overboard.”

“Uh-huh,” Kerry kept smiling, eyes locked onto Lindsey. “Are we going to just talk about work tonight? It’s still the weekend.”

Strahm ignored her, honing in on Will. He appreciated a woman that prioritized work. “Tell me about Rosello. You’ve met him?”

“Ugh. Yeah,” Will swirled her straw, taking a slow sip. Her lips left red marks wherever they came into contact with. He licked his dry mouth. “The guy likes to ‘mess with us’,” She finger curled quotation marks, “whatever the fuck that means. My partner had to coach me before meeting him so I didn’t piss him off and put a target on my back. And then he goes and mails me dick pics.” She wrinkled her nose, eyes glazed.

He widened his eyes and felt his jaw drop. “Your partner did what?” He never met this partner but now wanted to put a face to the name. Hoffman was his name. Hoffman.

“No. Not his dick. Rosello’s dick. You don’t know my partner.” She inhaled, “He’s not on this case.” She seemed irked. “Complicated.”

“Wait, what’s this about Hoffman’s dick?” Kerry rounded on her, looking concerned and fascinated.

“Nooo,” Will slurred, “Not his dick, Rosello’s dick.”

“You need to rewind, honey.”

The waiter returned, giving him a bottle of beer and a chilled glass. He drank straight from the bottle, ignoring the icy pint, flaring his nostrils as he sharply inhaled. He felt hot and irritable. While Kerry and Will blubbered together like tweedle dee and tweedle drunk, Lindsey shot him a warning glance. He got the message. Patience is a virtue.

He could practically hear it in her voice, her having chanted this mantra at him on more than one occasion.

He rotated the glass bottle in his hands, stealing glances at the woman across the table, who was repeating the tale in low murmurs to her colleague. It looked like tonight was going to cease productivity. Because of her relationship with the mole, he had wanted a chance to study her. He needed to talk to Will when she was more coherent. He set a mental note to give her a call sometime soon to pick her brain. Preferably somewhere quiet and secluded. Private.

His hopes that she would be much more forthcoming tonight was backfiring already. Sure, she didn’t seem to have any shame and answered his questions unguarded. But she was rambling and scattered. He didn’t have the tolerance to decipher her jumbled answers. Or maybe, he was just tired. It had been a long day. He needed to remind himself of this.

His cool drink settled in his stomach and already he felt himself calm down. He hadn’t eaten yet, his head light.

Someone’s cell phone was ringing. Will seemed to be fumbling for her purse, pulling out the flip phone, dragging the antenna upwards, putting the receiver to her mouth. “Hello?” He could see more of the whites of her eyes as they stretched outward. Her rouge lips parted. “Mark? Right now?” The way she shot upward and was already turning her body as though wanting to leave the booth told him all it needed to.

Ah, there’s the boyfriend. He took another swig of his beer.

“Wait, what? Uh-huh. Okay. All right. I’m coming over. Right now.” She flipped the plastic, turning to everyone. “Sorry, I need to go.”

“Wait.” Kerry held her hand out. “You promise that was Hoffman? And not Frank?” Eyebrow furrowed, intense scowl, Strahm stored these details for safekeeping.

Mark Hoffman’s the partner. So not her boyfriend. But Frank? An ex? So it is a breakup. He didn’t like how he felt almost relieved by this. But he felt the twist in his gut loosen.

“Yes, Ally, it’s just Hoffman. I promise. I’m not sneaking off to see Frank. Come on, it sounds urgent.”

“Want me to go with you? You’ve had a couple.” Ally gestured to the mess they made. Will just gave her a funny scowl while she slid her arms into her winter coat.

“I’m fine,” Will sighed. “Come on, scooch.”

Strahm knew Lindsey wanted to spend the night talking with Ally. He knew by the way Lindsey’s lips thinned just a little and the way Ally shot an apologetic pout her way, there was about to be some disappointment.

“It’s not safe going out on your own. I’ll take you,” he offered, eager for an opportunity to dip out early. “It’s getting late. I think I’m going to turn in.” He wanted to shoot a smirk towards Lindsey but kept his face expressionless.

Will paused, looking at him with careful consideration. She was on guard, despite her inebriation. He wouldn’t push if she insisted. But still, it was dangerous walking out in this city alone and drunk. No matter if she carried her gun in her purse or walked around with her badge on her chest.

“I agree,” Kerry chimed in. “Let Peter take you.”

“Okay,” her eyes were still shining with that acute awareness that only a woman who had seen too much had. “Thanks.”

They left the two lovebirds, walking out into the cold. He kept an eye out for a cab, intending to hail one as soon as one turned the corner. None appeared. They walked in awkward silence, the click of her heels and the scrape of his soles conversing for them.

“How far do you need to go?” Strahm wanted her to feel assured that he had no ulterior motive. He was just looking out for a colleague.

“Not far. He’s just a thirty minute walk from here.” The playful and silly act had frozen up. She looked so serious, scanning her surroundings as she briskly walked. The woman he had first met at the Green Lion Grill was back, as if she had never truly left.

“We can always get a cab.”

“It’s fine. I need to sober up. Sorry. Just got a lot on my mind.” Despite her quick footing, she was slow, her short stature compared to his long gait making him have to take extra short strides so she could keep up. It amused him how petite she was, the top of her head barely reaching his shoulder, in heels. She walked like a person who felt taller than she really was.

Each footstep echoed off the cement. She was shivering, despite wearing her coat. Her legs were bare, showing strong curved calves. He wondered if he should offer her his jacket. He didn’t want to come off as creepy.

He kept his jacket on.

“So,” he was grabbing wildly in his brain for anything to talk about. But all that came to was work. He decided now was his chance to snoop. “Why’s your partner not working with you on the Rosello case? He on another assignment?”

“Something like that.” She had her arms crossed, trying to walk fast and keep her face forward. Maybe he had misread the situation the last time they met. Tonight, he felt walled off. It was fair. If the roles were reversed, he’d be concerned about being escorted home by some guy he’d just met.

“Mark Hoffman’s his name?”

“Yeah.”

“I’ve heard of him. What do you make of him?”

“Why do you want to know?” She sounded almost hostile.

He felt frustration flare up under his ribs. “You can guess why. It’s obvious he’s involved.”

She stopped, scraping the rough ground. “Yeah, well, it’s not like it’s his fault. Let’s make things clear. Hoffman is not the bad guy. It’s Rosello.”

Strahm raised an eyebrow, taking in the glint of cinnamon irises under the pale yellow of the street lights. Fire and brimstone. “I know he’s your partner. But he’s compromised. You can’t deny that. You can’t deny this looks bad on you as well.”

“I’m not. But I don’t want everyone to just start pinning the blame on him. He’s another victim in Rosello’s trap. Everyone thinks he’s some malicious asshole. But they don’t know him like I do. He’s a good friend and will stick his neck out for us. No one ever talks about that but they should.”

“I see. It’s clear you two are close.” He needed to get them out of this awkward rut. He opted for changing the subject. “So. How do you like working at MPD?”

“It’s all right. Kind of a mess.” There was an almost relieved sigh as she finally looked at him, warily. “How do you like working with the FBI?”

“If I said I’d love it, I’d probably be raising some red flags.”

“Right. You’re a profiler.”

“Yeah.”

“So you’re a shrink.” She pushed red curls behind her ear, avoiding his look.

He laughed. “Not really. Why? You need one?” He hoped some good humored teasing would lighten the mood.

“Maybe.” She smirked back. “I think we all could use some therapy once in a while.”

“Ain’t that the truth. Well, if you need to just talk. I’m all ears.”

“We’ve only just met.”

“True. I’m sure our working together on this investigation will suffice for a grace period. Who knows? Maybe you can come help us out in the future.”

“Are you offering me a job, Special Agent Strahm?” He liked the way she said that, her voice low and pleasing.

“Maybe. We’ve only just met, Detective Maddox,” he returned the ball in her court. He put his hands in his pockets, though he was warming up from their walk.

“Well, we’ll see. I’ve gotten pretty invested with the precinct. A lot of good people who are just swimming against the current. And this city needs as much help as it can get. If not me, who will?”

He gave her credit. She sounded like she cared. “Well, I’m sure you can make some good changes. Just don’t sacrifice your ideals. But if it gets too hard, don’t feel ashamed about jumping ship. Especially if you end up hitting a glass ceiling.”

Her red lips curved, concave up. “You make it sound like I’m stuck in the fifties. Is the FBI so ahead of its time?”

“I think so. Look at Lindsey. She probably doesn’t deal with half the bullshit you and Kerry put up with.”

“Maybe. I’m not sure if I have the stomach for it, though. You deal with guys like Ted Bundy.”

“More often than I’d like. But you’ve got Toni Rosello. From what I’ve gathered, they’re not much different. But people like us are the ones that step up and take them out. If not us, who will?”

“It must be hard.” She was studying him, suspicion draining and replaced with intrigue. “Sounds like a nightmare.”

“Someone’s got to do it. We’re in the same boat, Will.” It wasn’t often someone turned the conversational spotlight back at him. He felt weird, talking about himself. “But I’m not complaining. Sounds like you guys have a lot on your table. The corruption makes my head hurt. I’d lose my shit if people kept misplacing paperwork. I can’t believe no one’s been fired yet.”

She let out a scoff. “Yeah. Right? I was in denial when I first got here. I thought people were just bitter and stretching the truth. It was a culture shock.” She bit her lip. “Honestly, I’m so frustrated. We need to do better.”

He smiled. “You going to make things better?”

“I’ll try.” She shot him a glare. “You keep asking that. You think I can’t do it?”

“I never said that.” He wanted to hold his hands up. Her defensiveness caught him off guard. He wondered how often she had to stand up for herself. “You must get a lot of pushback here.”

“Don’t we all?”

“Maybe Lindsey more than me. But from what she tells me, you all have it real bad.” Silence. He wondered if he sounded condescending to her. “Where’d you come from? I hear you’re from the west coast.”

“Yeah. San Diego. I miss it.”

“Why’d you leave?”

She didn’t answer right away. He had caught a glimpse of regret in her frown. “I don’t know anymore.”

They eventually reached the apartment building. “Well. Thanks for the walk,” she forced a smile. “Sorry about dragging you this far.” She had pressed the front buzzer, waiting by the intercom speaker.

“Don’t sweat it.” He had his fists in his pockets, wanting to leave with a lasting impression.

”Yeah?” A gruff, deep voice called out.

“It’s me,” Will’s eyes were fixed on Strahm as she spoke into the soundbox. The front door clicked and buzzed sharply. She was already heading in. “Take care, Peter.”

“Uh - Will.”

She stopped, face blank.

“You know, if you ever want to talk. I’m here.”

She gave him a raised eyebrow. “Peter, weren’t we just talking?” She gave him one more dazzling lipsticked smile, making his heart skip a beat, before leaving him out in the cold.

Mark Hoffman

When he opened the door, he thought he was dreaming. He had never seen her in a dress before. Or dolled up. When she took off her coat and flung it over his couch, he drank in her bare back and wondered who the lucky bastard was that she had gotten cleaned up over. He just prayed it wasn’t Frank.

And here he thought he couldn’t feel any worse.

He finally stepped into the light, letting her take a good look at his ugly mug. A part of him liked how quickly her expression morphed to horror. Concern. “You look nice. Who’s the guy?” He pretended nothing was wrong.

“Jesus, Mark. I should be asking you that. What the hell happened?” She stepped closer to take him in. Her eyes swept from his face and neck to his bare arms. He had only his tank shirt on, having just struggled out of the shower and only able to bear the thinnest material on his bruised flesh. She was so close that he felt his skin prickle.

He smelled perfume, something rich and sweet. It tickled his nose. His pulse was echoing in his ears, a throbbing pain pounded across his body with every beat.

“Rosello?” She didn’t try to ease the conversation. She went straight for the jugular. “Tell me, Mark.”

“Rosello.” He went for his comfort, bee lining to the fridge and taking down his whiskey. “You want one?”

“No.” She shook her head, following him. Her shoes were loud on his floor. She’d probably piss off his neighbors downstairs. “Jesus. Is Angie okay?”

“She’s fine. But that’s why I called you.” He downed a healthy glass, refilling the cup. He hated what he was about to ask. “I need your help.”

“What do you need?”

“I need you to tell your buddies to keep a patrol on her and Peter. Only someone you trust.” He was gripping the edges of his counter, squeezing with all his might. He wasn’t a man. He was pathetic. “And protect her. Because I can’t.” He expected Will to scoff at him. To call him a spineless coward. To walk away.

“Of course, Mark.” She placed a cool hand on his knuckles. Soft and light on his hot fingers. “We can do that. We’ll keep her safe. What about you? We should put you in a safe house. You and Angie.”

“No. If I vanish, it’ll just motivate him to come for her. For now, I need to just keep doing what he wants.”

“Which is?”

He saw the dark makeup beginning to smear under her eyes. He wanted to wipe it clean. “Give him intel on your investigation. And he wants the names of the feds you’re working with.”

She took a step back. “I can’t tell you that, Mark.”

“I know.” He looked down at his drink. “I’m not expecting you to.” Pathetic. That’s what he was. He couldn’t look her in the face. He had almost hoped she would have just given him the names. “Sorry I took you away from your date.”

She let out a huff. “I wasn’t on a date.”

“Didn’t know that’s what you wear when you buy groceries.”

“What if I told you,” she pulled her hand away, “that women don’t always dress up to impress a man?”

He finally stole a glance. “Fine. Sorry. It’s just you look pretty. I just don’t know how to tell you without sounding like an asshole.”

She blinked, blushed, crinkled her nose, then let out an audible groan. “Like that, Mark.” She let out a huff and went to help herself to a glass. “Why is it, every time I see you, I have to have another drink?” She pulled the bottle from his grip and poured herself a healthy dose. “Tell me everything. From the beginning. I’m not going to judge. But tell me everything.” She snapped her fingers and he sharpened his gaze at her. “Every detail. Toni Rosello will go down, Mark. I swear it. But if you try to cover shit up anymore, it’s going to make my job really fucking difficult.”

“You should probably call your family first. Anyone you care about. Rosello’s scared like I’ve never seen him before. That’s making him more dangerous. Your parents back west, any siblings. Anyone you care about. ”

She let out a harsh laugh. “Yeah, good luck to Rosello. I’m fine.” She was taking a big gulp of her drink, staring intently at a photo of Angie on the fridge.

Even he could feel the awkward tension filling the room, he decided to risk it. “...Your parents alive?”

“One. Technically.”

This was news. Hoffman waited for her to continue. When she refused to elaborate, he dared to push. “Technically?”

“My father’s been in a coma for a couple of years now. He won’t wake up. My mother and brother died when I was still in high school.” She sniffed and cleared her throat. “Home invasion. I was at dance camp. My father was on a fishing trip. Clark and Mom were home.”

“Jesus. I’m sorry.” He shuffled sideways to her but paused when she held her hand out.

“No. Don’t be. It was a long time ago and it’s made me who I am today. It made me want to go into law enforcement. ‘Cause they never caught the guy.” She was pouring herself another drink and then hoisted herself onto his counter. She was now perched at eye level, her knees just inches from his stomach. She rocked her heels back and forth and continued sipping spirits. “And a few years ago, my dad got a stroke. He’s currently in a hospital back in California. He had decent benefits when he worked the railroad. He’s taken care of but they said his brain atrophied to the point that he’ll never wake up. To me, he died a long time ago.”

“Damn.”

She shrugged, lower lip stiff. “The only guy Rosello may try to get to is Frank. And that would just be doing me a favor at this point.” She was slurring and her voice was thick like syrup. Her forehead was leaning towards him. “Jesus. I think I’ve gone a bit too far.” She was rocking forward.

“Hey.” He caught her, grabbing her shoulders, her skin scalding to the touch. “Yeah. I think you’re done.” He slid the empty tumbler out of her reach.

“Shut up.” She pressed her face into his shirt and let out a low groan. “Shit, I’m drunk.” He stiffened, gently squeezing his fingers into her skin.

“Yeah. You are.”

“There is someone, though.” She pulled back, panting heavily. She was flushed and put her hand on his chest. “Sorry about your shirt.”

She had smeared lipstick on his white tank. He didn’t care. His heart was beating fast as her hands brushed up and down his chest. This was getting a bit too close and personal. He knew she’d regret this and kept her firmly held back with his arms. “Yeah? Then call them. Warn them.”

Her pink mouth had a smile he wasn’t sure he liked. A woman’s smile. Her hands were like feathers, tickling up to his collarbone and shoulders. She began massaging his traps, digging digits into his tight muscles and making him inhale sharply. How could something feel so good and sting so much? “I don’t need to,” she whispered.

“Oh?”

“Rosello already has him.” She kissed his cheek, pulling back with a sad glower. “I want him back.”

He felt his voice hitch in his throat. The room had gotten stifling. His pants felt tight and this made him flush with embarrassment. He half-heartedly stepped back. “I think you need to go to bed.”

“I think you should join me,” she was singing, low and full of a teasing melody. Her face was so close he could smell the alcohol on her breath.

He smirked back, the horrors of earlier slipping away. “That’s probably not a good idea.” Though they drank together often, this was the first time he’d seen her acting so… forward. Relaxed. Maybe a little too relaxed then she’d like when she sobered up. I’m going to enjoy holding this over your head until the end of time.

This was nothing. As soon as the sun rose, she’d pretend this never happened and they’d go back to the way things were. The way things had always been. She wouldn’t want a pathetic man like me. “I think I should take you back to Kerry’s.”

She pouted. “And leave you alone for the sharks? No way, Jose.” Her palms were on his neck, the pads of her thumbs tracing his jawline. “I’m staying right here. With you. I think it’ll be safer if I stay the night.” Her lips were wet and warm on his neck, attacking him out of nowhere.

He froze, paralyzed as his living room clock ticked away and she continued to kiss into his bruised skin. It hurt. It soothed. A part of him wanted to let her continue. But the more rational part of him told him to shut this shit down fast.

“What are you trying to pull?” He pushed her back firmly, hoping they could pretend she hadn’t just crossed a major line. This was the sort of thing he had tried to avoid, pushing her to Kerry and away from him. His neck was cold from her absence and he suppressed a shiver. It would be so easy to just let it all happen.

But not like this.

She hit his shoulder with her forehead, pulling the thin fabric of his top in her fists. Knuckles brushed his chest hair. “I hate seeing you in pain.” She was whining into his skin, hot breath muffling into him. “I want to make it go away.”

“You think kissing it is going to make it better?”

“It doesn’t?” She blinked at him, unfocused.

“Not when you’re piss drunk. If the roles were reversed, this would be downright criminal.”

“Yeah. I guess you’re right.” She grumbled, finally pulling away. “Sorry, Hoffman.”

Thank Christ she’s a rational drunk. But there was a disappointment burrowed in his core, making him feel as though he was sinking. He chose to ignore it. He may have been a helpless man, a slave to Toni Rosello. But he would at least be a man that didn’t take advantage of a drunk woman. “You can take the bed.”

“Always the gentleman.” She kicked off her heels, the hard soles clattering onto the wooden floor. She ran her hand through her hair, pulling her thick curls back. “I haven’t been sleeping well. I’m not used to sleeping alone anymore.”

“That sucks.”

“I won’t kick you out of your own bed.”

“I’m not going to let you take the couch.”

“Then we’re at an impasse.”

He narrowed his eyes. “How so?”

She let out a frustrated noise. “Mark.”

“What?”

“Don’t let me sleep alone. Please.” He realized she was crying, burying her face into his chest and the warm wetness of tears spread across like summer rain. The way she pleaded. It was full of desperate need.

“Hey.” He wasn’t sure if he should, but he put his arms around her. He squeezed, trying to make her stop. He hated seeing her like this. “You’re okay.”

She sobbed, “I’m so fucking lonely, Mark. I have no one.”

“No, don’t think that.” He lamely patted her back as she cried heavier into him. “I’m right here. You’re okay. I’ll stay with you. I’m not going anywhere. Just. Stop crying, okay?”

She broke off and let out a small chuckle. She pulled back and wiped her tears, smearing black streaks around her eyes. “Damn it, I’m probably being a lot right now.”

“Yeah. But it’s okay. You’ve got a lot going on.” He swallowed and added, “you kind of look like a zombie right now.”

She laughed more, playfully slapping his arm. “Fuck you.” The anxiety eating him up slowed down.

“Let’s get ready for bed. We’ve got work in the morning. Though you could call in sick.”

“No.” She kept wiping the corners of her eyes. “Here I am, coming to help you out and I just unload on you and you end up helping me.” There was a fondness in her smile and awe in her eyes. “Thanks.”

He retrieved some paper towels. He heard the sound of a phone ringing and her shuffling. When he turned to her, she had a fresh frown and furrowed brow while she stared at her cell phone screen. He handed her a fistful of tissue. “Here’s looking at you, kid.” The frown melted and she grinned again as she wiped her cheeks and made her way into his bedroom. She had tossed her phone on the couch.

He heard the shower running. While she was preoccupied, he quickly did a walkthrough of his bedroom. He collected his bloody shirt he had dropped onto the floor from earlier. He straightened the bedsheets. He consciously recalled the wooden box was tucked away behind the air vents. He left some spare sweats and a shirt on the bed and retreated back into the living room, his fingers twitching as he ran through the scenarios.

He said he’d sleep with her. But he wasn’t sure what that would entail. He figured she just wanted someone in the room with her, so he fetched some spare pillows and blankets to make room on the floor.

The familiar shrill ringing of her phone made him pause. It was so late. There was no good reason for a call unless it was work or an emergency. He went to get the cell, picking it up to find the caller ID. Anger festered in his chest. Frank.

He squeezed the silence button, having it go to voicemail. Almost immediately after, the phone rang again.

He didn’t pause to think.

He flipped the phone, pressed the green button, and put the receiver to his ear.

“Will?” The fucker’s voice sounded urgent.

“What do you want, Griffin?” he growled back, keeping his voice steady and hateful. “Will doesn’t want to talk to you.”

He could hear the man’s rasped breathing. “Who the fuck is this?”

“Mark Hoffman. Look me up.”

“You. You fucking prick. So you’re fucking my wife now?” There was spiteful laughter. “I knew it.”

“No, I’m not. But let’s make things clear. She’s gone. She’s not coming back. And if you keep bothering her, I will make you stop. Back the fuck off. Do you understand?”

“Fuck you, pig.” The phone clicked and the call ended. Hoffman snapped the phone and placed it on the kitchen counter, the vein in his neck throbbing. There was a newfound anger that he needed to cool off. He flared his nostrils and inhaled deep, holding his composure.

The sound of the shower stopping made him return to his preparations. By the time he returned to the bedroom, Will was already changed, damp haired and sitting on the bed.

“Hey,” she towelled her hair, nodding at his little nest in the corner. “You’re not going to sleep there?”

He opened his mouth to say something but the words had died in his throat. He looked at the pile of blankets on the floor and back at her, bare legs over his bed, taunting him. She had forgoed his sweat pants. All she wore was one of his t-shirts. He just barely made out her nipples. She was cold. Fuck. “I figured. Just. Wasn’t sure.”

Will stretched, yawning, unphased by the tension he was caught in. She stayed on one side of the bed, getting under the covers. “Goodnight, Mark,” she murmured, eyes half-lidded. She went to turn off the nightstand lamp, shrouding them in darkness.

Fuck it. He went to the other side, staying as close to the edge of the bed as he could fit. He softly groaned from the aches in his limbs, the muscles sore and tight from his earlier beat down. Every movement was agony.

It was a queen size, not necessarily cozy, but he wasn’t used to sharing. He could feel her, the weight of her compressing the springs on his right side. She was angled in a way where she would gradually sink towards him, his weight just that much greater. He tried to roll over while avoiding her touch. Their arms brushed together, shooting up static in his joints.

“Mark?” Her voice broke through the silence.

“Hm.”

He felt her move, a thin limb slowly wrapping around his shoulders and the sensation of her cheek pressed against his chest made his heart pound fast. He suppressed the ache from his bruises, letting her sink her mass onto him. “Is this okay?”

“Yeah.” He forced his voice even and steady, but it was more of a croak. It kind of hurt. But he wasn’t going to ever admit it. “You really comfortable?”

“Yeah. This is nice.” She rubbed her face into him like a cat. “Thanks for this. I owe you one.”

He listened to the sound of her soft and rhythmic breathing as she drifted to sleep. He stared into the black as the sandman finally made its rounds to him.

Chapter 10: Pre-Saw: Killing Boredom

Chapter Text

Eric Matthews

It was one hell of a rainy Thursday afternoon. It seemed to rain a lot these days. The low rumble of thunder vibrated through the old building. The lighting flickered as he walked through the halls of peeling lead paint and dusty cracked linoleum.

Matthews made his way up the stairs of the station, heading towards the recreation room. The sound of squeaking tennis shoes and the smell of rubber and pinesol chased him as he walked by some of the guys from Narcotics who were in the middle of a game.

“Yo, Matthews!” One of the boys called out to him and he nodded back while balancing his gym bag. Across the basketball court was Room 109, a padded room where self defense training took place.

As soon as he crossed the threshold he witnessed Will Maddox flip Allison Kerry onto the mat in a flurry of brown waves and the solid thump as a hundred pounds and some change whacked into plastic padding.

“Damn,” Ally let out a low groan as Maddox pulled her back up to her feet. She was already sweaty, wiping her brow with the sleeve of her athletic jacket. “Got me.” She was pulled up by Maddox, getting to her feet as she stretched the arm she had been flipped on.

“You can try it on me next,” Maddox smiled up at Matthews. “Hey.”

“Hey.” Matthews chewed hard on his gum as he went to put his belongings at the edge of the room. He didn’t particularly want to spend his lunch break ‘reviewing tactical procedure’ as Maddox put it but Tapp had approved and what Tapp said, goed.

The rest of the geek squad met throughout the week to train. The partners stuck together, while Fisk and Gibson paired up. Because of the odd turnout, Maddox had requested bringing on Hoffman, a silverlining to the wasted lunch breaks. Tapp hadn’t been keen but so long as they kept the small talk non-work related, he had grumpily agreed.

He began stretching while Maddox was showing Allison some stances on what looked like jiu jitsu or maybe judo. He couldn’t tell off the bat. He never took any specialized martial arts. He never needed to. He was always fast and strong, never needing to worry about fancy maneuvers or tactical strategy like the smaller guys needed to rely on.

He figured he and Hoffman would chill with their backs against the wall, coking and joking while the women tumbled over each other. He looked forward to the show, already a wide smirk painting his face as he imagined a semi-erotic catfight in the next few minutes.

“Here, this will be more effective if you try this move when someone much larger is trying to grab you. Hey Matthews,” Maddox breathlessly waved at him to come closer. “Come on over. Try to grab her. And lose the gum.”

“Sure thing.” Matthews crinkled his eyes at her, smacking the gum while taking his time to the center of the mat. He caught the sharp look Allison threw at him, a green-eyed warning to behave. He softened his face. For her, he’d play nice.

“The gum, Eric,” Allison softly murmured. “Don’t want it ending up in my hair.”

He swallowed and opened his mouth for her to take a good look. “Should I give a warning? Count to three?” He smirked at Maddox.

“No, we don’t get warnings in the field. So don’t give it here.” Maddox took a step back, leaving the two of them with plenty of space.

“Don’t worry, Al,” Matthews watched Ally as she pulled herself into a defensive stance, spreading her feet and slightly bending her knees. He raised an eyebrow. It looked like her new roommate was teaching her some tricks.

He rushed forward to grab her arm, squeezing and pulling her into a bear hug. He had her firmly, arm trying to go around her throat, but he was stopped by her chin. She had tucked her fucking chin. She squirmed for a moment but he was in no rush to capacitate her. He let her struggle.

“Use his weight against him,” Maddox called out.

As if on cue, he suddenly felt himself lurch forward. He let out a surprised noise and found Ally drop and slip from his grip while he stumbled a few steps off to the side. He went to correct, going to reach for her arm again when she suddenly clasped his wrist and rolled in the opposite direction he was moving.

He let out a hiss of pain as he was forced to his knees, Ally now standing with his arm pulled to his back in the opposite motion of his ball and socket joint.

“Uncle?” Ally was panting hard.

Matthews let out a roar and pushed into her, throwing back his head until it collided with her face and sent her flying backwards.

He had knocked the wind out of her. Ally was on her back, eyes wide and gasping. A part of him felt regret tug his heartstrings, realizing he had gone too far. “Shit.”

“Ally?” Will knelt over her and helped her up to her feet. “Walk it off.” She gave Matthews a wary glance. “We did say not to hold back.”

“Al,” Matthews took a step towards her. “Sorry.”

“You’re fine, Eric.” She had her hands pressed into her knees, wincing. She looked up to Maddox. “Can you run by how to counter that shit?”

“Yeah. Take a breather. That was real good. Solid first time.” Ally went to lean against the wall and get a drink of water. And then the redheaded shrimp spun to face him. He expected bitching. Some nagging. But she didn’t look angry when she looked up at him and raised her arms, “All right, Matthews, do your worst.” She looked stone cold.

“You sure?” He was starting to second guess whether it was a good idea, playing rough with them. It just wasn’t fair. Besides, he had heard about Hoffman having to bail her ass out, her getting pinned by some gangbanger wannabe on some undercover job a couple months back. He seriously doubted she should be strutting around, talking a big game like she knew what she was doing.

He looked back over at Ally. He’d need to take her aside. Let her know to maybe take what this gal said with a grain of salt. But not here. He chose to be friendly, out of respect for his partner. Where the hell was Hoffman to keep his in check?

“Do your worst.” Maddox gave a confident smile. “Hurt me.”

He suppressed a sneer. “All right.” He threw a fist at her chest and she spun sideways, dodging it. She kept her hands up and was rocking back and forth.

“So you know some tricks. But let’s be real. You’re out of your weight class, Mad Max.” He lurched forward to grab her, gripping her by one elbow and pulling her in for a tight squeeze. She was a blur, grabbing his forearm.

The world spun in vertical ribbons of light and motion. He felt himself suddenly on his back, his head striking the padding with a solid thunk. His neck strained and he found himself staring at the light fixture above, wondering what the hell just happened.

“You okay?” He was looking up at the woman, catseye amber blinking down. Up close, he could count the freckles on her chin and nose. Sharp teeth smiled triumphantly.

“You got me.” He grunted and took her outstretched hand. She leaned back to help pull him up as he went back to his feet. “Not bad, Mad Max. Not bad.”

“Did I miss the fun?”

Hoffman walked in towards the three of them. He had fading yellow bruises on his cheeks. Old scabs and cuts on his neck. Matthews had heard he had gotten a beat down but hadn’t realized the extent. “Sorry I’m late.”

“Mark,” Maddox seemed to brighten up. “You made it.” Her voice had gone from its low, tough-girl monotone to a soft jingle. Matthews and Ally exchanged a brief glance, amusement twinkling in Ally’s eyes. She was like a kid on Christmas.

“About time,” Matthews cracked his neck as he made his way over to Hoffman. “We can throw down like back in ninety-two.”

Hoffman gave him a knowing smirk. “I recall you lost back then.”

“I’m overdue for a rematch.”

“We’ll spar with our respective weight classes, first for intervals of ten minutes,” Maddox announced, “And then we’ll alternate with our partners.”

“Aye aye, Mad Max.” Matthews called out as the two women went to one side of the mat. They were already gearing up, one donning boxing gloves while the other held a padded riot shield.

“She give you hell for that nickname?” He strode with Hoffman to the opposite end of the room as the man walked to his side. He didn’t plan on wearing any protective gear. Hoffman didn’t make a move to retrieve his bag either.

“Nope,” Matthews paused, struggling to find something neutral to say. “You said she was high strung. I don’t see it.”

“Give it time.” The two of them stood face to face, awkwardly, not sure how to proceed. “We seriously have to do this every week now?” Hoffman glanced over his shoulder where Ally and Maddox were punching and juking, committed to their work.

“Yeah. Tapp loves busting our balls. Shame you’re missing out on most of the fun.” Matthews raised his fists and threw the first punch. He wasn’t using much of his strength. It was more like playground jabbing. Hoffman blocked it and gave him a return throw, not quite as fast as he knew the man could move, and he dodged it.

“From the looks of it, I’m not missing much. I’ve got too much on my plate as it is.”

While they horsed around, Matthews thought of Hoffman, being pushed under Rosello’s foot, and thought of how much that must have sucked. It was a damn shame. He remembered early on, when they first met, the ambitions they shared.

Hoffman was stuck. Fighting shadows and forced to slow everyone around him down, too. It was part of why he hadn’t worked with the man on a case in years. Once Rosello was out of the picture, he expected his friend to be right as rain. If they ever could get a conviction on the bastard.

Despite the shit Hoffman was in, Eric Matthews held him in the highest of regards. He doubted he’d have handled the professional downfall and public shame that Mark Hoffman was experiencing. Certainly not with the same level of grace. It was fucking commendable.

“Okay, let’s switch.” Maddox called out to the room and the pairs broke apart.

“Later,” Hoffman walked off, already wiping at his forehead while Ally walked up to him.

“Don’t go easy,” Ally strode up to him, like a cheetah approaching prey. She was confident. Sexy. It was like Fourth of July in his stomach whenever she got this close. After a couple of years together, they had been doomed to fall for each other.

He still needed to figure out what the hell to do. With her. And Jane. And Daniel.

“You okay?” She was waiting patiently, her stance loose and poised, her biceps flexing as she held her cushioned fists upwards.

“Yeah. Just tired.” He swiped at her, trying his damnest to hold her in place. She side-jumped and slipped away.

He knew this training was more for their benefit than his. He rarely lost a fight. It was Ally who tended to get knocked over or overpowered when the chips were down. Tapp was just being political and subtle. Equal.

As he managed to wrap Ally in a chokehold, her forgetting to tuck her chin to prevent him from getting there, he squeezed gently. Of course, he held back. But he made it clear she had lost.

This was all because of the latest victims. Three broads. Clearly Rosello’s M.O. And their features were undeniable, having been found together, wrapped in plastic and laid out right on the station’s front steps earlier that week. With features that were disturbingly familiar. Curly red hair. Wavy brown curls. Crinkled black hair. All young women, their throats slashed.

The message was sent. And the task force had been briefed. The response was to prepare and not let this bastard hurt any of them. He needed to give Ally some tough love.

She tapped his forearm, surrendering. He released and let her slip and twirl about to reorient herself. She was breathing hard, already exhausted. “Cardio, Al,” he quietly murmured, no longer feeling so laid back. It could have been her, wrapped in plastic and left out in the rain to rot. If Ally ever got hurt, he wasn’t sure how he’d handle it. He needed to make sure she could handle herself. Or at least hurt the bastard enough to get the hell away.

“Eric?”

He blinked again. “Sorry. Look, you’re leaving your left side vulnerable. You need to work on that. Try to block me. Pay attention to what arm I use mostly. We all use dominant sides. Usually.”

And then he swiped for her again. She picked it up fast, like he knew she would. It was a relief. At least she was a quick study. When he made a grab for her again she had dropped and flung herself back, tumbling backwards in a funny looking roll. He stopped to laugh.

“Fuck off,” she panted and went to retie her ponytail. She had a red scrunchie around the wrist. It made him think of blood. The pictures from the recent victims, particularly the redheaded one, had been another warning to the precinct.

What Rosello left as evidence on one of the past victims had made him skip lunch.

Hoffman should be informed. Hell, Maddox should be taken off the fucking case.

Maybe he was overreaching and seeing connections that weren’t real. But he had that tightness in his stomach that was thick and heavy with the feeling that Rosello had a thing for torturing redheads. Or was targeting Will Maddox. Either reason, Maddox needed to watch her back.

And Hoffman should be told that his partner is in danger.

“Woah,” Ally’s eyes widened as she gawked over his shoulder. He spun to see what got her spooked.

Hoffman had both arms around Will tightly, while she struggled in his hold. He looked smug. She tried to stomp onto his foot but he was picking her off the ground, like some life sized puppet that kicked and flailed pathetically.

“You done?” He calmly asked as she grunted and tried to push out from him.

She suddenly skipped, the tips of her toes bouncing off the floor, then threw her head forward and threw it back as she leaped up. There was a clear sound of bone-on-bone contact and he let out a surprised grunt, dropping her. She ripped out of his arms, fell forward onto her knees and then shot her foot out to kick him in the ankle.

Matthews flinched, expecting her to break his leg. Maybe dislocate his knee. But she paused.

“Hit.” She wheezed before crawling away. Hoffman was gripping his chin, looking aggravated.

“I’d still win this,” Hoffman growled, taking a lumbering step towards her.

“Duh,” she kept crawling from him, as though realizing for the first time that the bear was dangerous. “But that’s not the point. The point is getting away. Staying alive. I think I’ve proven that now. I'd have run as fast as I could out of here.”

Hoffman nodded, still wincing as he gingerly pulled his hand away. His jaw was red and looked like it was already swelling. The sight of the injury bothered Matthews. She should have held back, like I’m sure he did. The kid had been brutal.

“Let’s take a break,” Ally volunteered to make the peace. “I’m out of water.” He opted to join Ally to go refill while leaving the two bickering lovebirds to whatever tryst they were going through. They left the room and instantly Ally gave him an eyeroll. “Those two. Does it take you back?”

He smiled back. “Maybe. I don’t recall you leaving so many bruises.”

She laughed as they made their way to the closest water cooler. “No. Definitely didn’t go assaulting each other. In fact, I recall a completely different exercise routine we used to do on the regular.” She was flashing him a toothy grin and a low voice, talking in the way that made his skin hot.

“Yeah. I miss those times.”

She was close and leaned into him. “You busy this weekend?”

The image of Jane and Daniel crossed his vision. It quickly dampened the heat in his stomach, though not in its entirety. “Yeah. Unfortunately.”

She nodded, not angry, only disappointed. “I figured.” She licked her lips and looked around before leaning in. “We could always try somewhere… accessible.”

“Oh yeah?” He felt thrills shooting up and down his limbs and the urge to grab her by the hair and taste the sweat on her skin was becoming hard to suppress.

“Yeah.” She looked around again. “There’s a broom closet down in the basement, by the morgue. And it has a lock.”

He nodded at this, face burning as he imagined them sneaking down there. Kind of fucked up. Kind of kinky. “We could probably meet after this.”

“I’d like that,” she murmured, voice rich like molasses. They refilled their bottles and returned to Room 109, Matthews now wearing a smile he didn’t bother to suppress. He let himself take in Ally’s curves, anticipating gripping and squeezing them in just a few minutes.

They returned to the lovebirds, walking in the middle of an even more heated debate.

“-you can handle yourself, then why the hell’ve you let the bastard hurt you?” Hoffman had sounded bewildered. Furious. “This whole time. You’ve just let him beat you.”

Maddox had her arms crossed, looking off with shame burning on her spotted face.

“Everything good?” He figured he’d break this up. He didn’t want Hoffman to fuck up a good thing, though he wasn’t sure what the hell he was whining about. It sounded a bit too personal for his ears.

Hoffman jerked and turned, his face passive but a slight nervous glint in his eye showed he hadn’t expected them back so soon. Or maybe he just forgot there were people around, in the heat of the moment.

“Yes,” Maddox nodded and smiled, a little too cheery for it to be authentic. She was like a saleswoman, always quick to charisma and good with putting on a show. “Unless Ally wants to spar with Hoffman, I think we’re done here.”

Damn, she was all ‘Mark, Mark’ earlier. He nodded, “Yeah, we can call it in early. Good work out.”

Ally had gone to Maddox and the two softly exchanged some words while he waited at the doorway. Hoffman stood off by himself, glaring at Maddox and avoiding looking anywhere else.

Matthews wasn’t going to worry too much about it. He and Ally said their goodbyes and left them alone to sort out whatever it was they needed sorting out.

Toni Rosello

“Ol’ Daft,” Toni Rosello called for his bodyguard as he leaned back into the buttery soft leather of his office chair. His cigar was already halfway through. He patted the ashes into his crystal ashtray and took another puff as he licked his lips to taste the honey.

He imagined a special little redhead rubbing her ass on his lap while running her tongue over the same lips. He let out a frustrated puff of smoke and scratched his eyebrow with his thumb. “Fuck, the last one didn’t last long.”

He was used to getting whatever he wanted. Women, especially, were not difficult. Most responded to green. Another healthy amount were attracted to power. With this one, she was a wild mare that wouldn’t break. It only made her more appealing to him. So he figured he’d go do the gentlemanly thing and wait.

After all, he was a gentleman.

But the gentlemanly tokens of his affection weren’t working. She had yet to respond to any of his letters. The pictures didn’t seem to make her eager to dial his number and agree to dinner. He was considering escalating.

But then again, he liked making himself wait. It made the reward much sweeter when he finally got what he wanted.

And he was used to getting everything he wanted.

“Yes, sir?” Olaf, the big oaf of a man, walked in, pinstriped suit only emphasizing how much fabric was needed to clothe the ape.

“Get me a florist. I want the biggest bouquet of red roses sent to Metropolitan Police. Oh,” he puffed and puffed, “And find me one of them - what the hell are they? Arachnologists?”

“Uh, yes, sir. A rack?"

"Arachnologist, you idiot. Spider scientist. Find me one."

"Yes, sir. And the roses... for the same person you had me mail to before?”

“What do you think?” He turned his eyes to the loyal giant. A part of him resented his size. He didnt like feeling small. It was one of his pet peeves. But the man behaved and he was reasonable. There were plenty of fun toys to play with. Olaf still had his purpose.

“Yes?” The man looked confused. Maybe a little nervous. This was good. Fear was his greatest asset. Fear made him what he was.

“Good man. Now get out.”

Olaf disappeared as quickly as he had entered. Rosello was left alone again, in his great room of the various exotic animals he had shot whenever he went on African safaris. He was particlarly fond of the elephant head that was mounted over his fireplace.

The polar bear rug that clashed with it merely boasted his wealth. That particular hunt had been too boring. A female trying to guard her young. Boring.

He had something new to hunt. Someone who didn’t seem interested to play games with him. Everyone can be manipulated. He thought long and hard, taking his remote control and flipping on his big screen to the news. He’d either find something inspiring and distracting to take his mind off his blue balls or he’d finally get around to finding exactly what motivated Red.

He had been so disappointed when he found her only family was currently a vegetable, molding in some hospital she never visited. But her cold bloodedness had surprised him. He had always figured she was Daddy’s Little Girl. He looked forward to learning all about it.

He needed to see her. The photos he had the private investigator take were rarely more than her going to work.

The speaker on his desk pinged. “Yeah?” He pressed the button. Finally. Something new.

“The PI is here.”

“Send him in.”

The weasel of a man had a wide nose and a goatee that Rosello wanted to take some pliers and jerk off the guy’s chin. The man kept eye contact, though, which was impressive. “Mr. Rosello, this past week’s surveillance.” He placed a thick packet of documents on the desk.

When he flipped through the first pages, he let out a pleased noise. “Ah, excellent.” Red, dressed like a belle at the ball, looking off in the distance. He appreciated how the photos had been developed with color. He flipped through more, pausing at the full body shot of her in some cherry toned dress that showed off enough for him to no longer need to imagine and his dick itched.

“When was this?” He held his new favorite picture for the guy to see.

“Sunday evening. She was with two federal agents and a colleague.”

“Hoffman?” He recalled, vaguely, that he had met with Markie-boy, but hadn’t expected him to be able to get around soon after.

“No. Detective Allison Kerry.”

“Ah, Matthews’ broad.” He let out a loud laugh, remembering that those two were pretty close for partners. “What was the occasion?”

“Not sure. Seemed like a date. But the target left early, escorted by one of the feds to Hoffman’s apartment.”

“Oh?” He rubbed his chin, displeased by this news. “Interesting.” He hadn’t considered Markie-boy to be shagging up with Red. But this made things significantly easier for him if this was true, though he didn’t want to risk losing his best MPD plug if it turned out she gave absolutely no shits for the big lug.

He sighed again, then giggled to himself. Oh, this is getting interesting. How fun.

“Olaf,” he yelled out, not bothering with his intercom.

The man obediently entered. “Yes, sir?”

“Find me another one. Someone a bit more fiesty. The last one cried too much.”

“Yes, sir.”

Angelina Hoffman

It had been a long day.

She tried to pretend that the plainclothesman wasn’t there. She walked fast, her snowboots crunching on patches of ice while the man’s dress shoes clicked closely behind her. The man’s name was Gibson. Matt Gibson. He looked young and she had never met him prior to that week, when Will had come by with him to explain his presence.

She didn’t like it, having someone she didn’t know follow her. She had gone to Dillon’s and back and someone with a suit was always there. It was supposed to make her feel safe. It just gave her a migraine and the heavy feeling of being a nuisance for taking up the MPD’s time.

There were many faces she was now growing accustomed to. She had recognized most of them from past potlucks, save for today’s man and another who went by Fisk. She wouldn’t have minded so much, but today’s escort seemed so… glum. He barely said a word. He looked very young, too young to already have that permanent frown on his face.

When she first got ready for her shift, she had brought down some coffee and a cider donut for him and he hardly responded besides taking the brown paper bag. He seemed to just take himself so seriously. He was polite. But there was little beyond him nodding in her direction when they locked eyes. But at least Ally and Will would be part of the rotation. Mark had insisted she play ball with them but didn’t give much on why he wasn’t going to be one of the patrolmen.

She just didn’t understand why her brother couldn’t be part of her bodyguard entourage. It certainly would have made things a bit easier.

She stretched her arms, repositioned her purse, and made her way down Michigan Avenue, leisurely looking at the various window displays. She wanted to go in but the rules had been clear. She needed to go to work. Go home. And only run errands after informing Will or anyone on the team.

Her thoughts wandered onto Peter and wondered if he felt as annoyed about the whole situation as she did. Peter’s shadow today was Fisk, who was parked in an unmarked car right outside their apartment building. Because Peter didn’t work at the moment, he was essentially under house arrest. He was taking the situation much better than she was, playing video games in the same pajamas he’d worn since Tuesday and cleaning up the apartment in between.

She didn’t mind, though. She wanted him home to spend as much time with her as possible before he had to leave. He was about to enlist and ship off to boot camp. He would be safe and constantly monitored after that. There was little likelihood that any mob bosses would dare try to trespass onto a military base and hurt him once he shipped off. At least, that’s what the MPD said.

This helped, knowing he was only weeks away from ensured safety. Her situation, though, was looking bleak. Will had even suggested a safehouse, which she would absolutely not do. The thought of having to simply disappear just made her more depressed.

It had been a busy day in the kitchen. She had slipped into the big pot of the soup of the day, causing a typhoon of orange minestrone all over the tiles. Her head chef had been particularly nasty about it. She wanted more than anything to quit but she was so close in her savings to finally afford to start her bistro. So close. She just needed to suck it up a little bit more.

And then her wedding. God. She was already behind on invitations - she still needed to mail them out. And then there was reserving the venue - she was thinking of this historical ballroom or maybe go for something a bit more hip and modern, like the former industrial steel factory to help save some money. And then...

She was light headed. She stopped to lean against the nearest wall, digging in her purse to get her water bottle. Working in the kitchen was sweaty work and the neverending rush that day left her with no opportunity for a break. She hadn’t remembered the last time that day she had remembered to drink any water.

“You all right?” It was Detective Gibson, steel gazed and thin lipped.

“Yes. Sorry, just dizzy.” She pushed herself off the wall and steadied herself.

Gibson put a hand on her shoulder. “We can have a seat real quick,” he pointed to the nearest coffee shop, “while you get your bearings.” He let her hold onto him as he steered them into the nearest chain cafe, the smell of roasted beans tickling her nose. The heat was nice on her face.

She sat in the nearest chair and let out a long breath. “Thanks.”

“Want something?” Gibson scratched his nose and looked around again, always alert. “It’s on me.”

“Coffee,” she straightened up, sipping her water and rubbing her forehead. She should have brought some aspirin. Her phone was ringing. Gibson was gone. She flipped her phone open. “Hello?”

“Hey, Ange,” Peter’s voice came through, relief in his voice. “Glad you’re safe.”

“Did something happen?” She straightened up, pressing the phone tighter to hear over the roaring of a blender.

“Just checking in.” Peter was always a worrier but after Mark had made that late night phone call he was a bundle of nerves. Her heart was breaking, seeing her fiance so anxious and paranoid. He had begun getting nightmares, tossing and turning at night.

“I’m almost home. We just went to get some coffee. I needed to sit down.”

“Long day?”

“Yeah. How about you?”

“It’s been quiet, just been working out.” There was a bubbling in his voice, like water about to boil. “M-maybe we can take that vacation? Leave town?”

She pondered this, the offer more tempting after the crumby day she had. “How about we talk about it when I get home.”

“Great. Get home safe. I love you.”

“I love you too.” Angelina hung up as Gibson returned with two styrofoam cups in hand, placing hers in front of her. “Thanks.”

“Don’t mention it. I didn’t thank you for this morning. I appreciate it.” He spoke slow and easy, his voice holding a hint of a southern accent. Gibson continued avoiding her eyes and she finally accepted this was how it was going to be.

Can’t get along with everyone. She kept a pleasant expression, enjoying the warmth of the drink and sipping the scalding liquid.

Gibson’s hand flew over and tapped the side of her arm, making her jump. “Stay very calm. But I think we have company.”

This made her heart race and she did everything she could not to suddenly leap to her feet and begin darting her eyes around the cafe. “Where?”

“Don’t be so obvious. Your nine o’clock. Two guys, look like they’re not part of the upper west side crowd. And they’re mean mugging us good.” He opened his to-go cup and poured some sugar packets in it while adding, “we’ll just sit tight for a little bit. See if they’ll leave. If not, I’ll call for backup.”

Angelina swallowed and tried to look as oblivious as she could but she couldn’t help but cross her legs and shrink into her seat. Her vision fluttered briefly, from Gibson to her left where she saw the two rough looking men that were both sitting and glaring at her. She looked over to the barista and the other patrons, all who didn’t seem too interested in the strange hulking figures that were perched right by the exit.

She and Gibson remained there for over an hour, both finishing their drinks. Her knee was starting to shake, bobbing up and down. Maybe it was from the caffeine. Maybe it was from the anxiety she felt from feeling the penetrating eye daggers directed at her from across the room. Gibson remained calm, the bored expression plastered as he checked his watch.

“All right. I’m calling it in.” He picked up his phone. “Hey. I need a ten seventy five at The Beanery on Caroline Street, off of 10th street. We have two males, caucasian, approximately six foot four and five foot ten. One is wearing a denim black jacket and blue jeans with a white shirt. The other is wearing a leather jacket, blue jeans and a black shirt. Copy.” He hung up and turned to her. “Don’t worry, Ms. Hoffman, we’ve got some people on the way.”

“Thanks,” she whispered back, hands fidgeting as she pressed them together and in her lap.

“He’s probably just testing the waters,” Gibson leaned forward and finally turned to her. “Nothing bad’s going to happen on my watch, missy, promise you that.”

“I don’t understand. Why is this guy going through all this trouble,” she blew out exasperated air, turning her body to put her back to the men. Gibson kept his face and torso directly facing them. “I wish all of this would end.”

“We’re working on it. It’ll be over soon,” He grimaced awkwardly, trying to give one of those smiles that were more cringe cheek pulls than a warm upturned mouth. He cleared his throat and they resumed silence.

After long minutes, the sound of sirens roared in the distance.

The two men looked to each other before getting to their feet and leaving their table. They left the coffee shop with one more intimidating stare down, their backs disappearing once they exited the door and rounded the corner.

A squad car with its bright blue and red lights filled her with relief. Her shoulders sagged. Two uniforms came out, hands on their guns, as they entered the coffee shop.

“Ms. Hoffman, let’s get you in the car. The boys will take us to your place.”

She was placed in the back of the squad car, Gibson at her right. All she wanted was to take a bath, drink some wine, and cuddle on the couch with Peter. She fought the water that seemed to collect in the corner of her eyes, brushing them briefly with the back of her hand as she kept herself staring intently out of the window, hoping the officers didn’t see.

Wilhelmina Maddox

She kept her eyes straight ahead as Hoffman drove them to the latest crime scene. It was a cloudy day. The overhead was so thick and gray, it felt like it was late at night. It wasn’t quite spring yet and the neverending murkiness of the city seemed to want to hold onto the bitter cold for as long as possible. She could still see her breath when she walked outside.

She was getting real tired of having to bundle up and wear her boots.

The morning had been icy, as well. She had literally said nothing that entire day. Neither had her partner, who seemed to be perfectly fine with reciprocating her silent treatment. They still hadn’t gotten past the last time they sparred, Hoffman’s sudden frustration with her ability to defend herself confusing and unneeded.

He practically accused her of wanting Frank to hurt her. Going on about how, if she could flip and maneuver out of his attacks, then Frank should have been easy to not let do the things that had been done. It was just hurtful. Disrespectful. Rude. Ugh. The barrage of irritating thoughts made her fold her arms and huff out audibly. She leaned her head back into the head rest, chewing the inside of her cheek.

And the audacity he had to think he was in the right in this argument was just plain frustrating.

She briefly took in his profile as he drove before returning to admiring the graffiti they whizzed by. They were heading to the Crossroads, a den infamous for addicts to ride out their back alley highs and find the next fix. The entire time, he kept his eyes on the road, pretending she wasn’t even there.

She wondered how things got this awkward. Everything had been just dandy before their latest fight. She didn’t get why the man who would hold her while she fell asleep would go off on her not putting up more of a fight from historic trauma. The mixed messages were driving her nuts.

This is for the best. We were getting too personal. This is what happens when you get too personal.

He maintained his stone-like expression, almost robotic, as he pulled the car into one of the alleys to shortcut their way through one of the nicer neighborhoods. Normally, when he drove, she put on some music to help fill in the noise. Today, she stubbornly refused. And he seemed perfectly fine with it, which just pissed her off even more.

She was going to spend this lunch break beating the shit out of the gym punching bag. At the end of the day, she was scheduled to stake out Angie’s place along with Sing, relieving Allison and Matthews. She’d talk shop with Sing and hopefully make some progress with getting Angie and Peter off of Rosello’s radar.

Hoffman parallel parked and she got out as soon as he silenced the engine. She didn’t bother waiting for him as she bee-lined to the crime scene, seeing Forensics already flashing their cameras. The familiar stink of decay and blood made her steel her stomach as she ducked under the yellow tape and held up the badge chained around her neck when the patrolman raised his eyebrow at her approach.

“Detective Maddox,” It was Daniel Rigg, approaching her along with Matthew Gibson. She hadn’t realized Gibson was on duty, having not seen him in his uniform before. She didn't envy being a rookie.

“Officer Rigg. Officer Gibson.” She shook both their hands.

“What’s he doing here?” Gibson nodded over to her back, while Hoffman was strolling up to them.

“We just got called in. Why?” She had her hands on her hips while staring up at Gibson. He seemed like good people, from what little interaction she had with him when moonlighting the Rosello case. He was by the book, straight laced, and so uptight his face never looked like he was in a fun mood. He barely spoke two words to her.

“He should head back. It’s likely a Rosello case.”

“How do you know?”

Rigg and Gibson exchanged looks. Neither would meet her penetrating stare. “Maybe,” Gibson added, “you should go too. We’ll call in Kerry and Matthews.”

“They’re currently on duty over at Angelina Hoffman’s.”

“Then call Sing and Tapp.”

“Both are currently out on the field too, looking into some gang war that's starting up. And Fisk is on emergency leave. I’m all you got right now.”

Again, the two exchanged looks. She was already pissed off. Now she was just getting furious. “Boys?” She hated being kept out of the loop. “What are you hiding?”

“Nothing.” Rigg cleared his throat while staring over her head. She looked over at Hoffman who wouldn’t give her any attention.

“Then let’s get to work.”

Gibson put a hand on her arm. “Maddox. A word?” She noticed he had kind brown eyes, the warmth giving her sudden flashbacks of her brother. Gibson steered her off to the side, out of earshot from the other two men. “There’s one thing we’ve been waiting for the right time to tell you about.”

“Yeah?” She pulled from his gentle grip and folded her arms. “What?”

“There’s been a notable victim profile of the latest serial killings. They fit Rosello’s M.O. with the sexual trauma, time duration of torture, and method of execution.”

“What’s the profile?”

Gibson swallowed, suddenly looking so much younger. He was young. Younger than her, younger than Sing even. He looked as though he wanted nothing more than to not be there at that moment. “Female. Late teens to early thirties. All with… features that resemble - fuck,” he lifted his eight point hat and scratched his buzz cut with his thumb, “-they look like you, Maddox. That’s what Tapp and Kerry said, at least.”

“Why wasn’t I informed of this theory?”

“Shit, Maddox, you know impartiality is one thing we all need. They’re already talking about having you removed from the case.”

“Who, Tapp?”

“Grissom.”

“Shit.”

“Yeah. Tapp’s fighting for you, though. Frankly, it’s because,” he squinted, “if he’s motivated by some weird obsession with you it could be used to our advantage.”

“I agree.” Will shot him a smile, knowing it looks harsh and ready for a fight. “I’m down for whatever’s needed. Hell, use me as bait. Maybe I can wear a wire and just walk up to him.”

“Yeah. Huh. Maybe you should be talking to the higher ups. After all,” he gestured to his navy blue dress shirt and the brass badge, the collar devices marking his lower rank, “I’m still just a patrolman. Fuck, I hate these things.” He cracked a grin, “Half the reason I joined the task force was just to wear civvies.” He pulled at his sleeve, the gesture taking her to when she was a kid.

Halloween. Bram went as a policeman. I went as a ballerina. The image hit her but just didn’t fit right. She couldn’t focus her memory to recall what her little brother looked like. And that hit her hard. The photos. They’re still at Frank’s. She blinked, returning to reality. Smiling, sharing a sympathetic nod, she punched him playfully. “Keep being such a go-getter, and you’ll probably get promoted before you know it.”

“Yeah, well, I’m trying. Thanks, Mom.” Gibson laughed and she decided that he was on her whitelist. “So… what are we going to do about this? Hoffman should probably leave?”

She bit her lip, glancing back at the two men who seemed to be having a grand old time talking sports. Or whatever. “We know for sure it’s Rosello?”

“From what I’ve seen, yeah.”

“All right. Then I guess I’ll have to send him home.” She was going to have to break the silent treatment first, which the petty side of her didn’t want to do. She swallowed her pride.

The two of them went over to the other side of the crime scene where Hoffman and Rigg were leaning against the bricks. Rigg looked notably less friendly while Hoffman kept his back to the two of them.

“Hoffman.” She called out to him. He barely turned to her in acknowledgement. “You can head back to the station.”

He finally gave her his undivided attention, blue eyes like arctic water pouring over her. She resisted the urge to shiver. “Whose orders?”

“Protocol,” she responded, refusing to back down. She took a step forward to the towering man. “This is a Rosello case.”

“And?”

“And you know damn well what that means.” She flashed to Gibson and Rigg. “Do you two mind?” The uniformed officers both slunk away, giving her some privacy as she prepared to rip into her partner. “Hoffman. Stop this.”

“Stop what?”

She pressed her finger to her temple, letting out a sigh. “This. Fuck. What’s with you?”

“Maybe I’m just trying to investigate the case. I’m not the one getting cozy with the fresh meat in this precinct.”

Her jaw dropped slightly. “What the fuck, Hoffman?” He was silent, glaring at her. She looked up to the black clouds and prayed for lightning to just take her out of her misery. “What do you want from me? An apology?”

“That’d be a start.”

She fumed and glowered, wanting more than anything to smack him. “And I’m guessing I’m the only one who should say they’re sorry. You know, I’m not the one that insinuated I deserved what happened to me.”

“You are perfectly capable of defending yourself. And you didn’t. All those times I saw you banged up. Fucking black and blue. You just stood there and took it. I don’t understand that.”

“Maybe because you’ve never loved anyone that much.” Her voice was wavering, rising and lowering like a rollercoaster of pitch. She knew that was below the belt. But her heart felt raw and he only made the pain worse. Her eyes felt damp so she turned her head. “Stop. Please. Let’s just not talk about this anymore. Go back to the station. Hell, take the rest of the day off, I don’t care. But you can’t be here. Okay?”

“Will,” His tone had gone gentler, “Hey -”

“No. Go. Now. Or I’m reporting you for compromising the crime scene. I'll fucking bring in IA. I'm not playing.” She turned to leave when the sound of gunshots exploded in her head and made her hand fly to her hip. She felt his strong hands pull her and shove her against the wall, behind a dumpster.

She dug her heels into the pavement, squatting behind the rough metal as Hoffman pulled out his gun and was kneeling down beside her. Adrenaline kicked in. She was on high alert, scanning the area.

Every person on the scene had drawn their weapons, hunched behind their squad cars or behind any reliable boundary.

“Fucking Crossroads,” she heard one guy spit.

A walkie-talkie broke in the tense environment. “We need a sweep of the area. Found a one thirty four. Who the fuck was supposed to sweep the scene?”

She saw as Rigg and Gibson, weapons extended, went into one of the buildings. She turned to Hoffman. “Might as well help,” she stood up and began checking her surroundings, keeping her finger just outside the trigger guard as Hoffman paralleled her.

“Will. Stick with westside. I’ll go east.” He nodded to the right where Gibson was headed.

She made her way to the leftmost region where the majority of officers had gathered. She knew it was the relatively safer area but she checked every corner, every potential hiding spot for hostiles.

They cleared the area and she finally felt safe to put away her weapon. Hoffman and Gibson were still missing, along with a few of their uniforms. Rigg had returned, joining her as she leaned against a squad car.

“Never a dull day out here,” Rigg muttered.

“You telling me.” She folded her arms and sighed. She turned to the man, considering him. “Maybe you can talk some sense into Hoffman. You two seem close.”

Rigg gave her a wary look. “About what?”

“He needs to head back to the station after this blows over. He can’t work this case if it’s Rosello related. Do you mind?”

Rigg smirked, “I ain’t telling him shit. He knows what he needs to do.”

She rolled her eyes. “Great. Perfect.”

“Maybe you should just trust him. The man gets results.”

She shook her head, aware that this officer had no fucking clue how messy and complicated this situation was. She wasn’t sure if he was cleared to be privy to it. She kept her mouth shut and stared straight ahead.

Several more gunshots were heard. Echoes in the distance. A few more officers were running towards the scene, rewithdrawing their pistols and heading to where Hoffman and Gibson had gone. Her heart sank and she craned her neck in hopes of seeing something to put her worries at ease.

Sudden panic ran through her like blades. She pushed off the car and jogged over to join the men. Her hand was at her waist.

Turning a few corners, jumping over litter and overturned steel barrels, she finally reached where most of her colleagues had gathered. Gibson’s face was splattered in blood. He was shaking like a leaf. Hoffman looked fine. Almost happy.

She let out a sigh of relief, clasping her holster and relaxing her shoulders.

One of the burly men was smacking Hoffman on the back and letting out a triumphant roar.

There was a man laying in a pool of blood at their feet, several bullet wounds in his back. One of the uniforms kicked him and let out a laugh. Will approached the group.

“You two all right?” She looked from Hoffman to Gibson. “Matt?” She put a hand on his arm and he jumped, looking up at her. The warm boyish glint was gone, replaced with a hollow shadow. “Matt, let’s get you cleaned up.” She shot Hoffman a relieved look but flinched. He looked high. “How about you, Mark?”

He blinked, then smirked. “We’re fine. Got the bastard just in time.” Something felt off. There was an intense energy she practically tasted. He felt almost hostile, despite the pleased smile he was flashing her.

“Okay. Maybe you should sit tight. I want to talk to you in a second.” She pulled Gibson from the group while some of the eavesdroppers let out a whistle and an ‘oooh you’re in trouble, Hoffman’. She’d normally be annoyed by this, but the relief that no one was hurt let her overlook this. “Did anyone call for medical? And the coroner?”

Silence.

“Someone call medical response. Please.” She called over her shoulder. “Come on, Matt.” She took him away from the cajoling knuckle draggers and found a crate off to the side. “Have a seat. There you go.” She could feel his arms trembling violently. He slumped down, staring at his feet. “Matt?”

He looked up at her. “Hoffman killed him.”

“I see. What happened?”

“The guy got the drop on me. Took my gun. I thought I was done for.” He wiped some of the blood off of his forehead, looking at his now soiled hands. “But Hoffman was there. The guy-,” And then he looked up at her, fearful. “He just killed him.”

Will listened to this, not sure if she understood. “Hoffman saved you.”

“Yes. No. The guy had his hands in the air. He shot him.” He blinked then shook his head. “Fuck. It happened so fast.”

Will raised an eyebrow. “Hey. Everything’s okay. You’re okay. Come on, let’s get you out of here.”

His hand reached out, pulled at her coat sleeve. “Maddox. He didn’t need to shoot him.” His voice was strained. “He didn’t need to.”

She bit her lip. He was in shock. The sound of the ambulance siren getting louder was comforting. “You’re safe, Matt. Come on, let’s get you checked out.”

“You’re not listening.” His grip on her arm was tight. His face contorted with indignant anger. “He shot that man in cold blood.”

Will felt a frigid breeze blow past them, making the hairs on the back of her neck stand up. She looked over to Hoffman, who had been staring right at her. She couldn’t read him. “All right. Let’s figure it out when we get back to the station. Come on.”

She took Gibson back to the streets where Rigg was standing by his squad car. “Rigg. Look after Gibson.” An ambulance was approaching, the lights flashing. “After he gets looked over by the paramedics, take him home.”

“What are you gonna do?”

“Investigate the original crime scene,” she tucked a red curl behind her ear. “Where is the body?”

Rigg pointed off towards where a lone officer guarded more yellow tape. She went off, hoping she’d look over everything before Hoffman got back and tried to intervene. If she could examine the crime scene while he was busy, she’d be able to avoid any more attitude from him.

The chaos was a godsend, in a way. No matter how pissed she was at her partner, she wanted him free of Rosello’s influence. Recalling that calloused and malicious smile he had given her, she felt reinforced in her motivations to get him the hell away from that mob bastard.Before he was tainted any further.

“Officer,” she nodded to the guard as she went under the yellow tape and looked down at the white chalk lines tracing the corpse. She went numb.

The woman was young. Looked like a college student. She had long, auburn hair and plenty of freckles. There was a notable resemblance that she couldn’t deny. The facial shape, proportions, it felt uncanny. Walking around the woman’s splayed limbs, Will forced herself not to mind her nakedness. But she did force herself to face the cruelty.

The woman’s breasts had been sliced off.

That was the first searing scar that was burned into her brain as she scanned the other features of the deceased. Her fingers had been broken in several joints. One of her ankles had been bent, her foot in a direction it was never meant to go.

There was gore running down her inner thighs.

She let out a slow breath, feeling fresh fear and wanting more than anything to just close her eyes and disappear.

This was one of those cases that made her feel out of her element. But she pressed on. As she continued examining the area, she nodded to the woman’s earlobe. An earring was the only article of clothing still on her. It looked familiar.

“I need some gloves and an evidence bag.” She turned to her only company, who knelt by one of the forensic officers’ packs and pulled out the supplies.

She removed the earring off the woman’s lobes, pulling it up to the lighting fixtures placed around the crime scene. And she almost dropped it when she realized where she recognized the white gold leaves and the three emerald marquise cut stones. Handed down, mother to daughter for generations.

She bagged the earring, the rushing sound of her heart pounding under her skull. “This needs to be dusted for prints and analyzed.” She handed it to the officer, already knowing she was likely stepping down from this investigation. They were always kept in a special mini drawer in the jewelry box. She was suddenly dizzy.

“Will,” Hoffman was there all of a sudden. “What did you find?” She walked by him, wanting to get some space. Some fresh air. She just needed to sit down for a moment.

She stood by a wall and held herself up, breathing quick and heavy. She squatted with her back to the bricks, looking up at the charcoal sky.

“Will,” he was there. Concerned. “Talk to me.” He was squatting beside her, big hand on her shoulder.

She looked up at him, wide eyed. “The victim was wearing my earring.”

Chapter 11: Pre-Saw: Poutine and Sing

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

He drove her back to the station. Will was no longer sulking nor pointedly ignoring him like that morning. He wished she would. Instead, her face was haunted as she stared straight ahead.

He had expected her to accost him with probing questions about what happened with Gibson. He had braced himself to relay a story to her to discredit the rookie. He had not expected to see her go into shock.

The victim had resembled her, as did the previous bodies that Rosello left them. This was exactly why he had not intended to leave her alone at the crime scene. He had tried to protect her from seeing Rosello’s work for as long as he could, especially because the fucker was getting more creative in his own twisted way.

And she treated him like the bad guy, as if he didn’t have her best interests at heart. She had proven to him that she did not give a damn about her own well-being, so he was going to assume that responsibility. He needed to explain this to her. He wanted her to understand.

All he could do was drive her away. Make her hate him. They were getting too close and Rosello was starting to notice. This was for her own good.

And then that fucking junkie came out of nowhere, complicating things. He had to go save some idiot who couldn’t maintain positive control of his fucking weapon.

Will seemed to be fond of the kid. He didn’t like the shrimp much but he wasn’t going to just let one of their own get shot with his own gun. He taught him a valuable lesson. Shoot first. Because those fucks certainly would if given the chance. Besides, it was always good to have someone inside of the task force that owed him. Big.

They returned to the station as though they had just left a funeral, solemn and bleak. He kept watching her from behind, following her as she walked up the stairs and to their desks. She hesitated and when he followed her gaze he felt fresh anger shoot up his throat. He tightened his hands into fists, squeezing hard.

Red roses, tons of them, were arranged in a vase on her desk. It took up most of the real estate. She approached them with a healthy skepticism, walking around her desk and taking in the bouquet. An envelope was nestled in between the flowers. To Red. He recognized the handwriting and instinctively grabbed her wrist when she reached for the paper.

They stood there, ignoring the men walking by who cast curious glances. Some even looked like they were amused. It must have been a funny sight, him standing there like a fool with his partner looking pissed over a flashy romantic gesture. Fucking perfect.

She turned on him. “What do you think you’re doing?” There was fresh anger in those orange eyes, full of distrust at him.

“Careful. You don’t know what he did to them.”

“How did they get here?” She sounded accusatory and she jerked her wrist out of his grasp. He let her go, shame burning his neck and cheeks.

“I don’t know.”

“Yeah,” she nodded, wary and disbelieving. “I don’t know anymore either.” She took the envelope, breaking the seal and pulling out the note.

And then he saw something quickly crawl over the sleeve of her shirt. Something shapely. Black and shiny. With long pointed legs. He slapped at it without thinking.

“What the fuck, Mark!” She snapped but he pushed her back hard. She flew backward and stumbled.

“Get the fuck back!” He grabbed the phone on his desk and slammed it hard on the creature. He heard the pop and crush, pulling back to see gelatinous goo and curled spider legs. There was a hint of red and he turned to her. “Black widow spiders.”

“What-,” and then she gasped and pointed at her desk. He turned again, seeing another with its bright red hourglass shining up at him like a bullseye. He slammed downwards with his phone, not caring if he broke it.

“Holy shit!” One of the nearby detectives had witnessed the action and upon approaching closer, saw the arachnids. More were starting to come out of the vase, crawling over the roses and down the sides of the glass. On their desks.

Another voice yelled out in the distance, but he didn't register over the pounding of his pulse in his head.

He kept killing them. He heard Will and other people behind him, shooing curious onlookers away.

“Mark!” Will’s voice called him and he felt her tug at his suspenders from behind, pulling him back. “We’re evacuating. Grissom’s orders.”

Steven Sing

One minute, he was fetching coffee for Tapp and himself. He was listening to the radio, hearing the latest scores for the Patriots and the Steelers’ game. He was thrilled to hear the Steelers were winning, having been born and raised in Pittsburgh until he went to college.

And then, the next thing he knew, he was being rushed out of the break room to the sound of screams and panic. Someone had pulled the fire alarm. But word passed around in the hallway that this wasn’t some fire.

Apparently, there were spiders? He didn’t know it was Halloween. Last he checked, it was December. He was just glad he had kept his coat on when he joined the crowd in the winter air. He balanced a coffee mug in each hand, planning on still making his delivery despite the melodrama of the day.

They all mustered outside, everyone cold and shivering. He walked by Internal Affairs Division, looking for Homicides to muster with Grissom. Sipping his steaming cup and gingerly pushing through his colleagues, he finally recognized some friendly faces.

There was some shouting in one section of the parking lot where he got a glimpse of his partner and Matthews, who were observing some commotion. As he got closer the yelling grew until he realized it was Maddox and Hoffman having a loud disagreement in front of the entire department.

Well, this can’t be good.

He raised an eyebrow when he saw Maddox shove upwards angrily at Hoffman, not quite pushing him but the effort was obvious. He grabbed her wrists and looked ready to shake her.

“Hey!” He called out and held out his occupied hand. “Maddox, I’ve got that coffee you wanted!” Completely random, but it worked. The two of them stopped to turn their heads in confusion, staring at him as he beamed back. “Remember?” He held out the spare cup, “You wanted us to talk shop once I got back. You ready to get to work?”

He watched as she jerked her wrists out of Hoffman’s grip, though he held onto one of them until Matthews appeared and put a hand on the big guy’s shoulders. Good on you, Eric. The two needed to be separated before they ended up causing a scene and getting the entire division screwed.

Maddox didn’t say anything as she brushed by him and stormed in one direction. He played it off as he stayed close to her heels, lazily sipping his joe in between strides until they were as far from their muster location. They could still see and hear their supervisor when he finally showed up, glasses fogged and cheeks red with rage. Turning from Grissom, Sing studied Maddox. Her breathing was erratic, shown by the clouds pouring past her lips as she fumed.

“Here. This will help.” He held out the cup. “Better drink it fast, it’s already lukewarm.” She took it, avoiding his eyes. He knew she was crying but he pretended to not notice. He continued noisily slurping coffee and exchanged glances with Tapp. Matthews had pulled Hoffman in the opposite direction they had gone, a cigarette in his mouth while talking to his friend.

He noticed her shoulders were twitching, her head bowed in shame. There were curious stares all around them, probably gawking at the soap opera unfolding. She finally took a drink. “Thanks, Steven.”

“Any time, Mad Max.”

She let out a huff. “You too?”

He smirked. “What? It’s not the worst nickname Eric has come up with.”

“Uh-huh.” She had thrown a glance back in her partner’s direction, pain in her face. “You know, Tapp already got a visual on us. We could probably go to lunch until all this blows over. Though it sounds like we need an exterminator?”

She shook her head, looking back at the station’s doors. “Rosello sent poisonous spiders our way.” She swallowed. “Unfucking believable. And it's all my fault. That's what everyone's going to say.”

He bit his lip. “Technically, I think they’re venomous.” She blinked, looked at him carefully, and punched him in the arm hard. He couldn’t help it. He laughed, his arm stinging.

“I never knew you were such a pain.”

“Yeah, well, I'm still pretty new. Come on, let’s go to the Grill. I need some poutine and I think you need to take the rest of the day off.” He knew it wasn’t the time or place to bring in all the other shit that was going on. The latest victims would be a lot to unpack over lunch, if she was ready to hear all that.

“You know, that sounds perfect right now.” Newfound fury in her voice, she threw back the last of the coffee. “Yeah. Let’s get out of here. I’m fucking done with today. I’m fucking done with everything.” She kept looking over at Hoffman, like a forlorn puppy dog.

He nodded, taking the ceramic mug from her hands and passing them to the nearest rookie. “Sweet. You wanna drive?”

He had been counting on her cheering up at this. “Yes.”

She was an absolute terror on the road. He thought his mother was nuts, often putting mascara on while steering with her knees on the highway. But Maddox, thankfully, had her hands on the wheel while whizzing in between cars and narrow alleys like water siphoning through rocks.

He also learned that she liked to talk when she was angry. He had not expected her to just unload but here they were, and there was a lot to absorb.

“And can you believe that he thinks it’s my fault because I should have just judo flipped Frank day one? Can you?” She turned to him as she stopped at a redlight, sighing while inching the car on the back bumper of the vehicle in front of them.

“Definitely a dick move.” Sing kept his eyes straight ahead, so he could witness his own death directly if this was the day. “I don’t know Hoffman too well but it doesn’t surprise me. He kind of comes off as a bit of a black and white kind of guy.”

“Really.” She floored it when the lights went green, going around the car in front of them before the driver knew what happened. “Even after this shit? With Rosello?”

“Honestly?” He gasped when she sharply turned, the wheels squealing as they spun around the corner on black ice. She managed to not go off the curb and returned to her lane. “Yeah!” He had flinched when she finally slid into a parking spot, their journey finally over. His heart was racing and he trembled as he got out of the car.

“Well, he’s a hypocrite.”

“Nobody’s perfect, Maddox,” Sing wanted to kiss the concrete but kept his composure as they walked to the restaurant. “But we did warn you about him.”

“Yep. You did. I didn’t listen.” She pulled her red curls back, nostrils flared. “I guess this is just what I deserve.”

“Well now,” Sing held the door open for her and she let him, “When I first came onto the force, I wouldn’t have trusted Hoffman as far as I could throw him. But I wouldn’t discount your judgment. You’ve always stood up for him. What happened back there? If you don’t mind me asking.”

They found a corner table, out of the way but with a good view of the interior. A waitress already left them drinks and menus.

“Well.” She bit her lip, “I know he’s reporting everything he knows to Rosello. And someone had to bring that - fucking bouquet of spiders on my desk. I just assumed it was him.”

“Wasn’t he with you all day?”

“Yes.” She sounded begrudging. Embarrassed. “I realized that. Just now.” She pressed her fingers against her temples and let out a low groan. “Can today just get any better than it already has?”

Sing nodded sympathetically. “Long day?”

“Well, considering that I’ve been kept in the dark on recent events pertaining to this case? And the fact that the latest victim I examined this morning was wearing my mother’s earrings while my partner is being a pain in the ass, I’d say it’s been a lot to chew.”

Sing whistled low. “So the cat’s out of the bag.”

“Yeah. Oh, thanks for that, by the way. Appreciate not being informed that Rosello has explicitly been murdering all of my doppelgangers in the city.”

“Well, it’s not just you he’s been basing his victims on. There was the triple homicide last week. But most of the victims were redheads.”

“Please. Just tell me straight. I’m so sick of not being trusted to handle this.”

“It’s not that we don’t trust you, Maddox,” Sing leaned forward, whispering, “it’s literally the opposite. We don’t want you forced off the task force. Grissom’s not liking this one bit. He’s worried you’re going to end up in one of the fridges down in the basement with all the others. Tapp has had to pull some weight to keep the women onboard. You, Ally, and Perez are targets to this creep. The guy’s not just a misogynist. He’s depraved. And he’s now got you on his most wanted list. It’s why we’re suddenly having self-defense training.”

The waitress appeared, pausing from the conversation. “I can come back later?”

“No, it’s fine.” Sing turned to her. “I’ll have the swiss melt and poutine.”

“Tuna salad sandwich.”

The waitress nodded, taking their menus and retreating. He craved a beer. Maybe next time. He and Maddox had a long night ahead of them for their shift for Angelina Hoffman’s patrol.

The silence felt uncomfortable and she spoke up first. “I think I should reach out to Rosello.”

This made him widen his eyes. “That’s risky. Too risky.”

“Yeah. But we need to get this asshole. I could wear a wire. Just take him on his offer. Invite him out to dinner.”

“Slow down,” He let out a small laugh, hoping she was joking. “Take a breath, Will. If you go rushing it, there’s going to be mistakes. Things can go downhill real quick.” A part of him wanted more than anything to take the plunge with her. But it was Tapp’s voice that kept him still.

”Don’t go doing something foolish, now, Sing.”

Eyebrows knotted with fury, she let out a heavy breath, pulling out a pack of cigarettes, taking one between her lips while offering him another. She lit up and took a low drag.

He took one, letting her light one for him. It was just one of those days. “Didn’t know you smoked.”

“Quit when I married Frank. Been hanging around too much with Matthews these days. Decided life's too short and been shit lately.” She was already blowing plumes and flicking ash into their table’s ashtray.

“First things, first, let’s eat. We can’t go take down this kingpin on empty stomachs.” Maddox had that fire that Tapp had burning inside him. It was that kind of fire that did a lot of good most of the time. But sometimes, if there wasn't someone around to help them remember to keep themselves under control, it would burn them.

And that was what Sing was good at. Keeping fires under control. He was the level-headed one.

He just hoped these next few weeks he'd be able to keep his own head on straight.

Chapter 12: Pre-SAW: A Bit More Personal

Chapter Text

Allison Kerry

Allison pulled up to the curb, Will’s old apartment building towering over them. “You ready?” She asked, looking over to her friend. Will sat straight up, looking directly ahead with her jaw clenched. She was dressed for labor: jeans and boots with a sweater that barely covered the bulge of her pistol strapped at her hip.

They both came prepared, knowing if Frank Maddox was home, they may just need them. All the guys were busy. Tapp and Sing were looking into some street gang that was starting to expand their turf southside. Matthews and Fisk were guarding Angelina and Peter. Even their FBI backup had to fly back to D.C. for the week, some political event needed their presence.

And Hoffman was off-limits, according to Will. She wouldn’t talk about him. She refused to explain why she had to get her things at that moment. It couldn’t wait. ”Not a moment longer,” she had said when she had gotten home that night.

Word was it had something to do with the spider incident. It was one hell of a rumor to get off duty to. Not knowing gnawed her insides and Will wouldn’t throw her a bone.

The sky was dark. There was an electric stench in the air. Wisps of snow fluttered onto the windshield. “Let’s get this over with.” Will was the first out of the car, leading them to the elevators and up the five stories.

Allison had been on high alert, scanning the hallways as they made their way to the residence. She had her hand resting on her holster, bracing for whatever bullshit this evening would throw their way.

Will took out her keys, the metal clinking as she put one into the door’s lock. The sound of the lock disengaging and the mild surprise glimmering in her eyes made her pause. “I thought he’d change the locks by now.”

Allison bit her lip, not liking that. It meant he had expected her to come back, after all he had done to her.

Will opened the door and called in. “Frank? It’s me.” She was the first in, inching through the foyer. “I’m getting my things. Are you here?” After some tense breaths, she softly murmured, “Guess not.”

The place had a sour, musty smell to it. It was freezing. A window must have been left open. There was trash, beer cans, and glass bottles everywhere she turned. Stepping over some trash bags, she kept surveying the area while Will had gone into the living room. The sound of metal and glass being rummaged through made the hairs on the back of her neck stand.

The sooner they got out of there, the better. It felt like a fungus was creeping into her veins. This made her look over to Will again, needing her close by her. A window was open in the living room, the wind blowing through the stained curtains and keeping the place frigid.

Will was squatting by the bookshelf, a leather-bound book in her hands as she flipped through the pages briefly. Satisfied, she slapped the book shut and stood up. “I just need my jewelry box and then we’re done.” She briskly walked across the room and through the kitchen, going toward the bedroom.

She paused, looking into the room before letting out a disgusted noise. “Oh God. You don’t want to see this.”

“I’ll take your word on it.” Allison called back, the urge to leave rising up her chest. “You find it? Let’s get out of here.” She stepped into the kitchen, glancing down at the plates on the counter. It was a good thing it was winter. The bug count was much lower despite the fuzzy mold rainbowing the various dishes.

She saw a flicker in the corner of her eye and she swung around, going for her weapon.

He was just there.

She saw a swift sideways movement and, suddenly, sharp, intense darkness whacked into her. Everything simply faded.

Wilhelmina Maddox

She heard the wet THUNK and was instantly on alert. She had just picked up the small box buried under discarded towels and was suddenly drawn with her gun pointed at the doorway. Her heart was racing. She had to remind herself to take slow, deep breaths.

“Frank,” she reached for her phone, dialing the station. “What did you do?”

Silence. She cautiously approached the doorway. “Ally? You okay?”

She burst through the door, sweeping her corners before pointing her gun to the kitchen. She saw Allison face down on the kitchen floor, brown waves with crimson fluids spread in a crumpled heap. “Frank!” She raised her voice.

“Metropolitan Police Department,” the voice of the dispatcher sounded on her phone, just barely heard over the sound of her beating heart.

“Officer Down. Back up needed at 425 East Madison Street. Apartment 503B. This is Will Maddox. Assailant armed and dangerous.” She took another step, about to cross the threshold of the hallway into the kitchen.

“Hang tight, we’ll be there in five - ,”

She ducked as soon as she saw the flash of movement, the sound of the bat striking the sheetrock exploded over her. She spun as she landed on her ass as she looked up to see Frank hulking over her, bloodshot eyes and snarling teeth roaring.

He swung downwards and she rolled over quickly, just barely missing the head strike. It had gotten her bun, her hair snagged on the floorboards. She kicked her heel into his knee, feeling the joint pop.

He let out a scream and swung again, this time hitting its mark as she raised her arm up to shield her face. She felt her arm break, white-hot pain searing through her body as she let out a pained yowl.

“You fucking bitch!” He screamed as he collapsed onto her, grabbing her by the fistfuls of hair and slamming her head against the floor.

The world was rocking and shaking as she kept ramming into the hardwood. She knew she was toast. He was straddling her, ramming his fists into her cheeks. Her eyes. Everything hurt but she couldn’t tell if she was dying or if this was a nightmare. She heard bits and pieces of his voice. Cursing her. Calling her every disgusting thing in the English language. And she felt he was right. Why would he be doing this if he wasn’t right?

She felt it stop all of a sudden. He was panting over her. There was something wet in her mouth. Sweat? Blood?

“I’m going to kill you,” he was whispering nearby. She recognized the words. But they were just words. “I need to. Look what you made me do.”

How had she ended up there?

She had never imagined it would all end like this.

A scuffle in the distance. Her gun. Where was her gun? She had it in her hands. She tried to move her fingers. Just feel for it. Her hand grappled into the ether. Nothing.

But she could move. She could fucking move. But it hurt. It hurt so fucking much.

She heard footsteps and then a sharp pressure in her stomach. She let out a low groan. It was the worst pain she had ever experienced. He had just stomped onto her stomach. She was coughing, throwing up copper and bile. Air. She needed air.

She was going to die there.

The footsteps faded again, broken glass and the sound of paper crumpling was grating on her aching head. She felt warm water fall down the sides of her temples. Despite all the damage, her eyes somehow could still shed tears. She didn’t want to die. He was going to kill her. But she didn’t want this.

Then get up. This wasn’t a real voice. Something deep and primal. Something she’d never experienced before. He’s gone. Get. Up. She listened.

She forced herself to roll, despite how much it hurt. But pain meant she was still fucking alive. She could still fucking go. She pulled herself to her elbows, wincing as her weight dug into the nerves of her broken arm. She needed to get to her feet. Run.

Find your gun. Grab a weapon. So many thoughts were bombarding through her. What was the right choice?

The window. Fire escape.

Of course. One of her eyes was swollen shut. The other, she could just barely see out of. But she knew this place. She had lived in it for years. This was once her house.

Frank’s back was to her, bent over in the living room. She needed to just run for it. The window. The window was open. She limped and moved as fast as she could.

“No you don’t!” He snarled as she toppled forward, falling out. She felt his grip on her ankle but she kicked again. She must have hit him because he let out a pained cry. She fell onto the frozen metal grates, pulling the bars with her bare hands. They stung from freezing onto the black iron but she pulled herself up on the railings. She was on the fire escape. Outside.

She let out a strangled scream at the top of her lungs.

“Shut the fuck up!” He was crawling out the window after her, his voice and breath so close. She tried to go down one level, the stairs slippery and the structure trembling under them as they raced down the spiral.

She was just out of his reach but barely.

And then her head was wrenched back. She felt her chin point towards the sky as his fingers dug into her neck. She was choking. Bright yellow splotches danced across her vision like strobe lights.

She didn’t want to fucking die. She wanted to live.

She pulled her good arm behind her, reaching for his face. She clawed and dug her fingers for any vulnerable points, feeling the warm softness of his eyeball as she pressed her thumb into it.

His grip weakened and she jerked forward, losing her balance as she felt herself topple off the railing.

She was falling. The drop a sudden freedom that made her almost believe she was flying.

But this was short-lived. She knew this was the end. She just knew.

And then she felt points and needles shoot up her spine as she collided with uneven solids. Some soft. Some hard. And it fucking hurt.

But pain meant life. Pain meant she wasn’t dead yet. She had to force her one eye open to look up. She was staring up at the black stairs framed in dark blue. A dumpster.

Of all the places to land, she landed in the fucking dumpster. And Frank was glaring down at her, still, a monster that wouldn’t stop.

A police siren sang, calling for her. It gave her a fresh dose of adrenaline. She took a sharp breath.

Keep moving.

Sitting up was almost impossible. She had to pull herself up with an exhausted weakness that made her feel like her bones had turned to lead. Her head was just a bowling ball of broken glass and pins.

She forced herself over the dumpster and she crumpled onto the icy concrete, crawling out onto the public sidewalk.

“Oh my god,” a voice was heard. She reached forward, seeing shadows in the distance. They must have been people. Good people. People who would help.

She held out her hand and someone warm took it. And relief washed over her as she began to cry.

Mark Hoffman

Knox and him were snickering at the TV as Dennis the Menace played in the background. In between sips of whiskey and the fog of smoke, it had been an alright evening. Now, it was well past midnight, and the two of them had started flipping through channels and decided to watch some reruns that old Vernon had watched in his youth.

He felt his pager go off on his belt. He went to check it, surprised anyone had bothered. He had decided to leave his cell at the office, never quite used to carrying it around like he was expected to.

It was Angie. He got to his feet while Knox kept cackling as the boy on the screen left a bucket of paint under his neighbor’s ladder, ready to see the shenanigans unfold as the adult descended down the steps.

Hoffman dialed Angie’s number, wondering what she could possibly want this late in the evening.

She picked up after the first ring. “Mark. Will’s in the hospital.”

He froze. “What happened?” But he knew.

“Frank.”

The confirmation made him grow hot with hate, the phone beginning to shake in his fist. “Where?”

“Mercy General.” Her voice was hoarse. She must have been crying. “It’s bad, Mark.”

“I’m on my way.” He hung up, baring his teeth.

“Everything all right?” Knox had muted the TV and was wheeling into the kitchen.

“My partner’s in the hospital.” He was already retrieving his coat from the kitchen chair. “I need to go.”

He was looking for his car keys, having tossed them on the kitchen table.

“Will she live?” He asked the right question. Not what happened. Not who did it. But the only thing that mattered. Will she live?

“I don’t know.”

“I’m coming, then.”

He didn’t bother to argue. It would have been futile anyway. Besides, Hoffman didn’t want to be alone. Not at that moment. “Then bundle up. It’s snowing.”

He drove fast, turning on his hidden police lights as he made his way through the quiet city streets. Knox kept silent and the only sound was the whoosh of the heater blasting onto them and the sound of his own loud breathing.

Once they parked at the hospital, he got the wheelchair set up steered Knox quickly through the sliding doors and into the warmth and fumes of rubbing alcohol. Emergency Care was surprisingly quiet. He recognized the group of familiar faces waiting amongst the chairs and outdated magazines. Tapp and Sing nodded as they stayed seated with their backs in the corner, clearly on guard duty. Angelina and Peter, rose with tear-streaked and tired faces. Kerry was with them, her head wrapped in gauze with a purple bruise on the side of her cheek. Two of their uniforms were there, whom he recognized were part of the Domestic Violence Unit.

“Mark,” Angie buried her face into his chest and hugged him tightly.

“Can we see her?” He looked over to the nurse behind the check-in counter, who was giving them a pitying frown.

“Not yet. They said she’s in critical condition. She fell several stories.” Angie let out a huff, resisting a sob.

He pushed her. Lava boiled under his chest.

“He got the drop on me, Hoffman. I’m sorry.” Kerry had avoided his eyes, the glistening of angry tears at the edge of her lashes glimmered under the fluorescent light. “I fucked up.”

“Hey now,” Vernon’s gruff voice broke though, “Don’t go blaming yourself, Kerry.”

She blinked, her lips parting as she gaped. “Knox. I - I didn’t see you.”

“Kerry, don’t tell me you’ve softened that tough-gal image after these short years.” He pushed his wheels and nodded towards Tapp. “Come over here, missy. Let’s give them a moment.”

Kerry and Knox went out of earshot, Hoffman keeping his eyes on his sister. “Did they say how bad it’s going to be?”

“They just need to set her arm and leg. And do some X-Rays. They’re only letting family see her.”

“She doesn’t have anyone here,” he growled, shoving a fist into his pocket. Fucking Frank had a right to see her and not they? It was fucked. “When are non-relatives allowed?”

“In a few moments,” a doctor arrived, draped in lab coat and clipboard in hand. “She’s conscious and insists you all will be permitted or she will ‘crawl out of this hospital’ if she has to.” He didn’t sound impressed as he clicked his pen. “She refuses to give a statement until we’ve allowed all visitors. She said she wanted to speak to,” he looked down at his clipboard, “Allison Kerry, Mark and Angelina Hoffman. I’m assuming that’s you three?”

He smirked, relief washing through him. It sounded like she was going to be fine. “Lead the way.”

The doctor led them through doors and hallways. “I must warn you. Her appearance. It may come as a shock.” He was looking at Angelina as he said this, barely flicking his glance towards Mark or Allison, who wore her badge around her neck in a silver chain.

He pulled back a curtain and Angelina gasped. He refused to shut his eyes, though the urge struck him.

The person lying in the hospital bed did not look like his partner. The only part that had been constant was the red curls pulled back with thick bandages wrapped around her forehead. Eyes swollen shut, tubes in her nose, arms, and a cast on her left wrist with blood staining the white, it would have been just another victim in a crime he was investigating on the job if he did not know it was her.

He kept his face still as he went to her side. He put a hand against her good one, letting his warmth seep into the cool skin. He found himself in the past, the familiar smells and sounds of the hospital and the soft sobs of Angelina making him feel like a young man again, saying goodbye to his mother.

He swallowed hard. “Will.”

“Mark.” Her voice was rough and soft. One eye opened slightly and a glimmer of amber in between pink flesh glimmered up at him. “Sorry about today.”

He squinted. “What do you mean?”

“I know you didn’t leave those roses. I was an idiot.” Her face was a bloated mass but he thought he saw a small curl of a smile. “I broke his knee.” Her fingers curled over his hand.

“You’re not an idiot,” he dumbly replied. “And good.” He squeezed her hand back. “Hang in there, Will.”

“Plan to.” She looked up at the ceiling and he saw a tear slide down her cheek. “Mark?”

“What?”

“Promise me,” her voice trailed off, visibly wincing from pain.

He leaned close. Deja vu. “Don’t strain yourself, all right?”

“I’m not. Just.” She let out a whisper, “Promise me you won’t go do something stupid. With Frank.”

Despite it all. Despite all this shit. She still had to do things the right way. His vision was reddening and he had to restrain himself from squeezing her hand too tightly. “I can’t promise that.”

“Please. Try. Let Domestics take care of it.”

“He almost killed you.” He knew damn well that a multi-story fall didn’t beat a person up this badly.

“And there’s plenty of evidence to lock him up. Please. Don’t do something stupid. I know you.” Her tone said more. I know what you’re capable of. Now she was squeezing his fingers, small hands with shaky strength.

“Fine. Promise.” He wanted to promise her the moon if it would just help her heal up. “Just rest. I’ll be here.”

“Thank you.” There was relief in her voice. A trust that he feared.

Angelina knelt down, softly crying as she put a hand on Will’s face. He left the two women there, taking an awkward step back as they knelt beside their friend. He looked away, uncertain of what he should do.

The doctor had returned to shoo them back to the waiting room, now with the two Domestics officers at his back. Hoffman knew this was when they took Will’s statement. There’d be a manhunt, if Frank had decided to run. Hoffman was itching to join them but kept the urge pushed down as he returned to the waiting area with Angie and Kerry, seated while they all sat in a depressed quiet that was only broken with the distant phone ringing and intercom pages for doctors to report to the scene.

“Dr. Denlon, ICU. Denlon, ICU.”

He pulled up a random pamphlet, some addiction rehab clinic, that he half-heartedly studied, as he took in the people around him. Kerry was rubbing her bandage, staring down at her feet, while Sing had a hand on her shoulder in comfort. Tapp and Knox were having a conversation, old friends catching up on lost time in respectful and solemn expressions. And Angelina was wiping tears while Peter rubbed her back.

Hoffman’s pager went off again. He checked, the number making his throat go dry. No. Not now. But he couldn’t ignore it.

He got up, approaching the front desk. “Mind if I use your phone?” The nurse pointed at a nearby payphone booth. Hoffman went to make the call.

Putting in change, he licked his lips as the phone rang. He silently wished for it to just be a check-in. He’d known what happened. Doesn’t mean I got to do anything but report.

“Markie-boy,” the nasal voice grated on his ears. “Give me the news on Red. She going to pull through?”

He clenched his jaw. “She’ll live.”

“She’ll heal up? Had I known she’d go back to that piece of shit, I’d have sent some boys over to keep her in one piece. Broke my heart when I heard what happened. So I’ve decided to take care of it.”

“Yeah?” Hoffman inhaled sharply, his nostrils flared. “You know where he is?”

“Oh, better. Come to my place. I’m feeling generous. Promise you won’t be disappointed.”

Hoffman looked over to the waiting room, locking eyes with Tapp and Knox, who both were watching him with an intelligence laced with tragic knowing. Tapp glared at him with a superior smirk.

“I’m on my way.” He hung up and left without saying goodbye.

 

Rosello’s home smelled of expensive things like Cuban cigars, leather, and walnut furniture. He always felt like the lounge hall was a symbol of everything Rosello was: overcompensation and death.

There were more stuffed animals than he’d seen in their city zoo before it was shut down. He stared at the big elephant head, a fleeting sadness rushed through him. To see something so grand and innocent fall victim to a worm like Toni Rosello just stung.

“Ah, Markie-boy,” Toni strode in, wrapped in a mustard paisley smoking jacket and a thick cigar in his teeth. “Punctual, I see.” He let out his hyena laugh, yellowed teeth bared. “Come, Olaf is warming up our guest.”

Rosello had a peculiar walk. Hoffman had never noticed, but he waddled because of his pot-belly, an awkward gait that he felt oddly glad he had. It made him seem more flawed. Finally, something that made him feel a bit superior to the slimy bastard.

He kept getting whiffs of the cigar as Rosello continued down the hallways of dark woods and extravagant wallpaper. The carpet under their feet felt expensive and Hoffman almost felt guilty for tracking the snow and dirt onto it. Almost.

Rosello opened a large door and below, stone steps led to the basement. Or really, an archaic renovated basement with an interior designer that was clearly well versed in victorian sado-masochism. The place looked like a torture-porn dungeon.

Graystone walls and sconces on the walls made Hoffman feel like he was on a theme park ride or on some movie scene of Dracula. The sound of the soles of their shoes on the stone stairs echoed off the walls.

A low moan was heard, coming in the distance. Hoffman already knew who it was, his stomach rolling as he pursed his lips with distaste.

Reaching the basement floor, the sight of the Frank Griffin curled in the fetal position as Olaf held a cow prod in his hand, brought the first pleasant spark in Hoffman’s heart. He looked on as Olaf pressed the end of the electric leads into the back of Frank’s neck and squeezed the trigger. The click of current and the sudden cries coming out of the man’s mouth made Rosello giggle.

“Oh, that’s cute. Let me have that,” Rosello held out his hand and Olaf obediently placed the grip respectfully into the man’s palm. Rosello hoisted it and pushed it into Frank’s face and the man seized, limbs flying as he twitched and writhed.

“Please,” he let out a strangled sob, “Stop!”

“What do you think, Markie-boy?” Rosello turned to him, intense with curiosity. “You can do whatever you want. I, sure as hell ain’t calling the cops on you.” He let out a laugh at his joke, a chorus of hyenas howling off with the dungeon echo.

He took a step towards the pathetic lump on the floor, who was crying like a baby. “Please,” he whispered, looking up at him with desperation. “Don’t let them do this to me. You’re a cop. You’re supposed to be one of the good guys.” He was on his knees, grabbing the pant legs of his trousers. “Please.”

Hoffman knelt down, squatting to get a better look at this embarrassment of a man. He looked up with wet brown eyes and his small nose; this was a creature that had been gifted kindness and love in this shit world, only to disregard and intentionally harm this gift with the stillness of a child who never knew anything but comfort.

He grabbed the man by the side of the neck, his rough hands touching skin as soft as a baby’s. He pictured Will, the pastries and coffee she’d offer every morning; the times she’d tell Grissom he was running papers when he was really late for work. Her smile. He thought of how she had kept her faith in him for much longer than most; how she kept believing he could still be good. And then seeing her in that hospital bed.

Promise me.

He promised he wouldn’t do anything stupid. He remembered that.

And with Rosello pulling the strings, there was little room for stupidity.

If anything, this was the smartest decision. Demonstration of loyalty and revenge, all in one sweet action.

He pulled at the man’s ear, twisting it with all his might. Frank let out a gurgling screech that just pissed him off more. He slammed the man down into the cool rock while pressing into his neck, pulling out his knife. He’d start small. Just a bit of flesh. Compared to what he did to Will, this was a pittance.

He took out his serrated knife, the one Angie had given him last Christmas.

And he began sawing off Frank Griffin’s ear. Blood was flowing out of the man’s head and the sight of it excited him. This felt the way justice should feel. Overwhelmingly satisfying. Almost orgasmic. He was breathing huskily as he kept slicing into the flesh, the screams making the hairs on his neck stand and his mouth water.

The sound of a happy hyena melded with the screams and Hoffman found himself smiling as the ear was finally sheared off the man’s head.

Angelina Hoffman

She pulled the leaves out of the vase of fake flowers resting on her mother’s tombstone, sighing at how unkept it seemed. She hadn’t come to visit her parents in years, life taking over and just making everything so busy. Eric Matthews and Allison Kerry were standing a respectful distance away, leaning against their car and huddled close.

Peter was taking a small brush across her father’s nameplate, cleaning off the hardening snow so they could see the dates and name clearly.

She knew it didn’t really matter, but the act felt good. It felt ritualistic and gave her something to do.

Mark had not gotten back to her when she left several voicemails for him. He had just stormed out the other night at the hospital and she worried he would drink himself into some trouble, like he was prone to do. A part of her wanted to join him, but she kept herself confined in her apartment and a bottle of wine.

The ache of loneliness hit her, as she imagined how Mark was handling the news. Apparently, Frank Griffin had gotten away. This news must have been driving her brother insane. It was one of his pet peeves, when the bad guy got away. Ever since the hit-and-run that killed their parents.

She took in a deep breath of the frigid air. Turning to her fiance, she rested her cheek against his shoulder. At least she had Peter, who was always a comfort and there for her. She couldn’t imagine a world without him.

“I wish they could have met you,” she commented as she looked down at her parents’ graves.

“Me too. Do you think they’d have liked me?”

“I know my mom would have loved you. My Dad?”

“Yeah?” Peter turned, alarmed. “What would he have thought?”

“Well, you know how Mark is. He gets that from our Dad. He had an old-school attitude on what made a man so I think he would have taken a bit to warm up to you. But in the end, he’d of realized that you would be the best man a woman would be lucky to have,” Angie beamed up at him and kissed him on his nose.”

“Whew,” Peter let out a relieved laugh, “I can’t imagine a man scarier than Mark.”

“Oh, Dad was much worse. Mark is a flower girl next to him.”

“Yikes,” Peter smiled in thought. “Speaking of flower girls.”

“Yes?”

“What do you think of my cousin’s daughter as the flower girl?”

“Oh, I was thinking Mark would be the flower girl. That’s why I brought it up,” Angie teased, “Sure. Sounds like a plan.”

“Six more months.”

“Not soon enough.” Angie looked up at her fiance, “I can’t wait to be Mrs. Angelina Acomb.”

“Well, soon-to-be Mrs. Acomb,” Peter wrapped an arm around her, “shall we return to the warm car? We’ll freeze to death at this rate.”

“Let’s.” Angie mentally said her farewell to her parents and they left the cemetery.

Peter Strahm

When he had heard about what happened, he had made some phone calls and burned an I.O.U. that Erickson owed him so he could take the next flight back to the city. His thoughts lingered heavily onto Will, sorrow heavy on him like pressure plates pushing into him.

Lindsey had to stay behind, sending her warmest regards in the form of a teddy bear and a Get Well Soon card. He was currently in a taxi, being taken directly to the hospital. He was not sure of the details, only that Will had been attacked and narrowly escaped.

He was sure she’d elaborate if she wanted to. He’d offer his services for trauma counseling, if needed. Though, it always was a gray line due to his more personal interests in her.

When he pulled up to the freshly plowed hospital entrance, he recognized Detective Eric Matthews smoking and shivering outside the doors, by an ashtray. “Can you believe they won’t let me smoke in there?” Matthews shook his head with disdain.

“Last PSA said those things kill and this is a hospital,” Strahm gave a good natured grin. “Times are changing.”

“For the worst,” Matthews took another drag. “Mad Max was moved out of ICU and is now in Primary. Third floor. Forget the room number but it’s to your right getting off the elevators.”

“Thanks.”

“Cute bear,” Matthews kept eye contact with Strahm, a cool gaze that felt penetrating.

“It’s from Perez,” Strahm felt an urge to go on the defensive.

“Ah,” suddenly Matthews was less intense. “I’m sure she’ll like that. She’s looking a lot better than when it happened. But she’s pretty banged up. It’s hard to see.”

Strahm nodded, his imagination all too canny that he doubted he’d be shocked. He made his way to the third floor, walking by nurses as he finally reached the room.

Recognizing the nameplate on the door, he knocked before entering. It was a private room, the TV turned on to the news, but muted.

“Strahm?”

He smiled, pretending it wasn’t as bad as it looked. Her eyes were swollen and purple, both looking up at him in surprise. It didn’t look like her. It was like a bad alien creature that had her voice.

“Hey, Will,” Strahm took a seat. “Lindsey wished she could have flown up but she’s being held back.” He put the bear on the table beside her and the sealed envelope. “Kerry told us. How’re you holding up?”

“I feel good. They gave me some wicked strong painkillers. I feel ready to go home.” Her voice was muffled and thick like honey.

The cast on her wrist and her elevated leg in plaster made him assume that would not be the case. There were little parts of her freckled skin that didn’t have purple or yellowish-green blemishes. Most of her was covered in bandages or floral hospital fabrics.

“Glad you seem in good spirits.” He wasn’t good at pretending to be thrilled. He tried to smile but it felt like he was just tensing his cheeks.

“You don’t have to do that.”

“Do what?”

“Try to look happy. I know I look gross.” She turned to him with misty eyes. “But you know, I don’t feel sad. Not in the slightest. It’s over. I’m alive.”

He nodded, feeling himself mentally retreat into clinical listening mode. “It will take time to process the trauma.” He hated the words as soon as they tumbled out of his mouth but it was too late. He had just made things awkward.

They sat in silence, staring at the TV as it spoke of the latest housing projects being constructed. “Four Walls Build A Home”. Cute slogan. Some big-shot engineer was designing affordable apartments with a key focus on sustainable communities to help cut back on the homeless rates in the city. An admirable mission.

“Strahm,” Will’s voice was throaty, “that offer you gave last we spoke. Is it still on the table?”

He turned to her, analyzing the stare. “Of course.”

“Can we start now?”

Peter cleared his throat and turned to the door. The slightest knot in his throat and the tinge of guilt in his stomach made him almost regret offering. It was frowned upon to give counseling to people you knew professionally. It was a potential conflict.

But he had offered, albeit out of a pitiful attempt to flirt and his savior complex he had trouble managing. He had to reap what he sowed, so to speak.

He went to shut the door. Once it clicked, he turned and provided his full attention. “Where do you want to start?”

“Just one thing.”

Peter returned to the chair by her side. A tear was falling down her cheek, dropping onto the pastel fabric of her hospital gown.

“After everything he’s done. Why don’t I hate him?”

He blinked. “I’m assuming by ‘him’ you mean…?”

“Frank. My husband.”

Ah. The word crushed him flat, catching him off guard. He hadn’t realized she was married. Never wore the ring. He could have read more into that but kept his composure. “After everything he’s done, you feel like you should hate him. Is that correct?” He had to reorient the conversation. This was a delicate matter.

“I should. I know this. I know that I should have left him after the first time. So why didn’t I?”

“You know what they say. Hindsight.” He leaned forward, wanting to reach out to comfort her but kept a healthy distance. “What were some reasons you stayed in the past?”

She looked up at the ceiling, ashamed. “I love him. Loved him.” She wiped her cheek with her good hand. “I’m not helpless. I’m not. I could have kicked his ass at any point.”

Strahm felt a real smile pull at that. “I’m sure.”

She shot him an angry glare. “And it’s my fault for letting it get this far, isn’t it?”

She was baiting him. He recognized the pleading question. The need for assurance. “You are not responsible for the violence your partner chose to do. Let’s make that clear.”

She swallowed. “Funny. Hoffman thought otherwise.”

Her other partner. “Well, Hoffman sounds like an idiot.”

She giggled at that. It was like church bells ringing. And he decided to commit.

“What else did Hoffman think? About your situation and your husband?”

She shook her head. “He didn’t like it. But he kept quiet, usually.”

“Must have been hard, not being able to talk about it with your partner.”

She let out a half-laugh. “Well, it’s honestly harder to talk about it than to pretend it’s not a problem.” She flinched, shutting her eyes tight as she cradled her broken arm to her chest.

He nodded, biting the inside of his cheek. A strong urge to protect and defend wrapped its electric arms around him. His heart pounded in his ears. “Do you need the nurse?”

“No.” She hissed, “I’m fine.” She shook her head. “I just want to move on. Get back to work.”

Ah. The layers were peeling back. Maddox was a textbook workaholic. He was the same. It was a decent coping mechanism. He swallowed as the memory of her face surfaced. He didn’t want to think about her right now. Not ever.

“Frank will go to jail. I’ll have to sit through the trial. And hopefully, he’s locked up.”

“I’m sure he’ll be convicted. They haven’t caught him yet?”

“Not yet. They would have told me. Hoffman would have told me.” She turned with a doubtful shadow in her eyes. “But there’s a chance he could walk. The DA is shit here. Domestics rarely get a conviction here.”

Like a mold spreading in his lungs, he felt sick. “He’ll have the book thrown at him. Despite how crooked your department is, there’s no way they’d let this guy walk. You're a cop. You all look after each other.”

“No. I don’t want some back alley deal. None of that. I want him locked away the right way.”

Peter couldn’t help but crack a smile. “Yeah. Don’t we all." He wanted to fix this. "I can help out. Make sure the paperwork’s filed right. Make some phone calls, maybe get some attorneys from out of state to keep the DA straight.”

There was a pregnant pause. They stared at each other and he wondered what was with the hesitation. “We're not in a personal relationship, so there’s no real conflict if I participate. Also, it’s related to the Rosello case. I heard about the earrings found on your lookalike. I’m assuming Frank must have either pawned it off or has some link with Rosello that needs to be looked at.”

“You know what? Sure.” She nodded. “I trust you won't be doing anything shady?”

“Of course not. You see, we at the Bureau have something called standards.” He pulled a teasing smile, hoping she’d take it well. “Unlike you dirty cops.”

She laughed, then winced. “Ow. And thanks.”

“Sure thing.” His mind was running wild. He’d need to investigate where her husband was last seen. Despite his lack of personal relations, it certainly was about to get more personal from now.

Chapter 13: Pre-Saw: Jonas Singer

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

She walked with a slight limp. She pressed on, up the stairs to the Homicide floor. Despite her crutch at her good arm’s side, her opposite arm in plaster, and a bulking medical boot strapped to her leg, she made it up with no problem. Things hadn’t changed the two weeks she was away. People looked up as they walked by, some giving sympathetic smiles, while some gave warm greetings laced with pity.

The worst was the occasional predatory stare, an almost lecherous hunger on some of the more problematic colleagues. It seemed word got around about her dirty laundry. Everyone knew. Already, she had to turn down lunch invites.

She didn’t care. She forced herself to just get to her desk with a stiff upper lip. The clicking of the crutches was echoing off the cracked walls of the hallway. She hated how slow she was and her casted wrist itched. This was going to be a long few months.

The snow outside didn’t help but thankfully the sidewalks were salted and the painkillers cut the sharp cold from being felt on her skin. She felt like her spine was buzzing and had an artificial pleasance warming her insides.

She made it to her desk, frowning at her partner’s empty seat across from it. A styrofoam cup of coffee was still steaming on it, indicating he had been there recently. Dropping her bag onto the tabletop, a familiar male voice cleared behind her.

She turned to her supervisor. “Captain Grissom.”

“Good to have you back, Detective,” Grissom held out his hand and shook it firmly. “If there’s anything you need while you’re healing up, let me know. I’ll make sure you’re taken care of.”

“Thanks, sir. I hope to get back to the field as soon as possible.”

Grissom nodded, a tight smile pulled below his mustache. “All in due time. Glad to hear your go-getter attitude is still there.”

She forced a smile back. Not like it was going anywhere. “Of course.”

Grissom nodded over to Hoffman’s desk. “Hoffman’s falling behind on his paperwork.”

“I’ll get on it,” she resisted letting her smile widen from amusement.

“And - I’m serious, Maddox. If you need some personal time, let me know.”

“Will do.” She was eager to pretend everything was back to normal. Finally, her boss left her and she sat in her chair with a low breath. She wanted to see Hoffman. To talk to him. She hadn’t seen him since the night it all happened. He hadn’t visited her after that one time.

She figured it was hard to see her in that state. She self-consciously pulled out her compact and studied her face. The swelling was all gone. The bruising had faded to green blushes. She angled her reflection and caught a glimpse of blue eyes staring back.

She flinched, dropped her mirror, and spun in her chair to glare at her partner. “Mark.”

“Will.” He put a coffee cup on her desk and went to retrieve her compact. “Welcome back. What did Grissom say?”

He had gone to his seat, rifling in his inbox. Something was off. He avoided her gaze.

“To finish your paperwork. Desk duty until I’m off the crutches, I’m assuming.”

With that, he shoved folders over to her side of the desk. “Have at it.”

She let out a frustrated groan at how easily he threw them at her. “Gee, thanks.” She flipped through pages. “Can you look at me for just a second?”

He did. She couldn’t read his stoic expression but she felt him study every inch of her face. This lasted longer than she liked, his gaze penetrating. “Okay, thanks, that’s enough.”

“Satisfied?” He was gruff. Curt. It stung.

“Yeah. Fine.” It was her turn to stare down at the papers in front of her. But a part of her felt even angrier. “What’s your deal?”

“What do you mean?”

“You know damn well what I mean? I haven’t seen you in two weeks. Where have you been?”

“Busy.”

He wasn’t going to give her any more than that. She fell back into her seat and crossed her arms. “Fine.” She began gathering a fat stack of folders.

“Where are you going?”

She forced herself to balance on her crutch while she gathered the paperwork. “I’ll be spending the day over in the conference room. Where the task force is. I’m sure there’s plenty of things to do over there.”

She turned and went to storm off but slipped on some melted snow. She collapsed, papers flying.

“Hey!” Hoffman sounded incredulous.

“Don’t help me!” She hissed at him, gathering papers.

“You’re being ridiculous.” He went to gather some papers, brushing them onto a pile with his palms. Some of the papers were damp from the icemelt on the floors. Great.

“So are you.”

“At least let me help you move over there.”

“You’re not allowed in that room,” she growled up at him. His stone-wall face cracked slightly.

“Will. Please.” The way he whispered made her shiver. “Let me help you, at least in this way.”

She hated how quickly her resolve was melting. “Just - to the door. But you can’t come in.” She turned and began her crippled journey to the Task Force’s office, still angry but not wanting to attract any more attention to their altercation.

Down the stairs, around the corner, through some historical partitions that made no sense but were part of the floor plan, and they finally reached the office in tense silence. She turned and held her hand out, waiting for Hoffman to dump the mountain of files onto it and walk away.

He hesitated. But then leaned forward, hand on her shoulder. “Domestics haven’t caught Frank yet.”

She kept herself from shaking under his firm grip. He was squeezing, his hand burning through her sweater. “I know. They told me.” She finally understood why he was being so strange. He didn’t like Frank being free. This was what was bothering him.

“Let me go after him. I’ll bring him in.” His face was close. Stern. He was practically pleading for her to grant him permission.

“No, Hoffman. Stay out of it. You’ll just kill him. Respect my wishes. It’s for your own good.”

“You think I can’t control myself?” There was a challenge there. A dangerous game he wanted to play.

She closed her eyes and remembered Hoffman that one night in the nightclub. She remembered how hard it was to pull him off of the pimp. “I don’t want to find out.” Her hand was on the doorknob and Hoffman put his other hand over it to stop her. His touch was practically burning her.

“Domestics don’t have the resources and they're idiots. They’ll never catch him. Let me hunt him down. I’ll find him. I'll even keep him as intact as possible. While he's out there, you're still in danger. What if he comes back for you?”

“I’ll shoot him.” She was breathing hard, noticing how close their faces were.

He scoffed. “Sure. You’re a terrible liar.” He gave her a look of frustration and dismay.

“And so are you.” She knew he’d kill him if given the chance. She wouldn’t stand for it. She wouldn’t let Hoffman dirty himself any more than he already had. She shrugged out of his hand and dug her elbow into his sternum, forcing him to take a step back. “Now, go enjoy catching bad guys in the field while I cry over paperwork. Excuse me.”

The door opened, pulling Will’s hand with it.

“Everything all right here?” Peter Strahm was suddenly there, leering over at Hoffman.

“Strahm,” Will was taken aback, looking up at him. “What are you doing here?”

He raised an eyebrow, smiling innocently. “Waiting for you. Ready to get to work?” He reached over to take the files from Hoffman. “Appreciate you getting her this far. We’ll take it from here.” He had a smile frozen on his face. Behind him, Tapp and Sing were sitting at a scratched table in the center of the room, waving with uncomfortable grins.

Will inched into the room, hoping it was the end of their discussion.

“Who’s this?” Hoffman didn’t look happy, studying Strahm with eyes darting up and down.

“Special Agent Peter Strahm. Nice to meet you.” Strahm held a hand out, smirking. When Hoffman didn’t take his hand, Strahm, instead, moved to touch Will’s back to help pull her into the conference room. “Hey, Will, no need to be on your feet this long. Have a seat.”

“S-sure.” She felt her face heat up and she looked away from her partner in hopes he wouldn’t notice. But when she snuck a glance back at him there was the distinct frown as they locked eyes. He had noticed. And he didn't look thrilled.

Hoffman squinted up at Strahm, jaw clenched. “I’ll see you around.” He turned and left, Will feeling guilt hit her hard as the sight of him went farther out of reach.

 

Mark Hoffman

He felt his heart thudding in his chest. He had to remember to breathe. He finally got a visual on one of the feds and he felt the sting of fear frost inside his mouth. This guy was dangerous. He could tell just by looking at him and knew he was going to have trouble.

He certainly didn’t like the way he acted around Will. Like he knew her. Personally. That was bothersome in itself.

Returning to his desk, Eric Matthews was leaning against Will’s vacant tabletop, cigarette hanging from his lip. “You look like you need an early lunch.”

“You buying?”

“I’ve got a newborn, asshole,” Matthews smirked as he blew smoke out his nostrils. “Besides, you still owe me for saving your ass on the Druthers case.”

“Fair enough. But I'm surprised you have the time.”

“Funny thing. Turns out, I’m getting reassigned temporarily.” He took his cigarette with his fingers and pointed at him, “Apparently, you need a new partner. Grissom’s orders. He thinks you ain’t gonna stay on the straight and narrow without Mad Max. And Tapp, begrudgingly, agreed to release me. I agreed, on condition Ally stay with Will on desk duty. Now, I’m a sexist asshole and in the doghouse with my partner. Sound familiar?”

“Surprised she didn’t shoot you for that.” Hoffman felt mild relief, though he knew the women were probably furious. But they needed to stay low, for their own good.

“Yeah, well, she basically threatened to end our partnership. I figured she needed some air to breathe and I could go for reliving the good ol’ days. What do you say, partner?” There was an urgency in his voice, guttural and eager.

“Fine with me.”

(Power of Will)

They sat at the bar in Larry’s, Matthews already down one pack while Hoffman had thrown back several glasses of whiskey. Both men had their attention glued to the TV, eating their lunch in silence. Hoffman felt like he had gone back in time and was just a young twenty-something rookie with his Police Academy roommate.

“You meet the fed yet?” Matthews was always the one to break the silence first.

“Yeah. This morning.”

“He’s been visiting Mad Max at the hospital. They’re getting close. The other fed is still in D.C. She's cute but I get the vibe the feds aren't shagging. She's real cozy with Ally these days. Kind of hot.”

Hoffman stared at the basket of greasy fries. Normally, Will would pick at his scraps. The basket was disturbingly overflowing. It didn’t look right.

“Figured I'd warn you. Not insinuating anything. But if you don't like some guy moving in on your partner, I've got your back. Especially this guy. He rubs me the wrong way. I think he’s a hardass prick who thinks he’s better than the rest of us. Total elitist asshole.”

He took another drink. “None of my business.” His ears were ringing. He didn't want to think about it.

“Acts like he’s some saint. I overheard him talking about bringing her to work with him, like he's some hotshot and she's too good for us.”

Mark looked down, seeing the reflection of the overhead lighting fixtures shine through his drink. The refraction of light made his hand look almost crimson. Thoughts of the other night and Frank Griffin’s screams filled the ringing. He still needed to come up with a plan to deal with him. A story Will would believe. Would understand.

“Ready to head over to Hill Street?” Matthews had spun in his barstool and was leaning his elbows on the counters, giving Hoffman a sideways glance. “Cleaning up the streets will put you in a better mood.”

“Yeah. Let’s go.” He threw some cash on the faded bar and got to his feet, his head fuzzy and swimming. Shit. He may have had a little too much to drink. “You drive.”

(Power of Will)

The two of them made their way to their latest case. A gas station robbery, with the convenience clerk shot. Small Asian woman - girl, really - laying in a puddle of her own blood. Staring up at the fluorescent lights, mouth agape.

Hoffman let out a sigh as he squatted down to get a closer look at her. His head was swimming. The woman had some discoloration on the side of her face, consistent with a pistol whip. Beyond that, there were no self-defense injuries.

As he scanned the surroundings, from the opened cash register with no cash inside, the overall neat cigarette cartons stacked with nothing out of place save for the spray of blood painting the walls, this looked like cold-blooded murder.

“Show me the tapes,” Hoffman pointed to the security camera in the corner. The uniformed officer and shop owner led him to the backroom. Matthews was silent, as he usually was when investigating. He was a listener. An observer. He didn't like arranging or planning, preferring to react and play things by ear. Hoffman was always expected to lead. It was refreshing, after so long competing with Maddox to call the shots.

The small television lit up with black and white visuals, gritty resolution showing the shapes of the cashier. A dark figure approached, pulling his gun. Male, black, adult. Age? Couldn’t tell, but old enough. Not too old to move so freely.

They watched as the suspect slapped the woman across the face with the weapon, followed by her falling over. Though the tape was silent, Hoffman could hear the gunshots as the perpetrator fired upon her. While digging through the register, the man looked up briefly, his face captured by the camera.

“Freeze it.” Matthews ordered. He put his finger on the glass, by the suspect’s head. “Looks like a perp we’ve been eyeballing. Typical gang banger. Jonas Singer.”

Hoffman tried to make out any discernible features, but it was just a blur. It could have been anyone. “You sure?”

“Yeah. The guy likes to sling in this neighborhood. Let’s pay him a visit.”

They had left the scene, with barely a departing message to forensics, speeding down and around several blocks. Matthews stopped abruptly, staring across the street where the man leaned against the bricks of a rundown building, huddled into himself for warmth.

“Listen.” Matthews parked the car and killed the engine and took out a fresh cancer stick with his lips, “You go around the other side and I’ll confront the prick. I’ll give you five minutes. Be ready for him to run. Fucker is fast. I’ve been trying to nab him for months now. He usually worms out of a conviction but not this time.” There was a mean smile on Eric Matthews’ face, “You got my back?”

“Yeah.” Hoffman got out of the car and took the long way around the block, a shortcut in-between two large buildings, and jogged down the alleyway. It reeked of rotting garbage and piss. When he rounded the corner, he slowed his pace and kept his distance as he watched Matthews approach the suspect.

Singer held his hands out, clearly familiar with Matthews. He was already backing away, preparing for his escape.

Hoffman closed in, silent, his hand rested on his holster in case the guy pulled out his weapon. Upon closer inspection, the guy looked young. Maybe early twenties. But there was a hardness in his face that showed a pride that was cozy with danger.

“The fuck you want, pig?” The man took another step back.

“Want to talk. There was a robbery at the corner store. You know anything about that?” Matthews inched closer to the man.

“I don’t have to talk to you,” Jonas muttered. “Leave me alone. Even if you arrest me, you ain’t gonna find shit on me.”

“Then you’ve got nothing to worry about. Come here,” Matthews reached for the kid as he leaped back, spun on his ankle, and began to sprint.

Hoffman was already upon him, grabbing him firmly by the arm. And then he saw the fist grow in his sight. He dodged and swung back, his knuckles contacting the firm flesh of the guy’s gut. The breath was knocked out of him and he collapsed to his knees, his gasps like a dying wind.

Matthews was already handcuffing him, roughly. “Now you fucked up, Jonas.”

Jonas wiggled but his wrists were restrained. He was hoisted up and marched across the street to their car.

“You sure about this?” Hoffman quietly asked as Matthews slammed Jonas Singer’s face down hard onto the hood of the car and searched his pockets.

“What? You want to rub his feet?” A challenge arose. Matthews was angry. “Don’t tell me sweet little Mad Max turned you into a boy scout. This prick’s plenty guilty."

"Where's the evidence?"

"Oh, fuck off, Hoffman. She’s made you soft.”

“She didn’t.” Hoffman felt defensive. For himself and her. Sure, this type of treatment of a perp wouldn’t have phased him a few years ago. But Maddox had shown him there was another way. A nobler way.

But then again, he wasn’t a fucking saint like she was.

Matthews kept applying pressure to Jonas who continued squirming. Matthews again pulled the guy’s head up and slammed his forehead back onto the metal frame, a loud thunk sounded. “Hoffman. He’s our guy. We can make sure he’s put away for a long time. Quick and easy. Don’t let that bitch’s naive idealism make you forget reality. He’s gonna walk if we go by the book. Besides, look at what's happening to her because she’s trying so hard to be so noble.” A flash of her in the hospital bed made him tense. Yeah. The city was infested with people like Frank Griffin. Going at it through the justice system would never clean it up. There has to be a way. A more efficient way.

Frank Griffin was experiencing a harsh justice. A justice Hoffman felt was well deserved. And it was all thanks to Rosello. Rosello, despite being the sick fuck he was, had an honor code that Hoffman understood. Frank Griffin was currently in a living hell for his sins, something society was too chicken shit to enforce anymore. True justice was impossible with their current legal system.

But with Frank Griffin, justice had been gifted right into Hoffman’s hands to administer. And he administered it well. Effectively.

Fuck the right way. It never worked.

“Let’s take him downtown.” Just be ready to deal with IA after all this. His head was already spinning with things to do to cover their trail. They’d need to get their stories straight. They’d need to plant some evidence. It could all be taken care of, this way. Matthews could play the big hero. Hoffman could see scum locked away for good and for the first time his entire career. It was a win-win.

Rosello covers his tracks. That’s how he escapes the consequences. This was the tricky part that Hoffman wasn’t sure he’d be able to properly do. He normally just followed his shadow boss’ instructions, not having to form a cohesive plot.

But after years of serving, he knew many of the tricks of the trade. He was a fast learner.

He went to retrieve Matthews’ fallen weapon, bringing it over to Jonas.

“The fuck you looking at?” Jonas snapped, glaring hatefully up from his seat in the back of their car.

Hoffman wordlessly pushed the man’s shoulders forward so he was leaning with his chin to his knees. He then pressed the revolver in the man’s hands and pressed his fingers against the cool metal. “What the fuck!”

“Shut up,” Hoffman growled, taking the gun back and handing it to Matthews. “The bastard went for your gun. We’ve got assault of an officer. Attempting to flee the scene of the crime. I’m sure we’ll find some drugs on him. We can get him for possession.”

“I ain’t carrying!”

Hoffman resisted the urge to smack the fucker on the side of the face. “You will,” he muttered. The perp’s jaw dropped.

“And the murder?” Matthews had his thumb in a belt loop, eyebrows cocked with mild amusement.

Hoffman paused, pursing his lips as he thought hard. “Like you said. He’s on the tape. And we’ll likely find the victim’s hair on his clothes when we book him.” Plus, the public defenders are shit.

“What?!” Jonas Singer was howling in the back of the car. “You can’t do this!”

“Now we’re talking,” Matthews went to the driver’s side, smacking Hoffman’s shoulder warmly. “Let’s drop off the bastard and celebrate.”

As they drove back, tuning out the pleas and cries of Jonas Singer, Hoffman felt a mix of sensations. He felt satisfaction warm through his chest. A buzzing of excitement rang in his ears. And a strange denseness in his gut put him on edge.

Rosello. Frank Griffin. Now, this. The faint memory of a promise being made was quickly swept under the rug of his mind.

He was already in things so deep. What was one more thing?

It was for a good cause. A just cause.

Will must never find out, he decided. No matter what.

Chapter 14: Pre-SAW: Lindsay and Allison | Hoffman the Hero

Chapter Text

Allison Kerry

She wanted blood.

She kept ramming her limbs into the punching bag with all her strength, hoping to get this rage out of her. It wouldn’t go away.

She already felt the skin breaking on her knuckles, despite them being wrapped and gloved. It stung like a bitch. But she kept on punching.

“Got something on your mind?” Behind her, Lindsey Perez sounded amused.

Kerry spun around, gasping for air. “I thought you were still in D.C.”

“Just closed the case this morning. Now, I’m all yours.” She held her arms out to the sweating woman. Heart pounding and muscles twitching, Kerry allowed herself this moment of reprieve. She leaned into Lindsey, smelling her fruity cologne and feeling the coolness of her pantsuit against her damp skin. “It’s surprisingly early for you to be hitting the bag.”

“Had to take the day off.” Kerry took her gloves off, dropping them to the ground. She went to the nearest wall to retrieve her water bottle, taking her time relaying the news. “...I’m off the Rosello case.”

“No shit.” Lindsey put a hand on her shoulder. “Why?”

“Fucking Eric. Told Tapp he wanted me safe. It’s bullshit. Asshole. I heard it’s something to do with Hoffman. Fucker.” Her mind was like a turtle on its back. All she could conjure were words like fuck, asshole, fuck, and goddamn it. “Goddamn it!” She threw her water bottle down, trembling.

“Hey.” Lindsey kept her hand on her, the contact electric and soothingly cool. “Let’s get something to eat.”

“Not hungry.”

“Ally,” Lindsey leaned close. “There’s a silver lining here.”

“Which is?” She looked up into Lindsey’s pretty face.

A smile spread on those full lips. “It means we have no business keeping us professional.”

She couldn’t help but let out a low laugh. “Aren’t you a bad girl.”

“You know it. Come on, let’s head to your place. You can tell me all the details on the way.”

(Power of Will)

Allison had whined and griped while Lindsey maneuvered through afternoon traffic. One thing Lindsey Perez was good at was listening. She nodded, eyes trained on the road but her focus was with Allison. It made her feel like she was worth something. Once they reached her apartment, Allison stripped off and went into the shower.

While her eyes were shut and she was washing her hair, the sound of the curtain rings rushing and the sensation of soft lips on her shoulder made her tense muscles relax. “Linds,” she softly murmured through the steam.

Small, skilled hands trailed up her arms, squeezing her shoulders. One hand made its way down to her breast, nails lightly dragging against the flesh. She felt goosebumps despite the scalding water.

Tossing her head back, Allison sighed as Lindsey continued exploring her skin. Her mind briefly flashed to Eric but was quickly brushed aside by the sudden thrill from Lindsey lowering her hands to her mound. She couldn’t resist letting out a surprised cry when Lindsey ran her finger over her clit, massaging her neck with her mouth.

“Oh, fuck, Linds,” she had her eyes shut tight while one hand was pressed against the tiling for support. She was about to fall over.

“Want to take this to the bedroom?” There was a smugness in her voice in between the sweet kisses and gentle nips of her teeth on her shoulder.

“Yes. Please.” She felt like she was becoming jello.

They barely towelled off, an eager pair of slender limbs and dripping hair. Lindsey had steered Allison to the bed, pushing her onto her back before pushing her thighs upward. Looking down at the edge of the mattress, Lindsey had her cheek rub against her inner thigh while lowering her mouth to please her.

“Oh!” She felt her hot and wet tongue graze her in just the right place. She let out a deep breath as she felt herself being lapped and kneaded. Lindsey had pulled back on her clitoral hood, tracing around her most sensitive spot with a rhythm that made her want to grind into, while at the same time, flinch away from the feeling. “My God!”

Lindsey started pushing a finger inside of her, moving in and out while flicking her sweet spot. Her foot kept twitching with the rhythm, until the burning heat that grew inside her finally overflowed. She let out a final gasp as the orgasm rushed over her like high tide, relieving pressure in her joints and making her feel like she was floating and sinking at the same time.

Not wanting to leave Lindsey unsatisfied, she pushed through the haze of bliss, sitting up. “Hey. Come here and sit on my face.”

Her laughter was like bells on Christmas.

 

Peter Strahm

He watched the Metropolitan Police Department’s finest at work. He was only visiting, preferring the quiet and better equipped amenities of the Bureau’s office than this dank and dilapidated conference room. And worse, the coffee was stale and burnt.

It was a small group that day. Apparently, Matthews and Kerry were both taken off the case, that bombshell barely acknowledged beyond Will’s noticeable increased focus on reviewing her partner’s case files.

He doubted they were going to need his skills much that day, having already provided detailed reports and predictions on Toni Rosello’s behavior. Until something new came up, he had to kill his boredom by studying his colleagues.

Fisk was currently escorting Angelina Hoffman, out on patrol. Tapp and Sing were in the corner, Tapp chuckling at something Sing griped. When the door opened and Gibson came in, Strahm was thankful for the terse cloud over the kid’s head. Finally, something interesting.

“I just filed a complaint with IA,” Gibson announced, southern drawl thicker than usual. He must have been nervous, though he held himself well.

The already muffled room had gone still. “Care to share with the class, Gibby?” Tapp, the alpha leader of their clan, had his arms stretched out on available surfaces on either side of him, making him look larger.

Gibson was not well loved by this group. But Maddox had looked up from the desk to give him a sad smile.

“Hoffman shot that man in cold blood. Unlike everyone else in this department, I’m doing something about it.”

Tapp let out a low chuckle. “All right, son, let’s see how this goes. But let this old timer spin the story that IA is going to get from all this. A fellow cop had his gun taken from him by some junkie. And backup came and took that junkie out. No dead cops. Hoffman’s a hero, in this case.”

“He shot the junkie first. After he surrendered.”

“They’ll probably promote him before they fire him, Gibs,” Sing, too, seemed kinder to the rookie. “Don’t get blindsided if that happens.”

Gibson was unhappy, looking for a face that would validate his conviction. He had decided their corner was the likely source of friendly conversation, and to Strahm’s vexation, the kid made his way to sit with them.

“Maddox,” Gibson leaned forward, “you were there. You can tell them.”

She returned to signing, flipping pages, and checking off boxes. “I was on the scene but not a witness to the events.”

The kid pushed and Strahm predicted this would be a popcorn worthy moment. “But you know Hoffman. Maybe you can testify-,”

“Testify against Hoffman?” Will’s eyes had shot up and there was a warning snarl growing on her face. “He’s my partner, Gibson. He’s had my back and saved me from plenty to know that he did what he thought was right to keep you alive. Try to remember if it weren’t for him, you’d likely have been killed. By your own gun. So unless you’ve got something important relating to classifying homicides paperwork or have something new on Rosello, please let me do the one job I’m allowed to do right now.”

The room had gone icy. Peter tried not smiling but couldn’t help letting a smirk grow as Gibson slunk away, looking like a petulant child that got sent to his room. “You’d be a scary mother,” he murmured.

She scoffed. “Don’t worry. Wasn’t planning on having kids.”

The room phone rang, Tapp, being closest to it, reached to answer. “Tapp.” The man’s at ease face was suddenly steeled, eyes glittering. “Where?” He was writing things down, snapping at Sing to read what he wrote.

Sing jumped to his feet. “Gibson, there’s reports of shootings on 95th and State. Rosello’s territory. Looks like his boys are fighting each other. This turf war sounds like it’s about to be a civil war.”

Will looked up, dazed. Tapp hung up the phone and pointed at her. “Sit tight, Maddox. We need someone to stand by. Strahm, you too.” She looked like she had swallowed an egg, fury in her scowl. Everyone else had run out of the room, off to adventures and danger.

He decided the best course of action was to let her cool down for the next hour. In the meantime, he got up to stretch his legs, walked around the room and studied the various cork boards that had pictures of suspects and connections, bound with twine in a spider web of leads and theories. This latest installment would hopefully paint a clearer picture of any of Rosello’s vulnerabilities. His most trusted allies were listed and Strahm studied them to search for the likely culprit who was currently making the power play. Hoffman’s face was beside one mean looking ogre of a man named Olaf. Below, there was a pointed face man who had risen in ranks fast. Someone with no previous criminal history, which raised a flag.

“Maddox,” Strahm tapped the picture, “Who’s this guy?”

Will squinted up at the picture. “That’s Mario Amoretti. Some distant cousin to Rosello. He’s kept his nose clean, or more likely, covered any criminal activity he’s been involved in. We don’t have much for you to build a decent profile.”

He nodded. “Shame we can’t interview him.”

She raised an eyebrow. “Too bad. You can read people well enough after just one meeting?”

“Usually.” He folded his arms, looking down at her. There was skepticism and intrigue in the way she bit her lip as she looked him up and down.

“You know, I’ve been morbidly curious. What was your impression of me?”

He smiled. “Are you sure you want to know?”

“Psychoanalyze me, Special Agent.” She cocked her chin up, a small smile on her pink lips.

“Fair warning,” he took slow steps closer to her, taking in the array of freckles on her cheeks and the amber irises that glowed back. “No one’s ever pleased with what I tell them.”

“I can take it.”

He sniffed, rubbing his nose. “You’re a people pleaser with,” he paused for the least offending words, “a strong conviction that you need to prove you’re capable by maintaining independence. But deep down, you just want people to like you.” He waited for her to react before he dared to continue.

She rested her elbow on the table, propping her chin up. “Go on.”

He rounded the table, feeling it safe to get closer. “You have a tendency for irrational convictions and take things personally when decisions are made despite your convictions.”

This got a reaction from her. “Like how?”

“Your faith in your corrupt partner, despite everyone telling you otherwise. Your need to do things yourself, even if the risk of your safety is astronomically greater than your colleagues. You want to be the hero.”

“Don’t we all? Part of the appeal.” She began to lose interest, turning away. “My turn.”

He took a seat next to her, now his curiosity peaked. “You think you can profile me?”

“Just flexing my talents.” She turned sharply, her hand reaching out to take his hand. He felt his pulse quicken as he held his breath. She ran her fingers over his palms, an intimate contact that felt so gentle and soothing he almost forgot where he was. Her hands were soft. They locked eyes, her face lovely.

He swallowed as the air had become thick. She leaned forward and kissed the meat of his palm, a sweet and gentle smile shining back at him. “You’re amazing, you know that?”

He could hear his heart in his ears and he struggled to get words to come out. “I’ve been told.”

But then she dropped his hand, the smile becoming cruel. “I’m not the only one with a savior-complex, you know. Like you. When you look at me, I see there’s pity… and something else.” Her eyes went warm to icy. “You find me attractive. And think you can save me. Or have me. But your vague summary of my person could be applied to anyone, like a daily horoscope. But you haven’t said anything that I’d find particularly insightful. You don’t know how hard I had to work to get to where I am today or how hard it is to keep respect in a precinct that sees you as some helpless little girl that they want to fuck. Is that all I am, Strahm?”

“No,” he felt she was misunderstanding. His cheeks flushed red and he wanted nothing more than to go back in time just five minutes ago, before he fell into this trap. This was embarrassing but his pride was struck and wanted retaliation. “I’ve only just begun.”

“Rationally, a person who has just been in a dysfunctional and messed up relationship like mine would probably not be making the moves so soon.”

“Grief drive people to perform impulsive decisions,” he calmly said, refusing to back down, “such as this.”

She blinked. “Grief implies he’s dead.”

“I am not saying Frank’s dead. But you are experiencing a severe loss. Throwing yourself into environments of high stress is your knee jerk reaction, as evident by your fixation with returning to the field when your bones are broken. Get over it, Will.” His palm, where the phantom sensation of her touch still remained, began to itch.

She huffed, glaring back. “Easy for you to say.”

“Yeah - I get it, I’m not a woman who works in this crooked department, so it’s easy for me to just go about life. But I’m not your enemy, Will. Far from it. I want to be your friend.”

“Why?”

He was at a loss. “Because you’re a good person.”

“You don’t know that.” She shrunk back into her seat, looking away. Her hand haphazardly went to her wrist brace.

“Actually, I do. It’s kind of my job.” He pulled her hand, squeezing it. “I can tell you care about others. You’re just going through a bad time but that does not dictate who you are. I respect and admire you. Your work ethic. Your stubbornness. Your need to lead. I want to experience your company more, though I admit, maybe my intentions aren’t purely platonic,” he cleared his throat, “but I never said I was perfect. I apologize. It was tactless, especially after all you’re going through right now.”

She shot him a forgiving grin. “Okay. I’m sorry too. I admit, you’re pretty good at making me hate you less.”

“I’m relieved.” He released her hand, wanting to try to restore some boundaries they had just taken down. Looking around for something to change the subject, the clock saved him. “It’s almost lunch time. How about I go on a food run? What are you hungry for?”

She blinked, checked the clock, then yawned. “Yeah. Let’s actually get out of here. I need to stretch my legs. They’ll page me if they need us, though I doubt they will. Oh, and can you give me a ride after work? Buddy?”

Her suddenly sunny disposition made him now nervous, wondering if this was another trap. “Sure.”

Mark Hoffman

His pager had gone off at an inconvenient time. He and Matthews had just returned to the station to book Jonas Singer. While the man’s fingerprints were being retaken, Hoffman excused himself to head to the nearest phone. As he rounded the corner, he recognized the familiar fluffy red curls walking beside a taller figure.

Will was being guided down the stairs, Peter Strahm holding her elbow as he aided her. He ground his teeth and ripped the phone off the receiver, punching in the number.

The man picked up promptly. “Get to my place now.” The dial tone followed.

Not wanting to anger Rosello any more, he made his way straight to his estate.

Pulling up, it looked like a fucking family reunion was taking place. He parked his Crown Vic at the nearest space while suited men walked around with bandoliers and belts of armaments, jaws throbbing from chewing tobacco. They looked ready to bite heads off.

The front doors were wide open, mud being tracked all over the imported carpets and polished wooden floors.

“Markie-boy, get your ass in here,” Rosello came in, draped in a giant teflon suit of armor, cigar hanging out the corner of his mouth. A tommy gun was snug in the man’s off hand as he scratched the stubble on his double chin.

“Yes, sir?” It was always safe to be respectful. Especially when the man had a gun in his hand.

“A couple of your boys are getting in the way.”

“Where? I can try to get them to stand down,”

“Don’t bother, the guys they’re currently after are chump change. Your boys can keep ‘em for all I care. Though I want my no good piece of shit cousin’s boys kept alive. For now. Give ‘em a call.” Rosello chin-jerked to the nearest phone.

Hoffman went to call it in. The operator, familiar with his calls, relayed in a bored tone, “The action’s just about over, they managed to get a cease fire. I’ll have a couple of uniforms guard the recently arrested.”

“Good. Make sure there’s eyes on ‘em around the clock. Thanks, Rita.” Hoffman hung up, observing as Rosello barked orders to his goons.

“What do you mean you lost him? Where could that piece of shit fucked off to?”

The phone rang and Hoffman answered it. “Yeah?”

“Tell Toni that I’ll be at the farmhouse. Let’s end this now.” Whoever was on the line hung up.

“The farmhouse,” Hoffman stated to the expecting faces, “They said they wanted to end things now and they’ll be at the farm house.”

“Oh, that’s how he wants to play it? Now that I’ve wiped out all his pawns, he wants to make a last stand? Fine. You’re coming, Markie-boy, time you’ve earned your keep.” Rosello waved as he quickly walked through hallways full of his goons, men preparing for war. Hoffman kept his head level, not wanting to ponder if this was the end. But that damn thought wiggled through. He wondered if he was ever going to see Angelina again. If Will would know he died helping Toni Rosello.

“Catch, big man,” Rosello tossed an AR-15 towards him. Hoffman caught it, warily checking the safety. “Help yourself to what’s in here. We’re leaving in five minutes. FIVE MINUTES YOU FUCKBOYS!” Rosello screamed at the top of his lungs as he lurched out of the room.

It was an armory.

Hoffman would have normally admired and drooled over the various weapons that even MPD didn’t have in their SWAT locker. He recognized an RPG and his giddy, inner child wanted nothing more than to take it off the wall. But it wasn’t too practical.

He put on a bullet proof vest, a fleeting wish for more time to make just one phone call gone as he ran out of time. He gathered ammunition. Practiced reloading the rifle, then made his way to war.

Rosello had him sit in the back of the limo with him and Olaf. Hoffman looked out the window, adrenaline racing through every pore of his body.

“It was my no good piece of shit cousin Mario. Been stealing from the family for years. When I confronted him, he tried to stage a coup. I swear, my Aunt tried to drown him in a well when he was born. That fucker’s an idiot, but one tough sonofabitch. Wouldn’t fucking die. Let’s finish what zietta started. Mario thinks he can try to move in and take my territory? We need to send a message. To him and any other idiots who think they can fuck with me.”

They drove far out of the city until frost covered fields that once held corn spread as far as the eye could see. A fog was moving in, which would complicate things.

The rumble of the tires on gravel made Hoffman brace himself. They were approaching a distant barn and silo, with a separate residence several hundred feet away. Once the vehicle stopped, Rosello flew out of his car, spraying bullets up in the sky.

“MARIO!” Rosello was spewing profanities in Italian, English, and just gurgled sounds that barely sounded like language and more the muscle-jerk rage noises of a feral animal.

Their entourage swarmed behind and Rosello had his army loyally behind him. Olaf and Hoffman followed suit, Hoffman scanning the area for any potential hostiles. The barn silo had no windows, though there were plenty in the other buildings. They were sitting ducks. Stupid, this is stupid.

Out of the barn walked a stocky man, shiny black hair slicked back and pocked skin from a long youth of acne. “What’s up, Two-Ton?” He had a high pitched voice, equally as nasally as his cousin’s.

“Don’t Two-Ton me, you asshole,” Rosello pointed his tommy gun at his cousin.

“Ah!” Mario held his hands up. “Wait! Before you shoot, I recommend looking behind me.”

“I am, don’t see shit in this fog.”

“Oh.” Mario turned around and let out a small laugh. “Damn, this was all a lot cooler in my head.”

“Can I shoot him?” Hoffman asked, breaking protocol. He was tired of this conversation.

“Yeah, do it.”

“I SAID WAIT!” Mario stomped his foot, a sneer on his mouth. “You never listen! There are snipers behind me! And they’ll take you and all your men down. You can kill me, but not before dying yourselves!”

“Doubt snipers can see through this fog,” Hoffman muttered, no longer feeling as afraid for his life as he thought.

Toni snickered. “Oh, cousin, you idiot.” And then the first bullet was shot.

Hoffman wasn’t sure who shot first but the first splatter of blood on his cheek made him go straight for Rosello, tackling him down to the ground. He just reacted.

As soon as he pulled the mob boss to the dirt, he realized he had made a terrible error.

He had just ‘rescued’ his slavemaster.

But now, his ears were ringing and the muffled pounding of rapid shots being fired made him crawl towards the nearest vehicle for cover. He wasn’t going back for Rosello. He needed to just survive.

The white mist everywhere made things hard to pick out. But Hoffman was already on his feet, squatting and ready to shoot first and ask questions later.

He… may have been shooting at allies. He couldn’t be too sure. It was either them or him. He chose them.

Anyone who came across his line of fire, he let them have a taste of lead. One after the other.
Blood sprayed whenever he made his mark. And he kept shooting until his gun was empty, which he then rapidly reloaded with another magazine until those, too, were out. He felt a sharp sting in his upper arm. One bullet got him right in the vest and punched through his sternum with enough force to knock the wind out of him. He had to lean against the cold steel of the car to remember to breathe.

Eventually, the gunfire had ceased.

There was little beyond a couple of death rattles, moans, and the faint high pitched ring in his ear when he finally felt brave enough to stand. The sun was setting and the darkness seeped in the air fast. But the fog had begun to clear, allowing the distant barn’s lights to illuminate the carnage.

Bodies were strewn, each with their own personal halo of ink on the gravel.

Hoffman took careful steps forward, sweeping the area.

“Markie-boy,” Rosello called behind him and he swung around with his rifle pointed. He was empty, though, having been out for a while. “Easy, boy,” Rosello held a hand up but another hand held a pistol trained at him. “You did good. Take a breath.”

Hoffman kept his weapon trained for a moment before lowering it.

“You surprised me today, Markie-boy,” Rosello walked up with a pleased smile. “Consider your test of loyalty proven. Your baby sister? She’s part of the family now. She’s now under my protection.”

Hoffman blinked, nodded. Inside, in the recesses of his skull, his brain screamed and howled until a dull migraine began to claw at his temples. He turned so Rosello wouldn’t see his eyelid begin to twitch.

(Power of Will)

He stopped his car, a decent parking spot right outside his building. Things are looking up, he sarcastically thought. Getting out of the car, he noticed he was being watched. Across the street, he recognized Will and her new pal as they looked over. She waved with a lukewarm smile, getting out of the passenger side of the car. Strahm had reached out, his hand grabbing her arm to tell her something before she left.

He didn’t need to see this shit right now. He turned to get out of the cold and into the lobby of his apartment building. He tried not to think about how chummy those two were getting. He just touches her like he knows her. Like there’s something there. He was too tired and ready to just start punching walls.

He checked the mail, noting that Ange had sent him an early Christmas card. He smirked. Even though they saw each other regularly, she always went the extra step and sent him letters. It made getting all the junk mail bearable.

The door opened again, cool air wafting through. He kept his back to her, pretending the latest pamphlet on local produce was the most fascinating read of his day.

“Hey,” she breathlessly greeted, the sensation of her closeness making it hard to not look at her.

“What do you need?” He gave her a side glance, frustrated he had forgotten how beaten up she looked. This made him soften to her. “You okay?”

“Yeah. I just. I want to check in. See how you’re doing.”

That’s rich. He would have been insulted if it had been any other day, her feeling compelled to check on his state as though he was some vulnerable pet. “As you can see, I’m fine.”

She let out a small laugh. “Okay, okay, yeah.” She leaned against the counter. “Well, maybe I just miss you. And I wanted to apologize this morning.” She smiled, looking like an innocent angel. “And about the whole Frank thing.” She was chewing her lip, clearly pained to continue, “I… think you’re right.” She winced up at him. “Maybe you could find him. But,” she held a finger up, “No funny business. Promise me.”

He blinked at her. “What?” He wasn’t sure if he heard her right. His eardrums were still sensitive from all the gunfire. One of the fellow apartment residents walked by, raising an eyebrow at the two of them.

She blinked, now concerned at the public space. “Can we go up to your room? It’s cold here. And I think I could really use a drink right now.”

He knew she was stalling but he nodded, leading the way to the elevator. She was slow but he spent the extra seconds at her slower pace to get his story straight. His arm was bleeding and needed to be tended to. His chest was bruised to hell. And if he had heard right, he was now going to have to somehow conclude Frank Griffin’s case. He was thrilled at her finally trusting him. But concerned at how he was going to fix the mess he had made.

Once in his apartment, he noticed Will was looking around as though it was her first time. “Nothing’s changed,” she murmured as she collapsed into her usual spot on his couch.

“Whiskey?” He was already taking one of the bottles off the top of the fridge and preparing their drinks.

“Yes,” she sighed as she pulled the velcro off her walking boot. She propped her leg onto a pillow and leaned back, as though she owned the place.

He hesitated pouring into her glass. “Aren’t you on some painkillers?”

“One drink won’t kill me. And if I get groggy, I can just crash here. Unless you’re planning on having company?” There was a mild challenge there and he smirked at how obvious she was.

“Just another date with a tall, busty blonde.”

“Oh, then don’t let me get in the way. Pretend I’m not here,” she turned to face him, tying her hair up into a bun. “You haven’t taken your jacket off yet.”

He looked down at his black coat. “I’ll get it off in a bit.”

“You usually throw your coat off as soon as you’re home.” She raised an eyebrow.

“You’re reading too much into this. You learn that trick from your new fed buddy?” He rounded to the couch with the drinks, not wanting to raise any alarms. His plan was to act natural and she’d be none the wiser. “Here. I’m going to take a shower.” He handed her the drink and turned to leave.

Her hand shot out, cool on his warm wrist. She gripped and pulled gently. “You have dirt under your nails, like you were clawing the ground.”

He pulled but she put her drink down and tugged at him to sit beside her. He could have resisted. He outweighed and out-powered her. But the concern in her face pulled at him, eyes making him feel hypnotized.

He was fucking exhausted. He sighed and sat down, ready for her freakout.

“You’re bleeding!” She was already unzipping and opening up his jacket, noting the bullet proof vest. “I knew you looked huskier than usual.” His raised eyebrow made her shrug. “Either you gained weight since this morning or you were suited up. What happened?” She went to put on her boot but he stopped her.

“Relax. It’s fine. Just a nick. Nothing serious.”

“Were you involved with that turf war?” She was immediately scared, pale and panicked, trying to put her walking boot back on. “Where’s your first aid kit?”

“I’ll tell you what happened, if you promise to not move. I’ll get the first aid kid. Just. Stop freaking out like my mother.” He got up and went to retrieve the kit, exasperated by her behavior but starting to just accept that this was the price of being partners with her. Returning, she sat upright, as though ready to leap up at him.

“Fuck. Relax.” He tossed the kit onto the cushion and took his jacket off, slowly. His chest felt as though he had been horsekicked. He normally wore dark shirts to hide the blood, but this time, he had opted for a lighter blue. Now, it was ruined. He unbuttoned the shirt, wiping up dried blood flakes and clot that was still running down his arm.

“Yeah, relax, as you’re actively bleeding on your carpet.” She gestured for him to sit and he complied, half enjoying her crooning. He retrieved his drink and took a long sip, feeling the edge evaporate as her cool hands and a damp alcohol wipe brushed against his skin. The sting was obnoxious but he barely flinched.

“This is deep, Mark,” she looked at him with concern. “I think you should get stitches.”

“There's a needle and thread. Save me the trip.”

She laughed. “Seriously?”

“If you want to know what happened,” he knew urgent care meant the doctor would need to know what happened. Bullet grazes meant an official report. More paperwork to shred. If she wouldn’t do it, he planned to as soon as she left.

“I do,” she shook her head. “Fine.” She dug through his kit, sanitizing her hands and needle. “I’ll try to be gentle.”

“You couldn’t hurt me, Will, even if you tried,” he smirked at her. Her face made him want to snicker, she looked confused.

“Any head injuries?”

“No. I’m just giving you a hard time.” He hissed when he felt her use the needle on him. “Fine. You can hurt.”

“Don’t you forget it,” she grumbled as she connected the first stitch of skin together. “So tell me. What happened?”

“Rosello’s cousin. Tried to become the new kingpin. Then they decided to have a game of sudden death out in the farmlands. I had to come along.” He paused when he realized she was crying. “Hey, it’s fine.”

“No. You could have died, Mark,” she blinked and kept sewing, each new stitch a sharp jolt up his arm. “You should have told me.”

“Didn’t have a lot of time. Got the call and it was minutes after.” She didn’t respond, instead finishing up the stitch work and tying the knot. Once done, she went to put the supplies away and wiped her eyes. “Hey,” he reached forward, “I’m here. Don’t cry.”

She punched him gently in the chest. “You asshole.”

He let out a rattled gasp and clutched his chest. She flinched. “Oh my God!” She leveraged herself over him to see his chest. “I didn’t know! I’m sorry!”

He clutched his eyes tight. “It’s. Fine.”

He heard her shuffle and limp towards the kitchen. After the sound of the freezer door opening and the rattle of ice, a numbing cold touched his chest and the pain was taken away by the distracting cold. She had put peas on his chest, wrapped in a towel.

She dug through her bag. “Hey. Take some of my pills. It’ll help.”

“Thanks, Mother Theresa,” he smirked but took the painkillers happily with a whiskey chaser. He lazily rested his head into the backseat cushion, looking up at her. “What did you want to talk about?”

“Oh,” she wrung her hand. “Just. Forget it. You’ve got a lot on your plate.”

“No. Tell me.” He took her hand and pulled her back to the couch. “You want me to find Frank?”

“So you did hear me,” she sighed. “Yes. Just. Please be by the book on this one.”

He studied her carefully, pressing the ice bag against his chest.. “What changed your mind?”

She avoided his gaze. “I want the divorce finalized. The sooner we find him, the sooner it can get done. Also, I realized I need to trust people more. Especially you. Because I know you’re a good man who deserves a fair chance.”

He studied her and wondered what she meant by that. Hell, saving Rosello sure didn’t feel like something a good man would do. He rested his eyes, shutting them to let his mind wander.

After a few minutes, he opened them and turned to Will. She had her hand on her chin, leaned against the couch with her eyes wandering over him. Once they locked eye contact, she looked away, now blushing. He looked down, noting his chest was clothed with just a thin singlet. She was checking me out. A knowing smile just barely broke over his expression.

“Shut up,” she hissed, crossing her arms.

“I didn’t say anything,” he sat up, taking in her defensive stance. “Pretty inappropriate, Maddox. What would Grissom say?”

“I said shut up,” her cheeks were as red as her hair. It was cute. He let out a laugh and she shot him a dirty stare. Fuck it. I almost died today. He leaned over her, letting the ice pack fall to the floor.

“What - what are you doing?” She was stuttering, trapped behind the arm rest as she looked up at him. “You should take it easy, you’re injured.”

“So are you.” His hand made its way to her cheek, pulling her face closer to his. The faded blemishes, he wanted to kiss better. He chose to start straight for the kill.

He pushed his mouth onto hers, half open and hungry, letting all of the painful wanting to simply have for just a moment. She inhaled sharply but didn’t pull away. She leaned into him, rotated her head for a better angle and deepened the kiss. Her tongue was playful, exploring him with as much fervor as he. This was an interesting revelation, something he hadn’t been sure was wishful thinking or if she, too, had been attracted to him.

Her fingertips dug into his shoulders and he pulled her spine into his to feel her breasts press against his chest. It half-hurt from the gunshot bruise but shot sporadic energy from his head down to his groin and he growled deeply at being reminded of all the places he had to see and never touch. She tasted of mint and cherry chapstick and as he continued feeling her lips against his, he let his hands wander down her back. He wanted to feel her bare skin but the damn shirt was in the way.

Once he found his way to her belt, he let his hands wander down to her buttocks but she flinched and pushed away. “Wait,” she was breathless and flushed, pupils dilated. “This is too fast.”

“We can go slow,” he whispered, leaning in to kiss her neck, tasting the salt on her skin. She leaned into his mouth for a moment, moaning before shaking her head. “No, let’s stop.”

He complied, though begrudgingly. “Why?” After a painful silence, he pressed on. “Is it the fed?” As soon as the words came out, he realized he had royally fucked up.

“What is that supposed to mean?” She pushed, now on his chest and he hissed and backed away obediently. “Has it occurred to you that it’s about Frank still being out there? And not some random FBI Agent I happen to work with?” She got to her feet, gathering her things.

Hoffman’s head was spinning, the sensation of her lips no longer against his like a painful withdrawal. But a comforting thought helped make it more bearable. She wasn’t interested in Strahm. That was something.

“Maybe,” she continued with a shrill voice, “it’s because you’re still working for an unstable serial killer who has it in for me? And us - doing anything - will just make him come after you? Rosello’s already putting you in situations that risk your life. And if he hurts you because of me,” she choked and shook her head. “I won’t let that happen. I refuse.”

“Hey.” He reached over and put his hands on her trembling shoulders. “I’ll be fine. Don’t worry about me.” He tried to hug her but she pulled away.

“No, not until Rosello is out of the picture.” She wiped more tears and left. “I’m sorry, Mark. I care about you. I really do.”

And she left.

Hoffman stood there, watching the door for a few moments before taking his empty glass and returning to the kitchen. He poured himself another drink and stared sullenly at it. He took it like a shot, letting the heat warm through his chest.

And then he slammed the tumbler onto the ground with all his strength, shattering the glass.

Chapter 15: Pre-Saw: Angelina Meets John Kramer

Summary:

Angelina meets John Kramer and Jill Tuck.

Will has to come to terms with Frank being gone.

Some thoughts from Daniel Rigg.

Chapter Text

Angelina Hoffman

Angelina was rushing an order of salmon filet to cater for the annual city charity gala hosted by the most elite and influential socialites around. She turned to her saucier, making sure the honeyed lemon sauce had the right color. “Did you add the rosemary yet?”

“Two more minutes. Just want to thicken it a bit more.” The man was whisking away while she took a spoon to taste.

She nodded, “Great, this needs to be ready to go in five.”

“Will do.”

The day had been the typical level of fast-paced and fiery. Various dishes of roast beef, rice pilaf, and seasoned quinoa were gathered, carefully packaged, and sent off to the dining hall. Though the kitchen and venue were foreign to her, Angelia adapted and had the carts loaded and the bussers swiftly bringing the fresh food off to feed the hungry patrons.

Angelina stepped out of the sweltering kitchen, wiping sweat off her brow, being stopped by a short blonde in a long muted green frock. “The champagne station needs some attention.”

“Right away Dr. Tuck,” Angelina went to retrieve several bottles of champagne and followed the woman who moved like a cheetah in her high heels, clicking her way across the polished wooden floors with echoing prowess.

“Jill. Please. And thanks so much for this,” Jill spun her head around with a sparkling smile, “I know how booked you get this time of the year.”

“Anything for a good cause,” Angelina was balancing five pricey bottles while eyeballing crystal flutes neatly lined up. “Besides, if it wasn’t for the Kramer Foundation, I would never have afforded college.”

Jill nodded with that perfectly political grin. “Ah, I never knew you were a beneficiary. The Foundation is more John’s work. I just help with event planning.”

“No need to be so humble,” A whispery voice sounded behind Angelina. Whirling around, she was face-to-face with an older man with sharp features and a cool stare. His smile cracked his intimidating presence. “Ah, thank you,” he held out his hand and Angelina handed him a bottle. He placed them on the table and added, “It warms my heart. Seeing such potential and promise begin to succeed. I remember you, Angelina.”

“Oh, wow!” Her face burned. “Thank you, I didn’t know I left such an impression.”

“Such a tragedy, about your parents. Good people. How is your brother?”

“He’s doing well. He’s a detective with the police department.”

“A respectable role. A protector of the people. You must be proud of him.”

She blinked, feeling as though he was intending to sound ironic. He had a funny way of talking. “Yes, well, he does his best.” She must have been imagining it.

“Now, John,” Jill put a hand on his arm. “Stop being so intense. It’s a party. You’ll need to lighten up if you’re going to attract any new investors.”

“That, my dear, should not be hard.” John kissed Jill on the crown of her head. “These housing developments would do so much for the city, they would only say no if there was some serious absence in morality with them.”

Angelina couldn’t help but notice the pitying look Jill gave her husband. It was so quick and so fleeting as she murmured, “But it wouldn’t hurt to remind them there’s money to be made as well.”

“Ah, Jill, your cynicism always amazes me, considering your line of work.” John explained with a toothy beam, “She operates the Homeward Bound Clinic, you see. And if I recall,” his eyes wandered the grand hall of colorful chandeliers and sconces, “we met at an event similar to this one. Only Jill was the one requesting funding from me.”

“Oh, right,” Angelina nodded, not sure what clinic he was referring to but too embarrassed to ask. These two are trying for the Nobel Peace Prize.

“I can’t believe it’s only been a year,” Kramer softly cooed to Jill. “It feels like I’ve been your husband my whole life.”

“Oh, you,” Jill swatted at him and giggled. The newlyweds fawned over each other while Angelina awkwardly went to leave the two lovebirds to their flirting while she went to continue setting up for the gala.

I hope Peter and I look that cute, she surmised, wistfully looking back at them before returning to work.

Mark Hoffman

“Please,” Frank Griffin was on his knees, the chains rattling on his ankle as he stared up piteously. “I promise, I won’t say your name. I’ll make up a story. I’ll leave town. I’ll do anything. Just let me go. Please.”

“Your call, Markie-boy,” Rosello called out behind Hoffman, blowing smoke over his shoulder. “You gonna risk Red finding out how you’re treating her worse half?”

The man was a hollow shell of his former self. Shivering, with a thick greasy beard growing in, the guy was wasting away in Rosello’s basement. Though the punk deserved exactly what he got, seeing him so pitiful was hard to stomach.

“I’ll figure something out.” Hoffman clenched his jaw. There was no point in regretting actions done. He just needed to find a way to make this problem go away. But he was late for work. It would have to wait another time. “Give me a few days. I’ll get him out of your hair.” He turned to the mob boss who puffed thoughtfully on his cigar. “Anything else?”

“Those feds. I want a name.”

“I’ve got one. Peter Strahm.” Fuck it. If Rosello could make the prick disappear, it would be doing him a favor at this point.

Rosello nodded. “Confirms it. They’re bringing in some bigshot profiler. I guess I should be honored.”

Hoffman chose not to respond, instead, gripping his wrist and waiting with forced patience. “You’ll need to avoid the spotlight for a while. The department’s on edge. They’re out for blood.”

“They’re always eager but they got nothing. They’ll get nothing, so long as you keep doing your job.”

“Speaking of.” He turned, “I need to go. I’m late.”

“Oh, while you’re there, look into Mickey Lounds.”

“What about him?” Hoffman tried to recall the face to the name but came up blank.

“One of my sweepers. Was picked up last night. He knows a little too much and if that dream team finds out it’s going to give me a headache. Find a way to drop the charges on him. Or kill him. Just get him out of your guys’ custody. Especially out of reach of any of those fucks in my personal task force.”

“Interesting options.” Hoffman cast one more glance in Frank’s direction. “But maybe we can kill two birds with one stone. If I needed a place to hide a body long term, you know a place no one would look?”

Allison Kerry

She was starting to lose track of time, being stuck in that godforsaken building for weeks now. Rituals helped her stay somewhat sane. She’d brew coffee. Tidied up her workspace. Checked in with Tapp. And then proceeded to pace the hallways.

She was now in the pacing phase of her morning routine.

When Allison turned the corner out onto the detective floor and saw Eric Matthews and Daniel Rigg whispering like they were up to no good, she had paused to consider interjecting herself between them.

Lately, Eric had been getting reckless. And his association with Rigg could only end with IA turning their magnifying glass to closely examine Eric’s tendency to punch first and ask questions never.

But she remembered why she hadn’t spoken to her partner lately and the still sharp sting in her chest reminded her she wasn’t ready to make peace. And so she turned around and decided to take the long detour around the station, her vision glazed.

“Hey Ally,” A familiar woman’s voice broke her out of her haze. She turned to see her roommate smile back at her, worry forming on her knit eyebrow. “Bad day?”

“Yeah,” she didn’t particularly feel generous with the information but thankful Will picked up her hints effortlessly. They stood off to the side, Will leaning against a crutch. She, too, had developed a habit of wandering the empty hallways and offices once there was no more paperwork to process.

“You busy? Angie said she wanted to talk about the wedding over lunch today. Plus, we need to get with the other bridesmaids to plan the bridal shower this week.”

“Oh, swamped.” She crossed her arms and let out a harsh laugh. “You know how it is.”

“Yeah,” Will let out a huff. “I seriously am losing my mind here.”

“Sorry to interrupt,” Sing approached the two of them with a frown, “But Will, we need you to come with us.”

“Sure, what’s up?” Will looked thrilled at the distraction.

But Kerry noticed how wide Sing’s eyes were, a disturbing look shined in them. She felt her throat constrict. “Need me to come along?” She softly asked Sing while gently placing her hand on Will’s arm.

“...Yeah.” Sing quickly glanced from Will back to Kerry. “Probably a good idea.”

Will was quicker on the uptake, tense and quiet as he lead them down to the basement. Through the heavy metal doors. Their shoes clicked on the dusty concrete and the air chilled.

The morgue. Shit. It had to be about Frank. There was no other reason.

Will kept her head held high, following Sing through the heavy metal doors. The clicking of their shoes echoed off the concrete walls and the air went cold. There was that faint smell of decay, sharp acid, and mildew.

The final double doors swung open. Tapp and the coroner stood waiting for them. Dr. Adam Heffner, their forensic pathologist, stood behind the metal slab with stoic countenance. A body bag rested, zipped, and disturbingly small for what Kerry assumed contained the remains of Frank Griffin.

“Is it him?” Will croaked, hands clasped together.

“Dental records were just confirmed.” Tapp held out the file which Will took half-heartedly. She flipped through the x-rays, shaking her head.

“So… this is it?” Her eyes were shining. “This is him?”

“Yes.” Sing cleared his throat. “We’re sorry for your loss, Will.”

“I want to see him,” Will whispered, clutching the folder to her chest.

“Are you sure?”

“Yes, I’m sure. Show me.”

Heffner proceeded to pull the black zipper down, revealing more black underneath.

Kerry clenched her fist when the charred skull revealed itself. He had been burned. Badly.

This already looked suspicious. Sneaking a glance at Will’s expression, she observed how Will had squeezed her eyes shut. Her jaw muscle twitched and her shoulders trembled.

“What happened?” Will sniffed and wiped at her eyes. “Was it an accident?”

“Doesn’t seem likely,” Tapp approached the body. “We’ll need to call in for a forensic anthropologist but Heffner suspects, based on the little tissue remaining, that the vic was restrained for several weeks.”

“There were also premortem fractures in the right tibia and fibula as well as several ribs and phalanges.” Heffner hovered his gloved hand over the right leg, up the torso, and then to both hands. “Indications of healing occurred in the phalanges, not properly set.”

“So he was in pain.” Will shook her head and went to collapse into the nearby stool. Kerry went closer to her to help her keep her balance. She was rubbing her temple before pawing through the file again, reading through the report. Her voice went incredulous and high-pitched. “Hoffman brought him in?”

“Holy shit,” Kerry gaped before going to read over Will’s shoulder with her. She scanned the important details. A farmer called in a strange bonfire on his land. This was days ago.

What looked especially disturbing were the circumstances on how Hoffman happened to just obtain Will’s husband, deceased. It was one hell of a coincidence. He was brought over by another department due to their being short-staffed. Grissom had signed off on it.

This stank of Rosello and Kerry already suspected Hoffman was likely part of the reason Frank was currently burnt toast on the gurney. But Hoffman wasn’t a killer. An asshole with impulse control, sure. But not a murderer. Or at least... not a murderer that would pull an idiot move like this.

“I told him not to kill him. I trusted him.”

Kerry blinked. “Hoffman?”

“I trusted him!” Will started to cry, shoulders violently shaking as she covered her face.

“Hoffman and Matthews are currently interrogating the suspect responsible. Some guy named Lounds.” Sing, of all people, was coming to Hoffman’s defense. “Let’s not jump to conclusions, at least until the case is closed. Evidence says Hoffman didn’t kill the guy.”

“Though this Lounds guy is getting shipped off to the next county, considering the murder was supposedly committed outside the city. Which is convenient,” Tapp had crossed his arms and shook his head. “I had a feeling this would happen after we uncovered Lounds has some dealings with Rosello.”

“So it was Rosello who did this?” Will’s tears slowed but she was still furious. “Not Hoffman?”

“Hoffman has an alibi,” Sing was grimacing, “But it would not be surprising to hear Rosello’s involved. Considering how he feels about… well, you. We need Strahm to verify if this would be characteristic of Rosello’s profile. I don't recall any of his past victims' having partners taken out like this.”

“Location and time of death occurred thirty miles outside of the city. We got the call a few hours ago. We’re expected to mail off the perp in the next twenty-four hours.” Heffner had his back to the detectives, putting his tools away as he droned on the facts.

“Touchy bastards,” Tapp was clearly displeased, shaking his head. “They could have at least given us a week before taking our latest bird.”

“Boys?” Kerry snapped her fingers and gestured to Will who was quietly wiping tears and staring down at the floor.

“Maddox,” Tapp’s tone softened, “How about you take the rest of the week off? Take as much time as you need. Get some rest. Kerry, you make sure she gets home all right.”

For once, Will didn’t argue. Kerry took Will by the arm and helped her leave the morgue.

Getting her to the car would have been a lot easier if Hoffman and Matthews hadn’t been standing at the top of the stairs. Great. More drama.

Mark Hoffman

“Will,” Matthews spoke first, a toothpick rolling between his lips, “so you’ve heard. Sorry it had to end up this way for you.”

Will merely nodded, avoiding their eyes. Her face was swollen and pink from crying.

She was taking it as well as he expected. A part of him had hoped she would have been glad. Hell, just relieved would have satisfied him. But there was only remorse and pain where she stood and this made him despise Frank Griffin all over again.

He had to remind himself that she had married this man and, though he never deserved it, she had loved him. And she loved hard and heavy. He needed to respect this and let her grieve for the loss of her chains.

What mattered was that she was finally free to move on. If he had been a better man, he would have felt some sense of guilt.

But he didn't.

“Hey, Ally,” Matthews took the toothpick out of his mouth, “Why not let Hoffman take Will home? I could use your help with something.”

Kerry threw a fiery stare in her partner’s direction. “Oh, now you want my help? Have some fucking sense, Eric.”

“I don’t care,” she muttered, shaking her head. “I can go home on my own.”

“I think it’s best you’re not alone right now. I’ll take you home,” Kerry rubbed Will’s back, lovingly.

“Come on, Ally, let Hoffman buy the kid some ice cream or something.”

Ice cream?” Kerry hissed, “You’re such a bastard, Matthews.” Her eyes flashed over to Hoffman. “I’m assuming this is just some ploy to swoop in on her now that she’s all broken-hearted? That’s tacky, even for you.”

That's rich, coming from you.

“Ally!” It was Will, despite her broken heart, who reached over to Kerry and calmed the situation down. Always the peacekeeper at the expense of herself. “It’s all right. I’ll be fine. I promise. Thank you,” Will gave her a hug, comforting though she was the one who needed comfort. My selfless angel. “I’ll go with Mark. We’ve got plenty to talk about.”

When she turned to him his sense of pride in her withered slightly. The way she stared up at him, he suddenly felt like a bug about to get stabbed with a needle and analyzed. Then again, angels are demons.

(Power of Will)

She didn’t argue when he reached the driver’s side first. He pulled out of the lot in silence, expecting her to be quiet, as she typically was when she was deeply troubled. But she didn’t stonewall him. “Tell me. Did Rosello kill Frank?”

He gave her a sidelong glance, remembering not to grip the steering wheel too tightly. “It’s a possibility.”

“Mark. Did you have anything to do with this?”

They had stopped at a red light. He took the opportunity to turn to her, taking her hand and squeezing it firmly. He looked into those amber irises. “I did not kill Frank.” A horn honked behind them and he flipped the light switch to turn on his light bar.

There was a pregnant pause as she searched his face. He made a point to keep his poker face as still as possible. Don't falter. Don't flinch. She sighed in relief, sinking into her seat. “I believe you. But… you didn’t answer my question. Do you know who killed him?”

“I don’t.” He let go of her hand to continue driving. “Hey. Don’t stress about this. Leave his murder to the detectives assigned to the case. Just -,” he suppressed a sneer and maintained an expressionless face, “mourn your husband. Move on. If you need me, I'm here." He cleared his throat, adding with risk to his health, "I’m not trying to be insensitive but he was a real bastard who didn’t treat you right. And now he’s finally gone.”

“How can you say that-,”

“Spare me, Wilhelmina. You always try to see the good in people but there are some people who just aren’t good. Frank was one of them. You’re better off now that he’s gone. And I’m not saying this because I’m trying to be self-serving, though it is in my benefit, but seeing you give that piece of shit everything only for him to just use and abuse you like he did - I’m glad he’s gone. I don’t want to see you wasting any more of your life worrying about his memory. You deserve so much better than that.”

He didn’t know what he had been expecting, but hearing Will wail and seeing her in full-blown ugly-cry mode made him grimace and park the car over to the nearest curb. He didn’t get it but clearly that had not been the right thing to say. But still. She was literally healing from the bastard breaking her bones. Frank had driven her to jump out of a five-story window because the alternative was so much worse.

“Will,” he put a hand on her shoulder. “I’m sorry. I’m not trying to hurt you.” He awkwardly shuffled across the bench seat to put an arm around her, hoping his previous experience comforting Angelina would be of some use. He tapped her back in a 'there, there' motion.

She didn’t pull away, which was promising. “I know. I know he was a real bastard. But he was mine." He stiffened at this. "He was my everything. He was my home. You didn’t know him, not like I did. He wasn’t always this way,” she held up her broken wrist, “he was once kind and loving. And I always hoped I’d get him back. I always held out that there was a chance he’d come back to me. That he'd change back. But now,” she broke again in a fit of sobs, “that’s never going to happen.”

“I see.” He didn’t know what to say to console her. He resumed awkwardly patting her back. “Even though he’s gone. You have the memories. Of the good times.” He felt his words were hollow but he had to try something. It was like chewing sawdust but he kept going. “I didn’t know the guy that well but it was clear he had issues. Maybe he was lost for a while before this happened. I’m sure Frank’s in a better place, now.” He clenched his teeth at that. He wasn’t sure exactly if Will was a religious person or not, but the very idea made him wonder if he had spoken the truth inadvertently. If there's an afterlife, the bastard's going to hell for sure.

Will sniffled and buried her face into his chest, her shoulders rising and falling under his hand. He rested his chin on the crown of her head. A part of him wondered if she would ever cry for him the way she cried for the man that hurt her.

“You’re so damn forgiving,” he muttered as he pushed his mouth against her hair, wanting to simply steal her sorrow away, as the sweet smell of her shampoo filled his nose.

He couldn’t fully enjoy the moment, though, as the hairs on the back of his neck prickled. He lifted his face and swept the area, trying to see something out of the ordinary in the late afternoon. The car’s windows were fogging but he thought he recognized a car several yards behind his, parked with a silhouette in the driver’s seat.

Rosello’s goons. He pulled Will tighter to him, the need to protect rushing through him. He should have noticed. But he had gotten lazy, thinking he had finally convinced Rosello he could be trusted. So he had let his guard down.

There was no denying it, now. Frank Griffin was finally out of the picture, but Will wouldn’t be safe until this new threat was neutralized.

He needed to find a way to get rid of Toni Rosello.

Daniel Rigg

Daniel Rigg had a love-hate relationship with the rumor mill that blew through the department minutes after some big juicy rumor reared its ugly head.

After he punched out that piece of shit at the school, he had personally experienced the hammer strike of the whispers. The stares. The sudden cold shoulder. But there were also a few who smacked him on the back and whispered, “Atta boy,” in the locker room where no one else could hear their unpopular opinions.

But it also let him get the latest update on the people around him. He admitted it. He was a nosy asshole. But he liked knowing the ins and outs of his colleagues. He’d like to think it helped him be a bit more empathetic and understanding when he knew the full story of their situation.

He knew Kerry and Matthews were more than just professional partners, thinking they were so slick with hooking up in broom closets in the station basement.

He knew about Sing’s sick mother, whom he often had to leave work early to run errands for.

He even knew about how that FBI agent, Perez, was making the moves on Kerry. It explained the falling out Matthews was currently experiencing.

And after lurking in the breakroom, he now knew that Maddox’s husband was a toasted marshmallow chilling in a morgue fridge drawer. The latest gossip was that after the big reveal, Hoffman had taken Maddox home. That had been last night. This was what gave him pause when he walked in on Hoffman shredding some documents in the mailroom.

They both stared each other down as the whining of the shredder rang in his ears.

“Need something?” Hoffman continued feeding papers into the blades, drowning the room in more violent motorized screams.

“No - no, just passing through.” He went to the many cubby holes of letters, his holding a single envelope. He snuck another glance over, curious as to what the guy was getting rid of. There was plenty being said about how Mark Hoffman conducted business, though the whispers were more hushed and those who muttered any hearsay would often pause to look around, to make sure they weren’t caught.

“How’s SWAT training?” Hoffman appeared done with his destruction, leisurely checking for any postage in his slot. He stood only inches from him, the smell of his aftershave hitting him hard.

“Great,” Rigg beamed back. Regardless of what most people thought of the guy, Mark Hoffman was one of the good ones. “Scheduled to graduate next month.”

“Good.” Hoffman smiled back. “And how’s Tracy?”

“She’s been good. Excited about Angelina’s wedding.”

Hoffman nodded. “Yeah, can’t believe it’s coming up. Angie’s been running around getting things ready.”

“Yeah. The bridesmaids are all throwing a party for her.”

“You going to that?”

“I’m just giving Tracy a ride. Maybe helping deliver some decorations. Being in a training status has given me some more free time. It’s been good for us.”

“Glad to hear it. If you can spare some of that free time,” Hoffman’s voice had gone quiet, “I need a favor.”

“Yeah? Name it.” Rigg looked around real quick, leaning in.

“Can you keep an eye on them, Angie and Will? Maybe park outside the venue for the bridal shower.”

“What's the trouble?”

Hoffman seemed hesitant to explain. “Toni Rosello has his sights on Will and I can’t be around her all the time. Especially right now. Ange should have a pair of our guys on her but Will needs some looking after. She’d never admit it, though. Especially with her current condition.”

“Ain’t that the truth,” Rigg gave a sympathetic smile. Dead husband and still broken up from his beat down. Yeah, I bet. “She’s too proud.”

Hoffman nodded. “Whenever you can, check in on her?”

“Sure thing. I’m usually landlocked except for field exercise. I see Maddox around, mostly pacing.”

“Good. If anything strange goes on, keep me posted. Especially if she’s hanging around people that might push her to play hero. Especially Tapp and Sing.”

“Yeah. Will do.” Rigg suspected Hoffman was hinting at someone else, a faint idea of a certain federal agent crossing his mind. "I'll let you know if anyone starts overstepping their bounds."

"Good."

Chapter 16: Pre-Saw: The Funeral

Notes:

Finally got taken down by the COVID monster. FUCK.
But that means more time to write so... here ya go~

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

“I dreamed of Frank. We were on our honeymoon, taking a walk on the beach. But when I turned around, he was far away. In the water. I called out to him but he was so far away. He was drowning. I tried to go to him but the waves kept pushing me back. When I woke up, I reached over to feel for him. And then I remembered.” Will sighed through blurry vision as she swiped at the nearby tissue box to dab the new tears that seemed to continuously appear at the corner of her eyes.

“That must have been hard,” Peter Strahm leaned into her, elbows on his thighs. “How often have you been dreaming of him?”

“Almost every night since he died.” She looked out the window of his office, the distant sky dark and stormy. “I know I should move on. I need to. But every time I close my eyes, I see him.”

“You can’t force yourself to just forget the man you spent years with. No matter what you think you should be doing, you can’t deny your feelings. The sooner you accept them the sooner you can confront your pain and heal from it.”

"It's been months since I decided to leave Frank."

"He only died weeks ago, you only being allowed to put him to rest recently. It's understandable to have unresolved pain. It could take years to move on from the separation. Don't have expectations. Just take things one day at a time."

She nodded. “Yeah. You’re right.” She sniffled and blew her nose. “Thanks for seeing me. I know it was short notice.”

“Any time. I appreciate you coming to me with this. I assure you, it’s no inconvenience.” Strahm smile warmly. “As you know, work’s been slow.”

“Right? It’s so frustrating. Work helped me not think about life going to shit. But all this waiting around has been driving me up the wall.”

“This is not necessarily a bad thing. Try to take this time to work on yourself. Maybe take some leave. After the funeral.”

She tried to smile back but it felt forced. “Yeah. Maybe I should.”

“It’s tomorrow?”

“Yes.” She swallowed and shuttered, “Our relatives are flying in from California. I - I haven’t told his parents too many details. I wasn’t sure how to. They only know he was murdered. But they think it was quick and painless.”

"Gentle lies are a mercy. When the crime goes to trial, they can learn the sad truth."

"If it goes to trial."

Strahm nodded in sympathy. "I’d be happy to accompany you, if it would make it easier.”

“I may just take you up on that offer.” She nodded. “If it’s no trouble.”

“No trouble at all.”

“Thank you. You’ve been so helpful.” She felt a twinge of guilt, turning to this man she had only known for a few months for consolation and comfort instead of her closest friends. But Peter Strahm had never judged her. Never expressed any strong opinion on what she should or should not do.

Kerry, despite her good intentions, was clearly glad that Frank was gone. It had been obvious in how she grimaced whenever Will wanted to talk about him.

And Hoffman. Hoffman was so much worse when it came to listening about her ruminating about her late husband.

Peter Strahm had been the only person in her life that actually listened and made her feel a little better after every conversation. That was something she needed.

But this was something she wouldn’t brag about, especially not to her partner. It was clear he didn’t like Peter Strahm and she didn’t want any problems over this.

“Has your friends and family been there for you? I’m not trying to push you out, but I figured you’d find more friendly support with familiar faces.”

“Well, my only family is my dad and brother. Dad’s… not able to help right now. Bram is flying in, though. But he’s my younger brother. Usually,” she felt the faintest smile crack across her cheek for the first time in days, “I’m the one that helps him out.”

Strahm nodded, always the active listener, “You’re only human, Will. Got to let the people around you help out once in a while.” He had leaned in closer to her, putting a hand gently over her clasped fingers.

She blinked up at him, feeling her cheeks flush warm from the proximity between their faces. She pulled her hands from his, her skin tingling from his touch. “I need to head out.” She jumped to her feet, forcing Strahm to lean back into his chair as she rose from the couch. “I’ll see you at work?”

He nodded, appearing unphased by her fluster. “Tomorrow. I’ll come by your place in the morning, before the funeral.”

“Okay,” she felt rushed and eager to leave. She couldn’t get out of the door fast enough, limping to the elevator to then catch her breath. Maybe she misjudged Peter Strahm after all.

Eric Matthews

“Ally!” Matthews grabbed her arm, his cigarette falling out of his mouth. “Can you just - wait one minute so I can explain?”

“I’m sure you’ll need more than a minute.” She hissed icily. They were outside, the sun had long set and the street lights were not on yet.

“So what’s it going to be? You just going to hate me until the end of time?” He had hoped she would have gotten over it by then. It had been over a month now but it only seemed to snowball into one hell of an avalanche.

He’d never seen Ally so angry. And with him, nonetheless.

“Eric, I know what the risks are with this job. You have no right to get in my way.”

“I do.” Eric kept his grip on her arm, missing her touch. “I do have a right to protect the woman I love.”

“Oh, fuck off, Eric,” her voice cracked. “You don’t. You only love yourself.”

“You don’t mean that.”

“Tell that to Jane and Daniel. To me.”

“You can love more than one person, Ally. I’m sure you know that.” Eric looked into her eyes, daring her to deny it. “I know about you and Perez. And I know I have no right on being jealous about that. I'm not doing this to spite you for finding comfort elsewhere. Though, I admit, it's really hot." He dodged a slap from her, limboing backward quick, and added, "But when it comes to your safety, I will do everything I can to keep you out of harm’s way. Whether you like it or not.” He squeezed her arm tighter.

She tried to wrench her arm away but he held on. She bared her teeth in a snarl. “Asshole.”

He smirked and gave her a kiss, which she proceeded to return with a backhanded slap across his cheek. She hit her mark this time. He finally released her, touching the sting with newfound respect. “Does this mean we’re forgiven?”

“Not even close,” Kerry snapped. “The only way you’re going to make this up is if you get Will and me back in the field. Or I’ll tell Jane what we've done.”

He felt his jaw drop open. “You wouldn’t.”

“Wouldn’t I? Jane’s going to the bridal shower. And she’ll be at the bachelorette party.” Rage and intent were all that he saw when he studied her.

“You’re not a petty bitch, Ally.”

“Don’t make me a petty bitch, Eric,” she jabbed a finger into his chest. “And next time, ask before you go and try to bench me in my career. Or this,” she pointed at herself and him, “will never happen again.”

“You’re not thinking clearly.”

“Don’t be condescending. I know exactly what I’m doing. I always have, even when I fucked you the first time and every time after. But now, you’ve overstepped your bounds. You’re coming after the one thing I have. Literally, the only thing that’s actually mine. You fuck with my career again, I will end you.” He didn’t believe her. He couldn’t believe her.

And yet, there they were, at a bridge that was already showing signs of burning. But he wasn’t ready to let her go. Despite her skepticism, he did love her. They had survived worse together. She was his partner.

He studied her face, searching for a sign as to where everything went wrong. Ally, never one to be much of a crier, had the faintest signs of it in her eyes. Though her face was straight and her expression cool, he could feel the pain there. This was a cry for help. He needed to take heed.

“All right. I’ll listen. I’m sorry.” He hated apologizing. But she wouldn’t back down. And he just wanted her to stop hating him. “I’ll talk to Tapp. I’ll get you both out there.” He bit his lip. “I - I just don’t want anything to happen to you.”

“That’s your problem,” she left him, the heels of her shoes echoing behind her.

Alone, Eric quietly took out his pack of cigarettes from his inside jacket pocket. He put a fresh one in his mouth, lit it, and took a long drag. One step at a time, he forced himself to take a walk down the block.

His mind was reeling. His heart was pounding in his ear. He needed to hit something. He wanted to scream.

“Spare change?” A croak called from his side. He jumped and turned to see a filthy bum who reached a dirt-caked hand onto his suit, gripping the fabric. He could see the grease stains that would never get out now. “You have any change, mister?”

He blinked, wondering what happened next. His fist throbbed. He was hunched over a piss-covered corner, looking down at the mangled and bloody face of some bearded old man who was moaning and wheezing underneath him.

Fuck. His fist was trembling and his head was pounding.

The pitiful moans of the man filled his mind.

Eric Matthews walked as fast as he could away from the scene. Soon, his swift stride broke into a brisk sprint as he ran. He ran until he physically couldn’t any longer, collapsing in the street, panting and coughing.

It began to snow.

Steven Sing

It was a clear day. The sun helped warm the patrons draped in black, surrounded by white and soothing-colored flowers. Sing was surprised by how many people had come to Frank Griffin’s funeral.

It seemed, despite all the terrible stories, the man had apparently mattered enough to people that they came from across the country just to see him put in the ground. He noticed the lack of tears, though, and wondered if it was another reason beyond love that brought the majority of attendees to the event. Only Will and what appeared to be Frank’s mother were weeping and holding each other throughout the day.

The closed casket during the wake had attracted curious murmurs. Almost everyone who knew Will Maddox had attended and many unfamiliar faces more.

One notable absentee was Mark Hoffman, which didn’t surprise Sing at all. Hoffman had made it clear he never cared for the man. What surprised Sing was seeing Peter Strahm present as Will’s shadow, a hand on her shoulder, and stepping in to exchange words with those that offered the usual words of comfort to the surviving family. Odd.

Allison Kerry and Eric Matthews had stayed back, looking out from afar. It looked like the two of them had made their peace. It was a relief, considering the awkward conversations Sing tried to have involving the two of them.

Tapp elbowed Sing, prompting him to casually scan the area. In the distance, leaning against a black sedan, looked like Daniel Rigg. He wondered what he was doing there, not aware that the rookie had any interactions with Frank or Will for that matter.

“He’s close to Hoffman,” Tapp muttered and that explained everything.

The ceremony ended with the lowering of the casket and bagpipes bellowing Amazing Grace. Will and Mrs. Griffin continued to weep and upon completion of the ballad, the crowd dispersed.

Bram Maddox, Will’s younger brother, came up to take Will back to the car. Mr. Griffin appeared to pull Mrs. Griffin away from Will, taking the grieving mother away. There seemed to be no love lost between Mr. Griffin and Will, a notable squint and frown tossed over from Bram.

“Go talk to Rigg, Sing,” Tapp, always the vigilant one with his mind on the task at hand, added, “I’ll walk around. See if there’s anything interesting going on.”

By interesting, he meant Rosello related. Sing nodded, already dreading the awkward conversation they would likely have. He barely spoke to Daniel Rigg, not particularly impressed with the guy’s hot-headed impulses. He's like a baby Hoffman, and the thought made him shudder. Cautiously, he approached with a disarming grin, walking around the tombstones.

Rigg nodded back, arms folded across his broad chest. “‘Sup, Sing.”

“Hey, Rigg. Didn’t know you were acquainted with Frank Griffin.”

“I wasn’t. Just here for Maddox.”

“I’m sure she’ll appreciate that. You want to catch her before she drives off?” Sing looked over his shoulder, noting the idling car and two siblings through the glare of the windshield.

Rigg’s head shook quickly. “No. Best to let her be. I’m just making sure she’s safe.”

Sing noticed Rigg didn’t have his badge in view, though his gun was attached to his hip. “Off-duty?”

Rigg swallowed and looked away. “Yeah.” He wouldn’t volunteer any further information but Sing could connect the dots.

“I’m surprised I haven’t seen Hoffman around.” Sing leaned lazily against the car beside Rigg. “You talk to him lately?”

Rigg gave him a sidelong glance, the silence revealing everything.

The two of them stood at a verbal standoff until the last of the procession dispersed, red taillights shrinking in the distance. “Well,” Sing pushed off the car, “send Rosello my regards.”

“Fuck you,” Rigg spat as Sing walked away. He didn’t bother to look back.

Mark Hoffman

“Nothing out of the ordinary. Her brother’s in town. Looks like he’s still in college. And her in-laws didn’t stick around, they left pretty quick.” Rigg took a swig of his beer. “Oh, and she’s been heading uptown to talk to those agents. I notice she'd grab a bite to eat with the guy. And get this-Strahm-he was also at the funeral.”

Hoffman didn’t care for the sympathy Rigg was giving him, opting to stare at the TV over the shelves of liquor and letting the bartender refresh his glass of scotch. “You know what for?”

“Looked like he was being moral support or whatever you call it. Seemed PG, though I wouldn’t put it past the bastard to try to move in on the grieving widow. Never saw Maddox so upset.”

Hoffman shook his head. She’ll get over it. But this Strahm guy just kept appearing and invading his territory. He’d need to keep tabs on the asshole. On the bright side, tailing the fed wouldn’t step on Rosello’s toes. If anything, it would be the perfect cover, especially now that he was back on the mobster's shitlist.

Speaking of. “I’ve got to go.” He threw some cash on the bar and gripped his comrade’s shoulder. “Good work.”

“Yeah,” Rigg returned the contact, squeezing his fingers briefly before releasing, “Anytime, Hoffman.”

The night air felt damp, surprisingly warm for the time of year. He drove with the windows down, smelling rain in the air as he mentally prepared for his meeting with Toni Rosello. Images of his stalker from last week flooded his vision and the faintest grip of fear squeezed his heart when he thought of what would happen with Will if he slipped up that night.

There was no room for error. Absolutely none.

The estate, with its tall bricks and dead ivy, towered over him like a guillotine. Men with rifles across their chests nodded in his direction as he passed the gate and various checkpoints. He pulled onto the large gravel road, parking close to the front steps.

Olaf was waiting for him, opening the front doors and standing with hands clasped behind him. Hoffman half-expected the ogre to be hiding a weapon but walked by him calmly, barely paying the man any mind.

Show no fear. Show no weakness.

The smell of cigar smoke was a familiar stench and once Hoffman reached Rosello’s office there was the usual gray haze that stung his eyes. “Mr. Rosello.”

“Markie-boy,” Flicking ash in a crystal tray, Rosello gestured to the seat across from his desk.

The sudden clang and the piping of a cuckoo clock forced Hoffman to turn his head. “That’s new.”

“A gift from Mario’s brother. Zietta didn’t take it very well, the death of her youngest son and all. But Mario’s brother, Lorenzo, is happy as pie. But now I’ve got to be on my best behavior. Drives me crazy but at some point, the relatives are coming in and got to show off the gifts. You know how it is.”

He nodded, though he had no fucking idea what the hell he was going on about. He clasped his hands together, intertwining his fingers as he patiently stared at the mob boss to get to the point.

Rosello had a twinkling in his eye and a sly pull of the cheek. “Tell me, Markie-boy, what’s your deal with Red? I’ve been trying to figure it out for a while.”

“Didn’t know it was that important to you,” Hoffman lied, “We’re partners.”

“Haven’t been working cases together in a while.”

“That’s because of this arrangement, as you’re aware.”

Rosello nodded, “I get you boys in blue sure have a hard-on for your ‘partners’,” he fingered quotation marks, “but let’s be honest. You and her are more than that.”

Hoffman resisted the urge to clear his throat. “We’re close.”

“As close as you are with your sister?”

The room became a void. He finally cleared his throat. “You mentioned that you would keep my sister out of this. After what happened with Mario.”

“Oh, I haven’t forgotten,” Rosello scratched his jowl, thoughtful. “You see, every so often, I like you, Markie. You do what you’re told. You’ve got talents. But you’re one bull-headed prick at times. I know you’re just waiting for your chance to end me like Julius Caesar.” The shark-like dullness returned to his black eyes. “So I need some incentive to keep you behaved. You understand.”

Hoffman squeezed his teeth together, slowly. “Are you going back on your word, Mr. Rosello?” He spoke carefully but couldn’t help let the growing rage seep into his words.

“No, not at all. But I’m simply warning you that my offer for immunity only extends to just one person. I’m giving you a chance to change your mind, that is, if you’re particularly attached to Red. You see,” he let out an almost shy giggle, “now that she’s available due to the tragic loss of her late husband,” he snickered as if they shared an inside joke, “I intend to make my move.”

A migraine was starting to puncture through Hoffman’s temples. “You can’t just kill her.” He meant it as a command but it came out like a plea. He hated how his vocal cords failed him.

“Kill her? Oh no,” Rosello roared in laughter, “I don’t plan on hurting a hair on her pretty little head. You see, it’s time I’ve settled down. That whole fiasco with Mario has angered some of my elders, and now,” he waved his cigar back and forth, scattering ember and dust around his desk, “I’m in the doghouse, you see? Zietta says it’s because I haven’t been married yet and -,”

“You expect Will Maddox to marry you?” He would have laughed if he had been a weaker man.

“Perhaps. I admit, she’s a looker. Wouldn’t mind waking up to that every morning. Tell me, she good in the sack?”

He rose to his feet before he could stop himself, breathing hard. He stopped himself from lunging across the desk but remained standing.

“So there it is,” Rosello nodded, satisfied, and a gun was pulled from under the desk. “There’s the truth. Sit down, boy.”

Hoffman ran his fingers through his hair and adjusted his suit jacket before returning to his seat. He felt his neck throb in rhythm with his racing heart.

“I’m sure you know I’ve been having you followed, Markie-boy. But I kept my word. Angelina has been undisturbed since you saved my life. And I am grateful for that. So, make your choice. Your sister or your partner. But not both. Whoever you choose, I’ll be just a bad dream to them. But the other, I intend to give my undivided attention.”

“You really expect me to let you just make another victim out of either of them?”

Rosello shrugged. “That’s their problem. I usually don’t - end - my romantic relationships unless it’s well deserved. And they’re both adults. They’ll know what they’re getting into.”

“Neither would ever seriously date you. Never.”

“I can be quite persuasive.” Rosello smiled but kept the gun trained on Hoffman. “You know, I already know who you’re going to let me have. Because your kid sister? Not my type. Too soft. Too weak.”

“Don’t talk about her. You have no right.”

“The guy with the gun has any right they want.” A blast exploded making Hoffman jump and his ears rang that high-pitched hum he knew would eventually just not go away. A steaming hole by his left foot made him almost lose his bladder control.

“You’re nuts.”

“Uh, doi?” Rosello’s hyena giggles began. “But it’s your fault, making all this fun for me. You should see the look on your face, you’re scared shitless!” The man started howling and Hoffman had to just sit there. “So. Back to business. Will or Angie. Who’s getting immunity?” He cocked the gun and retrained it back to Hoffman.

He looked down at his hands. Will or Angie? Their faces alternated in his mind. But it was a no-brainer. “My sister. I still want you to stay away from her.”

“Family first, eh? I respect that.”

“You hypocritical little shit.” The door opened behind them and Rosello looked visibly startled. “Zietta! I thought you weren’t arriving until tomorrow.”

“Toni,” An older woman drawled out, sounding mocking and disdainful, “I decided it was best to arrive as early as possible to fix all the damage you’ve done. It’s clear I am too late, again. Is this how we treat our guests? Pointing and shooting guns like a lunatic?”

Hoffman turned to face the intruder, seeing a short woman with salt and pepper hair and the same dead shark eyes as Rosello. “You must be the man that saved my nephew’s life and helped kill my son.” All he could do was watch as she walked across the room and stood beside Rosello behind his desk. She held her hand out and with a childish pout, Toni Rosello surrendered the gun. “You’ll have to forgive my nephew. He was kicked in the head by a horse when he was a toddler.”

“I’m right here, zietta.”

“And you will keep your mouth shut,” the woman whirled and looked down at him, her voice a polar vortex. “Remember that your father has given me complete guardianship over your business and wellbeing and you will behave yourself if you value what little freedom you have left.” Toni Rosello stared down at the desk, looking furious.

“If I’ve overstayed my welcome, I’ll take my leave,” Hoffman wanted nothing more than to get away from whatever freakshow this was but the woman raised a hand.

“No, Mr. Hoffman, you will stay. As one of Toni’s people, you will answer to me as well. And you will be happy to know that I am a much more reasonable employer.” She opened the chamber of the gun and let the bullets fall to the floor, completely disassembling the weapon. She dropped the pieces on the table with ease. “I will keep my nephew in line. And so long as you and your people serve my family well, no harm will fall upon them.”

Optimism was blossoming in his chest, relieving. “Will Maddox is off-limits as well as my sister.”

“And what incentive are you offering us to make this deal?”

He tried to think. “I will continue to work for you.”

She raised an eyebrow. “You believe you can just walk away?”

“I believe no matter what I do, I’m screwed either way. The only reason I’m dealing with you people is to protect those I care for. But you bringing them into your shit loses any motivation I have to do a good job by you.”

She nodded. “My nephew had only good things to say about you.”

It was his turn to be skeptical. “Is that so?”

“Indeed. It seems you’re the sole reason he has been avoiding conviction and prison for many years.”

He closed his eyes and took a slow breath. “I see.”

“I understand your reservations on surrendering someone you know personally to an oaf like my Toni here,” she put a hand on the back of the big man’s shoulders, rubbing it almost lovingly, “but I assure you that he will not be treating her like… the others. You have my word.”

“Not to be disrespectful, but your word means nothing to me.”

She finally smiled and she would have been almost pretty if they had been talking about something a little more mundane. “Toni agreed to settle down so long as he can have one thing. And his father was never one to refuse to spoil his son. Toni wants to marry this - what’s her name?”

“Wilhelmina Maddox,” Toni grinned like a kid on Santa's lap while keeping his eyes trained on Hoffman.

She nodded. “Yes, this Wilhelmina.”

“I’m having a hard time understanding - why do you care? Toni killed your son. Kind of strange playing matchmaker.”

The woman rounded the desk and stood beside Hoffman, cocking her head to the side. “You don’t understand why?” She put a hand on his chin and the other on his cheek, running her dry cold hands over his stubble.

“Care to explain?”

“Toni killed Mario, my youngest. And Mario, though I loved him, was a liability to the family business. For the good of the family, his death did not hurt us. In fact, it aided us.” She sniffled and there was the faintest glimmer of a tear running down her cheek. “But blood for blood. I demanded it and Don Rosello promised he would compensate me justly.” She knelt down and her fingernails began digging into the meaty flesh of Hoffman’s neck. He suppressed the urge to choke. “I want a son in exchange for losing Mario. And I want those responsible to lose someone they love. To give pain and to receive solace. For Toni, it was hard to come up with his punishment. He is incapable of loving anyone beyond himself. But this business will be enough. And, one day, a piece of him, his own flesh and blood, will be mine. A child to replace my Mario. And for you?”

Hoffman’s eyes widened as she moved closer, her nose grazing his. “I didn’t kill Mario,”he whispered.

“Yet you aided the man that did. Your hands are covered in Mario’s blood. I blame you. So I want someone you love taken away from you. I want their blood to become my blood. Toni tells me you only love two people. And you have put your shield over your sister. Which means that the other will be my prize.”

“Sorry, Markie-boy,” Toni Rosello shrugged as if he merely stepped on his shoe. “But whatever orders the big man gives, I’ve got to follow. I need to find a pretty bride. Have some kids. Leave my zietta to deal with the business in this city until I fall back in good graces with Papa. Those are the rules.”

The room was beginning to spin. He felt dizzy and sick. “Jesus.”

“You understand? Good.” Zietta Rosello released her grip on Hoffman’s neck. “Do not get in our way, if you want your precious Angelina untouched.” She sighed. “Perhaps, allowing this rabid dog off his leash for too long was partially our fault. But that will not absolve you of your part.”

He just had to work for this family of psychopaths. Hoffman buried his hands in his face, finally overwhelmed by the sheer inability to change this situation. He had tried to keep his head above the water. To keep Angelina safe. It had been simple back then. But he went and got himself attached to someone else and now it was Will’s turn to play lamb to the slaughter.

But Will’s a survivor. He lifted his head, carefully examining the vacant faces of the Rosello relatives. Will wouldn’t just let any of this go down. No, she’d find a way to put these bastards away. He hated to admit it, but Toni Rosello had been right: Angelina was too meek and submissive. She couldn’t take care of herself, not entirely. She needed his protection and he'd happily give it forever. But Will? He had faith that if anyone could take down these psychopaths, it would be her. He trusted her.

“I understand.” He suppressed a cruel smile. “I won’t stop you going after Will Maddox.”

Chapter 17: Pre-Saw: Operation Honeypot

Chapter Text

 

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

She had felt strange, coming to this forgotten corner of the city. She knew she was being followed, even stopped to wave towards Daniel Rigg’s car as she got out and made her way into the apartment building.

Sing informed her the week prior about her new shadow. He meant to warn her, as if she needed to be afraid for her safety. She only felt annoyed at Hoffman for being an idiot and not just coming to her directly.

She no longer felt resentful when something new occurred with Hoffman’s dealings with Toni Rosello. It didn’t solve anything. Instead, she simply knew that this was a sign that things had taken a downturn and she needed to maintain vigilance.

Her cast was taken off days ago and she was still getting used to her restored freedom. She needed to take it slow, the doctor stressed, but soon she’d be able to go on her jogs and return to her self-defense sessions. She would get her strength back if she just took it slow and easy.

It was the hardest part, for her, to wait.

She opted for the stairs, glad her pace was at least twice the speed it had been while she was hobbled. Taking on two stairs at a time, she raced the floors until she reached the level.

David Tapp had begrudgingly given her this address, after pestering and rationalizing this was crucial to learning more about Hoffman. She had to insist this would possibly provide a better insight into his relationship with Toni Rosello. Really, it was Sing who compelled the old man to surrender.

”I seriously doubt Knox is going to get his panties in a bunch if you send Maddox his way. Guy’s always bored and happy for company.”

She knocked on the door, hard. The paint was peeling and the 1 and 3 were missing on the 313B.

“I’m coming,” a gruff voice barked, muffled by the distance and walls. She heard the distinct sound of a shotgun being cocked and she jumped back with her hands held up.

“It’s Will Maddox, Mr. Vernon. I’m just dropping by.” She spoke loud and clear, her nerves now frayed.

“...Is that so? Is Mark with you?”

“No. No one is with me. David gave me your address.”

“Interesting.” The door cracked and a glint of an eyeball in the shadows greeted her. “You look better than the first time I saw you.”

She gave him a humored grin. “Yeah. I was a little banged up.”

He let out a chuckle before coughing, closed the door to undo the chain. She heard the rattle and click of several bolts and finally, he opened the door. “Come on, girl. Unless you’re here to take me out. Then do it quick and put me out of my misery.”

She followed him into his domain, the back of his wheelchair rolling down the hallway. She closed the door and locked up for him.

The place looked worn and dirty. Trash bags lined the walls, ready to be taken out. There was a faint smell of old beer, cigarettes, and rotting garbage. It gave her the sudden urge to begin cleaning.

“I’d offer you a drink but you seem the kind of cop that only does so off duty.”

She entered the kitchen to see him opening his fridge, grumbling to himself at the poor selection.

“Thank you, but I shouldn’t be long. Mind if I have a seat?”

“Don’t need to ask. I know I come off like a cranky old coot but it’s nice to see a friendly face. But I’m guessing you’re not here to just have a pleasant chat? Is Mark dead?”

“No. He’s not.”

“Good. That’s a comfort.” He took out a forty and drank straight from the bottle. Will noticed some of the brown liquid dribbled down his beard. She kept a straight face. “Well, spit it out, young lady.”

“You’re close with Mark.”

“So is his sister.”

“No, not really. Not in the way I mean. You were his partner.”

“And so are you.”

“You worked with him much longer than I.” She kept her political smile but remained stern. “I want to understand something and I hope you can help me.”

“Which is?”

“I want to understand his motives better.”

Vernon Knox let out a throaty laugh. “Oh dear lord.”

“I don’t fully understand how he got so tangled up with Toni Rosello. I was hoping you’d shed some light. I want all the information possible, especially now that things are getting personal.”

“Usually, a girl just directly demands her lover to talk about their feelings.”

“We’re not lovers.”

“Mm-hmm,” Knox swished some alcohol before swallowing it like mouthwash. “I'm not much of a matchmaker here. But I know Mark is terrible at opening up. Most of us are. It’s easier that way. What’s this got to do with Rosello?”

“I think the only way to take Toni Rosello down is to set myself up for bait. What will Hoffman do if he finds out?”

Knox didn’t blink. “Stop you.”

“How?” She crossed her legs and rested her arms on the table, biting her lip.

“Depends on how you set yourself up. You gonna doll yourself up and just parade down the Crossroads?”

“No, but close to it. Rosello has been sending inquiries as to whether or not I will go on a date with him.” She pulled at her fingers, fidgeting. “I think the best course of action is to honeypot him.”

“The bastard does love the thrill of the chase. But as soon as you bore him, it’s lights out.” He took another swig. “You got a death wish, don’t ya?”

“I think we all have some self-destructive tendencies,” she nodded towards his drink. “It’s how they recruit.”

He snickered. “The boy won’t like it. But I’m sure you knew that already. And a fair warning. Rosello is an ass. He’d probably parade you around for Mark to see, to get a rise out of him. You’re not going to be able to keep this a secret.”

She nodded, “I figured as much. What can I do to convince him to not interfere?”

Knox took out a cigarette and lit it. “On a good day, you can try to explain it to him. But if he’s having a bad day, he may just shoot the bastard on one of your little dates.”

“Joy.”

“You should let him.”

“Yeah, that’s not happening.”

Knox coughed in surprise. “You should. Let him take out one evil sonofabitch. It’ll do the world a big favor.”

“There’s intel that other Rosello family associates are here in the city. I doubt Mark can shoot all of them.”

“You underestimate my boy.”

She noticed the endearment in his voice and the emotion in his trembling hands. “I don’t want Mark to be put in prison just to be free of the Rosellos.”

“Well aren’t you just Joan of Arc?” Knox let out a low laugh. “This whole mess is making me think about how it all started. The boy won’t like me telling you, that’s for sure.” He watched her warily. “But I trust you’re discreet. Sometimes, we need to do what we must for the people we love, right dear?” She opened her mouth to deny but he held his hand up. “You’re almost as bad as he is. Almost. If you didn’t care about him, you wouldn’t be here, now would you?” He scratched his jaw, the sound like sandpaper.

“What exactly got Hoffman pulled into Rosello’s inner circle?” Will ignored the heat of her face and cleared her throat.

“He lost his damn self-control, that’s what. We were on patrol. Typical business. And I got the order from the higher levels. It was time to bring him face-to-face with the bastard. Rosello was holed up in some strip joint that day. We ended up having to sit through while he smacked around some stripper named Angel. And you can guess how that would trigger your partner.”

Will bit the inside of her cheek at the thought. “I’m assuming he reacted poorly.”

“You think he has poor impulse control now? Well, imagine that boy in his early twenties. It had only been a year since his parents died and he was particularly overprotective of his sister. Not that he wasn’t already.”

“What exactly did he do?”

“He tried to throw a punch and deck the prick. And that was all it took.”

“So it’s safe to assume that no matter how we break it to him, he’s going to not take this well.”
“When you tell him the news, if he behaves like a damn fool then send him my way. I’ll straighten him out.” He sighed. “If you were a man, he’d probably not be so damn reckless.”

“Yeah, but we wouldn’t be here talking about seducing Toni Rosello if I was a man.”

“True. Still, you be careful missy. I like you. Don’t let that piece of shit kill you.”

“I won’t. Thanks for seeing me. Would you like me to take some of these trash bags off your hands?”

“Bless you, darling.”

 

(Power of Will)

The sound of the shower lulled her awake. She got up and stretched, surprised she had slept through the night. It had been a long time since she spent a night with no dreams to remember.

Going out to the kitchen, she saw her younger brother, Bram Maddox, making coffee. He had grown out his brown hair to his shoulders, the flyaways making him look like a teenaged rock star. He turned and smiled. “‘Morning.”

“Good morning,” she went to retrieve a mug. “Still want to stay here?”

“Yeah. I don’t need to crash your friend’s bridal shower. Besides, we’ve been doing stuff every day since I got here. I need to just sit around and do nothing for a day.”

She nodded, putting a loving hand on his shoulder. “You’ve been such a wonderful help. Thank you.”

“That’s what I’m here for,” he forced a grin. “But one of these days we need to sit down and have a talk about Dad.”

She went to pour coffee, hoping he’d change the subject. Instead, there was a period of silence that cornered her. “Fine. We can talk about it now.”

Bram looked taken aback. “Oh. Okay. Well, I was thinking of Dad and myself moving here.”

It was her turn to look concerned. “What about school? You need to graduate.”

“Okay. Then after that.”

She nodded, “Good.” She lowered her eyes before adding, “Of course you can move here if that’s what you want.”

“I just think Dad would like-”

“Dad’s in a coma, Bram. For years. I don’t think Dad has any preference if he’s in San Diego or here.”

“You’re not wrong. But don’t you miss him?”

“Of course I miss him.” Will looked upon her brother with newfound sorrow. He should be worrying about girls and grades. Not this. “But visiting… an empty shell is not the same.”

Bram bit his lip. “He could wake up one day.”

“Oh, Bram.”

“I smell coffee!” Allison popped in with a towel wrapped in her hair. “Can we keep him, Will? I love how he’s always got the kitchen up and running by the time I get up.” She ruffled his hair before pouring herself a cup.

Bram gave a flutter of his eyebrows and a grimaced smile before retreating into the living room to watch some TV.

Will sighed in relief, glad for the reprieve. “What time are we leaving for Angie’s?”

 

Angelina Acomb

Muted greens and silver streamers decorated Angelina and Peter Acomb’s residence. Angelina was weary from all the preparations and planning of her special day but she kept pushing forward. It would all be worth it. Totally.

She sometimes thought it would have been better to just elope.

Already, Tracy Rigg, Jane Matthews, and Rachel Acomb had arrived. Her future mother-in-law, Sarah, was helping prep the snacks in the kitchen. Angelina wasn’t quite ready to join in the festivities as most of the other guests but once the doorbell rang and the high-pitched screams of joy made the presence of Will and Ally known, she was eager to get out and let her hair down for a few hours.

“Oh, Angie,” Sarah appeared with a tray of mojitos. “You seriously need to take a seat and prop your feet. You’ve been working too hard.”

“You’re so sweet, Mom,” Angie grinned at the woman who beamed back. It was a perfect day for a party. The sun shined through her apartment windows and upbeat trip-hop played on the speakers.

“Go, have fun. I’ll finish up here.” Angelina found herself shooed out of her own kitchen but relieved that a competent chef was taking the reins.

“Angie,” Ally pulled her into a great tight hug. “Five more months!”

She smiled ruefully, both excited and dreading the many more tasks that needed to get done before the wedding.

“Uh-oh,” Will snapped her fingers in front of her eyes. “Come back to us Ange. Don’t worry about the wedding. That’s why we’re here.”

“Yeah,” Ally took Angelina by the wrist and pulled her to the living room. “Time to play, ‘Who Can Make The Best Cocktail’!”

After several drinks and various bridal-themed games such as Telephone Wedding Toast and Tie The Knot, it was time to open presents.

Tracy had crocheted her a beautiful merino wool cardigan. Jane gifted various cooking utensils. “You can never have too many spatulas,” Jane nodded intensely, a seasoned fighter in the kitchen. Ally and Will had made a coupon book, complete with ‘Get Out Of Jail’ cards and ‘No Questions Asked Favors’ which made the group laugh at the idea.

“Maybe you’ll need to bury a body,” Jane quipped. The idea was ludicrous and hilarious. And, of course, all cards held checks to help pay for the wedding. Angelina brushed tears from her eyes, overwhelmed by the generosity.

“Thanks so much, everyone. You’re all the best.” Many hugs were shared and sentiments were expressed.

Well past sunset, though it was just before five o’clock, the party began to disperse.

Saying their goodbyes, Will leaned in close and whispered, “if you need anything, just ask.”

And with the final guest gone, Angelina began to clean up.

Though she had fun, she just wanted the wedding to happen. She shut her eyes and reminded herself to be patient. All good things come to those who wait.

 

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

“Walk? Are you sure?” Ally was hovering at her car door, eager to get out of the cold but not quite enough to get in. “It’s freezing!”

“Doctor’s orders. I need to keep moving on the leg and I haven’t had a chance to do my daily walk. I’ll be fine. I’m sure Daniel Rigg is somewhere around here.”

“He left with Tracy.”

“I’m packing.” When Ally didn’t budge, Will rolled her eyes. “Oh my God, not you too. I’ll be fine.”

Ally pouted. “Fine. Page me in an hour. If I don’t hear from you, I’m sending the works and tearing this city apart.”

“Won’t have to come to that.” Will waved and began the three-mile journey to her apartment. Despite the cold, her pace helped her warm-up. She was enjoying studying the architecture of the buildings, always envious of Angelina’s neighborhood.

She heard the idle hum of an engine as a car slowly rolled beside her. “Rigg, go home,” she turned to give the SWAT newbie a piece of her mind. When she realized it was a black limo and the window lowered to reveal the most dangerous man in her city, she immediately rested her hand on her weapon.

“Easy, Red. Easy. I’m not here for anything bad. Just checking in.” Toni Rosello smiled pleasantly. “You need a ride?”

“No, thank you.” She proceeded to continue her walk, ignoring the car as it followed her.

“It’s a cold snap right now. You don’t want to catch pneumonia.”

“Better than getting in that car with you,” she snapped, continuing to walk faster.

“You hurt me, Red. Why can’t we be friends?”

The way he said it made her stop and laugh. Like a kid on the playground. “How often has that worked for you?”

“More times than you’d think.” Rosello grinned back. “I got the go-ahead from your old partner and wanted to let you know.”

“The go-ahead on what?”

“On taking you out for the night of your life.”

She felt a wave of confusion. “Hoffman?”

“You have any other old partners?”

She approached the limo door and turned her head to hear better. “What exactly did he say?”

“Come in and find out.” The door opened but she didn’t get in.

“I need to walk for my injury. You’re welcome to join me.” She didn’t expect him to accept but if he was intending to pursue her she wanted it on her terms. And around plenty of bystanders that could intervene or at least witness if he tried to pull anything.

When Toni Rosello heaved out of his seat and joined her on the sidewalk, she felt a spark of fear at his proximity. “Lead the way, Red.”

She was on high alert but resumed walking, stopping at an intersection for the green light.

“I wanted to apologize for your loss. It must be hard, losing your husband.”

This brought a fresh pain down her throat but she swallowed it away. “That’s kind of you to say.” She warily kept glancing over at Rosello, the man a notable height and mass difference from her. “But aren’t you responsible for what happened?”

“Let the courts decide that. I haven’t bailed out the guy who did it. Isn’t that something?”

“He was your guy, though.” She bit her lip, remembering this man’s reputation for explosions and spontaneous violence with back-talking. The light turned green and they continued. She noticed Rosello was wheezing, clearly not used to covering much ground on foot. She slowed down for him. This is my chance. She remembered herself and what needed to be done. For Hoffman. For the good of the general public. “But thank you. For not simply covering for Mickey Lounds.”

“I may be a monster, but with you, I’d like to not be.” This tenderness felt like a foreign thorn in a shoe and as fake as poisoned honey.

But she pushed it down. “You’re surprisingly smooth when you want to be.” She gave a small smile, not too enthusiastic but enough of a bone to toss that he jumped for it.

“If you’re curious as to how smooth I can be, then consider an evening with me.”

“It wouldn’t be appropriate,” she looked away as though considering it. He wasn’t an idiot. He would know her intention. “Besides, what makes you think I’d accept out of authentic interest?”

“Because I know you’re authentically interested in Markie-boy.”

She returned to frowning, ready for his worst. “Is that so?”

He nodded. “Don’t deny it. But that’s fine. See, I own him. And you want to set him free. The way I see it, you could take his place one day. Once you show me you’re willing to stick around once I let him loose.”

She raised an eyebrow. “What would it take for you to simply forget about Mark Hoffman?”

“Your undying devotion and loyalty.”

She snorted. “That’s hard to prove.”

“I bet you could pull it off. And to me, that’s enough.”

“You don’t have a good track record with women. Especially women that look like me.”

“Ah, well,” now Rosello looked bashful, as if he was recalling an embarrassing memory, “you see, I’m being taken into an early retirement from all that.”

“I find that hard to believe.”

“Believe it, honey. Here’s one feather for your cap. Tell your boys in brass that Don Rosello has dethroned me. My purpose now is to find a pretty little redhead and settle down.”

“And I’m the lucky girl? Swell.”

Rosello laughed, hyena giggles that made a nearby walker turn their head in concern. “See, this is why I like you. You’re a little firecracker.”

They continued their walk. “I’m assuming you already know where I live?” Any desire to separate and diverge her route to avoid him seemed a vain point.

“Obviously.”

She shook her head. She was wary of rejecting him but he had finally conceded to walking quietly next to her. So far, he had been on his best behavior. “So what’s your pitch?”

“Dinner. Followed by the opera. And then an early evening, where you are returned safe at your home. No strings attached. You may even keep your gun on you the entire evening. Oh, but you will be searched for a wire. Especially if we’re to have an open and honest conversation. And none of your task force escorting us. I want some privacy.”

“Hm. That’s surprisingly fair. But it’s still putting me in danger.”

“Then perhaps you’d consider a chaperone?” There was a smirk on the man’s face.

“Who did you have in mind?” She already knew. Knox had anticipated this.

“Markie-boy, of course.”

She swallowed, imagining all the ways the night could go wrong. Most of them involved Hoffman losing control and then proceeding to get harmed by Rosello or one of his likely bodyguards that would be nearby.

But this was what needed to be done. She needed Rosello’s trust. “Fine.”

“Splendid!” Rosello declared breathlessly as he snapped his fingers and the limo pulled up beside them. “Enjoy the rest of your walk, Red. I’ll pick you up this Saturday at 5.” And the man drove off.

 

 

 

 

 

Eric Matthews

“You went and put yourself in danger as well as jeopardized this operation without consulting me first!” Tapp was angrier than he had seen in a long time. And it was the first time Matthews had seen Tapp angry at anyone besides him.

Mad Max stood head downcast and with her hands at her hips while she got reamed by the old man, spittle flying out of his mouth as he got up to her face and bellowed like a drill instructor in boot camp. The rest of the task force was spread throughout the room. Matt Gibson kept stealing glances over at the spectacle before shyly looking down at his coffee. Peter Strahm and Lindsay Perez seemed to silently communicate with each other with passive glances and folded arms.

Matthews exhaled some smoke and crossed his arms to enjoy the show. If only I had some popcorn.

Ally elbowed him sharply and he jumped. Looking over, she gave a stern, ‘You better intervene and fix this’ glower, making him moan in disdain.

“I have a mind to have you taken off the force and have Grissom consider suspending you without pay!”

“David,” Matthews grumbled as he approached the man.

“You compromised the integrity of this investigation and clearly have no respect for the hard work your colleagues have put into his case.”

“David,” Matthews raised his voice and put a hand on the man’s back with a smarting smack. “Give the kid a break.”

Tapp spun around with renewed fury and directed it in his direction. “Oh? I’m surprised you, of all people, think I should be giving Maddox here a break.”

“I think she made the right call.” Matthews stood toe-to-toe with Tapp, the two men glaring at each other as though sizing each other for a fight.

“She should have run it by you first,” Sing joined in, adding, “but it’s not like she planned for Rosello to just pull up to her and ask her out. We should take advantage of this opportunity. We’ve got no leads. We’ve got nothing new except this.”

“It’s not just about catching the bad guy, Sing,” Tapp lectured, “The safety of our peers needs to be protected.”

“And it will be,” Kerry stood up. “We have prepared for almost a year now. We’ll be cautious. But I think it’s time to let us use the little advantages we have over this guy.”

“Which is, what, exactly?” Tapp snapped.

“His obsession with Maddox,” Peter Strahm threw in. “It’s clear he has developed a fixation on her and we have a more concise profile. He’s desperate for a maternal figure that holds authority over him that resembles his mother. Which, Will here, has full capability of emulating.”

Tapp looked around at the room, searching for anyone on his side of the argument. Matthews felt for the guy. It sucked when it felt like the whole world was against him.

“If Will is aware of the risks and still wants to put herself out there to catch the guy, I think we should let her,” Perez softly muttered before looking away from Tapp’s furious stare.

“Well I don’t. There has to be a better way. Will could die.” Gibson’s cheeks turned pink when the entire room turned to glare at him. “Just saying.”

“So that’s one no. And you, Fisk?” Tapp looked over to Fisk who had been quiet in the corner. Fisk’s shoulders slumped. “If anything happened to Will, it would be a sad day.” Tapp nodded vigorously, eager for him to continue. “But we all signed up for this knowing the risks. We come to work every morning with the possibility we won’t go home. But if we don’t take those risks, there will be more Rosellos out there to hurt innocent people. More people will die if we don’t do whatever is necessary to stop the bad guys. That’s my two cents.” Fisk folded his arms and looked away.

Tapp let out a deep growl but bowed his head. “Fine. We’ll do it your way, Maddox. But mark me, girl, you will follow my orders and will not disobey them. Or you’re off. Do you hear me?”

“Yes, I do.” Maddox looked thrilled.

Matthews took another drag of his cigarette, going to sit back with Kerry. “You happy?” He whispered into her ear.

“Very. Thank you.” Ally reached a hand and squeezed his forearm, the touch loving. He blinked, feeling a smile crack his mouth. At least this all finally blew over.

Chapter 18: Pre-SAW: Hoffman's Promotion

Notes:

Happy Valentine's Day!

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

He wondered where his morning went wrong.

He had rolled out of bed. Shaved. Changed. And decided a good detour to his favorite cafe was just the treat he needed.

How the hell did that lead to him behind the counter trying to calm the shrieking barista with purple hair as some wingnut shot rounds in the air. Idiot’s already down one magazine. He wondered how much ammunition the fuck carried. It sounded like a lot.

Another problem was that an officer was currently clutching a bullet hole in his chest, trying not to die as he grew paler. Hoffman had shoved as many towels into and onto the puncture, pushing the packing down with as much pressure as the rookie could handle. “Am I going to die?” The guy asked with shaking fingers. “I feel cold.”

“You’re not going to die,” he growled before turning to the college kid with the colorful hair. “Hey. Come here and hold this down. Don’t let him bleed out.” The woman was crying but thankfully crawled over to hold the crimson-stained rags.

Hoffman didn’t recognize the downed officer. He barely looked out of high school. The boy’s face was contorted with terrible pain and absolute terror. Hoffman forced himself to compartmentalize. He needed to get these people out of here.

To complicate things, the guy had another hostage. A kid. Little girl was crying for her Dad.

This was not the kind of morning Hoffman had been ready for. He was just sad he didn’t get at least one sip of his espresso that now puddled on the floor a few feet away. Not that he wasn't wide awake now from sheer adrenaline alone. He took in a deep breath and waited for the man to reload.

Distant sirens sounded, a godsend chorus. He just needed to buy more time and keep everyone else alive.

He rose from behind the counter and pointed the weapon directly at the man. “Let’s calm down.”

The guy brought way too much firepower for the situation, his fumbling with his giant gun and his poor coordination gave Hoffman, the more experienced gunfighter, a chance to grab the upper hand. With a frustrated snarl, the perpetrator threw down his semiautomatic and proceeded to pull a knife and press it to the kid’s neck. The girl looked no older than kindergarten.

“You don’t want to hurt her. Let’s talk this through.”

“Back off!” The man screamed. “This is my daughter and I’m taking her with me.”

Of course she is. Hoffman looked at the girl and the corpse at her feet. The woman had a similar hair color to the kid but was very much dead. “Let me guess. Bad divorce?”

“She took everything. I’m just taking back what’s mine.” The man’s eyes were wild and his lips trembled, looking all around for boogeymen and danger.

“What’s your name?” Hoffman was never good at hostage situations, wishing Will was there to smooth this mess over.

“Nick.”

“Well, Nick, why don’t you let your kid go? She’s scared.”

“Because that bitch brainwashed her. Told her I was no good.” He was breathless but squeezed his grip tighter on her. “I’m not gonna let her get taken from me.”

“What’s her name?”

“Suzy. Her name is Suzy.”

“Nick, if we can get through this with no more deaths, I’ll personally make sure you and Suzy don’t get separated.”

The little girl hiccuped, tears streaming down her cheeks. She didn’t look particularly interested in being stuck with a father who would put a knife to her neck and kill her mother. But he had to say something to get the bastard to let her go. Just outside the coffee shop, the screeching of tires and the shouts of men filled the air.

Nick swore, spinning his head around and backing up with Suzy in tow. “I know I’ve gone too far. I just lost it. She was moving to Canada. She was going to take Suzy!” The man was shaking.

“Well, it looks like there’s a change of plans.” Hoffman kept looking down his sights.

The man’s eyes shined and he let out a hysterical laugh. “Yeah. There is.”

“But let’s try to think about Suzy. Don’t you think you’re scaring her?”

“She just doesn’t know me anymore. But she will.” The girl whimpered, which merely earned herself a sharp jerk from Nick who had grabbed the side of her collar and shook her around.

“Shut up! I’m not going to hurt you!”

“Nick, how about you cool it with being so rough with her. You’re only making things worse. I’m sure she loves you. Don’t you, Suzy?”

The girl shook her head quickly and Hoffman would have laughed if the situation was not so dire. The father grabbed her by the hair and jerked her small head back, her neck exposed even more.

Anger flared up and out of him. He clicked the safety off and had his finger caressing the trigger. “Cool it, Nick. What you're showing her right now isn’t any good. It doesn’t look like she’s understanding the situation. How old is she?”

“Six.”

“Imagine how confusing this whole situation is for a six-year-old?”

The man snapped, “This whole situation is confusing for anyone!”

Well, he’s right on that. Hoffman backpedaled, “I’m a cop. I can make sure this whole mess gets taken care of.”

The man blinked. “Cops are liars.”

“Not all of them,” Hoffman lied, “But if you go through with this and hurt Suzy? There won’t be anything I can do. And you don’t want to look back on this day, regretting you did anything different yeah?”

The man bowed his head, sobbing. “It’s too late.”

Hoffman had lost him. This guy wasn’t going to be rationalized with and he wasn’t going to bother trying anymore. It was going to waste time and end up with another dead kid. He had to come up with a Plan B and fast. One of his guys was bleeding out and needed an ambulance pronto. Searching around, he noticed the man was standing on what looked like a mix of coffee, creamer, and blood.

What he needed was to get that sharpened steel away from the girl’s throat. He, having the gun trained on the man’s head, would be able to make the shot but didn’t want the kid to end up with a scar or worse, bleed out before the paramedics made it.

He needed to distract the guy somehow. Or at least get a clean shot of the back of his brain stem. If he hit the spot just right, the guy would die standing, with no muscle spasms to make him do any more damage.

“COME OUT WITH YOUR HANDS UP,” The amplified voice of what Hoffman assumed was Detective Willis, called out behind him from the street.

Nick shook his head. “I’m not coming out. You. Tell them I want a car and all of those fucks to back up a block.”

Hoffman nodded. “Sure. But I want to talk to Suzy.”

“Fuck off.”

“Suzy?” Hoffman was starting to doubt this guy would actually slit his kid’s throat but he remained delicate with the situation. “You ever go on the swings?”

The girl nodded, confusion eclipsing her fear.

“If you hear a large bang, I want you to pretend you’re trying to make the swing go forward. Kick with both legs. You got me?”

“What - what the fuck are you talking about?” Nick’s voice became shrill.

“It’s all right,” he pretended to talk to someone behind him. “I’ve got this under control.”

The man spun around, pulling Suzy with him.

Hoffman only had a handful of seconds with a clear view of Nick’s back.

He made the shot.

An explosion of blood and brains flew outward and what was left of the man slumped to the side.

A little girl’s screams were drowned out by the sound of the sirens of backup. But screams were good. Screams meant her throat wasn’t cut.

Hoffman rushed towards her, picking up her tiny form and pulling her away from the man, pulling her face to his chest to block the sight of gore. She doesn’t need to see any of that.

David Tapp

When David Tapp was examining the blueprints to the Rosello Estate, a ruckus outside made him pause from his study. He wondered what those rookies were doing that got them so excited but his curiosity got the best of him. He went out to investigate.

It looked like a good ol’ party that he wasn’t invited to. He recognized Matthews and Kerry as they talked with smiles on their faces among the throngs of uniforms and detectives.

Mark Hoffman was getting pats on the back and smiles from faces belonging to conscientious objectors to the Mark Hoffman Fan Club.

Sing was on the outskirts of the crowd, arms folded as he leaned against a desk.

“What’d I miss,” Tapp asked, looking on as Matthews came over and threw an arm around Hoffman’s shoulders, pulling him into a chokehold as the two began horsing around like they were ten years younger.

“Hostage situation. No dead cops, though plenty of dead civilians. Saved a little girl. It’s a news circus right now but he made all of us look real good. You should see Grissom, he’s practically skipping. There’s even talk about Hoffman getting a promotion.”

“It’s bullshit,” Gibson called out, joining their conversation. He stared glumly at the celebration. “Hoffman probably shot first.”

“How’s that IA investigation going?” Sing, too, kept his eyes trained on Hoffman with skepticism.

“Apparently, the IA found nothing wrong with Hoffman’s performance. In fact, there’s Brookers over there.” Gibson nodded towards the head of Internal Affairs, who seemed ready to kiss Mark Hoffman, though instead gave him a one-armed hug.

“It’s how it is,” Tapp grumbled.

Will Maddox came up, all smiles and starry-eyed. They all watched as she shamelessly threw her arms around Hoffman and planted a kiss on his neck with the erupted “oohs” from the onlookers.

“It’s wrong,” Gibson shook his head, voice thick with emotion. “IA ain’t doing their job.”

“Sorry,” Sing shared sympathy, though Tapp knew he had been warned. “Maybe next time.”

“People like Hoffman can’t be allowed to get away with this. It’s not right.”

“Well, you can always try to transfer to IA. Sounds like that’s more your speed,” Sing smirked.

“Yeah. You know, maybe I will.”

Tapp and Sing exchanged glances. “How about wait until Rosello’s put away, rookie,” Tapp decided now was the time to get back to work. He had seen enough.

Mark Hoffman

Detective Sergeant Hoffman had a nice ring to it.

“You did good, Hoffman. Damn good.” Grissom was beaming, a rare sight in his presence. He opened his cigar case. “Want to celebrate?” He went to pick up one of the hand rolled logs but Hoffman shook his head.

“Not a smoker.” He kept his face smooth and friendly but just the idea of the smell made him want to punch the wall. He was sick of cigars and the smell of them.

“Well, feel free to take the rest of the day off. Tell your sister about your new promotion. We’ll have a ceremony Friday.”

“Thank you, sir,” he felt like it was a dream. He never thought he’d finally make the next rank. Not after everything he had done.

“We’re thinking of putting you up in one of the offices upstairs.” Grissom rubbed his nose with a sobered frown. “Once all this Rosello business gets sorted, that is.”

“I understand.” Hoffman looked down at the shiny temp badge, the brass all glossy and new. A spur of guilt burrowing into his chest.

“Maybe you and Maddox can share the eastside room. She’s up for promotion as well.” Hoffman felt Grissom’s eyes on him, dissecting him.

He kept his face blank but he knew what this sudden fascination was about. She just had to go and kiss me in front of the entire department. He tried to feel nothing but indignation yet his ears heated up as he recalled how thrilling it was, feeling her soft lips on his skin. The act had staked its claim for all to see. Everyone now knew that she and him were something - whatever something was - and sent a clear message.

She was his.

Hell, if all he had to do was rescue kids from estranged fathers to get some more of that attention, he’d start camping out in front of a divorce attorney’s office.

“Hoffman? You deaf?”

He blinked. “That’ll be fine. We’re used to sharing space.”

Knowing amusement twinkled behind thick spectacles. “Funny. A couple years ago, you’d be bitching about how you don’t share with anyone.” After some silence, Grissom shrugged. “Well, how about you figure out a way out of this mess you’re in soon. That way we can all move on and get some control on the city again. Maybe this new year we’ll finally not look like a gang of idiots.”

“I’ll figure it out,” he promised. “Need anything else?” Dismissing himself, he left the office to suddenly get blindsided by a sharp jab in his left arm. He turned and looked down at the freckled cheeks surrounded by red curls. “What?”

“So? What’s the news?” She was vibrating with excited energy and she practically jumped when she saw the brass shining back at her. “You got it! Oh! Congrats!” She pushed him again, the sudden physical contact shocking him to move slightly.

“You’re going to give me a bruise.”

“If you think I’m the one that’s going to bruise, you have another thing coming.” She shook her head. “Hopefully your chest’s healed up before you wear it.”

“Doubt anyone’s going to try to smack the badge into me. I never got that sort of treatment before.” He knew she was referring to an old tradition where the badge would be hit against the wearer upon their first few days of being promoted. It just wasn’t something they did at the Metropolitan Police Department. “And you’ve already used up all your punches.”

She playfully pouted, folding her arms. “Well at least let me buy you dinner.”

He raised an eyebrow. “What’s changed? I thought we needed to keep our distance.” As he spoke he looked behind her, noticing two men from Narcotics glancing their way before turning their heads sharply.

She followed his gaze. “I’ll tell you over dinner.”

“That sounds ominous.”

She squinted up at him. “Well, I know you’re not going to like it. But I’m hoping you’ll be bought off with food and drink.”

“What’s my limit?”

“None.”

“Now I know I’m not going to like it.” He folded his arms. “What is it?”

She sighed and tried to pull his forearms back down. “Just - let’s go. Name your place. Somewhere quiet will probably be best though.”

“And what if we’re followed?”

“It’s not like anything I’ll tell you will be new to Rosello.”

“Goddamn it.”

(Power of Will)

He opted for Angie’s restaurant. Normally too pricey for his tastes, he figured whatever bad news Will was about to throw at him, it couldn’t be the end of the world if he was eating his sister’s cooking.

Will and him sat at a table by the wall, far from the windows but with a decent vantage point. The cost of the beer alone made him want to weep for the common folk. But hell, she said no limit, so he opted for some top shelf scotch. She didn’t even raise an eyebrow.

Her lack of jibe or complaint at his drink choice was what set him off the edge. Heart pounding, he pulled at the bread they were served with and peered over at Will as she leisurely perused the menu. “What do you recommend?” She was stalling.

“I don’t eat here. I’m not sure. Ange usually keeps things simple at home. I’ve never seen these words in my life.”

“I think raclette is a cheese?” Her eyes scanned the menu before darting back up to meet his with nervous energy.

He could be patient when he wanted to. But after his first drink, he finally caved. “Just tell me.”

She sighed and put the menu down. She folded her hands in her lap. “I’m going on a date with Toni Rosello.”

“What?” He must have misheard her. He took a healthy gulp of the filtered water. “Say that again.”

She bit her lip. “This Saturday, I have a date with Toni Rosello.”

He blinked, slowly inhaled, and contemplated what she was saying. “What did he do?”

“He just asked me.”

“And if you had said no, what would he have done?”

She shrugged. “I don’t know. He didn’t exactly threaten me. He just asked. But he did suggest he’d consider leaving you be if I do.”

“I know you’re not that gullible. And you just accepted?” He was incredulous. “What’re you thinking you’re going to get from him? A signed confession if you sit on his lap for a few minutes?”

“No. I don’t. But I need to get close to him. But it’s not all bad. You’re going to be there.”

He was taken aback. “Rosello’s idea, I take it.” The idea of having to watch the two of them in a romantic setting was enough to make him map out where the nearest gallon of bleach was.

“Yes, but it makes sense. You can be my extra protection.” She breathlessly added, “We can take him down together.”

He rubbed his temple, a headache rampaging in his skull. “For fuck’s sake, Maddox.”

“Feel free to order the lobster.” Will turned to the approaching waiter and took the glass of wine, sighing into it as she took a healthy sip. “And name your demands. I’ll make all of this up to you.”

He never felt more defeated in his life. “What do I have to do to make sure you don’t go through with this?”

“Absolutely nothing.”

He ground his teeth. “Wilhelmina.”

Her eyes curved into pained crescents at the sound of her full name. “No. This is not part of that discussion. Okay? I’m tired, Mark. I’m tired of seeing you like this. I want the Mark Hoffman of today. The man who goes and makes the right call and saves lives. Not this side of you that the devil is forcing you to be.” She put her glass down and took his hand, her grip tight and cool. “I love you.”

The world felt slow all of a sudden. He wasn’t sure he heard her correctly. “What?”

“I. Love. You. Okay? As soon as all of this is over, I want us to go back to being partners. Solving crimes. Cleaning up the city. And we can be. Once you’re free.”

He felt like he was dreaming. It must have been a dream. “...as friends? Or more?”

She shook her head, pretty and serious. “I don’t know. But that’s not the point. I’m telling you. The last time, at your place,” she looked briefly away before returning his eye contact, “I was scared about how you made me feel. But I’ve thought about it. And everything that’s come to this - I don’t want it to be for nothing. You’re… you’re someone I don’t want to lose. I’m tired of losing the men in my life.” Her eyes were brimming but she pressed on. “Let me save you. And after, we can figure the rest out from there.”

It wasn’t a marriage proposal. But it practically felt like one. He flustered. “I…” He wasn’t a man of many words but she had frozen the few he had in his mouth.

The waiter arrived to take their orders. He stumbled through, not caring or even remembering what he had asked for. He just wanted the guy to go away so they could continue this talk.

The three words rang in his ear and he could have played it on loop forever.

I love you.

It had been a very long time since he heard someone besides Angie say that to him.

Finally, they were alone again. “You’re not just saying this to get me to go along with your plan, are you?” Please don’t be cruel to me, Will.

Now, she looked thoughtful, as though seriously considering him. “You don’t believe me?”

“I don’t know what to believe.” He shook his head. “You confuse me, Will.”

“Well, stay alive long enough to not be confused anymore.” She pulled his hand to her and kissed it, smiling that dazzling smile and it felt like the world had stood still. “And trust me on this. I’ll get you out. Just be on your best behavior-,”

“OH MY GOD!” The two of them jumped and turned to see Angelina in a chef’s coat and hat with her hands on her cheeks, beaming down at them. “Mark! Will! How long?!” She was red-faced and squealing, making him wince.

“Calm down, Ange,” he tried to soften the disruption but she continued pining.

“I knew it. I just knew you two would get together. I’ve got to tell Pete, we have a betting pool going.” Angelina leaned down and put her arm around him and pulled him into a hug. “And you two decided to finally tell me! This is just perfect for the wedding! Now you two can dance together as a real couple and it’s going to just be so cute! The pictures!”

He took a deep breath, keeping his cool for his sister’s sake. Maybe choosing her restaurant wasn’t the best venue for this situation, if he was going to keep his work-life separate from his personal life. But looking at Will, he knew that ship had sailed, been lit on fire, and sunk to the bottom long before that day.

Chapter 19: Pre-SAW: A Date With Toni Rosello

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

Kerry helped her attach a thigh holster under her skirt, the velcro scratching her skin. She couldn’t help her twitching fingers as she adjusted the straps to her dress. “I’m nervous,” she admitted.

“I don’t blame you,” Ally pulled at the hem of her dress to help conceal the bulge of the weapon. “I’m not sure how thorough they’ll be with their search. You sure you don’t want to risk a wire? In case…”

In case things go wrong and there’ll at least be some evidence as to what went down. “Yeah, I’m sure. Remember, I’m armed. We’ll be in public. And there’s Hoffman.”

“Yeah.” Ally tried to smile but couldn’t quite get there. “Will,” she took her wrist and gave her a squeeze. “Be careful out there.”

Will nodded and left the locker room. Normally, during an undercover sting like this, the guys would whistle and throw some playful remarks, for irony’s sake, at seeing one of their own in a ridiculous costume. She stepped out, hooker heels tall and her red dress tight. Everyone stood around with arms folded and stiff frowns painted on.

Tapp looked her up and down, nodding in begrudging approval. “You’ll need a coat. It’s cold out there.”

Perez provided something long and warm, the thick black wool covering her calves.

Peter Strahm approached with his arms folded, eyebrows furrowed. “Remember. Appeal to his ego when he begins showing hostile behavior. But maintain a distance to keep him interested. And even though we won’t have it on record, try to get as much intel as you can.”

She nodded and he put a hand on her shoulder. “Stay on your toes.”

Kerry drove her back to their apartment, now with the task force in separate vehicles and positioned at every corner of the block. She had been running on non stop adrenaline rushes since the day began, her knee bouncing as she sat in the car seat. The various tips of her colleagues echoed in her mind.


”Keep him in your view.”


“Stay on his good side.”


“Don’t show fear.”


Was this it? She tried not to think about it, but the harsh fact that she could die that night was like a terrible fog swallowing her up. It wasn’t an ideal way to go, by any means. She wanted Rosello behind bars and many others like him before she finally kicked the bucket.


“We’ll get him, Ally. I’m not sure about tonight. But I’ll figure something out.” Her friend didn't reply and instead, put on the radio. The traffic report droned on.
Once they reached their destination, she got out of the car. No sooner had she stepped out than the familiar black limo pulled up behind their car, the driver fast with patting her down and opening the back door for her. He let her keep her all weapons, from the guns attached to her thigh to the one in her purse. Even the mace was allowed to stay. Will waved a farewell to her roommate who nodded back with as much a brave face as she could muster.


She slid in, her partner on the driver’s side of the bench seat. Mark looked straight ahead, barely acknowledging her entrance. They were immersed in a typically luxurious interior. Leather seats, a small television, and a minibar greeted her. The smell of car leather, cigar smoke, and cologne wafted through.


Sitting across from her, the great round blob of a creature, grinned back at her. “‘Evening, Red.” She couldn't tell when his pupils ended and his irises began. He either was high or just a soulless beast. She knew it was the latter.

She smiled back at the grease slicked hair and freshly shaven face. “Mr. Rosello.”


“Please. Call me Toni when we’re out here like this.” His eyes glittered and invaded her space with hunger. “You look nice. Real nice.”


“You clean up rather well yourself,” she spoke, though he always leaned towards formal attire whenever she came across him.


Her eyes scanned the area and landed on Mark. “Did I miss any interesting conversation?” She was noticing how white his knuckles were, held in his lap. He was dressed in a dinner jacket, looking ready to eat a bear.


Rosello smirked. “Oh, don’t worry. He hasn’t given me grief for tonight. Which means you’ve either told him in advance or I’m in real trouble.”


“Guess you’ll have to wait and find out which it is,” she felt uncertain if she was making the right impression, so she opted to take her coat off. “It’s a bit warm in here,” she fanned herself, though she wasn’t remotely sweating.


Black beady eyes swept from her neck to her exposed shoulders, making her internalize the shiver that almost broke through. She kept her red lips upturned and batted her lashes a bit, hoping she could sell the night on mostly her physical appeal alone. It was a lot easier to sit back and look pretty than pull the guy’s interest with her wit. She wanted to hold back, in case she really needed it to keep Hoffman from going off the deep end. He had shifted in his seat, suddenly fascinated by something out the window, jaw muscles twitching.


The mobster didn’t offer to reduce the heat, confirming that he was enjoying the wholesome peepshow she was giving him. Looking out her window, she admired the passing city lights and gardens, noting they were heading towards the upper crust of the city that was way outside her literal paygrade.


Despite her nerves earlier, seeing the many people out and about as well as the very public venue he was taking her to, helped. A little.


“Relax, Red,” Rosello had proceeded to pour her a drink. “Here, this should calm your nerves.”


She had carefully observed him pour the drink and waited for him to pour himself one. Before he took a sip of his she calmly demanded, “Let’s switch drinks.”


Amused, Rosello complied, but upon exchanging crystal tumblers his fingers grazed hers. She couldn’t help but narrow her eyes at the obvious intentional contact but all that was returned to her were dancing eyebrows as he heartily emptied his glass. “Shouldn’t you offer Hoffman one?”


“Oh, I’m sure your bodyguard should stay sober tonight. Don’t want to make you feel like I’m taking advantage.”


Conversation felt stunted and awkward until they finally pulled up to their next destination. The chauffeur had proceeded to hold the door open for all three of them, Will returning into the warmth of her coat while shivering and gravitating towards Hoffman’s direction.


“Shall we?” Rosello had held out his arm, patiently waiting for her. She nodded and took the thick and mushy elbow, keeping her eyes cheery and her mouth upturned.
He guided her through the doors, pulling her into a dark room with smells of exotic spices and rich meats. Despite them, her stomach felt like a bee was buzzing inside.


The sudden loss of light made her on high alert, blinking quickly to adjust to the loss of visibility.


The host greeted them with a wide smile and led them to their dining area, in a private room far from the majority of the patrons.

Hoffman, who had only been a shadow in the corner of her eye, had fallen back. She whirled to catch him standing at the archway that separated the external room, hand gripping his wrist in front of him.

He seemed to intensely admire the golden sconces. Violently.


“It’s nice to have some privacy, don’t it? Makes things more intimate.” Rosello's voice pulled at her face like a slimy verbal tentacle.


“I like how quiet it is. Makes it easier to talk.” She flashed her teeth and let him hold her seat for her at the large square table. Seats adjacent to them remained empty. He sat across from her, snapping his fingers for the waiters to arrive to pour their drinks.


“Exactly. Let's get to know each other better.”


She had taken a shaky drink of her water, the ice rattling against the glass. Shit. She felt his eyes capture the tremor with disdain. Strahm's warning echoed in her memory. Don't show fear. “What's there to get? You seem the kind of man who does their research. Thoroughly.” 


He giggled, the hyena pleased. “You know what they say.”


“And what’s that?”


“You’ll never know a person until you climb into their skin and walk.” The hyena bark came out as he howled at his own joke.


She leaned into her backrest, sighing. If there is a God, give me strength. “I’ll spare you the trouble. Under all this skin we’re the same.”


The beady black eyes narrowed. “Oh, we’re quite different, Red. Don’t try to flatter yourself.”


Empathy not working. Abort. “Have I done something to offend you tonight, Toni?”


“Not particularly. But I appreciate honesty in a relationship. I’m aware that you don’t find yourself quite on the same level of perspective as I am.”


“Care to enlighten me?”


The server arrived to pour the wine and she took the glass. Rosello held his glass up. “In time. A toast. To the future. To us.”


She drank, not sure what exactly he was alluding to then continued their train of thought. “If, by perspective, you mean how we value human life, then perhaps that’s where we diverge.”


“Diverge. Cute. But that would suggest we were once walking the same path. I never knew we overlapped. But I appreciate you trying to ‘connect’ with me, Red. Is that what that federal shrink told you to try on me?”


Her eyes widened briefly but she regained her composure. “I’m just making an effort here. Go easy on me. Isn’t this a date?” She leaned forward, his eyes falling down to her chest and she smiled with newfound fire. Gotcha.


“It takes two to tango, Red. I’ll play nice if you will.” He brought a hand up to brush a stray curl from her forehead. She kept her face still despite the urge to flinch.


Hoffman, in her line of sight, was a boulder at the archway. He seemed to tighten the grip of his wrist in front of him, thick lips pulled back in the faintest snarl. He stared at the two of them with venom.


"Toni," she lowered her voice and studied the mobster's face. She could see the pores on his nose and the yellowing cracks of his teeth. "Why me?"


The shark looked like he was about to dine on a sushi buffet. "You're brave. Cute. I like that in a woman."


If it had been anyone else to compliment her, she would have been touched. But coming from him, it had been akin to being told she was a doll in the toy store he had to have because they had the fiercest outfit. He was collecting her. Like all the other victims.


"I'm flattered. I didn't know you'd have a soft spot," she reached and put a hand over the predator's wrist. She always wondered how the beautiful trophy wife could lean into flirting with someone way below their league. It surprised her to find it was quite easy.


"By the end of tonight, I'll show you a couple of other spots you didn't know I'd have."


She forcefully restrained her spine from shuttering in repulsive terror. "Let’s start slow. Dine me first."


"After dinner, that's fair. Can't make a life-changing decision on an empty stomach my zietta always says."


She opened her mouth to ask what he meant about life-changing but the first course had arrived. Olives, cured meats, cheeses, and spreads were placed before them. The shark began to feed with greedy gobbling while she cautiously picked at the meal.


She occasionally stole glances at her partner who had remained as stoic and motionless as a gargoyle petrified in his rage.


Her wine glass had not been permitted to be empty as the diligent servers kept pouring her fresh glasses so she began nursing with false sips while Rosello continued to consume like a black hole trying to prove its supremacy.


"I like this, Red. Sitting here, you by my side. I can see this happening for a good long while."


She kept smiling but hoped her silence was seen as a respectful gesture and not her struggling to continue the charade. She felt tired.


"What would you say, imagining us having meals like this more often."


"So far, I'm open to the idea." She was floundering with faint ideas of how to tow the conversation onto him incriminating himself. And then it struck her. "I don't know how realistic it would be, though."


"Why not?"


"Our businesses clash."


"Ah, good point. Well, you know my ways of making your business go away."


"I'm not dirty, Rosello."


"Not yet. But I'll get you on my level soon enough. I've got what you want." Rosello looked over at Hoffman with a sneer. "And you've already proved you'll walk through the mud for this oaf."


"He's not an oaf," she snapped before she could pull the words back into her mouth. She bit her lip but the damage had been dealt.


The shark was on high alert, watching her with reproach. "What is he, then?"


“My partner.”


Rosello swiped his arm across the table, throwing the plates and cutlery onto the floor. The shattering of ceramic made her wince. “Aaank. Wrong, Red. He’s more than that. At least, nowadays he is.” The barrel of a Smith and Wesson stared back at her, Rosello pulling the hammer back with his thumb.


“What’s the meaning of this?” Will forced her voice to remain calm but it felt as though a fist was around her throat and it was beginning to squeeze tight.


“Tired of you not being completely honest, Red.”


“About what?”


“You. And him.” Rosello kept his eyes trained on her, looking at ease. “Have the decency of being forthright with me here. I ain’t a dummy. So don’t try to give me those sweet little lies by omission you seem real fond of trying.”


Her wrists were resting on the corner of the table. She slowly reached for her surviving wine glass and took a long, healthy drink. Finally, she declared, “you’re insane.”


Rosello giggled. “Finally. If this is what it takes to make you candid, then this is how it’ll be. And don’t even think about it, Markie-boy,” Rosello pressed the revolver into Will’s temple, the cool metal digging into her skin with a sting. “I want you to slowly walk over here with your gun and put it on the table close to me. You, too, Red. And have a seat, Markie.” Rosello narrowed his eyes, his obsidian irises glinting. “I want to play a game.”

 

Mark Hoffman

The blood had drained from his face but he maintained his composure. He slowly removed the rounds from his weapon and gave it to Rosello. In pieces, so he wouldn't easily use it on them.


He had a few backups on him. One on his ankle. Another attached around his shoulders. The one at his hip had to be sacrificed but he was bulky enough and his suit was draped to hopefully let Rosello not pay attention to the remainder.


He was counting on the bastard having a freakout. The lines of coke he had snorted before Will had arrived tipped him off that this was going to be one hell of a night. This sudden shift to violent chaos brought a serene calmness over him, a soothing break from having to stomach watching the bastard touch her. But only for a moment.

 

Rosello pointing a gun to Will's head was only a slight improvement to him drooling over her tits.


She had taken out her small pistol and placed it on the table, pushed to Rosello’s side. In her small red dress, she looked vulnerable and shaken. The yellow mood lighting of the restaurant made her look jaundiced. Hell, this was the most scared he had ever seen her. He wanted to tell her everything was going to be alright.


“What kind of game?” Will’s voice had gone low and gentle, as though soothing a child in a tantrum.


“Truth or Dare?”


“How old are you? Twelve?” Hoffman jeered, no longer holding himself back. Rosello’s eyes snapped to him and with one swift movement, he backhanded Will across the cheek with his gun. Hoffman jumped to his feet and Rosello shot a round in the air before returning it to Will’s head. The restaurant’s ambiance had shattered with the screams of nearby patrons. A waiter had been entering the room to provide their next course but had quickly turned around and walked away as if he had forgotten something. Coward. Hoffman couldn’t blame him but he only hoped backup would arrive sooner than later.


“You’re pushing, Markie. And now you’ve gotten her hurt.”


Will spat blood, her cheek swelling asymmetrically. “I’m fine,” she snapped with renewed fury, her words already muffled with pain. “Don’t worry.”


“You both should worry. This version of T and D is going to be judged by yours truly. I’m going to ask Truths I know for a fact are true or false and the dares, you just gotta do. Pretty straightforward, even Markie-boy can't fuck it up. Now. Let’s start. Markie. Truth or Dare. If you don’t follow the rules, I’ll blast her to pieces. One ear at a time. And keep your hands on the table. Both of you.”


The weight of the situation began to press its leaden foot deep into his chest. He curled his hands into fists as they rested on the tabletop, some spilled food sticking to his skin.

Truth would have been his first choice, had it not been for all the dirt Rosello had on him. “Dare.”


Rosello let out a triumphant laugh. “I dare you. To deck Will. Like you mean it.”


“No,” he growled but Rosello shook his head with euphoric glee.


“I have the power. It’s either a fist to her face or a bullet. Your choice, but I believe she’d heal from the fist.”


“It’s fine,” Will looked up at him. “Won’t be the first time I took a punch.”


“And don’t hold back. I’ll know.”


Hoffman shook his head again. “No. I’ll take Truth.”


“No takebacks, Markie-boy. That wasn’t part of the rules. Now, on your feet.”


“I could kill her,” Hoffman muttered, hoping with foolish desperation that Rosello would stop this to protect her. “I could seriously hurt her.”
“I gave you a choice. You chose this. You have on the count of three. One.”


Hoffman got to his feet, looking down at Will whose eyes had gotten wide. Her chest was rising and falling rapidly.


“Two.”


He threw his fist back and sent it towards her, aiming for the hardest part of the skull. Her forehead. Every moment felt as though it had slowed down, despite his desire to have gotten it done and over with. His knuckles dug into the skin of her forehead and pain shot up his wrist. He had tried to minimize the damage by striking her with as open of a fist as he could sneak by, the pain shooting up his arm and his fingers. Fuck.


She had not escaped unscathed. Her head flung back and she fell out of her chair, delirious. “Fuck,” she groaned to his relief. She'd be fine.


“Damn, Red. I guess this explains how you stuck around with Griffin for so long. You sure can take a punch. Sit down, Markie.”


Hoffman collapsed into his chair, looking at the floor with only contempt grinding in his teeth. He felt like a fucking monster.


“Now,” the persistent snapping of fingers forced him to look at their torturer who seemed bored. “I need you both attentive, otherwise the game will get boring. Come on, Red. Back in your chair, now.”


She was struggling to pull herself up, the straps to her dress falling down and revealing bruising skin and scrapes on her chin. “Sorry, Toni,” she spat again, her teeth as bright scarlet as her smudged lipstick. Her nose was bleeding and dripping liquid crimson onto the pale skin of her chest and dress. Hell, her eyes looked like they're bleeding. She locked eyes with Hoffman and but he had to look away. He felt nothing but disgust for himself. “Good call getting Hoffman to throw the punch. You’d never be able to hit me like that.”


Rosello’s giddy gasps in between the background noise of people fleeing the scene in shuffling panicked footsteps filled their pause as Will coughed and wiped at her nose. “You,” Rosello was wheezing, “are one fun broad.”


“I’ve got nothing to lose, now. So my turn. I choose Truth.”


“Oh, no fun. Fine.” Rosello pulled the gun away to scratch his head with the barrel. Hoffman cursed himself for not immediately tackling the man as he swiftly trained it onto Hoffman now. “Fine. Are you wearing a wire?”


“No.”


Rosello squawked the cheap imitation of a buzzer. “That’s a lie.”


“No it’s not!” She jumped to her feet, patting herself down. “You had me searched. No wire.”


“Well, I was implying underwire.” Rosello put his finger on the trigger. Hoffman shut his eyes tightly, embracing the darkness.


“Stop! I’m not wearing that either.”


“You going to prove it?”


A small, disbelieving laugh from her. A delay. “Is this your way of getting me to take my clothes off?” Despite it all, she sounded incredulous. The sound of a zipper forced Hoffman to open his eyes.


What the fuck.


She had taken her dress off and let it fall to her ankles with a plop. Had the circumstances been different, he would have thought he’d won the lottery. But it was some warped, drug-induced nightmare. She turned in a circle, draped in revealing, but practical, underwear and his most hated enemy eyefucked her as she showcased her anatomy. “See?” She went to retrieve her flimsy clothes. “No wires. Not even with the bra.”


“Oh, don’t put it all away, honey,” Rosello whined as she put her clothes back on. “Fine. Hoffman gets to survive round one. Damn.” Rosello pulled the gun back to Will. “Truth or Dare.”


“Truth.” Hoffman needed another chance to take out Rosello. A shift in attention. Something. But the man was hyperfocused. The blob was clenching his teeth, rolling on the high of being God to them. And he was raising his magnifying glass over the ants to watch them burn.


Triumph. It radiated off the mobster and Hoffman already knew what the question would be. “Who killed Frank Griffin?”

The air felt cold and thin.


Hoffman swallowed and avoided Will’s face. “No one.”


“Liar.” Rosello got to his feet and shifted over to Will, grabbing a fistful of her curls and pressing the gun to her temple. “Now you’re going to watch as Will bleeds out a new hole.”


“It’s the truth.” Hoffman didn’t back down and Rosello, for once, looked less hyper and more fascinated.


“I ordered you to kill Griffin. You said you did it.”


“I don’t follow all your orders. And I was lying then.”


“Then where is he?”


“Not the game.”


“I decide what is the game,” Rosello’s fingers were running up Will’s cheeks, thumb brushing over her lip.


“Then what are the new rules?”


Rosello looked torn as he looked down at Will who was gripping his wrist to try to lighten the tension in her hair connected to his fist. “What about me?" She was furious, teeth bared with fresh anger. "Don’t I get my turn in the original game? Come on, Toni. Ask me. Truth or Dare. Didn’t you have a master plan all this drama? Don’t let Markie-boy ruin the fun.”


Hoffman narrowed his eyes to Will, not liking how she was hijacking his attention. The heavy man leaned over her, breathing rapidly. While he was focused on her, Hoffman went to reach for his ankle holster. Rosello snapped to look at him and he froze. “Hands on the table, Markie-boy. And Red. Thanks for reminding me.” He released her hair and walked over to Hoffman, gun pressed to his heart. “Truth or Dare, Red.”


“Dare.” She got to her feet, kicking her heels off. There was a feral energy in the way she bared her shoulders. She looked as though she was planning on doing something impulsive. Drastic. 


It was time they did something drastic. But the gun was pressed into him and he had no vest. Nothing to stop that caliber from punching a hole right through him.


“I dare you,” Rosello dug into his breast pocket and pulled out a folded piece of paper. He tossed it onto the table. “To marry me.”


She smirked in disbelief then gently unfolded the document. “How can this legally stand?”


“Never underestimate the magic of lawyers. The Rosello family just needs your signature. What’ll it be, Red? Your hand in marriage and I’ll let your partner go. Hell, I’ll give him and his sister and future brother-in-law immunity. After all, he’s going to get his heart broken no matter what you choose.”


Will bit her lip as she studied the paperwork. “Will,” Hoffman growled. Honeyed amber illuminated him, a look of calm clarity reflected through the bloody face. He pleaded with her. “Don’t.”


“Not much of a choice, Mark,” she sighed. “You got a pen?”


“Sure,” Rosello went to retrieve one but paused. “Give me a sec.” He turned to look down at his pantlegs while digging one hand through the various pockets and Hoffman went for the opportunity.


He didn’t think too much on whether he’d live through it. But he damn well wasn’t going to let Will sign that paper.


The sound of the gun going off and the worst pain in his chest struck through him like lightning. He felt wet. He felt cold. He remembered to pull out the gun in his ankle holster and he raised it up to Rosello, who had been dancing in circles searching for his lost pistol.


He lined his sight but the sound of a loud pop confused him. He hadn’t fired yet. But his vision was blurry. His arms were so heavy. He couldn’t breathe.


“Mark!” Fire, red and warm, touched his face and pressed into his chest with searing pressure. He let out a low groan, wondering why it hurt so much. “Hold on. You’re going to be okay.”


Sure he was. He wasn’t worried. Every time he blinked the blurry world got darker. He wasn't scared, not when she was there with him. Safe.

Chapter 20: Pre-Saw: Amanda

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Angelina Acomb

When she got the phone call, it had played out exactly as she had always feared. Ally had called to give her the worst news. 

Mark was taken to the ICU, having been shot. By Toni Rosello.

She couldn’t think straight as she tried to choose a sweater to put on. She needed to get ready to leave. Ally and Eric were going to be there any minute. She shouldn’t be struggling to choose something to wear. Just choose one!

She realized she was crying and wiped at her cheeks.

Somehow, she had gotten to the floor. There was a dust bunny under her bed. Her knees throbbed. Her ears were ringing.

And the tears just kept pouring. 

Warm hands on her shoulders and arms engulfed her. She recognized the smell of fresh laundry and Peter’s body wash. “Ange. It’s going to be alright. Let me help you. Come on.”

She didn’t remember much beyond the apartment.

Darkness. Movement. Lights.

It was beginning to rain. The cold didn’t bother her. But the splash of raindrops jolted her awake.

She was walking to the hospital, the white building and the familiar red cross a beacon that wrenched her back to reality. 

The smell of rubbing alcohol was like a sharp sting in her brain.

Will was there, an oversized blazer around her shoulders. Her dress was red. The dark fabric looked off. Wet. But not with rain.

There was blood on her knees. Blood stained her dress. And the suit jacket, despite the stains, was familiar.

She had bought it for him last Christmas. Tears made her vision blurry, once again. She wondered if it was Mark’s blood.

“Angie,” Will turned and threw her arms around her neck, pulling her in a trembling hug. “He’s in surgery right now.” Will smelled of copper and gunpowder and the ivory soap her brother had used since they were kids. She pulled her close, shutting her eyes tight and holding on for dear life.

“Please tell me he’ll live,” she whispered, praying to God and anyone that would listen. “Please. No matter what, don't let Mark die.”

No one responded.

David Tapp

David Tapp shook his head as Toni Rosello’s face disappeared behind the zipper of the oversized black body bag. It was one of their largest ones, XXXL, and the fucker barely fit. 

He watched the coroners try to hold the seams together as they pushed the bulk down to pull the zipper up. Tapp wished the warm and fuzzy feelings of finally catching the bad guy would sink in.

But it didn’t.

It just didn’t feel right, the way it all ended.

And he had a creeping feeling in his gut, like a rot with roots. It was spreading inside, an itching burn that promised that this wasn’t the last of their problems.

This city seemed to love attracting criminals of a whole new magnitude of pain in the ass.

Sing appeared by his side. “Looks like there’s already violence on 9th and Cicero. Rosello’s main stomping grounds are going through territory grabs from his underlings. Sounds like Zietta Rosello is trying to keep things under control and failing.”

Tapp nodded, not surprised. “How’s Hoffman?”

Sing raised an eyebrow. “Doesn’t look good. Matthews and Kerry are at ICU with Maddox. He’s in surgery.”

Tapp sighed. "And the wire?"

"It gave us enough. He gave a whole monolog to Hoffman right before Maddox showed up. Good ol' Toni didn't expect a thing. He just had to run his mouth, admitting to all sorts of convictable offenses. We got him and enough dirt to keep the Rosellos at bay."

Tapp nodded. “Good. Let’s get this all wrapped up so we can tell Grissom to put out the news that this city is finally free of Toni Rosello.”

“Detectives,” Lindsey Perez greeted as she and Peter Strahm arrived on the scene. “Before we fly back to Washington, we wanted to thank you for your work.”

“We’ll be sure to send copies of all records and evidence to the Bureau.”

“Good. We hope Hoffman pulls through,” Strahm forced a grimace, clearly trying to show sympathy. “I admit, I was surprised he put himself out there. If it wasn’t for him, we’d probably still be standing around with our thumbs up our asses.”

“And Maddox dead,” Sing muttered under his breath. 

Tapp shook hands with the feds and watched them leave. He had a feeling it was going to be the last time he’d see those two kids. Which was a shame. They were damn good cops.

“Strahm,” Sing had slunk to talk to him in a softer voice. He heard bits and pieces, Maddox’ name being dropped. He wasn’t sure what about, though he had an inkling that Strahm and Maddox had a thing at some point. 

Sounded like Strahm intended to part without saying goodbye.

It was how life was, sometimes.

Tapp remembered when Tiffany would get mad when he had to drop whatever he was doing and report straight to work. It was part of why she had left him, the constant moving. For people like them, romance always took backseat.

Besides. Tapp, though he often tried to keep his nose out of everyone’s business couldn’t help but smile. If Hoffman pulled through, looked like Maddox would finally be off the market. This was good. It meant most of the thirsty clowns would stop getting so distracted whenever she walked by.

After she left Frank, productivity had noticeably slowed.

He sighed, the reality of the end of the task force sinking in. He’d have to go back on generic cases. The typical braindead assignments. He almost wished another thrilling case would show up sooner than later. Otherwise, it was going to get boring fast.

Daniel Rigg

Daniel Rigg had been amongst the many boys in blue who heard the news. A dark cloud had set over the station. All, even those who had dismissed Mark Hoffman as a no-good sellout, had become grim with guilt as one of their own was holding on by a thread.

He wanted to go straight to the hospital. But Grissom had ordered all hands to remain on station. He had to go patrol. There was a call of a robbery and it was his turf. So he went to investigate.

Despite all the chaos from the sting operation, it had been a slow couple of weeks. There hadn’t been too much to do beyond patrolling and checking in with the news. 

It was raining. Cold. He internally groaned, knowing the robbery had taken place at a park. When he arrived to back up the officer on the scene, he recognized one of the suspects currently handcuffed and sitting on a curb. A skinny man with a weasley face. Beside him was an emaciated young woman who looked more dead than alive, her eyes blackened sockets.

“Cecil Adams,” Rigg shook his head in disapproval. “Why am I not surprised?”

“Fuck off, pig,” Cecil snapped. “I ain’t saying nothing.”

“No need,” the officer on the scene turned. “It seemed these two had a brilliant idea of distracting tourists and lifting their valuables off them. When one of them fought back, it got violent.”

“Charges?”

“For this one,” the officer nodded down to Cecil, “Assault, robbery, conspiracy to commit a robbery. And this one,” the woman was gestured next, “aiding and abetting, robbery, and conspiracy.”

Rigg nodded. “All right. I’ll take them in. Hey,” Rigg squatted down to the woman, her hair stringy. She shied from him. “What’s your name?”

She was trembling. He assumed she was a junkie, desperately in need of a fix.

“Amanda.”

“Okay, Amanda. A word of advice. Keep clear of this guy.” He looked over at Cecil. “He’s nothing but trouble.”

She said nothing, only stared at him with an intensity that made his blood cold. 

Shit. She’s not gonna listen to me. He sighed and straightened up, preparing to take them back to the station.

 

Notes:

A/N: I know Amanda claimed she never took drugs until after Matthews framed her and had her thrown in prison, but I wanted her to finally make her appearance. I'll try to figure out a way to make it all fit. (Maybe she's not on drugs, just robbing people :P)

Chapter 21: Pre-SAW: Promotion to Detective Sergeant

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

He was floating. Flying. He was in the air. The world was gray. And misty. He thought he heard a noise in the distance but it was gone before he could pause to listen. Everything hurt. 

He felt as though he was on a spinning top, being pulled apart at the limbs. Stretched like a rubber band as he rotated. And then the pain exploded, in his chest. 

It was hard to breathe.

He heard a high pitched beep. Consistent.

He heard crying. Angie? 

And a voice. Not Ange. He knew that voice.

“He’s stable,” a male voice came in, clear. “The anesthesia should wear out soon.”

“That’s a relief. Is there any lasting damage?”

“No. Not after a few months of taking it easy. He needs to be placed on limited duty.”

“Don’t worry, he will.”

“Promise me, Will, when he wakes up, you’ll make sure he doesn’t try to play hero.” It was Angie. She sounded scared. Angry. Both.

“I promise, Ange.” 

Will.

He wanted to say her name but when he tried to move his mouth he felt as though his lips were taped shut. 

He tried to move. His arms were filled with lead. 

Everything was heavy. 

He opened his eyes.

“He’s awake!” 

He saw his sister. His partner. His future brother. His coworkers. 

“Mark,” Will, her face bruised, tears streaming down her cheeks, leaned against the bed and touched his hand. 

“Thank God,” Angie was also weeping, eyes red and swollen. There was a heated fury in how her lips trembled, as if he had done something wrong. Peter held her with a relieved smile. 

“Fuck,” he growled, figuring out how to use his mouth. “I feel like I’ve been pushed through a cheese grater.”

Will laughed and swiftly broke down into another string of tears. She wiped her face furiously. “You saved my life.”

“Couldn’t let you marry that prick.”

His sister had a slight waver of confusion before she shook it away. “You both are going to be the death of me.”

“We got ‘em, Ange. He’s not going to bother us anymore.”

Ange inhaled sharply, letting out a low chuckle. “You did it. I knew it.” She sat on the edge of the hospital bed, sniffling. “I hate hospitals.”

“I know, Ange.” He took a slow breath, the action making his tight chest burn. “You can go home.”

“I’m not leaving you.”

“How long have you all been here?”

“Your surgery took six hours.”

The doctor cleared his throat. “You’re lucky you survived. Very lucky. Two bullets went through soft tissue. One had penetrated your liver. The other, a portion of your small bowel. You’ll be off your feet for at least a week. Then, the next few months you’ll need to take it easy. And I would wait three weeks before consuming alcohol.” The doctor stared down at him, as if he knew of Hoffman’s drinking habits, before turning to the other cops. “I know you guys like to be all macho, but make sure he stays out of the action. He’ll be catching bullets in no time so long as he rests when he needs to.”

Angelina made a shocked noise while Matthews chuckled.

Hoffman let everyone talk. He leaned back into his pillows, watching them.

Matthews went on the phone, casting a glance in his direction every so often as he paced on the other side of the room. His hand was on his hip and he was biting his lip. He did that whenever he craved a cigarette. 

Peter and the girls were off to the side, listening to the final words of the doctor. Kerry was pulling at her necklace. Angie linked her arm around Peter’s, resting her head against his shoulder. She looked tired. Worn.

He winced from the throbbing in his chest. He blamed guilt. Ange shouldn’t be worrying about him. She had her wedding to plan. 

“Thank you, Doctor,” Will, always in control, concluded the discussion.

“I assure you, he’s out of the woods. It’s late. You should all go home. Get some sleep.”

“We will,” Peter forced a smile and looked down at his fiance, who shook her head.

“No. I’ll stay.”

“No,” Mark cleared his throat. “Ange, you must be exhausted. Go get some sleep. I’ll be fine. Visit me in a few hours.”

“I’ll stay with him,” Will suggested. “I’ll keep him company.” Angie pursed her lip but when she locked eyes with Mark he gave her one of his looks. She blinked and nodded, understanding. 

“All right.”

Matthews yawned. “Sounds like a plan. Hoffman, you’re a tough bastard. See ya.” 

The room cleared out, Angie quickly returning to his bedside to give him a gentle hug and a kiss on his temple. “Love you.”

“Love you, sis.”

The group left, leaving Will behind.

He turned his head, smirking at her. “You owe me. Big.”

She let out a surprised scoff, hugging herself and nodding. “Yeah.” Her voice was a tired whisper, throaty. “I sure do.”

“Come here.” He held a hand out, wondering why she was so far away.

She walked to him, her heels clicking sharply, drowning out the beeps of his heart rate monitor. 

Still dressed for Rosello, now looking as though she had escaped a zombie apocalypse, she still looked so damn beautiful. 

She stood next to him, her thigh just out of reach. Her cheek was still swollen. “How’s your face?”

She looked away. “Intact. You sure can throw a mean punch.” 

“Hey.” He looked up at her, wanting to touch her. “Come closer.”

She smiled nervously. “What are you planning?”

“Come here and see.”

She did.

He took her hand and squeezed it, surprised to feel it cold. “It’s over.”

“Yeah. It is.” Her eyes were shining and she cleared her throat. “You’re free.”

“Thanks to you.”

She raised an eyebrow. “You were the one who knocked Rosello down. Taking bullet s for me.”

“I wouldn’t have had the chance, if it weren’t for you, putting yourself out there. Willing to let that bastard toy with you. I’m grateful. I want you to know that.”

She bit her lip. “So,” she smiled. “We can go back to the way things were? Before?”

“I don’t want that.”

She flinched, hurt. “I see.” He shook his head, frustrated at being misunderstood.

“I want more.”

“What do you mean?”

“I want us to be together.”

She blinked. “Mark, I think you’re pretty drugged up on painkillers right now. I don’t think… you’re not thinking clearly.”

“Maybe.” He felt himself grin up at her. Maybe that’s why the room feels fuzzy. “But I want you, Will.”

She looked surprised. Lost. Uncertain.

He didn’t want her to feel those things. 

But regardless, she sure looked pretty with her eyes so wide. Afraid.

Was it fucked up to find her attractive when she looked so scared?

Yeah, probably.

He sunk back into his pillows, dizzy. “I think I need to sleep.”

“Good idea. I’m going home to take a shower and will be right back. We’ll play some cards.”

“Bring some whiskey.”

“No.”

He chuckled, weakly, as he felt himself drift away.

 

Will Maddox

 

The flash of the camera gave her a headache. She hadn’t slept much lately. It was Hoffman's first day out of the hospital, the same hospital she had practically lived in for the past week, trading off with Angelina in shifts. Not that she was complaining.

The cameras were only flashing because of good things this time. 

So she smiled as an applause thundered in her ears.

The uniform’s collar was tight and felt as though she was being choked. She cleared her throat and kept showing teeth as the reporters looked on with approving faces. It was a rare experience. Normally, when the media was around, it was a witch hunt for the scape goat to blame for some fuck up that MPD had failed to sweep under the rug. 

They stood behind Grissom, who was leaning against the center podium of the press conference room and speaking into the mic.

“I am proud of the men and women who came together to take down one of the most evil organized crime leaders of our time. And it is with pride that I promote Officers Mark Hoffman and Wilhelmina Maddox to the rank of Detective Sergeant.”

Another flash and a roar of applause. 

In the crowd, Will recognized Angie and Peter, both grinning widely and waving up at them. She watched Hoffman in the corner of her eye, who also was grinning widely.

A pang of worry struck her. She wondered if he was tired from standing for too long. 

Grissom and the city commissioner presented their placards, showcasing their titles with golden starred badges glistening in the fluorescent lights. 

Hoffman and Maddox took their prizes, shaking hands with their supervisors for a job well done. Maddox let out a sigh of relief when the ceremony had concluded.

“Mark! Will!” Angelina approached them, dressed in a pink paisley dress, beaming like a sunrise. Mark approached her, all jolly and joyous, holding out his award to her. She looked at it briefly before holding her arms out to pull him into a deep embrace.

“I’m so proud of you,” she kissed his cheek before turning to Will to hug her as well.

Will had never seen Mark so expressively happy before. Never, in the years she had known him. She knew he had all but given up on any hopes of ranking up until this case. 

Despite the odds, he overcame such a terrible obstacle. Pride swelled in her chest, knowing he would go forth from that day and never tarnish his hands again. He had changed since she met him. He was more in control. More careful.

He had learned his lesson with letting a mad man take control over his life.

Even if something else came up, she was confident that, together, they would beat whatever came their way.

She would help keep him on the straight and narrow. He would watch her back.

She would keep her partner out of trouble. This, she silently swore to herself.

“Congrats, Will,” Sing walked up and shook her hand. “How does it feel, Sarge?”

“About the same,” she shrugged. “It just hasn’t sunk in yet.”

“Oh, once everyone comes at you for your signature, it will.” Sing laughed at his own joke, waving in the distance. Tapp and Gibson were still seated in the audience, speaking amongst each other. Tapp gave a nod and a smile to Will. Gibson was glaring in Hoffman’s direction, a sullen look shown.

“About time,” Vernon Knox wheeled up to them, looking surprisingly clean shaven and showered, smirking up at Mark and Angelina. “Proud of you.”

Will decided to let the old partners have their moment and she left the room. Her thoughts were on her father and a tremor in her chest made her wonder if she should have invited Bram. But the guilt of knowing that Bram was currently back in San Diego, caring for their father, shoved that thought into a box far in the back of her mind.

She decided to explore her new workspace to keep her mind off of her personal life.

She walked through the rookie pit, climbing the stairs and going down the corridor where small but private offices were nestled along narrow walls. She stopped when she reached an office. Grissom had immediately reassigned her and Hoffman to this new room.

The door still required their nameplates as an identifier. The frosted glass hid its interior.

She opened the door and walked in, noting the two small desks and sparse decor. 

It would be strange, sharing this room with him. It felt intimate. Private. A piece of this building that was all theirs and theirs alone.

She decided to grab the desk closest to the door. She figured Hoffman wouldn’t want to be the very first person seen when someone entered. She smirked at this, tossing her hat onto the tabletop and taking a seat behind her new desk.

The door opened and Hoffman came in, raising an eyebrow before closing the door. “So these are the new digs?”

“Yep.” She spun on her swivel chair, grinning. “Congratulations, Mark.”

“Congratulations.”

They stood in silence, looking at each other, as though frozen in a trance.

A knock on the door made them both turn. 

“Hey, congrats, ladies,” Matthews strode in with a cigarette dangling from his mouth.

“I’ve got to say, I’m going to miss seeing you guys every morning. Don’t forget to come down and visit us lowly folk every so often.” 

Allison Kerry came in, a thumb in her belt. “By the way,” she lowered her voice and whispered to Will, “Just a fair warning. Gibson was running his mouth again. I heard he’s switched to IA and he’s out for blood. Hoffman’s, to be specific.”

Will nodded. “Thanks.” She had a bad feeling about Gibson. She really needed to clear things up with him.

Chapter 22: Pre-Saw: Matthews and Kerry Caught

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Matthew Gibson

 

He was happy for Will. 

Really.

But when he saw her and Hoffman leave together, he felt a stir in his gut.

“Someone’s got to stand up to that prick,” he muttered.

“Now, Gibson,” Tapp turned to him with a bemused smile. “Today’s a happy day. None of our boys died. Rosello’s gone. Just enjoy it.”

“Aren’t you mad?” Gibson rounded to the veteran cop. “You, of all people, know what Hoffman did. What he’ll keep doing.”

The image of the junkie that had taken his gun filled his vision. The guy’s chest, exploding as Hoffman shot him in the back. The spray of hot blood on his face. The taste of metal and gunpowder. It haunted him.

It had been cold blooded. 

Cruel.

It had been wrong.

“Now, Gibs, I know you’re all excited with your new assignment with IA. But remember what happened last time? You need to have hard evidence before bringing down a superior. Especially now that the precinct sees Mark Hoffman as the hero that took bullets to save our golden girl? I bet you ain’t gonna find a single cop here who’ll say boo to Mark Hoffman now. Now, you’re a nice kid. I may even agree with you on a lot. But I also know to be smart about it. Pick your battles. Let it go.”

Gibson clenched his jaw. Tapp must not have been that clean. 

This entire department was dirty.

He’d clean it up.

He swore it. Even if it killed him, he’d be sure the bad guys would face justice.

He got to his feet and almost collided into Detective Kerry.

“Easy there, hon, where’s the fire?”

He grumbled and walked away, shoving his hands into his pockets.

How could Will stand being partners with that creep?

He went to blow off steam. Poured some coffee. Chewed on a toothpick. 

But his feet somehow carried him away from the Cop Pit and to the higherup’s level. He knew where Hoffman’s new office would be. And he wanted to give the guy a piece of his mind.

He knocked the on frame. Hard.

The door opened.

It was Hoffman.

He looked past him, searching for Will.

She wasn’t there.

“Looking for Maddox?”

“Uh,” he looked up at Hoffman, suddenly remembering that he was noticeably larger than he. “No. I want to talk to you.”

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” Gibson squirmed, suddenly feeling warm. “I’m out of Homicide. I’m now in IA.”

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” He rubbed his nose. Fuck it. “About what happened at the Crossroads. You killed that man. It was wrong. And you may now have this entire department around your finger but I want you to know,” he paused, “that I know what you are. What you’re capable of. And I’m going to keep a close eye on you. If you step out of line. If you start slipping. I’ll be there and I’ll bring you in.”

Hoffman’s face had gone blank. His lips curled into a sneer. “Oh, will you?”

“Yeah.” Gibson cleared his throat. “And Maddox. She’s a good person. I won’t let you,” he rubbed the back of his neck and looked away, “corrupt her. Someone’s got to protect her from you. You got me? I’ve got my eye on you, Hoffman.”

“I’m shaking like a leaf. I didn’t know Maddox needed you to be her knight in shining armor. I’m sure she’ll find that cute. But let’s get things straight.” He took a step towards Gibson and they were chest-to-chest. “She’s my partner. If there’s any protecting her to be done, I’ll be the one to keep her safe. Not some loudmouth rookie who’s still waiting for his balls to drop. So here’s a tip. Back the fuck off.

They glared hatefully at each other.

“Hey, what’s going on here?”

It was Will, holding two cups of coffee with concern knitting her eyebrows.

“Gibson was just saying congratulations. He’s leaving now.”

“Okay?” She smiled but her eyes still sparked with awareness. “Oh, Matt, I heard you’re now in IA. Glad to hear it. I’m sure you’ll do great there.”

He felt his cheeks flush. Hoffman was staring down at him, waiting. “Thanks, Will.”

He couldn’t help it. I’m a fucking coward.

He walked away.

 

Allison Kerry

 

“But we had to get back to Virginia. You know you’ll always hold a special place in my heart, Ally. But long distance just won’t work. We good?” 

Allison tossed her hair over her shoulder, squeezing the receiver tightly. “Yeah. We’re good.” She refused to believe her heart was breaking. No, she had Eric. 

She didn’t need Linds. It had been a fling. Just a fling.

“As soon as I can, I’ll find another reason to get back up there. Maybe we can pick up where we’re leaving off, you know?” Lindsey’s voice was playful but laced with concern. “I’m not the only one with regret here. Strahm feels terrible about how things just ended. He didn’t even say goodbye. How has Will taken it?”

Kerry sighed into the payphone, still looking at the convenience store entrance for Eric to come out. It was just like Lindsey, to try to deflect with gossip. “Well, Will doesn’t seem too concerned. I wasn’t even sure they were an item.”

“So here’s the thing. I heard they were seeing each other, but purely in a professional setting. Which is weird, isn’t it?”

“Actually, it sounds like what’s expected of adults to do.”

“Ouch. That’s fair.”

Allison kept looking over her shoulder. She felt like she was about to be caught cheating - which was ridiculous, considering she wasn’t the one married and with a child - and wanted to get off the phone promptly.

She wasn’t too torn up about Lindsey. She and Eric had just spent the morning getting reacquainted with each other’s anatomies. She had almost forgotten how to use his equipment. Working with Lindsey, and getting ‘reacquainted’ with her old college roommate, had been the longest period of time being with one person exclusively. Well, the closest thing to exclusivity for her. Technically, she had still been fucking around with Eric behind Jane’s back.

Long term relationships weren’t a thing in her line of work. 

She knew that.

So why did her chest sting so goddamn much? 

“Ally, I’ve got to go. See you later.”

“Yeah. Bye, hon.” She hung up and got into the car, biting the inside of her cheek.

Eric finally returned with some chips and a soda, a tense look on his face. He opened the door and threw in his purchase. “I’ve got a page. It’ll be a minute.”

He slammed the door, angry. 

She already knew it had been Jane. 

Lately, it seemed his wife had been needier than usual. It had set him on edge.

This had made their latest trysts more intense, as if he was trying to fuck his way out of his marriage.

Which, technically, he was.

She watched him in the phone booth, the yellowing glass distorting his face. But his arms said it all. His body language started defensive. Then openly hostile. She watched as he took the receiver and slammed it against the glass, hard.

She leaped out of the car as he continued using the plastic phone as a hammer, cracking into yellowing glass, lines spiderwebbed around his impact.

“HEY! Easy there, big guy!” Allison opened the booth door and released the pandora box of Eric Matthews’ vulgar vocabulary.

“You fucking bitch! You think you can take my kid away?!”

“ERIC!” She put a hand on his shoulder and he flinched.

She had seen Eric furious before.

But this time, she wasn’t sure if she should risk trying to cool him down. 

He stormed out and kicked a can. He was unbridled, enraged violence in the form of flailing punches and a snarl. 

She watched as he tired himself out, nervous when a couple of bystanders stopped to observe his tantrum.

He collapsed to the ground, pinching his nose and breathing heavily.

Allison slowly approached his back. “Eric. Let’s go. I’m driving.”

Eric complied, not brushing the gravel off his clothes and slumping into the passenger seat. She started the car and drove off, her heart racing.

“What happened?”

“She’s leaving me.”

Allison swallowed. “She knows.”

“She found one of your bras when doing the laundry. I thought it was one of hers. I just threw it in the hamper this morning.”

She bit her tongue, withholding any admonishments. She would have called him a dumbass, if she had not been as equally responsible.

“I’m sorry.”

Matthews was staring out the window. “Now what am I going to do?”

She didn’t know.

Notes:

A/N: So so sorry for the drop in activity. Moving and all sorts of chaos in my life right now. Will be writing more consistently soon, likely once the dust settles end of August.

Chapter 23: Pre-SAW: Angelina and Peter Acomb's Wedding

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

He didn’t know the details on why Kerry asked him to take Matthews on a case. But judging by how quiet and depressed the guy was, he had a few ideas. Guess the cat’s out of the bag.

“Hey, Hoffman.” McCallister greeted them as they made their way to the parking lot. Roger McCallister worked in Narcotics and, back when Hoffman and Matthews had been partnered as rookies, had been a friend. But once Hoffman ended up cornered to being Rosello’s gofer, McCallister had treated him as if invisible for years. Now, the stout redhead was beaming up at him as if he was Santa Claus. “At some point, I’d like to pick your brain on this case I’m having a hard time on.”

“Sure, I’ll come by.” Hoffman was enjoying this newfound attention. Now, people came to him for help. They trusted him, eager for his advice on how to handle a particular murder investigation or approach an interrogation. 

Matthews seemed on autopilot, grumbling to himself that he needed to buy a new lighter on the way out to the scene. He had buzzed his hair. Hoffman never pointed it out, knowing it was a way to cope with the rapid thinning hairline he was currently experiencing. 

Will walked past the two men, a fat stack of papers in her hands. She beamed at him as she power walked to their office, red curls bouncing.

He never wanted to lose this feeling, this high he was experiencing every time he looked at her.

Angie’s wedding was next week. Rosello was gone. 

Will and him were back to working together. After his day being Matthew’s therapist, that was. 

No problems in my corner.

Life was finally starting to look up.

For Matthews, though, the man had lightning in his eyes and dark clouds over his head. 

“Kerry mentioned a domestic dispute. Uptown.”

“Fine. Stop by the liquor store on the way there.”

Hoffman raised an eyebrow but didn’t refuse.

They stopped along the way, Matthews scowling and going into the store to return with a brown paper bag, a carton of cigarettes, and a new lighter. Hoffman felt himself relax when Matthews shoved the bottle of bourbon in the glove box. That was one complication he didn’t have to deal with.

Hoffman rolled down the windows as Matthews chainsmoked the rest of the journey.

When they arrived at the address, the apartment building looked fairly maintained. One of the higher end properties that must have cost a fortune every month. The front door was propped open by a brick. No doorman to be seen. Matthews sauntered through, Hoffman darting his eyes around.

There had been emergency calls by several neighbors about a violent altercation with the couple. He and Eric were sent to check in on her, after the wife refused to press charges.

Rex and Jane Wilson. The name was familiar. Hoffman wasn’t sure from where.

When they knocked on the door, the door opened and Hoffman knew.

He cursed himself for not remembering soon enough.

“You.” Rex Wilson, the man who filed a complaint with IA for Rigg breaking his jaw, stood and stared half-surprised-half-furious at the two detectives. Though years since the surgeries had taken place to heal his cracked skull, there were still traces of the scars underneath his stubble. “I told you guys last night. We were just having an argument.”

The wife appeared and Rex turned to yell at her. “I’ve got this, Jane.” After the woman fled, Rex turned back, smirking. “Women. Am I right?”

Matthews did not appear amused, instead leaning against the door frame threateningly. “What happened to your hands?” His lip was pulled back in a sneer, rubbing his thumb against the side of his nose. 

The guy looked down at his knuckles, purple and scabbed. “Punched the wall a few times. I told you guys, I didn’t hurt her. She told you.”

“We’ll need to hear it from her.”

The guy wanted to protest but Matthews lurched and grabbed Rex by the collar. “Listen here, you bastard. I’m in a shitty mood. Bring Jane out here or I’m gonna make your face match your hands.”

“Again?! You think you can get away with fucking me over twice?”

“Eric,” Hoffman pulled his friend off the guy. “Calm down,” he growled, despite wanting more than anything to release the dogs on this piece of shit. Hoffman had a special hatred in his heart for wife beaters. 

Matthews cursed and stormed away. 

Hoffman sighed, shaking his head. Maybe it was because the wife’s name was Jane. Matthews needs to take a sabbatical. Before he does something stupid.

“Please,” the woman’s shaky voice had him turn to her. She had her hand on the door knob. “I’m fine. Please go. Please.” She looked terrified, her eyes brimming. 

But there wasn’t anything more he could do, if she insisted there was nothing wrong.

The bruises on her neck and face were red. 

Hoffman’s mind went to Will.

“Fine.” He took out his business card, discreetly pushing it into her hands. The husband was at her back, coolly watching them. “In case something comes up,” he quietly muttered before adding louder, “Appreciate your time.”

She shook her head. “Thank you. Goodbye.” The door closed quickly in his face.

He hated handling domestic abuse cases.

Neither did Matthews, it seemed. The guy was found right outside the front door with his nostrils flared, scratching his head.

“Sorry. I’m on edge.”

Hoffman nodded. “Maybe you should take the rest of the day off.”

Matthews shook his head. “And what, sit in my shitty motel room and count the cracks in the ceiling?”

Hoffman stood in silence. He wasn’t one to pry. If the man wanted to tell him, he would. Otherwise, it wasn’t any of his business.

“Jane’s leaving me. She knows I’ve been cheating. But not who.” Matthews shook his head, looking closer to crying than Hoffman had ever seen. “Fuck. How did it get so fucked?” He looked at his friend, defeat drawn on his frown. “You know what she said?”

“What?”

“That it’s not like Daniel would notice the difference, me not being there ever. That fucking bitch.” He went to light a fresh cigarette and took a low drag, smoke flowing out of his nostrils as he grunted back what sounded like the start of a sob.

“You can crash on my couch if you need.”

Matthews shook his head. “Thanks, Hoffman. Really. But it’s best if I’m on my own. Don’t need to get in your way.”

“Let’s get some grub.”

“Nah. Let’s just head back.”

Not one to argue with a man whose life was falling apart, Hoffman took Matthews back to the station. They went to McCallister’s office, the guy currently glaring at various photographs. 

“Hoffman. Matthews. How you bastards doin’?”

“Cut to the chase, Roger,” Matthews had lit another cigarette. “What’s the deal?”

“Tryin’ to nab this dealer. We know he’s working with the K2K gang. But every time we think we’ve got ‘em he ends up clean. Fucker’s quick. It’s takin’ too long to wait for ‘em to slip up.”

Hoffman reviewed the file, briefly scanning the statements and looking down at the evidence listed. Guy was never found with so much as a joint on him, though he was supposedly slinging heroin.

“Maybe he’s clean,” Hoffman suggested.

McCallister shook his head. “Nah, we had a witness come forward once, but quickly backed out. Must have been silenced. Bribed, likely.”

“You know what you should do?” Matthews leaned forward with a mean smile. “You know this asshole’s guilty. Just take a shortcut.”

Hoffman looked at Eric, wondering if he heard the guy right. He wouldn’t say he was surprised, per se. More impressed by the frankness.

McCallister, clearly, was as well. “You suggestin’ I plant some on him?”

“Save taxpayer money. Put another dealer away. I suggest you administer justice, Roger.”

Hoffman liked how Matthews phrased that. Administering justice. 

Roger McCallister leaned back, scratching his cheek as he pondered this. “I was thinkin’ about it. Never pulled it, though. How do I make sure that this,” he tapped his desk, “doesn’t blow up in my face?”

“It won’t. IA’s a bunch of pussies and idiots. And who are they gonna believe? A no-good piece of shit with a record? Or a man of the law? Especially when we back each other up. Hell, I’ll go to the scene and be your second set of eyes.”

McCallister looked impressed. “All right. At this point, I’ll try anythin’.”

“Prick won’t see it coming,” Matthews smirked while McCallister let out a raucous laugh. 

 

Will Maddox

 

“Do you, Angelina Marie Hoffman, take this man to be your lawful wedded husband?”

“I do.”

“And do you, Peter Nicholas Acomb, take this woman to be your lawful wedded wife?”

“I do.”

“Then the power invested in me, I now pronounce you husband and wife.”

When the bride and groom kissed, Will joined the thunderous applause that broke out. In a sea of green and gold, draped in a satin bridesmaid dress next to Allison Kerry, Will watched as Angelina Hoffman became Angelina Acomb.

She glanced over at Mark, who had the widest smile she had ever seen, as he watched his little sister on her happiest day.

Will loved weddings.

Despite how her marriage went, she remembered hers with fond, if not bittersweet, memories. And this wedding easily ranked her top three. 

She would never forget seeing Mark and Angie walk down the aisle together, her brother looking like he was doing everything he could not to cry.

It was the sweetest moment she had ever seen.

She hoped Angelina pulled through with providing photos of the ceremony. 

The bride and groom walked down the aisle, arm in arm, and the maid-of-honor and best man followed. Finally, Will slid her arm into Mark’s and the two followed the rest of the wedding party out to music and the claps of the audience. 

He felt warm through his suit, their linked walk both awkward and comforting. “It’s going to be okay, Mark,” she teased once they stepped out to the foyer, breaking apart. He gave her a look and she giggled. Behind them, the patrons began filing out of the chapel and made their way towards the dining hall.

It had been a surreal week. The rehearsals and preparations had brought the two of them together in a new light. Instead of solving murders and dealing with concentrated violence, they had been spending a great deal of time simply enjoying each other’s company.

Doing normal, happy things together. 

She liked it and was feeling a gentle sadness sweep over her when it dawned on her that after that weekend, they would be back to work. Exclusively spending time trying to catch criminals. Cling to life in sudden shootouts. Survive the pain.

Despite his recent hospitalization, he stood tall and proud. He seemed fine.

“Hey. Everything’s going to be okay,” Mark returned her previous statement, though not with the same humor as she. “You look like you’re about to cry.”

She fanned herself, not wanting her makeup to run. “Me? No, I’m fine.”

“Right.” He pulled at his bowtie, clearing his throat.

Changing the subject, she held her bouquet for him to hold while she reached up to straighten the silk fabric. “You know, you’re quite dashing in this.”

“It itches,” he grumbled. “You look good too.”

Her cheeks grew warm. “You have a way with words,” she tried to sound sarcastic but fell flat. 

“Hey,” Kerry approached, waving her bundle of flowers towards the line of bridesmaids. “Lovebirds, it’s time.”

The wedding reception was full of MPD and various friends of Angelina and Peter. Will and Mark walked by Matthews, who looked like he was doing everything he could to smile but resulted in him looking constipated. 

Daniel and Tracy Rigg held drinks up when they walked by, the two looking relatively boozed and content. 

“You ready for the dance?” She looked at her partner with a wary grin.

She felt him stiffen against her. “I’ll get by for a couple of seconds.”

“Don’t worry, I won’t expect the cha cha slide.”

“The what?”

“Nevermind.”

They took their seats, assigned to be next to each other. Allison was with her groomsman, the two clearly hitting it off. Mark had thrown back his glass of champagne and was already looking for his next refill.

“Here,” Will slid her flute towards his hands, the man taking it wordlessly. He seemed nervous, a noticeable first for her to see. “I never took you for a guy who had stage fright.”

“I’m not one for the spotlight,” he muttered.

“Lucky for you, this is a once in a lifetime kind of moment.”

“Yeah. I keep telling myself that. If Ange divorces him, I’m not dancing for the next one.”

“You think they’ll split?”

“Nope. Only way they’re splitting up is the whole ‘death do they part’. Ange is stubborn like that.”

Once the bride and groom had their first dance, it was time for the bridesmaids and their groomsmen to join. Will took Mark’s hand and steered him to the floor, turning and letting him take the lead.

His hand rested on her waist, eyes looking down at his feet. He moved with the careful shyness of a scarecrow, as though he was desperately avoiding stepping on her toes. A drop of sweat was running down his temple as his lips pursed.

She tried to go with it but despite the gentle music he barely budged. “Mark.”

He looked up, locking eyes with her.

“Just look at me. Like we practiced. One. Two. Three.” She moved and counted out loud softly, repeating her cadence. He picked it up, finally moving with her, until he seemed to finally go with the flow.

She looked up at him, realizing he was watching her with an intensity that gave her goosebumps. She smiled widely, taking in the steel blue of his eyes.

“I can see the big dipper,” he said.

She blinked. “What? Where?”

His eyes swept across her face. “On your right cheek. Your freckles.”

“Shut up.” She had the urge to smack him and tried to pull away. 

He chuckled and tightened his grip on her, pulling her closer, their chests now touching. “Now, you’re blushing.”

“You’re an ass.” She smelled the amber and cinnamon of his cologne. “But at least you don’t smell like one.”

“Ouch. Do I normally smell like ass?”

“No. You’re fairly clean. For an ass.”

Seconds became minutes, until she realized the rest of the audience had joined. 

“You know, this is nice,” Mark admitted. “Don’t know why I was worried.”

“You just need the right dance partner,” she smiled back. “I don’t know about you, but I’m starving. And thirsty.”

“Same. Let’s start with drinks.”

“You’ve read my mind.” The two of them stopped moving, though another second lingered before they let go of each other’s hands. 

The rest of the evening, the two of them hung out by the open bar. Will had nabbed various servings of the food: glazed salmon, prime rib, shrimp, kabobs sliders, and more were available. It was a feast fit for a fine chef’s wedding.

“Angie certainly outdid herself with the food,” Will was in between chewing while Hoffman had already finished two plate fulls and was helping himself to some of her kabobs. 

“She pulled a few favors for catering. She has a lot of friends at work.”

Will nodded, feeling warm and light from the drinking. “Their kids are going to be so cute.”

Hoffman choked on a slider, coughing hard into his napkin. Will smirked as she took another sip of whiskey. “Yeah,” he growled, face purple.

“Sorry about that,” Will finished her drink and waved to the bartender for another, taking a deep breath as she felt her pulse quicken. She had a little too much too early and she needed to sit down.

“Hey. You okay?” Hoffman had a cheek full of meat, chewing. 

“Yeah. Just been a long day.”

“Maddox,” Matthews called out, stumbling over to them. Allison was in tow, cheeks pink and looking glassy eyed. “Get me a drink.”

“Get it yourself, the bartender’s right here.” Will shifted over to make room for their colleagues. Matthew leaned against the bar, clearly decimated with liquor. Kerry rolled her eyes and leaned her head against Will’s shoulder.

“Fun night?”

“Hon, you don’t know the half of it.” Ally was breathless, smelling of wine and lilacs. She was sparkling with gems on her ears and neck, a vision of loveliness in the drunken haze. 

“Ladies and Gentlemen,” Angelina’s voice on the microphone captured everyone’s attention, the bride in her grand white gown was turning to smile at every face in the room. “Thank you all for coming. Peter and I are about to turn in for the night. Please, enjoy your evening. Good night.”

The crowd cheered as the bride and groom made their leave, Will sighing in relief. That meant she could finally go to her hotel room, shower, and pass out in her bed. 

She couldn’t wait.

Matthews protested loudly. “Hey! Where is everyone going? The party’s just started!” 

“Cool it, Matthews,” Hoffman growled with warning, a hand on the guy’s shoulder and a firm frown at the man’s out of focused eyes. The message was clear. Hoffman wouldn’t tolerate anyone ruining his little sister’s event.

“Hey, Eric, let’s take a walk. I know a decent bar down the street.” Kerry took Eric’s arm and pulled him, giving an understanding nod as she took Matthews away before he made a scene.

Will let out a breath, relieved the night ended smoothly. “I think it’s time I turned in.” She turned to him with a tired yawn. “Where’s your room?”

The venue, commonly used to host weddings, was a hotel in the respectable historic district of the city. Thankfully, they hadn’t needed to catch rides back to their apartments. Instead, they had rented rooms that were a simple elevator ride away.

“1403. You?”

“1404.” 

“Guess we’re going in the same direction.”

“Yeah.” She bit her lip, withholding the drunken giggle that threatened to escape. Thankfully, a hiccup masked her sudden moment of vulnerable awkwardness and she led the way to the elevator, trying to push the sudden moody thoughts that began to tickle her. She shivered, until a very warm cloak was draped over her shoulders.

Hoffman had taken his jacket off, his bulk hugged by his shirt. Will avoided looking in his direction while they waited for the elevator to reach their level, eyes glued to the level indicator above the doors. 

They stood in silence, as they often did.

But this time, she struggled to remain cool and collected.

Being drunk didn’t help. Her heels were hurting her feet. She was off balance and this made her feel on edge.

She refused to question why. 

She knew why.

Now that their biggest barrier, Rosello, was gone, all that remained in her keeping a distance was her desperate cling to not risk ruining what they had. Their partnership was intact and functional. They understood each other. They were friends. They had a closeness that she feared intimacy would strip away and make vulnerable. 

It was all so fragile.

“Will.”

“Yeah?”

“The door’s open.”

“Oh.” She walked to the elevator, tripping on the edge of the door.

“Hey!” Hoffman caught her, saving her from face planting. “Easy.”

“Shit,” she cursed and angrily collapsed to the rough carpet of the elevator as the doors slid closed. She began unbuckling and taking off her heels, her toes thanking her for the release. 

“Are you about to get sick on me, kid?”

“Ha!” She looked up at him defiantly. “You know I can hold my liquor.”

“Then why are you on the floor,” he looked down at her, smirking. “You’re acting weird.”

The lines on his face emphasized his cheek bones. His lips looked so kissable at that moment. She shook her head, flustered. “I’m just drunk.”

“I thought you ‘hold your liquor’.”

“I meant I’m not going to puke. But I need to go to sleep.”

“Fair enough.”

The doors finally opened, Hoffman holding his hand out for her to take. She gave him her fingers and he pulled her up with ease.

Grabbing her heels, she walked towards her hotel room, digging in her clutch for her key card. She tapped her card to the door lock, waiting for it to be disengaged. 

A red light indicated it had failed.

She tapped it again.

Still, nothing. 

She tried to open the hotel door, tapping and muttering curses under her breath.

“Problem?”

“Yeah, the key’s not working. Fucking new technology. What was wrong with the standard brass key?” She flipped her hair over her shoulder, embarrassed and frustrated. “Great. Now I’m going to have to go back to the lobby.”

“No. We can call down from my room. They’ll send a guy up to let you in.” Hoffman opened his room door, going inside and holding it open for her to enter.

She hesitated.

“What?”

“Nothing.” She had slept over at his place before. They had shared the same bed, in fact. So why was she suddenly feeling so shy? Wary?

She blamed the alcohol. 

She walked across the threshold and into his room.

The bed was large, king sized. She went to the phone and dialed for the concierge, requesting to be let into her room.

“I apologize, miss, our computer system is having some technical issues and it’s going to take at least an hour or two to fix.”

“Are you serious?”

“I apologize. We can provide complimentary refreshments down here while you wait? Or if you remain in the room you’re in, we’ll happily send it up.”

She looked over at Hoffman and her eyes lit up. “Fine. Please send up a bottle of champagne.”

“Right away. We appreciate your understanding.”

She returned the phone and let out a sigh. “Computer problem. Going to be stuck for at least an hour. So the champagne’s on me.”

“I knew you were good luck to keep around.”

She wrinkled her nose and let out another breath. Her dress was tight around her waist and she wanted nothing more than to take it off. “Hey. You got an extra shirt?”

“Yeah. Need a shower?”

“Badly.”

Hoffman went to his suitcase, digging through the clothes and tossing her an old oversized t-shirt that had been from the police academy. “Go ahead.”

“Thanks.” She went into the bathroom, shut the door, and ran the hot water. As the roar of the shower drowned out the sound of the TV playing outside the door, she looked herself in the mirror. Her eyeshadow had smeared. Her eyeliner was running. She pulled her hair over her shoulder and unclasped the top part of the back of her dress. When she moved to unzip, the zipper wouldn’t budget.

She narrowed her eyes and tried again, with more force. “Are you fucking kidding me?” She murmured as she spent a few minutes struggling to unzip her dress.

She looked at the door, conflicted. 

She could ask him to help her, but this seemed too personal. 

I want us to be together. 

She could simply not take a shower and remain in the dress for another hour.

But she was getting irritable with how constricted she felt.  

She shook her head. She was being ridiculous.

A part of her, the small and uncertain troublemaker that poked its shy head around the corner, was eager and hopeful. Maybe this is it.

A part of her wanted what he wanted.

No one will know. Nobody saw you enter his room.

It could be their little secret.

One final tug. Just to try and get out of this moral predicament.

She pulled as hard as she could down on her zipper while gritting her teeth.

When it didn’t give, she surrendered.

Her heart was exploding in her chest when she opened the bathroom door and let the build up of steam release out into the room. “Mark?”

“Yeah?” He was on the bed, sipping booze from the minibar, his bow tie and shirt long hanging on the nearby loveseat. He looked more relaxed and at home in a plain white tank. His shoes were off. He leaned back against the pillows, not looking at her while he watched a rerun of some old football game.

“Can you help me?” She pressed her lips together, flushed.

Hoffman turned, eyes slightly slanted from curiosity. His lip curled in dark humor. “With what?”

“My zipper.” She held her hair up and turned her back, avoiding looking at his face. She felt his eyes, like hot flames on her skin. She heard the rustle of the bedsheets as he stood up and went to her. The sudden feeling of his knuckles and fingers touching the skin of her back made her flinch and she held back the gasp when she felt the callouses brush over her, fingers digging under the seam as he tried to pull the contraption.

“It’s caught good,” he whispered, voice suddenly thick like honey.

“Yep. You think I’m stuck in this?” She wondered if Angie would forgive her if she took a pair of scissors to it. She had told her to keep it. 

The tide of claustrophobia came in like an icy wave. 

“No. I’ve got it.” She felt a tremor in his hands and the build up of energy as he tried to brute force the metal to give. She bit her lip, pressing her front to her chest, bracing for the zipper to finally slacken.

When she heard the sharp rip of fabric, the silence that followed was deafening. 

The dress was now in tatters, shredded fabric dangling from where she held the front. 

Hot, slow fingers landed on her shoulders. She felt his breath against her ear and the smell of whiskey mixed with spices made her dizzy. “I told you I got it.”

“You ripped it.” She didn’t pull away, her heart racing as she felt his other hand feel her bare back, the tips of his fingers dragging down. Her breath caught in her throat. 

“Oops.” And then she felt his lips against her neck, soft and wet.

She felt a primal desire rise from her lower stomach, making her lose all rational thought as though it had been nothing more than water evaporating off her skin. 

The sound of the water made her think of rain. “I should go take a shower.”

“Yeah?” His voice had gone gruff and short, his hand lowering until it stopped at the waistband of her panties. He continued gently kissing the side of her neck, biting into her skin gently. He squeezed her shoulder firmly. “But you’re not even dirty yet.”

She bit her lip, eyes transfixed on the door and the steam that continued to billow out. Her frozen disposition made him scoff and he lifted his mouth away until she let out a soft moan of protest. She sharply inhaled when his teeth dug deeper into her, shooting jolts of pain that broke the spell. She pulled away, turning to him with fury, pushing him while touching her neck that throbbed with the harsh reminder.

“That hurt.” Her stomach was doing cartwheels. Her breathing was hitched.

That cursed part of her that had remained in the background was now on the tips of its toes, now fully attentive and interested. 

She was losing control.

He had let her push him back towards the bed. He sat onto it, amused, elbows on his thighs as he leaned over and leered at her. “You weren’t complaining just a second ago. But I don’t want this to be one sided.” He reached forward, grabbed her wrist, and pulled her to him. She felt like a fish on the hook, being reeled in against her will. “I don’t want you to treat me like-,” He stopped, knowing better.

She was grateful, understanding him. She wanted him to continue and all it would take is one word. One sign that what she was feeling was real.

Despite the familiar voices warning that this would complicate things, that creature that was taking over, growing and demanding, was slamming the door on all common sense.

“I want this, Mark.” She let go of the front of the dress, allowing her breasts to be exposed. His eyes wandered, hungrily, and she felt as if she was back to being college-aged and inexperienced. 

He had suddenly become savage as he tightened his grip on her arm and pulled her quickly to him. She stopped at the edge of the bed, between his legs, her hands catching herself against him, pressed against his full chest. She could see the five o’clock shadow on his chin. His lashes, brown wings around a blue sky. She missed the feeling of his mouth. She needed to taste him.

She decided to finally give in. She dived off the deep end and landed in his sea.

She kissed him first, hungry and willing. She let go of the fabric to her chest, opting to wrap her arms around his neck as she felt him grab a fistful of her hair to steer her head and push his tongue past her lips. 

She gasped when he spun her around and had her pinned to the bed, pulling from her lips to nip at the nape of her neck. She felt his hands grope and search her as he devoured every inch of her.

It felt wholly familiar, as if returning to a long forgotten house that she once lived in for years. 

He undid his pants, revealing a bulge pressed against his boxers. Grabbing the remaining portions of her dress that still covered her hips, he pulled them off with an almost mad energy, a man in lust and control. 

She sat up, leaning against her elbows, as he returned to kiss her. She noticed she felt clumsy and sloppy, another layer of inebriation making her miss his mouth and instead plant her tongue onto his collar. She tasted salt and soap, her hand lightly raking over his stomach as he let out a soft growl of gratification. The healing scars from the gunshots were still raw and red, breaking through the heat like an ice bath for a split second. She kissed them delicately, not wanting to bring him any more pain but to thank him for his sacrifice to her. 

He had saved her life. 

She let her other hand explore down to his boxers, feeling him thick and hard through the cotton. 

“Fuck, Will,” he was squeezing her shoulder, his grip firm but not overpowering.

She pulled the elastic of his waistband, seeing for the first time him in his full glory, and wanted to reward him with wonders that would keep him up at night from then on with heated nostalgia. He tasted of sweat, his girth burning as she took him in her mouth.

His breathing was ragged as Will moved her head back and forth, feeling him slide past her lips and over her tongue, a surge of triumph at every baritone grunt being forced out of his chest like the strike of a flint over her fuel. 

She pulled back, taking his pillar in her hand, to a protested whine from him. “I love how hard you feel in my mouth, Mark.”

He was panting over her as they shimmied further onto the bed, new lovers with lumbering urgency. “I don’t have a condom.”

“I’m on birth control. It’s fine,” her breathing was ragged as well, her legs splayed apart as she felt his firmness press against her and driving her insane. “Please, Mark. I need you.”

He plunged inside of her, his eyes shut tight at savoring the feeling. She arched her back, feeling him fill her to the hilt. Despite how wet and wild she was, the sharpness of being stretched from many months of lone nights brought shockwaves through her spine and she found her nails digging into his back as he gently moved inside her with clenched jaw and restraint. He enveloped her with thankful kisses and increased his speed.

He began pacing his thrusts, the wet smacking sound of their connection adding a teasing tingle through her anatomy and she tossed her head back to cry out in delight. 

This encouraged him to speed up, the feeling of his sweat an additional aphrodisiac as he roughly pushed into her with unhinged power. 

She was building up, about to be overcome, and she whimpered, “I’m so close. Don’t stop.” He ran his thumb over her nub, drawing circles around her clitoris while he slowed down his thrusts and watched her closely. The feeling was too powerful and she had to shut her eyes and simply allow the sensations to shoot through her bones and sing. She felt her limbs jerk like a marionette, Mark pulling the strings with each touch and probe. The growing heat and pressure rose from her groin and up to her crown and then the wave of ecstasy took all the intensity and turned it to sugar in her veins.

Her sudden change in pitch had been his indication to finish, returning to thrusting into her with accelerating pace until he took one final plunge and let out a satisfied bellow as he finished inside of her. He collapsed on top of her, the two of them breathing heavily as a warmth spread inside and down her thighs.

“You…” Hoffman spoke in between pants, voice thick and slow. “...okay?”

She laughed. “I’m great.” She kissed the side of his cheek. 

The phone on the nightstand began to ring.

 

Notes:

A/N: I love how happy-ending this feels. But that means it’s going to be so sad when it all falls apart. 

To those who want some more dark/depraved kinky shit, fret not. Hoffman’s descent into darkness will make things spicier. Promise. But for now, I think he’s still at that rainbow and unicorn vanilla stage in his life.

Feels like I’m not exploring more in depth about Matthews. Next story arc that’s coming up, I hope to go into more detail. (It involves the K2K gang Sing and Tapp had solved right before the events of SAW). I also want to dive deeper into how Matthews framed all the Saw 2 victims, Amanda’s origin, and introduce Gordon. That means one more pre-saw story arc before we finally dive into the real lore.

I’m concerned about writing a boring play-by-play, so I want to minimize writing scenes that actually happened in the movies. Instead, I want to fill in the gaps. Try to make sense of that convoluted plot where everything’s connected (and Hoffman was there at the very beginning). 

To all who have made it this far, thank you for reading. This story is purely self-indulgent but if anyone else enjoys it that makes me happy.

Chapter 24: Pre-SAW: The Heart Stealer

Chapter Text

Peter Strahm

He looked down at the latest victim, another woman with her sternum broken, her ribs now spread like the doors of a bird cage. As with the M.O. of the killer, her heart was missing.

It had been the thirteenth victim in the past year. Erickson had given him the file as soon as he showed up that Monday, back from the Rosello case. No rest for the wicked , he thought to himself as he looked around him. They were in a tobacco field, the tall and thick leaves of the plants providing significant cover in the southern Virginia farmlands. The body was discovered by the farmer, the man hysterical and in need of immediate counseling and no help to them while he muttered to himself incoherently when questioned.

“All victims had traces of a bioluminescent algae on their skin, suggesting they had been in contact with a large body of salt water. The algae is often found in tropical climates. The coroner explained there was an indication that they were submerged for at least several hours before death, based on the state of their skin and the traces of algae found in various orifices of their body, except above the neck.”

Strahm looked up at his supervisor, Dan Erickson, the man looking grim. “He follows his pattern religiously. Almost as if there’s a ceremony behind the removal of the heart.” Strahm stood up, looking around at the roving hills of red clay and leafy green crops. “Victims have all been found on the east coast. From New York to Miami. He must have a localized location within driving distance. The algae is native to South Australia, so he must have a tank.”

“He?”

“No markers indicate a female serial killer. No accomplices. This man is a loner. A man who has a poor relationship with a woman that fits his victims’ appearance. Early to mid twenties. Caucasian, and likely well educated. I’m assuming the suspect is around the same age and race. He’s not rash, he’s careful. He won’t make mistakes, at least for the time being. He may develop a feeling of invincibility if he’s not caught soon.” Strahm grimaced. “If we’re not fast enough.”

“Tell me what you need to nail this sonofabitch.”

“Perez. And any available agent.” Strahm took out his pen, clicking it as he ran through the logistics. He needed some perspective. “We may need some outside help, too.”

Erickson raised an eyebrow. “We’ve already coordinated with the Richmond PD.”

“They’ll do their best. But I know two cops who would be excellent in this case.”

Erickson shook his head. “Best to keep this down low until we have a better sense of what this guy’s about.”

“Thirteen not enough, Dan?” 

“We can’t afford to throw the nation in a panic. See what you can do with what I can spare. If things get worse, I’ll consider bringing in your hand picked choices.” Erickson wiped sweat off his brow with a handkerchief, shaking his head. “There’s been a recent uptick in violent crime this past year. The media’s gone nuts with it. The higher ups are already on edge and out for blood. It’ll not be a good look if the FBI needs help from some city cops. Otherwise, I’d give the go ahead.”

“Politics,” Strahm scoffed, anger rising up and out of him.

Erickson gave a sympathetic nod. “Always. For now, you’ve at least got Lindsey. You both are excellent at what you do. Have a little more faith in your own kind before running for help.” Erickson walked away to talk to forensics.

Strahm looked back down at the victim, her eyes vacant and glazed. Flies were already buzzing in her mouth. He grit his teeth, wondering how the family would recover. They’d have to inform next of kin as soon as they were done at the crime scene, having identified her immediately. It was going to be a long day.

Angelina Hoffman

She refused to cry.

She threw her arms around Peter one final time before he went to board the plane. “I’ll write to you. Call me whenever you can.”

“Sure thing, babe. Don’t worry, it’s only for a few months.” He hugged her tightly, squeezing her until she couldn’t breathe. “Before you know it, you’ll see me again. With a tan.” He smiled, trying to make her laugh.

“That’s too long,” she whispered, her voice cracking. They had only just been married. He had only just returned from boot camp and he had changed so much since then. He had a hardness in his face she hadn’t seen before. His floppy hair had been shaved completely off. He was firmer and louder. Confident.

And now, he was going to Iraq, only a week after the news of the invasion of Kuwait reached her awareness. This was all happening so fast.

Peter stood before her, in desert camo, a man that had changed before her eyes. She hardly recognized Peter Acomb anymore.

“Last call for Flight A2041,” the feminine voice on the intercom had Peter look back at the gate. “We will be closing the door in five minutes.”

“That’s me,” he grimaced and backed away. “I love you.”

“I love you!” Angelina waved back as Peter Acomb disappeared down the boarding gate. She wiped the corners of her eyes and sniffed, sadness squeezing her heart tightly. A hand touched her shoulder, squeezing it gently. She turned to her brother, who gave a comforting look.

“He’ll be back, Ange.”

She nodded, trying to put on a stiff upper lip. “Yeah.” She went with Mark as he drove her home, the day sunny and warm. She tried to think of tasks to get done. Things to keep her mind busy and distracted. She had work and preparations for her new cafe. She had catering contracts to handle. Another charity function. 

She wanted to go with him, her life here seeming pointless and trivial compared to what he would face.

The radio cracked, Mark’s personal car was equipped with a police scanner. A familiar woman’s voice sounded off. “Hoffman, 10-20.”

“Hoffman,” he responded, “leaving the airport. On the way back.” He had the faintest of smiles on his face.

She studied him. “That was Will.”

He looked over at her before refocusing on the road. “Yeah.”

Though he didn’t make any sudden movements, she could tell he felt cornered. This was a  break from the darkness, a comforting distraction that made her grin. She always suspected those two would hook up. “Do you guys talk on the radio often?”

He didn’t respond but it was clear he knew what she was hinting at. “All the time.”

“Mark,” she turned on him, her smile growing. “I haven’t seen you glowing this bright since - Natasha?”

“Natalie.”

“Right. Oh my God, why didn’t you tell me?”

“Nothing to tell.”

She raised an eyebrow. “Are you two still working together?”

When he didn’t respond she shook her head. “Won’t you two get in trouble?”

“Lay off,” he griped. “It’s my business, Ange.”

She smirked, folding her arms and turning to pout out the window. “Well, it’s about time. But does this mean you two can’t be partners anymore?”

He remained silent and she realized she was poking at a sore spot. She quickly changed the subject. “I’m thinking of bringing some blueberry muffins to this weekend’s potluck.” She was referring to the MPD picnic, a yearly event hosted in the summer. 

“Yeah, that sounds good.” 

It was clear she wouldn’t hear anything from him where Will was concerned.

She figured she’d get the gossip from Will herself, then.

Eric Matthews

Daniel was now walking. Actually, he was running. Eric watched him as he stomped across the room with high pitched glee. When did he start doing that? 

Jane slid the papers over to him. “Just sign it.” She never looked him in the eye anymore. She kept looking down at her hands, a tan line on her wedding finger along with a fresh manicure made his throat tighten.

“Is that what the alimony is covering?” He nodded at her nails. “And child support?”

“You have no right,” Jane’s eyes brimmed with tears. “I know you and Allison were fucking this whole time. I didn’t want to believe it. But I’m sick. And tired. Of letting you disrespect us. Daniel deserves a father that is here. Who cares about his family. If all you can do is provide financial support, then fine. But don’t you fucking dare lecture me.”

Her words were like the crack of a whip. He gripped his fist under the table. His lungs itched for a cigarette and his blood coursed through his veins like boiling acid. He knew there was truth in her words.

Regret. So much fucking regret.

He hated himself and everything that led to this moment.

So he signed the divorce papers. 

There wasn’t much he could do. Even if he spent the time to get a good lawyer, he was fucked either way. 

He left as soon as he could, walking out to his car. He kicked at a nearby can. Kerry was watching him in the passenger’s seat, exchanging with him a sympathetic frown. Now what? He got into the car, gripping the steering wheel and remembering how to breathe.

“You ready?”

He didn’t look at her. Instead, he pulled out his pack of cigarettes and put one between his lips, squinting off in the distance. “Let’s get to work,” he growled, starting the engine.

Steven Sing

He looked down at the pale form of a teenage boy, long left for dead in an alley on 118th Street. He studied the spray painted ‘K2K’ at the scene.

“Looks like Rosello left one hell of a void. It’s a goddamn free for all,” Tapp shook his head, his footsteps crunching gravel against concrete. “Another body found. Apparently the motherfuckin’ yakuza are trying to take over. And taking advantage of the chaos while K2K was busy trying to take a chunk of the pie. The fucking yakuza, here. Those bastards usually keep a low profile.”

“Hate to say it, but it’s culling the herd. So far, no civilians have been killed.”

“You mean found,” Tapp reminded him. Sing begrudgingly nodded. 

“Yeah. Found.” Summer seemed to bring out the worst in the city. Maybe it was the heat. Maybe it was the pollen. Either way, it was hot and humid and fucking miserable underneath the noon sun. Sing wiped at his face, sweat pouring. "Looks like we've got our work cut out for us."

"Just in time for performance review," Tapp joked when the world suddenly slammed into the two of them. Sound had magnified and a blast flicked the two men like ants as a pillar of fire erupted from the ground.

Sing's ears were ringing and the orange light of fire danced in the corners of his eyes. He was on his back. His cheek was wet. And every inch of him felt like he was sunburnt and raw. 

"Sing!" Tapp's voice was croaky as rubble clicked and tumbled nearby. He looked up to see Tapp, eyebrows knit and face terrified. "You're okay, Sing?"

"Yep." His voice was scratched. "Just a Tuesday, Tapp." He let out a low chuckle as he forced himself up.

“At this rate, we’ll need to bring in the motherfuckin’ national guard.”

Sing winced, his ears ringing. “Yeah. I don’t know how much more this city can take before it breaks.”

“She’s already broken, Sing.” Tapp was coughing and brushing the front of his suit, trying to get the dust off of him. It wouldn’t come out. “She’s been broken and we’re all eating what’s left of her.”






Chapter 25: Pre-SAW: Trading Partners

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

The sun was streaming through the blinds, hitting his eyes and beckoning his consciousness from pleasant dreams. He stirred in his bed, spreading his limbs to stretch when he contacted a familiar mound of warm, soft flesh beside him.

 

Hello . He smiled as he wrapped his arm around Will, pulling her close into his chest and taking a deep breath of her shampoo. Flowers and candy. He had gotten used to that scent, finding it lingering on his bedsheets and towels these days, a pleasant reminder of the past months of bliss.

 

He had everything he wanted. All he could ever ask for. 

 

These months had been paradise.

 

She was softly snoring as he held her firmly, making him chuckle. 

 

"...Mhm what?" She awoke with sluggish words and a tired tone, exhausted from the long week. Though his personal life was perfect, work had been hell.

 

The city was on fire as the latest plague of gang wars ravaged the streets. 

 

The fucking yakuza was moving in and taking out the smaller factions. All vultures wanted a taste of the carcass left by Rosello's absence. 

 

Tapp and Sing were currently taking on the chaos westside, after one of K2K's old booby traps detonated in the middle of a crime scene. To complicate things, Kerry and Matthews had been forced to sever their partnership after Matthews' wife had raised hell over their relationship. 

 

Thoughts like that made Hoffman know he had to be careful. They had to be careful. Even Grissom had taken him aside the day before, right before his weekend.

 

"Level with me, Hoffman. You and Maddox. I'm not going to hear any problems like with Kerry and Matthews, am I?"

 

"No, sir. Neither of us are married. And Maddox' psycho ex-husband hasn't been around."

 

"You know what I mean, smartass. Damnit. I don’t hear any denying of you two screwing. God. Damnit. You just couldn't keep your dick in your pants. Just made my life a hundred times more difficult."

 

"We still work well. No issues."

 

"Doesn't fucking matter. It's against the rules. I kept a blind eye for too damn long. Now the commissioner expects me to crack down on interwork relationships. You've only just turned your career around." Grissom had taken his glasses off to rub his eyes. "I'll give you the weekend to break the news to her. Starting Monday, your partnership is done. You're going to be reassigned to take Matthews. Kerry will be with Maddox. And don’t give me that look, Hoffman. It’s for your own good. And hers. What do you think Kerry’s going through right now, dealing with the shit slinging right now? You want Maddox suffering through that too?"

 

"Morning," Will turned to face him, amber orbs radiating back the sunlight, her cheeks rounded as she grinned. "You look intense. What's up?"

 

He blinked. He didn't want to ruin this. Telling her now, he knew she wouldn't take it well. Her job was important to her and this uprooting would complicate things. 

 

He didn’t want to think about it. He wanted to enjoy this for just one more day. He brushed some stray copper curls from her forehead, strands of rose gold in the sun. "Just admiring the view." 

 

He liked when her cheeks got so pink when she was embarrassed. She covered her face with the blanket and he pulled it away, teasing.

 

"Stop!" She yowled as he kissed her, tasting her morning breath and loving every moment of it.

 

They rolled under the covers, the sound of laughter blending with the tremor of traffic and sirens.

 

Eric Matthews

 

Being put on patrol was a slap to the face.

 

After everything he had done. Everything he accomplished. They fucking put him to patrol the streets.

 

He walked in his wrinkled uniform, lighting his cigarette while pacing. Everywhere he looked, made him want to punch the nearest wall. The homeless bum on the street, shaking his change cup like it was a maraca. The hooker that had winked at him a third time that night. The blatant drug dealer at the corner, unafraid of his police presence - some punk kid. And he was locking eyes with him as if he wanted a fight.

 

He didn't like the way he looked at him. Like he was unafraid. Like he was better than him.

 

"Problem?" He approached the man. Looked only in his late teens, early twenties. Hispanic. Scrawny. 

 

"Nope." The boy sniffed and wiped his nose. The kid spat, the glob of mucus landing just inches from his shoe. “Just minding my business, pig.” 

 

Matthews was in a bad mood. And this fucker gave him the perfect excuse.

 

“Turn around. Hands on the wall.”

 

“Excuse me?” The kid was incredulous. “I don’t have to do nothing’ asshole.”

 

This made him smile. He had no fucking idea just how wrong he was. He grabbed the guy by the shoulder and forced him to turn around. “Fucking spread ‘em.” 

 

The kid planted his palms on the bricks while Matthews patted him down. When he found nothing, his heart sped up. He was furious. This shitstain was clean. 

 

“Yeah? You done fondling my balls, officer?” The kid smirked back. 

 

Matthews swore he had seen the kid deal just earlier. Maybe he somehow tossed his stash. Yeah. That’s what it was. 

 

And he was about to just walk, as if he wasn’t guilty. 

 

He wasn't going to fucking let it happen. He was guilty. He knew it.

 

"You have the right to remain silent." He smacked cuffs on the kid's wrists and squeezed his bony shoulder tight. He'd figure out the technicalities at the station. There’d be some old coke from the evidence locker. Just enough to keep a conviction. 

 

"What?!" The boy looked gobsmacked. "I ain't carrying anything."

 

"Never trust a drug dealer," Matthews twisted the boy around and shoved him towards his car. "All they'll do is lie to save their own skin." I'm just saving time. I'll get everything I deserve back. By cleaning up this shit city so fast it'll make Grissom's head spin.

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

 

She stared at her new - no, old - desk, a box holding the few items she had. She had avoided her partner - no, old partner - when he broke the news to her the night before after he had gotten her nice and drunk over an old western.

 

She hadn't said a word to him since.

 

"Will." He was leaning against his desk, impatience burning at the edge of his voice. "Nothing's changed."

 

She bit her lip, holding back a tear. She knew she was being childish. It wasn't just his fault. She had happily tangoed in their mutual fraternization. This was just the consequence. 

 

She had been furious at him for not telling her sooner. When she stole a glance at Mark, there was no ill intent in the discomfort of his frown. He looked like a wounded puppy dog that wanted her forgiveness. Big blue eyes and a pout.

 

She couldn't be mad at him forever. She forced a smile. "Yeah. Nothing's changed. Except you're about to have to do all your paperwork now."

 

Realization shined on his face; hope mixed with the fear. She would roll with it - for his sake - and try to let go of this frustration. She watched as relief relaxed his mouth as he muttered, "Matthews sure as hell won't."

 

She laughed and went to him. She wrapped her arms around his neck to pull his face down to hers, standing on her tiptoes as she pressed her mouth to his. 

 

So they weren't partners anymore, in the professional sense. They wouldn't see each other as much at work, but they had long surpassed a working relationship . I've seen every inch of him, far deeper than a professional relationship ever would allow.

 

She suppressed a sigh, chasing the regret away. Things were good. She wanted to enjoy it. And yet. 

 

"I know you're still upset." Mark watched her closely, always aware of her mood as if he could read her mind. "Means a lot, you trying to act like it’s not."

 

"I’m just embarrassed. Getting reassigned partners isn't a good look."

 

"If anyone judges you for it, and starts running their mouth, I'll take care of it."

 

She pulled back and tried to smirk. "Still, not exactly my proudest moment. Even if they don't say it to my face, I've got a black eye now."

 

"Never thought you cared about what other people think. And it’s not like you haven’t shown up to the office with a literal one." His grip on her tightened, his face dark. She felt his hand on her cheek, his thumb just under her left eye, tracing the delicate skin underneath as if wiping away a stray lash. Or a bad memory.

 

"I don't care. Not what the people think here. But. Just thinking of what my dad would say." She felt her face flush and quickly withdrew. "Anyways, I better head across the hall. Dinner after work?"

 

He seemed unwilling to let it go but finally nodded. He looked curious and concerned, but knew better than to bring it up. "Yeah."

 

When she opened the door, Matthews appeared with a sneer as plumes of smoke gusted over her face. She resisted the urge to cough. "Mad Max."

 

"Eric. Take care of him," she pretended she didn't see that cold fish glaze in his stare as she avoided shoulder grazing him to exit the office. 

 

"And you do the same for Ally." She jumped when she felt his grip on her arm. "Call us if you need some backup in the future."

 

"Yeah, will do." She didn't like how wild he looked, as if he had been to the ninth circle of hell and somehow returned to this plane of existence, just for a smoke break.

 

"Hoffman, got some cases I want to tackle -," Matthews' voice was cut off with the close of the door.

 

When Will reached the other end of the floor and entered her new office, Allison sat up. "How are you feeling about a trip to Quantico? Linds just called. A serial killer's targeting young women in Virginia and they want us over there. Grissom already gave the green light. Once travel's set, we can go first thing next Monday."

 

She blinked, surprised that the first emotion was not enthusiasm but dread. Mark's face and the likely reaction he'd have of her absence washed over her thoughts. 

 

Allison, on the other hand, looked thrilled. Positively glowing. Will knew work had become hostile for her, with the cops all casting disapproving leers and not-so-quiet whispers wherever Allison walked.

 

Her friend - and partner - needed to get away. And she wasn't about to let her go alone on an invitational investigation. 

 

Peter Strahm's face was a distant memory, buried with so many others. Sand over a beached bottle. But already, a tide was gently wiping the grains off the glass, coming into the light for her to remember what it looked like. 

 

So much had been left unsaid. And now, that ship has sailed. Despite her conviction, Will swallowed, knowing Mark would not be thrilled when he’d get the news of her next assignment.



Notes:

A/N: Happy Halloween season!! I'm going to try to get some more chapters out in celebration.

Chapter 26: Pre-Saw: A Rift Emerges

Chapter Text

Angelina Acomb

 

It had been six months since she heard Peter's voice. A dark cloud had overcast her days and so she buried her feelings into work. At The Dillon, it was so easy to lose herself.

 

She would run about, prepping ingredients. Stir sauces and simmer meats. More oregano. Thyme. Salt. She then went to the desert station. She took out cake tins while her pastry chef held out a spoonful of frosting for her to check. She took a small taste, closing her eyes and focusing solely on the flavor notes. 

 

The loud hiss of steaming chaos and the rich smells of caramel in the kitchen almost made her forget.

 

They were catering for a large charity banquet with Umbrella Health, a medical insurance company collaborating with Urban Renewal Group and Homeward Bound Clinic. 

 

"Angelina?" The low and gentle voice of Jill Tuck broke through her thoughts. She smiled at the beautiful doctor. "Yes, Jill?"

 

"Do you mind adding another appetizer to the menu? And an additional course that's vegetarian?"

 

"Of course, there's still time." Truthfully, it would take more preparations well into the late evening but she had nothing better to do. She was grateful for it. 

 

The one thing Angelina dreaded was going home to her empty apartment. She didn't know what to do, now that Peter was gone.

 

She had found herself simply standing and staring down at the telephone, as if hypnotized and waiting for a phone call to break the spell. This scared her.

 

She had called Mark a few times, to see if he wanted to come over. The first time had been the last.

 

“Ange?” Mark sounded as though he had just been awoken. A thunk, followed by a soft giggle had piqued her interest. 

 

“Who’s that?”

 

“Uh.” He had been quiet for a few extra seconds before sheepishly admitting, “Will.”

 

“Oh!” A familiar feminine sleepy murmur had made her immediately backpedal. “Sorry for bothering you. I know it’s late.”

 

“Everything okay?”

 

“Yeah! You know, funniest thing. I forget why I even called. Sorry.”

 

“...You need me to come over?” There was that knowing tone, that he wasn’t buying her words. 

 

“No - no, seriously, it must not have been a big deal. I’m going to bed. Good night!” And she had hung up, shaking her head at herself. She was happy for them, more than she was sad for herself. She would get through this on her own.

 

She just needed more work to keep herself distracted. Time would fly faster and Peter would be back home to her sooner. She did everything she could to not be home.

 

Sometimes, she felt resentment worm its way through her heart, her being left behind.

 

She couldn't remember the last time she felt so alone.

 

Amanda Young

 

She stood before the judge, in disbelief as she heard her sentence. Her public appointed lawyer put a hand on her shoulder in sympathy but it did little to bring any comfort. Five years . She was sentenced to five fucking years.

 

And she hadn’t even done the crime she was accused of. Possession. Sure, she hung out with Cecil and the wrong crowd. And sure, she had done her fair share of criminal activity. But she never fucked with dope. She never needed to.

 

So how the hell did she get found with heroin?

 

She knew it was that fucking cop. He was in the courtroom, unphased as he looked right at her as if he was in the right for this whole mess. He must have framed me. Lied.

 

She had protested and even begged to have a drug test done. It changed nothing. Her friend, Cecil, managed to evade prison time. She was happy for him. Really. But the resentment itched up her arms despite it. How the hell did he get off while she got stuck in this mess?

 

“Do you understand?” The judge looked down at her, unimpressed and cold. 

 

“Yeah. I understand.” I understand that this system is fucked and I’m going to prison for a crime I didn’t commit. Fuck you. Fuck all of you.  

 

“Perhaps you’ll reflect and change your ways during your sentence. I hope so. You’re young and still have a long life ahead of you. I suggest you take this time to reconsider your life choices.” The judge smacked the gavel, the court dismissed. 

 

Amanda barely registered when the handcuffs were clasped to her wrists. She glared hatefully at the cops that did this to her. She would never forget their names. Eric Matthews, the cunt with the oral-fixation and the dick-sucking-lipped Mark Hoffman. 

 

She wished she could shoot lasers from her eyes and vaporize the two of them. The two men were talking amongst themselves, laughing like schoolboys and ignoring her hateful eyes as she was pulled from them. 

 

She’d get them. One day. Somehow. She swore this.

 

Even if it kills me, I’m going to make them pay. 

 

Mark Hoffman

 

Six months. After six months of dating, he thought they had built a healthy enough relationship to trust each other. He was slowly stalking up the stairs towards their office level. The ambient buzz around him had snuffed out. He was keeping his fingers from tightening into balled fists. He felt his pulse beating under the skin of his neck. She had even rolled over and kissed him good morning, no hint that she had been hiding anything from him.

 

If she hid something like this, what else was she not telling him?

 

“You’re going to Quantico?” Hoffman pushed into the women’s office, hot anger gripping his throat. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

 

Kerry was in mid-sip of her coffee, eyebrow raised, before she straightened up and walked out of the room with her mug. Hoffman was grateful for her tact and closed the door behind her. He pulled the blind shut at the door’s window. And then he rounded upon Will.

 

“Were you just going to leave me a note?”

 

Will looked like a naughty teenager getting caught sneaking out after curfew. He refused to find it arousing. He refused.

 

He kept sharply reproaching, not blinking as she squirmed in her seat. “Well,” she closed the folder she was referring to and leaned back into her chair, “I don’t know how long it’s going to be. It’s for the collaboration program and the agents who helped us on the Rosello case asked for us specifically.”

 

“Yeah. I’m sure Strahm will be thrilled to know you’re going.”

 

“What does that mean? Perez made the request.”

 

He remembered the first time he met Special Agent Peter Strahm, the thorny memory of his hand on Will’s back as he steered her back into the task force room, closing the door in his face. Riggs’ words replayed in his mind. “ Oh, and she’s been heading uptown to talk to those agents. I noticed she'd grab a bite to eat with the guy. And get this - Strahm - he was also at the funeral.”  

 

Strahm, he had thought, was not a threat any longer now that he was out of state. How fucking wrong he was. Will, that fluff of red hair pulled back, looked up at him so naively, it sometimes made him incredulous. She had to know. And yet she was trying to deceive him, to pretend she was unaware. It hurt, and he wondered if this was a sign he couldn’t trust her. “I know the guy has feelings for you.” 

 

Her jaw twitched. “I won’t deny that before we were dating,” she cleared her throat, “there may have been some flirting.”

 

Hearing this, though it raised the temperature in his blood, he felt his shoulders relax a bit. She was open to him. That was something. “And now?”

 

“Obviously, I don’t intend to do anything beyond maintaining a working relationship. And not like ours, so don’t start on that,” she shook her head and sighed. “There’s nothing between me and Strahm. We haven’t even spoken since the night Rosello died. I’m sure he’s moved on and,” she got to her feet and went around her desk to put a hand on his arm. “So have I. I love you. I don’t want to ruin what I have with you.”

 

Her touch was like a healing spell that calmed the buzzing in his head and halted the sparks of anger before they could catch aflame. He wanted to take her face in his hands and pull her close to him and not let her go. “I love you, Will.” But he didn’t want her to leave. “How long are you going to have to work with the FBI?”

 

She smiled sadly up at him. “Until we catch the serial killer that’s been murdering women all up the east coast.”

 

“That could take months,” he grumbled.

 

“Kerry and I plan to still keep up with our caseload here. We’ll be flying down to Quantico and back up here every other week.”

 

He shook his head. “You’re going to be busy.”

 

She gave him a grin, all chagrined. “Well, if you and Matthews want to help us when we’re here, that would certainly clear up my schedule for some more downtime with you.”

 

She could always pay him like a fiddle. “I’ll be expecting a form of payment, then.”

 

“Oh,” Will pulled at his necktie, mischief glittering in her laugh. “I think I can find a way to make it worth your while.”

 

David Tapp 

 

The Japanese man looked so calm and refined, despite being cuffed to the table. His black suit was pressed and without stray hair or lint. He had a scar at the corner of his mouth and his right hand was missing the tip of his pinky. 

 

“Mister Yamaguchi. We appreciate you speaking with us.”

 

The yakuza’s mouth curled into a lazy smirk. “Of course, considering I have been arrested under false charges. So, what does the esteemed Metropolitan Police Department require of me, to have the drug charge disappear?” 

 

"Information." Sing approached, arms folded and sour. This round, he was center stage as the bad cop. "Any information on the locations of other explosives your syndicate has stashed so we can save some innocent lives. Get your group to stop this bloodbath, hell, we may let out some of your brothers that are already incarcerated. Two years is long enough."

 

“No one is innocent,” Yamaguchi commented with candor. “Especially when those who uphold the law twist it to get what they want. And delude themselves into believing it is for a worthy cause.”

 

Tapp stepped in, leaning back in his seat and giving the man a smile. “That’s what judges and IA’s for. Now we appreciate you letting us know about the corruption in the department. Believe me, I want to do things right. But we’re on a time crunch. I know, unlike the street hoodlums here, you follow a strict set of code, Mr. Yamaguchi. You won’t harm children. You won’t harm innocents. And yet your bombs are directly putting those at risk who aren’t involved. Level with me. Do you want innocent blood on your hands? Because maybe we’re bending the rules because that’s the last thing we want.”

 

Yamaguchi pondered, a thoughtful hum escaping his nose. “Yes. Perhaps. Give me a telephone, and I will speak with the syndicate. Perhaps we can make arrangements.”

 

Tapp’s feet twitched with hope. “Get this man a telephone,” he turned to Sing who leaped and left the room, to get the authorization to escort their prisoner. 

 

“But know that our war with K2K will save many more, and we intend to purge this city of their corruption. They are like an infected limb and must be cut off,” Yamaguchi whispered, eyes black pools of night that reflected no stars. “I advise keeping your distance from their contested territories and soon we will erase them. And order will be restored.”

 

“As the Sumiyoshi-kai maintain that order, is that right?” Tapp always felt creeped out by the yakuza. They normally kept low profiles and were low maintenance on his case docket. But Rosello’s absence made everyone see gold and it was just chaos. The mayor had ordered a curfew. There weren’t any idle officers at the moment.

 

“We will return to balance. And, unlike Toni Rosello, we will not get too glutinous with power. Understand that we are not your enemy, Detective Tapp. We are businessmen.”

 

Tapp nodded, wanting the man to continue. He was on tape. 

 

“In the end, the civilians want to walk out in the sunshine and to go to the markets. Take their children to the parks. Pray in their churches. The sumiyoshi? We want to earn our wealth and return it to the outcasts of society. We wish to aid those that need it. And keep the black markets in line. No unnecessary bloodshed. Simple perfect dance, police chase to catch us, we simply evade. ” Yamaguchi smiled serenely. 

 

Tapp pursed his lips. “Very eloquent, Mr. Yamaguchi.”

 

“Thank you.” 

 

Sing finally returned. “Tapp. A word?"

 

Outside the interrogation room, they went into the observation chamber where Yamaguchi looked straight at the one-way looking glass, smiling.

 

"What is it?"

 

"K2K members have come forward, asking for protection. Get this, apparently, the yakuza have already just about wiped them out. The bombs are still out there, though. "

 

"Then we still need to play their game." He scratched his beard, taking slow and deep breaths as he contemplated. "No wonder he’s playing nice. They got what they wanted.”

 

“And the other bombs?”

 

“Well, Sing, let’s get him that phone call."




Chapter 27: Pre-Saw: Jurassic Park

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

  They arrived at Quantico, getting their visitor badges, and were led through tunnels of white painted walls and glossy waxed floors. The sound of their shoes squeaking filled the silence. Will studied the short man in uniform, his swagger similar to how Perez and Strahm held themselves.

Kerry elbowed Will to look over at a group of youths in matching sweats, fresh Academy students who held a grimness rarely seen on a person so young. Everywhere they went, there was an intensity that screamed, ‘We take ourselves very seriously’. 

The brass sign announcing ‘Behavioral Sciences’ with Dan Erickson and Peter Strahm’s names proudly listed below. Passing the surprisingly modern furnishings and the distinct smell of air freshener gave Will a window into the world of their old colleagues. They went through a common waiting area and finally reached Peter Strahm’s office.

“Looks like the federal government pays better,” Kerry quipped as she looked at the degrees and credentials framed on the walls. Rich mahogany desks and navy blue carpet with walls of academic texts gave her the feeling of being in a library. She half expected a librarian to be seated at the desk, to hush her partner for her loud remark. 

Instead, Peter Strahm rose from his seat, reading glasses on the tip of his nose. “Allison. Will. How was the trip?” He shook Kerry’s hand first before turning to Will’s, giving her only the minimal amount of eye contact necessary to be polite before turning his attention back to Kerry. 

Confusion with a thick dose of relief coated her insides and she felt herself slacken as she took a seat across the desk. The cushions were surprisingly plush and after hours of taxi rides and flying coach, she could have happily curled up and napped in its softness. 

“It’s going to be rough, bouncing back and forth every week.”

Strahm shook his head. “Exhausting, I know. We appreciate the MPD’s willingness to spare two of their best detectives. We’re happy for all the help we can get.” He had his pen in hand, playing with it in between his fingers and clicking the cap. Will noted the shadows under his eyes and the lines that had deepend on his face since she had last seen him. He looked exhausted. Angry, even. She knew he was a serious guy, always with a look that felt deep with troubled thoughts and a dark outlook.

But now, there was an almost furious edge to him, like a pot about to boil over. 

“So,” Will decided to dive right in. “You have a profile on this guy?”

Strahm finally smiled at her, softening just a touch. “Male. Caucasian. Mid-thirties. Has a negative relationship with a young, attractive woman, early to mid twenties. Various appearances and professions. We are still trying to figure out what makes him decide to target his victims. They were found with their hearts removed. We’re assuming a romantic gesture is represented in the act. In addition, traces of bioluminescent algae on their remains, neck down. The algae is only found in Australia or tropical fish aquariums, though they are very hard to maintain. We scoped every major aquarium but the algae needs to be cultured and do not survive in controlled environments for longer than a week.” Strahm opened a drawer and took out a thick folder, dropping it within the womens’ reach. 

“How about algae culture suppliers?” Will and Kerry shared the folder, craning their heads together to take in as much detail simultaneously. 

“What color?” Kerry asked, looking up. “The algae, what color does it glow?”

“Blue.”

“Any mythology referencing blue glowing water?”

“Not that we’ve seen. We’ve scoured religious references to blue water, beautiful maidens, anything. So far, we haven’t found anything worth exploring.”

Kerry wrinkled her eyebrow. “This case seems to have some flair. You always get the creative types?”

“Unfortunately. They’re not as straightforward as the flavor you get up north.” 

“And the victims. Besides gender and age, any other commonalities?”

“That’s the thing. Most come from various socioeconomic groups. Most have not even lived in the same state. Two runaways. Four college students. Three stay-at-home-mothers. We even had a corporate executive who normally frequents Wall Street. One was also from Russia, here on a work visa. Two Jane Does that haven’t been identified yet. And then there was the most recent victim.” Strahm returned to a seething scowl. “Alicia Reynolds. Her remains were placed as a stage spectacle for one of the running senators of Virginia. He was hosting a campaign event, and once the curtains were drawn, she was revealed. She had been strung up on the rafters of the venue.” The pictures were there, showing the woman nude and pulled apart by her limbs high on the stage of what looked like a theater hall. Her yellow hair braided was around her head, carefully, her face clearly made up to emphasize her features.

“I’m no psychologist, but she seems to be presented in a way that looks like the suspect cares for her. He’s presenting her to look her best.”

Strahm squinted, his mouth thin. “Your interpretation may be more aligned with what he believes. But it’s clear she’s an object to him. A prop to further his agenda. Why else was she nude with her rib cage exposed? Her heart, missing. This indicates the desire to humiliate.”

“And yet, he took the time to groom her. And even her restraints aren’t cheap. Looks like satin or silk rope. You mentioned he’s got issues with whoever he’s projecting onto his victims? Maybe it’s not just hatred - no - rage. They aren’t beaten. They’re not disfigured outside of the practical removal of the organ.”

“He left the others out to be eaten by the buzzards.”

“Were they displayed similarly?”

“No. Most were discarded, like trash.”

“So what makes Alicia different?” Kerry interjected, reaching over to take a headshot of the victim, where her lips were gently rouged and her cheeks caressed with blush. 

  “The killer needed her to make a statement. To publicly display his work. We are currently investigating any connection the senator has with Alicia or any potential link to a motivation.”

“Who’s the politician?”

“Larry McGill, Democrat. Been using immigration and student debt for his campaign. He’s down fifteen points since the uncovering of the victim, as it was being broadcast live statewide. Now, it’s about to break nationwide. It’s the reason I was able to get you two here,” Strahm looked at each woman, grim. “We’re desperate and need him caught sooner than later.”

“We’re on it.”

The door knocked and Lindsey Perez entered, lighting up at the sight of Allison. “About time you two got here.” She, too, sported dark patches of weariness under her eyes, looking as if she hadn’t had a rich meal or a goodnight’s sleep in weeks. “Any trouble getting here?”

“None. Fret not. Back up’s here.” Kerry got to her feet, hand at her hip. “So what’s the plan?”

Mark Hoffman

“So yeah, got promoted to Head Chef,” Angie had been swirling her glass of wine with feverish focus, the golden liquid having coated the inside of the goblet several layers over. “That Umbrella Health event went well. Jill’s been great, she even gave me a bonus for all the work. I think I’ll have enough saved to open my own restaurant in the next two years. But I want to wait for Peter to get back from deployment.” He knew she was far from the bundle of joy she was pretending to be. He knew from the way she wouldn’t look him directly in the face as she spoke. She would look at his ear or at the top of his head. 

She hadn’t been putting on makeup lately. And when she returned in the same pair of sweats he’d seen her wear just the other day, with a bottle of wine within reach, he knew she wasn’t in a good place.

“I haven’t been paying attention, Ange,” he felt as if his ankles were being grabbed and pulled into the ground, the gravity of guilt crushing. He reached and took the wine glass from her, noting her flinch from his grasp, before collapsing into his hug. She was sobbing into his chest, her tears warm and damp as they soaked into his shirt. 

Fuck . He had been so caught up in his own shit that he neglected the one person he promised he never would. “It’s going to be alright.”

“I just miss him. I haven’t gotten a phone call or letter in weeks. I don’t know if he’s alive. If he’s okay.”

A lump had formed in his throat. He wanted to fix this. But he had no direct link to the military. And Peter was overseas in a warzone. He went through the list of people in his network. Some were veterans, sure. He could ask them if there was anything they could do. Hell, wasn’t there some sort of support base for people like Ange? Spouses that could get a hold of someone that could at least verify that he was all right?

He needed to at least distract her. “Ange. When was the last time we went to the movies?”

She sniffled, her shoulders slowing in their violent shrugging. “I don’t remember.”

“Let’s go. I hear there’s this movie on dinosaurs that’s pretty realistic. I’ve been meaning to see it.”

She was wiping her eyes. “Dinosaurs?” She hiccuped and let out a small laugh. “Yeah. Okay. Sure, anything if it means getting out of this apartment.” 

He took her to see the film, keeping Angelina in the corner of his eye while he considered what he needed to do to help ease her fears. Once the opening credits began and the theater dimmed into darkness, did he allow his attention to break from his exclusive focus upon her. She was engrossed in the film, like a deer in the headlights. The music was larger than life and whenever he peaked a glance at his sister, it was clear she was enraptured in the story. 

He thought it was an okay movie, if not a bit dull at the beginning.

It wasn’t until the giant tyrannosaurus rex went on its killing spree, was he so invested. He was amazed at how realistic it all looked. The giant lizard roaring and tearing apart anyone in its path was a beautiful sight.

Angelina thought otherwise, covering her eyes and burying her face into his shoulder. He laughed at this, returning to memories of her squealing in terror whenever they snuck horror movies back in their childhood home, while their parents slept oblivious.

It was like they were kids again.  

After the movies, Angelina had been noticeably lighter. “I’ve got a terrible sweet tooth right now,” she turned to him, hair spinning around her as she twirled hyperly.

“Want me to make you something?”

She laughed. “Yeah, your famous chocolate cake.”

He raised an eyebrow. “Really?”

“God, no,” she pretended to be horrified. “I remember how you always tried to bake sweets to cheer me up and they always ended up being both overcooked and raw at the same time. It’s actually what got me into cooking, so we wouldn’t starve to death or get food poisoning.”

“They weren’t that bad. I remember you’d eat them without complaint.”

“Actually, I secretly threw them out when you weren’t looking. To not hurt your feelings.” The sun had long set and the air had gone cool. It seemed autumn was approaching quickly, her breath steaming out as she spoke. 

“Well now, that breaks my heart,” he pretended to be hurt, clutching his chest and pouting. 

She stopped and gave his arm a squeeze. “The fact that you made them was the important thing. Regardless of undercooked centers and burnt edges. You’ve always been a good brother to me. I hope you know that.”

He felt warm and emotional. He avoided her eyes and suppressed the tightness in his throat. “You’ve been a good sister, Ange.”

“Okay, let’s not get all sappy here.” She pointed a few blocks over. “I know this amazing late night cafe that serves the best chocolate mousse. My treat.”

Peter Strahm

He knew that Will and Hoffman had begun dating. Lindsey had told him in passing before she arrived, the message sent by Kerry who had made the call to let him know in advance, to spare any awkward rejections. 

The case took precedence. Strahm fully understood and was grateful for the heads up.

Despite maintaining his professionalism, he couldn’t help but wonder incredulously.

After everything with Rosello, how the hell did Will decide to commit to a man who had compromised his ideals and had blood on his hands?

It wasn’t any of his business and he knew this. 

He had left the city without so much as a farewell. He had been the one to initiate distance, the growing affection he had developed during their therapy sessions something he knew he needed to stop before it continued.

Yet here they were, back on a case together, and she still made his heart pick up the pace with a simple glance. 

Truthfully, he had felt ashamed of himself for how he had not argued against letting her go on that sting operation as the bait. 

He remembered the night, sharp and sore like a wound that had gotten infected and was slow to heal. 

“I dare you to deck Will. Like you mean it.”

All he did was stand there, in the undercover van while the live feed brought him to the scene. He had heard everything. Every word. Every punch. 

And she was now fucking the man that hit her.

The forensic psychologist in him had concluded Will had some underlying attraction to men who invoked pain. Her history with her ex-husband and with Mark Hoffman justified this theory. But he also considered how this catered to his own ego. 

He wasn’t the problem. It was Will’s warped desires. Yeah, wouldn’t that be convenient?

Even he thought that was a farfetched and outlandish conclusion.

He objectively knew that was from his own bias of not wanting to consider another reason she had run into her partner’s arms. Such as a personal shortcoming she deemed incompatible. To distance himself from the possibility, he had taken clear clinical treatment of their relationship, keeping it as sterile as he knew he should.

It was the professional thing to do. It followed protocol.

Mark Hoffman was notorious for not giving a damn about protocol, not if there was something he wanted.

And that had given him the advantage when courting Will.

Strahm had unrealistic expectations of her, assuming she would have no romantic thoughts of the man she worked with. But he had hoped that she would at least not act upon it.

He had been wrong.

He didn't want to ruin the friendliness between them, though.

"Strahm," Lindsey raised an eyebrow at him. "There’s fingerprints."

That was new.

He approached, careening around forensics who were like birds around a feeder, the flash and chirp of the cameras sounding off.

The latest murder had only happened a day after Will and Allison arrived.

He was beginning to lose his patience. This guy was getting more brazen with every kill.

This one looked young, thin. Her hair was still damp, as if he had been in a rush when he was performing his ritual. Her lips were almost blue, her eyes milky white.

"There's also some unknown sediment under her nails," the coroner lifted one of her hands. "I need a bag over here."

Allison was shining a flashlight over the walls, taking in every detail of the vinyl records store. "There hasn't been consistency in the disposal of the remains. Any clues as to why here?"

Will was squatting by the body. "Musician, maybe? She has a tattoo of a treble clef on her ankle."

Strahm turned and went to her. There, in bold black ink was that music symbol. His mind went back to the other victims. Alicia, what was her relationship with politics? There had been nothing hinting of such in the background check. Kimberly and a tobacco farm? Besides an uncle that smoked, there had been no reason to suspect a link. This was the first victim with any strong indication of an intentional connection to the scene where they had been dumped. 

"Hey! We got something you'll want to see!"

Strahm turned to one of the photographers who was staring at the bottom of the stairs, camera clutched to their chest, their face looking green.

"What is it?"

And then he saw it.

A box, stained in blood, "Pete," hastily scribbled on the wrinkled cardboard.

He narrowed his eyes. "Get a bomb squad in here. Everyone back away."

 

Chapter 28: Pre-SAW: Thin Wrists

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

John Kramer

 

He admired the old building, a relic of the past that still withstood the test of time. His meticulous plans had finally led up to this moment.

Years of studies, careful anticipation of the real estate market, and eventual independence with his own contracting firm had built this new foundation to his ever growing empire.

The Gideon meatpacking plant, still proud with all its rust scars and broken windows, stood before him wrapped with chain linked fences and barbed wire. He felt like a royal entering his castle.

"Congratulations, John," his lawyer, Art Blanck, looked smooth in his suit, giving the new property owner a smug nod. "It’s a beaut."

"A fixer-upper," Jill was craning her head to the roof. The walls. When they entered the warehouse, she stepped deep into its bowels and spun around like a dancer. She took in all the equipment left behind, admiring some shelving with dusty hooks and hammers. "It’s perfect,"  she turned to him and beamed. 

Blanck had his hands in his pockets, swaggering about. "One of many, I'm sure. Considering the declining prices, now is the time to buy up whatever you can. A brilliant business opportunity-,"

"And a good opportunity to renovate these buildings for affordable housing," Jill added, wary of Blanck. "To help get people off the street." 

John loved Jill's charitable heart, it being her idea to consider this line of work. Before Urban Renewal, he had been more focused on pleasing the customer, be it the private contractors who sold his creations for weapons or the latest product gimmick that got the American consumer eager to trade their paychecks for. He had not discriminated, driven only by the pursuit of wealth.

But when he met Jill, he was taken aback by her bravery. She was pure of heart. His rock in this crazy world. 

He wanted to help her, in her dreams, which was to make the world a little bit better off. Her own project, Homeward Bound, was far from profitable. She spent every waking moment at the clinic and so he had decided to assist in financing it for her.

Art Blanck had not approved, the tax break not enough incentivize or justify such a poor business decision. 

The tension was clear. His wife and lawyer were just civil enough, though Jill did little to hide her disapproval.

"Well, John. Jill. Congratulations. I’ll leave you two to celebrate.” Blanck forced a smile as he strode out of the old warehouse.

As soon as he crossed the threshold, Jill’s shoulders relaxed downward and her face smoothed to a beautiful twinkle. “John Kramer,” she would say his name with such honey and fondness that it made his heart swell, “I’m so lucky to have met you in my life.”

He took her hand and spun her around, as though about to sway to secret music. He pulled her close to him, tightly into his arms. “And I, lucky to have met you, Jill.” 

 

Angelina Acomb

 

It was a hot summer day. The sun was already burning her shoulders and making her sweat. 

The annual Metropolitan Police Department Potluck had a full turnout, despite the growing tensions the city was experiencing, tightly clutched by rumors of terrorism in the form of explosives and gunfights in the streets.

She had brought cupcakes. Decadent little pastries with carefully swirled frosting and high end pearl sprinkles accenting them.

Her work stood out in the sea of homemade goods, though love was placed everywhere she looked.

“Angelina,” a woman she recognized as Jane Matthews approached her with her son, Daniel, who was now walking around and sputtering to himself. “I love your cupcakes. It’s so good to see you.”

“Great to see you too,” she was taken off guard when Jane pulled her tightly into a hug. She knew that Mark was now partners with her husband, thus explaining her affection, but still, she had only spoken to Jane in passing at holidays and the occasional police function. “How are things?”

“Honestly? Terrible. I’m only here because Daniel needs to spend time with his father. Though it’s so awkward,” the woman was staring over at her ex - or, soon-to-be ex, - husband, who was talking with Mark over some beers as they watched the grills. “I’m so sorry I couldn’t make it to your wedding.”

“Oh,” Angie shrugged, not sure what was the right thing to say at that moment, “that’s all right. I can only imagine what you’re going through right now.”

“Yeah. Trust me. It’s not fun.” Jane forced a laugh but her eyes were watering. She looked down at Daniel, as if that would hide them. “Anyways, I just wanted to say congratulations. On your wedding. I hope you and Peter are well?”

“We are. Though the distance is hard,” she grimaced but remained pleasant. “He’s in Iraq right now, what with the tensions in Kuwait.” Her heart was already hammering in her rib cage, adrenaline coursing through her veins like acid at the thought. 

Jane gave tisking and clucking sounds of sympathy. “Terrible what’s happening over there. You know, I hear George Bush…” Angelina forcefully muted Jane’s voice, the desire to melt where she stood and absorb into the grass at her feet overwhelming. 

Angelina found herself picking faces in the crowd, hungrily searching for Alllison or Will’s features to pop out and rescue her. She recognized the two curly puff balls of hair and mentally pleaded that they would be attracted by the forces of sheer friendship and she would be free from this awkward conversation. 

Her prayers were answered with the glitter of recognition from Allison as she waved and turned to tap Will on the shoulder. The two cops turned and approached, though a darkening of awareness shadowed their faces from seeing Jane Matthews. They slowed their pace.

Angelina grimaced over Jane’s head, nodding in understanding that they needed to keep back for just a moment longer. Will whispered something into her partner’s ear, Ally shaking her head and mouthing curses.

“Oh, Tracy!” Jane let out a high pitched squeal as she walked off to join the throng of police wives. 

She couldn’t walk away from the desert table fast enough.

“Ange,” Will put an arm around her and pulled her close. “How are things?”

“Hanging in there,” her smile was no longer forced. “Seriously, though, such an awkward time with Jane.”

“Yeah, tell me about it. I’m surprised she showed,” Allison took a swig from her bottle, swirling the beer in her mouth with a pout. “Hoffman’s keeping Eric close. Especially with how drawn out the divorce is going, he’s been on a short fuse.”

Well, he did cheat on her , Angelina kept the thoughts down, torn between her friendship with Allison and Eric and knowing they had gone and made a downright mess of things. The addition of negative thoughts piling onto her mental trash heap was bringing her down, so she quickly turned to Will with a mischievous need to distract from the dull pain. 

“So, Will, how long have you and Mark been together?” She leaned forward, eyes wide with intensity as she watched the redhead shrink from her scrutiny. “If you say more than a few months, I will absolutely kill him for hiding this from me.”

“Uh.” Will whirled over to Mark, who seemed to be in a deep discussion on the precise moment a burger needed to be flipped with Daniel Rigg and Eric. 

Angelina was not about to let this go. “Since when? I knew you two weren’t working on cases anymore - but that was years ago.” It was mostly denial, her refusal to believe that her brother would have hidden this from her for this long, but she already knew. 

Mark had been pleasant lately. She had seen him make smalltalk to strangers in line at the movies. She even saw him hold the door open for a young couple, throwing a small smile at them. Though Mark was always such a loving brother, to most people he was calloused and aloof. 

She had been so caught up with herself after getting married. She had not spent anywhere near as much time with Mark as she used to and this was likely another reason she never noticed. She never even thought to ask.

Still, he could have at least told her.

“Well, we may have become more than just coworkers for a while now.” Will was waffling. 

“Since when?” She took her hand and squeezed it. “Please, I need to know!”

“Since your wedding?” Will let out a gasp when Angelina squeezed her hand tight. 

“That. Was. Three years ago.” She was looking through Will and at her brother. “How come Mark didn’t invite you over for the holidays?”

“Well - I usually go back to California to spend time with my relatives - and - Jesus, Angie, you’ve got a grip,” Will pulled free and shook her fingers. “Yeah, I knew he hadn’t let you know yet.”

“What was he waiting for? Will I even be invited to the wedding?”

Allison choked on her drink and Will sighed. “I don’t think marriage is on the radar for a while.”

“Don’t ruin my hopes and dreams,” Angelina was already imagining a church house wedding, complete with pink roses and silver silk. Will would look like a dream in white, her hair orange fire pulled back with pearls and lace. Mark would be in a tux, hair slicked back, happy and all teeth. “I was starting to lose hope that Mark would ever get me a sister. And the kids!” She felt triumphant, fist pumping as she let out a gleeful cackle. “I’m going to be an aunt!”

“How much have you had to drink, Ange?” Ally was amused. 

“None, actually,” she was clinging to this good news, wrapping it around her like a blanket, nestling into the comfort of it. 

“Speaking of weddings,” Will effortlessly dodged the spotlight, “You’ve got to show me the photographs from yours. I haven’t had a chance to swing by and reminisce. Sorry about that, Ange,” Will looked sheepish and sympathetic. Angelina felt as if she was reading her and knew every dark thought that was barbed into her brain. 

“Oh, yes! Come by any weekend. It’s been slow with the catering contracts.”

“Sorry, Angie honey, we’ve got to fly down to Virginia this Friday.”

“Oh, right,” disappointment was like an anvil over her head. “You two close to catching that monster?”

“We’re trying. He’s been quiet this summer. Part of the reason we’ve been staying here for so long is because he’s gone underground since the last murder. It’s slowing things down on our end.” Will and Ally exchanged looks, as if there was a lot more going on than they let on. She knew better than to push, though. When it came to high profile murder cases, they had to keep the details under wraps. Especially if withholding information was used to verify the killer’s story when they finally caught him. 

Angie shook her head, shivering at the prospect. Women taken and having their hearts removed, it was gruesome. The stuff of horror movies. 

Sometimes, she wished Mark hadn’t chosen to go into law enforcement. She just wanted a normal, simple life, for both siblings. The Hoffmans were such a small family, really just the two of them. And it terrified her, to imagine a world where Mark was gone. She wanted him far from danger. Far from serial killers and violence. 

And with that, she thought of her husband, off to war. She wanted Peter home. She wanted her future children to not worry about losing their relatives. She wanted to live somewhere safe. 

And she wanted her brother to experience all these forms of happiness as well. 

They were all dreams so close to coming true. And yet so far. 

A part of her, in her anxious paranoia, feared it could all fall apart at any second. That Mark would one day not return her calls. That Peter would never come back. 

Lately, the future plans she had felt out of reach and so fragile, like smoke on water. 

“Hey, ladies,” Eric called out while loudly clicking the metal tongs, “How many burgers you want?”

 

Mark Hoffman

Larry returned with the whiskey and two glasses, giving a clearly warmer look over at Will before turning to wipe the greasy towel onto the old wooden bar. 

When his old bartender approved of the new addition to his evening ritual, he knew he must have been one of the lucky ones. 

At the corner of his eye, he saw Will yawn and flip through the pages of the American Rifleman, picking at the soggy fries in her basket. Her lips were pulled together in a small pout, her freckles fading with the warmth of the late summer. 

These days, she wore darker colors. Black and navy. Colors of control. The shadowed bruises under her eyes gave her a punkish look, followed with how her fingernails were all torn and chewed to the quick. The flash of amber eyes flicked a jolt of energy up his spine. She could give a look that would make him feel like a deer in the headlights getting blasted with a flamethrower. “What?”

“Nothing.” He pretended he wasn’t feeling eager to grip her by the hair and sink his teeth into the softness of her neck. He forced himself to look away and stare at the broadcasting football game. A fumble caused some nearby patrons to curse and grunt, shaking their heads as another let out a laugh. 

“I hate how small my wrists are,” she spoke, holding the shiny pages up to reveal a Big Frame Revolver Magnum, the classic western pistol, glint in its matte stainless steel finish. “Ain’t he pretty?” 

He smirked, reaching to where her hand pressed the magazine down to the bartop and ran his fingers over the back of her hand and up to her wrist. It was like warm butter, a teaser to the rest of her he wanted to caress. “I think you’ve got nice wrists. Never stopped you from throwing a good punch.”

“Yeah, but imagine the recoil on this puppy.” She had her lower lip stuck out. “I want it but it’s not like I’d be able to use it.”

“Yeah, but it’ll scare the hell out of anyone who crosses you if they see that on your hip.”

“Nah, they probably would just assume I wouldn’t know how to use it. Because, realistically, I’m not built for it.” She huffed. “But it’s so pretty.”

He suppressed a laugh. She had this way of raising the octave of her voice whenever she got all gushy. Usually, it was when she walked by a dog. Or a good looking weapon. The latter was a turn on. “What’s wrong with Edgar?” He was referring to her Smith and Wesson 38, her preferred weapon since he’d known her. His eyes darted down to her hip holster, where it was resting on her belt. He poured her a drink.

“Nothing. Edgar’s served me well. Nothing wrong with dreaming of life across the fence. A life with thick wrists.”

“I think you’ll hurt Edgar’s feelings, looking at other guns like that,” he joked, realizing as the words came out that they had an almost metaphorical bite to it. He squeezed his lips together, cursing himself. Fuck. I guess we’re not going back to my place after this.

She sighed and closed the magazine, turning in her swivel barstool and leaned forward to put a hand on his thigh. Oh? They locked eyes, and he kept his as blank as he could despite feeling the warmth of her palm through his slacks. 

“Hey. You know you’re the only big gun in my life.”

He was glad he hadn’t taken a drink, because he would have choked on it. “Yeah?”

She teased, “Oh, definitely. And soon, I’ll be back to spending every workday right across the hall from you. Who knows, maybe we’ll be assigned to some cases together.”

“So you’re close to catching the Heart Stealer?”

“Maybe. Can’t go too deep in the details.”

“That’s too bad. I could help.”

“Yeah that would be nice,” a want in her voice, full of denied desire, trailed her words. “But know that I’m working hard to get back to working with you. I miss not feeling like I’m constantly being watched and analyzed by the men in black.” 

He liked it when she complained about the feds. He had been starting to worry that she would move onto greener pastures and end up working with the FBI, permanently. “Well, I hear their benefits are better.”

“But they don’t have your handsome face,” she leaned forward and planted a kiss on his mouth before turning back to her magazine. “What do you say we get outta here?” 

“Don’t have to ask me twice.”

 

 They had practically ran back to his apartment, an easy ten minute walk from Larry’s Sport’s Bar that they made in four, and as soon as the elevator doors locked the two of them alone he had dove upon her, pressing her against the wall as she had one palm on his face while the other reached down and fondled his groin.

He let out a hiss as he felt her push and play into his loins, cutting into his focus as hot hunger roiled out of him. He tasted the salt and scotch on her tongue, the smell of her shampoo familiar and comforting. She was like a squid, each limb rubbing and tugging at wherever they could reach. He felt his tie being loosened and his shirt being ripped open. 

“Naughty girl,” he growled, “that was my favorite shirt.”

“I’ll buy you another one,” she breathlessly whispered into the fat of his lips. 

Despite all the intermittent travel that forced them apart, it had only heightened their mutual physical need for each other. 

Migrating from elevator to apartment was a blur, with only bits and pieces of visuals including the cream of her collar bone down to the red lace of her bra. He found himself kneeling before his goddess while he ran his tongue down her pelvic bone as she swooned against him, knees thrashing over his shoulders as he showed his devotion through his tongue. 

She let out a gasp chased with a scream and he groaned against her pubic bone as he resisted the burning need to find relief. She needed to be savored and cherished. He only had her to himself every few weeks.

He continued swirling his tongue over her nub as she writhed against his chin, twitching and yowling, round calves flexing against his neck and pressing into his shoulders as her heels dug into his back ribs.

He knew he had her when she breathlessly inhaled, suddenly releasing him from her leggy vice, relaxing into his sheets as if the Great Kraken itself was appeased. 

She looked spent.

But he wasn’t even close.

He ascended over her, feeling her small, sweaty form underneath him as he peppered her with kisses and pushed her legs far apart with his knees. She looked up at him with half-lidded eyes, drunk from his treatment, until they burst wide from his impulsive plunge into her. 

She gripped his shoulder as he began his eager thrusts, no longer composed and no longer caring. He felt her gummy walls, slick and warm, squeezing and sucking at his girth and it was like sparks were short-circuiting his brain. He didn’t feel his limbs but he felt absolute fucking ecstasy up his spine as he pushed into her, grunting as he pushed as far into her as he could while she dug her nails into his arms and bleated out profanities like his dirty little angel. 

“Mark! Fuck! Mark! Oh, God!” 

Her cries made the hairs on the back of his neck stand and he had to slow down the pace so he wouldn’t come right then and there. He pulled the sheets into his fist as he took long, careful breaths, holding onto the last thread of control as it threatened to snap.

She was grinding upward into him, taking his free hand and sucking on his thumb with such profane gusto that he let out a low growl as he pulled it away from her, gripping her wrist and holding it above her head. “Not. Yet.” He was speaking more to himself, but she looked up at him with wide, lust-filled eyes that looked half-afraid and half-into-how-afraid-she-was-feeling. 

He picked up one of her legs and hoisted it over his shoulder as he began drilling downward into her. She tossed her head back into the pillows and sang for him as he returned to feeling her insides, feeling her pussy spasming around him. This drove him to ram his cock deeper and deeper until he finally released. 

He was panting over her, dripping with sweat, collapsed and feeling the dark comfort of sleep begin to pull his consciousness away. He felt her kiss his cheek and ear gently, her heart beat strong against his chest. 

 

Notes:

A/N: (Related) Yeah, he would name her pussy the Great Kraken. I’m so sorry, I had to. 
Ughh I think I'm messing up this timeline. I hope nobody cares about any discrepancies but let me know if there is anything obvious, I'll try to go back and fix it at some point. I've got several years to fast forward to, to get to the next set of events but it definitely feels like it's only a span of months right? But Hoffman was a cop for at least 20 years by the time he got recruited by Jigsaw so there's a lot of forward leaping that's gotta get done.

(Unrelated) Sorry about delays. I've been wanting to post more because of this Halloween season but I just got laser beams shot at my corneas lol. Pro tip: Do NOT watch raw footage of a surgical procedure you are about to undergo. Especially when there's no anesthesia involved. I can attest that I felt like I was experiencing a mini-saw trap. What a brazen, foolish, fool I was.

Chapter 29: Pre-SAW: Becoming Tainted

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

“Hoffman.” Roger McCallister and Ron Willis, partners with desks downstairs in the Cop Pit, were waiting in his office, seated in front of his desk. Through the billowing smoke and growing stacks of unfiled documents, Matthews was flicking ash and bobbing his eyebrows up and down in his direction. Whatever these two wanted, it was worth listening to. 

“McCallister. What’s up?” 

“Bad things,” McCallister was rubbing his receding hairline as he spoke, a guilty look marred his face. “I’ve got two sex workers.One of them wised up and got a lawyer. Now, we're about to have hell on our asses. One of them's claiming Willis copped a feel.” 

"Did he?" Hoffman turned to the short man, who scratched his beer gut as if comfortable at home.

"I had to pat her down for weapons. Didn't mean anything else by it."

"Regardless," McCallister waved it off, "IA is about to fuck us real good. We need your help."

"Not much I can do, what with my not being there to be a witness." Hoffman sat into his office chair, hearing the squeak of the pivot. He knew what was to come. He felt like the godfather, about to have his rings kissed.

"We're not dumb. We know you've been closing cases like clams. The people you bring all bitch about how they're innocent. That they're being framed. Now, not saying we look down on that sort of thing. But lately, Gibson has been watching us like a hawk. If you can give us a tip on how to get around that asshole, it sure would make life a hell of a lot easier."

Hoffman inhaled slowly. This put him in an awkward situation. If Will was here, she would have been furious to know what he had been up to… but she wasn't. She would never know. 

He and Matthews had been bypassing the tedious processes she followed religiously, because at the end of the day, it was about locking away the criminals. Waiting for them to get lazy and leave evidence for a solid conviction never happened. 

He looked over at two cops. "They're for sure guilty?"

"Without a doubt. Caught them soliciting at one of the usual nightwalker hangouts. Dressed the way they were. Carried a fuckton of cash."

"Did they approach you?"

Willis looked uncomfortable, his face pinching towards the center as if he ate something sour. "Well, no. When we approached, they told us to get lost."

Hoffman didn't like the idea of bringing more of the department into what he and Matthews had set up. It left a lot of openings; vulnerabilities that could come back and bite them in the face.

But turning his back on his brothers, it would have been a real betrayal. And he wasn't about to go back to the days when he was Rosello's mole and ostracized by the entire department.

"If you can't build a strong case on prostitution, look at other options. Did you find any drugs on them?" He gave them a weighted stare, expecting them wise enough to catch on.

McCallister perked up.  "Actually, yeah. We found an eighth of coke on each of them."

"Possession. That's at least three years." 

The two men nodded like bobbleheads, eager.

"Since you haven't added them in the initial report, you're going to need to find another way to pin it on them. Did you impound a vehicle?"

"Their Corolla. Yeah." Willis looked over to McCallister. "We haven't submitted the inspection paperwork yet."

"There ya go," Matthews flicked ash onto the floor, smirking at Hoffman. "That's how you get it done."

"Hell, it's fucking genius." McCallister laughed, relieved. "You're a godsend, Hoffman."

He nodded, not sharing the revelry. There was a chunk of ice in his stomach and he kept thinking of what Will would say if she knew.

She doesn't have to know. Never.

 

Lindsey Perez

She hated it when the victims were kids. The teen girl should have been worrying about who would ask her out to prom or whether or not she'd pass her next algebra exam. 

She should not have been lying out in the middle of a drive-in theater, arms spread out as if crucified, rib cage spread open like the gates of hell, with a clearly missing portion of the organ cavity where her heart should be.

It had to have been recent. The smell hadn't set in yet. She had been left undisturbed by the insects. Putrification was not yet setting into her pretty face. The dawn was still breaking. Distant lilac skies blushed above, barely noticed under the neon scarlet of blood that dripped down the great billboard. 

The projection had long finished its showing, flickering muted white light over the body. Shadows shifted, contouring her figure, making her resemble a gargoyle standing watch over them.

"This can't go on," Lindsey muttered to herself, at a loss.

"It won't." 

She turned, seeing Strahm, who gave her a sympathetic frown. 

"This one's like the last. They’ve found some prints. He’s getting sloppy," Strahm assessed, "and arrogant."

"And yet, he's still out there," Erickson stepped towards them, displeasure plastered on his frowning mustache. "Eighteen months. That's unacceptable."

Lindsey looked away in embarrassment, hating the scrutiny of Erickson's gaze. He was always a hardass, especially with her. She figured it was remnants of partner-possessiveness, as he used to be Strahm’s partner before he was promoted to their supervisor. 

"Look, I get that the higher ups are breathing down your neck, but we're stretched thin enough as it is, Dan," Strahm stepped between her and Erickson, quick to save her from the direct attack. 

"I've granted you the resources you've asked for." Erickson casually glanced over his shoulder at the two women that were currently at the base of the billboard, pointing their flashlights along the blood trail with their backs to the agents. "And I expected results."

Lindsey suppressed a sigh. He wasn't wrong. Every lead had resulted in wild goose chases and dead ends. They had believed a college professor was the likely suspect, but after being issued their warrant, they came up with nothing. 

Still, of all the people Erickson was lecturing, Peter was the last man he should have focused on. He was the one taking it all the worst. She looked over at her partner, watching as he had his hands on his waist, glaring down at some of the debris as if searching for the answers of the universe at his feet. She bit her lip and pulled at her necklace, worrying about him.

Ever since the killer started leaving packages for him to find, taunting him, Peter had become obsessed. He rarely slept. He barely left the office. He had become so transfixed and a hot angry mess. He had upturned his desk twice. Each time, over the puzzle of the various artifacts the killer had left him.

The first box had various pictures of the record store victim, followed with a manifesto that was unintelligible and disturbing. Angry rants written in red ink that swore of the end of days and how the impure would be cleansed only confused them and muddied their investigative waters.

She had only seen him be so erratic one other time, earlier in their career when they had first partnered up. He rarely got stumped but when he did, he was like an angry bull thirsty for blood.

A rustle was at her back. She thought she saw a glimmer of light in her peripherals and she turned to find the source. Something felt off. Across the pavement were dense bushes and trees. The wind was tickling the leaves, some of the dying vegetation falling to the ground.

She felt the hair on her neck prickle. She rested her hand onto her gun, the feeling of being watched making her knees vibrate. 

She scanned the horizon.

The bushes. She could swear there had been some rustling and not from the wind. Another glint of light. Not too bright, but as if someone was pointing a mirror in her direction. She took a step, squinting in the darkness.

"Perez!" 

She spun, seeing the group gathered and waving her over.

She walked over, noticing everyone gathered around a carefully taped box. An envelope was fastened to it, simply addressed, FBI .

"We need a bomb squad over here," Strahm shouted behind them.

They had waited for the all clear.

"He wants acknowledgement. He wants an audience." Strahm was pacing, jaw clenched, hands fidgeting for a pen that wasn't there to click. "What's changed?" He was looking right at her, intense, angry.

Perez exhaled through her nose sharply. "I don't know."

"Come on, Linds," he was close to her, not to intimidate, but because they had solved every challenging case together. He believed she could give him the answer. He trusted her, turning to her when even he was at a loss. She was one of the only people he turned to for help.

She scanned the scene. The settings must be related to the victims. All women. What drove this man to kill? To take their hearts? To leave them, naked, and cast aside like trash. And what was with bathing them? Hatred would have torn them to pieces. Lust would have indicated sexual assault in the autopsies. He was collecting their hearts. A symbol. Love was the obvious one. Bathing suggested they were in need of being cleansed. 

"Damn," Allison muttered to Will, her voice always low and seductive, "I used to come to a drive-in for the nostalgia. Now that's ruined."

A drive-in theater. The thought of Allison, and all the dirty ideas that crossed her mind. 

And then it hit her.

"Sex," she muttered.

Strahm blinked, dark eyes unimpressed. “No indication of sexual assault.”

“But… I mean, where was your first time? Drive-ins are famous for the setting of a teenager’s first time.”

Strahm considered this. “The tobacco field. The music hall. A drive-in theater. Secluded places the victims had access to. Maybe they conducted sexual behavior where they were left."

"The Heartstealer's targeting sexually active victims he catches in the act? Maybe their first times?"

"That’s a stretch. Many had previous relationships. Some were well above the age of losing their virginity. There has to be more than that."

"The bathing," Lindsey was gesturing with her hand, excitedly, "if the victim sleeps with someone, he feels he has to wash them. He bathes them to purify them?"

"And he takes their heart as his trophy. What, they’re no longer pure of heart?”

Lindsey bit her lip. “Maybe.”

Strahm turned to glare up at the dead girl. “He feels entitled to them." Strahm seemed to be renewed, "he invests in them. When he finds a new fixation, he follows them. Watches them. He believes they’re pure and belonging to him. And once they betray him, by taking another lover, he takes action."

Will folded her arms, frowning. "What do you mean 'invest'?"

"He invests time, observing them. In his eyes, he's courting them." Strahm looked up at the victim. "When they go about their lives, he sees when they have sex, it's an act of betrayal of his deluded 'relationship'. He believes they've tainted it. That it's no longer a pure, good bond. So he severs that bond."

Allison cast Lindsey a skeptical look but Lindsey looked at Strahm with grateful awareness. She knew he was on the right path.

"Holy water," Will muttered to herself, her lips moving as if going through lines in her head.

"What's that, Maddox?" Strahm turned to her.

“Holy water. Maybe he’s baptizing them."

“This is conjecture," Strahm was done, his frustration taking over. He had his moments, especially during a tough case, where a switch would flip and he had enough. Lindsey watched him as he turned, fist at his hip, looking around to kick something or flip a desk. With nothing to target, he ended up walking toward his car before calling back, "I'll be back in the office."

He drove off, the tires squealing with his tantrum. Lindsey shook her head and gave an apologetic look to the two of them. "He's just excited about this new lead."

Allison shrugged while Will looked especially disturbed, looking down at her feet. Lindsey knew Will did not take male disapproval well, especially when it was from a man she found attractive. 

Daddy issues, seen from a mile away. She would never dare express this, even over pillow talk with Ally - if they ever hooked up again, that is.

There wasn't much to do now, besides wait while forensics swept the scene. 

"I'll see you guys," Will left as well, heading to her car and leaving the two women behind. 

"Want to grab a coffee, before we head back?" She turned to Allison, who had not looked her long in the eye before shrugging. 

"Might as well. Going to be a long night." Allison and her had been off since she ended things. She had hoped it would have smoothed over after all these months but from what she gathered, Allison wasn't interested in rekindling their previous fling.

Maybe she wanted more commitment.

It was something she had always struggled with. She never knew a stable relationship. Not even growing up, as her parents split up when she was a kid. Still, that didn’t mean she didn’t want to be with someone. She just needed more time to be ready for something long term. Especially if it was long-distance.

They had gotten in the car, the tense silence frosty. She decided to break the ice, turning to Allison to lean forward, her lips so close to hers she could almost taste them. 

“Linds,” Allison’s eyebrows were furrowed as she stared off in the distance, avoiding her eyes. “Stop.”

She pulled away, letting out a sigh. “What’s wrong?”

“Don’t play dumb. We’re not an item. And I don’t plan to pick up where you left me.” Ally was curling a strand of hair around her finger, looking out of the window. “I’m with Eric.”

“Matthews?” She was incredulous. “But he’s such a prick.”

Ally turned her eyes sharply at her. “Don’t call him that. You don’t know him.”

She tried to smile the hostility away. “Come on, Ally.”

She shook her head. “No, you come on. You had your chance. I’m tired of being jerked around. I’m tired of being taken for granted. Eric, at least, needs me. He wants me. He misses me when I’m not around. But you?” She looked away, but not before Lindsey saw the tears. “You just want my body. I need more. I deserve more.”

Lindsey swallowed back a response. What Allison was saying was fair. “I’m sorry, Ally.”

“Don’t be. I don’t expect you to be forced into something you don’t want. But you’ll respect what I want. We can still be friends. But I don’t want anything else.” 

Lindsey didn’t want to believe that. But she wouldn’t push. She could wait. “All right. Whatever you want, Ally.”

 

Chapter 30: Pre-SAW: Hurting Yourself

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Amanda Young

She had never messed with dope. No matter how many times it had crossed her path.

She had always stayed away from the stuff. Even when her older brother brought it home. Even when it seemed everyone in high school had been strung up in class. She never dared to even experiment. No matter what her friends said. She had stayed out of trouble, despite the worst situations she was in. But, now that she was in prison?

She wasn’t so sure she could stay strong, now. Prison was so fucking boring.

She was currently reading the same fucking book, a third time that week, while she heard the scuffle and screams of a brawl outside her cell. The fights kept her up at night. She sighed and rolled over in her cot, pulling the sheet over her shoulders and curled into a fetal position as she stared blankly at the yellowing paper. It was the Great Gatsby, and Gatsby was such a little bitch, pining after dumb cock-tease Daisy. 

“Yo, Mandy,” her cell mate whispered in the bunk above her. “You okay, sweetie?”

She looked up and forced a smile at Ronda, a heavy set intimidating woman that, for some reason, liked her. She was lucky. She had seen Ronda dig another woman’s eyeball out with a spoon just last month. Apparently, solitary was the worst punishment they’d dish out to the inmates there. Ronda was a regular in the solitary cell. “Wish there were some new books.”

“Never liked them. Reading gives me a headache.” Ronda slumped off her bunk and landed on the concrete, squatting to be eye level with Amanda. “You know what will take the edge off, sweetie?”

Amanda swallowed. She knew what Ronda would offer. She shrugged. “I’m trying to keep my nose clean.”

“Oh, don’t worry, baby, you don't snort it. I just got some painkillers. It’ll make the day seem perfectly fine. How about it? I’m feeling charitable.” Ronda, pupils already great black pools, took out the silver foil of a pill sheet, shaking gently the drugs in their plastic casing. “Besides, I owe you for always giving me your pudding cups.”

Amanda couldn’t help but laugh. “Yeah, but I don’t want anything in return.” Besides you not shanking me in my sleep, that is .

“Well,” Ronda pushed out a pill and put it on her pillow. “I’ma leave it here before I change my mind. Trust me, it’ll help pass the time. The fucking guards said they were planning on skipping afternoon recess.”

“Again?” She groaned. She had been looking forward to going outside. To feel the sun on her face.

Lately, the guards have been such fucks. They were almost as bad as cops.

Almost.

She was grinding her teeth, looking at the heavily painted yellow walls again. The bricks burned her eyes and she wanted to just slam her forehead into the concrete until she caved in her own skull. 

She wanted to just die.

She had been in for six months. Six long fucking months. And it never got easier. The time never passed any quicker.

And she wasn’t even sure what waited for her when she was finally outside. Her parents had disowned her. Her brother was dead. She didn’t have anyone she’d expect to wait for her on the outside. Maybe Cecil, if he was sober and not in a bad mood.

But she wouldn’t count on the bastard. She was still bitter and blamed him for getting her in this mess in the first place.

The little blue pill looked appealing, all of a sudden. 

She always wondered if it was as good as they said. 

What else am I going to fucking do here?

Without a second thought, she took the pill and put it in her mouth. The coating stuck to her tongue and she forced-swallowed, clearing her throat.

And then she laid back on her pillow and waited.

Eric Matthews

Detective Bradshaw pistol whipped the suspect in the middle of the interrogation. Red splashed the concrete floor. Matthews looked on, leaning against the wall with his arms crossed, smirking as the guy spat out a tooth. Bradshaw was a heavyset man and he had thrown all his weight - beer gut and all - right into that smack. 

They were currently in the middle of ‘questioning’ with his preferred approach. It was two in the morning. Just the bare-bones skeleton crew, preferable when they needed to keep the potential witnesses down. 

“You can’t fucking do this,” the guy growled, surprisingly still with the attitude. 

“What are you talking about,” Matthews was at his back, taking a step forward while lighting up another cigarette. He was unconcerned. Hoffman was at his right, exchanging a look with him that was full of agreement and pent up rage being held back. Everyone in that room wanted to hurt something. “We can do this all fucking night if you want.”

Their latest piece of shit to take down, a man who they knew had beaten his wife and child to death with a baseball bat, had crossed their path with a flip of the middle finger and a grab at his crotch, signing his sentence right then and there. They had been investigating the surrounding area, looking for him. Witnesses all pointed in his direction. When they confronted him, with the terrible news of his family, he had only cared about his own wellbeing. 

And then they ran his background. It solidified their decision to deal with him as they were. 

He had plenty of priors. And though he hadn’t been actively committing a crime when they arrested him, had no solid evidence tying him to the scene of the crime he was supposedly involved in, that quickly changed when they ‘discovered’ some dope in his pocket.

Now, they were going old school, a stack of yellow pages on the table, more a symbolic gesture than actual instruments to administer compliance. They wanted to use their fists. They could always explain away the bruises later.

Despite the unconventional approach, Matthews was pleased with how quick they had cleaned the streets. While Sing and Tapp were focused exclusively on keeping organized crime in check, they dealt with the miscellaneous chaos that had run about, untethered, long enough. They administered justice swiftly, stomping out any rebellion like tufts of flames on dirt. 

Things were finally improving. Wherever they went, people behaved. They feared the police, as they should. Because they weren’t going to take any bullshit anymore. 

Matthews just had one complaint - Hoffman, his brother in arms and right hand man, seemed to want to pull him back more often than he’d like.

Maddox had made him soft. 

Whenever Eric went on a rampage, like last week when he had pummeled some fuck too many times in the face with his flashlight, Hoffman had stepped in, pulling him off the guy and throwing him like a sack of rice. 

He didn’t like it, but when it came to his partner, he knew he needed to take a walk and cool down. He knew, deep down, that in a fair fight Hoffman would likely win.

The door knocked and everyone straightened up. Bradshaw put his gun away. Matthews continued blowing smoke on the suspect as the prick spat another glob of blood on the floor.

In came Gibson, the little man looking ready to breathe fire. “Stop right there.” Behind him were two other cops from Internal Affairs. Matthews resisted the urge to laugh. It was like watching a kid play cops and robbers. 

Hoffman remained calm, coolly watching as Gibson walked toward the table, looking down at the seated man. “You all right?”

“No! These fuckers knocked my goddamn tooth out,” The guy looked up, lowering his hands to reveal bright red cherry juice leak past his lips. Matthews felt the corner of his mouth curl. They had gone easy on him. If they had really wanted to hurt him, he wouldn’t have been able to speak. 

Gibson immediately turned with a triumphant smile plastered on his face. “I finally got your ass, Hoffman.”

“What’re you talking about?” Hoffman looked passively back at the kid. “The suspect attacked Detective Bradshaw first. We tried to be civil, even taking off his handcuffs in good faith. And he made a move to strike him.” He said this so easily and Matthews nodded in agreement.

He didn’t get why Gibson had it in for his partner. Likely jealousy, but Gibson always ran his mouth and hadn’t made too many friends in the precinct because of it. It looked like the kid was about to make some more enemies, though, as evident from Bradshaw twitching his nose and clenching his jaw while eyeballing the IA representatives warily. 

Gibson raised a hand, shaking his head. “No. You may have turned off the cameras, but I’ve gathered enough complaints that I’m about to indict you and all of the members of your little fuckboy club.” 

“Yeah?” Hoffman pushed off the wall and took a step toward Gibson, looking down at him. “Talk is cheap, what do you have to back it up?” 

Matthews observed as Gibson stood his ground, chin up defiantly as Hoffman closed in on him. He thought of David and Goliath, though he doubted Gibson would walk away after slinging a rock at Hoffman’s forehead. 

“Eye witnesses. Enough of them to at least have Bradshaw here,” Gibson turned to glare at the cop, “put on suspension without pay, while IA conducts an investigation.”

“You’re joking,” Bradshaw shook his head before looking alarmed. “No, that’s bullshit.”

“You’re right, it is bullshit that you’re not arrested right here,” Gibson snapped. He looked at each member in the room. “It’s bullshit that Grissom turns a blind eye and everyone in this department refuses to stand for what’s right. While Kerry and Maddox are out, you all suddenly behave like a bunch of animals and don’t get punished for it.”

“What’re you gonna do, Gibson, tell mommy?” Matthews snickered. “You’re fighting a losing battle, kid. You can’t beat us.”

Gibson’s ears had gone pink and his face contorted to fury. “Mark my words, Matthews. Hoffman. You may have friends in high places here. I may not get you tonight. But one day, I’ll get you two. One day, you’ll both slip up. And I’ll be the one to put you in your place.”

Hoffman rolled his eyes, amused. “Get out of here, Gibson, before you embarrass yourself.” 

“Not until Bradshaw comes with us. I’m serious,” Gibson held his hand up and gestured with a curl of the fingers. “Come on. We’ve got an affidavit you need to review. Now.”

Bradshaw cursed and left, casting a nervous look at the two of them before disappearing behind closed doors.

Matthews stared at the door before turning to frown at Hoffman. He knew they had gotten brazen. But Grissom had been thrilled by the arrest rates and the higher convictions. The DA had been practically dancing as of late. And it was always their word against criminals. Who would question them? No one. 

Life in the MPD was good, as of late.

So why the hell was Gibson fucking it up for everyone?

Didn’t he get it? The city was a monster that would swallow up everyone in its path if they didn’t take shortcuts to keep the worst of the riff raff away from the public. They had to assert their dominance on the scum of the city, otherwise innocent people would get caught in the crossfire.

It was the only way that worked. 

The lower violent crime rates these past few months was all the proof they needed.

They were fixing things.

“We got a problem,” Matthews growled, shaking his head. “Fucking IA.”

Hoffman nodded. “We’ll handle them.” If Gibson kept poking his nose in their business and tried to take down anymore of their guys in Homicide, he would be digging his own grave.

He’d have to teach Gibson a hard lesson, if that was the case.

The door knocked again, this time, the deputy on-call arrived, some rookie with her uniform pressed and starched. “Matthews, phone call for you.”

He cursed before turning to his partner. “See you tomorrow.”

He followed the girl down the hall, noting her short stature and blonde hair pulled back in a tight bun. He could smell the fruity perfume, sharp and sweet, breaking through the smell of his cigarette smoke. He took one final drag before he let it fall to the ground and stomped it on the linoleum, leaving it as they made their way to one of the entryway desks.

He took the phone, already knowing who it would be. “Yeah?”

“I need you to come watch Daniel.”

“Why?” Anger, fresh and never ending, poured over his head in heated waves. “You made it clear I’m not fit to have custody.”

“Well,” Jane’s voice came in like a shrill sigh, petty and passive aggressive. “Something came up. I need to go out and I can’t find a sitter this time of night.”

“If only you didn’t kick me out, I just so happen to be getting off work. But I’ve got plans, too.” He put a fresh cigarette between his lips, smiling into the phone. “Looks like you’re out of luck, bitch.”

“He’s your son, Eric-,” He heard Daniel screaming in the background all of a sudden, wailing for attention. “Danny, hang on, I’m coming!” The sound of fumbling, followed by Jane, rushed and angry. “You know, If you hadn’t been fucking off and actually took time to get to know him, we wouldn’t be this way.”

He knew she had a point.

He bowed his head, looking down at his feet. Shame was gripping him by the throat and making him feel weak. A part of him wanted to tell her she was right. That he would head over there and help out. That he was sorry, for everything.

But to hell with that. 

“Jane, when I get visitation rights, then we’ll talk.” He slammed the plastic receiver onto its seat, causing the internal bell to clang. 

Hanging up never felt so good.

 

Mark Hoffman

Gibson was starting to piss him off. It was commendable, the kid’s eagerness to be the big hero that saved the department from his corrupt ways. He understood why Will liked him so much; her affection for the underdog was endearing, if not misguided. 

It was early morning, sunrise many hours away, when his shift came to an end. He hadn’t participated as much in the line of questioning that Matthews and Bradshaw had conducted, his focus on watching Matthews carefully to make sure he didn’t push his luck.

Despite his philosophical agreement on Matthews’ approach in collecting and taking out the metaphorical trash, he also knew there was a way to go about it. Going around and punching everything that had a face and a running mouth, was not it. Hoffman knew Matthews was unhinged as of late, his stress linked to the growing bills from his divorce attorney as well as the general pent up frustration with Kerry being away. 

He was waiting for the storm to pass, choosing to take on the role Will had held in their previous partnership. It was hard, not joining in the fun. He missed unleashing his strength and teaching a good lesson to someone in dire need of it, but after Gibson crashed their recent party, he knew it was not wise to cross the line. 

Now that Bradshaw was taken out, it was likely that the others in association with him would follow. He’d need to cover his tracks and keep an eye over his shoulder. Gibson wanted blood, and Hoffman sure as hell wouldn’t be giving it to him. 

Things sure have changed. If he had asked himself ten years ago whether or not he would be the one keeping Matthews in line while being seen as the golden boy of the department, he would have likely given himself a black eye out of frustrated rage.

Things had been so different then, back when he was still relatively young and chained to Toni Rosello. He had fallen so far from grace, back when he made the wrong move at the wrong time, in poor control of his emotions.

Knox had tried to warn him. To teach him the game. He had been too idealistic and naive, and when he tried to stand up to Rosello that fateful day, it ended with Knox in a wheelchair and Hoffman ruined. 

Back then, Matthews had been the hero, decorated and exalted, getting the promotion and the accolades while he had been thrown down in the Pit with the one desk that had an uneven leg and dumped with the throwaway cases that would do nothing to help his career. IA had been on him then too, and he had to learn quickly on how to avoid getting spiked.

And then he had been left forgotten in the precinct, never to promote and never to be trusted again. He had been left to rot, until the day Grissom had plopped a plucky little redhead in front of him as his new partner. 

And despite how annoying she had been, with her constantly keeping him to follow the rules, she had saved him from making terrible mistakes. She had been a good partner, on the level of Vernon Knox.

Thoughts of Knox made him feel nostalgic and thirsty for a drink. 

He drove off the parking lot, his tires bouncing from the uneven pavement, when he decided to take a detour. He hadn’t seen his old partner in a long time. 

The night was quieter than most, the air humid and full of the typical stink of urine and rubbish. He stopped to pick up the usual items: a bottle of middle shelf scotch and some pistachios, pretzels, and a case of cigars. He told the cashier to keep the change and carried the brown paper bag up the flights of stairs with a throwback tune under his breath.

Vernon Knox had not responded with the usual growl and the cock of the shotgun when he knocked at the apartment door.

This, disturbed him. He immediately moved away from the door and lowered the groceries against the wall, taking out his gun. “Knox?” He called out, loud but keeping his voice steady. He immediately assumed some old Rosello-loyalists had come for revenge. Or maybe it was just a random burglary. Hell, Knox had a long and colorful career that had given him a long list of enemies.

He wasn’t worried, though. He was just being overly cautious. He knocked harder, wondering if the man had a little too much to drink; that he was just passed out.

Hell, the old goat needed to catch up on sleep. Maybe he shouldn’t disturb him.

But he had a gut feeling that something was wrong.

He knocked again. Hard enough to notice dust had wafted off the frame in plumes of plaster. He counted to three in his head.

And then he kicked the door down. An eruption of gray mist exploded into his face but he walked through the bent frame, stepping onto the crumpled door as he entered.

When the smell hit him, his heart dropped to his feet. He sprinted deeper into the dark apartment, turning corners, not seeing but knowing from the hundreds of times he had visited, where to go. That stench grew stronger. He had hoped it was just the garbage, that Vernon just lacked a visitor to come by for so long that it accumulated to an ungodly level.

But he knew that smell.

It was unmistakable.

No. Fucking NO.

The stench of rust and rot, a cologne that haunted his daily life as a homicide detective was as familiar to him as the smell of coffee. 

The lights weren’t on, but the city lights provided enough illumination through the window for him to take in the scene.

Blood was splattered on the windows like brown stained glass. Blood coated the walls. He stepped forward to find the fucking floor was sticky with the evaporated crust of brown congealed fluid. 

He saw the wheelchair, first, silhouetted by the faint light streaming through the windows. He couldn’t see Vernon. 

He knew he would regret it but he flipped the light switch. 

And then he realized he had been looking at the rotting husk of his old partner the entire time. 

Vernon Knox’s head was detached and in pieces. Bits of skull were tacked to the wallpaper. His lower jaw was still attached to his neck. His tongue was blackened, still nestled in between his lower teeth. The rest of him was all over the place, having been sprayed outward from his neck.

The sawed off shotgun rested on his lap, his fingers still wrapped around the handle, thumb in the trigger.

He had done it by the kitchen table, where a piece of paper and pen rested.

Sorry.

That was all he wrote. 

Hoffman felt his legs tremble but he locked his knees and leaned against the wall, forcing himself to remain standing. He turned, his throat tight. His nose felt stuffed. He coughed into his fist before slamming it against the wall, indenting the sheetrock, barely recognizing that the low guttural moan sounding in his ears was his own. 

Angelina Hoffman

Mark hadn’t been answering the phone for the past few days.

This worried her.

Even though she was trying not to be so needy lately, she still called him every other day. Hearing his voice was a comfort she needed and going a week without it left her like an addict in desperate need of her fix. After the most recent missed call, she decided to drive straight to his apartment.

She knocked and waited, her pulse thudding in her ears as she impatiently stood by the door. He never failed to open the door when she visited. This made her expect the worst. She let herself in with the spare key he had entrusted with her. The door creaked as she slowly pushed it open. 

When she saw the mess the apartment was in, her first thought was that he had been robbed. Mark was neat. Organized, and proud of it. 

She had never seen him leave his home in such a state. Dishes stacked in the sink, trash bags piled around the overflowing bin, and mountains of clutter of newspapers, magazines, and unopened mail ranged the counter. 

What was more telling were the sticky whiskey glasses collecting on the coffee table and the various empty bottles strewn around the floor.

She felt a crunch under her boot. She had stepped in broken glass.

“Mark?” She knew he was off duty and should be home. 

A click of metal made her flinch. 

“Damn it, Angie,” his voice made her whirl around, her heart frozen in her chest. With only the dim light from the kitchen, he stood in the hallway like a shadow of death, only the glint of his eyes defined. She reached for the nearest lightswitch to flip up. The overhead yellow illuminant revealed his state. He was in sweat pants and an undershirt, eyes bloodshot. His hair was messy and over his forehead. She saw the gun just as he pointed the barrel downward, and she widened her eyes.

“Mark. Why haven’t you answered my calls?” He didn’t answer, flicking the safety on and turning to put his gun away. She followed him. “Mark?”

“Just needed some time alone,” he growled. “What do you need?”

She balked. “I just wanted to see my brother. Something’s wrong. Tell me.”

He stiffened still holding the gun that was pointed at the ground. She felt nervous with it out in the open. “Give me that,” she reached for it but he pulled it away before she could touch it. “Mark!”

He looked at her, expressionless. “Knox is dead.”

She blinked. “Oh…” she raised a hand to her mouth before throwing her arms around him. “I’m so sorry, Mark.” She felt her eyes water and her heart sink. Vernon Knox had been like a second father to Mark. “Was it his injury?”

“No. He shot himself.”

She pulled away, alarmed. “Oh my God.” She looked up at Mark, taking in the grit in his eyes, the crust on his mouth. He looked sallow and greasy and he didn’t smell any better. She had never seen him so completely messed up. Not even when…

Something in her rose up, scraping up her throat, filling her with scalding energy. “Mark, when was the last time you ate?”

He blinked, narrowing his eyes. “I don’t know.”

“Okay. You’re going to take a shower.” She took his arm and pulled him to steer him towards the bathroom. He let her, for which she was grateful for. “And I’m going to make you something to eat. Okay?” She pushed him into the bathroom before closing the door, turning to face the mess. 

Okay, Ange, one thing at a time. She needed to clean up. She entered the kitchen, separating and shoving shot glasses and debris, looking into the fridge to find only assorted condiments, some eggs, and a random carrot. She pulled her lips to a grimace, turning the cabinets to analyze the spices and dry foods she hoped Mark had kept on hand.

She found a random box of spaghetti, some parmesan cheese, and a generic bottle of olive oil, followed by a lone salt shaker. She suppressed a smile at how limited Mark’s cooking options were. She had gotten him accustomed to never needing to cook much at home and it showed. She wouldn’t be able to whip up a gourmet feast with this limited selection.

But she knew she could work with this. 

Like lightning, she moved quickly and precisely to clear the countertops and began cleaning the dishes in the sink. She hoped Mark would take his time cleaning himself up while she sped through getting the kitchen in workable order.

Since she could remember, Mark had always taken care of her in situations of loss. She was aware that when their parents died, he had stepped up and taken on the parental role. He had sacrificed so much of himself and his own feelings for her sake.

Now, it was her turn to help him. 

Vernon Knox’s face was in the back of her mind. Her eyes began to sting again. Why did he do this? She hadn’t been close to the man but Mark certainly was. Every time she had met him, he had always had a joke and a compliment to share with her.

“Your parents named ya right, after the angels. You sure look like one. Now be an angel and tell your brother to visit ol’ Knox more often, won’t ya? And tell him to bring some good beer, none of that cheap canned shit he’s been drinking.”

She filled the pot with water, realizing that her vision was swimming again. She wiped at  her cheeks quickly. She knew Mark didn’t handle her crying very well. She had to force the tears down and push the sorrow out of her. This wasn’t about her. This was about Mark.

“I’ll clean up while the water’s warming up.” She was talking to herself softly, to keep herself grounded. The pot was on the stove and she was now reaching for the trash bags under the sink, to begin scooping up every piece of debris and trash and have it all ready to be taken out by the front door in minutes.

The pot was a chaotic cauldron of bubbles, now. She took the pasta and let it sink into the water, setting a timer, and then ran to clean enough dishes to serve the meal on. She pulled at one free-looking dish and the sink exploded in a cacophony of crashes as the dish pile caved into itself slightly. 

She bit her lip and looked over in the direction to Mark’s bathroom, hoping this didn’t stress him out any further. As she scrubbed at the heavily caked and grimy plate, she thought of when Mark had always made sure she had eaten. 

He had taken her out, often to the very same diner she had met Peter, when she was still in high school. Knox used to join them there, too, the man tall and proud, walking with a swagger in his shoulders and a cocky grin. Mark would brighten up whenever Knox would take a seat at their table, often ordering corned beef hash and sunny side up eggs, drinking at least four cups of coffee black before picking up the bill for all three of them. 

He used to scare Peter so much, back when Peter was still trying to pick me up with his magic routine, she mused to herself. One time, Peter had arrived with the bill to leave for Mark while the waiter had planned to make a bouquet of flowers appear from out of nowhere. 

Knox had proceeded to grip Peter’s wrist when he had made his sudden movement, the older detective’s reflexes quick and had broken the illusion as Peter’s one hand had been left frozen and holding the stems of some flowers that had come out of his sleeve. 

“Go back to school, son, if you can’t move fast enough for a man twice your age to stop ya, magic just ain’t for you.”

The timer went off and she ran to retrieve a freshly cleaned colander, having to improvise with dish rags as oven mitts to pour out the excess water. 

The rest was a quick saucing and heating, followed with pouring a generous amount of parmesan onto the noodles. Mark always went overboard with the cheese. 

She heard him open the door and leave his bedroom. 

“Mark, food’s ready,” she tried to sound normal. Happy, even. She gave him a wide smile as she poured the steaming food onto the plate and handed it to him. “I’m not leaving until you eat at least half of what’s on this plate.”

Mark took the plate glumly, avoiding her eyes, before going to take a seat at his couch. He turned on the TV, the channel already set to the sports channel. She joined him on the couch, pretending to find some newscaster who ranted on some various names and football moves as fascinating.

She knew he wouldn’t bounce back right away. And that was perfectly fine. She would stay with him until then. She wouldn’t let him out of her sight.

She wondered how she could take his gun away. If that was even possible. 

“Thanks, Ange. You don’t have to worry about me, I’ll be all right.” Mark got up to put the plate on the counter. 

Angelina turned to her brother. “Hey, I'm going to stay over tonight.”

“You don’t have to do that.”

“Uh, yeah, I do.” She stood up and walked up to him, reaching out to put a hand on his shoulder. He looked fresh but still exhausted. His full face looked as if it was beginning to narrow. She waited until he finally looked at her and she smiled sadly. “Mark, it’s my turn to take care of you, okay? Don’t worry about the mess here. Just go to sleep, okay? But I need you to promise me something.”

Mark didn’t answer, only waited for her to continue.

“Promise me, Mark, that you’re not going to do anything stupid. Like hurt yourself.”

He shook his head. “No, Ange, I don’t plan to.”

She nodded, not able to completely believe him, but she’d at least take his word on it. “And if I ask for your gun -?”

“Out of the question.” His voice had a sudden edge to it, stubborn and angry.

She backpedaled quickly. “Okay. Well. Good night, then. You got work tomorrow?”

“Yeah.”

“Okay. Then all the more reason for you to go to bed now.” She waited until he turned to go to his bathroom before her eyes fell to the phone by the front door.

She needed to call Will.

 

Notes:

A/N: Whew, work's been picking up so my updates may be a little spread out for a while. (December, should slow down though!)

Hoffman's about to go through a gauntlet of pain. *Cracks Knuckles* Time to attempt to make him suffer and drive him into the monster he becomes in the movies.

I'm worried I'm losing a bit of cohesion with the FBI-side plot. It feels more like character studies with them kind of investigating a serial killer but the Heart Stealer just doesn't feel very cool. Hopefully the tension makes up for it.

Thanks so much for your reviews and kind words!

Chapter 31: Pre-SAW: How We Deal With Loss

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

Rain was striking the building with loud thuds that filled the awkward silence. It was three in the morning. They had been debating on the killer’s next move. On the table before them, the contents of the very first parcel he had left for their investigative team was uncovered. Its contents, which held sealed plastic bags marked as evidence, held a dirty old Barbie doll with its hair shorn, a once gold plated necklace that was now tarnished with a pendant that was meant to be adorned with rubies and diamonds. The hand scrawled note was unfolded, its black writing hard to read. You think you’re so smart, don’t you Peter?

Will bit her lip while Strahm clicked his pen furiously. She was exhausted. They had been at it for hours, ever since Strahm stormed out of the crime scene. With all this rain, I hope they got the scene cleaned up in time. Will’s cell phone began to ring. She pulled at it, recognizing Mark’s apartment phone number on the caller ID and her heart skipped. She looked up at Strahm who was leaning back in his office chair, watching her.

“I need to take this,” she gave an apologetic frown as she turned away from the contents. She flipped the phone, pulled out the antenna. “Hey, Mark?”

“Will, it’s me,” Angelina’s voice whispered on the line. Will’s heart sped up. 

“Ange, what’s wrong?”

“Vernon Knox died. Mark’s not doing so well. His apartment’s a mess and he wasn’t eating until I made him. And I’m worried. He has his gun.” A soft sigh followed by a long pause, then, “You see, Vernon killed himself. And he was like Mark’s second father. I - it’s just that I don’t think I’ve ever seen him this way. Not even when our parents died. I know you’re busy, but… you see he won’t give me his gun. I’m just scared he’ll…”

“I -,” Will turned just briefly, locking eyes with Strahm whose already angry stare had darkened further. She felt her face harden in response. “I’ll catch the next plane back. I just need to wrap things up here.”

She heard Angelina sigh in relief. “Thank you. You’re seriously the best.”

She bit her lip. “No, you are. Thanks for looking out for him. I’ll be there as soon as I can.” She hung up, looking at the large clock that ticked above the door. A flash from outside followed by the deep grumble of thunder shook the room.

“Trouble?” 

She turned and cleared her throat. “Yeah. Family emergency. I’m afraid I need to head back for a few days.”

Strahm clicked his pen again, lips pressed together. It was clear he wasn’t happy about it. “We were finally starting to get somewhere, Will.”

“I know. I know. But.” She ran her fingers through her hair, noting how oily the locks felt. She needed a shower. Some sleep. Like him, she was near the end of her rope. This case was draining her of everything she had. “You’re going to have to get through this without me.”

“I’ll take you to the airport. We can continue this discussion while I drive.” Despite all his previous tantrums, Strahm got to his feet and retrieved his suit jacket, pulling it on. “At least we won’t likely hit traffic this early. You need to get your stuff first?”

“Uh, yeah.” Her mind was currently stuck on Vernon Knox. She wondered about the circumstances and feared the worst. 

Allison and Lindsay were likely fast asleep, unaware that she was about to leave the state. She got into Strahm’s car, now familiar with the smell of car leather and his cologne; sandalwood and pine.

“Earlier,” Strahm was pulling the car back out of the parking space, “you mentioned something interesting. You said you thought he was taking their hearts, not to steal, but -,”

 “To take what he thinks is his. He displays them as if to humiliate them. And he brings them to places where he wants them to feel shame in,” Will felt herself fall back into the shroud of this persona. She was trying to think like the killer. To understand him and why he did this. “He feels entitled to their hearts.”

“And where would that entitlement stem from?”

She was biting her lip, keeping her eyes ahead. “He gave them his heart. And when they threw it away, he decided to take it back. An eye for an eye. A heart for a heart.”

“If he didn’t have his heart, he’d be dead.”

She gave him a look and was surprised to find he was smirking at his own joke. “Too far-fetched?”

“No. I think it’s brilliant. The locations mean something - something terrible in his eyes. And so he takes his victims to clean them. To purify them. And then he brings them to the place where the victims did something terrible - a wrong that he must right. And so he kills them, takes their hearts, and leaves them to rot in that location. He has the final say. He casts them aside, in his finality.”

They were pulling onto the highway, the roads completely devoid of other cars. They sat in silence with only the hum of the engine in the background. 

“Everyone all right back home?” Strahm’s voice was thick with concern.

She turned to look at him, his profile a shadow in the dark. She wondered if she should share anything with him. If he would judge her, for dropping such a serious case. So far, he hadn’t done a good job hiding his honest feelings of her dating Mark Hoffman. “It’s Mark. His old partner killed himself.”

Strahm nodded, swallowing, his eyebrows softening. “I’m sorry to hear that.”

Will turned away. “His sister called me, telling me he’s not handling it well.”

“I don’t blame him. It’s hard. Losing someone that way. You never get over it.”

She studied Strahm, seeing his jaw clench and unclench, eyes fixed on the road. “Did you lose someone?”

“Yeah.” Strahm’s left hand twitched and Will looked at his ring. Lindsay Perez had told her that Strahm, despite wearing it, was not currently married. 

But Lindsay never elaborated. 

“If you don’t mind me asking, who was it?”

“My wife.” Strahm’s voice sounded almost hoarse. She instantly regretted asking him. He added, “She had been depressed for a while. I was always working. And I kept my distance back then. I didn’t want to share all the horror with her. She was lonely.” Strahm’s eyes flashed over to Will’s, haunted. “She suffered from insomnia. Was prescribed sleeping pills. One night, I had to work late. And she downed the whole bottle. I didn’t come home until the next day. By then, she was long gone.”

“I’m sorry,” Will whispered, feeling the world press in over her with dread. “I can’t imagine.”

Strahm cleared his throat. “You blame yourself, after that. You wonder if you could have done things differently. Cared more. Showed that you cared more. And no matter how many years go by, there’s always knowing that they were suffering.”

The silence had grown awkward. Will wanted to reach out and touch his shoulder, to offer some comfort, but found her hand hovering just over his jacket. “What was her name?” She desperately wanted to fill the silence, pulling her hand back and resting her folded hands into her lap.

“Jessica.” A longer pause, then, “We met in college. She and I were both psych majors. She wanted to settle down. I was more career driven.” Strahm shook his head. “Sorry, Will. I don’t want to burden you with my problems, not now. You’ve got your hands full. I’m glad Hoffman’s got you to look after him.” He spoke with genuinity, no hint of resentment or malice sneaking through his words.

“It’s okay, Peter,” Will felt it was all right to touch him. She put her hand onto his shoulder. “You don’t have to feel bad for opening up. You can’t keep things bottled up forever. It’s not good for you.” Will tried to diffuse the dark mood. “You know, they say that’s why law enforcement get heart attacks in their forties.”

Strahm breathed out of his nose, huffing with a smirk. “Is that what they say?”

“Yep. You guys keep your emotions all in and it literally ages you prematurely.” Will was delicately grinning. “A shrink that shrinks to no one will shrink into nothing.”

“God, that was terrible.” Strahm was chuckling. “And made no sense.”

“Don’t act like you don’t think I’m hilarious,” Will boasted, glad the conversation was making a new turn. 

“The term shrink came from the historical context of how heads of fallen warriors were shrunk. The shrink doesn’t get any smaller themselves.”

“Nerd,” Will teased. “Way to turn a pun into an object lesson.”

“I’m just making sure you understood where the term came from.”

“I thought you were called that because you made our problems seem smaller.”

Strahm nodded. “I can see how that was interpreted.” His long lashes blinked before changing the subject. “What airline do you fly?”

Eric Matthews

“You’ve done good work, Matthews,” Grissom held out the cigar case and Matthews helped himself to one, smelling the honey on the paper with that comforting scent of luxury he knew he deserved.

“Damn straight,” Matthews reached for the cigar cutter and lit himself a healthy puff. “Mm-mm. Tastes sweet. Cuban?”

Grissom eased back into his chair, holding a match and taking gentle sucks of his cigar. “I cannot confirm or deny the origin, you got that?” There was a playful warning in his eye and the two men chuckled amongst each other. “You’ve done an excellent job picking up the slack, what with most of this precinct handling the K2K case. You and Hoffman, both. Despite all your problems at home. You’re a damn good cop, Matthews.”

“I aim to serve, chief,” Matthews felt like he was floating. Sure, his life was a damn mess at home. His ex-wife kept nagging at him for child support. Daniel could apparently speak, now, and kept asking him to stay and play with him whenever he visited and it broke his heart when he had to tell the kid no. 

Grissom flicked some ash into the tray on his desk. “So, I’m thinking of getting you and Hoffman raised to the next pay grade, for all the damn good work you’ve done.”

Matthews brightened. “You don’t say? About time.” It wasn’t exactly a promotion, but a pay bump was always a good thing. “So how about moving us to one of them good offices. The ones with the windows?”

“You want a view of the back alley?” Grissom's smug smirk melted as he looked down at his desk. “IA’s been getting antsy. Gibson’s got it out for you two. I’ve been sweeping things under the rug, because I see the big picture. Like you and Hoffman. I understand what you’re doing is, in the end, right.” Grissom took a thoughtful puff. “But if the public start learning the dirty details, they may suddenly grow a conscious and want us to pay for their guilt. So best if you try to keep your nose clean these next few months.”

“Fucking Gibson,” Matthews scoffed, hate rooting in his chest. “The punk’s not learned his place yet.”

Grissom shrugged. “The rookies are always the idealists. Just give it more time. He’ll come around. Like you and Hoffman did.”

Mathews blinked at this. “Us? Idealists?”

Grissom let out a laugh. “You probably don’t remember too much, what with all the years you’ve got behind you. How long has it been now? Fifteen years now?”

“I think it’s still under fifteen,” Matthews took a puff, suddenly feeling ancient. His lower back was sore. Every time he looked in the mirror, his scalp kept reminding him of how he used to have a thick head of hair that was now a thinned remnant of what had once been his youth. He sometimes woke up choking for air, coughing and desperate to get his morning cigarette in. “Yeah. Hoffman and I were in the Academy back in eighty. Fuck. Thirteen years.”

“I remember a rookie who once prided himself in being so straight-laced and by-the-book.” Grissom flicked ash and chuckled. “We all had a more sunny disposition, back then.”

“Yeah, back when murder was a weekly case and not every single goddamn day.” Matthews scoffed at the past. “We got to do what we got to do, to keep up with this crazy fucking world.”

“Ain’t that the truth?” 

John Kramer

He had everything planned. The basket was packed. He had an extra blanket in his trunk, in case the warm weather took a turn for the worst. The Fall air was rich with crisp leaves and the trees would be at their peak level of color. He had checked the weather daily as this Saturday approached. He had looked at the past ten years of climate patterns and foliage surveys to ensure that this would be that one special day.

The perfect Autumn picnic. 

True, plans often did not always succeed. But that was why he had various contingencies in his back pocket, should the need arise.

He was confident there would not be a need to utilize one of his backup plans. For one, the location of their vista point was at the edge of a cliff, facing the valleys and mountain ranges of the park. He had explored the hiking trails and found this one to be simple enough to explore while being private enough to ensure they would not be disturbed by fellow hikers.

He had managed to acquire one of Jill’s favorite vintages, a zinfandel they had discovered when they vacationed in the Maldives, their first trip together, many years ago.

He had this romantic day planned for his beloved wife. 

Jill, having worked tirelessly for the downtrodden who wandered into her clinic, was in dire need of some pampering. She would work even later into the evening than he did on his busiest nights. While he would wrap up his schematics and the urban renewal renovations past sunset, he would then go to drive and pick her up at her clinic which closed at ten in the evening. 

She always looked exhausted, eyes closed while he drove her home. She wouldn’t say a word, instead taking a quick shower before collapsing onto the bed as soon as they returned.

To him, Jill Tuck was a saint. His Lady Madonna. She gave every piece of herself to others and never asked for anything in return.

Except for one thing.

She had always wanted to be a mother, for which he had always kept the idea out of both of their reach. He had his reasons for not wanting to be a father. One of them, being, he was afraid he would turn into the very man he had despised. His own father had been a cruel man.

It had taken him time but he finally felt ready.

They had been married for many years and Jill was at that age where it was now or never. And they were not worried about the money. Oh, no. He had made a fortune throughout his career as a mechanical engineer that evolved into independent consulting that left them with more money than they knew what to do with. 

He wanted to give Jill the one thing that she always wanted. And what he now wanted as well.

“John,” Jill wrapped her jacket tighter around herself, beaming at him. “Where are you taking me?”

“It’s a surprise,” he grinned as they pulled up to the trailhead. They trekked up the dusty path, stepping over jagged roots and ducking thick branches as the wind rustled through the leaves.

It took them about an hour before they reached the end of the trail. There was a clearing where the trees ceased but grass spread outward with giant rocks that protruded about like teeth. 

“It’s so beautiful out here,” Jill sighed, closing her eyes to feel the fresh air on her face. 

He laid out their blanket and Jill was opening the bottle of wine. They enjoyed the peace together. Often, they spent many moments in a comfortable silence where they had no need to say anything at all. They were connected on a level that transcended words. 

They ate their meal and looked out toward the long mountain range, taking in the textures of trees and deep blue shadows of the landscape. He waited for the right moment. And when it came, he turned to Jill.

“My love,” he whispered and she looked up at him with such innocence and admiration that his heart swelled. He took her hand in his. “I have a proposal for us.”

“What is it?” Her eyes widened and her smile did not waiver.

“Do you still want to start a family? With me?” He suddenly felt nervous. His palm was sweating. He had a lump in his throat. And his pulse was getting faster. But he pressed on, knowing that despite his insecurity, that with Jill, it would all be fine. It would all work out in the end.

“Oh, John,” she looked excited and hopeful. “Do you mean…”

“I want us to have a child. If you still want to.”

“Yes!” She threw her arms around his neck and planted a kiss on his mouth. “Yes!” She was laughing, like bells in the breeze.

It was one of the happiest moments he had ever experienced in his life.

Mark Hoffman

Mark knew he should take another shower. But what was the point? He barely got out of bed, other than to use the bathroom or to try to stare at the TV. But there were too many things that reminded him of Knox. When the Eagles would be playing, he remembered Knox would clap his hands and cheer at the screen at every touchdown. When Trebeck would come up with a quip on Jeopardy, Knox used to snort in humor.

But Knox was gone. Forever. He would never see him again.

Mark felt that familiar loss, like a frozen punch to his throat. Just like his father, who had died in that accident. He never gotten a chance to say goodbye to him, either.  

Life could be so fucking unfair.

Ange kept checking in on him. He didn’t have the heart to yell at her to go away, though he wanted to. He knew she was trying and it reminded him of when he had taken care of her when their mother died. 

He knew loss. He was familiar with it. But it didn’t mean it was any easier when more people died on him. 

He heard his front door knock. He rolled over so he could hear the commotion.

He heard Ange’s voice. And then Will’s.

Despite hearing her, he didn’t bother to get out of bed. He only felt embarrassed at his state. She shouldn’t see me like this. He shut his eyes and hoped that if they came into his bedroom, they’d think he was sleeping and leave him alone.

He heard his door open, the hinges creaking. He heard the soles of her dress shoes on the wooden floor. He felt her sit on his mattress, feeling the shift in gravity attract him closer to where she had sat. 

Her arms slowly moved over him and pulled him into a careful hug. 

He felt his eyes sting and he refused to move or say anything. He felt her kiss the back of his head and wrap herself around him. 

It helped a little. 

Feeling her, warm and firm, was a nice distraction. 

“Hey, Mark,” she whispered. “I’m right here. We’ll get through this together.”

(Power of Will)

Will had convinced him to shower, change, and go out to get some food. He just wanted to get a drink. Ange looked relieved as she left to go to work and kissed him on the cheek before leaving. 

Will looked like she had a rough time in Virginia.

It was the hardened frown on her face that he noticed, when she wasn’t looking at him directly. But when she realized he was watching her, she turned and lit up like a Christmas tree, all smiles. He knew she was pushing herself for his benefit.

It made him feel worse. But the two of them continued this charade of pretending that everything was fine. That they were all just going about their normal routine. Their old habits. 

They were now at Larry’s. Sitting at their usual swivel chairs at the bar. Larry was wiping the same bartop with the same greasy rag. The same channel was on the TV, showing the results of the last baseball game taking place. 

Everything was the same, the world unchanged despite Knox no longer being a part of it.

Will ordered the usual basket of fries and grilled chicken sandwich. He ordered the same double cheeseburger he always got. He asked for a bottle of Jamesson and had Larry leave the bottle. Will joined him and the two clinked their glasses together.

He appreciated Will not asking any questions. She didn’t keep quiet. She simply took a shot of the whiskey and talked about the case. “He’s taunting us. He left a fucking doll for us to gawk at. And he kept leaving notes. He’s a cocky sonofabitch.” 

He knew she was breaking the rules, telling him details when she wasn’t supposed to. He knew she was doing this for him. To try to help distract him with the fascinating evidence of the most notorious serial killer case since Ted Bundy. “Will,” he murmured.

She peaked at him at a side glance, her shoulders relaxed but her eyes sharp as a hawk’s. “Hm?”

“Thanks.” Hoffman didn’t like talking about certain topics. Emotions. Feelings. They were off limits in the best of circumstances. But he felt as if he was boiling over. He was full of this poison. This anger. This rage. “But you don’t need to fuck yourself over to make me feel better. Better not say anything else.” He threw back a shot of whiskey and let the alcohol burn his throat, enjoying the pain. He felt like he deserved it.

“Okay,” her voice was delicate and that made him angrier. “What do you want to talk about?” 

He was silent as he fumed. He squeezed his shot glass and glared up at the TV. Thankfully, she didn’t push it. They sat there, watching as Jimmy Key revved his arm and pitched to the White Sox. The batter struck out. 

He took another shot. In the corner of his eye, Will matched him.

He couldn’t help but smirk. He turned to her and she looked back at him with that competitive spark she always gave him when she wanted to prove that she could keep up with him in something. He refreshed both their shot glasses and they both downed them with the familiarity of high functioning alcoholics. She burped. He scoffed and the pressure growing in his chest subsided. 

He didn't know how many hours it had been. But his head was feeling nice and numb. His face was hot. He felt sweat down his neck. And his vision was getting blurred. He knew he was pretty fucking drunk at that moment.

Will was hiccuping beside him. He had forgotten why they were there. He turned to her, glad she was there with him. He missed that giant mop of orange hair and brown spots on her face. And she smiled back at him, looking at him like he was the tastiest piece of cake she was going to eat. 

“You… good, Mark?” She was slightly slurring her words. He smirked. 

“Yeah. You?” 

“Never better. I could use a water, though. My head hurts.” She was rubbing her temple.

Larry had heard and was retrieving a glass to fill with the soda water from his dispenser. He wordlessly slid the glass down the bar and Will caught it, taking sips in between her hiccups. 

Mark looked up at the game. The Yankees were losing. Badly. He remembered when his father took him to their first game. When he was just a kid. And when he was a young man, still a rookie, he had then gone to watch the Yankees with Knox.

Oh, shit. The pain in his gut had him hunch over for a moment. He had forgotten. How could he forget Knox, just like that? He hated himself for it.

“Mark?” Will’s hand was on his arm. He looked up at her, blinking. “You okay?” She looked scared.

“Fine,” he lied. He shook his head. “Just thinking.”

She hesitated but finally began prying. “About Knox?”

He looked at her, angry and seeing red, so quick he couldn’t stop the words already coming out of his mouth. “Yeah. Knox. No shit. The man fucking kills himself without so much as a goodbye. Just blows his brains out for me to find. How can I not fucking think about him all the goddamn time.” He took the bottle and chugged the remainder of the handle, the amber liquid scalding his insides. He slammed the bottle to the bar and growled. “Man was like a father to me, you know. I let him down.”

Will’s face was red and her glazed eyes were glistening. “No, Mark. You didn’t let him down.”

“I should have visited him more.” He was talking more to himself than to Will. He felt like he was at church, giving his confession. “I should have talked to him more. I would have picked up on it. He’d probably still be here, if I had.”

She was close to him. He could smell the alcohol and perfume on her skin. “Knox wouldn’t want you to feel guilty about this.”

He shook his head. He didn’t want to hear this. He wanted to hear the truth. That it was all his fault. “He’s gone. We’ll never know what he would have wanted.”

“That’s horse shit, Mark,” Will huffed. He looked up, surprised. She looked angry, too. “Knox loved you like a son. And no father would want their kid to feel like they’re to blame for something like this happening. I promise you.” She turned away and wiped at her eyes. She let out a small laugh. “I never told you this, but Knox used to call me up every so often, asking about you.” She had a small smile, her eyes distant. “He would call, saying he had advice to give or that he needed me to pass a message to Tapp. But I knew what it was really about. He wanted to make sure you were okay. He once told me that he thought of you like his son. He was such a caring man.” She wiped her cheek. “Hey, Larry, another bottle, please.”

Larry nodded and brought them more liquor. Will poured their glasses and held hers up. “To Knox. Such a loving man. A father figure to both of us. And we’ll miss him.”

Mark swallowed a lump in his throat. He felt as if a knife was twisting in his heart. But he held his glass up as well. He hoped Knox was in a better place. 

Maybe it was the booze, but his mind went to Will’s father. Still in a coma, since she was a teen. She never told him the full story. He never tried to push. But now, maybe it was time. “You never told me what happened to your father.”

She swigged and sighed. “I haven’t?” She was being coy but shrugged. “Well,” she was stinking drunk, her words loud and lulled. “My father, you know he’s been in a hospital since I was seventeen. Back then, I wanted to be a dancer.” She gave a sheepish grin. “I was pretty good. Was talking to recruiters from Julliard.” Her smile evaporated. “But then some burglars broke into our home one night. I was out at dance camp. My brother was still a toddler, but had been sleeping in his room, thank God.” She ran her fingers through her hair, sighing. “They had broke in and my father had tried to fend them off. They shot my mother. She died quickly from blood loss. And they beat my father. Beat him to the point that they say he’ll probably never wake up. When I got the call, the police came and escorted me to help identify my mother’s body.”

Mark felt the air escape his lungs. He had never known. “I’m sorry.”

She shrugged. “At first, I was so angry. I wanted to find the men who did this to my family and hurt them like they hurt me. The investigator understood me. I’ll never forget him. He told me that he wouldn’t rest until they caught them.”

“Did they?”

“No.”

He grimaced, knowing something like this would have driven him mad. “Is that why you became a cop?”

She nodded, fascinated by the stains on the bar. She ran her fingers over the various nicks and dents in the wood. “I joined the police academy as soon as I graduated high school, after that. I always hoped the police at the time would find the killers. But if not, I wanted to try to. It wasn’t until after I graduated from the academy that I found out it’s against the rules to investigate homicides where next of kin is concerned.” She let out a harsh snicker. “I was so naive, back then.”

He didn’t suggest she still was, knowing that when she was this drunk she threw punches. And they stung. “What about Bram?”

“Oh, my Aunt raised him. He never knew our parents. I really sucked as an older sister. I was so focused on becoming a cop. But despite all of this, he still calls me. He still lets me know how Dad’s doing. He visits him every week, to read to him. Bram is a saint.” Will sniffed. “Damn. How did I start talking about myself? My bad.”

It was his turn to put his hand on her shoulder. “You have nothing to be sorry about,” he told her. After all this time, despite how long they had known each other, he felt a new layer of connection with her. She, too, had lost her parents so young. And like him, she had taken her loss and had tried to make their deaths a purpose to fight back. 

Fuck, he loved her so much. 

“Closing time,” Larry spoke, as usual, for the pure necessity to kick them out. “Last call.”

Angelina Acomb

She found herself standing over a bowl of peeled potatoes, her tears falling onto the naked spuds. She gasped. How long had she been standing there? How long had she allowed her tears to drip into the food? She knew they were no longer fit to be served. She looked around, embarrassed, and fled with the bowl out the back exit. 

The alley she walked into smelled of rotting garbage and tobacco. She tossed the produce into the nearest open dumpster and suddenly collapsed to her knees.

She just lost control of herself and began to weep. It had been four months now, and still no word from Peter. She was now worried. She had asked the liaison for military spouses to look into what had happened. They told her to stay patient. But now, she expected the worst.

She was violently shaking on the oil slicked pavement when she heard a voice clear its throat.

“Um, you okay?” 

She turned to the sound of the male voice, looking up to see one of the dishwashers staring awkwardly at her, rubbing the back of his neck. He was one of the new hires. He had a scruffy face and his uniform shirt was unbuttoned, revealing a wife beater and various tattoos underneath. Despite his rough appearance, his eyes were kind and sympathetic. 

“I’m fine,” she wiped her eyes and got to her feet. “Sorry, you didn’t need to see that.”

“Don’t worry about it,” The man was smoking. He took a lazy drag and exhaled out of his nose, digging into his pocket and holding the pack out to her. “You want one?”

She shook her head and rubbed her arms, letting out a forced laugh. “Thank you. I don’t smoke.”

He shrugged. “Yeah, this shit kills you.” He had a playful smirk. “He’s not worth it.”

She felt herself go on high alert. Whoever this man was, he seemed to know too much. It made her on edge and she quickly scanned the alley for an escape. “Who?”

“Whoever you’re crying over. I don’t know your life but seeing a lady get so beat up over something so heavy, I just think it’s a man. Am I wrong?”

She blinked and felt her paranoia deflate. “Oh. No - I mean, yes, but it’s not what you think.” She suddenly felt the need to defend Peter. “My husband’s been deployed and I haven’t heard from him for months. I’m getting worried.”

“Oh, for real? Shit, I’m sorry. Didn’t know. That’s a drag.” The man took another puff of his cigarette. “I had a buddy who joined the army. Hadn’t heard from him in years. And we used to be tight. But then one day, he rolls up and it’s like he never left. What I’m trying to say is, it’s going to be okay, Chef. Promise. He’s probably just somewhere with no post office. Right?”

She smiled. It had been a while since she was comforted. She had held her fears inward for so long, not wanting to be a bother. And now, she was unloading to this complete stranger. Well, not a stranger. But one of her subordinates. It wasn’t professional.

“Sorry. Thanks for this. I need to get back inside.”

The man nodded. “You work hard, Chef. But don’t forget to take it easy once in a while. It’s not good to be so tense. You get me?” 

She forced another smile. “I’ll try.” She felt guilty now, after this man showed concern for her well being. She didn’t even know his name. “Sorry but I don’t remember your name.”

“Nah, I figured, I just started Monday. Name’s Seth. Seth Baxter.” He didn’t hold his hand out for her to shake. He looked too cool to do anything but lean against the wall and take his smoke break. 

“I’m Angelina Acomb.”

He smiled. “I know who you are, Chef. I’d have to be blind not to.” There was a glint in his blue eyes that made her cheeks flush. 

“Take care,” she retreated back into the kitchen.

“Take it easy,” he called out behind her. 




Notes:

A/N: So many characters, so many details, so little time! Sorry for delays, work has been hectic and Christmas season means scrambling to get presents/cards all sent out. Hope you like this chapter!

Chapter 32: Pre-SAW: The Showdown In The Woods

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Peter Strahm

What is a partnership, Peter?

The message was scrawled in black, the red card stained in what appeared to be dried blood. He flipped the card and scowled down at the words. This had been the latest note the Heart Stealer had left at the crime scene. It was a cryptic riddle pinned to a bouquet of tilia leaves. 

The only reason they knew what kind of plant it had been was because the forensic botanist happened to be dropping off some files to Erickson and she had noticed the leaf shape while standing around by Strahm’s desk. The branches had been in a dented cardboard box. 

The Heart Stealer mailed them another one of his packages, straight to the Behavioral Sciences department.

My home is loud. I am quiet.

But for us, God fashioned our fate together.

I am faster than my home.

But when I rest, my home still runs.

I will stay at home as long as I live.

Should we be separated, I will die.

What am I and what is my home?

“And yet he gives us the answer?” Lindsay was pulling at her necklace, pursing her lips. “A partnership?”

Strahm narrowed his eyes. “That doesn’t seem right. Do partnerships run?”

“Yes?” Lindsay grimaced. 

“I’m with Strahm,” Kerry was digging through the various notes from previous crime scenes. “Like this line - ‘I am faster than my home’. Who would be the runner and who would be the home in the context of a partnership?” 

What does this mean ? Strahm looked back at the bouquet. Every single detail meant something. The Heart Stealer was too methodical. Too precise to allow a single action be wasted. What did this bouquet of tree leaves mean?

“The tilia leaves. What do they represent?”

“With respect to the riddle?”

He shook his head. “By themselves. What are tilia leaves?”

Nobody answered. Strahm fumed. “Get me an encyclopedia.” He rubbed his temple. “And bring me back that botanist.”

Lindsay was on the phone, contacting the forensics division. Kerry had left the room. He continued to glare hatefully at the riddle. He never liked The Riddler in Batman. Apparently, this guy thought himself akin to the villain. So what did that make him? Bruce fucking Wayne?

Great. It certainly fits the profile of exuding traits of narcissism and delusions of grandeur. But this means that he wants someone to play with. Someone to help validate these delusions. In a perverted way, Strahm was flattered to be perceived as a worthy adversary to the bastard. 

He wondered what made the Heart Stealer fixate on him and his team. He had a bad feeling in his gut that warned him to be vigilant. He looked over at Lindsay, who hung up the phone.

“She’s coming back.”

He flared his nostrils to inhale sharply. “We can't go on like this, Linds.” 

She had her arms folded. “You’re telling me. I just want to catch this guy.” There was an edge in her voice and the shadow of defeat was on her face. She was beginning to bend to the pressure. “I feel like such a fish out of water on this one.”

He didn’t blame her. 

He, too, was at a loss. Never had he felt so little and weak as he did with this case. He felt he had met his match. Whoever this bastard was, he was just too smart for them.

And that pissed Strahm off to no end. “We’ll catch him.” Lindsay’s words sparked something in his thoughts. He felt sudden inspiration and he hurled himself forward. 

“The riddle. It’s a red herring.”

“Why?”

Suddenly, he felt overwhelmed with panic and rage. “The riddle. It’s a fish in water. The water moves. But the fish moves faster. Without the water, the fish dies.” He held the card out to her. “And it’s red.”

Lindsay’s mouth tightened. “Is he really that obvious?”

“He’s arrogant, remember?” Strahm jumped up and looked back at the plant. It had to be related to this. Whatever this was.

“You asked for me?” An older woman appeared, glasses over her pointy nose. 

“Yes, thank you for coming,” Lindsay straightened and gestured to the bundle of tree branches. “Can you tell us anything about this tilia? What makes it significant?”

The woman straightened her frames and squinted down at the leaves. “Looks like a North American basswood tree. Also known as Tilia. Linden. Lime trees in Ireland, though they are not citrus. The wood is soft and easy to work with.” She flipped the leaves over. “I don’t see anything of note that makes this sample particularly special. Looks like a standard basswood tree.”

“Anything else? Anything related to it at all. A myth? Someone dying of a splinter from a basswood tree?” Strahm knew he sounded desperate but he was. 

The woman grimaced. “Um. Well.” The woman’s eyes scanned the room and fell down onto Lindsay’s desk. What she saw, engraved on the brass name plate, made her eyes widen. “Oh.”

“What?” Strahm leaned forward, eager. 

“Well,” The woman looked down at the leaves, then up to Lindsay. “Linden. This tree. In Ireland, they used to have islands covered with these lime trees. Or Linden trees. The Isles of Linden was called Lindsay.” 

He felt his face tighten and cool as the blood rushed out of it. He looked at Lindsay who made no change in her expression, though she fiddled with her necklace even more.

That’s the real message. He’s coming for Lindsay, next.

When the botanist left, he turned to his partner. “I’m going to have to bench you for the rest of the case.”

“No,” she balked. “You can’t.”

“Not your call,” he kept his resolve hardened. “This is a direct message addressing you.”

“We’re not sure if that’s what he meant. It could just be a coincidence.”

“See, this is exactly why you’re not going in the field anymore. Your being targeted is affecting your perspective. You’re going to ignore blatant evidence because you don’t want to be sidelined.”

Lindsay blinked, hurt. He knew he was being tough with her. She was younger and less experienced with the depraved psychopaths he had known since the very beginning of his career. She was more used to criminals driven by greed, not sadistic glee. 

“Lindsay,” he let his voice get soft. “This is not some bastard selling children for profit. This is a mentally unpredictable and disturbed individual who has been outsmarting us at every turn. You need to face that reality.”

Before Lindsay could open her mouth to respond, Kerry opened the door and came in. “Here’s the encyclopedia,” she held a giant tome in her arms. 

“Forget it,” Lindsay spat. “He figured it out. I’m the next target. Apparently.” She stepped out of the office. Kerry glanced in his direction before chasing after her.

Strahm felt his fist tighten but he forced it to relax. He was getting emotional. That wasn’t going to help things. He needed to keep his head.

Lindsay Perez

There were only a handful of times she cried over this job. Oh, she cried plenty when she was still in college and through basic training at the FBI Academy. When she was a rookie, she cried secretly in the shower after coming home from a sting operation where her team had uncovered a warehouse where children as young as two were being kept in cages to be sold off to god knows where, all around the world.

She had cried when one of her colleagues and closest friends had gotten shot in the neck during a raid gone sour. She had pressed her fingers into the bullet wound, trying to plug the severed carotid artery, hoping it would just keep him from bleeding out long enough to get a medical evacuation. He had died in her arms and she let herself cry then and there when the helicopter arrived far too late.

And now, she was crying in the safety of the women’s restroom, pressing her fingers to her eyelids as she unleashed all the frustration she had for this case and let the tears fall. She felt a familiar hand on her shoulder and could smell Ally’s perfume of sandalwood and cardamom. Ally’s hand rubbed her back as she sobbed.

“Let it out, honey. I’ve been there.” 

“He never takes me seriously. He always thinks I’m too weak to get the job done.”

Ally didn’t contribute. She didn’t judge. She simply rubbed Lindsay’s shoulder, giving sympathetic noises as Lindsay felt the words spill out of her.

“He did this on the last case. A serial shooter, who was doing drive-bys. Did not have a victim profile, beyond just who was available as a target. When we got the arrest warrant, he had me stay here while he went to make the arrest. He insisted it was too dangerous.”

“He doesn’t want you hurt,” Ally muttered. “He clearly cares for you.” 

“Well, that’s not what’s going to catch the Heart Stealer.” Lindsay choked and shook her head.

“Maybe you should take a break. When was the last time you had a full night’s sleep? Or a meal that wasn’t take out?” 

She couldn’t help but scoff. “I can’t just leave.”

“Mm,” Ally had her hands on her hips, rolling her eyes back to the door. “Strahm won’t have you sent out on the scene. So looks like you’ll just be filing paperwork. Maybe staring at the current evidence we have. But there’s little more you can do. So go. Go home. Get some sleep. Come back tomorrow. And during that time, I’ll talk to Strahm. See about getting him to change his mind.”

She didn’t like this. But she knew she was on a much shorter fuse than normal with all the stress. Yeah. Maybe I should. Just recharge the batteries . “Fine.”

“Atta girl. See you tomorrow, hon.” Ally held the bathroom door. “Drive safe.”

Ally walked down the hall, leaving Lindsay alone. She walked off, heading towards the exit and down the sidewalk towards the parking garage. It was dark. The sun was setting so early these days. She scanned the surroundings, taking in the dried grass and empty flower beds. Winter was coming early. 

She could see her breath.

When she entered the parking garage entrance, she found it empty, save for a few cars she recognized. She walked past Peter’s car, the sudden urge to kick a hub cap coming and going. She sighed and went towards her red Camry.

She paused. She felt something was wrong. She turned sharply, hand at her pistol, expecting a man to be standing right behind her.

There was no one there.

She shook her head. Damn it. Ally’s right. I need some sleep.

She went back to her car, entering the driver’s side. She started the engine, waiting for the heaters to warm up. She turned on the radio, letting NPR play in the background.

When she reached to put her car into gear she felt a sudden jerk of her head being pulled back. 

She felt her scalp slam into the headrest, a cloth over her mouth, the acrid smell of chloroform hitting her nose and making her eyes water. She held her breath and went for her gun. 

The sudden sting on her neck followed by a coolness filling her veins made her panic. She tried to fight. She couldn’t see the attacker. She couldn’t see.

And the darkness swallowed her up.

Angelina Acomb

“Mrs. Acomb?” The man, tall and dressed in a black suit, was standing in her doorway. 

She blinked at the badge he was holding up. She didn’t recognize the credentials but noticed the ‘Department of Defense’ printed in bold. She straighten up. She watched the two men warily. 

“Yes?”

“I am sorry to bring this news, but your husband, Peter Acomb, has died.”

She felt herself collapse. Gravity pulled her down to the ground, her knees hitting the wooden floor. But she didn’t feel the pain. She only heard the stranger’s voice, echoing in her ears. 

“Mrs. Acomb,” the other man knelt and helped her to her feet. “Please, may we come in? To answer your questions?”

“Huh?” She felt as if it was all a dream. Yeah, that’s what it is. A dream. “Sure.” She straightened up, no longer afraid. This was all just a dream she would wake up from. All she could do was play along. “Come in. Would you like me to get you a drink?”

“No, thank you.” The first man looked at his partner with a frown. “Do you have a relative nearby? A close friend?”

“My brother. Mark. But he’s at work right now.”

“It would be best to call him. Have him here with you. Or a close friend.”

She wordlessly went to the phone resting in the hall of her apartment. She picked up the receiver and mindlessly dialed Mark’s office phone.

It rang several times before Mark picked up. “Hoffman.”

“Mark?”

“Ange? What’s wrong?”

“Peter’s dead. These men told me to call you. Can you come over?”

“I’m on the way. Sit tight, Ange.” She heard the sudden forced calmness of her brother’s voice. It was the voice he used when he wanted to sound completely still and controlled when things were far from it. But she wasn’t going to worry. It was just a bad dream, after all.

She turned and sat on the couch, leaned back. She stared at the two men who looked uncomfortable and awkward. “Mrs. Acomb. Are you… aware of what we are saying?”

“Yes. Peter is dead. So how did he die?” She looked the man in the eye, waiting for the dream to start falling into the ridiculous. For a figment of her imagination, he sure looked more real than she usually conjured up in her sleep. He had hazel eyes. Gray hair. He looked old. Wise.

“He had been struck by a stray bullet, from the rifle of one of his fellow marines. It was an accident. He died immediately and did not suffer.”

That was when she knew it was just a dream. She could have almost laughed. “Peter would never die from something so silly.”

There was a tense pause. Then, “Mrs. Acomb, let me get you some water. May I?”

“Sure.” She chose to stare straight ahead. What was the point in playing this game anymore, when it was all just a dream? She preferred reality over this fiction. So she wouldn’t play.

Time had elapsed when she heard the door knock. The two men answered the door.

“Where is she?” She recognized Mark’s voice and she looked over to see her brother.

“Mark, you’re here.” She was surprised the dream was lasting so long. “I’m having a bad dream, Mark. These men say Peter died by friendly fire. Isn’t that just ridiculous?” She smiled widely, feeling hot tears begin to fall down her cheeks. “Peter wouldn't die like that.”

Mark sat on the couch beside her and took her into his arms. She let him and she suddenly felt this anguish crushing into her chest. She began to cry. And she suddenly felt anger rise up her throat. “Why are you coddling me?” She pulled back and wiped at her tears angrily. 

The crushing sensation was beginning to get worse. It was a pressure that was flattening her. The realization hit her. “Oh my God.” She covered her face. “Oh my God. Peter. Please, no, Peter.” She felt arms wrap around her, tightly.

“It’s going to be okay, Ange. It’s going to be okay.” Mark’s voice and the gentle rocking of his movement did little to ease her pain. 

Angelina wanted to die. She couldn’t live without Peter. Her husband. Her best friend. The man she would grow old with. The man who brought her joy and always loved her. She couldn’t live without him. 

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

She returned to Quantico, feeling fresh and ready to continue where she had left off. After Knox’s funeral and several days of looking after Mark, he had shown a rapid recovery from his grief.

It seemed he had to just unleash all his sorrow with some heavy drinking and some quality time of binging westerns. He had returned to his routine and had returned to work to join Matthews on four more arrests. 

She was surprised by how fast he had improved but after two more days of him going about his business and telling her he didn’t want her to fawn over him anymore - that he didn’t need it - she had to begrudgingly agree. He had pulled her into a tight kiss and told her to get back to Virginia to catch the sonofabitch murdering girls before sending her off with a slap on her ass. 

She half-worried he was over compensating but there was little she could do when he had shown no indication he was going to do something reckless or stupid. Mark had work to do back at the MPD. She had her work, as well. 

She drove her rental car from Dulles International and drove south toward Quantico. She had not spoken to the others since she left and she was eager to learn of any progress done in her absence. 

She pulled into Quantico, surprised by the heightened security. The guards had scrutinized her badge, squinting and triple checking that her face matched the photo on the ID before she was waved through the first checkpoint. The second checkpoint, a gate, was usually not manned. But today, there stood another security officer, this one a familiar face, waiting for her to give her credentials.

“What’s with the extra security?” She had noticed the sign that normally stated FPCON: NORMAL now stated FPCON: CHARLIE by the checkpoint booth. “What happened?”

“An agent’s missing. Surveillance showed suspicious activity. A possible compromise of our security procedure.” The man offered no additional information so Will thanked him and continued to the parking garage. 

She parked, noting that Ally and Strahm’s cars were there. She didn’t see Perez’s.

Gathering her briefcase, she walked towards the nearest building entrance, wanting to get away from the cold. She entered the heated foyer and sighed in relief as she made her way to Behavioral Sciences. As she approached, she heard the familiar voice of Peter Strahm. His voice was carrying across the hall, loud and furious.

Will braced herself as she approached his office.

“So you have nothing of value to give?” Strahm’s voice was accusatory. “So you have the car. But no sign of her?” Strahm was hunched over his desk, fisting his phone receiver to his ear, scribbling urgently onto his notepad before hanging the phone violently with a bang. 

“Sign of who?” Will decided to dive right in.

Strahm looked up quickly, eyes wild. “You’re back. Good. The Heart Stealer has Perez.”

She felt the briefcase in her hand drop to the ground. She fumbled to pick it up. “When?

“Last night. The entire Bureau is on alert. Anyone who’s free is out there. Allison is currently at Perez’s apartment, trying to find any clues as to where she was taken. But so far, nothing!” Strahm threw his pen onto the table and turned away, hands on his hips, breathing heavily. 

Will assessed the room. One of the chairs was across the room from its original resting place, upturned and on one of the sofas. A dent in the wall’s plaster indicated he had thrown the chair. He had sweat stains on his white shirt, long wrinkled from being overworn. Papers were strewn on the floor. 

“Strahm,” she walked up to him, looking him in the eye. “We’ll find her. What do we know?”

He looked at her with reproach but the fury was dampened. He exhaled slowly. “Surveillance cameras showed a white male entering her car in the garage. When she entered, the car was shaking. She put up a fight, but the car drove off. Nothing else.” He kicked the desk, forcing the furniture to shift a foot in front. 

Will walked around the desk, putting a hand to his arm. “Peter.” She, too, was filled with dread over what Lindsay was experiencing. But Peter’s hot head wasn’t going to help.

He turned to her, looking ready to pop. She put an arm around him and pulled him to her, hand on his back. “We’ll find her. Okay?” She had to believe this. Otherwise, they would have given up before they even put up a fight. They had to find Lindsay.

He stiffened from her hug but didn’t pull her away. “You don’t know that.”

She looked up at him. “I do know that. Don’t you quit on me, now, Peter.” He looked down at her, disbelief framing his face, but he shut his eyes and pulled her to him. 

“You’re right. She’s still out there. There’s still a shot.” 

She could smell the coffee on his breath. Feel the tension in his arms. His heart was beating, fast and steady.

The phone rang, pulling them apart.  

Strahm answered. “What is it?” His face went from passive to alarmed. “Where?” He reached for a pencil and paper, scribbling the details. “Send everything we’ve got. We’re on the way.” He turned to Will. “Kerry followed up on a tip after we sent out a BOLO for Lindsay’s car. It was found at the national park, over at the Noland trailhead.” 

Strahm didn’t need to tell Will to follow as they both ran out of the office, towards his car.

Strahm had his small emergency light strobing as he slammed the gas out of the parking garage. All checkpoints opened their gates in time for him to blast past them, revving the engine as the siren blared.

“It’s an hour away. We can make it under forty minutes, if traffic allows,” Strahm muttered.

Will turned to the back of the car, noting the shotgun and bulletproof vests ready to go. “Did they sight Linds or the suspect?”

“No. But Kerry had just arrived at the scene. The engine was still warm. Backup is on the way, but it’s a remote location. We may be the first ones after Kerry. Hopefully she doesn’t try to be a hero.”

“No promises,” Will bit her lip. “How did Kerry handle Lindsay’s kidnapping?”

Strahm crossed several lanes to turn down the nearest exit. His aggressive driving was almost as bad as hers. “Not good, but not bad. She’s kept her head despite it all. More than I have,” Strahm frowned to himself. 

They roared down ninety five south, cars getting out of their way as they stayed in the left lane, making decent time. 

“What’s the significance of Noland Park?” Will didn’t know Lindsay Perez very well. Not like Strahm.

“Not sure. But Lindsay grew up in D.C. Probably some college girlfriend and her used to hike there. Kerry would probably know more.” 

“Yeah. Maybe.” Unease crept into Will. She tried dialing Kerry’s cell, with only the ringing and the voicemail as her answer. “Kerry’s not picking up.”

“That’s not a good sign.” The engine growled as Strahm pressed harder on the gas. They sailed further down the black evening pavement. For the rest of the trip, they drove in silence.

The highway lights faded as they turned onto private, rural country roads. The trees surrounded them, bouncing back the high beams of Strahm’s car with ominous bark and the occasional glowing green eyes of a raccoon. 

They had to slow down once the roads started curving. Sharp lefts and rights, along with the urgent need to get to the destination had Will fidget as Strahm pushed his vehicle’s suspension to the limit. They hopped bumps and potholes, the vehicle silent with its emergency lights long turned off. They wanted to get the drop on the Heart Stealer, if they still had surprise on their side.

They first saw Ally’s car and Will leaned forward, her seat belt pressing into her neck and chest. And further down… was Lindsay’s car. 

Strahm parked the car beside Ally’s and the two of them got out. Strahm pulled out the bullet proof vests, tossing one heavily over to Will who caught the dense kevlar with an ‘oof.’ Fastening the black vest over his shirt, Strahm pulled out the shotgun, checking the chamber before cocking it. Will tightened the vest around her torso, throwing her coat over it and pulled her Smith & Wesson. 

It was a cold winter night. Most of the trees were bare, save for the pine. No insects sounded. The distant smell of wood burning sent Will on high alert and on edge. 

The hoot of an owl had her look up, tensing. 

They looked inside Allison Kerry’s car, nothing abnormal to note. They walked further to the trailhead, where the large roofed billboard and the box holding the registry for hikers was out. The book’s pages fluttered in the breeze, a pencil holding the book open to a specific page.

Will and Strahm exchanged glances before Strahm held the page down, showing what was written. 

Off hunting. Foraging for Lindseed. 

-A.K. 21:50

“Rather obvious,” Strahm muttered before closing the book. He raised his weapon. “Be on high alert, until we have Allison and Lindsay on sight. We don’t want to shoot them by accident.”

Will nodded, letting him take the lead. 

A crack broke through the silence and Will felt her gut sink. She threw Strahm a nervous look. He looked white as a sheet and it wasn’t because of the moonlight. A distant scream, feminine and angry, had the two of them sprinting further into the forest.

Will heard her heavy breathing as branches snagged in her hair and clothes. She pushed through, following as Strahm sprinted ahead. He powered past jutting trees and jumped over fallen trunks. Will kept up with him easily, his larger size blasting back obstacles that she could hurdle over.

“Let her go!” Allison’s voice broke through their sprint. Strahm skidded to a halt, Will face planted into his back. “Turn around!” 

Ally’s voice was to their right. They treaded through thorny branches, pushing through the thick piles of leaves, the sound of their approach loud with the hissing of dried vegetation and the crackle of breaking twigs. 

They broke through a clearing, the moonlight illuminating a man with his face distorted, knife pressed into Lindsay’s neck. Allison had her pistol trained on the assailant but couldn’t get a clear shot.

Strahm and Will went to Allison’s back. “FBI, drop your weapon,” Strahm snapped, stepping next to Ally and pointing the barrel of the shotgun at the man.

The assailant laughed. “You going to blast both of us, Peter? How foolish. I knew you’d be this way. Reckless. Impulsive. Angry. Predictable.”

“Shoot him, Ally,” Lindsay choked before the knife pressed deeper into her neck. Her lips were shut tight, her eyes wide with fear. 

As they stood for long seconds, Will realized Lindsay was glowing. Bright blue light emitted off of her, as if she was covered in glow-in-the-dark paint. “Why Lindsay?” Will asked, hoping to distract the man. “When did you give your heart to her?”

The man cocked his head to the side. “She smiled at me and I knew we had a connection. But then she slept with this whore. That’s why I reached out to you, Peter. You understand. You loved her, too. But she never saw either of us.”

Despite herself, her eyes flickered to Allison. They had gotten back together? She moved to Allison’s opposite side, wondering if she could make a clean shot to the man’s face or if it would be too risky.

“You’re wrong,” Strahm narrowed his eyes. Sirens were sounding in the distance. Backup had arrived. “Lindsay and I were never like that.”

“Lies. You love her. I see the way you look at her.”

“You’re right. I love her. We all love her. You’re going to break more than my heart, if you hurt her. She’s got two parents that love her. A brother. Friends. Don’t do this.” Strahm kept his shotgun pointed at the two of them but Will knew he wouldn’t pull the trigger. His finger wasn’t even past the guard. It was because the blast radius would kill Lindsay, if he fired.

Lindsay threw her head back, headbutting the man in the face. Allison made a shot. The explosion of the gun made Will’s ears ring but she charged forward, ramming into the suspect to get him away from Lindsay.

Will could feel the man struggle underneath her. She was straddling him, trying to pin his arms down. She could feel warm sticky blood on her hands. But the way he thrashed, it was clear he wasn’t injured badly.

“Will!” Strahm was heading over to her but she felt the man lift her off of him and push her back. She tumbled and returned to her feet promptly, ready to charge him.

The pistol that appeared in his hand took her off guard.

The red white flash of the gunpowder followed by a feeling of being punched in the shoulder, hard , made her fall backwards. 

Pain. The worst pain she had felt in a long time dug its jagged teeth into her shoulder. She touched it, realizing she was bleeding. She tried to keep her breathing even but she was already going into shock. Fuck No. No.

Is it fatal? No. No, it can’t be. But it hurts so fucking much .

She felt her head hit the dirt. Strahm was over her, pressing into her wound with his palms. She let out a gasp of pain. “You’re all right, Will. You’re all right.” His voice was low and steady. His eyes were wide but his words soothing. His hands were hot on her cooling shoulder.

“We got him,” Kerry called out, the distant jingle of handcuffs made Will relax. 

We got him. That’s all that matters. She was taking slower breaths now.  

“He… going anywhere?” Will whispered, not able to sit up and look.

“Yeah. He’s down. You’re okay.” Strahm looked sallow, lips pressed, steam billowing out of his nostrils. “Will, can you get up?”

“I’ll try,” she felt so feeble all of a sudden. In all her years in law enforcement, she had been punched, kicked, scratched, and cut. She had fallen several stories into a dumpster. She had survived broken bones, fractures, and plenty worse from Frank. She had lived through being beaten within an inch of her life. She had been punched in the face by her own partner. But she had never been shot before. “This is no joke,” she whispered. “Getting shot sucks.”

Strahm burst out a small laugh. “Yeah. It does.” She heard the rip of fabric, feeling her shoulder being wrapped with a tight pull of the fabric. Sometimes, she’d see Peter’s face over her. And sometimes, she’d see nothing but black. “That should hold you off. Come on, I’ll help you.” She was pulled up to the ground gingerly, her ears ringing and her lungs burning. But she managed to stay on her feet. She watched Lindsay and Allison on each side, holding the Heart Stealer in place. Their faces were grave. 

“Hey, Strahm,” Allison called out. “Let Lindsay go with her to the ambulance. I need you here to make sure this asshole doesn’t pull anything.”

Strahm nodded, giving Will a sad smile. “We’ll talk later. Get that shoulder checked out.”

Must not be bad. But fuck, it hurts. Will nodded as Lindsay came up to her, taking her hand with a squeeze. “You okay, Linds?”

“Better, now that you all came. Come on, I’ll lead the way.” The blue fluorescence on her arms and legs had begun to fade. “I don’t know about you, but I want to get the hell out of these woods and have a stiff drink.”

Mark Hoffman

He didn’t think he’d have to worry about something like this again, so soon. With Knox, his ex-wife and son had stepped up and taken care of the funeral business. It took his death for them to suddenly want to be involved with the last vestiges of his memory. But Mark didn’t complain, as it let him grieve in peace and took the burden of planning a funeral off his shoulders.

But now, he sat on Angie’s couch staring at the booklets of coffins and the pamphlets of funeral floral arrangements and he had no idea what to do with any of them. This should be Angelina’s call . But she was in her bedroom, lying in her bed, refusing to get up.

But Peter Acomb’s body was on the way back from Iraq. Scheduled to be delivered to the funeral home the next day. He would be prepared for an open casket.

God, help me.

Hoffman leaned back, trying to think of what Acomb had been like. A goofball. A total nerd. Overall, not a bad guy. He never paid much attention to the man, so long as he never made Angie cry. Which he never did. The man, despite being a goof, had loved his sister with all his heart. He hadn’t been a close friend with the man. But Mark missed him. He missed how happy Angie had been with him. 

He buried his face in his hands, frustrated by the way the world had turned out. Angelina didn’t deserve all this loss. She had so much love to give. There was only so much he could give her, as her brother. 

She had wanted kids. To start a family of her own. She talked about it all the time. 

He sighed when he tried to flip through wreaths. Lily’s? Carnations? Fuck, he didn’t know. Will had just returned to Quantico, so he didn’t bother calling her to let her know what had happened. He’d give it another day. He figured she’d want to attend the funeral, at least. But he’d give her some time to get settled in, before another death had her dropping everything to come help out the Hoffman siblings. 

Two deaths, in the same month. He sometimes wondered why they had such rotten luck. His cell rang, saving him from his thoughts. He recognized Matthews’ number. “Hoffman,” he answered.

“Need you at the station.” Matthews sounded weary, unusual compared to his normally braggadocio demeanor. He thought he heard some high pitched voice followed by a hush.

“You got someone with you?”

“Yeah. Daniel.”

Hoffman blinked. “Jane left him at the station?”

“Yeah, can you believe it? Told her it’s not a good place for him. But she just walked off. My lawyer thinks this will be good for getting partial custody again. But I can’t get anything done because of it. The boys think it’s fucking hilarious. But that fuckboy Gibson got wind of me endangering a child and he’s writing me up for it. Could use some back up.”

Hoffman would have said no but the excuse to get away from staring at another somber bundle of flowers had him already on his feet. “I’m on the way.”

He hung up and looked over to the master bedroom. He went and gently hit his knuckles against the wooden door. “Ange?”

She didn’t respond. He opened the door, entered the dark room and sat on the bed. He put his hand on the shadowy head, feeling her hair. “I need to head back to the precinct. You going to be okay?”

“Yeah,” she whispered, not sounding okay.

“I’ll come right home once my shift’s done.”

“Okay,” she whispered before her shoulders began to shake. She sniffled. Mark turned to the nightstand, pulling tissues from the box and holding it in front of her face. She took them and began blowing her nose. He noticed there were crumpled up used tissues all over the comforter and floor. 

He went and freshened her glass of water, knowing she would be dehydrated from all the tears. There was nothing more he could do, besides be there for her and wait.

Time was the only way she would heal. 

He, too, felt random waves of sadness whenever he thought of Knox. But he had to push it down, for Angie’s sake. She needed him right now. She needed her big brother.

He went to the precinct, his thoughts hazed and his mood dark. 

When he was back at work, he could hear the kid crying as he approached their office. But at least this kid was likely crying over shit he didn’t understand. These were tears he could handle. He opened the door, sighing in relief when he saw Matthews holding a chubby blond six year old in his arms, asking, “What’s wrong, little man, don’t cry. It was just an ouchie.”

Seeing his partner in such a domestic setting, had him struggling to suppress a grin. Hoffman went to his desk, digging through the top drawer, pulling out the stash of candy he kept. He pulled out a sucker and held it out to the kid.

Instantly, Daniel Matthews halted his wails, looking at Hoffman with wide blue eyes, fascinated by the red tootsie pop. “You can have this if you behave,” he told the kid and the boy nodded his head obediently. “There you go.” 

The kid struggled to pull the paper off the candy and stuck it in his cheek, drool dripping down his chin. “Shoulda known you’d have something good in your desk, you fat fuck,” Eric sounded exhausted and relieved. “Thanks.”

If the kid wasn’t there, he’d have flipped his middle finger at the prick. 

“Daddy,” the boy sounded so shy and vulnerable. “I love you.”

Seeing Eric Matthews melt at his son’s words, it made Hoffman feel a flutter in his chest. He smiled, sad, wondering what it would be like to have something like that. The thought of Will full of domestic bliss like a 1950s housewife appeared in his mind, the idea ludicrous, and it popped out of his imagination fast as a flash.

A knock on their office followed by a uniformed rookie opening the door made both men turn. “Hey, boys,” she threw a thumb over her shoulder. “We have some guy here for Matthews. Name of Michael Marks. Says he has information.”

“Send him in,” Matthews took a seat, bouncing Eric on his thigh. 

A tall, lean man with dark features entered, the guy looking shifty as he locked eyes with Hoffman before flashing them to Matthews. “Matthews.”

“What do you got for me, Mike?” 

“Information. On a fire over at Chinatown. I have it on good authority it was an inside job. Hired man named Obi Tate. He’s good at covering his tracks. Figured you’d like to know.”

Matthews nodded, moving Daniel onto the other leg. “I’ll look into it. If it’s good, I’ll send you something nice.”

“Oh, it’s solid. And I expect payment soon.”

Hoffman decided to work on some paperwork, not finding this informant interesting.

“Got anything on what’s been going on with K2K? Got some boys here who could use the help.”

“Not much. But everyone’s on edge. Though there hasn’t been another bombing in a while, word on the street is K2K is ready for retaliation, now that the yakuza have backed down.”

Hoffman’s eyes darted to the guy. Who was this informant? He looked plain, middle class, educated. Not someone who would get much street cred to know the ins and outs of the crime world. 

“Same time next month?” Matthews was rushing the informant out. Daniel was beginning to get restless, wanting to be let loose to wander on his small feet.

“Yeah. Next month.” Marks got to his feet and turned. “Remember. Expect my payment next week. Or I’m done sharing the juice.”

“Yeah yeah, you’ll get your money.” Matthews waved the man off.

“Who’s he?” Hoffman asked, once the guy left with a shut of the door.

“Some creep I caught for possession a while back. In exchange for not charging him, he feeds me info he hears while playing wannabe badass at the underground raves. Mostly, it’s crap. But sometimes, he gives something useful. Fuck, I need a cigarette. Will you watch Eric while I go grab a smoke? Jane won’t let me smoke in front of him.”

Hoffman opened his mouth to say, ‘hell no’, but Daniel was already walking over to him, giving a shy smile while his dad escaped the office.

Hoffman leaned back, letting out a breath. The boy kept watching him. “Daniel, how’s it going?”

“You’re big. I bet you’re really strong,” the boy gushed, jumping up and down, flexing his fingers in the air. 

“I get by.” Hoffman didn’t know how to be around children, unless it was on a case. Rarely, the kids wanted to talk to him. “You eat your veggies, you’ll be big and strong like me.”

“Really? Do you eat a lot of veggies?”

“Uh, yeah,” Hoffman lied. Potatoes were a vegetable. Technically.

“Okay! Can I have more candy? Pleease?” The kid drew out the please. 

Hoffman pursed his lips, not wanting to feel the warm and fuzzy emotions that were spreading through heart. “All right. But you gotta brush your teeth when you get home, all right?”

“Okay!” The kid looked like he already had plenty of sugar, mouth stained red, bouncing and spinning, cackling with glee. Hoffman took out another candy, some chocolate wrapped up. 

“Here.” The kid seized the wrapped goods and started stomping over to his father’s desk, climbing into the chair with his legs dangling over the side. The kid liked to talk to himself, muttering, “I gots some candy. I’m gonna eats all of it!”

Hoffman smirked, looking back at his paperwork. The kid was all right, in his book.

Allison Kerry

“You think you’re more worthy of her love? You whore,” the Heart Stealer spat at her feet. Kerry stepped back, avoiding the glob from hitting her boots. She lowered her gaze at the prick. It took all her self control not to kick the tip of her boot into his face, wanting nothing more than to teach this son of a bitch who he was dealing with. 

Thankfully, Strahm was there, diffusing the situation with a simple dirty glare down at the perp. “You’re just adding to the charges. You have the right to remain silent. I suggest you use that right. It’s for your own good.”

The Heart Stealer looked to be in his late twenties. Caucasian. Blue eyes. Dark hair. He was short in stature, dressed in jeans and a hoodie. Regardless of his unimpressive features, there was an aura around him that gave Kerry the creeps. She didn’t like being alone in the woods with the guy.

She could only imagine what Lindsay had gone through. She closed her eyes briefly, reliving the moment when she thought she had shot Lindsay. She had made the shot. Willingly risked the woman she loved.

It had worked out, but what if it hadn’t? 

She would never have forgiven herself. She wondered if Lindsay would forgive her for gambling with her life like that? Could she forgive herself?

Her knees were getting tight. She squatted down to the ground, feeling them pop. She covered her eyes with her fingers, containing the feelings of terror and relief all rolling through her. She shivered.

“Kerry?” Strahm sounded concerned at her back.

“I’m fine. Just. Glad it’s almost over.” She straightened back up, brushing at pieces of lint on her pants. It was too dark to actually see any. She was just nervous. Anxious to get back to Lindsay.

She had so much to tell her.

Just before Lindsay had been taken, she had allowed herself to be swayed once again by her. They had spent the night at her apartment. 

In the end, she couldn’t even be loyal to Eric. 

Yet, despite this, she truly believed Lindsay was the one she wanted to be with. After almost losing her, she knew she would never have recovered if Lindsay had died. She decided, then and there, that she would end things with Eric. That if Lindsay would take her, she would be hers, forever.

When the arresting squad arrived, armed to the teeth with kevlar, batons, and various rifles, she could relax. 

“You can go,” Strahm told her, eyes full of awareness that Kerry always felt unsettling. “I’ll look after him. Go be with Lindsay.”

“Thank you,” Kerry whispered before jogging towards the trailhead.

 

Notes:

A/N: Slowly but surely, we're getting through this arc. Soon, we'll get to the movie content.

Chapter 33: Pre-SAW: What Brutality?

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Wilhelmina Maddox

“Mark, I’m coming home.”

“That’s great,” there was joy underneath his steady words. Relief, even. “It’s all over the news. So you finally caught the bastard, huh?”

“Yeah.”

“There were reports of some injuries. You all right?”

“Peachy.” She forced a smile on the phone as she sat in the hospital waiting room. In front of her, Lindsay had a shallow cut on her neck and was scheduled for a long itinerary of psychological evaluations but was not the one that needed ten stitches and a blood transfusion. Despite the doctor’s advice, she had insisted on walking out as soon as they looked her over. As a compromise, she had to sit there for another fifteen minutes, for observation. Around her, the coughing of waiting patients and a voice over the intercom, paging a doctor, filled the air. “I… now I’m fine, so don’t worry but-,”

“That’s not a good start. What happened?”

“I was shot.”

A long pause, followed by, “I’m on my way to the airport.”

She sat up straight. “What? No! I’ll be flying out in two days tops. I just need to finish filing the case files. Closing it for good. Give a debrief. The usual.” She felt a flutter in her chest, hearing Mark so worried. But she didn’t need him to drop everything when she was perfectly capable of coming home by herself.

“Where were you shot?”

“The shoulder. Grazed, really. It was only a .22. But I did lose a decent amount of blood.”

“That’s not making this sound any better.” He sounded half-frustrated, half-afraid. “You could have died.” There was a low whine, thickening his voice.

Will knew, after Knox, that Mark would be more sensitive to death. It was why she wanted to hold as much of the brutal truth back as possible. She swallowed back a smart comeback, and instead, softened her voice. “Mark, I’m okay. I didn’t die. It’s all over now. And from now on, I won’t be getting into any shenanigans for a while. Just finishing up here. And when I get back, maybe you can kiss my wound and make it better?” She tried to sound teasing.

She nervously waited for him to respond. “Maybe we can compare scars.” There was a sudden heat in his voice. All seemed forgiven.

Will couldn’t help but laugh. “Do gunshot wounds turn you on, Mark?”

“You turn me on. When you get home, I’ll be spoiling you rotten, Wilhelmina.”

She groaned. He had begun using her full name when he wanted to be affectionate. She wasn’t a fan. “Anything going on back home? What’ve I missed?”

There was a long pause that set her on high alert. “Mark?”

“Peter Acomb was killed in action. We got the news yesterday.”

“Oh my God,” she sat up straight. Lindsay and Allison both shot her surprised glances. She covered the mouthpiece of her flip phone to mouth, “Peter Acomb was killed.” She returned to Mark. “But - oh, no. How is Angelina?”

Allison jumped up and sat in the seat over with Will, pressing her ear against the other side of the phone. 

“Not good. She’s not eating. She can’t get out of bed. I’ve been checking in on her. Trying to get her to get up every few hours.” Hoffman paused again. “It’ll be good, having you and Kerry back here. I think Ange needs her friends here. Something to distract her.”

“Yeah, of course,” Will felt her eyes sting. She hadn’t known Peter Acomb well but he was - had been - a kind man. “I’ll fly up as soon as I can.”

“I know you will. Pass the message to Kerry.”

“Already have,” Allison spoke up.

Hoffman was silent. Then, “Good to know. Call me before you’re flying out.”

“Okay. Take care, Mark. I love you.”

“Love you, too.” He hung up first.

Will let out a deep breath. Her head was spinning all over again. Mark and Angelina both experienced grave losses so suddenly. She rubbed her temple. She tried not to feel pity for them. But she wanted to do something, to help. She wasn’t sure what she could do, though. Loss never came easy.

Angelina, from what Mark had told her of how she handled the death of their parents, would take much more time to get back to normal. Mark had bounced back in less than a week, albeit she wasn’t sure if he wasn’t just forcing himself to go through the motions. But for Angelina… Will knew she would need extra care and attention.

“We’ll look after her,” Ally quipped. “Take her out to brunch. We’ll make sure she gets plenty of distractions. Get her out of her apartment. I’ve done my fair share of grieving.” Ally tucked strands behind her ear. “And I know how it usually goes down. At some point, she’ll need to start purging her possessions, to wash her hands of it. That’s the hardest part. We’ll need to be there for her when she does that.”

Will nodded. She knew Ally was someone who thought five steps ahead in times of crisis. “Yeah. We’ll be there for her, when she needs us.”

For the rest of the night, they sat in silence, thinking of Angelina and Peter Acomb.

 

“It was a pleasure,” Strahm, freshly shaven and with a full night’s sleep, looked reborn and downright charming as he smiled down at Will. “Have a safe flight.”

“Thanks,” Will slung her purse over her shoulder, pulling her carryon closer to the gate. “Appreciate you walking me to the gate.”

“Let’s make a habit out of it,” he smirked. “You did good work. You and Allison, both.”

“Well, you were certainly the teacher. I’ve learned a lot from you. I wouldn’t turn down another opportunity in the future. But I’ve neglected the MPD long enough. It’s time to get back to my roots.”

Strahm smiled, lashes framing his blue eyes in a way that made Will appreciate the ruggedness of his face. She felt guilty admiring his features, so she looked away. She blamed the attraction on her being separated from Mark for too long.

“Good luck, Will,” Strahm held his hand out. She took it, feeling the warmth of his shake.

“Same for you - ack,” she felt herself being pulled into a tight hug, smelling his aftershave, the sandalwood tickling her nose. She stiffened briefly before returning the hug.

“You’re a good friend. An excellent detective. I’m sure whatever is in store for the future, you’ll be charging in head first. Stay safe. Don’t be a stranger,” Strahm pulled from the hug. “Hope that was appropriate.”

“It - was.” Will refused to read more into the hug. “We’re friends, after all.” She emphasized this, wanting it to be clear. “Like you and Lindsay.”

“Of course. Give my warmest regards to Hoffman. And my condolences. To both him and his sister for their losses.” 

Will nodded. “I will. She said her goodbye to Special Agent Peter Strahm, wondering if they would ever cross paths again. A part of her hoped so but another part could detect the ulterior motives from him. She shook her head.

Man, I can be so full of myself. She was probably reading too much into it. I’ve been trying to read men so much, I’m seeing things that aren’t there. She stepped down the gate, looking forward to taking a nap on the flight home.

Peter Strahm

He knew he had crossed the line, sneaking in that hug with Will. But a part of him knew he would have regretted it if he had let her go without doing so. The case had taught him one thing: he needed to be more assertive. He had been too passive with his methods. When he had hunches, he held himself back, not wanting to go down the wrong direction. He reviewed every memory he had of the Heart Stealer case, wondering if he had done things with more courage and daring, would more lives have been saved? If he had agreed to the first gut feeling he had, that his team would be targeted, would Lindsay not have been kidnapped?

He believed so. 

So he would make decisions that pushed him to be more aggressive with his impulses. And the first action was giving Will Maddox a hug goodbye. He rationalized, it was fine. They were friends. But he felt a twist in his stomach, that familiar pang of guilt he used to get whenever his mother would catch him stealing cookies from the cookie jar. 

Will was in a long term, committed relationship. He should have respected that.

Yet, no matter how he forced himself to express no animosity towards Mark Hoffman, it was there. A strong distrust. He didn’t believe the man was a good match for Will. 

Embedded in his ego, was the conviction that Will would be happier with someone less corrupt. Like you? He questioned himself. Yes. Me.

He did not enjoy dealing with his inner self, the self-serving id component of his personality. But he humored it this one time. 

And, in honest discourse with himself, concluded that he did not regret the affection he gave Will. A part of him felt empty as he watched her plane pull from the gate and head towards the runway. He waited until the plane took off, disappearing up into the sky, before he turned to walk back to the parking lot.

The closing of this case was bittersweet. The killer was locked away. His job was done. But that meant Will would be back in the city. And he, in Quantico.

His phone rang. He recognized Lindsay’s number. “What’s up, Linds?”

“I’m hungry. Could go for some pancakes. What do you say?”

He smiled. “I can eat.”

He walked off. He wouldn’t dwell too long. Life went on. In the end, Lindsay was safe. Together, they would live to fight another vicious serial killer. And he was confident that the next would not be anywhere near the headache as the Heart Stealer.

 

Mark Hoffman

“Angie,” Mark had the takeout boxes unpacked, one of every item on the Chinese takeout menu spread around her kitchen island counter. “Please. Just one bite.”

She stood, in the same shirt she had worn since five days ago, looking glumly at the fried rice. “Okay,” she whispered, taking a plate and dispassionately dropping a spoonful of rice onto it. She sat at the bar stool, glumly forcing the spoonful in her mouth, chewing with no enthusiasm. She swallowed and tears began to fall. “It’s just - it feels wrong to eat. When Peter’s-,” she was beginning to weep again, her pretty face all ugly from her crying..

Mark turned and grabbed paper towels, holding them out to her. “Ange, Peter wouldn’t want you to be like this.”

This only made her wails worse. He quickly backpedaled. “Angie - at least - Peter, he died a war hero. He’s dead, but he died a good death.”

Angelina stopped crying, and for a moment, Mark believed he had said the right thing.

Until he saw the rage in her face. He then realized he had royally and unequivocally fucked up. 

“You think,” she hiccuped, “that Peter died a good death? What the fuck does that mean? That it’s okay he’s dead, because he died in a war? How can you fucking say that?!” She screamed, throwing her plate to the ground. The porcelain shattered and Angelina began sobbing violently, clinging to the counter. 

Mark kept his mouth shut and went to grab the dustpan. Angelina rarely got so worked up. But he forgave her. He understood this wasn’t really who she was. She was just going through something he couldn’t imagine.

He tried to imagine a world where Will had died. And he couldn’t stomach imagining it for long. He wished he could go back in time and shove a sock down his gullet. How could he say something like that to Angie?

His thoughts went to Knox and he then understood why. 

Of all the ways to go, rotting in a trash filled apartment with your brains spattering the wall, it was one of the worst ways imaginable to go. Hoffman swept up the shards of plate and threw them away.

“Angie,” Hoffman offered the other plate. “You still need to eat.”

She sniffed and snapped, “Just get out, Mark. I don’t want to talk to you. Get out!”

His chest tightened. Angie never spoke to him like this before. He wanted to hold his arms out and hug his sister. “I’m sorry, Angie.”

“Just - please,” she was blinking rapidly, eyes flowing with water. “I need air. You’re smothering me. I just want to be alone. Okay? I’ll be alright. I just - want to be alone. And take this out. I won’t eat it, I’ll just throw it all away.”

Hoffman stood there, waiting for her to continue. She instead began to sob into her paper towel. “All right, Ange,” he softly spoke. “I’ll head home. I’ll give you a few days.”

“Thank you,” she choked in between violent shaking. Her face was splotched. Her cheekbones were poking out of her gaunt face. Hoffman needed her to eat. But he couldn’t push her.

He gathered most of the takeout, putting them in the brown paper sack. He left at least one container of fried rice, hoping she would at least take a few more bites before she threw it away. He left her apartment, making sure the deadbolt was engaged before he walked away. He walked to his car, dialing for Will. She had returned the day before, but had been busy with unpacking and getting caught up at the office. Her cell kept ringing until it went to voicemail.

He sighed. It was a Friday night. She was likely still at the precinct. He wondered if he could go to her office. Just to not be alone. 

But he knew he didn’t need to bother her. He decided to head to Larry’s. Have a few drinks. Try to not think about all the shit that was going wrong.

He paused. No. There was something else he could do. He started the car and headed westside, towards the abandoned steelworks factory. He had some old business he needed to attend to.

The place was secluded. Nothing out of the ordinary. He forgot the last time he had been there, which wasn’t good. 

It meant that he may have a mess he’d have to clean up.

He grabbed the giant paper bag, getting out of his Crown Vic. He marched over towards the big rusted yellow door.

TRESPASSERS WILL BE PROSECUTED was faintly read on the old sign. Hoffman took out the key, an old remnant from Rosello. This property, though abandoned now, had belonged to the mob boss. The city still hadn’t realized the property was effectively up for grabs. Perks of the bastard’s many aliases. 

He entered, taking a right and entering an adjacent room. He walked past the various tools and dust covered saws, walking down a narrow corridor. He stopped at the end of the hall, where a heavy steel door remained. He knocked.

“You alive?” He waited a long pause.

A low moan made him smile cruelly. The bastard was resilient, he gave him that.

 

Eric Matthews

“I’m sorry, Eric. But I think it’s best if we end it. For good, this time.”

He leaned back, looking at Allison, at a loss of words. “What happened down there?”

Allison looked away, eyes tight with distress. She was clenching her jaw. “It’s just - I don’t think we’re good for each other. We haven’t been, for a long time.” She looked at him with pity. He hated that.

He lit a cigarette and blew it towards her. “Yeah, well best of fucking luck then,” he grumbled to himself. He wouldn’t say his heart was breaking. It was already ripped to pieces, eaten, and shit out a long time ago.

“Think about our careers. It’s not good for us, being together, still.”

“That’s horse shit.” He pulled the cigarette from his lip and let in a sharp breath. He knew he should have kept his mouth shut. But he was so fucking tired of the women in his life bending him over and screwing him. He pointed his cigarette, between his main and middle finger, toward her. “Yeah, your career. Cause that’s all that matters to you, huh?” He shook his head, sneering. “No wonder you’re such a good cop. You can just do whatever you want, cause you got nothing to lose. It’s not like you've been married. Or have a family to go home to. So this is all you’ve got. I gave up everything for you.” He took a puff and angrily jabbed the cigarette into the ash tray. “Get the fuck out of here.”

She didn’t linger. She stormed out, slamming the door behind her. 

He fiddled with the folder on his desk, pretending he was reviewing the documents. He didn’t even register the words he was reading. He was just pissed.

He jumped to his feet, needing to stretch his legs.

He stormed out and went for a walk. A long walk.

It was beginning to snow. Even though he hadn’t worn a heavier jacket, he was burning up. His fingers itched. 

He heard a car slow down beside him. He turned to glare at the asshole that was bothering him. He recognized Daniel Rigg in the driver’s seat of the patrol car.

“Matthews, what’re you doing out here, man? It’s below freezing.”

“I’m fine,” he clipped, continuing his walk.

“Come on, man, get in. You’ll die out here. I’m on homeless duty. Rather be sparing you of hypothermia, though.”

Matthews stopped, rubbing his nose. “Yeah, that sucks.” Rounding up the bums to keep them from turning to popsicles was a pretty awful gig. Daniel Rigg, looking like he was getting off duty, looked up at him with friendliness. His toes were getting numb. 

He decided he’d take the guy up on his offer. 

“Got anywhere to be?” Rigg asked when he slid into the passenger side. The car pulled away from the curb. 

“Whatever bar’s got the cheapest booze.”

“Sure. My treat. One of those days, huh?”

“You can say that. More like one of those fucking years.”

Rigg made a noise in agreement. “Sounds like you’ve been getting shit from all fronts.”

“Yeah.” Matthews hardly worked with Rigg. But he knew Jane and Tracy went way back. At first, he felt distrust tighten his neck. Whatever I say, he’ll tell his wife. And Jane will just hear it through the grapevine. But he always thought the guy was all right. Hell, he was about to buy him some drinks. “Just hard. The divorce. Everything.”

“I hear you.”

“And after losing it all,” his thoughts went to Kerry. When did it all get so fucked up? “You find out that everything you gave up for was never yours to begin with.”

He felt Rigg cast a glance in his direction. He could practically hear the man’s curiosity. Thankfully, he didn’t say anything after that.

It was one of the few things he was grateful for.

Rigg took them far from the central part of the city. The urban sprawl of gas stations, strip bars, and liquor stores were a relief with their neon lights. When Rigg parked the squad car by the nearest bar, the two men got out and entered the dive. 

Matthews basked in the stale smoke and musky smell of old booze. They took a spot far from the pool tables and people, in the corner part of a bar where the bartender approached them for their order. 

Matthews drank and drank a lot. Back to back he pounded back tequila, wanting that agave nectar to soothe his bitter pride. “So what’s new with you, Rigg?” Matthews was warm and feeling friendlier now that the alcohol was doing its job. He almost felt happy.

“Just got promoted to SWAT Commander.”

“And you’re rounding up bums?”

“Grissom’s call. Anyone who was free. I got the short end of the stick, but it happens. Still, I’m not complaining. I got what I wanted.” Rigg’s smile was small but genuine.

Matthews nodded, forcing a grin through a pang of envy. He punched Rigg in the shoulder playfully. “Atta boy.”

“Tracy’s pissed, though.” Rigg took a deep drink. “She wants me to get desked. Says it’s too dangerous to play ‘hero’ all the time.”

“What does she know?” Matthews griped, reaching for the bottle to wet his glass but finding his hands slippery. He dropped the tequila bottle, slow to pick it up. 

When did things get so hard to pick up?

“All right,” the bartender growled, “he’s had enough. Best take him home, Officer.”

Matthews got to his feet, realizing the world was spinning. Shit. He had a bit too much.

He lurched and stumbled out of the bar, hearing Rigg call out to him. He needed fresh air.

The winter wind stung his face but felt real nice when he vomited by the front door, nearby walkers gagging and scurrying away from him. He didn’t think about where he was or what he was doing.

He just wanted to get to the car and go home.

“Eric!” He heard Rigg’s voice again and he turned, seeing multiple Riggs jogging towards him. “Slow down, man.”

“J-just get me home,” he pulled out his pack of cigarettes and put one in his mouth. 

“Sure thing,” Rigg looked fine. Maybe he hadn’t drank as much.

He hadn’t been paying much attention earlier.

“Excuse me?” A man’s voice made him turn. He saw what looked like a camera. He could see the black foam of a microphone being pushed into his face. “Officer Matthews.” 

“Not now,” he barked, hating reporters.

“Is it true that you broke a suspect’s jaw with a flashlight last week?”

“No fucking comment,” his head suddenly hurt. 

“There’s rumors you are using brutality against your suspects.”

Something in him snapped. He looked up and glared into the many eyes of the perp. He felt hatred, like hot fire, rising up his chest and through his throat. “What brutality?” He felt his cigarette fall from his mouth. He took a step forward, quick and furious. “Let me tell you something.” He unclipped his holster fastener and took his gun out. He pointed it at the reporter. He would blast this fucker’s brains off. He didn’t give a fuck. “What brutality? What brutality?” He stepped closer, pressing the pistol inches from the bastard’s cheek. “Huh? WHAT BRUTALITY? WHAT?!” 

Time had slowed, the reporter’s mouth agape in terror as Matthews waited for the piece of shit to give him a reason to pull the trigger.

He felt himself being jerked back all of a sudden, knowing it was Rigg but not caring. Despite how fucked up he was, he knew he had just made things a whole lot worse. “Eric!” Rigg’s voice broke through and had him backpedaling. But it was too late. 

He knew it but he still turned away, suddenly ashamed. What have I done?

He put his gun away and went to the cop car. “Where’s my cigarette?” He wouldn’t look back up, at the camera or the man that he had just pointed his gun at. 

He hoped it wouldn’t be that bad. A part of him was hopeful that it wasn’t going to blow up in his face.

But he knew it was.

 

Notes:

A/N: Whew, I survived the holidays but barely. I seriously am not a fan of driving hundreds of miles all over the states. Sorry for the white noise last December. So, real talk. What do you all think of shorter chapters? My uploading would be more frequent. (It's how I'm able to update my other fics, by keeping their chapters barely a thousand words a chapter.)

If you're happy with the long chapters, I'll keep 'em nice and dense, but uploads will likely not be weekly. Maybe monthly, at the rate I'm currently writing. Each is about 17 - 20 pages on Google Docs currently.

Take care and happy new year!

Chapter 34: Pre-SAW: He Swore Revenge

Chapter Text

Angelina Acomb

When she heard Amazing Grace on the bagpipes, she felt herself collapse with sobs. Mark caught her, keeping her up on her feet as she buried her face into his shoulder and wailed underneath the roar of the hymn. She felt his arm press into her chest, protective of the folded triangle of the American flag that she loosely held, so she wouldn’t drop it.

She could still hear the pops of their rifles from the Three-Volley Salute. She wasn’t sure when the blasts would stop echoing. Besides Peter’s tombstone, their parents’ names gleamed in the sunlight on their markers to his left.

As Peter was lowered down into the ground, she wept harder. She wept for the loss of her husband, her parents, for everything. 

Mark stayed by her side long after most of the other mourners left. Despite the clear skies that morning, it was still deep winter. “Angie, it’s time,” Mark gently pulled her from the rectangular pit.

She turned, seeing Will and Allison, both who approached to hug her. 

“Let’s get you out of the cold, hon," Allison comforted gently.

Angelina felt a wave of overwhelming emotion. But he's here. Out here, in the cold ground.

But she knew there was nothing she could do but be led to the car.

She let them take her home. All three hovered over her, trying to help.

But she didn't want their help.

All she wanted was to collapse on her bed and just sleep forever. She wanted to stop feeling. To stop breathing.

Long days had passed. She felt like a leaf blowing in the wind.

She somehow managed to get to work. Food was constantly sent back, customers complained, and her supporting staff stepped in.

"Don't worry, Chef," Charles, her sous chef, would pat her shoulder when she would burn whatever she had in the frying pan. "You're pushing yourself too hard. You should head home early."

"I'm fine," she would feel anger bubble up whenever she was told to leave. She couldn't go back home. She would rather be anywhere but there. "I - I'll clean this up and start over."

She took the still smoking pan to the scullery as the dishwashers quickly sprayed their high pressured hoses over the sinks full of greasy plates.

"Hanging in there, Chef?" Seth Baxter gave her a half curled grin before nodding towards his station. "Happens to me, too."

She stared, confused. "What?"

"Forget I had the stove running," Baxter pulled at his beanie, scratching his forehead. "You okay?"

She blinked and nodded. "I'm fine." She turned to where freshly cleaned pots were and took one, returned to the kitchen, filled it with water, and set it on the gas burner.

"Chef!" Her line cook, Jared, called out to her. "We're behind on orders!"

She blinked, recognizing the line of waitress notes suspended above the center station and walked to the farthest slip to the right. "Two spaghetti, one BLT, and a salmon," she called out.

"Yes, Chef."

"I need back up with the garnish," shouted Charles and she joined him chopping vegetables and lining plates with them.

She felt bursts of focus, when she forgot about her life, but then the pang of memory would paralyze her, in the middle of her work.

She tried to shove it down. To just move on. To get through it all without falling apart to tears.

She was going fast.

The pot. She forgot she had the pot boiling.

"Where’s the pasta?" The shout made her jolt and lurch towards the pot. She was panicking. She grabbed the pot.

She slipped. 

She felt her feet slide faster than she could stop them, her grip on the frothing pot still tight.

She felt the scalding heat on her hand and the sharp sting of the back of her head.

She was on the floor, her left arm burned from her hand to her forearm and her head pounding.

She heard her colleagues curse and shout in surprise. Charles' face swarmed her vision. 

"Shit," she heard Seth's voice and she felt ice where her arm stung. She blinked through tears and sat up, groaning from the pain.

"Can you get up, Angelina?" Charles was pulling her, to get to her feet. "You're lucky you didn't burn your face. You need to get to the hospital."

She looked at her arm. It was bright red. Her skin felt violently itchy, as if a million ants were chewing at her flesh. 

It hurt like hell.

She grimaced as the pain amplified, never plateauing.

"I - urgh," she fell back. She wasn't feeling sorry for herself anymore. All she could feel was her arm.

"Hang in there, Chef. I'll drive ya to the hospital." It was Seth. "Let’s get you in the car. Can someone give me a hand?"

She felt a sharp coldness being pressed to her skin, the roughness of a towel-covered ice bag both solace and irritation.

Everyone was looking at her. Worried. Eyes were full of pity wherever she looked.

She hated it all.

She was careened, gingerly, into an old car that was full of trash and smelled of stale cigarettes. A Hawaiian bobblehead was fixed to the dashboard.

She leaned back in the passenger side and let out a groan, gripping her bundled arm.

"Want something for the pain?"

"Fuck," she grimaced. The burning sensation only got worse with each passing second. She felt as if she had rusty nails pressing deeper into the meat of her arm. "Sure."

"It's kind of heavy. Prescription grade."

She didn't fucking care. "Just - if it makes this stop. Yeah. Please." Her eyes were full of water as she looked at the dishwasher.

He had concern knitting his brow. He dug out of his pocket an orange cylinder of pills, uncapping and tapping out one before handing it to her. "Ain't got water, you're gonna have to swallow it dry." 

She took the small white circle and popped it in her mouth, forcing herself to put it down after four gulps. She doubled over and curled into a ball. "I've never felt so much pain." 

"Yeah, burns suck. Buckle up. I'll get you to the doc real quick."

He started the engine and tore out of his parking space, turning sharply onto the street. 

Long minutes elapsed. They had been caught in traffic. All she could focus on for what felt like an eternity, was keeping herself still as every nerve in her skin seared white hot.

"Ten minutes," Seth murmured. "How you holdin’ up?"

She closed her eyes and took a slow breath. Surprisingly, not that bad . "I'm hanging on."

He nodded. "Medicine kicking in?"

Now that she thought about it, her arm was nowhere near as bad as it had been. "I think so." She felt the same heaviness she had been feeling since Peter died, but with a grogginess that made her want to lean back and fall asleep. "I feel… weird."

She heard him laugh. "Yeah? Figured you'd have shit tolerance. I remember that feeling. Man, I'm jealous."

She turned to him, raising an eyebrow. "You want second degree burns?"

"Psh, nah, Chef. Just saying oxy is sweeter when it's your first time.:

"Oxy?" She registered that he was talking about oxycodone. "Why do you have a prescription?"

He smirked. "Uh, for real?"

She blinked, slowly. She began to realize that maybe Seth Baxter was part of a world she was completely separate from. She could already tell Mark would have not approved of the guy. "You a bad boy?" I can't believe I just said that.

He chuckled, blue eyes distant. "Oh, the baddest. We're here. Let's get you to the doc. Who knows, maybe later I'll show you just how bad I can be."

Matt Gibson

He finally had them.

He gripped the formal suspension notice in his hand, marched to Grissom's office, and plopped the documents onto his supervisor's desk.

"These are for Eric Matthews and Roger McCallister."

Grissom was leaning back in his chair, sipping through a straw from a McDonald's cup as his Big Mac was half eaten on his desk. There was a long pause as the sound of turbulent air crackled with ice. The man sure likes draining every last drop.

Gibson knew this was a power move. Whoever spoke first, lost. He kept staring, knowing no matter what Grissom said or tried, it was undisputed. 

Matthews, had royally fucked up so hard, it was already in the news.

Already, everyone who cared about their careers had distanced themselves from the hothead.

Eric Matthews, golden boy of the Metropolitan Police Department, and closest corrupt piece of shit to Mark Hoffman, was about to crash and burn.

That gun pointing stunt he pulled with the news reporter had been exactly what Gibson had prayed for. The bastard was finally going to be taken down a peg. Gibson almost enjoyed watching Matthews, on camera, point his weapon at the civilians, without a care in the world.

It was the perfect example of what was wrong with Homicide. It was a perfect example of what was wrong with the MPD. And finally, consequences would be dished out. The boy’s club was getting knocked down a couple of levels.

Gibson believed it was a sign that the whole festering tower was tumbling down, after this. And it was about time. He was the first to break the silence, impatient. “Internal Affairs has concluded their investigation with Detective McCallister. 

“As for Detective Eric Matthews, we recommend he be suspended without pay until the conclusion of the investigation of his alleged assault of a reporter and the supposed rumor that he pointed his weapon at two unarmed assailants. We will ensure we are thorough and focus on solid evidence before we make a conclusion on whether the case needs to be elevated.” He said this, sarcastically. The video was all the proof they needed. 

“You enjoying yourself, Gibson?” Grissom was in no mood to bond. 

“Frankly, yes,” Gibson nodded, stiffening his lip. “I meant it when I said I was going to clean up this crooked department.”

“If you’re here to preach, then get the fuck out of my office.”

He felt himself smirk. “Fine. IA’s going to be busy for the indefinite future. Just so you know.” He turned and left the office, feeling buzzed. He walked down the narrow passageways, cutting through the detective rows of offices. Ahead of him, the man of the hour walked out of the room where ‘Eric Matthews’ and ‘Mark Hoffman’ were neatly labeled on the doorplate.

Mark Hoffman’s stone face darkened at the sight of him. He closed the door behind him and stalked away. A loud yell through thin walls erupted. He heard the sound of shattered glass from the office Hoffman had just left.

Sounds like Matthews is redecorating. 

Gibson opted to go for the more level headed of the pair. “Hoffman!” He called out, knowing it was risky to pick a fight with him. But he was riding high. He felt invincible at that moment. And everyone was watching all the detectives in Homicide like hawks.

“What do you want?” Hoffman kept his face smooth but he could see the resentment in his curled lip.

“Just to talk to you, about Matthews.”

“Got nothing to say. I wasn’t there.”

“Yeah, but you’re his partner.” Gibson spat the words, finding his emotions had been boiling over. “And this is exactly what I mean about why you can’t take the law in your hands and abuse it. Consider this a warning.”

Hoffman looked around, cautious before turning to glare at Gibson. “You like to run your mouth, kid. But you’re way in over your head. I told you to back the fuck off.”

“And I told you,” he looked up at the man, adrenaline rushing through his veins. “That I was going to clean up the corruption here. McCallister. Matthews. They’re just the beginning. But you’re my main prize.”

Hoffman scoffed. And then he let out a low laugh.

“What’s so funny?” Gibson wanted to hear it.

“You’re so delusional. You think you’re in the right, taking down my men. You’re just taking down good cops that do what’s needed to get done to get a conviction. You’re just screwing the department and the city over that way. Get a clue, Gibson. Doing things by the book has never been how things operated. It’s a pipe dream. If you need the job done right, you’ve got to get down from your pedestal. Criminals will always play dirty. It’s all they know. And playing their game - it’s the only way to put them in their place.” 

Gibson shook his head. “No. No, you just gave up before trying. Look at Will. She does things the right way. And Kerry.”

“You don’t know shit about Will. And that’s cute. Damn, you are such a rookie.” Hoffman leaned forward and whispered, “And just so you know, for fucking over my men, I’ll make sure you get what’s coming to you.”

Gibson took a step back, furious. This son of a bitch just threatened him.

“Mark,” the feminine voice made them stop and turn. It was Maddox, striding up to the two of them with an eyebrow raised. “Gibson. Care to share what you two are whispering about like a pair of schoolgirls?” 

“Just complaining about the busted coffee pot in the break room,” Hoffman lied so easily, Gibson pitied Maddox. He knew those two had been dating for at least a year now.

“Oh, I heard about that. Guess that means we need to do a coffee run. Come on, I’ll let you drive.” She turned and paused. “You coming, Gibson?”

“He was just heading back to work,” Hoffman’s voice didn’t betray what Gibson knew: there was no way in hell Hoffman would be cool with Gibson tagging along as the third wheel. “The IA’s neck deep in dealing with Matthews.”

“I heard.” Maddox shook her head, looking genuinely sad. “I can’t believe it. Matthews? If I didn’t see the video, I wouldn’t have believed it.” 

Gibson stared, confused for a moment, until he realized that she likely had no clue what had been going on while she was working with the FBI for the past two years. It was the first time he had seen her in the office in months. And before she had left for Quantico, Matthews had still been relatively stable. He had been a practical boyscout, alongside Tapp and Sing. 

“It’s a shame,” Maddox continued, “I know the divorce was rough on him. I didn’t see it coming.”

Of course you didn’t. You weren’t here. But everyone else? Oh, everyone else had seen and turned a blind eye when it had been barreling towards them like a runaway train. 

“What’s your latest case?” Hoffman touched Maddox’s shoulder and gently steered her away from Gibson.

Their voices grew more distant as they walked away.

Gibson let out a small sigh. Poor Maddox. How could someone as sharp as her be so blind? He shook his head and went back to work.

 

Chapter 35: Pre-SAW: Holding Things For Friends

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Daniel Rigg

He needed to blow off some steam, so he went to the gym.

The room stank of sweat, feet, and antique rubber. 

Most of the cushions on the benches were torn from decades of use.

But he didn’t mind it. Lifting weights helped keep his mind off of things.

Like tonight. 

Of all the times to bring up sour talk, he hadn’t expected Tracy to do it on the rare Friday night he had off-duty. He was livid. He should have suspected something was up when he saw that she had prepared a full spread of all his favorite foods: a whole roasted chicken, mashed potatoes, collard greens, cheesy mac, and sweet potatoes. He had been several heaping bites in when Tracy brought up wanting him to get off SWAT. 

The food had instantly turned to rocks that got caught in his throat. 

Rigg let out an angry grunt as he pushed the steel bar over his chest, forcing hundreds of pounds into the air.

“You got it!” His spotter was a guy who happened to be working out the same time he had. They didn’t know each other - but they had spotted for each other from time to time. Spotter had his hands over the bar in case he couldn’t push it through. He pushed it through.

That was the one thing he could always thank Tracy for, was making his workouts easier.

He had learned to channel his rage at the gym. He picked heavy things up and put them down. He kept at it and after two years of this, he was starting to bulk up. 

He wanted to be a monster after another two. He wanted to stay as the SWAT Commander, until his back gave out and his knees finally cried mercy. 

He’d give Tracy what she wanted - him, desked and bored, when he finally got too old for action. But for now, it was the one thing he enjoyed doing more than anything. 

He loved physically saving people. It sure beat traffic duty or walking the city. He was happy to muster his boys and break down doors. The adrenaline rush was a drug he could never get sick of. 

Tracy needed to understand that only he could do this job. 

Doesn’t she understand that I’m saving lives? He pushed another rep, this time, his elbows finally giving out. He felt the bar begin to return down to his chest.

“Push it!” His spotter cheered.

Rigg shut his eyes, bared his teeth, and with one final surge of energy he forced the beam up one more time.

 

David Tapp

“That’s the last of ‘em,” Sing signed off on the final form, finalizing the booking of the last K2K member. He leaned back into his office chair, propped his feet on his desk, and folded his fingers before resting them on the back of his head. He breathed a satisfying sigh. “Took a while. But we’re finally done. I don’t know about you, but I need a vacation after this one.”

Tapp nodded, sharing in his partner’s weary joy. “I hear you, Sing. I’m ready to take a two day long nap.”

“On the bright side, there’s no way we’ll ever get a case as nuts as this one.” Sing, no longer a rookie, still had that boyish optimism that David admired and pitied. 

“Now you just jinxed us, Sing,” David shook his head, smiling. He, too, didn’t really believe terrorist gang wars could be topped in his career. Especially since he was due to retire in the next five years. But it was true that crimes were getting more violent and more over-the-top since he started out. For Sing, maybe he’d have to face some seriously disturbed criminals. It made David wonder if he should push his retirement back.

He knew Sing was capable. No longer naive, Sing had more lines on his face and a weariness in his voice from the long hours and rough reality of the job. But the guy still had such a strong moral compass that it was always a risk he’d be pigheaded and get himself killed. Tapp worried about it. Sing was one of those rare cops that genuinely wanted to help people and valued the lives of others over his own.

That recklessness made David Tapp fear that he would outlive his much younger partner. And he wasn’t about to let that happen.

Sing was more than just his partner. He was like a son to him. At some point, he wanted Sing to settle down. Meet a nice girl. Have some kids. 

He didn’t want Sing to be like him, in his late fifties and about to retire to an empty house.

“Yeah, you look like you need some sleep, old man,” Sing was up, coat in his hand. “Let’s grab a beer. Maddox is treating us. Haven’t talked to her in a long time.”

David blinked. “Oh yeah, I heard she’s back for good this time. I haven’t seen her since Knox’s funeral.” He remembered seeing her, close to Hoffman’s side. She, too, had a shadow over her face when he last saw her, and it wasn’t just because she was at a funeral. There was a stark contrast from the shiny eyed rookie he recalled. That Heart-Stealer case must have been rough for her.

“Well, what are you waiting for? Let’s get out of here for once.”

David and Sing arrived at the Green Lion Grill, Sing’s favorite spot in the whole damn world. David knew the menu inside and out. The only thing that had changed were the prices and the happy hour specials. 

“Sing! Tapp!” Will was waving from a booth, seated alone with a pint of yellow beer halfway gone. 

“Sup, Mad Max?” Sing slid into the seat across from her, Tapp following. “Congrats on catching the Heart-Stealer.”

“Definitely a joint effort. Kerry is the real hero.”

“Where is Kerry?”

“She’s on sabbatical, still in Virginia.”

“Yeah, good call. Speaking of, why is it I hear you’re still up and about?” Sing pointed to the bandage on her shoulder. “Shouldn’t you be in bed, sleeping off some painkillers? Should you be drinking?”

Will let out a small laugh. “What are you, my father? Yeah, I flushed the rest a few days ago. It hurts like a bitch. But I need a clear head. I’ve got so much to catch up on.” She said this and proceeded to finish the last of her beer.

Tapp figured she was drinking to cope with the pain. None of his business, but he thought it funny. Maybe a little hypocritical. 

“So,” Will was fiddling a napkin between her fingers. “I hear you’re both the reason the city can rest easy tonight, knowing there’s no more hidden explosives for civilians to step on. Good job.”

Sing shrugged. “It was a shit show.”

“Yeah, sounds like it.”

The server arrived to take their orders. Once gone, Sing leaned forward, interest curling his lip.

“So, you and Hoffman survived long distance for how many years now?”

“Two.”

“Sounds serious.”

David knew Sing always had a thing for Maddox. He folded his arms and suppressed a smirk.

Will nodded, picking up on Sing’s curiosity. She smiled. “Don’t expect wedding invites anytime soon.”

“How’s Hoffman holding up?” David asked, “After Knox?”

Will’s expression faltered. “He’s… fine. He took it hard but I think he’s handling it well. Doesn’t talk about it much.”

He could feel the anxiety coming off the woman. Her shoulders were raised. Her lower lip was pulled under her teeth. Will looked back at him, knowing that he knew she wasn’t being so honest. He politely smiled, nodding in sympathy.

The server returned with their drinks. David raised his beer glass up. “In memory of Vernon Knox. A good cop. One hell of a man.”

Everyone raised their glass, somber.

“So, what’s going on with Matthews?” Will changed the subject.

Sing and David looked at each other. David decided to be the one to get his feet wet in that territory. “So he’s suspended. Can’t go pointing your weapon at a reporter. Though we’ve all been there and many of the guys feel for him. I admit, I’ve wanted to shoot a nosy reporter from time to time. Especially when they get in your face and follow you around, when you’re off duty.”

Will nodded, lips pursed. “What’s Grissom going to do?”

“Oh, he’s not getting fired. Grissom remembers back when Matthews hadn’t juggled a divorce from hell. He’s not going to just kick the guy, especially when he owes alimony and child support. But Matthews will likely be on desk duty for the rest of his career. And that’s after IA finished taking the biggest shit on him they possibly could.” David had grown to strongly dislike Matt Gibson, after all the trouble he caused to many decent cops. 

The man was so holier-than-thou, David was surprised he hadn’t gotten nabbed for not putting quarters in the break room’s coffee fund but still helping himself to a mug. Despite his qualms, he feared for the boy’s safety. At the end of the day, David Tapp was a peaceful man. But there were many in the department that wouldn’t blink before taking Gibson into a private room and physically educating him on not crossing the wrong people. 

“For now, Matthews is no longer partnered with Hoffman. He’s going to be stowed in the basement. Now, your boyfriend is getting his own office.”

“Wow, he doesn’t tell me anything,” Will half-joked, half-griped.

“I’m surprised,” Sing took a slow drink of his beer, a knowing smirk on his face. “What with the latest I’ve heard.”

“Which is?”

“Grissom can’t have Hoffman go solo. And what with Matthews out and Kerry gone it only makes sense to put you two together, temporarily.”

Maddox’s eyes shined. “Wait, you're saying we’re partnering up again?”

“If Hoffman wants to, yeah. Otherwise, it’ll have to be someone else in Homicide. And there hasn’t been anyone else free or willing.”

David thought it was strange that Will had no idea. He wondered why Hoffman hadn’t let her know as soon as possible. Either Hoffman doesn’t want her as his partner or there’s something else. Whatever it was, now that David had all the free time in the world, he looked forward to sitting back and watching the two lovebirds duke it out. He always did love reality TV. 

 

Angelina Acomb

The burns on her hand and arm constantly reminded her how clumsy she was. And now, without work keeping her mind busy, she was stuck at home to face reality.

Peter was not coming back.

She couldn’t cry any more. She wasn’t sure if she could ever cry again.

There was a numbness in her. She couldn’t feel anything, except the pain. At least it was something.

She wondered if she would ever feel anything besides pain again.

The door knock jolted her from her thoughts. She let out a sigh. Mark, again.

The only thing that was making things harder was Mark’s constant fawning over her. She knew he was trying his best. He was doing the same things he did back when their parents died. He looked after her as if she would break from the slightest breeze.

Didn’t he understand that she wasn’t the same person anymore?

She was used to people dying on her. Now, she was twenty eight years old. She was a full grown woman, for god’s sake. And he had his own grief to go through. She knew he was doing that thing again, where he pushed his own feelings for her sake. 

And that just made her feel worse. 

She wanted him to be a bit more selfish. She could handle it. Really.

She opened the door, ready to give Mark a piece of her mind when the words froze in her throat.

“Hey. I brought some ice. Wanted to see if you need anything.” Seth Baxter, wearing a black beanie and giving her a small smile, held up a bag of gas station ice. “How’s your hand?”

“Fine,” she lied, letting him into her apartment. “You didn’t have to do this.”

“Yeah, I know.” He itched his upper lip with his thumb, looking away. “But I wanted to.”

She crossed her arms and raised an eyebrow. Her initial reaction was guarded. What does he want from me? She waited for him to continue.

“I know it’s none of my business. But I know life can suck. If you just want to take your mind off of it, I can help.”

She raised an eyebrow. “You can make all my troubles go away?” She recognized the bite in her words and wondered when she became such a bitch. 

Seth didn’t seem bothered by it, though. He just grinned at her, as if her rudeness made him happy. “Babe, I can take you to worlds you’ve never imagined.”

She snorted. “Are you on drugs?”

“Most of the time.” He laughed but Angelina didn’t join in. “Well, tonight there’s a get together happening on the south side. Good music, chill vibes. Just extending the invite. You look like you could use a good time.”

“Why are you doing this?” She felt lame, holding the melting bag of ice that was surprisingly soothing over  her hand. She needed to put the bag in the freezer, soon.

“I have a thing for women out of my league.”

Her eyes narrowed. “My husband just died.” She was about to tell him to get out but he held his hands up looking defensive.

“A joke, Ange. You just remind me of someone I used to care about. That’s all.” There was an edge in his voice and the sudden vulnerable moment set something off in her brain. 

“Who?”

“None of your business.” He laughed again. “So I take it you want me to get the fuck out. I respect that. I hope you feel better, Angel.” 

“Don’t call me Angel.” She knew she was being unfair to this man. He had driven her to the hospital. He seemed to be trying to do a good deed. 

And maybe doing something way out of her comfort zone would be the perfect distraction. 

The phone rang. Seth and Angelina stood in silence until the voicemail began recording.

“Hey, Ange, this is Will. Call me back, I miss you. I heard what happened and I - I’m so sorry. Let me know if you need a friend. Bye. ” The click and beep of the voicemail brought more silence into the room. 

Angelina’s stomach sank. Great. Now Will pities me

“If I go,” she cautiously spoke, “to whatever this party is, know I’m not going to hook up with you or anything. I’m grieving right now.”

Seth smirked. “Sure, I get that.” He raised an eyebrow. “So you’ll go?”

She shrugged. “What the hell. Anything to get out of this apartment.” And for everyone to just leave me alone for a few hours. 

“All right. It’s not a classy scene, so don’t feel the need to try too hard with getting prettied up.” He paused, as if considering his next words. “Not trying to pick you up or anything, but you look good now.”

“Smooth, Baxter,” She pushed the ice bag into his chest. “Throw this into the freezer and I’ll get ready.”

 

The two of them entered the abandoned warehouse. The smell of weed, cigarettes, and sweat clung to the musty air. They were in an abandoned steel plant, where iron sheets were stacked in piles, covered in metallic dust and rat droppings. 

The music made her bones vibrate with each thump. 

She was surrounded by people. Young people danced like maniacs by the center of the room. Along the walls, older people sat on steel beams or leaned against the building supports and watched on, nodding their heads to the music. 

Lights from above, green and blue and red flashed and burned her eyes.

She felt Seth’s mouth by her ear as he shouted, “Want to dance?”

She shrugged. She wasn’t sure. But this place was exhilarating. She was excited to be here, seeing these new sights and experiencing such a strange world. 

All around her, everyone looked like they were having the time of their life. 

But she didn’t dance much. She felt too awkward.

Seth crooked his finger and led her off the dance floor and into an adjacent room. The music was still loud but notably softened in this room. 

It was like a small market. Crates covered in tie dyed fabrics with glass smoking devices, paper signs with sloppy handwriting read, 

‘Dabs $40 

Flower $15 

Edibles $25’

“Ever smoke?” 

“No.” She felt her shoulders square in defense. 

“You want to?”

“No.” The knee jerk reaction she felt spilled from her mouth before she could think about it. 

“I hear your brother’s a cop. Got to be a good girl for him?” Seth smirked.

Angelina suddenly felt enraged. So he knew about Mark. That was weird but not alarming. They worked together. It was bound to come up in gossip.

But his preconceived notion that she had her life revolve around what Mark thought was downright insulting. “You don’t know anything about me.”

“True. So what? You scared?”

She opened her mouth, then shut it. She grimaced. Actually, she was. A little. She was always told weed was a gateway drug. It would start with weed and then…

“Weed never killed anyone. It’s impossible to OD from it. And one hit from a joint will help relax you.” 

She crossed her arms and studied Seth. He wasn’t necessarily twisting her arm. But still.

“It’ll help with the burn. Weed is a non-addictive pain killer. And fun.” Seth left her and handed some cash to one of the stoners sitting in their lawn chair. Seth took a joint from the table and put it between his lips, flicking the flint of his lighter and taking small puffs. Once the joint was finally lit he took a deep drag, holding it in his lungs before handing it to her.

He made a small gasp before exhaling a thick cloud of smoke to the side. “Here. Live a little, Angel.” He looked at her with this dangerous smile that made her stomach flip.

She glared at him for the nickname but took the joint. There was something about this man. She would normally never associate with someone like him. But at that moment, she felt almost giddy. She felt dangerous. She almost felt like she was alive.

She took a small puff, keeping the smoke in her mouth.

“No, you gotta let it hit your lungs.”

She took a deep breath, sighing to relieve some tension. She was nervous. Her heart was racing. Her hand was trembling. The other, throbbed and reminded her not just of the burn but of how she got it.

Peter.

She took a deep breath but instantly felt a burn inside her chest. She coughed, her eyes tearing up. She couldn’t breathe.

She felt Seth’s hand on her back, pounding it. He was laughing. “Now you’ll get high, Angel.”

Mark Hoffman

Everywhere Mark went, he heard whispers. 

“Did you hear about Eric Matthews?”

“Poor guy.”

“Fucking idiot should know better than to point a gun at a reporter.”

“I heard there was a camera. Dude’s caught on tape. He’s fucked.”

The worst of the gossip was in the break room. He pitied Matthews, knowing what it was like, experiencing this sort of thing. The fucking losers had nothing better to talk about. “Shouldn’t you get back to work?” He calmly stared at two rookies who were looking at him now with worry.

“Uh, sure thing Hoffman. Sorry about your partner.” And the two uniformed men retreated. Hoffman poured his coffee and left the breakroom, deciding he would spend the rest of the day in his new office.

He entered the space, noting a cute little redhead sitting at the small couch against the wall, lounging about while reading the paper. “I like what you did with the place,” she smiled but her tone held a sharpness. He knew what this was about.

“Word travels fast.”

“So,” she swung her legs to the ground and dropped the newspaper. “Explain why you didn’t tell me about my reassignment? Partner?”

He could tell she was thrilled, despite her tone. She wanted to be angry. But he knew she couldn’t be. It was good news he had withheld from her. 

“Been busy. You know, with Ange.”

Her eyes dulled. “Oh. Right.” 

He knew she hadn’t forgotten. She simply avoided the issue. He, too, was guilty of that most of the time.

But lately, Angelina was scaring him. He wasn’t going to ignore the problem. Not when she was concerned. But the more he kept trying to get involved and help his little sister, the angrier she got. 

He had never seen her this way but he adapted. He had begun to give her space. He stopped dropping in after work every day. He would call but not leave a voice mail every time. He’d just leave one message a day, to remind her that he was there for her. That he was always going to be there for her.

He figured she was just tired of being abandoned by everyone around her. And she was pushing him away because she was scared of losing him too.

But he wasn’t going to let that happen. He knew it was arrogant to assume this, but he had decided he wasn’t going to die. He wasn’t going to let anything get the drop on him until Angelina was well taken care of and they were both ancient and gray and surrounded by their respective grandchildren. 

“So, what do you want for lunch? My treat,” Will walked around his desk and leaned against the table, a flirty grin. She wore tight pants and her blue collared shirt was unbuttoned at the top, revealing a pleasant amount of skin. She was close to him, practically about to fall into his lap. 

She smelled of that sweet perfume he liked. She smelled like a bakery. She nudged his thigh with her knee, giving him a sultry look. “Maybe we can skip lunch and have some dessert instead.”

He couldn’t help but wish for that. But the door wasn’t locked. And he sure as hell didn’t want Gibson to walk in on them and get him cited for sexual harassment. 

Which, despite their declared relationship, the fucker would definitely try to pull. 

“You’ve been gone for a while. And let’s just say I’ve got to keep my nose extra clean these days. I don’t want you dragged into this mess.” A part of why he wasn’t especially keen on being partners again was because it would put a bright red target on Will as well. Gibson’s hate for him far exceeded any respect he had for her.

She raised an eyebrow. “Maybe we should eat, then. Larry’s?”

He smiled at her. It was good to have her back. “Yeah. Let’s go.”

 

They didn’t make it to Larry’s, instead, opting to grab a ‘bite’ back at his apartment.

As soon as the front door had shut, Will was on him like a rabid fox, leaping and wrapping her legs around his waist, arms around his neck, pressing her mouth hard into his.

He missed her. He missed how she tasted. He missed how nimble and quick she was.

He missed feeling her firm butt in his hands. 

He missed feeling her soft hair against his cheek.

It had been months since they had last slept together. He knew he wasn’t going to last long if they dived right in.

He carried her as she nipped and pulled at his lips and cheek with her kisses, down the hallway. He made it to his bedroom and lowered her onto the bed, keeping his hands pressed down on the blankets.

He was already sweating, feeling way too hot for his clothes.

Below him, Will was already unbuttoning her blouse, looking up at him with half lidded eyes, full of hunger and need. He was mesmerized as she revealed the smooth skin of her collar and chest, her breasts pushed up to him with her bra. 

He let himself begin to touch her, feeling the buttery soft skin that was decorated with brown freckles. The bandage on her shoulder gave him pause, his thumb grazing the gauze delicately.

“It’s fine,” she breathlessly whispered, pulling at his tie as she undid the knot. She gripped his shirt and broke off the buttons.

“Hey!” He liked that shirt. And sewing them back on took time.

She didn’t seem apologetic as she went down to his pants, greedy and rushed as she unbuckled his belt.

Seeing her, so feral, made him feel as if he was about to fall off the edge of a cliff. In a good way. 

He dived on top of her, pulling at her bra roughly, twisting at the fastenings with so much strength she gasped in pain as the fabric ripped with a sharp ‘sheeek’. 

“Payback’s a bitch,” he growled back, enjoying the searing hot fury that was pouring from her, now. 

“My shoulder, Mark,” she scolded, and he felt the instant regret like a shot of cold water. She rolled her eyes before unbuttoning his pants and pulling them down with fluid ease. 

They were both breathing hard and fast. 

He felt like a teenager, getting laid for the first time.

You’re not leaving me again, Will . He silently promised this. He would do whatever it took to keep her close to him. 

It was clear they had missed each other, desperately. 

She was pulling at his boxers, small hands pressing onto his cock and squeezing it gently. He let out a hiss as she smiled triumphantly up at him. “You’ve missed me, I see.”

“Yeah, no shit.” He pushed her down onto the mattress, grabbing a breast and squeezing with a little more force than he intended. She arched her back into him, eyes shut tight as she savored his touch.

He pressed his mouth against her breast, tasting her skin and sucking on a nipple as he ground his boner into her pelvis. His blood was electric. He sucked and bit rough on her as she let out a half-cry, half-moan. 

He felt her push him back suddenly. At first, he wouldn’t let her, until she let out a sigh. “Mark, let me suck your cock.”

Oh. That got him to pull from her, sheepishly hopeful. He stepped back as she scooted off the bed, lowered to his groin, pulling at his boxers to unsheath his throbbing manhood in her hand, dragging her tongue over its skin. 

He inhaled, feeling the air fill his lungs and her wet, hot tongue engulf and devour him. He looked down, enjoying seeing her bob her head back and forth, cheeks tight and the wet sucking sounds strumming his nerves like a guitar. 

After long, hedonistic seconds of this, he felt himself begin to build up, already about to climax. “Will. Slow down.” He gripped her hair and pulled her head back when she had ignored him. “Fuck, you’re about to make me cum.” 

She finally pulled her mouth from him, pumping his meat slowly, smirking up at him. “How long has it been? Months?”

“Five months,” he growled, grabbing her wrist and pulling her back onto the bed. “You drive me nuts, you know that?”

She let out a hum in sadistic glee. “Then fuck me, Mark.”

He swallowed, feeling more than just unbridled lust but this urge to dominate her. One minute, she was his saint. Then, she was a maddening vixen.

He gripped the waist of her pants and pulled them down, forcing them off her curvy ass and down her legs. He wanted to admire every inch of her but she was already tossing her head back and spreading her legs for him, glossy from being wet, her pussy inviting. 

He pressed himself onto her, guiding the tip of his dick into her opening, pushing with a groan. She was tight, slick, warm, and pulsing. He pulled before pushing back into her, going as deep as he could as she let out a soft yowl like a kitten.

He kissed her neck, licking the salt off her skin, savoring the feeling of her wrapped around him. He thrust into her, not taking his time but with rough and violent force that he had to grab her hips and pull her back onto him when she had been pushed across the bed.

She wrapped her legs tight around his waist, bouncing off of his cock as he vigorously pounded away.

He let out a gasp as he felt the orgasm crash over him so suddenly. He collapsed and twitched as he emptied his load inside of her.

Will’s moans had stopped, an awkward pause filling the room.

She propped herself up on her elbow, him, still inside of her. “I’m that good, huh?”

He felt embarrassment flooding his ears and neck. He was light headed, still feeling that pleasant buzz but ashamed that he hadn’t gotten her there as well. “Sorry.”

“No,” she shook her head, letting out a forced laugh. “I shouldn’t have rushed you. We’re just out of practice, is all.” Her eyes glittered. “I expect better results round two.”

He nodded, humiliation lacing his satisfaction. “You can count on that.”

 

Angelina Acomb 

His thumb grazed her cheek, pulling back an eyelash. “Make a wish, Angel.” They were outside, her ears still numb from the cold and loud music. They had just left a basement bar. A real dive. She smiled back at him, blowing the long black hair off his fingertips. Seth’s smile was crooked as he took a drag of his cigarette. 

She, too, took a puff from hers. 

When did she start smoking? She knew it had been shortly after she and Seth started going out every Friday night, a ritual she had fallen into because he just made it so damn easy. At first, she just tried it out to not feel like a square. But eventually, after doing it every weekend, she started joining Seth on his smoke breaks at the kitchen.

She needed to quit, though, and soon. Her sense of taste was starting to go. Her sous chef had complained that dishes had been returned to the kitchen, way too seasoned and off. “ I’m worried about you, Angelina. You sure you don’t need to take more vacation? Maybe talk to someone?

She had been sure. She shook her head, shoving the familiar anguish away with each drag of her cigarette. 

“Well, the night’s young. Let’s get the hell out of here. That scene sucked.” Baxter flicked his ash and walked down the street. She followed, eager for the next adventure.

Though they spent a lot of time together, she wasn’t sure where they stood. Maybe they would eventually become something. Honestly, she felt like she had been using him to get over Peter. He didn’t seem to mind, especially after they started sleeping together.

It all just happened so fast. One night she had taken an edible and had gotten too high to think straight. The next thing she knew, she was lost in her thoughts, feeling Seth over her, grunting and sweating, while she shut her eyes, gripping the bed sheets, thinking it was one hell of a bad trip.

The next thing she knew, she awoke, sore and feeling even more numb than usual. 

She didn’t think about it, choosing to just keep moving forward with life. She showered and went to work. Cooked, though there was no joy in what she did anymore. She forgot what it was like, enjoying things. She wondered if she would ever enjoy anything ever again.

The only time she could count on not feeling so terrible was when Seth came over, often with some new drug she had never done in her life.

“Scored some coke off an old buddy. Down for a bump, Angel?”

She liked cocaine and ecstasy the most. They were the closest things to her feeling happy. Ecstasy made her overwhelmed with compassion for the world and filled her with obscene amounts of pleasure until the crash came and she was suddenly so aware that the feeling had been artificial. Cocaine had filled her with the magnificent Godlike sensation that the world was hers to take and she would get through whatever was thrown her way. Until it wore off and she wanted to take a week long nap. 

Regardless, the drugs helped her forget about all the pain and suffering in the world. It helped her deal with things. It helped her deal with how shitty things had become. And she couldn’t find anything else that made her feel even remotely happier. 

“Babe, can you do me a favor?” Seth had a brown paper bag bundled up in his hand. “Hold this for me, okay, Angel?”

“Sure,” she wasn’t sure why he suddenly sounded rushed. She was still stoned, her face feeling tight and her head hazed. But she took the parcel in her hands as Seth walked off. “Hey, wait for me?”

“Excuse me,” a deep stern voice made her stop. She turned, seeing a police officer looking at her with a grave frown. “Ma’am, can you show me what’s in that bag?”

“Uh,” she looked down, instantly on edge. Adrenaline and paranoia made her begin to shake violently. “I - it’s not mine.” She could already assume what was in the bag.

“The bag.” The cop was cool and firm. He took the bag from her, unrolling it and looking inside. In under a second, she felt her wrists being pulled behind her back and the metallic clip of cuffs fastened on her. 

“Wait - “ she tried to wriggle but he held her firmly. “It’s not mine!”

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

Will entered the interrogation room, arms folded, looking down at Angelina Acomb. She couldn’t believe it when Sing had grabbed her and broken the news. Hoffman’s sister was found with a gram of heroin. 

At first, she thought it had been a joke. Some weird prank Sing and the boys had concocted. But when Sing gave her the deadpan stare, she knew this was no joking matter.

“Angelina,” she felt awkward, in this situation. Mark was still in the dark. He had been called to give a statement to IA on Matthews’ character hours ago. “Care to explain?”

“It’s not mine!” She sounded exhausted, as if she had repeated that statement many times before. She still had cuffs on, her fists on the table. Will took in her stringy hair, the shadows under her eyes, the emaciated physique of skin clinging to her cheek and jaw bones. She looked like a junkie. Hell, the stench of dope was thick in that room. 

“It’s been a while,” Will knew the rush of guilt crushing her stomach down to her knees was well deserved. “I don’t think I’ve gotten a chance to talk to you in months. Did you get my messages?” Will had left many voicemails on her answering machine. Ange hadn’t answered any of her phone calls. Kerry, too, had complained about not getting a hold of her.

Even Mark had confided that Ange had told him she wanted space. And he had respected her wish. We should have been more involved . Will was sure of that, now that they were in this predicament. 

“Does Mark know?” Her voice trembled with panic. 

“Not yet. But he’s going to. Word spreads around here, as you know.” Will noted the harshness in her tone and bit her lip. “How the hell did you end up with that much heroin, Angelina? You’ve never struck me as the type.”

“I - I was holding it for a friend. I know that sounds so cliche, but I was!” She coughed, cursing. “Can I have a cigarette? Please?”

Will’s hands went to her side. The woman kept surprising her. “Yeah. Sure.” The interview had been underway as soon as she entered the room. The camera in the upper corner of the room blinked its red light, indicating its recording. 

Will was in good cop mode, forcing herself to emotionally compartmentalize. Angelina was in serious trouble and unless Will decided to start breaking the rules, she was likely going to sleep in a jail cell that night. 

She left the room, talking to the guard by the door. “Got a pack of smokes?” 

The man took out a lighter and a pack from his breast pocket, handing it to her. She saluted him before returning to the room, taking out a stick for Angelina and holding the lighter for her. 

“Thanks.” Angelina let out a smoky sigh, relief relaxing her lined face. 

Will noticed her fingernails were dirty and her left wrist had some yellowing bruises. Observing the suspect even further, she noticed there were what appeared to be hickeys on her neck. “How are things, Ange?”

Angelina blinked slowly, looking at Will with caution. “Pretty terrible, Will. I’m sure you knew that.”

“I couldn’t be sure of that, Ange, what with you screening your calls. Did I do something to offend you?”

“No. I just.” Angelina’s eyes shined with tears. “I just couldn’t talk. It’s not you. It’s. Everyone.” She was sniffing, taking another puff, and forcing out a thick plume. She coughed and shivered, avoiding eye contact. “But I guess I’ve got to talk, huh?”

“No, you don’t. You said you understood your right to remain silent. Or did you not?”

“No, no, I understand. The whole Miranda Rights thing. Mark always said to shut up and lawyer up. Guess I should do that, huh?”

Will bit her lip. Never did the interrogator want the suspect to demand a lawyer. But she couldn’t say that. 

“And I know what you’re doing. The Reid Technique, right?”

Though she had never shown interest in criminal science or law enforcement, it was clear she was well aware of the standard procedures. Perks of being related to a cop.  

“How did we get here, Ange?” Will decided to just be frank with her friend. She rubbed her temple, revealing her true feelings. Disappointment. Disbelief. “You are the most innocent and sweetest person I’ve ever met. Who gave you the bag? I know you wouldn’t have any idea where to score. Just give me a name and we can get you a slap on the wrist.”

Angelina’s lips thinned and she shrugged. “You just don’t know me well, Will. I know how to get what I need, plenty.” There was a hauntedness over her face, her eyes glazed with the familiar weariness that Will had seen throughout her twelve years as a cop. She also had known Angelina for almost as long and knew she was lying. 

“I never told you this, Ange, but you are a terrible liar.” Will leaned back in her chair as Angelina glared daggers back. “When you lie, you flip your hair over your shoulder. And a couple of other tells that I’ll let you think about. So let’s cut the bull shit. Mark is going to be fucking devastated when he finds out his baby sister is a strung up junkie. And he’ll find out who’s been poisoning you, one way or the other. If I get the name, I can make sure the fucker is safe in prison and not somewhere Mark will one day decide to take out back and handle on his own. You know your brother, Ange. And he’s one mean bastard when someone he cares about is hurt. So do us all a favor and just spill the beans.”

Angelina had a hateful sneer on her face, obscene and unfamiliar to Will. This moment in her life was perhaps one of the hardest she had experienced in a long time. This drug epidemic, it seemed, infected any and everyone. 

But Angelina was at least alive, not found overdosed in some gutter or in the trunk of some mobster’s car. She could still be saved. 

“I want a lawyer.”

Will jumped to her feet, furious at her. She wanted to snap at her, to tell her she was being a selfish idiot. But she remembered herself. She remembered what she was in this situation. She was a servant of the law. She could not backhand Angelina Acomb across the face, no matter how hard she deserved it at the moment.

“Fine. Enjoy your night behind bars, Ange.” She turned to leave but stopped when she realized the door was wide open. Her heart sank as she recognized his shocked expression. “Mark.”

Notes:

A/N: This chapter was hard to write for me. I don't want Angelina to be a bad girl TT_TT

Chapter 36: Pre:SAW The Scene We Were All Waiting For

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

Angelina was silent on the car ride to her apartment. She stared out the window, sulking when he had told her she couldn’t smoke in his car.

He was still trying to wrap his head around things. 

When Rigg had told him that his sister was currently in custody, he had laughed at the joke. When he saw that Will had been the primary interrogator, he then thought this had to be a nightmare. 

She didn’t tell me first. Mark couldn’t believe she hadn’t told him before going in there.

Mark had made damn sure the charges were dropped. Ange was going through a tough time. And she said the drugs weren’t hers. He believed his sister. He knew her. She wouldn’t do something like that.

Will, on the other hand, had tried to stop him from protecting his sister.

“It’s not the right way,” she had preached but he simply tore her arrest warrant in her face. 

Will, despite her wish to do good, sure had some fucked up priorities. There was no way in hell he would let his little sister go to jail. It wasn’t right. He wasn’t going to allow it. 

“At least get the name of the dealer,” Will had instructed.

Mark, rarely, felt such rage directed towards his girlfriend. But at that moment, he was furious with her. She was so fucking insensitive. This was Angie , not some street junkie. This was his sister.

“You don’t have to walk me up,” Angie practically jumped out of the car when he pulled up to the curb. He had to hurriedly put the car in park and kill the engine, fumbling with his seat belt as she already entered her apartment building. 

“Ange, wait!” He called out. “We still need to talk.”

She had been caught at the elevator, huffing as she finally lit a cigarette. He resisted the urge to take the stick out of her mouth. She was an adult, after all. But damn it, she knew better than to start that bad habit.

They stood in silence until the elevator arrived. The doors slid open and they awkwardly got in.

“What do you want to talk about?” Ange spoke first. 

“Tell me what happened?”

“Ugh.” She had exhaustion in her tone. “I’ve said it a million times already. I was out. Partying with some friends. One of them gave me the bag and told me to hold it. Then the cop nabbed me. End of story.”

“I need his name.”

She turned, eyes electric. “No, you don’t.”

“Who are you? What happened to my little sister? Did I do something wrong? Is this some midlife crisis?” He had never felt so exasperated before. He wondered if Angelina was trying to make up for lost teenaged angst. Her whole life, she had never been rebellious.

There was a glimmer of regret in her frown. “No. I mean, yeah. It’s just -,” she ran her fingers through her oily hair, “you just suffocate me sometimes, Mark. All you do is keep pushing me when all I want is some space.”

This was new. Their whole lives, it was Angelina who had been the needy sibling and he, the loner. “I’m just worried.”

“Yeah. I know. And I know today isn’t helping.” The elevator dinged and let them off on her floor. They made their way to her apartment door when the knob began to turn. 

Hoffman went to his gun and took it out, pushing Angelina behind him as he waited for the intruder to come out.

“Holy fuck!” A man raised his hands, eyes wide, mouth open in surprise. “Shit, don’t shoot!”

“Mark, put the gun down,” her voice shrill, “He’s a friend.”

He lowered his gun, confused. “Friend?” He instantly knew this guy was trouble. He looked ungroomed. Shadows around his eyes, gaunt cheekbones, and the yellow on his fingertips made Mark instantly connect the dots. So this is the friend. Looks like the typical back alley junkie. 

“Yes, my friend. We work together.”

“Doesn’t look like a chef.”

“Uh, dishwasher. Busboy when it gets busy. Hey. Name’s Seth. You, uh, must be the brother. The cop.” The guy lowered his hands, looking as though he was trying to smile off the tension. He didn’t hold out a hand to shake. He shoved his hands in his pockets, shrugging with the casualness of a punk. 

“Mark Hoffman. How long have you two been close enough for him to have a key to your place?”

“Mark!”

“Uh, it’s cool. She asks me to water the plants every so often. You know, check the mail and stuff when she’s out.”

“She doesn’t travel often.”

“Maybe she just doesn’t tell you her goings all the time.”

Fresh hot fury flowed up his neck and into his cheeks. He kept his face still and his hands at his side. 

“Mark, it’s fine. Seth’s been keeping me company. He took me to the hospital when I was burned a while back. Remember when that happened? I told you about that.”

He turned to Angelina, as if seeing her for the first time. She was unrecognizable to the woman he had raised. And it was dawning on him that she was in serious trouble. “Angie,” he softly implored, knowing his tone communicated all it needed to.

There was guilt in her face. Pain in her grimace. But she swallowed and shook her head. “Go home. It’s none of your business, Mark.”

“Considering you almost were booked for a felony and I got you out of it, I think it is my business.” 

She was chewing her lip and turned to her ‘friend’. “Seth. It’s best if you go. I’ll call you.”

He wanted to interrupt and tell the punk this was the last time he’d ever see her. But he pressed his lips together to keep the peace. Pushing Angie wouldn’t help. He needed to be gentle with her. To show that he was on her side in all this. 

And most importantly, she needed to get as far away from this scumbag as possible.    

“Sure, it’s cool. Call me, Angel,” he smiled at his sister before sauntering to the elevators. 

“Well, come in, I guess.” Angelina walked in. “Ignore the mess.”

He could not. 

The place was completely fucked. 

He had never seen her apartment in a state of disorganization. But it wasn’t just the clothes strewn about the floor, the couch shoved against a wall and a bare mattress sitting on the floor that was notable.

It was also the mirror on the coffee table where a syringe, a dusty mirror, and a bong rested along with the usual trash and grime that came with the drug dens he’d seen at the Crossroads. 

“What the fuck, Angie?” 

She looked away. He knew she had to feel something for this mess.

“It may have gotten a bit out of control.”

“Out of control? Ange, what the fuck’s going on? I’ve given you space because you asked for it. But this? This is not acceptable. This shit will kill you.” He felt fear grip his chest. “Ange, you need to get to rehab.”

“No, it’s fine. I can quit anytime.”

“Right now, then.”

She laughed. “Funny. Why should I?” She flicked ash on the floor and took another drag of her cigarette. Despite her confidence, concern was pulling her eyebrows together.

“Is this about Peter?”

She blinked and became angry. “Peter’s fucking dead. What does it matter?” 

He put his hands on her shoulders, feeling how they trembled. They were so bony. “Because you loved him. Because losing someone you love is one of the worst things you can feel. Because I’m losing you. And I don’t want to, Ange. I love you.” He felt his eyes tear up and he blinked them, embarrassed by his emotion. “This is hurting you.”

She sniffled and shook her head violently. “No. I’m fine.”

“No, you’re not.” He pulled her close and hugged her, his chin on her head as she sobbed. He could smell the oil in her hair. She needed a shower. “But I’ll fix it, okay? I promise. We’ll get through this together.”

 

(One Month Later)

 

Mark Hoffman waited, patiently in his Crown Victoria parked across the street to the Dillon bistro. Angelina was currently inside, working.

It was lightly raining. The sun had long set and it was a cool evening. Seth Baxter, dishwasher at the Dillon, was currently taking his third smoke break that shift. Mark had done the standard background check on the perp. Seth Maurice Baxter, aged thirty-two, was a high school dropout with nothing but bad news on his record. Convicted of possession two years prior. Drunken disorderly. Just got off parole. And picked up refreshments from his two favorite dealers, one at the Crossroads and the other at a seedy nightclub on Tuesday nights. He frequented the alley of the restaurant and Angelina’s apartment.

Currently, Mark had decided it was time to give the guy a good scare. At first, he had planned on nabbing the guy and arresting him, for whatever charge he could think of at the time. But he knew that Angelina would get wind of that. And she would likely not see the big picture here.

Mark knew the best way to get Seth Baxter out of his sister’s life was to tell it to the guy straight. To back off. To skip town. To put the fear of God into him so good, he would piss himself every time he heard his name. 

It was his best talent.

Angelina’s big brother was a big scary cop with equally scary friends. And life would get hard for the prick real quick if he didn’t listen. 

He never confided in Will what he was doing on his investigations these past few weeks. He had kept his distance, still disappointed in her, regardless of how many coffee runs and donuts she tried to bribe his forgiveness with. 

Once Baxter was dealt with, he’d talk it out with Will. But he was still wondering how he could ever forgive her betrayal. 

Baxter, at the moment, was getting off of work. It was ten in the evening. The restaurant was closing. Baxter took his hoodie and put it over his wiry frame, the hood blocking his ears from the rain. He was a walker, crossing the street and looking right at Hoffman’s car, not registering that he was being watched. 

Mark got out of the car and kept a good hundred feet away from the guy. He recognized they were walking towards the direction of Angie’s apartment. 

This made him pick up the pace, wanting to get to him several blocks before his destination.

The guy was oblivious. No concern of being followed, no turn of the head. The guy had shit instinct. This was good.

Not many people were out. A bum was shaking his change cup as Hoffman walked by. A woman with high alert of her surroundings was walking her yorkie and cast him a nervous glance, as if she could sense he was dangerous. Taxis drove by, their engines and tires the only sound on the pavement.

Hoffman was closing in, close enough that he could grab Baxter by the back of his neck and shove him behind the nearest alley.

As soon as an opening arrived, he grabbed the guy and threw him towards a pile of trash. Baxter’s head hit the dumpster with a satisfying clang.

“Guh!” The guy looked dazed as he looked up as Hoffman grabbed the man by his collar and threw him against the brick wall.

He threw a heavy punch and felt the satisfying pain of his knuckle skin slicing from the prick’s teeth. Baxter let out a wail of pain. 

He shook him firmly, cooly waiting for him to recover from the head blow. “You listen good. My sister? You don’t talk to her anymore. You stay the fuck away from her. You understand?”

“...f…fuck you.” Warm spittle struck Hoffman’s cheek. He wiped it, lifted the guy by the shirt, and threw him into the dumpster. A loud metallic boom filled the alley.

“Still going to meet up with her? Huh?” Hoffman took his gun out and pistol slammed the crown of his head.  The guy slumped forward, forehead against the lip of the dumpster. He grabbed him by the hood of his hoodie, Baxter’s head bobbing back and forth like a cheap novelty toy. 

The gun felt warm in his hand. He pulled back the hammer with a satisfying click. He wanted to push the barrel into the fucker’s mouth. He opted to have him stare right down the black tunnel, instead. 

He felt Baxter begin to tremble. He heard the splatter of liquid on plastic rubbish and knew the man had pissed himself. Good.

“F - fine. We’re done. I ain’t seeing her no more.”

Hoffman studied his face, searching for any twitch of resistance. “Tell her about this meeting, and I won’t just kill you with a bullet. Too easy. Clear?”

“Yeah.” When he felt the guy was thoroughly cowed, he slammed the butt of the gun hard over his head, knocking him unconscious. 

The guy collapsed like a sack of potatoes, joining his fellow trash.

Hoffman looked around quickly before backing from the dumpster and left the alley.

This was for Angie. This was the right way to do things.

He knew she’d get over this, as soon as the cancer had been cut out.

And now, she could finally heal.

 

Angelina Acomb

 

She woke to the door knocking. She was so cold. She was sick. Seth had stood her up the night before and she was beginning to feel the worst pain of her life. Withdrawal. She knew that was what this feeling was.

She needed a fix. She needed him to come through and give her just a small dose.

She had sprinted to her door and threw it open, eager for reprieve. 

And smiled in relief when it was Seth who stood in the doorway. “Babe, where have you been?”

He pushed through the door, devoid of warmth. She wondered what had gotten him in a bad mood. He looked bruised, his left eye black. She noticed that his one good eye was mostly a big black hole. He must have taken something before coming here , she thought enviously. 

“Babe, what happened?”

He was pacing in her living room, wiping his nose and sniffling, his right hand in his pocket while his left was rubbing his nose.“Yourfuckingbrotherhappened.” He spoke so rapidly it had all come out as one word.

“What?” Realization dawned on her. Anger was hot under her skin. “Did he hurt you?”

He scoffed. “Come off it. He’s your brother, bitch. What do you think?”

His words stung but her needs let her overlook it. She needed that fix. “Seth, baby, tell me about it. Let’s just chill tonight, okay? Relax.”

He was scratching and shaking his head as he muttered words under his breath. “Bitch” and “push me around” were all she could make out. She had ever seen Seth so out of control. He reminded her of a caged tiger she once saw in a zoo, who kept pacing and grunting. He was making her nervous but she was also trying to form sentences through the worst body aches and migraine of her life. 

“Seth, sit down. You’re making me nervous.”

The knife appeared. The tip of the blade was inches from her nose.

“You don’t get,” Seth’s teeth were bared, “to tell me what to do. You hear?!”

She raised her hands, fear seizing her thoughts and making her speechless.

“Your fucking brother thinks he can bully me. He doesn’t fucking know who he’s messing with.” Seth lowered the knife and kicked an end table, knocking it over in a loud crash. She flinched but didn’t move from her spot.

She wanted to get out of there, right now. 

But Seth was standing at the archway of the living room, the closest exit to the front door. He continued to rub his head and grumble words under his breath.

“Seth,” she softly asked, feeling tears fall down her cheeks. “What did you take before coming here?”

He twitched and fidgeted, looking at her with confusion before looking away. “Nothing. Something. To keep me alert. In case that fucker comes back. Fucking scared. He’s fucking out to get me.”

“I’ll talk to Mark. Get him to back off.”

Seth spun and pointed the knife back at her. “No. You don’t tell him anything. He’ll kill me. Your bro’s a psycho.”

She balked. “He’s not a psycho. I think this is a misunderstanding.”

Seth’s face contorted, looking like a snarling animal. “YOU WEREN’T FUCKING THERE!”

She backed away, knowing a lamp was resting on a table against the wall. He took a step towards her, closing the distance. She needed to be quick.

He’s going to kill me. I think he’s going to kill me.

“Seth,” she whispered, “let’s talk this out.”

“No talking. Just. Get. Over. Here-,” he jumped back when she threw the lamp at him. The sound of shattering porcelain was at her back as she sprinted out of the living room and into her kitchen. 

She reached for the knife and spun around, just in time to see Seth leap forward, slashing his blade towards her. She pulled open her spice drawer as a barrier between them, Seth crashing into it and ripping out the cabinet with a snarl.

She fled the kitchen, heart pounding in her ears as she tried to go down the hall to the front door.

But he was there, fast and rabid, breathing heavy.

“Seth. Please,” she took steps backwards, holding the kitchen knife in her hands. She wasn’t sure how she was going to defend herself. The gun was in her bedroom safe. But the bullets were under her bed in a locked box. She cursed herself for not keeping one loaded on the nightstand. 

The fire escape.

She remembered how Will escaped Frank and decided that was the best option. She spun and sprinted to her bedroom, trying to close the door behind her.

She just needed to lock it, to buy herself a couple more minutes.

But as she tried to shove the door closed it wouldn’t sit on the frame.

She panicked and tried to shove the door closed but realized why it wouldn’t.

Seth was holding the door open.

And he was so strong.

He threw the door open, punching her in the chest.

She fell backward onto her bed.

Above her, the glint of steel glowed above her head.

She let out a scream.

And a jagged pain tore into her throat.

Hot and wet blood gushed out of her neck. Her fingers and feet felt cold. She tried to touch her throat. She couldn’t sit up. She had no strength to stop the bleeding. 

Her scream had faded into a rattle that sounded gurgled. I’m drowning. I can’t breathe. She couldn’t inhale to try again. She couldn’t fucking breathe.

She was so scared.

Mark. Help me .

Above her, Seth looked down at her with wide eyes.

“No. NO! Angel! Stay with me. Please!”

The pain in her throat numbed. And her thoughts faded into the cold, cold black.

Notes:

A/N: I'm going to make these next few chapters shorter, for my bandwidth :)

Chapter 37: Pre:SAW Withdrawal, Renewal, No Deal

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Amanda Young

 

The bus took her far from that cursed place.

She had survived the three years of her sentence. Now, she was free.

It was a hollow feeling. She had no plans, outside of the steel bars and concrete cage. No family would take her in. The only person she could think of to turn to was Cecil, who owed her big time. She felt like a tumbleweed, blown about in the dirt by the cruel world.

She knew she was being pathetic, feeling sorry for herself.

The bus slowed to a stop, taking her just west of the Crossroads, the farthest stop of the route. She got off.

It was early afternoon. A distant siren released her adrenaline. The thought of men in blue filled her gut with dread. She was already feeling so tired, she could collapse.

She knew there wasn’t a lot she could do, besides enter the crummy building. Climb the cracked stairs. Knock on the door with peeling plaster.

The door opened and Cecil’s black eyes glittered back at her. “‘manda.”

“Cecil.”

He moved to let her inside, closing the door behind her. The place was small. A mattress on the floor, cardboard boxes as makeshift tables, and a familiar spread of pills and brown stained spoons on the kitchen counter gave her a forlorn smile. 

“How was prison?”

“What do you think?” She would have punched him in the face if he wasn’t offering his place for her to crash. She needed to get herself back on her feet. Find a job. Get clean. 

Speaking of. She wiped the sweat on her brow. She had been kept steady in supply while locked up. The irony that she had all the drugs she could have wished while in prison wasn’t lost on her. 

She knew it was going to be a rough few weeks. But she intended to get clean. She was going to fix her life. 

“Want a hit?” Cecil was already wrapping his arm with a rubber tube.

“How much?”

Cecil paused, raising an eyebrow. “You for real? I thought you didn’t touch the shit.”

“Yeah. That was before.” Before she lost her freedom, for a crime she never committed. For Cecil’s crimes.

The man smirked. “Alright,” he sounded almost gleeful. “First round’s on me. For, you know.” His tone held just the slightest semblance of remorse . So he does know he did me wrong.

This did little to make her feel better, though.

What would was the promise of that warm, pleasant buzz that was sure to come from that needle. Cecil always bragged about only buying primo shit.

She took stray surgical tubing and wrapped it around her upper arm, pulling with her teeth as her heart picked up in eager anticipation.

Cecil flicked his lighter and heated up the powder under the spoon, letting it turn to liquid. Antiseptic and burnt rubber filled her nose. 

There was an awkward moment as he filled the syringe. He went to push the needle into his inner arm, pushing the plunger inward, the light yellow liquid vanishing. Cecil’s face relaxed and he let out a slow breath. 

Amanda went to help herself, taking a spare syringe that looked somewhat clean, draining the last vestiges of fluid from the spoon. There wasn’t much furniture to sit on. Cecil was already taking up the dingy mattress in the corner. She sat on a dry spot on the carpet.

In another minute, none of this would bother her anymore.

She flicked the syringe and aligned the needle right over a thick vein that bulged eagerly from under her skin. She gently pushed it in and pressed the stopper.

She felt the warmth of the fluid as it spread from her inner elbow all the way up her arm until she felt the pleasure spread across her chest. Her spine hummed. She felt herself fall over. She was sinking. Sinking gently down from this shithole apartment and going to a happy place.

Yes. This was nice. This was so much better.

She didn’t care anymore how fucked up her life was.

As long as she had heroin, it was going to be fine. 

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

 

“Maddox.” Grissom entered her office door. He had a stern frown that raised her to her feet.

“Sir, what is it?” She expected him to hand her the case file gripped tightly in his hand. Perhaps it was a particularly sensitive victim or too close to corruption in-house.

“You should sit down, Maddox.”

This alarmed her. She obeyed, her fingers already beginning to twitch. “You’re scaring me, boss.”

Grissom took a seat at the chair across from her desk, his mouth a wide line of discomfort. He slowly placed the folder on her desk. “Just got this called in an hour ago. Forensics probably haven’t combed the scene yet. I’m still deciding whether it is appropriate you be the principal investigator for this case.”

Will raised an eyebrow, opening the folder. 

Her heart thudded in her neck.

There were no photographs. Yet. It was so fresh the papers were still warm from the printer.

Domestic Dispute.

Neighbors reported screams.

Victim, female, 20-30s. Black hair. Brown eyes. 

Lacerations to the neck. 

No suicide letter.

Indications of struggle, homicide, defensive wounds.

The address burned into her vision and she shook her head. 

“This is Angelina Acomb’s home address,” she whispered, feeling as if dreaming.

Grissom nodded, looking away. “We need someone to ID the body. There’s been some issues with the pathologist’s car - body’s still at the scene.”

Will kept looking back, trying to still her trembling arms.

She needed to be involved. She already knew that. A part of her refused to believe Angelina was dead. But another part of her, the one that was more cynical, was not surprised.

Angelina had dived head first into a pit of trouble. 

Will already had a feeling this was a drug deal gone wrong.

Thoughts of Mark and him eventually learning of this broke her heart.

“Your personal relationship with the victim makes this difficult for me,” Grissom leaned forward, grunting, “but for one of our own, when it’s family, I know the pain. Having to watch things from the outside, leashed to just watch from the sidelines. And I know Hoffman. We know Hoffman.”

Will nodded, agreeing. The painful lump in her throat grew and made it hard for her to breathe. She forced it down.

“I can’t let him investigate. He’s proven time and again that he’s going to take shortcuts. And if this prick gets off because he gets a defense attorney that can sniff out anything that was done incorrectly - we could see the killer walk. And I don’t want that. He’d never forgive himself.”

“Then why me?” Will narrowed her eyes. “I knew the victim personally as well.”

“And you have the cleanest track record in this department. No one else can brag how by-the-book you are, except for IA. And for Hoffman, it’s the best I can do for him, putting you up to it. He trusted you. If you’re up for it, the case is yours.” His jaw was clenched, his stare penetrating. “This is asking a lot. I know.”

She nodded, swallowing the painful lump forming in her throat. Despite the grief that wanted to bubble up she slammed it down, reminding herself that she could cry when they caught this bastard. She cleared her throat. “I’ll do it.”

Grissom nodded. “Then get to the scene. Don’t worry about breaking the news to Hoffman.” He looked weary and almost afraid. “I’ll do it.”

Will felt the blood drain from her face. “You don’t have to do that, sir. I can.” She doubted it would be any better, coming from her.

Grissom shook his head. “The crime scene’s just been established.” He got to his feet. “And I’m going to give the poor man a few more hours of blissful ignorance. Just focus on this case, treat it as pristinely as you do with all the others.” Grissom gave her a final nod before leaving her alone.

As soon as the door shut, Will let out a deprived gasp. She covered her mouth and the tremors she had suppressed unleashed like a violent earthquake. Hunched over her desk, she took the case to the side so her tears wouldn’t leave wrinkled dots on the papers. 

“Angie,” she choked back a sob, “no.”

After a few more minutes of heavy breathing she wiped her tear streaked cheeks and got to her feet. She grabbed her jacket and car keys, stopped by the nearest restroom to splash cold water on her face, and drove to the crime scene.

 

Angelina’s apartment looked like a nightmare. 

Will took in the spray paint on the walls, the clear signs of drug abuse strewn about every horizontal surface, and the confusing layout of furniture. She remembered when this apartment was once tastefully decorated with modern furnishing that resembled the cover of Home Living. 

She wasn’t sure where the drug abuse started and the violent murder ended. 

She carefully stepped over taped squares and yellow number cards as forensic technicians took pictures of every square inch of the living room.

She stopped at the bedroom, bracing herself before she entered. 

There, on the bed, in a thin camisole and sweats, lay Angelina Acomb. Dead . Her head dangled off the edge of the mattress, her hair cascading down to the ground. Her eyes were vacant. Her face held the slightest remnants of surprise and fear through her agape lips.

Her fingers were curled with bruises along her wrists, indicating defensive wounds.

Her neck was slashed wide open, the arterial blood having splattered along the ceiling. A significant portion of the wall in the path of trajectory was bare. 

The killer was likely covered in her blood. Better have some guys go through all the dumpsters in the next ten blocks. See if any CCTV cameras are around. Keep an eye out. 

“Anyone interview the doorman?” 

One woman who was dusting for fingerprints shook her head. “This building hasn’t had a doorman in months. That’s how we all got in so easy.”

How had she not noticed? She should have realized this when there was no one standing guard at the entrance. These details, she should have picked up on instantly. She realized she was distracted, thoughts often flashing back to Angelina’s wedding. Brunch. Times when they used to laugh and shop and complain about their love lives together. She needed to get a grip.

She wished Allison was back from Virginia, but decided it was better she wasn’t. She knew this was going to break her heart as well. 

Distant yelling sounded and Will spun around, heart hammering. She half expected the suspect to have returned to the scene.

In a whirlwind, she recognized Mark’s angry voice.

“Let me in. This is my sister’s apartment. Where is she?!” 

She stepped out of the bedroom, down the hall. Uniformed cops were trying to stop a trespasser at the front door.

“Detective, you’re not assigned to this case. You need to step back.”

She saw Mark, hair disheveled, eyes wide. He saw her and something on her face must have told him all he needed to know.

“Let go of me!” He forced himself free from the grip of one of the uniformed rookies who looked unsure of what the protocol was in this type of situation.

“Mark,” Will took a step forward, holding her hands out to him. “Hang on, slow down.”

“Where is she?” 

“Mark, she’s not ready yet - you need to wait.” 

She felt him push by her, like a bull barreling past. 

The rookies followed, trying to pull him back.

They managed to grab him just as he entered the door. But they were too late.

She watched their backs, hearing Hoffman’s voice contort into a wail.

“NO!” 

Will leaned against the wall, her knees weak, as she heard the man she loved scream in agony. But if Mark touches her - touches her body - I can’t let him do that.

She wanted to cry as well. The familiar click and whine of a camera, the white flashes, snapped her into action. She pushed herself back up and sprinted into the bedroom. She stopped when she saw Mark on his knees, weeping at the foot of the bed, Angelina’s corpse remained as it had been, unmoved. One of forensics continued to photograph the stuffed animals on the floor, the blood splattering the pale pink sheets.

She knelt by him, putting an arm around him. “Mark,” she whispered, “As soon as they’re done, you can have all the time with her. Okay? But please, you need to wait outside.”

He turned to her, eyes an angry red, cheeks streaked with tears. 

He grabbed her hand and squeezed it tightly. “It was Baxter. Find him, Will. Arrest him.”

“I will. I promise. I’ll find Angelina’s killer.”

His eyes scared her. They were wild and cold. “It was Baxter. I know it.”

She wanted to ask how. But he wasn’t in his right mind. So she remained gentle. “Okay, Mark.” 

“Otherwise,” he got to his feet, looking back at Angelina with sudden callousness on his expression. Emotion was thick in his throat and his voice was quiet. “I’ll deal with it myself.”

“You won’t have to, Mark.” She stood up as well, hand on his elbow. “I’ll make sure whoever is responsible for this will be behind bars for the rest of his life. I promise.”




Jill Tuck

 

Jill had brought the vial of urine out of the bathroom, her heart hammering. “John.”

John was at his drawing table, sketching out a floor plan. He turned, reading glasses hanging at the tip of his nose. His eyes landed on the blue liquid and he jumped up with surprise.

“You’re -,” his words stopped and he looked as if he was about to choke and laugh.

She was beaming. “I’m pregnant!” 

He was laughing, arms outstretched, taking her into his arms.

She loved how taken aback he was acting. He had been especially attentive these past few months, ever since their conceiving a child would align with the Chinese Zodiac’s Year of the Pig. He had been so invested in the concept of rebirth and renewal. 

It was part of his and Art Blanck’s brand - “Urban Renewal”. 

John already had big plans for their future child. Boy or girl - he would name them Gideon. Terrible name, she knew. But no matter how much she pushed or pleaded, he would not budge on the name.

He was stubborn like that. 

But she was just happy that they were having a child together, after so many years of his refusal to. 

So Gideon, it was. 

She only hoped he would let her dress Gideon however she wanted. 

John put his hand over Jill’s stomach, as if he could sense Gideon’s presence. 

“Hey there, son,” John whispered at her stomach. “We’re going to see you real soon.”

“How are you so sure it’s a boy?” Jill raised an eyebrow.

John was smiling at her, shrugging. “I just know.”



Mark Hoffman

 

He stood and could do nothing but watch.

The coffin was being lowered down into the ground.

The headstone read: 

Angelina Acomb

1976 - 1999

Loving Daughter, Sister, and Wife.

Gone But Not Forgotten

He wasn’t sure if it would have been what she would have wanted. Angie never left a will. There never seemed to be a reason.

She was only thirty three.

That made his eyes well up. He shut them tight and willed the world to pause its progression of time.

He felt a small frame wrap around him. A small bit of warmth on that frosted, cloudy morning.

It was Will.

He didn’t look at her. He knew he should be thankful she was there, to support him as he said goodbye to the only family he had.

But all he felt was the venom of misery and the emptiness of loss.

Next to Angelina’s headstone was Peter Acomb’s. To the left of Peter, were his parents. Eventually, he planned on joining them here, in this plot of earth to rot away. Together.

But first, he needed to see that justice was served.

Seth Baxter needed to answer for what he did.

It was the only thing he thought about for the past three days.

It was the only reason his body somehow kept breathing. It was the only reason he got out of bed in the morning, despite his nightly drunken wishes to not wake up.

Will had managed to arrest Baxter just yesterday. That had been another reason he kept living.

The punk had lawyered up but was still waiting on a public defender.

The process was slow but Will had reassured him that she would make sure the DA would have all the evidence needed to convict him. 

He trusted her on this.

He had to.

These days, he just wasn’t on top of his game. He knew he wouldn’t have been able to properly arrest Baxter.

He wanted to kill him. Squeeze the life out of him. Strangle the bastard until his neck bones cracked and he saw the spark of life darken in his eyes.

But going to prison wasn’t something he ever wanted.

And killing himself wasn’t in the cards either, when Will had taken his gun from him with Grissom’s blessing.

Every few minutes, it seemed, he would feel a flash of anger at her, for getting in the way of what he wanted. But every so often, a moment of clarity would shine and remind him that she was doing what she thought was right. She cared for him. It would last a few seconds, until he remembered that Angie was dead. 

He didn’t realize they had left the gravesite.

He was in her car. Will was driving. 

“You hungry?” She asked softly, returning to the city.

He wasn’t. But he was thirsty. “Yeah.”

“Larry’s sound good?” He felt her eyes on him. She had been casting nervous glances in his direction regularly. It was annoying but he didn’t complain.

He nodded. 

She parked at their usual spot, entered the bar.

Larry had left two shot glasses and an unopened bottle of Jack Daniels where Hoffman sat. “On the house,” Larry gruffly spoke. “Condolences.”

Hoffman would have been touched. 

If he could feel anything at all.

He took the bottle, ripping the cap off, and began taking thick gulps straight, the liquid scalding his throat and burning his eyes.

He had finished half the bottle before he felt a wave of nausea.

He put the bottle back on the counter and leaned forward, willing himself not to start crying there. 

Will had her hand on his shoulder, squeezing it gently.

She didn’t say anything and he was grateful to her for that.

He sulked as the alcohol began to warm him and help take the edge off his pain. It was numbing and pleasant. It was the only thing that didn’t completely suck in his life.

Will poured him another glass and one for herself. 

He suddenly recalled a time when Angelina had poured him a glass of whiskey before. Back when he had first graduated from the Police Academy.

“Congrats, Mark!” She had grinned, wide mouthed and beautiful. “Got you this special scotch, aged for twelve years. Something I was saving for when you became this city’s ‘messenger of justice’.” 

He had been touched, knowing she had been on a tight budget, the both of them always had been.

“You didn’t have to get me that,” he told Angelina, but happily tasted the smooth warm oak flavored liquor. 

“Only the best for my big brother. You’re going to be such a good cop ever. You’ve always done the right thing, since we were little. You always stood up for the kids in the playground who were getting picked on. And you always will. You’re my hero. And I love you.”

Where was that bottle? He struggled to remember. And then he remembered. He and Will had drunk it dry on one of their movie nights, years ago, and remorse punched his gut.

He should have treasured it. He should have treasured everything he had ever received from Angie.

His vision blurred and he shoved his thumb and forefinger into his eyelids, willing them to stop getting so damn wet. No. Fucking stop. You don’t deserve to cry .

“Mark,” Will’s voice broke through, her fingers pressing into his upper arm, squeezing him back to reality.

“What?” He growled, not looking up to her.

“You should eat something.”

“Not hungry.”

They spent the rest of the evening in silence. Mark drank as much as he could before he forgot to remember to forget to remember. 

Somehow, he ended up back in his bed. He knew it had been Will who had put him there. 

 

Amanda Young

 

She could handle most of the symptoms of withdrawal. The paranoia. The confusion. The fever and sweats. The shaking. She just couldn’t handle the fucking pain. 

The pain was in the form of white hot pokers stabbing into the cartilage of her elbows and knees. Her joints felt as if the cartilage was composed of barbed spikes stabbing into her bones. She wanted to die, then and there.

Where the fuck is Cecil? She would gasp and curl into a ball as her body seized from the agony. “Where. The fuck. Are you?” She was breathless and desperate. She needed her fix.

“Shit, Mandy,” Cecil’s voice croaked over her. She tried to glare up at his beady black eyes and scream at him. Blame him for all of her suffering. 

He stood over her, looking nauseous himself. “Mandy. There’s a shortage right now. I can’t get anything.”

“Are you -,” she doubled over, rolling on the dirty floor, “shitting me?” She was crying, her face stained with soot and tears. “Just kill me. Please.”

Cecil licked his lips, looking afraid. “There’s this clinic. They can help with withdrawal.”

“Anything. Please. Just go.” She didn’t know what he was talking about but she wanted more than anything for it to end.

“You got to come with me.”

“I can’t.” She felt another jolt of hot pain and let out a gargled scream.

“Hey! You can. Unless staying here and riding this out is what you’d rather do.”

“Ugh. Fuck. No.” She was panting as she rolled over, trying with all her might to muster the strength to get off the ground. “Just. Drive.”

“Yeah, no shit.”

Somehow, she had managed to crawl up to her feet and with the help of Cecil, they climbed into his shitty car and drove for several blocks, until they were in the outskirts of the city. Homeward Bound Clinic’s sign burned into her retinas. She hated the font. She hated this entire world. 

“Come on. It’s first come, first serve.”

She gasped as she climbed out of the car, stumbling while holding her stomach. Cecil kept her balance. She briefly felt gratitude for him there. Sometimes, he wasn’t a total piece of shit. She somehow managed to walk the hundreds of years from the car through the doors, past some fellow junkies in the halls who was tweaking out, and landing in a cold steel chair. 

A waiting room.

The smell of rubbing alcohol and body odor was making her headache worse and her mouth water at the idea of what other substances were likely stored in the clinic.

She sat there, cringing and writhing in her oversensitive nerves, until she heard a gentle voice.

“Oh, dear. Let’s get you cleaned up.”

She looked up, twitching and trembling past her greasy hair. She saw an attractive blond woman with concern in her eyes and the faintest baby bump on her stomach.

“P-please,” she whispered, “just make this stop.”

The woman nodded, no judgment in her face. Only understanding and compassion. “My name is Jill. Come with me.”

Amanda half-believed she had died and this was an angel. She happily went with her, following her. If anyone can heal my pain, it would be her.

She didn’t know why she thought that but blamed her withdrawal delirium.

She was brought into a private patient room.

“Have a seat,” Jill told her, at the paper covered medical bed. She did so, her head fidgeting. It was cold in that room.

“You appear to be suffering withdrawal. Can you tell me what drugs you take?'' There was a glint from the clipboard and Amanda looked up to see the doctor was writing things down. She felt defensive but knew better than to resist.

“Heroin.”

She saw Jill’s lips thinned. “I’ll prescribe you methadone.”

“Yes. Thank you. Oh,” Amanda was literally crying tears of joy. “Thank you so much.”

“I’ll prescribe you just enough to get you out of the woods. But you’ll need to stick to the dosage. Here,” Jill had dug out of her pocket a bottle of pills, taking out what looked like a single pill. She handed it to Amanda before turning to the sink to pour a glass of water. “This should kick in about thirty minutes. You’ll feel a lot better then.”

Amanda didn’t need the glass of water, instead dry swallowing with eagerness. It would be the longest thirty minutes of her life. 

“You can stay in here.” Jill turned to a corner chair where wool blankets were folded. She took one and wrapped it around her shoulders. “Would you like me to stay with you? Or something to read?”

Amanda’s eyes began to tear up. This woman was so damn nice. It hurt her, feeling as though she wasn’t worthy of such kindness. “I’m just going to try to sleep”

Jill nodded, understanding. “Sure thing. I’ll check in. If you need anything, just come out and ask one of the nurses.”

Amanda nodded. Jill had left, the door clicking shut. She hadn’t said thank you fast enough.

Shame gripped her, tightly in the throat and she found herself weeping into the blankets.

Never again , Amanda promised herself. I’m getting clean after this. I’m never touching the stuff ever again. I’m going to clean up. Get my shit together. This is the last time.

John Kramer

 

John enjoyed walking through dilapidated buildings, finding old structures falling apart romantic. This latest building he purchased had so much potential. He would convert the old hospital rooms into private studios that were affordable for the many struggling citizens of their city.

“We’ve secured the zoning permits,” Art Blanck swaggered ahead, looking clean in his bright blue suit and colorful paisley tie. “Had to pull a few strings but it’ll be worth it. All we’re waiting for is your blueprints and approval to begin construction. I have a couple of firms eager to offer their services. Tax cuts sure bring in a crowd. Who knew?” Art was smirking, looking very satisfied with himself.

John always found his old college roommate both brilliant and self-serving. It was fortuitous that they got along despite their fairly different life goals. But honestly, if it weren’t for Jill, John would have likely joined Art in all his schemes, driven solely by the number of zeroes that would be granted from a project. 

He hoped Art would one day see more than that. He still had faith that there was good in Art. He was just blinded by greed.

John paused when he saw a flicker of a shadow. The surprised stare of a dirty face followed by the pattering footsteps let him know that this building had not been completely vacated yet.

“Fucking layabouts,” Art cursed, shaking his head. “Looks like we’ll need to get some security to keep the squatters out.”

“They’re the very people this building will hopefully house,” John whispered, not particularly caring if the homeless used the structure for shelter for the time being. But it would be dangerous as soon as they began building. Most of the structure was being demolished.

“Can’t start building if people are around. It’s against the law,” Art explained. “Look, I know you feel for the unfortunate. But their presence will delay construction.”

“Then find a way to reshelter them,” John turned to his lawyer, knowing he was fully capable of coming up with a solution if motivated. 

There was an awkward pause but Art cleared his throat. “Sure thing, John. I can come up with a way.”

John nodded. “Good.” He changed the subject, turning to look at an old elevator that was long ago out of commission. “I agree though, that security will protect people from sneaking in and getting hurt. This building needs a lot of work. The elevators will need to be restored. And we’ll need to perform tests that the structure is sound.”

“Maybe it’ll be easier to just raze the place and start from scratch.” Art muttered under his breath.

John watched him, thinking that was a rather peculiar thing to suggest.

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

 

Baxter’s lawyer was a real son of a bitch.

Will had plenty of evidence. Seth Baxter’s DNA was all over the crime scene. But they didn’t have the murder weapon. It’s likely at the bottom of the river. That would hurt things. There was also the issue with Baxter claiming that Mark had assaulted him and threatened him. It definitely wouldn’t make it easier to lock him up. The jury could paint him in a sympathetic light. 

Who knew Baxter’s relatives were financing a competent defense attorney, in this economy ? The world was unfair.

Will needed a confession from him. It was the only way to guarantee his conviction.

He looked as though he was proud, smirking up at her in the interrogation room as his lawyer studied his notes through thick reading glasses.

“So, Seth,” Will had to play the charming interrogator. She was the good cop, the sweet cop. She batted her eyes and gave him the biggest charming smile she could. “I appreciate you taking the time to talk to me.”

“Yeah, not like I have a choice.” Seth pulled at the collar of his jailbird jumpsuit, the bright orange making him look sallow. 

“Well, Angelina is dead. And we need answers. I know you can help us with that, Seth. Don’t you want Angie’s family to have answers?” She did everything she could to not think about her own feelings. She pretended Angelina was another victim. It helped.

She could feel Mark’s eyes on her, through the one-way mirror, and already knew he likely detested her ability to play this role. 

Angelina Acomb had not been a friend that had dined with her, gossiped with her, shopped with her. This Angelina Acomb was equivalent to a Jane Doe. A stranger. Another poor person in her many hundreds - no, thousands of poor anonymous persons she had investigated in her long career. 

“Look. Angel was my sweetheart. Why would I want to hurt her?” Seth, despite the tough guy persona he was struggling to keep acting as, had a haunting shadow over his face and a heavy fatigue weighing his shoulders down.

“Well, remember that warrant that let us take your hair, blood, and urine?”

“Yeah.”

“Well, we ran more than DNA tests.”

The lawyer looked up, finally, with interest.

“What tests?”

“Drug tests, Seth.” Will allowed Seth to squirm under her scrutiny. He scratched the back of his head suddenly, his legs fluttered and his arms crossed. He was anxious. On edge.

“I do not recall the warrant you provided included toxicology tests,” the lawyer sounded furious.

Will winked at him, smiling coyly. “Read it again.”

The man humphed and flapped through the many documents he had in his briefcase. Baxter didn’t wait for the man to allow him to speak.

“So?”

“We found phencyclidine in your system, Seth.”

His eyes narrowed. The lawyer paused, looking at his client with shock. They sat in silence for over a minute. Will had counted, hoping Seth would break first. He remained frozen, looking like a deer in headlights.

“Also known as PCP. Angel Dust, Seth.” Will took out of her folder the lab reports, sliding them to his lawyer. “Side effects include delusions. Paranoia. Violent episodes.”

Seth’s eyes became saucers and he was visibly sweating.

“It was an accident,” he whispered. His lawyer looked flabbergasted.

“Not another word,” the lawyer instructed. “We need a couple of minutes, detective.”

She shrugged, acting as nonchalant as possible. “Sure. I’ll give you five. Just so you know, a jury is going to see all these facts. With a confession, it’ll only do you good, Seth.You may even get parole.”

She got to her feet and left the room. The guard at the door walked in, briefing on relocation to a private room for lawyer-client deliberation. She walked to the adjacent room where Mark and Allison were waiting.

“No parole. And don’t make a deal,” Mark growled as soon as she entered.

“Don’t need to,” Allison interjected. “We got the bastard. Worry about the parole hearings if he survives a year locked up. His lawyer’s probably advising him to just confess.”

“He won’t without some deal. I want him locked away for life.” Mark’s arms were crossed and he glared menacingly at Seth Baxter through the glass. The guy was getting up and walking out of the room, casting nervous glances in the direction of the looking glass. His jaw twitched and Will could only imagine half the fantasies going through Mark’s mind. It was obvious he wanted to do a lot more to Seth Baxter than just throw him in jail and lock away the key.

It was a shame they didn’t have the death penalty in their state. Maybe then, Mark would find some satisfaction in the upcoming legal battles ahead.

Notes:

A/N: Got back from a work trip, hope this post makes up for the delays! More prep for SAW movie-canon!

Chapter 38: Pre:SAW - The Beginning of the Beginning

Summary:

We set the stage for these star-crossed killers.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Lindsey Perez

When she heard the apartment door’s tumbler click, Lindsey stiffened, her finger twitching for her gun. She stilled herself, still waking from her nap, the foreign green walls and unfamiliar floral upholstery providing comfort. She wasn’t back in Virginia. She was staying at her friends’ place.  

The next click of the knob lock and the leisurely pace the door swung open had her already suspecting the person responsible. It wasn’t likely Will, who was currently devoting all her waking free time as Hoffman’s emotional support. Will had barely shown her face since Lindsay had come to stay.

The FBI Agent was taking a sabbatical. It had been planned for a while now, this break from murders, kidnappings, and violence. Ally, Will, and she were supposed to be sipping mojitos at some hot springs in Arkansas, but when Angelina Acomb’s murder uprooted all intentions for a break, the trip had been canceled.

Lindsey decided to still use her paid time off, to at least keep the flames of her and Ally’s romance alive. Will didn’t mind - didn’t have the attention span to - and Strahm had asked Lindsay to check in on her every so often on his behalf. She owed her partner a favor or two. 

But the true, raw reason she decided to muscle her way into Ally and Will’s lives despite the inconvenient time, was because she needed a break from Strahm.

Ever since the Heart Stealer case, he had become suffocating. Overprotective. Unhinged. His constant fawning over her had been stifling. He called every day with the same questions. And his temper, which had always been on a shorter size of fuse, had left her feeling like she was walking across a landmine field whenever they conversed.

“Are you safe? When are you getting back to Quantico? Do you keep your gun on you at all times?”

He was treating her like a rookie and a little sister, all at the same time and it was starting to piss her off. 

Your mom worries about you ,” Strahm would say, and Lindsey knew her mother, too, often liked using Peter as her own personal spy on the goings ons of her daughter.

How’s Ally? ” That question usually got a guaranteed hangup these days. Especially when it came to her love life, she wanted her mother out of her business.

“Hey, hon,” Ally sounded tired, shrugging out of her jacket and unbuckled her shoulder holster. “You didn’t need to wait for me.” Ally had put her right hand behind her back, as if trying to conceal something. She made out the faint white glossed bag of a jewelry shop.

Suddenly on high alert, and taking advantage of Ally’s sluggishness from a long day at work, she swiped the parcel and jumped back with a smirk of triumph.

Ally had barely tried to stop her and looked more amused than exasperated. “I know how you hate surprises, but damn, I really wanted to make this one.”

She dug through the yellow tissue paper, pulling out a long velvet jewelry box. Inside, a delicate gold chain glinted up at her.

“It’s not flashy, but happy anniversary, Linds.”

It looked real, the yellow glinting. She threw her arms around Ally’s neck, pressing her lips firmly on her soft cheek. “It’s perfect. I love it. I’ll wear it always.”

At least Ally didn’t treat her like a kid. And that was everything to her.

 

Amanda Young

How many times had she shown up to this clinic? More times than she could count. Every time she left with pills to help her get over the shakes and aches, promising this would be the last time. She was starting to catch onto herself. The dirty little liar.

There was never going to be a last time.

This was just how it was. She smiled at the nice doctor, who was now looking ready to pop from the size of her swollen belly. Her eyes held a firmness Amanda recognized. It was the same look everyone in her life gave her now. 

Wariness.

“Amanda,” Dr. Tuck trailed off as she studied her clipboard. 

Ah, yes, a long history of opioid abuse and broken dreams. Yes, and you will take the usual? Actually, I’d like to try Lucemyra this round. Excellent choice.

“Amanda?”

She blinked. How long had she been thinking to herself? She had no idea. She had begun to lose track of time, escaping into her mind. It helped distract from the stares of judgment and disgust. Everyone had to wear their opinions with deep frowns and narrowed eyes. 

Yes, escape in herself was the best tool she had. It did little with the damn throbbing in her joints though. “Please, doc. I just need…”

“Amanda, we’ve been over this. I need you to consider attending some group therapy sessions.”

“Fuck that. I’m not doing that.”

“They’re very helpful.”

Her arms were trembling and despite the shame burning her guts and keeping her face down to the floor she jumped up with renewed energy and anger. “That’s just some bullshit. Just give me. What I need.”

“I’m telling you what you need,” she was not saying this with accusation. Dr. Tuck was gentle. Compassionate. But Amanda was a junkie. And withdrawal made her the nastiest bitch. She was tired of asking. She just wanted the damn pills. Why wouldn’t this quack just give them to her?

“I’ve had enough,” she growled and rushed out of the room, beelining to the exits. Fuck this. Fuck everything.

She stepped out to the waiting room where Cecil, too, had had enough.

“FUCK MAN! I’ve been here for three fucking hours!” She walked around the corner, seeing Cecil get palm smacked across the face. She knew it was time to ditch this place.

She snuck out while Dr. Tuck ran towards the brawl. The woman’s shrill voice followed Amanda as she pushed through the emergency exit doors. 

“Stop it! Please, stop it!” 

 

Mark Hoffman

He believed he heard his watch ticking away. But it must have been a hallucination.

He was barely sober - barely awake - but he listened with keen ears.

“We, the verdict, find the defendant…” time had stood still. The ticking had drowned into white noise. He could not breathe. His eyes stung as he stared, unblinking, at the foreperson who looked solemnly down at the paper.

Say it. Fucking say it already.

They had only deliberated for twelve hours. It was short. That usually guaranteed a guilty verdict. Usually. But Mark couldn’t consider it. He couldn’t dare to hope.

Will had placed her cool hand on his, squeezing it gently. Like a defiant spirit, she moved despite the rest of the room remaining petrified. He felt as though he was watching the scene outside his body. He watched as he watched himself, the baggy eyes and greasy hair, watching with complete disconnection that it could have been strangers he was observing. 

His palm felt wet. He realized the pain he was feeling was from his fingernails cutting into the meat of his hand. He had curled his fingers into a fist so tight, his arm was trembling and a drop of blood trailed down and stained the cuff of his shirt.

“Guilty.”

The life left his lungs. Will continued to securely hold him, her touch the only sensation that kept him tethered to his body. The word echoed in his mind. Guilty. He was trying to register what it meant.

The court proceedings continued and the realization made the lead in his lungs suddenly soften to air. Guilty. They fucking did it.

“Juror 864. Is this your verdict?”

“Yes.”

“Is this still your verdict?”

Guilty. He had thought he would be overjoyed. He was waiting for all the pain to simply stop. He would be patient for a little more. Any moment, it would come.

Guilty. It was exactly what he wanted. The right word.

And Seth Baxter, the bastard that had taken away the only family he had left, who had snuffed out his Angie, his baby sister, was crying as his defense attorney tried to console him. Seeing that, he had feelings beyond pleasure.

Guilty

Something was missing. Though glad that justice was served, that justice was working , a part of him knew it would not make him whole. That word just wasn’t enough to bring Angie back.

But it would have to do.

Justice would keep Baxter behind bars, to never rob another family or ruin another life.

“Are there any post trial motions?” The judge sat back, looking bored. This was just another day at work. As routine as a daily shower and shave.

“Yes, your honor,” the defense attorney stood and Mark narrowed his eyes, feeling his neck and ears burn. But he remained stoic and controlled. For some reason, it was easier these days to stay still despite the strong desire to rip everything apart with his bare hands. Because today, justice was being served. Angelina could rest in peace. 

“We request a motion for a mistrial and set aside the verdict, under the grounds of the previous proceedings as mentioned prior.”

This made him swallow. Will’s hand tightened over his wrist. It did little to ease his worry.

“Your honor, the verdict is proper.”

Two uniformed officers stood, on each side of the man who murdered his sister. “Upon review, the evidence of guilt is overwhelming. Mister Baxter, you have been found guilty of the count of murder, one count of possession of the weapon to commit the crime, and possession of Schedule II narcotics. The loss and grief you have incurred demands justice. Thus, I sentence you to life in prison.”

The courtroom had become a vacuum. Mark heard the faint wail of a woman break through. Turning, he saw Baxter’s mother, who had her face buried in her husband’s shoulder, the parents devastated.

He felt nothing for them. No pity, no understanding. They raised a killer. A scum sucking parasite who had leached on Angelina and had decided if he couldn’t have her, no one would. 

The gavel erupted in a crack that echoed off wooden walls. It was a good sound, a final sound.

It was done.

He turned to Will, to the last person in his life he could trust. “Thank you.”

She nodded, grave, her eyebrows pushed up, a tear welling up in her eye. She, too, was hurting. He took her in his arms, savoring the warmth and comfort of her body. 

He wouldn’t forget that it was her that had stayed by his side throughout it all. The occasional break in the clouds, she was a brief ray of sunshine that kept him holding on to sanity. And she had kept her promise.

She had done it her way, the inefficient yet right way. The by-the-book way. And, in the typical Will Maddox fashion, she had pulled through with an effortlessness he used to disbelieve.

Now that it was finally over, maybe he could heal. It had been two years. And he knew he had neglected their relationship, drowning in his self pity. All he did these days after work was go home, drink, and find himself passed out with his shoes off on the couch and a glass of water on his coffee table. 

Two years of him being so self-absorbed and she still stayed with him.

“Come on, Mark, let’s go,” she pulled away, wanting to leave that room. He knew she would want to not look back. It was who she was, not one to dwell too long on the pain of the past.

He wanted to be like her, in that regard, but wondered if he had it in him to move on now that it was all over.

He had to try. For her.

 

John Kramer

He should have been concerned, when Jill had been seven minutes late. That had never happened before. He was going to go to her, to help her close, until the prostitute slammed against his car door with sultry smile and desperate eyes. He had told her to leave, respectfully.

“Honey, I can show you how nice a girl I can be.”

“Go home,” he had repeated, Jill temporarily forgotten as he assessed whether this prostitute was going to try to rob him. Should he roll the windows up and lock the doors? He didn’t bring a gun and had no weapon to defend himself.  It was a terrible neighborhood. And the city had begun to boil over in the past few months. 

He feared at any minute, Jill would stroll out and witness the scene and that was the last thing he wished was for his close-to-term pregnant wife seeing him in this predicament.

Finally, the woman left him and he saw Cecil run out of the clinic like a bat out of hell, arms flailing, looking terrified. John knew, deep in his soul, that something was terribly wrong. 

He got out of his car and sprinted to his wife. He pushed through the front doors and ran by the stairs, jumping over trash bags left out, towards the glass windows of the Homeward Bound Clinic. 

Jill .

He pressed his hand against the glass, staring down at her. She was wailing, her face contorted in pain. The bright red on her white skirt froze him to the glass.

“No,” he whispered as he rushed to open the door. Please , he prayed, let them be alright. Please . “Jill,” he knelt down to her. There was so much blood. Too much. It was on his hands and stomach. It dripped on the floor. There was too much of it.

She only has three weeks left. The baby is so close. 

“Can you stand?”

She wailed. “I can’t feel him,” she sobbed, “he’s not kicking, John!” 

He had to suppress the panic. Pick her up. Get her to the hospital. Now. He listened to the rational side of him, the part of him that helped pull him through the worst of times.

But his worst of times had never been so dire. Don’t think on that. Just get her to the hospital.

He could carry Jill, easily, and up two mountains if it meant Gideon would live. He couldn’t run fast but he walked as quickly as he could, taking Jill out of the building and towards his car.

Please. Let Gideon live.

 

Amanda Young

Shit! Holy shit!

She was trembling as she drove the car, the rain making it impossible to see. But she would not stop. Not for the two red lights she had passed through. When did it start fucking raining?

She would not press the brake. Not for the bum that had stepped in front of her car, which she had somehow avoided clipping while he screamed out at the two of them in a brief passing of sound. She heard the shatter of glass behind them, flinching. 

The bastard had thrown something at them. 

“Mahna,” the muffled voice coming from the distance garbled through the white noise of the radio and the patter of fat raindrops on the windshield.

“Manda! Stop!” 

She jumped and slammed the break, the car skidding and fishtailing before hissing to a stop. How the hell she was so damn lucky with the driving when she was riding withdrawal and guilt for murdering a woman’s baby was beyond her.

“Let me drive.” Cecil, rarely, looked disturbed. But at that moment he looked fucking mortified. His dark eyes were wide. His mouth agape. She could practically read his thoughts.

We fucked up big time, Manda.

A car blared its horn and passed them, making her jump again before slamming the car shifter into park. “Fine. Fuck!” She got out into the rain, knowing no matter how much the droplets stung, it wouldn’t clean the metaphorical blood off her shoulders. Her hands. 

Cecil may have slammed the door, but it was because she had made him go. She had grabbed his dick and forced him to go.

The events played in her head, over and over.

“She’s been good to us.”

“I’ve been good to you. Please.”

Please . She still had an inkling of hope. Maybe it would all be fine? The husband came through and got her, while they snuck out the back. They hadn’t left her alone. She had help. The doctors would fix her. Hell, she bet a pregnant doctor could figure out a way to save herself. Right ?

She wanted to believe so.

 

Peter Strahm

“I don’t know about you,” his partner, Dan Erickson, yawned and leaned back in his seat, loosening his tie, “but I can’t wait to get back to Quantico. This city stinks.”

Peter smirked back. “Come next promotion cycle, you’ll regret taking these work trips for granted. You’re going to be tethered to your desk for the rest of your career.”

“Oh, I’ll get around. I can’t let you have all the fun, hotshot.”

Peter would miss Dan. He was sharp in the interrogation room and a calming presence when things got too hot for Peter. Especially these days, when Lindsey would start butting heads. But he wouldn’t stop him from being promoted to his supervisor. He was a couple years ahead and getting to the point in his life where he was just barely keeping up with the physical fitness assessments. 

“So, that’s the last of them? You don’t have any last minute prisons you want to drive out to?”

“We’ve compiled enough profiles for the database. The techies say that in another five years, every office on the continent will be able to access it. What a time to be alive.” Dan looked more tired and suddenly like the old man he kept claiming he was. “Computers still make my head hurt.”

“Come on, you liked Pong when it first came out?”

“I’m not that old! Speaking of age, you good with Perez taking my spot?”

“It’s what I prefer. We have good rapport.” It was a good way to keep an eye on her, making their partnership official. “Besides you, she’s one of the most trustworthy agents I know.”

“That’s saying a lot.” Despite Dan’s neutral tone, Peter caught on to the twitch in his mustache. Dan didn’t approve of Lindsay’s ‘lifestyle’. He was a bit too old fashioned.

“You and her, I’d take a bullet for.”

“And the others?”

“Depends on my mood.”

They both laughed. “Well, you want to grab some beers before crashing?”

Peter shook his head. “I have a friend I want to meet up with.”

Dan raised an eyebrow. “Oh? A lady friend?”

Peter shrugged. “Just a friend. Who happens to be a lady. She’s already spoken for.”

“Hmm,” the way his partner sounded, there was that silent comment of disapproval thick in his tone. “Married?”

“No.” But by how long their relationship has been, might as well be.

“Then there’s still hope.” Dan smacked his back. “Keep your nose clean. I’ll see you at the airport tomorrow morning.”

“Night, Dan.” 

While Dan took off with their rental car, Peter went to the nearest payphone on the corner of the city street, dialing her number from memory.

It was Saturday, her off day, but there was a low chance she’d be on duty. After a few long rings, he got voicemail.

“Hey, you’ve reached Ally and Will,” Allison’s voice was low and husky, almost more so than usual as if to allure to random callers, “You know what to do.”

“This is Peter. Strahm. Hey, Will, if you’re around, page me. I’ll be at this bar called the Dead Rabbit on Water Street-,”

“Peter? When did you get here?”

He smiled, her voice filling him with soothing nostalgia. “Hey, Will, been a while. I happened to be in town on assignment. You free?”

A deeper, male voice broke through the happy moment. 

“Well,” Will trailed off and a muffled exchange that sounded heated followed. 

Peter frowned. 

“Go ahead,” the unmistakable growl from Hoffman. “I’ll see you tomorrow.”

“Wait,” the distant protest from Will, “Mark!” 

A slam of a door. 

Peter grimaced. It was clear, despite almost five years since the Heart Stealer case, that Hoffman still didn’t think much of him. 

A flash of guilt kicked Peter in the gut for rocking the boat. But another part of him, the more selfish defiant part, swelled with a masculine pride. You threatened by me, Hoffman? Peter knew it was toeing the line of delusion that he maintained a flicker of hope on something more with Will, after all this time. It was low brow, but frankly, he didn’t give a fuck these days. 

He was in his forties now, and Hoffman still hadn’t put an end to Will’s availability. He hadn’t heard the ring of wedding bells anytime soon. Linds had never dropped any bombshells on diamond rings or bridesmaid drama. He was confident that Hoffman was just sitting on his hands when it came to popping the big question and whisking Will away to the happily-ever-after she deserved. The idiot.  

But still, at that moment, Peter was calling just as a friend. He needed to remember that. “Sorry, guess I shouldn't have called.”

“No, no, Mark’s fine. He’s just been on edge lately, with Seth Baxter’s latest appeal.” Her voice had a tremor he had never heard before. It was so subtle but he had an ear for these changes. She was straining to sound cheerful. It had a forced lilt to it.

“Well, if you want to come out tonight, drinks are on me. You can tell me all about it.” You can tell me anything, Will.

“Sure,” the tremor faded, followed with relief. “I’m on my way.”

He made sure they had a decent table by the front windows and watched young couples linked at the elbows, enjoying the warm summer evening. He felt a pang of nostalgia for Jessica and how she would drag him out on walks when he didn’t feel like it, griping but obliging her. I should have complained less , he fumed and sipped his drink. He should have done a lot of things differently, when he was younger.

The familiar pang of loss and emptiness had him clear his throat, distracting himself with thoughts of what must have transpired for Will since they had teamed up to take on serial killers together. He was glad that the country had been experiencing a lull in serial murders, but he missed how they brought them all together. What had happened after they captured the Heart Stealer? 

She had to leave for Hoffman’s friend’s suicide. Knox was his name. And not long after, his sister died. 

The man had rotten luck. 

Peter began to remember why he never tried harder with Will. He had kept his distance this long, partly out of respect but mostly out of pity for Hoffman. Will was probably one of the few good things in his life. As a man, he felt it went against some moral principle, something unspoken but instinctual, to meddle with that.

But he was lonely too. And no other woman captured his intrigue and attention quite like-

“Hey, Peter,” Will’s voice had him rise to his feet and he turned to smile, captivated by the dark freckles and orange curls. Pippi Longstocking, all grown up . They hugged and right away he could feel the bones in her shoulders and spine.

He suppressed the frown and they sat, him probing the notable lines under her eyes and the haggard way she held herself, as if she was about to collapse from exhaustion. She was still beautiful but looked as though she was not being taken care of.

“Geeze, you’re not saying anything,” she shrugged and forced a small laugh. “I look that bad?”

“I wasn’t going to say anything, but yeah. You’ve seen better days. You okay?” He leaned forward, wanting to put his arms around her and comfort her. 

She kept the tough girl routine, pursing her lips and forcing a grin. She lit a cigarette, taking a long drag. “I’ve had worse.”

He raised an eyebrow but the waitress came by to take her drink order, giving him time to process this. All pity he felt for Hoffman evaporated away. If he hadn't known, he would have been under the impression that it was Will who had lost her sister. Despite not seeing her in years, he had been confident in his reading of her character and her being so drained from this ordeal meant Hoffman was taking every bit of life force out of her.

The bastard’s bad news. I knew this.

He knew her history. Her tastes. She had a tendency to gravitate towards men who used her, the hairs on the back of his neck standing as he promptly went through the mental checklist he always had ready to go. He searched for any sign of abuse. Bruises, cuts, her body language sinking into itself, the need to defend.

She ordered a glass of Bordeaux, another notable difference in her typical preference of whiskey sours or long island ice teas. “I’ve been cutting back,” she answered his silent question, the both of them able to read each other a little too well. “I know what you’re thinking. And please, spare me your shrink talk. I don’t want tonight to be a therapy session.” 

“Then why bother coming here, to me, your friend the shrink?”

It was one of the benefits of their lines of work, the ability to fully understand each other without needing to say much. Despite the years apart, it was like putting on a well loved pair of shoes. But the other side of that sword was that they couldn’t hide their feelings, even when they wanted to. The shoes sometimes pinched.

They just locked eyes until Will sighed and wallowed like a wilted flower, bowed her head, and covered her eyes with her hand. He put a hand on her shoulder. 

“Hey,” he softly cooed, “I’m here, now. It must be hard, dealing with all this.” With him.

“You don’t know the half of it,” she sniffled, wiping her cheeks and looking down at the table. “I feel like something bad’s coming. And I know it’s going to be all my fault.”

This alarmed him. “Will, what are you talking about?”

She was chewing her lip, looking as though she was one of his suspects in interrogation, about to confess a terrible crime. Why was that?

“I did something. That’s been eating me up.”

He could only imagine the wild scenarios. “Professionally, or personally?”

“Both. Oh, it’s such a mess.”

“Start from the beginning.”

“There isn’t a beginning. There was just Seth Baxter and him needing to go to jail.” 

He now understood. Ah, she broke some rules . For a stubborn, moral-leaning person like Will, this was likely weighing heavily on her. “What did you do to make sure he went to jail?”

“It’s not something I thought would be a big deal at first. Just threw on additional tests prior to the paperwork being filed. I expected the judge would eventually sign off on the warrants. But she never did. Only DNA. No toxicology, until later. The dates are wrong. Most lawyers wouldn’t catch it. But Baxter’s are breathing down my neck about it. I’ve got maybe two months tops before it all comes blowing up in my face. I haven’t told Mark. But I’m so fucking afraid that they’re going to consider a mistrial.”

“That won’t be for another few years, though. There’s still time.” For what, Peter wasn’t sure. City police was not his bureaucracy. And he hadn’t ever been in a situation like hers. “Will.” Normally, he would have lectured that she did a wrong thing, going to such lengths. That it was beneath her.

He had always seen her as a person who would never bend her code of ethics. But that was an unfair pedestal he had put her on. It hurt, knowing that for Mark Hoffman and him alone, she had been willing to break the rules.

“I know, I should turn myself in. But then Baxter will walk. I can’t have him do that. I promised Mark.”

He clenched his jaw. She was unraveling before him. Wiping her cheeks and trembling. People were watching. “Maybe we should get out of here. Go somewhere quiet. I can help you with some breathing exercises.”

“No, no therapy. Not right now. I - I just want to sit here, have a drink with my friend.” She took her wine glass and downed it, a pained grin pulling her cheeks as her eyes glittered. “So, what got you coming all the way out here? Come on, spill.” Her mask was back on, spunky cop girl, acting as though she hadn’t just cried in front of him.

It was as if she had slapped him but he kept his composure. Friends. That’s all. “Sure, Will, whatever you want.” All he could do was play her game, dance to her terms. He hated seeing her like this, so frayed, but he could do nothing but watch. 

She just wouldn’t let him in.

 

Mark Hoffman

He knew he had acted childish, storming out like that. But seeing how she had lit up at the sound of that prick’s voice and picked up the phone with a smile had struck a primal chord in him. It had made him feel small. It was petty jealousy, pure and simple. Irrational, because he was confident Will would never betray him.

Yet if he had faith in her loyalty, why was he there? He couldn’t explain to himself why he had followed her, like a common stalker, his Crown Vic shadowing her in the distance as she walked to the bar. She wasn’t dressed to attract, which helped relax his knotted stomach. She had thrown on her everyday jacket, no bright lipstick or change in appearance from when he had left her.

But she had still gone out. Without him. This used to not bother him. She was a looker. And she was his .

Even after her fortieth birthday - which she insisted to not make a big deal out of because she was so damn insecure about her age - she still turned heads. Now, on their usual rounds of cases, he felt nervous when a young smooth-faced rookie would flash her a smile looking trim in his uniform. She was desirable. And though this used to be a point of pride, he had grown paranoid at the side glances of the boys in the office to the point he almost wished she wasn’t so damn beautiful. 

 

At least then, she would only be his and no one else would want her to take her from him.

Lately, he had become… needy. He needed to know where she was when she wasn’t with him. He needed her by him, promising she would stay with him. He had even suggested she move in with him. 

It was her hesitance that had worsened the possessiveness he had developed as of late. “Mark, are you sure? I mean, I’m just settled with Ally. I don’t want to break the lease. How about when it ends, we’ll talk about it?”

He didn’t understand why she had resisted. He believed she was hiding something from him and he didn’t enjoy not knowing what it was. He didn’t know if he could handle whatever it was she was concealing from him. He suspected it involved another man. Which meant he’d have to take care of this man.

Will was all he had left. He wasn’t about to lose her. And he wasn’t going to lose her.

He trusted her. Will was loyal to him.

So why was she out tonight?

There was a small doubt planted in his head and it was taking root. 

Why else would she go out, if she didn’t have feelings for Strahm? 

What made it worse was Strahm looked exactly the same despite the years. Tall, slim, good-looking bastard.

Mark hated the way he looked these days, the long months of binge drinking and him no longer in his twenties taking its toll on his waistline. Just another reason getting old sucked.

And Will was out, having drinks with her old FBI colleague instead of with him. And it looks like she was crying? He cursed himself for not bringing binoculars. But he squinted. Why was she crying ? And the bastard put his hand on her.

Don’t touch her. She’s mine.

He gripped the steering wheel but stayed seated in his car. His jaw was hurting and his vision was starting to burn into a faint red film. But he kept still. There wasn’t much he could do, at the moment.

But Peter Strahm was a dead man. He just didn’t know it yet.

 

Jill Tuck

The sun didn’t feel warm, even with the heat wave warning proclaimed in the news. She sat in her wheelchair, wondering when it would begin to feel like sunshine again. It felt like snow. 

She felt so empty, Gideon no longer inside of her. She missed his kicking. She missed knowing he was on the way. That he was going to be hers.

A tear slipped down her cheek but she didn’t bother to wipe it.

John sat beside her, on the bench as they stared blankly at the birds that tweeted and skipped on bush branches without a care in the world. 

She wished she could have joined them, to turn into a bird and forget all of this had happened.

She had just wanted to help them. She wasn’t sure if she could go back to the clinic after all of this. Cecil. Why? Why was he so rushed? Why?

“Jill,” John whispered, “Let’s go back inside. You’ll get sunburned.”

She blinked and looked up. John, sparing her the brunt of the rays, casted a shadow over her.

Oh, poor John. Despite all this pain, he somehow managed to push through it and look after her. But he barely looked at her, now. She knew he blamed her, despite never saying it out loud. She could feel his resentment, in the way he only lightly touched her hand when it was absolutely necessary. Something between them was severed.

Gideon. That was the connection.

He had been so careful with this baby. He had it all surveyed and foreseen. He had told her to take a break from the clinic. To stay at home, until the baby was born, for safety.

“I hate seeing you, there, when those junkies and lowlifes brandish their knives just because they can’t stand waiting a couple of fucking hours.”

“John, they’re in pain.”

“They’re causing others pain. They’re causing you pain, Jill. That’s the whole motto of this clinic. Cherish your life. Well, cherish your life. Your life.”

And yet she hadn’t listened. She wanted to tell him that she was sorry. That he was right. But it wouldn’t change anything. It wouldn’t bring Gideon back.

John turned the wheelchair and pushed her back into the hospital, the dutiful husband he was. There were no further words shared between them.

 

John Kramer

His head was killing him these days. He ignored it, popping aspirin and focusing on helping Jill get better. He would sit with her while she stared at the television. The nurses said she would be cleared to leave in two more days. 

They also mentioned they would release Gideon’s remains for them to bury. 

The year of the pig. Renewal. Resurrection. Ruined. Robbed from them. And all that would remain would be a tombstone and a plot in a graveyard. 

You were taken too soon, my son.

When Jill slept, he fantasized what he would do to Cecil when he saw him again. He recalled a trip to Spain in his youth, before he had met Jill, to Galería de la Inquisición. A particular chair with sharp pins protruding from every seat, back, and arm rest surfaced from his memory. He imagined Cecil, strapped to it, bleeding out a slow and painful death. But he was no murderer. No, he would not kill Cecil, no matter how much the desire arose.

He liked to imagine forms of punishment. Especially when the police were of no help. He had filed the report but, like so many cases in this corrupt city, the case would be buried and run cold.

It was all John could do to resist flipping tables and screaming to the heavens a curse for their disregard to everything he had built.

He rubbed his temple, sighing at the sharp pain that dragged rusty nails from his skull down to his spine. Perhaps he’d need to speak to a therapist. It had to be psychosomatic, a phantom of the subconsciousness to cope with this trauma.

He would attend to these matters after he took care of Jill and Gideon. 

Jill had whispered, in passing the day before, “I’m so sorry, John. All I wanted to do was help them.”

She had no reason to apologize. Like the tide, a slow roiling anger built within him. It was Cecil and all of those like him who should apologize.

His son. His legacy. Were gone, forever.

And it was Jill, blameless in all of this, who begged for his forgiveness.

“You can’t help them. They have to help themselves.” He had whispered back to her, so only she could hear. 

 

Notes:

A/N: HOLY HELL I finally finished writing this chapter. It had several rewrites. Thank you for your patience. Work saps the creative energy from me and when I finally get a chance to write I suddenly find my diction all robotic and stunted. I hope my latest review/edits helped make it more interesting.

I hope I'm not making Hoffman and Strahm parallel too hard - I can't help but love triangle the eff out of 'em but I'm trying to make their psyches distinct and all.

Poor Will. She needs to start prioritizing herself more.
Kind of don't like Hoffman right now, but know that's how it's gotta be. TT_TT

Chapter 39: Pre-SAW: Death and Resurrection

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

John Kramer

He had chosen to sleep at his workshop after Jill was fully recovered. She would call, every morning and night, leaving voicemails for him. “ Please, I need you, John. Come home .”

But he couldn’t bear to pretend life was the same.

The funeral had left him drained and numb. Watching such a tiny coffin lower into the dirt destroyed all shred of hope he had in this world.

All that was left were his body and his cursed mind that reminded him of his failings.

He could not protect his wife and child.

“John?” When he heard her voice he froze in his chair. He was too tired to stand. Too weary to move. If they found him, so be it.

There were two pairs of footsteps echoing off the concrete. 

“What’s all this?” Art Blanck’s voice resonated. They were likely going through his latest drawings. Fine. Let them snoop . What difference did it make? There was nothing to hide. Nothing to protect.

He only wished they would stop making such damn noise. His headaches were perpetual these days, loud noises exacerbating the agony. 

“Don’t be mad.” Jill sounded afraid. 

“What?” The clatter of wood on concrete. “Hey, John, you alright?” Art Blanck’s voice, slick and smooth. He squinted up at the lawyer. Blanck’s expensive cologne made him want to gag. “You’re not, uh, returning any of my calls, buddy.” John could barely look up at him. “I’m sorry, I understand uh, what happened was a tragedy. But I gotta tell ya,” Art shot a look to Jill, who had wandered off, and if John had been just a little bit more himself, he would have gotten to his feet and told them both to leave.

But he was so tired. He wasn’t sure if this fatigue was due to his lack of sleep or if he was perhaps coming down with something. “Listen John, you know those buildings we’re working on–,”

“Take them. Give my share to Jill.” He wanted nothing to do with this conversation. Art and Jill were disturbing his peace. They were reminding him of so much hurt. Couldn’t they understand that?

“That’s not the way it works, John, you see we’re partners. Your designs are what makes those buildings special. We have forty families ready to move in. You hear me? Forty. All low income families. You can’t just walk away. You’re their savior, John.”

White hot anger rose up his throat and the bitter taste of bile hit his tongue. “Get the fuck out of here.” 

“What? Who you talking to? It’s me, John.” Art’s voice was delicate. Pitying.

His vision blurred but the anger helped him focus and the pain helped keep the anger red hot. “Did you hear what I said?” 

“Oh, I heard you, John,” Art’s face looked unmoved, almost challenging.

“Get the fuck…” his brain went black for a moment and he thought he was about to faint. “You heard me.” His voice was croaked and he needed a glass of water. But more than that, he needed everyone to just leave him alone. 

“Okay John,” Art looked displeased but resigned. “Take care of yourself. Give me a call when you’re feeling better.” Art strode out and Jill followed, her eyes burning into him. The squeaking door slammed shut, finally freeing him of their scrutiny.

He needed to make an appointment with the doctor. He needed something for these damn headaches.

 

Mark Hoffman

“Will, stop!” He shouted, panting as she sprinted far ahead of him. Fuck . Sweat poured down his neck and back. Why did he skip all those days at the gym? Why the fuck did he let himself get to being so out of shape? And now, his partner was going ahead to catch the perp, leaping over the edge of rooftops as if she was an olympic hurdler.

He wasn’t going to let her leave him behind. He pushed and gained on her, stepped on the raised level and jumped, not looking down and feeling his stomach dive down to his ass knowing they were at least fifteen stories up.

He felt his feet hit the angled slate and his trembling hands were supporting him as he caught his breath. This was more than dangerous. This was damned irresponsible . He was still just out of reach, his partner the next building over. “Will!” He shouted again, knowing it wouldn’t stop her.

He would have just pulled his gun out and shot the fucker in the back like back in the day but not with her watching. Below, the sirens announced the cavalry’s arrival. About damn time

The man seemed stuck because he stopped running and turned. Will lurched forward to grapple him but he managed to dodge her. And then he kicked her in the stomach.

No ! The force of the impact sent her flying back and she just barely avoided being tossed off the side.

That was the last straw. He took his gun out. “Freeze!” He knew he couldn’t lunge his thick ass across on this one. It was too far. And though his aim was good, it was a windy day.

Thankfully, this perp wasn’t an idiot. The guy turned to him and held his hands out.

“On your knees!” He shouted over the traffic, sirens, his pounding heart, and industrial cacophony below. “Now!”

Will had straightened and took her cuffs out, snapping them onto the bastard’s wrists while chanting the Miranda rights.

He lowered his gun, finally, a moment to catch his breath.

“Meet you down,” Will called out, steering their arrestee towards the nearest doors to bring him down to the ground level.

“No, wait for backup.” 

The guy had been a handful and was stronger than her. She needed him there.

But he couldn’t jump the distance between their buildings. He took his cell out, pressing the speed dial button to the call center. “We’ve got the suspect up on the roof at the building on third and Madison. The blue one.”

“Uh, copy. Got a building number?”

“No, we’re on the goddamn roof,” he snapped, hanging up and resuming his heavy breathing. 

Will looked exasperated. He hated that.

“We’re just going to sit tight?” The annoyance in her voice made him angry. Everything she had done today had been reckless and unnecessary. 

When back up finally arrived, officers in uniform took the suspect away and Will waved at him as she turned to follow. She smiled, looking pleased with herself. He turned, realizing the only way down for him was the fire escape.

After the long and grueling descent, he found her waiting for him, arms crossed, grinning. He kept his words to himself the rest of the day. They submitted their reports and went to his apartment.

It wasn’t until he closed the door that he turned to her.

“What the hell was that today?”

“What do you mean?” She turned to him, looking pleased and wild, her hair a mess. “That was such a rush!”

This added fuel to his fire. He put a hand on her arm and squeezed it. “You put yourself in danger for no good reason.”

She pulled, resisting. “Mark! Let go! You’re hurting me!” She looked at his fingers digging into her skin and looked back at him, doe-eyed and pleading. “Please.”

He loosened his grip but didn’t release her. “What did I say back there?”

She avoided his eyes. “The guy was going to get away.”

He leaned into her, his nose grazing her temple, teeth clenched, and repeated with a hiss, “ What did I say ?”

She looked up at him, pupils dilating, breathing hitched. “You told me to stop.”

“And why didn’t you?” He watched her, studying her face, daring her to challenge him.

Her chin tilted up and she, indeed, dared to challenge. “Because I’m doing my job.” She wrenched her arm out of his grasp and stabbed a finger against his sternum. “Don’t forget that I’m a cop first. Your girlfriend, second, when we’re on the clock.”

He didn’t like that. He narrowed his eyes. “Our relationship is second to you?”

“When we’re at work, yes. That’s when we’re partners , Mark. You should be thanking me for nabbing this guy. Not lecturing me on listening to you as if I’m some rookie. I’ve been a cop for as long as you have.” Her voice held the accusation that he knew all too well. “Stop treating me like I can’t function without you.”

“You can’t just go chasing suspects across buildings like you’re fucking catwoman, Will,” he backpedaled, going a more gentler approach. “It’s dangerous.”

“Yeah, comes with the territory.”

He clenched his jaw. She just didn’t get it. She wouldn’t listen. She never did. And today, he was done being patient with her. He grabbed each shoulder, wanting to shake her but resisting the urge. “Next time,” he whispered, “you wait. Understand?” He held no option in his voice and hoped she got the warning. “I can’t bear the thought of losing you, too.” He allowed this brief vulnerability to surface, swallowing.

She was looking at him now, wary. “Not your call, Mark. Not for this.” She looked conflicted, pain on her face. “I know you’re worried. But I won’t die on you. Okay?” She took his cheeks in her hands, rubbing her thumb from his chin to his lips. “I’m alive.”

He closed his eyes, taking a deep breath, sighing at the feeling of her soft skin brushing against his face. He leaned into her, smelling the fruity shampoo in her hair and pressed his mouth into the crook of her neck. “I know. Thank God.” He kissed her, tasting salt and sinking his teeth gently into her soft flesh.

She giggled, leaning into him, her breasts pressed against his chest, her hands running down his shoulders and chest and down to his belt. He felt her gently squeeze his balls in her hand and he let out a grunt of heated desire. 

Lust hit his lower stomach and he went to unbutton her blouse. “You know how hot you looked, sprinting after him?”

“Hmm, tell me,” she, too, had proceeded to help undress him, starting with his belt and then his pants. 

“Your hips swing back and forth, it’s fucking art.” Wanting to restore his wounded ego, he swiftly bent over to grip her ass and picked her up, swinging her and pressing her against the end table and the wall, knocking over mail and the ceramic bowl that held his keys. He heard the shatter but didn’t mind, the clamber only adding an urgency as he pressed his lips into hers, slipping his tongue to play.

She moaned and shrugged out of her shirt and he, no longer a patient man, tore down her bra so her breasts would pop out for him to grab and squeeze. They were soft, familiar, and his to feel and fondle whenever he wanted.

“You’re such a poet,” she worded in between kisses. He smirked and pulled down her elastic waistband, feeling the G-string strap on her hip bone. He pulled back.

“You’re wearing this to work?” His breathless voice was incredulous, the heat dampening, his mind reeling. 

“What?” She sounded confused, her eyes half-lidded and her lips swollen and pink. “So?”

He narrowed his eyes. “What for?”

“No reason. Feels sexy?” She cocked her head to the side. “What’s gotten into you, lately? Doesn’t the idea of me wearing naughty underwear at work not turn you on?” She dragged her fingers up and down his chest, returning to his cock to squeeze and caress. She bit her lip, unconcerned. “Mark, what’s wrong?”

“Don’t want guys at work checking out your ass. I don’t want to think that they can tell you’re wearing a thong.” He swallowed, knowing he sounded insane. But that was how he felt. 

“No one notices. I’m not taking my clothes off at work.”

That’s not the problem. They just have to look and see no seams on your ass to know . He wanted to argue but her fingers deftly pressing and rubbing, and then her spitting into her hand and returning to rub him faster, now slick and lubricated, made him shut his eyes as he was powerless to the overwhelming sensation of her touching him. 

“Maybe I’m hoping one day you’ll want to fuck me on your desk at work,” she softly teased, her voice sending shocks of lightning up his spine. “And I wear my best panties hoping that day is today. I was so disappointed when we got that call. It ruined my plans.”

He swallowed, opening his eyes to see Will in her sultry glory, looking down at freckled breasts and thick lashes, and the idea of bending her over his office desk and fucking her raw and hard made him growl in need.

He wanted to fuck her like that then and there but the narrow end table was not convenient. He pulled her up, feeling her wrap her legs around him and carried her into the bedroom, dropping her on the bed, pulling her ankles roughly towards him. He knelt down to lick her stomach, dragging his tongue down to the curve where her leg and hip met, taking the thin string of her underwear in his teeth and pulling hard at it. He felt it snap and she let out a gasp of protest but he ignored it, pulling her thighs to position her opening over his dick, enjoying how wet and slippery it felt, and the way her lips squeezed and resisted as he pushed himself inside of her.

He pushed until he was completely inside, their hips kissing, and her legs spread wide apart as he savored the feeling of her squeezing and pulsing around him. She gasped again, her fingernails digging into his backside. This was heaven. This was all his. He pulled out slowly before pushing into her again, deep and hard, wanting her to feel every inch of him as he did her.

“Mark,” she gasped, eyes shut tight, face contorted as if in pain. 

He was upon her, pressing into her, pulling and pushing, the feeling half pleasured and almost painful but she moaned and cooed and confirmed that she enjoyed it, too.

They knew each other’s bodies so well, after being together for so long. He knew how easy her knees could be pushed to touch her ears when he wanted to bend her and fuck her in just the right angle that left her in tears of ecstasy. He knew how she sometimes whined but never denied him when he would push a thumb in between her round cheeks, biting her nipples to the point he feared he would draw blood.

Lately, he had been rougher with her, but she never complained, nor showed any sign that she disliked what he did. After fast paced thrusts he found himself winded again, being reminded of their earlier physical activity of sprinting and leaping to help excuse his fatigue.

She took the opportunity to sit up and push him to get on his back, getting down off the bed to grip his manhood and take his length in her mouth, sucking him with slick tongue and warm lips. He groaned, her mouth heaven. She could suck cock like a professional and she almost had him coming before he grabbed a fistful of her hair and pulled her head back.

She could give him a look that was so dirty and depraved, he felt both giddy and terrified. “You like that, sucking my cock?”

“Mm-hm,” she huskily and eagerly tried to take his member back in her mouth but he wouldn’t let her. No. He wanted her to flounder first, to remember who was the one who had the strength. 

“Tell me how much you want my cock?”

“I want it so bad, Mark, it hurts. I love tasting your meat.” 

He let out a noise, pleased by her compliance. “That’s too bad. Get back on the bed. On all fours. I want to fuck your pussy.”

She obeyed him and he admired the glossy sheen of her lips and how his cock looked pressed in between them. He took her hips and pulled her onto him, sighing at her grinding her ass against him. He resumed thrusting into her, so hot and tight, and he knew he wouldn’t last long at this rate.

“Mark, choke me,” she gasped in the middle of his thrusts, and he hesitated, pausing his rhythm.

“You want that?” he whispered, half excited at the prospect.

“Please.”

She tossed her hair back, turning to him. He leaned over her back, wrapping his fingers around her neck and squeezed tightly, his cock twitching at the sensation of the lines of tendons on his fingertips. He returned to thrusting into her, his free hand cupping a breast and pulling at her nipple, and he threw his hips into each hump with all his strength.

Her pussy was compressing hard onto him and her gagging from his grip sent a fresh wave of power through him. He felt mighty euphoria course through him and he sank his teeth hard into her shoulder as he reminded her that he was there, and she was his.

“Mm!” She grunted, and when he pressed his mouth to her cheek he felt the warm wet salt of her tears. She reached back and dragged her fingernails across his balls and after a few more full bodied thrusts he couldn’t go any further and he felt the explosion of the orgasm punch through him and spill into her.

The two of them collapsed onto the bed, panting and soaked, Will turning to bury her face into his chest and Mark, pulling her close to him, knowing he would never let her go.

 

John Kramer

He had only gone to his primary provider to address the headaches. It was supposed to be a standard procedure. But after some bloodwork results came back, he was referred to a Doctor Lawrence Gordon. Oncology.

He knew what that meant. But he remained calm when he met with the man.

Doctor Lawrence Gordon was a man with little empathy as he leaned back in his chair, twirling his pen around his fingers, staring at the window as though he was fantasizing about some fishing trip.

“Doctor,” Kramer whispered, wanting some eye contact. 

Gordon blinked and looked embarrassed. “Sorry about that,” he whirled his chair and cleared his throat. He looked down at the file quickly. “John. Appreciate you coming down to see me. How are you feeling?” Though his words were of concern, his tone sounded bored.

This was not a doctor who cared for his patients. Or perhaps the news was so good that there was no need to soften any blows.

“Am I healthy, doctor?”

When Gordon pulled his lips back with a short grimace, Kramer’s heart sank.

“John, the recent MRI shows a prefrontal lobe tumor. In addition, various tumors were found throughout your digestive tract, believed to have originated in the colon.”

He waited, patiently, for the doctor to be finished.

“John, I’m sorry, but it’s inoperable.” 

He said this so easily, as if telling a man he was doomed to die was as everyday as breathing.

Now this?

He tried to take in a deep breath to calm himself. It was as if he was trying to inhale sand.

“John, I’ll refer you for hospice care. I recommend getting your affairs in order.” Gordon checked his watch and jumped to his feet. “I’m sorry, but I need to go.” He went to the door, clutching the knob. “John?”

He turned, not sure if this was a dream. Surely, it was?

“John.”

“I understand,” he numbly answered, slowly getting to his feet. He suddenly could feel every joint bend and muscle move as he rose. His big toe cracked. His neck popped. The office of boring beige and blue seemed to burst forth with brilliant color. He could make out every texture. He smelled Gordon’s expensive cologne and recognized that his mouth was dry.

He coughed, wanting more than anything a glass of water.

He left the office, wandered down the hall, stepped into the sunlight, and felt every drop of warmth on his skin. 

These were his last days. And soon, all that would be left would be him writhing in agony. 

He sat in his car, trying to collect his thoughts. Jill. She would be devastated. Everything he worked for his entire life, would have been for nothing.

First, Gideon. Now, this?

He didn’t know how long he sat in his car, contemplating. But he knew it wouldn’t be much longer. He started the car, resisted the habitual urge to put on his seat belt, and put the car in gear.

He drove.

He didn’t know how long he drove. He didn’t know exactly where. 

But he was soon out of the city, far from the apathetic doctors, homicidal junkies, and he felt the wind in his hair. He smelled pine trees as the sun set. 

All of a sudden, it was dark. He kept driving.

He drove until the gas tank reached empty. He drove uphill, for as long as he could, until a sign appeared.

DANGER! CLIFF!

He pressed his foot hard, narrowing his eyes, focusing on that sign. The air around him rushed. He was going fast. He drove right by the sign, the smooth roar of the engine suddenly jumbled by the clank of pebbles on hollow steel. His chair jumped as the suspension on gravel bounced him about.

And then it all gave way to the sensation of his stomach flying up to his throat.

He was in the air.

And then the car’s nose sank to the ground.

Him, without his seatbelt, held his hands outward, as though on a rollercoaster.

He closed his eyes, to Jill. To Gideon. To the world. To his legacy. 

He didn’t remember much else after that.

Until he woke up.

He awoke to the sharp paralyzing pain buried deep in his side, the taste of dirt and the hot wetness of blood on his hands and face, reminding him that it wouldn’t be that easy.

He was alive.

How ?

He crawled out of the wreckage, half-delirious from denial, not believing that he had actually survived the fall.

Cancer will be my end, yet a plummet off a cliff did nothing? He tried to crawl further but couldn’t, realizing a metal beam was puncturing his side and the other end was caught on a bush. There was pain but something else. Something desperate. Instinctual. He grabbed it, adrenaline and the sudden clarity that he didn’t want to stay here pounding in his head. 

He didn’t want to die.

No, he didn’t want to die and he still had days to live. No, months to live. Maybe even years. He still had some time.

He gripped the beam and pulled with all his might, screaming at the top of his lungs into the night sky. 

A distant howl of a coyote joined him.

He clasped the bleeding open wound to himself and forced himself up. 

I’m alive.

This realization struck him as a sign. He was not done yet, with this life. There had to be a reason he survived such a deadly feat. 

He needed to know what that was. He needed to know, before the cancer took him. He needed to understand how was it that a man could survive such terrible trauma. Again and again.

Legacy.

That word stuck to his brain like glue, and he remembered his last thoughts as he fell in that car. My Legacy. 

John returned to his workshop, lightheaded from the blood loss but buzzing with purpose. Yes, his legacy. Everyone treated life as if it was a virtual reality. Himself, included. It wasn’t until the cancer that he realized what he had been doing to himself. This disservice had made him waste his days. He had done so little.

He had taken it all for granted. And he did not want others to suffer as he did. He would not allow them to go about their lives, taking their health and families for granted.

He couldn’t just go out with a white flag of surrender. No, he had to leave his mark. He had to make the world understand how precious a thing life was.

He went to the first aid kit on his workbench, digging for antiseptic, pouring it directly onto his stomach as he hissed at the pain. The adrenaline had worn off and now, a deeper ache almost as cruel as his headaches lacerated his side. He knew there would be more pain in the future. And more blood.

He wrapped the puncture hole with heavy bandages. He should go to the hospital. But first, he wanted to draw some plans. Prepare.

He had a new vision. It was the year of the pig. Gideon was gone. But not his memory.

And there was still the need for justice to be served. Cecil was still out there. John could share this newfound gift to Cecil. Cecil had certainly taken his life for granted.

Anger was there but John knew he had to separate from it. His current ideas were rudimentary. He thought of the pin cushion chair, the Inquisition, and ways to enact a just punishment for the death of his son.

He must walk on this earth with a face as hideous on the outside as his soul is on the inside.

John got to work.

 

Will Maddox

“So it’s true?”

The judge and district attorney looked at her, incredulous. “You forged the toxicology report?”

Her eyes burned. Her heart sank. She looked up and swallowed. “Yes, your honor, it’s true.”

She could feel Grissom’s disappointment behind her. She didn’t need to turn to him to know. 

But worse, she couldn’t bear the thought of how Mark would take this when he heard. 

“I know it’s wrong, your honor, but please do not allow a murderer out of prison because of my fuck up.”

“A technicality,” Grissom added, his support unsurprising and Will was glad for it. “A simple misprint on the date.”

“She sent his samples to the lab for unauthorized testing and stamped the wrong date with the intention of falsifying judge approval after the fact. Sloppy,” Baxter’s lawyer was smirking. “You were squeaky clean, Maddox, until this. Should have let the more experienced dirty cops handle this. Lucky me.”

“I suggest you focus on your client,” Grissom turned, face red, mustache bristled.

“Everyone, quiet.” The judge rubbed her temples and looked at Will with a disappointing frown. “Detective, this is a serious offense.”

“It is, your honor,” Will nodded, knowing there was no coming back from this. She would likely lose her badge and gun after this. Even though Baxter was dead to rights, on paper this was essentially his way free. “I have no excuse. But please, remember all the other evidence pointed to him. And he confessed.”

“Your honor, my client confessed under the evidence that was extracted illegally. He was pressured and unconstitutionally forced to confess. I am filing a motion to request all charges be dropped.”

It had been her worst fear. She had no way to avoid it. No way to get around it. She had hoped it would have just not happened. That the lawyers wouldn’t have caught on. She had been so naive. So dumb.

So desperate. 

Mark will never forgive me.

“Now, my priority is just to get my client out of prison. I’ll leave the reprimanding of your department to you. Good day.” Baxter’s lawyer sauntered out. 

The DA sighed. “Figured we’d give you two the heads up, thanks for coming on such short notice. I know this involved the murder of a cop’s sister. From where we’re standing, the guy’s going to walk tonight.”

“That’s unfortunate. Appreciate you bringing us down to tell us in person.” Grissom put a hand on Will’s shoulder. “Come, Maddox, let’s get back to the station.”

The drive back had been silent. Will stared ahead while Grissom drove. When they thought they were finally past this, Seth Baxter just wouldn’t fucking disappear from their lives. 

“Before you go high road and try to turn in your badge, let’s get one thing straight,” Grissom broke the silence first, pulling up to a red light. “No one will blame you for what you did.”

This made her finally cry. She sniffed and turned her head so her boss wouldn’t see her like this.

“That’s all right, girl, you go on and cry. You held out long. Longer than any of us. Nobody’s perfect. It’s a hard lesson. But try not to be too hard on yourself. Everyone gets their hands dirty at some point. It’s just the nature of the job. So don’t beat yourself about it.”

“I’m the reason Angelina’s murderer is about to walk free. And you say don’t beat myself up about it?”

“It’ll do you no good. There will always be a technicality. If it wasn’t the dates on the toxicology reports, it would have been your interrogation. Or the fact that it was fucking raining on a Sunday. Damn lawyers pull every loophole they can. That’s why the laws’ written so damn illegible. Because only lawyers can decipher them.”

She didn’t respond, not knowing what right she had in responding.

“Now, don’t quit. At least give it a month to think about. I’m going to suspend you with pay for the next two weeks. Tell Hoffman. Work it out with him.”

“He’ll never forgive me,” she whispered, knowing she sounded like a child.

“That may be. But you’ll tell him. End of the day, it’s just what you do. Who you are. You’re still an honorable person, Maddox. And I know you’re always going to try to do the honorable thing. I know you two care for each other. And if Hoffman would forgive anybody for this, it would be you. You two are close. Something like this, it’s downright impossible to get past for many. I know you wanted Baxter behind bars. I know you probably thought it was the only way. Just remember that you did what you thought was right, in the end. Even if Hoffman doesn’t see it now, I hope you at least forgive yourself. Maybe not today. Maybe not next year. But that’s the person you got to get forgiveness from. And I know people like you, they’ll let something like this eat them from the inside until there’s nothing left. I don’t want that happening to you.”

He reminded her of Vernon Knox. His words were frank. Honest. It both stung and gave Will some comfort, knowing what she had in store for her. 

For five years now, she had dreaded every day wondering if it would finally be the time her sin was revealed. Now that it was out, she felt surprisingly lighter. Tainted. Sadder. But no longer leaden with the weight of dread. 

The last barrier of anxiety she had left was to tell Mark. She swallowed, steeling herself.

 

Mark Hoffman

“Mark,” Will entered his office, closing the door behind her. She turned and shut the blinds, giving them privacy. For a fleeting moment, he had felt excited at the prospect that she was about to jump him. But the redness and swelling of her eyes turned his fun thoughts to worry.

“You okay?”

She shook her head, avoiding direct eye contact. “No. No. And I - I need to tell you something.”

He leaned back in his chair, not liking how she was wringing her hands in front of her. She was shaking like a leaf. His stomach had turned to a shard of ice and suspected it was about Frank. “What is it?”

She sat down, submissive. “Seth Baxter will be released from prison by the end of the month on a technicality. And it’s my fault.”

The pen in his hand slipped through his fingers.

“What was the technicality?” He whispered, instantly on edge.

“His confession will be dismissed on the grounds that the toxicology reports were what pressured him to confess.” She had her fingers to her forehead, ashamed. “I had him tested before the judge signed off on it.”

“I find that hard to believe,” he remained calm. “You always cross your T’s. The lawyer’s grasping at straws.”

“The lawyer’s right. I did forge the report.” She chewed her lip, avoiding his stare. “I did it to speed things along.”

“Will, you telling me you ignored protocol?” In the twenty years he had known her, Will had never so much as left five minutes earlier than her scheduled off time. 

She nodded, swallowing.

All this time, she insisted she lived by the book. He remembered that day, when she had been assigned to Angie’s case, and what he had made her promise. “Find him, Will. Arrest him.”

“I’ll make sure he's behind bars for the rest of his life. I promise.”

“So he’s getting off,” he dumbly stated. Just like that.

“I’m sorry, Mark,” tears brimmed her eyes, her mouth curled in remorse. “I wanted to get him. But I should have found another way.”

Will, distraught, upset him. But overwhelming self pity kept him frozen in his chair, his mind flashing to Angie, dead in her bed, her throat slashed open. And Baxter, who should have been the one who died, was going to walk free.

He clenched his jaw until his teeth ached. “Go.”

“Mark?”

“Don’t make me repeat myself. Get out of my sight.” He couldn’t look at her. He couldn’t let her see him like this. He knew he would lose control of himself and hurt her. He wanted to break everything. He wanted to be alone, to think, to set things right. To cool down.

He heard the chair scrape the linoleum and her faint footsteps as she left. When the door clicked shut he looked up and let out a breath.

His eyes stung. His nose burned. Every inch of him felt as though he was on fire. He realized the sharp copper he tasted was his own blood. 

 

Will Maddox

When she spotted Mark at his usual spot at the bar, she sighed in relief.

“Hey,” she greeted delicately, “missed you today.” They hadn’t spoken during her entire suspension. Today had been her first day back, and he had been unfindable.

“Guess he’s patrolling the streets ,” Rigg had told her when she asked him in the breakroom that morning.

Probably at the gym ,” Matthews had suggested when she had stopped by his new ‘office’, a repurposed janitor’s closet in the basement, during lunch.

She suspected they had given her inaccurate ideas - in their misguided intention to let Mark have his space.

After two weeks of leaving him be, Will felt it safe to push. If she didn’t, she feared they would never recover.

She wanted to make things write, whether that be aiding him on whatever work there was he’d rather not do or go as far as turn in her badge and end her career then and there. She wouldn’t know, though, until he spoke to her.

“Mark,” she tried again to get his attention. He was transfixed on the TV above, the Jamesson handle already low.

“What?” He finally asked.

“Talk to me. Yell. Anything. Please.”

Bloodshot blues flickered to her before retreating. “I don’t have it in me right now.”

She bit her lip. The walls were closing in. “I’ll do anything to make this right. Just give me a chance. I know I’m asking for so much and I have no right to. But I don’t want us to end like this.”

She was losing him and wanted to resist. Maybe - just maybe - they could get past this.

They had survived so much, so far.

“You can’t fix something that never worked to begin with.”

His words punched her in the gut, knocking the air out of her lungs.

“How can you say that? We had so many good times.”

“Yeah - not talking about that. I’m talking about the system. What we do. Upholding the law. Trying to make this fucking city better. It’s impossible. The system never works. All it does it leave a trail of blood in its wake.”

He was occasionally a philosophical drunk.

“Maybe it’s time to call it a night.”

“You’re not listening, Will,” He turned to face her, fully and furiously. “You were that system. And even you knew it wouldn’t be enough to put Baxter away. That’s why you did what you did.”

Her cheeks tightened. “Mark, I shouldn’t have done what I did. It was wrong.”

“The fact that you - the one person incorruptible in this shitstorm couldn’t stick through it - it’s made me finally see. My eyes are open the fuck wide now.” He tossed back another shot. “Justice. True justice, never existed with us. We’re just dicking around like it’s a play. I’m tired of playing.”

“Mark,” she touched his arm, trying to reach him. But he was so far away.

“Just stop.” He took her hand and pushed it off. “Let’s end this here and now.”

Panic. Fear. Disbelief. “No,” she whispered, holding back the tears because they were in a public bar, goddamn it !

“You’re drunk,” she stated, “you’re not thinking straight.”

“I am, for the first time in a long time, thinking straight. If I had just handled Baxter from the very beginning - but I didn’t. For you.” When he looked at her, she only saw hatred and anger. “I always stopped, thinking, ‘what would Will think’?”

“Mark-,”

“I said we’re done, Maddox. I want this over.”

“Because of Baxter?”

His jaw twitched. “You’re my choke collar. You keep me from going the distance.”

“That’s not a bad thing.”

“Tell that to Angie.” He governed his face, hands sliding down his cheeks. “Just get the fuck out.”

When she didn't move, he slammed his shot glass down on the ground. “GET OUT!” 

The room silenced.

All eyes were upon them.

Will felt shame burn her cheeks and heartbreak sting her chest.

“Fine,” she softly spoke, no longer able to look him in the face. “That’s it, then.”

She left him alone at the bar.




Notes:

A/N: I'm sorry, this is probably one of the most depressing chapters ever. I tried to spice things up earlier to make up for it. D:
I blame Seth Baxter. This is all his fault.

Chapter 40: Pre-SAW: It's a Miracle

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Will Maddox

“Will, honey?” Ally’s voice called through her door. “You gotta eat. Come out, please?”

She didn’t want to get out from under her covers.

“Hon, you can’t sulk forever. Come out.” She knew what it was like, being in Ally’s shoes, trying to comfort someone so inconsolable. It sucked. She forced herself to open the door, seeing her roommate who had a bag of McDonald’s and a matching cup. 

“To hell with men,” Ally tried to crack a joke. “How about you join Linds and me and we’ll just be a ménage à trois?”

Will cracked a smile, a bit of it forced, for Ally. “I swear, it never gets easier. Maybe I should join a convent.”

“Oh, god, honey, don’t do that!” Ally put an arm around her and steered her to the living room. “Your ass would be wasted in a habit. Let’s just watch some gratuitous violent action movies, eat our problems away, and just remember. You’ve got a friend in me.”

Will groaned. Ally had been getting into the Toy Story series as of late, blaming Lindsay for the introduction. The references had been unrelenting. 

“I rented us the Matrix. Finally, it was taking for-ever to grab a copy. I had to fight an old lady for it at Blockbuster.” Ally laid their meal out in a junk food spread. 

“That poor old lady,” Will leaned back on the couch, trying to blink back the tears that carried flashbacks to Mark. To Angelina. To everything that had gone wrong in her life.

Despite the guilt, she selfishly wondered if there was a way to go back. Was it possible he could ever forgive her? Take her back? These hopeful, delusional wishful thoughts sprang up, giving her bits of life to only have herself snuff it out. 

He doesn’t want you. Why would he? Wouldn’t you want the same, if you were in his situation? If he was the reason Bram’s murderer walked?

She couldn’t imagine forgetting about him so easily. But if she was being honest with herself, she wasn’t trying to.

“Nuh-uh, you don’t get to sulk.” Ally handed Will a quarter pounder and got up to push the tape into the VHS player. “Hoffman may be giving you hell but Angie would be pissed to see you so worked up about all this.”

“She’d want Baxter in prison.”

“And world peace, the end of homelessness and hunger, but Angie never lingered on holding grudges on people she cared about.” Ally must have been trying to stretch the truth for Will’s sake, for she distinctly recalled how more like her brother Angelina had been. Stubborn. Indignant on how unfair the world was and how it shouldn’t be. And that temper.

“She’d be heartbroken to know it was her murder that broke you two apart. She always wanted you to be her sister-in-law. I know she’s watching us right now, probably thinking Mark’s such a damn knucklehead. And mourning the loss of your future children.”

That, Will could imagine. She remembered when Angie would tease Mark. 

“When are you two getting married already? Stop leaving me in suspense!”

Between the two Hoffman siblings, Angie would have been the more forgiving one. Will was sure of it. She nodded, sniffing. “Yeah.”

“So you’re going to ogle at the fight scenes and I’m going to fantasize about Trinity. Pull yourself together and eat something.” 

“Angie would be so disappointed in us, getting McDonald’s.”

“Yeah, well, nothing gourmet will ever be as good as what she’d make for movie nights.” 

Will forced herself to eat, the sudden taste of salt and grease hitting her in a way that made her feel instantly less miserable. By a fraction. 

Despite how sorry for herself she was feeling, having Ally there made it bearable. But Mark, who does he have? Will wanted to call him. But she knew it was not her place and she had no right to try to push herself into his  life any longer.

He wanted a clean break. She would respect his wishes, even though it broke her heart.

She tried to focus on the movie. There were definitely great moments she could lose herself to. The panning of the camera as Neo froze in the air was a breathtaking shot. It was one of the coolest looking movies she had ever seen.

She just wished Mark was there to see it.

She sniffled and tried to play it off that she was just going through some allergies. Ally didn’t say anything, only reaching over to hand her the box of tissues.

 

Mark Hoffman

Larry shook his head.

“You’re cutting me off?” Mark stared in shock up at the bartender he had been going to for half his lifetime now. “Why?”

“And taking your keys,” Larry growled, holding his hand out. “For your own good, Mark.”

“No,” Mark got to his feet, trying to find his pockets. He couldn’t seem to get his fingers in them. He was going to tell the guy to shut up and give him another bottle. But it was hard to stand straight.

The room was spinning.

He admitted, he probably had too much to drink.

He slumped forward, against the counter, a wave of nausea rushing through him. He managed to push it down, burping and standing up straight. He believed he was looking Larry in the eye.

“You already gave me your keys. Hours ago. It’s closing time. Go home. Call your partner.”

He blinked at Larry, never hearing him speak so much before. “No. I’m fine on my own.”

“Well, you can’t stay here. I’ll call you a cab.”

Hoffman tried to stumble away, to say he didn’t need anything. From anyone.

But he lost balance and fell backwards, feeling his head hit the ground but it didn’t hurt.

Nothing hurt anymore.

And that was just fine with him.

But then, he realized he was standing again.

Where was he?

He was standing on grass. There were flowers. A graveyard.

Oh, this graveyard.

He recognized his parents’ names. Hoffman. Mark. Darcy . Besides, Acomb. Peter and Angelina . Angelina . There wasn’t much room left, but the rectangular shaped grass patch next to her would be his one day.

He figured why not lie there? Might as well. He fell back onto the grass, the cool damp dirt seeping into his clothes. Which was fine by him.

He had half hoped he’d feel Angie through the ground. Maybe hear Pete crack some lame joke. Maybe he’d even hear his mother’s voice one last time. Hell, he’d be happy to just see his old man’s ghost, to ferry him to the afterlife.

Dad, I could really use some advice here . As usual, there was no response.

He was disappointed he was still aware enough to know he wasn’t dying of alcohol poisoning.

“A bit late to mourn, son,” a man stood over him. 

Mark blinked up, seeing a familiar face. A ghost did visit him. He shivered.

“Knox.”

“That my name?”

“Why?” Hoffman let out a strangled whine. “Why did you go and leave me too?”

“Now, son… it wasn’t like that.” The man squatted by him. A warm hand, on his shoulder. “We should get you inside. You’ll catch a cold. You got a friend I can call? I’m sure a goodlooking guy like you has a nice girl waiting at home, who’s worried sick.”

He felt his eyes burn. Fuck . He was going to cry like a kid. “Knox. It’s over. I can’t stand the sight of her.” He blamed Will, blamed her despite the whisper in the back of his mind telling him it wasn’t fair to her. That she did her best. 

He just couldn’t get past the fact that Angie’s murderer was free. That the one person he trusted had failed him.

“Oh no,” the old man let out a sigh. “Well, I got a couch in my office. You won’t mind if it’s got some broken springs. On your feet now. My bum leg won’t get you up on my own. Come on now. Easy going. There you go.”

Hoffman pulled himself up, steered by Knox, and was led to a small shack. He felt himself collapse onto a lumpy couch, leaned back, breathing heavily. Damn . he hadn’t felt this drunk since he and Matthews were boys in the Academy.

The Academy. Right. He’s a cop.

What a sorry excuse for one.

“Now, son, I’ve got some water right here. You drink it. And can I get a number? Got an address book on you? A number in your wallet? Help me out.”

“Yeah.” He struggled to paw through his pants. 

“Is that a gun?!” 

“Here,” Mark took out fistfuls of everything that had been inside his pants. “Take them.” He heard clutter drop and the old man cursed.

“Damn, that’s a police badge. Son, you could get in a lick of trouble, running around drunk as a skunk. You’re lucky I’m feeling mighty sad for you right now.” The man was grumbling more to himself, Mark barely making out anything but syllables and consonants. 

He leaned back and let himself fall back to sleep.

He next awoke with violent shaking that jolted him back to consciousness. “What?!”

“Hoffman,” the face was a mold of flesh color and lines until his focus revealed who had jerked him back to the pain of reality. He smelled cigarettes.

“Eric?”

“Come on, Mark, on your feet,” Matthews was pulling him up. “Grab his other arm, fucker’s heavy.”

He felt another pair of hands grab his arm and shoulder. He turned, blinking to see Rigg’s solemn face. “Dan?”

“We got you, man. Just one foot in front of the other. Come on, there you go.” Mark slumped his head forward.

“Here, thanks for keeping things down low,” he heard Matthews mutter.

“Oh, don’t worry, I ain’t going to the media about this. Nothing exciting about a broken hearted cop who drank himself stupid. I’ve been there. Just make sure he doesn’t drown in his own puke. Lost an ol’ army buddy that way.”

“We will. Damn, Hoffman, when’d you get so fucking heavy?”

“When my sister was fucking murdered,” he snapped back, trying to wrench his arms from being held. But he was too sluggish and slow. Fuck. He felt so weak.

“Hey, now, don’t go putting your shit out on us. We’re helping you out, after you go and kick Mad Max to the curb. Tracy’s gonna have my head.”

“Yeah, Hoffman, you’re being a real bitch right now. You’re gonna outshine me at this rate.”

He bowed his head again. They were right. He was being a little bitch.

Life was a bitch.

Why couldn’t he just wallow a little more about it?

“You’re lucky we ain’t gonna toss you in the drunk tank. Though you deserve it.”

“Fuck you.”

“Nah, you stink, asshole. Come on, you can crash at my place. But if you throw up anywhere, you’re cleaning it up.”

“Next time you want to drink yourself to oblivion, let one of us know. We’ll join you.”

“Hell, I certainly will, I got nothing else to do these days.”

Hoffman let out a groan. “Fuck, my head hurts.”

“Yeah, no shit.”

 

Mark Hoffman

“Mark,” Will poked her head into his office, looking more nervous than usual.

He stared at her, waiting for her to say what she was going to say. He had avoided her since he called to end things. It had been a successful month of him dodging every glimpse of copper curl and petite curve when he was at the department. He had screened his calls and declined to call back whenever she left voicemails.

But it seemed she had enough of his dodging and came to him directly.

Fine, then. 

A part of him knew he was in the wrong with how he had been treating her. These days, he was always angry. It wasn’t just her but everything else that set him off. He had been making a point to stay at his desk to avoid ending up grounded like Matthews.

And with Will. It was almost too easy to let his rage out on her. She made it too easy. When she approached him now, it was with a wounded look, always submissive and needy. She was always hovering around him, within verbal punching reach. It was almost like she wanted him to lash out at her. He only had cruel words to say, mostly just because she would stick around to listen, but also because he just wanted someone else to hurt as bad as he felt.

He didn’t understand himself. He didn’t want to talk to her but he still secretly enjoyed her attention. But he needed to make the end of their romantic relationship clear to her.

When he had said they were to remain professional, and they were still partners, he did not intend for them to share any amicable rapport. He wanted her to be a stranger. To not be someone he wanted. Needed. 

He wanted to hate her.

Attachments only brought him pain and suffering. He didn’t want to experience loss again. He didn’t want to feel anything, ever again.

“So,” she put on a brave expression and stepped deeper into his domain, closing the door behind him. She looked good, he admitted, and he wished he wasn’t mad at her so he could tell her so.

She had something behind her back. 

“What is it?”

“Happy Birthday,” she revealed what she was holding behind her back. A gift wrapped in blue and gold paper. She stepped around the desk and sat on it, her knees close to his side. “I know you never like to make a big deal about it, and I know we’re not in a good spot, but I bought this a while ago. Can’t return it. So please, take it.” She put the gift in front of him, on the untouched documents he had been ‘reviewing’. “I hope this is okay?”

He swallowed, feeling a little less spiteful. “Yeah,” he muttered, “thanks.”

She looked visibly relieved. In fact, she seemed a lot livelier since they last saw each other. There was a genuine smile on her face. She looked fine.

This made him feel worse all over again. Why did she look so damn happy?

He hated her for how she could just shine so bright after everything. He hated her for trying to move on while he was still dealing with Baxter’s freedom.

And Baxter. That was all he wanted to focus on these days. He had found where the punk was living. Every free chance he got he was the prick’s shadow, waiting for the right moment. The right opportunity.

For what, he didn’t know.

“Mark?” The smile left, replaced with worry. 

“Nothing,” he decided to put an end to this, scorched earth style. Will, long the object of his focus, his affection, his obsession , was no longer a priority in his periphery. She was a distraction. She was in the way.

“Mark,” Will folded her arms, eyes shining. “I want to make things right. With you. With Angelina.”

“I know.” That was the problem. She wanted to be involved. And it was her involvement that got them into this mess in the first place. Now, it was time he did it his way.

“Will, I meant it when I said we’re done.”

She stared at him, face blank. “I know. But. Maybe we can still be friends?”

“I don’t think so.”

Her face had fallen, filling him with both satisfaction and the burning pangs of loss. But he wouldn’t backpedal on this.

“You’re suffocating me, all right? I’m tired of it. Stop trying to talk to me. Just stop.” He got to his feet, needing the higher elevation to stick to his conviction.

“Mark, can’t we talk abou-,”

“No. I’ve decided.” He looked down at the present she had brought, taking it in his hand and handing it to her. “I want a clean break. For both of us.”

She refused to take the gift back, turning and rushing out of his office with a slam of the door.

He sighed, sinking back into his chair, swiveling around to look up at the book shelf, where a picture of Angelina smiled down at him. 

 

Will Maddox

“Why were we called in for this?” Will sighed, rubbing the sweat off the back of her neck. She was trying to act unperturbed to Hoffman’s presence. He, too, pointedly ignored her. They had both driven separately to the scene, surprised to see the other as they approached the yellow taped perimeter. 

They were both partners still, technically . So it made sense that when a homicide was called in, they would both be called on the scene. But over the past few months, they had been especially careful about staying out of each other’s domains. They took turns with assignments and had succeeded in closing cases with this arrangement.

The only times Will had seen Mark was in passing when they crossed paths, neither looking directly at the other, pretending the other didn’t exist. Fifteen times, that had happened, and each time had left a stinging tattoo of hurt that had fermented into resentment.

Will’s grief had turned hostile and she couldn’t help but feel short tempered whenever she was within five feet of her partner.

Grissom had turned a blind eye to their current ballet. So long as they didn’t start shouting matches or throw furniture and got the job done, everything was just peachy at MPD. After all, they were adults about it. Sure, they weren’t romantically involved anymore despite having been for the majority of their careers. Hell, they weren’t even friends now. But they could close cases just as well.

In fact, because they had made a point to stay separate, their ‘partnership’ had resulted in almost double the case closing rate as pairs. Will had already been crowned Detective Lieutenant just a month prior, enjoying the extra decorative badge dangling on her hip, a small pleasure knowing she now outranked her ex-boyfriend. What kept her going, now, was the need to compete. 

She was fine without Hoffman. Doing great, in fact.

Hoffman, surprisingly, had even acknowledged her about it, giving her a rare moment of eye contact and a passive, “Congratulations, Maddox,” during the award ceremony. The impersonal way he greeted her had been the harshest slap to the face, far worse than his silent treatment had ever given her. 

Standing at the crime scene, Allison gave her a hard look, silently telling her to cool it. Will sighed and looked down at the victim. Multiple lacerations across his face. Deep, what looked like reaching the cheek bones of his skull. Severe punctures in his inner wrists. And the chaotic tearing of flesh all over him.

“Looks like he fell into a pit of razor wire and had a seizure,” she calmly observed and looked up at her roommate. Hoffman stayed a respectful distance at her back. 

“Name’s Cecil Adams. Got quite the rap sheet. Was found in a dumpster in the outskirts of town. He was last seen behind the Homeward Bound Clinic, where he was a regular. Had an arrest warrant out for assault of a pregnant woman.” Allison looked down at an open folder she was holding. “Because of the victim’s history, we thought at first it was a drug deal gone bad. But this level of torture? I haven’t seen something like this since Rosello.”

This got Will’s attention. She straightened up, her knees popping. She winced. She wasn’t as young and spry as she used to be. “But Rosello tortured women.”

“I’m not saying Rosello’s back from the dead, but I think this should be on your radar.”

“Don’t tell me,” Will grimaced, already feeling dread grip her throat. “This city’s got a new flashy serial killer?”

“Won’t know for sure until the coroner hands me the autopsy. But I can feel it. This vic? Way different from our usual. We’ve been having it easy for a while. Some sicko was bound to show up. I’ve already told Linds and Strahm.”

“Aren’t you rushing into things, Ally?” Will bit her lip and couldn’t help but glance back at Hoffman. He was watching them, narrowing his eyes slightly.

“See, that’s why I called you. There’s another victim on this block.”

Will widened her eyes. “Show me.”

They followed Allison, who guided them down the narrow alleys that were now being gated off by yellow and black tape, into a worn down building that smelled of rust and oil. Tapp and Sing appeared around the corner, looking grim and shaking their heads.

The body was covered with a dusty blanket, the smell of decay and the buzz of flies grew stronger as they approached the body. Fisk was squatting, holding the blanket up to squint at the meat underneath.

“What makes you think these cases are related?” Hoffman’s voice made the muscles in her neck tighten. She strode over to Fisk to join in observing. She saw the carefully cut skin, an almost perfect incision of a jigsaw puzzle piece.

“Looks like this guy likes to leave a calling card. We’ve had reports of two more bodies last month. Coroner has been keeping track, he’s never seen it before,” Ally’s heels clicked on the concrete as she paced back and forth.

She was on edge. Hell, Will, too, didn’t like the looks of this. This body had his knee caps blown clean off. “Jesus,” she whispered, and was transported back to the days when she would see victims with their faces peeled back or their breasts sliced off. This was violent and sadistic.

“This whole building’s a crime scene,” Fisk announced, pulling back and looking up at the rafters. He pointed up at what looked like a carefully arranged matrix of chains and pulleys. “This guy had been suspended five stories up. Was told to either jump or get his kneecaps blasted. Looks like he was afraid of heights.”

“How do you know the killer wanted him to jump?” Will asked.

“Because he left this,” Ally had in her hand an evidence bag with a tape recorder. She pushed play.

Hello, Larry. I want to play a game. ” Will felt the hairs on the back of her neck stand. “ For years, you’ve poisoned this city with your heroin, even when you didn’t need the money. Did you do it because you like seeing desperate addicts debase themselves for your entertainment? Well, let’s see what you do when you have nowhere to go but down or up. Only this time, going down, I assure you, will be far more beneficial for you. Live or die. Make your choice.”

“So what was up?” Hoffman asked, craning his neck.

“A ladderwell with a shotgun angled below his waist and rigged to explode if he opened the door. Bastard must have hoped it was a prank.”

“Media’s already got a whiff,” Tapp commented, “They’ve been blasting the morning news, calling this the work of the Jigsaw Killer. Looks like he puts them through the damn ringer. Forensics found gunpowder all over him. Whoever is killing these people, he left plenty of his instruments behind. And he’s got tech skills. Strong mechanics knowhow. But no prints we can use. Nothing that gives us a hint on who he is.”

“We don’t know if it’s a he or she yet. Let’s wait til Strahm develops a profile,” Ally commented, exchanging a nod with Will.

“Just what we need, another psychopath,” Sing shook his head, folding his arms. “Fuck, getting blasted by a shotgun sounds terrible.”

“He’s just killing people for kicks?” Hoffman asked, notably more interested than Will expected him to be. She was surprised he hadn’t left sooner.

“Vigilante kicks. We’ve got ourselves a guy who is targeting victims he sees are commiting wrongs he wants them to fix. And he makes them choose death or severely crippling themselves,” Ally grimaced, shaking her head. “Nobody’s safe.”

“Some less than others,” Fisk commented, shuddering. “So far, it’s been drug addicts and dealers. I’d say most people are safe.”

“Well, that’s the tricky thing, with vigilantes. They may start like they’re doing good work, until the power gets to their head,” Will commented, remembering Peter Strahm mentioning a serial killer who believed he was a vigilante and soon developed a god-complex. She felt eyes on her and turned, locking onto Hoffman, who was watching her. She raised an eyebrow. “What?”

He shook his head and turned away and continued to ignore her.

 

Mark Hoffman

He awoke, his hair wet, drenched in sweat. His sheets were soaked. His heart was racing. “What the fuck,” he whispered aloud, trying to remember what had gotten him so worked up.

Angie. He had a dream about Angie. He had reached out to hug her, to only pull away with the sensation of bugs crawling up and down his chest. Worms. She was full of worms. They had flown out of her mouth. 

And he saw in the distance, Baxter, laughing at him, whole and clean.

“How can you let him go?” Angie had asked him, black eyes full of accusation. She lifted her chin to reveal the deep cut in her neck where a millipede writhed out of the skin. 

He pressed the meat of his palms into his eyelids, willing the images to disappear. He needed to take a walk.

He had been cutting back on drinking but it made the nightmares worse.

So he got out of bed, put on the clothes he had worn earlier that day, and gone straight to the graveyard.

He went there, because he had an idea. And he wanted their blessing before he went through with it. The walk to the Hoffman family gravesite was long and full of mist. A perfect night for a haunting.

He half hoped the ghosts would take him tonight. He stopped when he reached Angie’s resting place. He noticed fresh flowers had been placed. He knelt to examine them, wondering who left them. He didn’t know shit about flowers. Were these her favorite kind? He wished he had paid more attention back then to know.

“Ange,” he looked down at the marble, her name staring back. “Baxter’s free. But I can fix that. I’ll have to get my hands dirty, though.” Like before. He remembered when he worked for Rosello, all to protect her. And in the end, it had been all for nothing.

He hadn’t protected her when she needed him most. But the least he could do was make sure Seth Baxter paid for it. “I know you won’t like what I’m going to do. But I hope you understand. I need to do this. For you. For all the other women out there he’ll hurt. I can’t let him get away with it.”

No response followed, except for the gentle breeze that made him shiver. It was cold for a summer night. “Rest easy, sis. I love you.” 

He turned, hearing the rumble of thunder above. It was going to rain. He needed to buy a raincoat. He’d be outside a lot from now on.

 

Will Maddox

 “Will,” Bram’s voice sounded tired. “Dad’s awake.”

She had dropped the phone receiver and had to scramble to pick it off the ground. “That’s amazing,” she tried to sound pleased, smiling, though the idea of flying to San Diego weighed heavy on her. “H - how is he?” What she really wanted to know was how extensive the brain damage was.

“It’s a miracle. The doctors can’t explain it, but he’s speaking full sentences and has passed all their screenings. He woke up last week. He’s only now stabilized. He freaked at first, still thinking it was 1981.” Bram’s voice broke. “He said I look like mom.”

“You do.” Will wiped her eyes. Damn tears seemed to come so often these days. “I’ll catch the first flight to you.”

“Yeah. He’s asking about you.” He gave the number to the hospital extension where their father was staying. “I’ll likely be there if you can’t reach me at home or on my cell. Hurry home, Will.”

She hung up, gathered her things, and went straight to Grissom. 

“How long do you need?” The man leaned back, incredulous and pivoting his chair back and forth.

“Two weeks. Maybe longer. I’m not sure what the plan is, now,” Will’s voice was gentle and automatic. She had never thought her father would wake from his coma. She had always assumed he had been brain dead. That’s what the doctors always told me . They kept him alive, though, as he had requested in his will. 

“Not a convenient time, what with this Jigsaw nutjob on the loose.” Grissom scratched his head, sighing, “but when is it ever a good time? I’m happy for you, really. But we’ll be worse off without you.”

“I’ll get back as soon as I can. Kerry and Fisk are taking point on this one. And the FBI should be helping out. And you have Hoffman. I bet you’ll apprehend the killer by the time I get back.”

“I hope so. This guy’s already causing panic. Phone’s ringing off the hook with tips on who the ‘Jigsaw Killer’ is. People always love the theatrics. Christ.” Grissom had bags under his eyes and his thinned white hair was almost gone. “Safe flight, Maddox.”

She turned and left, knowing Grissom would tell the others. She had a plane to catch. And a resurrected father to reunite with.

 

Mark Hoffman

“You know where Maddox is?” Kerry barged into his office, blowing strands of hair out of her face and looking flustered.

Hoffman slowly leaned over his work, covering the schematic with a police report, looking up at her blankly. “How should I know?”

She rolled her eyes. “Because she’s your partner.” After an awkward pause her expression widened into astoundment. “Well, she’s on a plane to San Diego. Her father woke up from the coma.”

He blinked, the news actually surprising. “What does this have to do with me?”

“Come on, Hoffman, you seriously don’t care?”

“No.”

“I don’t believe you.” Kerry closed the door, stalked closer, pressing her hands on the desk and leaned to him. This was not usual of Allison Kerry, the laid back and apathetic woman barely ever gave him the time of day. But she must have been pissed. “When are you going to let her live down what happened? She forged some documents. Big deal. We’ll get Baxter, in time. He’s bound to fuck up eventually. But right now, we’re understaffed and there’s a madman out there.”

“You don’t know if we’ll get him. And this is Angie’s murderer, Kerry. Not some random guy that walked. You were her bridesmaid for Christ’s sake. You may be able to let it go. But I can’t. Of all the times to try to play dirty, she chose my sister’s case?” He shook his head. She should have told him. He would have made sure no lawyer would have ever found the trail. She should have trusted a pro.

“Obviously, she was scared we couldn’t convict him with what we had. Her one fuckup is a drop in the bucket with what you’ve done your whole career.”

“Exactly. She got proud and that’s what got him off.” 

“Jesus, this isn’t about her not trusting you. This was to protect you, you idiot!” He narrowed his eyes and cocked his head to the side, waiting for her to continue. “Your name couldn’t be anywhere attached to the case or Baxter wouldn’t have even sat in jail for five years. But that’s beside the point. We’ve got a madman going around giving Michael-Meyers-level-life-lessons to our citizens every week and you’re here sitting on your ass not out there helping? Why? Because you’re mad at your girlfriend?”

Ah, so that’s her angle . Hoffman knew Kerry had an ulterior motive, coming here and giving him the after school special. 

“Ex-girlfriend.” Hoffman pretended to return to filling out the report, checking boxes, ignoring her.

“Men,” Kerry grumbled under her breath, turning to storm out. “And I knew Angie, a lot more than you, Hoffman. And she would think you’re being a real bastard right now.” She slammed the door behind her. 

Don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out, bitch . He clenched his jaw, returning to his work. So Will was out of state. This was good to know. Less chances she would suddenly want to try reconnecting with him at the worst of times.

He looked at the drawing, trying to crunch the numbers in his head of how the pendulum’s arc length would spread as it descended down and across the board holding Baxter in place.

He had gotten inspiration from Edgar Allen Poe, the writer Angie loved back when she was still an undeclared major in college. Before she became a culinary chef. Once, she talked about being a writer. Horror and mystery. 

“I love getting chills and being kept awake from a scary story. You know?” 

He hadn’t known. He had plenty of real life to keep him awake. But he humored her.

Back when she still lived with him, she used to read to him the classics. The Raven. The Pit and the Pendulum. Hoffman intended for this to be for her. This would be Angie’s retribution. And the extensive technical needs - all skills their father had bestowed upon him.

He erased a portion of the lowering chassis that supported the pendulum. A clockwork mechanism would lower after a complete period, resulting in the bob - really, a blade - getting closer to the victim’s stomach. Eventually, the arc of motion would result in lacerating the victim. 

He needed to implement a factor of choice, to disguise it as a Jigsaw trap. So many victims had been popping up as of late, one more would be thrown on the pile, and no one would be the wiser. If anyone found evidence tying him to this, he could easily make it ‘disappear’, as he did so often back when Rosello had been in power.

This would be easy. Because he would be careful. Meticulous.

The only people he was worried about catching on would be the usual types. Tapp. Kerry. Matthews, if he was in a good mood. And Will.

Speaking of, she’s probably going to be gone for weeks. He was eager, he knew, and rushing was risky. But he had Baxter’s routine memorized. The guy had kept busy and in public view, to Hoffman’s frustration, going to his therapy sessions and choosing to walk about shopping malls.

What was worse was the bastard had kept his nose clean. As if he had a right to change. He worked at a shoe store, selling sneakers to kids with a salesman smile. Baxter also had a hobby of sculpting. He went to a studio at the same mall every Tuesday night to make shitty vases or coffee cups for his mom, before taking the trash out the side exit that led out the back of the mall.

It was a place Hoffman had made sure the cameras’ wiring was severed. And in the past two weeks, no maintenance guy had bothered to fix it.

Hoffman thought of how it was Baxter’s hands that continued to touch, grope, and create. Those very hands had also been responsible for taking Angie away from him. 

He thought of how satisfying it would be, to watch the man destroy those hands himself, to try to escape the pendulum. The pressure plates emerged from this and he considered how many pounds-force would be required to crush his hands. He would make it as slow as possible, to make Baxter feel every crack and every crunch of bone.

He knew of several of Rosello’s old properties that had still not been seized. They just sat there, collecting dust. He would build the instrument tonight. It would take a week, likely, needing to only bring in gears one trip. The harder piece to conceal would be the giant sheet of steel that would compose of the blade. But it was all well within his ability. 

He smiled, realizing he had drawn an ugly sketch of Baxter, his bowels ripped open, and Hoffman couldn’t fucking wait until he saw it all happen in real life.

 

Notes:

A/N: hope this chapter is good - My work has me traveling a lot. I'm halfway through this month TT_TT I just got to make it a few more weeks and I can finally sit still. Apologies for any errors/inconsistencies, I'm fairly scattered these days.

Chapter 41: Peri-SAW: I Call This Justice

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Will Maddox

“Oh my goodness, is this beautiful woman my daughter?” Jules Maddox, Will’s father, looked good since she last visited his sleeping form the Christmas prior. He had shaved the thick beard the nurses had maintained since she had been a teenager.

He’s been in a coma for twenty five years now, she surmised, the shock always fresh when she took the time to reflect. She held out the cigar box and bottle of bourbon he used to drink, back when she wasn’t old enough to drive. After all this time, she still remembered these details, for some reason. Her hands remained steady. She was thankful for that.

“How you feeling, Dad?”

“Still stiff. Only just got my right toes wiggling. I feel like I could get up and do a flip - but my body just isn’t cooperating.”

“Take it easy, Dad,” Bram looked overwhelmed with joy, his smile pulled cheek-to-cheek.

“So,” Jules’ eyes sparkled, “Tell me about your life, Willmee.”

She bristled at the long dead nickname. A tear broke through, for she never thought she’d hear him call her that again. The memories wanted to break out but she held it back by biting the inside of her cheek.

“Well, I’m a cop. Been, for most of my life now.” She didn't feel so strong, despite expecting to, saying it. Only shame. She had nothing to show for it. Despite all this time, they had never caught the bastard who caused all this.

Jules’ cheer softened. “Sounds dangerous.”

“It is,” Bram blurted and sulked when Will glared him down.

“I’ve taken good care of myself.”

“That you have,” Jules held a hand out to her and she took it. His hands were soft and paper-like. “Are you happy, honey?”

She blinked. “Yeah, Dad. I’m happy.”

He nodded. “That’s all that matters, then. I’m so thankful you and Bram grew up to be so-,” he paused, looking away, his voice breaking. 

“Dad,” she sniffled and knelt over his bed to give him a hug.

He was bony and touching him brought her back to that night.

The screams of her mother. Bram’s infant wails in the next room. Her father, shouting. Gun shots. Silence. And her, cowering in the closet, pressing her palm to her mouth, praying whoever it was didn’t find her.

“Honey, you’ve got a grip,” Jules laughed. “Careful now, I’m still delicate. Can’t be throwing you over my head anytime soon.”

“Sorry Dad,” she pulled back, letting him see her cry. “I’m just so happy to talk to you again.” Happy. Nervous. Embarrassed.

She swallowed and kept a smile pushed up her cheeks.

Bram was watching her - likely, judging to himself in his own way. Will had put off facing the guilt of what she had done all these years and now, she had to face it with Bram’s reproachful gaze. But he wouldn't understand. She left Dad, comatose, for Bram to handle on his own when she and Frank had left California.

She had run away.

And now, after everything leading to that moment, she was full of remorse.

I should have stayed. For Bram. For Dad.

“So, not to put you on the spot, but you got a husband? Children? Am I a grandfather? You used to say you wanted three daughters,” he laughed good-humored, while Will bit her lip.

“Well, no,” she didn’t want to elaborate on her terrible romantic history - especially not with him. “I’m not seeing anyone these days.”

Bram raised an eyebrow. For all he knew, she was still dating Hoffman.

“I was married when I was in my twenties - but let’s just say it ended and not bring the mood down on the details.” She swallowed and forced a grin. “Say, how about I get some cards and we play some rummy. Like old times.”

“That’s a swell idea,” Jules sounded enthusiastic. “Feels like only yesterday I was schooling you two.”

“Get ready, dad, your winning streak is about to come to an end,” she laughed, pretending with all her heart that everything was fine. Because it was. 

And when she left the hospital room and found herself alone in the elevators as it descended down to the gift shop, she realized she was bawling into her palm, anguish overwhelming her. Her father was awake. He was alive. 

And he was exactly the way she remembered him. Acting like everything is just normal. But only it wasn’t.

Mom was still dead. He had lost almost three decades of his life, lying in a hospital bed. And the one thing she had promised him when she had first joined the Police Academy, the one thing she swore she would get done in her life, she had failed to do.

And instead of still trying, she had given up.

Like everything else in her life, she had simply abandoned it all.

She wiped at her cheeks, hating herself for everything. 

 

John Kramer

John waited patiently as his tea brewed, looking at the newspaper. 

‘JIGSAW’ KILLER TERRIFIES CITY. 

How distasteful. He didn’t approve of the way the media portrayed him. Jigsaw Killer. He was no killer. All of his test subjects had died by their own hand. The puzzle pieces he had removed from each victim, symbolic in intent, had been distorted into a cheap calling card by the tabloid rags. 

Perhaps he would have his message spread more clearly. He needed to refine his methods. Learn from his past errors. Cecil had just been the first. He had focused on the most common troublemakers that had frequented the Homeward Bound Clinic, finding a rich vein of despicable people to mine.

But his vision was growing grander with each test. Games, he thought. And what grand  games they were. It had rejuvenated him despite his sickness and gave him purpose.

Despite his passion, he had to take more breaks lately, the headaches only supplicated with the medication he was prescribed. He avoided the heavier substances, choosing to allow the pain to transform him. Mold him with its raw agony. He needed to stay sharp. A dull blade was useless.

His latest trap, a glass coffin, was something he would have to shelve for the time being. The glittering shards he had placed inside the bulletproof container called to him. But he was too weak to move it. Too old. Too sick. He could not, single handedly, transport the coffin to the next location.

He wished he could test multiple people, simultaneously. But to accomplish such an ambitious project, he required assistance. He wondered if it would be possible to find someone worthy of this. 

Not a single test subject had yet to survive the games. 

So for now, he bided his time. He would focus on the simpler tests. The lighter instruments and easy to transport tools would have to do for now. 

He was also limited to the persons he could grab. Though he had plenty of narcotics to drug people, it was still extremely taxing on the body to drag and carry fully grown adults. To fully test the fabric of humanity’s survival, he would need at least one person who was younger and stronger.

Gordon had given him two years, ideally. He didn’t have much time.

But who?

He rubbed his temple, sighing. When the tea kettle whistled, he retrieved it, poured himself a cup, and returned to his drawing board.

Before him, his latest creation smiled up with its maw of steel and careful measurements. He had taken the high torque of the bear trap, reversing the spring mechanisms so that it would burst outward instead of inward. He imagined what it would do to the jaw of a person who found their teeth pressed between the contact points.

He wondered who would be the person he would have wear it. As he sipped the hot liquid, savoring the bitterness, he thought of one particular drug addict whom Jill had always complained about during her off hours.

“This poor girl, I see her at the clinic so often. She promises she’ll get clean but comes back right after. Her arms are covered with infected needle marks. I tell her she will die if she keeps this up. She just agrees with whatever I say because she wants the withdrawal to stop. I’ve never seen someone so defeated by life.”

He took his pencil, carefully outlining the headset that would support the four pounds of steel. 

“Poor Amanda. She’s a lost cause, I’m afraid.”

 

Mark Hoffman

He let out a roar of triumph when the mechanism lowered with a metallic click. His voice echoed off the concrete, deep laughs that he almost didn’t recognize as his own. The only sounds that had kept him company in Rosello’s old warehouse were the clang of construction and the occasional swear word growled in frustration.

Finally! 

He had spent days trying to figure out what the problem had been. Whenever the pendulum blade would complete its full sweep - back and forth, back and forth - the chassis supporting the entire fucking thing was supposed to lower by two inches. 

For reasons unknown - until now - he had been struggling to find why it would not lower. The motor was not receiving a signal from the sensor by the fourth swing. It had been off by a hair. So he had to have the sensor shifted down an inch and suddenly it all worked, perfectly.

As the pendulum clicked and lowered another interval, the woosh of the blade slicing across the slab where Seth Baxter would soon lay, Hoffman knew it would happen tonight.

Like the scene from Frankenstein, a flash of lightning followed by the boom of thunder filled the warehouse. 

It’s alive. And soon, Baxter will die.

After he observed the pendulum complete all its operations, reaching the end of its possible reach and finishing with its return to the original position, he zipped up his rain jacket and went to his car. 

The rain cascaded down his windshield as he dialed Matthew's number. 

"Yeah?"

"Eric, I need an alibi."

"Oh yeah?" Amusement and the puff of a cigarette. "Need help burying the body too?"

Mark paused, the irony not lost to him. "I have a date tonight. Don't want it getting back to Will."

"Huh. Yeah, I get it." The hesitation made Mark's stomach roll. "Never knew you were such a player. Especially after how things ended with her. Figured it was temporary." Though Matthews was never one to judge a man from getting his rocks off, it was clear he didn't approve.

"It's nothing serious. Just a distraction. I have needs."

"I hear ya, brother. I've got your back. Allison won't hear a peep from me. We were out drinking tonight, after all. Just the two of us. I had a lot to bitch about."

"I owe you one." Relief sighed through his veins.

"Don't you forget it. Have fun." The phone clicked and silence followed.

Mark snapped his cellphone shut and started the engine.

Despite his urgency, it was not fueled with rage. Far from it. True, he wanted Baxter to suffer as soon as possible. But he would savor every moment of it and needed every step he took to be perfect. It was a close call, but Mark was sure things would go as planned tonight.

Alibi done. No one is going to look for me. Trap is set, following the M.O. Kerry's FBI friends profiled. Will is across the country. Now, I just need Baxter

The only reason he didn’t wait another week was because this was the last day of Baxter’s shift for a while. The guy wasn't scheduled to work for another month, and that was too far down the road for comfort. For all Mark knew, the real Jigsaw Killer could be caught by then and he'd have to come up with a completely new way to kill him. 

He didn’t allow his mind to wander as he drove to the mall. He was completely in the present. Hyper-focused. He saw every person he drove past. The sound of his own excited breathing was clear in his ears.

He parked his car in the spot just out of view of the cameras. Raising his hood to hide his hair, he stalked forward. He clutched the syringe in his pocket, keeping his head down, and squatted behind the dumpsters. 

Despite the two hours of waiting, Baxter had appeared right on time, carrying two giant trash bags and swinging them over the same bin he always did. And then, like the trash he was, he proceeded to light himself a cigarette and lean a shoulder against the metal, sighing out smoke and oblivious to the shadow that closed in on him. 

Hoffman was behind him, uncapping the needle.

He let Baxter take one more exhale before he plunged the needle into his trapezius, pushing all the sedative in. Besides the surprised flinch, Baxter fell over in an instant. 

Too easy

He smirked and went to drag the man by his ankles, far from the evening light's touch and the watchful eyes of any cameras. 

He was confident Baxter wouldn't wake for the next four hours. Ten milligrams of Diazepam and at his low bodyweight, he wouldn't be surprised if it took at least five.

But to be safe, he handcuffed his wrists and ankles before stowing him in the trunk and slamming it shut.

" Nice and easy, son. If you're going to do a job, you got to do it right ."

These words were old and distant memories. He had heard it often, when he was just a young boy learning how to build birdhouses or change the oil of their family station wagon.

Despite all the trouble this elaborate revenge required, Mark felt it was the right way. Framing the Jigsaw Killer would keep suspicion off of him. And it allowed something more.

" One day, you will be the man of the family. And as a man, it is your duty to protect the family ."

He knew his father would have wanted a hand in avenging Angelina's death. Using the skills passed down to him to kill Seth Baxter was a way to share the knife handle as it plunged into that bastard’s heart.

Mark Hoffman senior would have designed something more elaborate, had he been alive now. Perhaps a timed electric chair or something a little more flashy. His father would rewire his childhood home's lighting fixtures for Christmas to flash in sync with music he blasted on the stereo. The man's brilliance always left Mark awestruck.

He arrived at the warehouse, the yellow door's peeled paint familiar and comforting. The rain wouldn't let up, it seemed. That was fine by him.

Let it rain. 

He got out, feeling the warm water seep through the openings of his jacket, invigorating his resolve.

Getting Baxter out of the trunk and carrying him to the slab had been as easy as bringing in groceries.

He took the hoodie and shirt off his back, curling his lip at the patches of tattoos along his torso, and secured the leather straps. Clamping the neck restraint closed and checking his handiwork, he nodded to himself.

This was clean. Baxter would not break free, no matter how hard he tugged at his restraints. 

He left the man, checking his watch, noting he had at least an hour and a half before he would begin to wake. The motion detected lights would trigger when Baxter flailed about, and Mark would begin the game.

So now he waited. 

He took post at his vantage point,  behind the door with the peephole, sitting on an upturned eight gallon bucket and leaned against the wall. Exhaustion seeped through his bones and made his eyelids heavy.

When was the last time he slept?

Days ? It seemed so.

He rarely slept anymore. He hadn't been able to drift naturally since she died. Only heavy drinking brought him waking in his bed, not remembering how he got there.

As soon as Baxter was dealt with, he'd return to this self medication. He’d reward himself for his hard work.

He closed his eyes, thinking only of Angie. He couldn't linger on happy memories of her. They only tightened his throat. So he held onto the night he found her, throat slashed in her bed. Anger boiled in his chest and he held onto it with gratitude, knowing soon all this hate would blossom into satisfaction when the pendulum would slice through Baxter's guts and spill his blood for all this pain he had caused.

The lights flashed on. He heard a gasp and metallic fumbling in the room. He opened his eyes, surprised at how fast the time had gone.

"GAHHHUHH!"

He sneered as he silently got to his feet. He took out the small remote from his pocket and turned on the television, squinting through the peephole.

Trapped and wriggling, panting and looking terrified, Seth Baxter froze when the TV flashed to the edited footage Mark had prepared from copies of the current collection of Jigsaw tapes he had pilfered in the past months.

"Hello, Seth," his own voice, distorted to that raspy whisper, brought chills up his neck. " I want to play a game. Right now, you are feeling helpless.This is the same feeling you have bestowed upon others. But now- ,"

"It is onto you ," he mouthed softly, lip syncing to his own recording, smiling. 

"No!" Seth gasped.

" Some may call this karma. I call this justice. Now you served five years on what should have been a life sentence for murder. A technicality gave you freedom. But it didn't give you an understanding of the impact of taking a life. Today, I give you true freedom. "

"NOO!"

"In thirty seconds, the pendulum will drop far enough to touch your body. Within sixty seconds it will cut you in half. To avoid the pendulum, all you have to do is destroy the things that have killed. Your hands."

Seeing Baxter lift his hands, emotion twisting his face and wetting his eyes, was a beautiful sight. 

He wondered if he would put them in between the pressure plates or would he truly accept his fate with the pendulum.

Mark already knew it was likely he would try to survive.

"Make your choice."

The clock began ticking.

The motor revved up and the pendulum dropped, whooshing over Baxter's stomach.

"IT WAS AN ACCIDENT!" He screamed at the top of his lungs.

This infuriated Mark but he gritted his teeth and remained patient. He waited this far. He could wait another sixty seconds.

The thunderous clang of the pendulum lowering its first interval and Baxter's horrified gasps were a reward for his self restraint. 

Baxter pulled and looked around, a wounded rat in a glue trap. After vain attempts to break free from the straps and chains, he finally put his hands in the crushers.

At first he flinched away.

But the next lowering and the constant whoosh of the blade made Baxter finally oblige and press the switches to compress his hands.

The crunch and wet splat of gore followed by the pained yell filled Mark with triumph. Suffer .

Baxter pulled his crushed hands free, trying to pull his collar off. When it didn't and the realization widened his eyes, it was finally time.

The first slice was quick and without any notable sound besides pained screams.

The second slash and his belly ripped open to show the tubes of intestines glisten cherry red under the lights. Tearing flesh had the sound of wet cardboard ripping.

The third slash and Baxter was now in two pieces. A clump of his guts flung across the room.

Sixty seconds, gone in an instant.  

It felt far too short.

Baxter was dying, his head turned to look right at him. They locked eyes and a defeated understanding darkened in his pale face.

"I did what I was supposed to do," he whispered in weak confusion before he jerked and let out his final rattling breath.

The pendulum slowed, its job done, now allowed to rest.

Mark went to the room, looking down at his handiwork. He had seen plenty of dead bodies in his life. But unlike the usual twist of pity when gazing at a victim, he felt a cool detachment as if he was browsing meat at a butcher's shop.

He took his serrated knife, Angie's gift, and carved the jigsaw puzzle piece along the body's skin and peeling it out of his flesh.

He was still conflicted, knowing he should dispose of it properly, but wanting to keep it as a souvenir to remember this moment.

Angelina can now rest in peace.

"And you can burn in hell," he spoke to Baxter's empty eyes.

 

Peter Strahm

Stepping off the plane, he could feel the dry heat of California as he walked up the gate tunnel and into the airport. He sighed in relief, thankful for air conditioning and being in a more open space.

Flying these days was brutal. It was bad enough that security had exploded and new restrictions that didn't make sense were imposed, but he also ended up with a middle seat with a broken backrest, the very last spot available for the next flight to San Diego.

His lower back was killing him. But his spirits were high.

Will had called him, her voice desperate. "I could really use a friendly face right now. I'll explain when you get here." He had plenty of time to take off. And his face could be downright cuddly when needed.

Lindsay, from Allison, had informed him that Will's relationship with her immediate family was complicated. It was hinted she would benefit with a grounded companion while coping with the multitude of emotions. 

He would withhold the analytics, wanting more than anything for this opportunity to bloom into something they both wanted. He was worried for her, it sounded like she was having a terrible time. 

She was currently at the hospital. He waited in line for a rental car, feeling impatient but keeping his frustration down. He would see her, sooner than later. 

He was given an old Honda Civic, the cruise control not working, but he didn't care.

Traffic was backed up miles and slow but it didn't annoy him.

Because when he pulled up to the hospital parking lot and saw Will sitting on a bench, clasping her knees to her chest, while balancing a cigarette in between her fingers, he felt a pleasant tickling in his chest.

He got out, walking to her with a warm smile. "Hey, Will."

She looked up at him, forcing a smile back. He saw it in her eyes. She was hurting. "Thanks for coming, Pete."

He sat on the bench beside her, the sharp acrid smell stinging his nose but he didn't complain.

She looked tired. Bags under her eyes, lines cutting her forehead and the corners of her mouth. "Have you had lunch?"

She shrugged. "No."

He waited a beat. "Want to grab something? I'm starving."

She looked at him with a hopeful glimmer. "Yeah. Dad's sleeping and Bram needed to take care of things. I'm down to get out of here."

"Any good spots?"

She smirked. "This is San Diego, Pete, the real question is, what are you hungry for?"

"I hear fish tacos here are to die for."

"You got that right. Come on, I'll drive." She disposed of her cigarette and led him to her rental, a Dodge Charger.

"They gave you a muscle car?" He asked, bewildered and envious.

She laughed, the sound a beautiful thing. "Yeah, I lucked out."

He had only experienced Will drive once, but as she sped across lanes and dodged cars, he held on for dear life, wondering what her more reckless use of the steering wheel meant. He kept his teeth clenched and thoughts to himself, though. 

"How was your flight?"

"Fine," he lied, "the peanuts were gross."

She snickered again. "You eat those?"

"I don't turn down free food."

"Fair."

She soared across the pavement, taking them across a tall bridge that overlooked grand Navy warships, yachts, and a cruiseliner. 

"The views were beautiful here."

"They are," she agreed. "And the weather is perfect. I almost miss it here."

Almost. It was a baited statement and he could tell she was ready to open up to him. "So why not?"

"I left here with Frank. My brother still hasn't forgiven me. Which I get. And now that my father's awake, I can't keep running anymore."

"You felt like you were running before?"

She parked the car along a street downtown, where a tiny restaurant with loud corrido music blared from a corner speaker.

"Not to be so dramatic, but my whole life I've felt like I'm running from something. You know what I mean?"

She had said this in passing, leading the way into the restaurant and studying the menu board while he stared at her in alarm. He did not know what she meant, not personally. But he knew of a long list of conditions that could drive an urge for escape. 

"Lunch is on me," he announced, "get as much as you want."

"Thanks. What are you having?"

"Fish tacos, of course,” he tried to stay jovial. "You?"

"The Cali-burrito, missed those back east."

They got their food and sat outside, the warm sun kissing their shoulders and brought out the rose-gold in her hair.

"So I have another favor to ask."

"Sure," he said before taking bites, watching her. 

"Come with me when I visit my father." She keeps calling him 'father', as if trying to keep distance. "And maybe bring up a reason for me to leave next week. I said I'd stay for a while, but I just can't. But I can't just go and tell them that. So if you can mention a case, hell, the Jigsaw case, that would be so helpful."

It was a silly thing to ask. Surprisingly non-confrontational, which he did not think typical of her. But he wouldn't judge. "If that's what you think is best, sure."

Relief relaxed her shoulders. She put a hand on his, squeezing it briefly before releasing. "Thank you."

Her hand left a buzzing sensation on his skin. He cleared his throat. "Anytime." He took this as a good sign. “May I ask why?”

The narrowing of her eyes answered him but she let in a deep breath. “I just can’t face him right now. It’s hard to explain.”

“Maybe I can help make it easy,” he prompted, curious and eager. 

They got their food and sat outside, looking out at the street where people went about their lives with smiles and no worry.

“Did I ever tell you why I became a cop?”

“No, you haven’t.” 

“When I was fourteen, home intruders broke in. My father stood up to them. I hid.” She spoke matter-of-fact and monotone, as if reading a newspaper. “Bram was a baby. I remember that day. I don’t remember his face anymore. But I remember his voice. He had come into the room I’d been hiding in, digging through drawers. He hadn’t even bothered to wear a mask. It makes sense now, but at the time I didn’t think about why that was. He lft the room. And I heard my mother scream. And the gun shots. My father yelling. My mother not. Bram, crying in the other room.” She didn’t touch her food and ran her fingers through her hair, eyes downcast. “I became a cop because I wanted to catch the bastard. I thought I could do it.” And then her face twisted, her grief muscles twitching.

He reached over and took her hand, squeezing it comfortingly. “What happened next?”

“The case went cold. By the time I was old enough to join the force, politics kept me from it. I tried to fight them but they had assigned it to other investigators. Lazy pricks. Said I was too emotionally invested and to let them handle it. And then I met Frank. And just let it go. I had other things to worry about after that. And I let it all distract me.”

“Can you continue to let it go?”

“Not when my dad’s awake. I just can’t now, right? He needs to know the guy that did this is locked away for good.” She was somber. “But what can I do now? It’s been decades. I barely remember anything. And I don’t know if I could just take time off and investigate solo, you know? I didn’t keep many lasting connections here in San Diego.”

“But you do want to investigate it?”

She blinked, nodded. “Yeah. I do.”

He nodded, his mind listing the various things that would need to get done. He could reach out to San Diego PD, offer FBI resources in exchange for access to the investigation. And he could recommend Will to one of the programs they had where they offered temp work with her department. “I can help.”

The tears brimming her eyes faded away. “I knew I could count on you.”

His heart skipped a beat. “Don’t you forget it.”

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

"Hi, Angie," Will brushed the stray leaves and dirt off of her tombstone. She replaced the wilted bouquet with fresh angelonias and laurels, pushing stray blades of grass from blocking her name. "Sorry I haven't visited in a while."

She hesitated, as if she was really there. "You probably already know, but Mark and I broke up." No longer did tear dew her eyes when she dwelled on this. "I'm sorry, I couldn't make this work. And I'm more sorry that I let Baxter out of prison. You didn't deserve that." Now the salt flowed down her cheeks and she wiped at them and looked away, admiring the clouds above. "I just hope that you are in a better place." Her voice broke. "You and Peter. I don't think Mark wants me in his life anymore and I need to respect that. I know you'll look after him. So I'm not worried." Her face flushed with guilt. 

Like everything else, she chose to let things go.

Every time she crossed paths with Mark, he looked through her. He came to work, looking pristine and well kept. But he had returned to the days when he was a loner. Only when a new Jigsaw case appeared, had he socialized with their colleagues, though he continued to pretend she didn't exist.

And now that her father was awake, Bram was exhausted with being the only one there for her family. Things needed to change. She needed a change.

She wanted to be a better person than she was.

She stood over the bones of one of her closest friends, Angelina's very memory forever tainted by her own failures.

She could follow Mark and drink her pain to oblivion. Push everyone away.

But I'm not a quitter, damn it. I’m tired of quitting.

Yet she had to quit Mark. She had to, because he had quit her first. 

She was so tired of feeling so damn lonely.

"I know I don't deserve forgiveness over Seth Baxter. But I hope you can forgive me for letting Mark go." She sniffled and turned away. 

Mark Hoffman stood, watching. She flinched back and gasped, his presence like that of a phantom’s.

"I didn't know you were back."

"Landed this morning," she blinked quickly and shrugged, eyes downcast while her cheeks burned. How much had he heard?

"How's your father?"

This sudden interest, she had not expected. "He's well."

"I thought it was the groundskeeper who maintained their graves."

She shrugged and the shrill ring of her phone made her sigh in relief. "I got to take this. Bye." She wasn't sure when she'd come back. Probably not for a long time. She left him there, feeling his eyes follow her.

While walking to her car, she answered. It was Ally.

"Hey," she was about to explain her long lunch break.

"I need you southside. There's another Jigsaw death." There was a prickle in her words.

She sighed. "I'm on the way."

"Will, first, listen. Are you sitting down?"

"Yes?" Now fear's icy grip squeezed her throat. "Do we know the victim?"

"It's Seth Baxter."

She stared out the windshield to an old sycamore tree where half the branches were dead and rotting. "What?"

"Seth Baxter. Looks like Jigsaw liked Ange's cooking." The misplaced humor and practical glee caught Will off guard. Ally sounded almost happy.

She covered her mouth and began to cry all over again. She should have maintained her composure. She shouldn't have felt the emotions she did. Relief. Hope. She found herself glancing at Mark’s back in the distance as he looked down to the tombstones. 

"Thank God."

Notes:

A/N: Don't feel this chapter is quite polished but hopefully it's good enough TT0TT You all are wonderful, thanks for reading! Sorry for the long month of nothing - work and personal life decided to curb stomp my free time and this is my first weekend back!

Chapter 42: Peri-SAW: Going to the Same Place

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

"Hoffman," Fisk had walked into his office while he was lost in thought. He had been daydreaming of that night, at the moment the splat of Baxter’s intestines slapped to the floor. "We've got a body. Looks like another Jigsaw victim."

 

He blinked. It hadn't even been twenty four hours since Baxter died. It couldn't be him. Could it?

 

Fisk looked concerned at his hesitation. "You up for this?"

 

"Yeah." He tossed the folder he had been clutching on his desk and followed Fisk out.

 

If it was Baxter, he would need to play it cool. He wasn't worried about Fisk, who wasn't the sharpest detective in the precinct, which was why he was one of Mark's favorites these days. But the others - they would notice if he was acting off. Especially Will.

 

When they pulled up to the warehouse, Mark's stomach felt like moths were cage fighting inside. “This is one of Rosello’s,” he stated, as if surprised.

 

“Huh. Weird coincidence.” Fisk killed the engine.

 

He saw Will and Kerry at the entrance, in a heated discussion. Great . He hadn't anticipated she would be back from San Diego so soon. Seeing her at Angie’s resting place had been unexpected - but surprisingly welcome. He had forgotten how easily seeing her face could bring a glimmer of warmth. Only recently did that feeling return instead of anger.

 

Absence makes the heart grow fonder . The saying had some merit. It seemed their break had helped soothe his resentment towards her. Now that he had taken Baxter’s fate in his hands, reclaimed control, now he could heal. They could heal.

 

Standing at the doorway, hugging herself, she cast him a fleeting glance that was stained with concern. Doe-eyes. He wanted to say something to her but he looked away.

 

Not here . She would complicate things, as she was prone to do, and he wasn't in the mood. Not when he had to act shocked seeing Angie's murderer dead.

 

He expected her to accost him as he crossed the yellow tape. He snuck a glance, curious at her subverting his expectation.

 

Kerry had her hand on Will's shoulder, consoling her. She locked eyes with him, pursing her lips and shaking her head.

 

She’s acting like I’m the bad guy, he fumed as he followed Fisk inside.

 

"Victim is a typical murder convict who served five years and was just released last month." Fisk did not know what Kerry and Will obviously had.

 

Mark would have been annoyed at Fisk’s poor attention to detail - if it was just any other case. But at this moment, he was grateful. Of all the detectives to investigate his crime, it was a godsend the man for the job had been this guy.

 

All around, forensics took their pictures and dusted for fingerprints. Mark was confident they would not find so much as a shoeprint. So why was his heart thundering in his ears and his fingers twitched at his sides.

 

As soon as he saw Baxter's gray face, he announced, "I know him. His name is Seth Baxter. My sister's ex-boyfriend." He tried to look down and sound grave. The flies hadn’t even gotten to him yet. He looked too fresh for Hoffman’s liking.

 

Fisk had gone quiet. "This is the guy that murdered your sister?"

 

Mark nodded, letting the authentic pain show in his frown. "He was sentenced to twenty five years. Reduced to five on a technicality."

 

Fisk’s silence was thick with the knowledge that everyone in their department whispered about. It had been Will Maddox, his partner and former lover, who had been that technicality. "Well then I'd say justice was served."

 

Mark kept his mouth pressed tight into a frown while he squinted to suppress the grin that itched his cheeks.

 

“That’s dangerous talk,” footsteps clicked behind them, Tapp’s low voice echoed off the concrete. “I knew it was too quiet for too long,” he muttered while looking up at the pendulum, eyebrow raised. “And every time it’s always topping the last. We got ourselves a vigilante serial killer who fancies himself a mad scientist. Damn.”

 

The sharp high pitched wisp of the body bag zipper robbed Mark’s attention. He watched the pathologist seal Baxter up while Sing strode across the room to admire the peephole.

 

"Hey, Hoffman, you wouldn't happen to have the Jigsaw Killer on payroll, would you?" Sing was joking but there was a shadow of inquiry laced in his words.

 

Tapp silently observed.

 

"Obviously, I’m thrilled my sister’s murderer is no longer a threat to the public. But I don’t take pleasure in seeing her memory being tarnished by this." The words rolled off his tongue, the way he rehearsed it.

 

Tapp was nodding. “This is one of the first victims I'm not particularly sad about. None of us are. But we've got to treat this like every other victim. A human life was ended here. Promise you keep that in mind, and you have my support being on the case." 

 

This surprised Mark. Tapp walked up, hands in his pockets. "I know you'll be good help."

 

He felt triumph fill his chest. He was in the clear. "I'll get the report from the coroner, then."

 

"There’s just one thing," Tapp's voice stopped him in his tracks.

 

"Which is?"

 

"This property. You know anything about it?"

 

He knew what Tapp was hinting at. “It’s Toni Rosello’s.” He remained calm. “You think it’s more than a coincidence?”

 

Sing nodded. "Yeah, and I wonder what the connection is between Angelina and Jigsaw.”

 

He flared his nostrils. “Nothing, likely. Jigsaw probably just went through public record on murderers who got out early. Or it’s an old connection with Baxter.”

 

“Yeah. Weird it’s all connected to you, though,” Tapp, despite earlier seeming friendly, eyed him like an insect he was studying.

 

“With the current kill count, it’s only due time until more of us find ourselves standing over a body we’re connected to,” Sing interjected, “That is, unless we stop this guy fast. And from where I'm standing we need all the hands we can get right now. Matthews is out. And Will just now refused to join."

 

This, made Hoffman raise an eyebrow. “Why?”

 

Sing shrugged. “I have a couple of guesses. She just said she’s busy.”

 

If it wasn’t perfectly aligning with what Hoffman wanted, he would have been insulted. “But she and Ange were close.”

 

“I hear,” Tapp leaned over Baxter’s belly to squint at the jigsaw-shaped red flesh. “Kerry is pissed. But Will won’t budge. You saw them bickering out there. This." Tapp looked upwards, dark eyes heavy, “scares me. He’s smart. And refining his method.”

 

“Let’s just hope there’s a Rosello link,” Kerry announced herself as she walked in, clicking her cell phone shut. “We’re pulling up the old case files. Making sure Jigsaw doesn’t make a habit out of using Rosello’s properties for where he plays his sick little games. Oh, and Maddox went home.”

 

Mark studied her face, searching for any hint as to why. She stared cooly back. “She says she won’t compromise the investigation and will comply with being interviewed to clear herself as a potential suspect. She wishes us luck.”

 

Tapp sniffed loudly and nodded. "A shame. Maybe she’ll change her mind soon. And how about the FBI?”

 

“They’re finishing the profile and will brief us next week. They’re pretty swamped though, so they won’t be in-person. Perez said she can consult. Strahm’s MIA. And Hoffman,” Kerry got close to him, lowering her voice, “I need you to come back and answer some questions before you can poke around anymore.”

 

It was protocol. He did, after all, have motive. Understandable . Hoffman wasn’t worried, not when Tapp and Sing had basically rolled the red carpet for him to join the investigation. “Then let’s get it done.”



John Kramer

 

John enjoyed reading the paper first thing in the morning these days. He had a ritual where he would brew ginseng tea and peruse the pages to read the latest on the Jigsaw Killer, as the media loved to call him.

 

But this particular morning, his tea had gone cold and bitter before he had a chance to drink.

 

He was fuming as he glared along the black text, wondering if this was some desperate trick by the police.

 

Jigsaw Killer Strikes Again by Pamela Jenkins

 

The city continues to cower as the Jigsaw killer terrorizes those he claims to ‘take life for granted’. The latest victim is Seth Baxter, a resident of Bronzeville East, found in the southside last night by two urban explorers. Baxter was found in a gruesome state, in an apparent ‘game’ involving a pendulum that sliced him across the lower stomach. Police are completely baffled and without any leads on the Jigsaw Killer…

 

The details were specific. The tabloid even had a picture of the pendulum. John narrowed his eyes. What an overly grandiose choice . Whoever it was, certainly thought highly of himself. Despite his reservations that this copycat was some low class cheap imitation, he admitted that there must have been some skill for the developer to have produced a functional trap of that magnitude. 

 

Though he abhorred being given credit for work that was not his, he believed this was a golden opportunity. Someone admired his work. He smiled. This was what he needed, now, more than ever.

 

He suppressed the urge to cough. He was growing weaker by the day.

 

He needed to gain more information. Whoever did this somehow fooled the police. John knew details of his latest traps had been withheld from the public. Whoever was able to fool law enforcement had to have intimate knowledge of his methods, otherwise, it was likely they would have announced a copycat had emerged.

 

John deduced it had to be someone from the inside. An officer of the law, likely. And someone intimate with the case - had to be a homicide detective.

 

He took the paper and went to the computer, performing an internet search for Seth Baxter.

 

The first article, talking of Seth Baxter's conviction for the murder of a young girl, led him down the trail of a tragic story. Angelina Acomb. A Gold Star Wife. A chef with a promising future, robbed of it one fateful night. And then, he knew who he was looking for, from a single picture appearing in an old article.

 

Detective Mark Hoffman, as he lays his sister to rest after her murder.

 

John studied the photograph. He could see pain in the boy's eyes, and a hardened resolve as he clutched his hands in front of him, staring at the camera.

 

He would need to follow him. Verify that his theory was correct. But John’s hunches were never wrong. It used to drive Jill insane, when he would predict whether a clinic donor would back out last minute or the many times he would know just what she was feeling and thinking.

 

I’m married to a psychic ,” she would say. 

 

John felt a coughing fit rise up and he choked out his lungs for a long minute.

 

If this copycat is this Mark Hoffman, I can use him.

 

But he would need to plan. Carefully. He would need to sneak around and learn this man’s routines. His vices. His secrets. He would learn of those he loved the most. And the things he cared about. And John would use them to keep him close. 

 

He didn’t know this man but he could sense that this was a kindred spirit. A fellow soul desperate for justice.

 

“So you lost your sister. A shame. She sounded like a lovely woman,” he whispered as he studied the obituary of Angelina Hoffman. Survived by a brother and friends. No one else

 

“No other family?” Pity came over him. Though the details weren’t clear, he could read between the lines. Domestic dispute. Drug abuse suspected. Another victim to the corruption of the city and the predation of those who have yet to truly understand that life was precious. 

 

For the first time since his diagnosis, John felt hope. 



Wilhelmina Maddox

 

She kept herself busy with as many non-Jigsaw homicides as she could fit on her desk. Sometimes, Ally would knock on her door, coming up with a new sales pitch to convince her to come join the investigation.

 

She just couldn't. Not when Mark was involved. She understood everyone else's openness to him joining. And she knew she was a hypocrite for trying to stand with the code of ethics she had swept aside back when she helped convict Seth Baxter. But this feeling in her heart that there was something deeply wrong if she got involved made her keep a wide berth. 

 

She blamed it on the post-break-up blues.

 

Damn , she wanted a cigarette, but she had only recently quit again. She intended to stick to it this time. She had a lot she wanted to change.

 

Lately, her mind was caught on imagining a future where she was married and had a kid or two. It was a funny thought, something that never crossed her mind before, but it had burrowed into her subconscious and constantly popped into her ruminations at random intervals.

 

Maybe it was because Peter Strahm had been rather aggressive with courting her lately. She admitted, she liked the attention. 

 

He called her every Thursday evening and they would talk for two hours on how their days had gone. Boring stuff. Perfectly normal. Complaints about work. Inflation. The strong desire to take a vacation somewhere sunny with a beach. And though these conversations would have bored her to tears a decade ago, these days she found herself oddly comforted by them. 

 

At first, they were exclusively casual friendly talks. But lately, the conversations became thick with suggestions, honeyed words and warmth that she found a thirst for. 

 

She had at first thought it was nothing serious. But somehow, the topics ranged from the latest investigations into dreams of finding someone to spend the rest of their lives with. Sprinkled in were updates on Peter’s attempts to get a hold of her mother’s murder case file. So far, the paperwork had been routed but they were waiting for San Diego city officials to release them.

 

She would find herself crying randomly afterwards, overwhelmed with joy that a man like Peter would be so interested in helping her - among other things - while admitting that his one flaw was that he was just not Mark Hoffman. And no matter how hard she tried to lie to herself that it was not a flaw but a perk, she just couldn’t seem to believe herself.

 

She knew time would heal that one pain and she looked forward to it.

 

Maybe Peter was more of a rebound, but at least he was a wholesome one.

 

When she arrived at work one Monday, slammed with four fresh homicide cases, and before she even got her first cup of coffee in, she had slumped in her office chair in defeat. 

 

At lunch, loud jeers and whistling had her go and check the commotion outside. 

 

A delivery boy walked in, cheeks pink, holding out a large vase of thick red roses. "Will? Maddox?" The boy looked uncomfortable with the throngs of cops all leering at him. “Oh, I thought you were a guy.” Relief reflected in his face.

 

"That's me," she was hesitant, the burning memory of the last time flowers were delivered to her at work branded in her recollection. She didn’t want to touch the vase. She warily looked for spiders.

 

"These are for you. I need you to sign for it. Please. I’m running late." The urgency in his voice had her lead him into her office. Not one to let a kid suffer, she signed and thanked him, closing the door to confront the gift in peace.

 

She pulled the card from the vase, the printed lettering read, " Hope these brighten your week, beautiful. I miss you . - Peter "

 

Her cheeks flushed, feeling indeed happier because of them. 



Mark Hoffman

 

It had been five weeks since Seth Baxter’s body was found. Five long, painful weeks. The first week had gone quick and smooth. The alibi Matthews had provided cleared, without so much as a follow up. His ex-wife kept raining hell over him and Eric Matthews had too much to care about to even question why he had to provide one in the first place.

 

The second week was when things started going wrong. It wasn’t obvious but Mark had felt as though someone was watching him. His standard routine of going to work was usually quite consistent. But when he found his office door shut - the doorknob latch bolt found to not be firmly in its seat but instead just pressing the strike - the hairs on the back of his neck had stood up.

 

It was an old door and Mark usually had to put some muscle when he pulled it securely shut. Someone had been in his office over the weekend. He tried to shrug it off as that of the janitor. He normally left it unlocked, but the usual guy who emptied his trash knew about the tricky door jam.

 

New guy , he assured himself as he went about his day. He quickly forgot about it.

 

Nothing came up again until the third week. Every day after work, he would go to Larry’s and drink until either the guy cut him off or he found it in him to finally head back to his quiet apartment. 

 

It was one particular night he had felt especially sorry for himself. Now that Baxter was dead and no one was the wiser, he was back to square one in his pitiful life. Only now, no buxom redhead would sit in the barstool beside him, quietly chewing on salty fries while reading pistol magazines and quipping about the poor performance of their city’s baseball team. Instead, his company was the squeaking of glass on greasy rags, the occasional click of a pool cue on bakelite balls, and the phlegm-scratchy coughs of fellow lonesome patrons.

 

Larry had approached him, silently wiping a pint glass, nodding his chin at something behind Mark. “New guy eying you,” he softly muttered before turning to a stumbling drunk who was waving at him for another drink.

 

Mark slowly cocked his head to catch a glimpse in his periphery. Against the booths across the bar, sat a single man. His head was bowed, wearing a baseball cap and a hoodie, not looking out of place but unfamiliar to the usual regulars Mark recognized. Mark was already six drinks in the last hour and this was around the time his vision became hazy around the edges. He couldn’t distinguish the man’s features. He thought the guy looked like a bird, maybe. But he blinked and couldn’t quite make out anything else. 

 

He was too drunk to care. He doubted it was anything more than the usual paranoia. He turned back and took another shot, wanting to finish the fifth of Jameson before Larry’s conscience decided he had enough tonight. He had stumbled to his bed and managed to wake up the next day, as usual.

 

It was the fourth week when he began to suspect someone was targeting him. When he came back home, drunk as a skunk, and fell onto his couch to catch his breath, he thought he had heard a scrape somewhere.

 

He had immediately jumped to his feet, balance off, and gun in hand, eyes darting around his living room with frenzied panic that someone was in his apartment and shouldn’t be. “Will?” He slurred, half-hoping and half-expecting it was her and not some idiot he had to take down. He had cleared his bedroom, closets, bathroom, and had found nothing amiss. 

 

He remembered Angie used to read him one particular Poe story that these days seemed like a prophecy. The Tell-Tale Heart. But it wasn’t Baxter’s heart pounding in the floor boards, it was his own and the damn thing was in his skull, pulsing and throbbing and giving him one hell of a headache.

 

He had put the gun down, clutching his temple and sitting back down on the couch to wait out the pain. Maybe he should quit drinking. But he had nothing better to do these days. His eyes landed on his landline and an urge to call the number he still had memorized coming and going. But he resisted because he wasn’t sure exactly what he could say to her that could fix everything he had said and done. 

 

Maybe it was the guilt that was getting to him. Maybe he wasn’t a complete asshole. He had done what any man would, given the circumstances. His little sister was gone. He had made sure the man responsible was gone, too. But now what? Every day he thought about what could possibly get him caught. He went through every moment. Fingerprints? No. Alibi still checked out, even if Matthews ever took some time to think about the timelines lining up. They could recover hair but Mark was smart. He made sure Fisk kept him on the case. If anything popped up, he could easily forge findings or make the evidence simply ‘disappear’. There was no physical evidence that would get him. He was safe.

 

So why did he feel so damn afraid?

 

He couldn’t sleep that night. He didn’t sleep well for the rest of that week.

 

The fifth week had hit him hard like a freight train. He had been sour from the poor sleep. Even booze wouldn’t put him down now. And with the constant shakes and headache hammering his forehead, the commotion outside his office now was making him want to puke.

 

He had heard the boys outside his office hooting and hollering loud enough to motivate him to get off his ass and investigate. Poking his head out of his office, he paused when he saw Will receiving a ridiculously large bundle of flowers with a smile.

 

He went back inside. He was surprised it had taken this long for someone to make a move on her. He figured the brash and outlandish gesture would get shut down immediately.

 

Her smile stayed in the back of his mind, though. Did she like them that much? Who sent them?

 

He grabbed a document and stared at the words but the more he tried to shut it out the louder these thoughts poured over. She never smiled like that when I gave her flowers.

 

He hadn’t spoken to her in weeks. The two of them were practically strangers, now. How long is she going to keep avoiding me like this ? He wondered. We’re still partners, after all.

 

Come to think of it, he wasn't sure when in their many years together he had ever gotten her flowers.

 

Women like flowers. Nothing new.

 

But the fact that it was Will receiving them was. He remembered the day Rosello had left black widows hidden in a bouquet on her desk when they were younger. This made him jump to his feet, suddenly overcome with a racing heart and breathing hard. Was this another one of those? But he stopped himself. She’s a big girl, she can take care of herself

 

He needed coffee. He was just hung over. Pathetic . Leaving his office, he paused when he reached Will's closed door, her laughter distinct through the thin plaster. The breakroom was just another few doors down. But his feet were cemented to the floor.

 

"Pete, you didn’t have to do this. You're making me blush."

 

Pete? He instantly knew who it was. Peter Strahm. That rat-faced twerp

 

He couldn’t help but linger, letting his ear inch closer to the door frame.

 

"Well, I miss you too. Maybe I'll fly down there sometime. I have the vacation days."

 

"You accidentally glue your ear to the door, Hoffman?" Kerry's sharp voice made him jump. 

 

He turned, feeling embarrassed and angry at being caught. He didn't know what to say.

 

Kerry, looking smooth in her suit and clutching another folder with the familiar ' Jigsaw' label, handing it to him. "Latest victim. We need you to head to the crime scene." 

 

He took the file, his ears burning in embarrassment. Kerry was staring, a slight smirk on her mouth. She nodded to the muffled laugh. “She’s had a few guys ask her out. She turned them all down, waiting for you. And you just kept pushing her away…” She paused and pressed her lips together, shaking her head. “I wouldn’t meddle.” She gave him a side glance. “Just know, she’s been having the worst time because of you. You needed to punish her, and I get that. But you went too far. And after her dad -,” Kerry sounded truly concerned. “She’s changed a lot these past few months. And I can see it in your eye, like I’ve seen in all the men who insisted this would be the last time… so don’t even think about it. Don’t string her along.” She stepped forward, and for the first time he saw cool Allison Kerry look mean and ready to scratch, “Break her heart again and I’ll break your nose.” She spun and left, her heels clicking off the linoleum.

 

Mark couldn’t help but sneer, unimpressed by her threat. Bitch . He went to return to his office but glanced one more time at Will’s door, the knob just within reach. He wanted to open it, just one more time, but then he heard Will’s voice, happy.

 

“I’ve got to go, Pete, loads to do. Tell Lindsay I said ‘hi’.” A long pause. “Oh, wow. Um. I… sorry, kind of need to go. I’ll talk to you later, okay? Bye.” 

 

He could imagine what had gone down in that conversation and he felt the rush of triumph. Did he tell her he loved her? Something along that line? He returned to his office and shut the door, sitting at his desk and contemplated.

 

Will wouldn’t have waited for him forever. He knew that. So why did he feel so disappointed?

 

But of all the men out there, she chose Strahm? That scumbag wasn’t good enough for her. He wondered if there was a way - even a small chance - he could have her laugh with him like that again. Maybe I should buy her some flowers sometime?

 

He sighed, not able to come up with any creative romantic gesture. He could conjure up a million ways to end Seth Baxter but when he tried to think of what would get Will Maddox to take him back, his mind went blank.

 

If he could go back in time and stop himself from pushing her away so forcefully - he would.

 

Still in the trash can, visible through the mesh despite the overflowing crumpled papers and fast-food wrappers, glinted the blue metallic wrapping of Will’s birthday gift to him.  He dug it out.

The box was bent and there was some mayonnaise smeared over the gloss. 

 

He opened it. 

 

It was a brown bottle of cologne. It looked expensive. 

 

He felt himself smile, his headache weakening.. He uncapped the bottle and smelled the nozzle, spraying it in the air and closing his eyes. What scent did she think suited him? He couldn’t make out the specifics. It smelled good, though. All the stress he had been carrying in his neck and shoulders lightened. For just a second, he could relax. She always had a way of doing that to him. Even now, without her being in the room or acknowledging his existence, her actions brought light in his darkness. He recapped the gift and put it in his top drawer. 

 

I should get some work done

 

He went to flip through the folder on his desk. As he turned pages, a manila folder with ‘ DETECTIVE HOFFMAN ’ caught his eye. What’s this? He opened it.

 

I KNOW WHO YOU ARE.

 

His blood froze in his veins. He looked up, around, wondering if this was a prank. But he knew it wasn’t wise to dismiss this.

 

I knew it. Someone knows. He could feel the cold metal of handcuffs on his wrist and practically smelled the piss and grease of prison. No. He needed to deal with this, fast.

 

He instantly thought of Tapp. Sing. If it is a prank, it could be Matthews, but Matthews has been even worse off since his son got arrested for shoplifting. He’s too pissed these days to be funny . Kerry was too busy taking herself seriously to pull a stunt like this. And Will? Will would never . The penmanship wasn’t even close to her soft and rounded handwriting.

 

It’s the Jigsaw Killer, a soft voice whispered in his ear, only heard by his mind and filling him with adrenaline. He knows what you’ve done.

 

He got to his feet, suddenly feeling like the office walls were closing in on him. He needed fresh air. He needed to get home and regroup.

 

He’d take the rest of the day off. Yeah, that’s what I need . He couldn’t remember the last time he had given himself a break. He folded the note, his fingers slick with sweat, and rushed out.

 

“Hey, Hoffman,” Fisk called out, “got a minute?”

 

“Can’t.” He avoided his eyes and wiped his temple. “I think I’m coming down with something.”

 

“Oh, yeah, you look like you’re burning up. Go home. I’ll let Grissom know.” 

 

He was glad to have Fisk.

 

He made it to his car, driving extra carefully, wondering if someone was tailing him. Paranoia tickled his ears and made him look in the rearview mirror every few seconds.

 

When he got into his apartment building, he paused at the foyer. The place looked unchanged. Dirty. Desolate. 

 

Get the mail. Maybe there’s another message. He strode to his mailbox, finding only the typical pizza coupons, political ads, and junk mail littering the area. One brochure from an addict clinic stuck out. Homeward Bound. Cherish Your Life. He tossed the waste of ink back onto the mail counter and leaned against it, telling himself that the reason he felt so on edge was because he was letting his drinking get out of hand.

 

No one knows I killed Baxter. How could they? I’m worried about nothing. I covered my tracks. He figured he was just letting the stress pile on him and the recent revelation of Will’s romantic relationship was breaking the camel’s back. It’s because that piece of shit’s trying to make a move on my woman. Thinking of her helped ease the inexplicable anxiety he was feeling. Maybe I should call her. Yeah. Ask her to coffee. Just get to fixing things.

 

He turned a corner and almost collided into some punk teen, the girl’s headphones blaring loudly as she put a cigarette between her lips without so much as an ‘excuse me’. He looked after her, disgusted. Kids these days have no respect.

 

But so far, it was the usual mundane headaches to get to his room. Nothing out of the ordinary.

 

When the elevator’s ‘OUT OF ORDER’ appeared he rolled his eyes and sighed, stabbing the up button and waiting for the only free car to arrive.

 

He heard the distant cry of a woman. “STOP!”  He whirled towards the source, taking his gun out. He knew his nerves were fried. But he wasn’t taking any changes.

 

It was to the stairs. He expected someone to be lurking behind the door, waiting to pounce on him. He crept close, his heart thudding in his ears, when the door burst open and a dog barked, being held back by a screaming woman.

 

Noises melded together, screams and barking and the sound of his own heart exploded and scattered his thought processes like a house of cards. 

 

“Come on! Pee Wee! Come on!” The woman held back the german shepherd while grumbling about the gun but thankfully, raised no further complaints as she left Mark to his thundering pulse. 

 

“Fucking Pee Wee. Shit,” he whispered to himself before he reached the elevators. 

 

He returned to waiting at the doors. At the ding he stepped forward.

 

“Do you mind?” A hostile woman glared hatefully up at him. He stepped back as the crowd of people walked by, their eyes and smirks adding to his bad day.

 

An old man remained, nodding at him as he entered.

 

“Going up?” he asked, assuming the man had gotten caught going down because of the single car. 

 

“Yes, thank you,” the man whispered.

 

Mark entered and pressed his floor level and the doors closed. That awkward silence that followed when entering a confined space with a complete stranger followed. Mark looked up to admire how the buttons progressed with every ding. 

 

He looked at the button panel and paused, noting that only his floor was selected.

 

This guy wasn’t one of his neighbors.

 

That uneasiness returned in his gut. Trying to be slow and subtle he turned his head. In the corner of his eye, he noticed his fellow rider’s hand.

 

He was wearing black leather gloves.

 

He went for his gun. “What floor are you going to?”

 

Feeling the wind rush over his face and the sudden skewer of his neck made him flinch and cry out in pain. 

 

But he pushed back. He growled and mustered all his strength to fight whatever it was that hurt his neck and push him to the floor. He tried to roar. Something cool rushed into him, and then everything became warm. Nausea and the need to sleep made him heavy.

 

His vision blurred and soon it was all fading to black. “I think we’re both going to the same place,” the man’s words softly echoed into oblivion.



Notes:

A/N: So sorry for the delays - this summer has been one hell of a ride. And then my computer shit the bed but I finally got this chapter ready to go! I'm so hyped for SAW X btw! Part of me wants to slow down and try to incorporate the lore in X to this story. I hear it takes place in between SAW 1 - 3. And I'm not going to get my hopes up on Hoffman being in it. But I swear, if he's in it, I'm gonna squeal in theaters.

Chapter 43: Peri-SAW: The First Apprentices

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Amanda Young

 

She awoke. Her neck hurt. Something was making her head feel heavy. The corners of her mouth were throbbing. All she could taste was blood… and metal.

Opening her eyes she realized her wrists were strapped to the arms of a chair. “Mmm!” She tried to look down, realizing something was attached to her head. She pulled at her restraints. Tried to stand. She kept trying to scream but something hard was against her teeth and tongue. Help me!

How did she get here? 

She had been at home. She had scored. And was supposed to be lying on her bed, riding out her shiny new high.

But she knew what this was about. The Jigsaw Killer, she thought, and then the TV erupted in a static analog shriek at her side.

A puppet, gruesome, turned its head to her. She could have laughed. A dream. This is all just one real fucked up hallucination. 

But as she twisted her wrists, the burn of the straps biting her skin, she knew this was real.

“Hello, Amanda. You don’t know me… but I know you.”

All she could do was stare at the screen, panting, trying to make sense of his words. What is happening? Why me? Why?

“When the timer goes off…”

This wasn’t fucking fair. What did she do to deserve getting this psycho’s attention? She felt the skin on her arm sting from the friction. Her eyes were wet.

“...Think of it as a reverse bear trap.” The ticking made her stiffen and when the mannequin’s head exploded into dust she began to scream again, fingers trembling. Fuck fuck fuck. This asshole’s gonna blow my head off!

“There is only one key to open the device.” The hope was thick and coagulated in the back of her throat. “It’s in the stomach of your dead cellmate.”

She looked around and noted the man on his back several yards away. Dead. A dead body.

“Look around, Amanda. Know that I’m not lying. Better hurry up. Live or die. Make your choice.”

The TV erupted into static and the aggressive jerking of her wrists were rewarded by the sudden slip of her hand through one of the arm restraints. She used her free hand to loosen the other and jumped up with a triumphant muffle.

The feeling of tension on the back of her head snapped. She froze. When she felt a strong ticking right against her skull her eyes widened. 

NO. She touched the device on her head and tried to pull it off. She writhed and spun, dizzy from her craze. I can’t get if off. I’m going to fucking die! But then she saw the body.

She remembered what she had to do.

The clock kept ticking.

She made it to the man, the sight of his pale face making her stomach roll. But she didn’t have time to get sensitive now. Fuck that. No. Key. I need the key . At his side a small pocket knife glinted. She took it.

She knelt down, realizing she knew who it was.

Donnie. You poor bastard.

Donnie - wasn’t her friend. He had been more Cecil’s. But he had kept her supplied. He even pretended he cared, when he needed a booty call and felt generous. 

Sorry, Donnie, she silently prayed as she held the knife over her head and prepared herself to play operation on his corpse.

His eyes fluttered. Her hands hesitated. The ticking continued.

How much time is left? FUCK! She didn’t pause to think, bringing her arms down and plunging the blade into his chest with all her might. 

Everything rushed by her, no longer there, only stabbing and striking, and digging and squeezing, and where the FUCK is that damn key?!

She felt a thick protrusion through the thin wet and warm slippery tubing and dug her fingers through to break the membrane and retrieve it. 

Her fingers slipped as she tried to push the key into the lock. The ticking. Her heart beat. She wasn’t breathing. She couldn’t. Why won’t it fucking fit?!

When she felt the lock click open she pushed the metal deathtrap off her head and no sooner the device pulled out of her mouth and it flew off her shoulders she heard the thunderous slam of the contacts as they ripped apart.

She let out a scream, a guttural shriek,  releasing all the terror and tension, realizing that high pitched witch cry was coming from her and that meant she survived.

She was alive . Her voice died to a low wail and she began to let all the self pity drown her and she curled into a ball as she raised her bloody fingers to her mouth, not wanting to touch her face but wanting so desperately to soothe the raw corners where the bear trap had dug so viciously into her cheeks.

She stopped when she realized her wails were mixed with a rusted metallic creak.

In the distance, the puppet rode its tricycle towards her. It looked so life-like she cowered back. A child? A small man? No, it was just a toy.

This isn’t over, she knew. 

“Congratulations,” the puppet’s voice was cold and cruel. “You survived. So many people are ungrateful for being alive. But not you. Not anymore.”

The lights flickered. She got to her feet. In the distance, the red exit sign beamed like a beacon. She looked around, wondering where the next trap was.

But maybe, she half-wished and half-disbelieved, he’s letting me go.

She rushed out, wondering if someone would come for her. If arms would pull her back into the warehouse and prevent her escape. But the doors flew open.

Sunshine blinded her and the cool air was fresh as she gasped it in. Never had breathing felt so good. She was free. She was alive. Truly, a-fucking-live!

She stumbled, needing to lean against the bricks, confused. What now?

Her first thought was back home, where she had enough to fill a syringe or two and just forget all this happened. She wanted to forget. 

But no. She slapped herself, the tenderness from the metal jaw vice additional pain that she welcomed.  She let out a small laugh at herself. She really was a sick fuck. But this was her wake up call. No more drugs. 

No more. She’d go to the police. They had to know. Because she sure wouldn’t wish what she had experienced on anyone else.

But the cops can’t be trusted, a small voice whined, reminding her about the last time she had tangled with the pigs.

But she shook her head. No, this guy was nuts. Fucking nuts. And it was a miracle she was alive. Never heard of anyone surviving Jigsaw. If she was the first, she had to let the detectives know.  She survived - and maybe she could help stop this.

She had to at least try. For once, I need to at least do that.

 

Mark Hoffman

 

He awoke, his mind thick with a velvet fog. He smelled something good. Tea. 

He rolled his neck and opened his eyes, his muscles sluggish and uncooperative. He was looking at his wrists. They were restrained. Leather. Buckles. He tried to move them and felt the resistance, the gentle thum of a metal cord raised the hairs on the back of his neck. His vision cleared, then his stomach dropped to his balls. 

A double barrel shotgun was pointed right at his head. 

He tried to look farther, past the dark fog, his depth perception only clearing after a few long seconds.

The figure in the distance morphed into that of an old man. He was reading the paper, sipping tea, and watching him like a hawk observing a mouse. 

“You know why you’re here, don’t you?” Calm. Controlled. This man, Mark recognized from the elevator, was the reason he was in his current predicament. With no doubt, this man was the Jigsaw Killer. 

His mouth was twitching. He felt sweat begin to form on his brow. Images of the past crime scenes writhed in the back of his mind. A corpse with only its legs to recognize, the upper half blown away from shrapnel. The guy from the dumpster, whose face had been lacerated to swiss cheese. And here he was, looking like there wouldn’t be a head to identify his body when this was all over.

He had never felt more terrified than at that moment. 

“They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.” The old man stepped closer, smiling. “But I find it,” his smile soured, “distasteful for getting credit for work that’s not mine.”

The man looked sickly. Mark felt confident he could overpower him easily. But he had to assess his surroundings first.

He had no idea what had put a target on his back, until the man held out the newspaper for him to see, where Seth Baxter smiled back as if to mock him, and the bold words: ‘JIGSAW KILLER RESPONSIBLE FOR PENDULUM MURDER’ recited his sin. His breath froze in his throat. He darted to lock into the icy stare of his captor, waiting.

“Especially inferior work.” 

He almost didn’t register what was being said, not even daring to blink, wondering what was in store for him now. He couldn’t restrain his jaw from twitching.

“Like you, I know what it’s like to lose family. I know what it’s like to not be able to protect loved ones.” There was an understanding in his whisper, almost kind, and had even coaxed, to Mark’s horror, tears that began to blur his vision.

No. Don’t cry. Don’t fucking cry in front of him. 

Almost like an act of mercy, the man turned and walked away, giving Mark a moment to collect himself and blink the tears back. “It’s a powerless feeling.” Now that he wasn’t under this psychopath’s scrutiny, Mark looked down at his restraints, the instinctive need to fight back having him play with his binds again, feeling the pull of the tension, wondering - 

“Ah, I wouldn’t do that.”

Mark looked up just as the man took the mirror and whirled it to face him. He blinked, unsure of what was going to happen.

“Hair trigger.” His captor seemed unconcerned, as though pointing out a splinter, nothing more. There was twine tied to Mark’s straps and the trigger of the shotgun. If I move far enough, I’m toast . But Mark now understood that he had to remain in his seat and to let whatever would happen, happen. “What do you see? Hm?”

Mark humored him. What else could he do? He stared into his reflection, thinking he looked like he was about to shit his pants. There wasn’t much to point out.

“Vengeance can change a person. Make you into something you never thought you were capable of being. But unlike you, I’ve never killed anyone.” A birdlike nose and a thin smile. This waif of a man was starting to piss him off.

You’re fucking kidding me.

“I give people a chance.”

“You call this a fucking chance?” Anger, fresh and hot, poured out of his mouth. 

The man smiled. Pleased. “We’ll see. Our game’s just begun.”

Mark narrowed his eyes. “Our game?” I thought this guy was a vigilante . So far, Jigsaw had only targeted criminals. Not cops. And Mark wasn’t like the other victims - the drug dealers, rapists, murderers, and the miscellaneous scum of the earth. This man thought he was in league with them? “You don’t even know me.”

“Oh. I know you. I’ve followed you. As you pursued me.” A chill went down his spine at the idea. “I know you. I know about your sister.” His heart sank. “I know how you cared for her.”

Mark had to look away as he remembered Angie and how she threw her arms around him the day he was promoted to Detective Sargeant. He remembered her smile. Her words. “ I’m so proud of you .”

He didn’t want to think about it, because he knew he’d remember more. His chest tightened and his throat stung. “I know she was your only family.” The day he found her, dead, her throat torn open, blood everywhere, and how he could do nothing but cry.

He glared up hatefully at the person responsible for bringing these memories to the table. How dare he . He wanted to get up and strangle the son of a bitch but felt the pull of the twine and remaind seated as he nervously looked down at the shotgun in frustration.

“You sit at bars until closing. You drink so you can sleep. You stagger to your car and then you start it all over again the next day.” He was being judged, the man acting all pious, like they were in a church or something. “Then I discovered what you do for recreation.” 

Baxter, on the table, the pendulum swinging across as he screamed. Mark had to look away from the man’s penetrating gaze that polluted the pleasurable memory pool with deep shame. So now, he was bare, a fellow murderer, and any sense of moral high ground had evaporated in that instant.

“Mm-hm,” the man nodded, as though he could read his mind and understood exactly what Mark was feeling. “You can dispense justice and give people a chance to value their lives in the same moment.” The man closed in, impassioned resolve in his voice, “by the way, the blade on your pendulum was inferior.”

He squinted in confusion, not understanding what this guy was on about. Did he just bring me here to criticize the trap?  

It would have been laughable, being lectured by this nutjob - if he wasn’t currently sitting at the end of this damn gun. He had to glumly wait, wondering if this meant he was going to be kept alive just to hear this fucker berate him. He was beginning to consider lunging and letting the shotgun put him out before he had to listen to this a second longer.

“If you want a true edge,” the man’s voice was distant as the sound of scraping nearby followed with Jigaw returning with a shaving razor in hand, “you have to use tempered steel. Tempering’s better for the long haul.” Now in front of him, brandishing the razor, Mark swallowed and returned to watching the man. “You in this for the long haul, detective?” The blade glinted back at him, close to his neck. His face.

“I’ve been a cop for twenty years. Is that long enough for you?” He figured to play along but his patience was frayed. He wasn’t like Will, who could gab and keep a conversation indefinitely. But that damn blade was getting closer and he’d rather put off getting kissed by it.

“You and I both know the statistics for repeat offenders in this city.” God, he’s going to keep going on, isn’t he? “Sixty seven point five percent of criminals are back in prison within three years-,”

“What do you want from me?!” He snapped, tired of hearing this man drone on. 

The man straightened, looked around, annoyed. “So you might look at what you did to Seth as a sort of public service?” He smiled sarcastically, teeth sharp.

“She was my only family,” the excuse fell out lamely, as though he was trying to justify to his father why he broke curfew. “He didn’t deserve a chance, he was an animal-”

“EVERYBODY DESERVES A CHANCE!” The man lurched forward, still in control but the explosion setMark off. His eyes bore holes into his soul, demanding Mark bare himself to this judge.

“You didn’t see the blood!” He shouted back, emotion thick as he refused to apologize. He’d rather die than ever say he regretted it. “You didn’t see what he fucking did to her !” A tear broke through and his voice had cracked but he would take whatever punishment came for him, now, because if he had to redo it all, he would have done it again - he would have killed Baxter even if he could go as far back as to before her murder - just to ensure the bastard never had a chance to take her from him.

“Killing is distasteful!” The man’s voice stopped, the bladed hand pointed in conviction, and Mark’s heart quickened at the sporadic pause. For a moment, it seemed the man was trying to find the right words, now a whisper, “To me.” 

Something was off. But Mark could only stare back, angry and afraid, helpless.

“There is a more efficient way.” The man turned to retrieve a stool and got close and personal. Fury flared his nostrils and the finger on the shotgun trigger made Mark flinch. “What do you see? LOOK!”

Mark was violently shaking but he obeyed, his breath erratic and labored. His heart thudded in his ears. He tried to suck in a breath and hold it, panicking. 

“What do you see?”

“Tell me what you want!” He shut his eyes tight, bracing himself for the sound of the end.

“I want to know if you have what it takes to survive.” 

Mark gasped for air and realized this was it. This fucker was insane. There was no way out of this. He straightened and looked at his reflection, seeing the long years. The many nights drinking in that piss-stained bar to return home to his quiet dusty apartment. What the hell had he been doing his entire miserable existence ever since Angie went and left him alone?

He had nothing to show for this life. No family. No friends. He tried to think of just one thing he wouldn’t regret. Killing Baxter? Catching some perps with Matthews? He remembered Thanksgivings with Angie and Peter. And Will. The thought of her pretty face, that nearly broke him. She brought up all the regret he had pushed down for years. 

He regretted what he had last said to her. How they fell apart. And now, they were just strangers, once so close and so in love, only to now pretend they never mattered to each other. What would she do, when he died? Marry Peter Strahm? Have some kids? Forget she ever knew Mark Hoffman?

She should. 

The only consolation was knowing that he would finally see Angie again. So he looked up, final courage steeling him, and watched in the mirror as the man’s finger pressed against the trigger and accepted this fate with sweat and trembling fervor.

The click of the shotgun made him jolt and the hot wet sensation in his pants informed him that he had pissed himself. Warmth spread along his thighs and the shame of it all made him turn to his cruel executioner. All he could sob was, “Fuck you. Fuck you.”

“You see it’s a different method that I’m talking about. If the subject survives my method, he or she is instantly rehabilitated.”

Mark almost questioned the logic - not a single survivor had shown themselves so far - but he remembered the razor blade and forced himself to breathe intstead. Though the relief of not being vaporized was still vibrating his joints, he knew this ride wasn’t over yet.

“Now you want a chance? Hm?”

Mark nodded, eagerly.

“You want a chance? I’ll give you a chance.” The man got to his feet, strolled closer to the mirror, playing with the razor blade, and looked at Mark through the glass. “I am the man you call Jigsaw. It’s your duty to bring me in but I know who you are. And I know what you’ve done.” He turned to look at Mark, expectantly.

“So this is blackmail,” right away, Mark knew the game. He understood the rules. 

“No, no,” the man knelt over and severed the string. “This is redemption. I’m just giving you an option. That’s all.” Now, the shotgun was being removed, the pull of the weight a relief to his chest. “Now you can arrest me, but doing so ends your life as you know it. Or. You can explore a method of rehabilitation that will put you to sleep at night.”

Mark cocked his head, in disbelief in what this guy was suggesting. He seriously wants me to join him ? The smile confirmed his suspicions. And all the familiar apprehension he had once felt - to have someone control him, to lord their power over him, to tell him what to do, where to go, who to hurt - it made Mark suddenly feel like a cornered dog.

The man cradled his gun and sat on his stool, looking weary and was looking off in the distance.

The razor blade was just within Mark’s reach, easy and open. “Or,” Mark rubbed his wrists, turning away from Jigsaw, and leaned towards the table where the blade had been abandoned, “I could kill you now.”

“But you’re not a true killer,” the man whispered, his voice holding a warmth that Mark didn’t trust. “That’s your dilemma. The information I have on you is exactly where it needs to be. It will be released in the events of my disappearance.” A smug look, full of the confidence of having thought of every detail and every possible outcome, made Mark second guess the ‘just kill the fucker’ approach.

But still. “They’ll never believe your word over mine.” He grabbed the knife and stood up, knowing he could take this feeble old man. 

“You willing to take that risk? Risk of ruining your whole life? In order to protect a corrupt legal system that puts murderers back on the streets?” The man cocked the shotgun. “What would your sister feel?”

Mark knew Angie would have been devastated at the whole situation. But he remembered Rosello. And this song and dance sounded painfully familiar. 

Only this time, this was a situation even Will couldn’t get him out of this.

And then the thought of Will and what she would think if she knew what he had done and gotten himself into, made him decide.

“You’re at a crossroads, detective. Make your choice.”

He clenched his jaw but knew he had to hide this. He couldn’t just come clean. Not now. Even if Will didn’t love him anymore - she still respected him. Angie would never know what he had done. But Will? 

He closed the blade, feeling numb, but convicted in his decision. Will could never find out. And he had to find a way to not only survive Jigsaw but to take him out at the first opportunity possible. He had to make sure of that. He would play along for now. And as soon as he made sure that there was no way his secret could get out, he’d kill this old man and whoever else had the knowledge that Seth Baxter’s blood was on his hands. 

“Fine. Have it your way.”

The old man turned, looking pleased but unsurprised. “Welcome, detective, to your redemption.”

“So what now?”

“Go home. Live as you have. I will come for you when I need you.”

“And what’s your real name? Or should I just call you Jigsaw?”

Jigsaw let out a small amused sound. “My name is John Kramer. Now, go home, Detective. I promise, when I next come for you, I will show you the way to your rebirth.”

Mark looked around, for the nearest exit, and hurried to get out of his piss-stained pants.

Notes:

A/N: So SAW X, eh? Saw it, loved it, was truly an epic good time ;)

Definitely reinspired. Was holding off because I wanted to be sure no drastically new lore would come up in the movie since the story's now just on the cusp of SAW I. And all the flashbacks had me checking the timeline to try to be sure everything still fits. (When the story reaches SAW III/IV is going to be such a clusterfuck but I'm so excited for it.)

Though these scenes were already in the movie, hopefully there was something added to help make them enjoyable as a replay.

So what were your thoughts on SAW X?

Chapter 44: Peri-SAW: Friends Forever

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

David Tapp

 

“Tapp,” Sing’s voice made him freeze as he was reaching for the last krispee kreme donut in the break room. He turned, noting his partner’s wide eyes and the way he was breathing hard.

“What’s up?”

“Another Jigsaw victim.”

He hummed, taking a bite out of the pastry. He was bracing himself. Sing looked troubled. “So how bad is it? And where’s the body?”

“Currently waiting downstairs.”

Already in the morgue? Tapp didn’t feel rushed but the way Sing bounced from foot to foot, there was a nervous energy he didn’t understand. “And?”

“She’s alive, Tapp.”

He almost dropped his donut as he went to follow Sing down the stairs towards the interrogation rooms. They stepped in observation, where a crowd of curious cops not assigned to the case gawked at the two way mirror.

“Get the hell out,” Tapp snapped at them. “None of you have a reason to be here.” 

As the men grumbled and shuffled on, Tapp shook his head.

“Amanda,” Maddox’s voice sounded over the speakers, a gentle coo. “Do you need some water?”

“A cigarette. Please.” 

Tapp approached the looking glass, seeing the woman who was hugging herself with a razored smile cut into her cheeks twitch and stare at the table.

Tapp saw the backs of Allison Kerry and Will Maddox, likely the ones performing the interrogation to help the woman feel less intimidated, and the obvious social worker who had a hand on Amanda’s shoulder.

Maddox took out a pack from her blazer pocket and Amanda’s eyes lit up briefly as she took a cigarette out. A gentle flick of a lighter and the flame to Amanda’s lips glowed orange. Tapp heard her inhale and sigh out the smoke, looking less anxious. 

“So you have no clue why anyone would do this to you?” Allison sounded on edge. Impatient. This case had been weighing heavily on her and it showed.

“No,” Amanda gave shaky a shaky breath. “I mean yeah. But no one I know is smart or creative enough to pull this kind of shit off.” There was anger, in her voice. Subtle. But there. She didn’t like what happened to her. Obviously.

“So you do believe someone you know did this to you?” Will added, “Do you have any enemies?”

“Doesn’t everyone?” Amanda looked up, staring her down. “Bet you have some enemies too, sweetheart.”

“Sadly, you’re right.” Will tucked a curl behind her ear, leaned back. “But what happened to you wasn’t right. You didn’t deserve that. I wouldn’t wish that on my worst enemy.”

Amanda furrowed her brow. “No,” she softly murmured. “No, I deserved a lot worse.” She puffed smoke and crossed her legs, avoiding eye contact. “I’m a piece of shit junkie. I hurt - so many people because of my selfishness.” She wiped angrily at the side of her face, her voice cracking. “But not anymore. I’m done.”

Silence filled the room.

“Amanda, you did not deserve that. Even if you’ve made some mistakes, I can tell, you’re not a bad person.” Will was trying to salvage the interview, keeping Amanda talking. “And you’re a survivor. You’re the first person to survive this monster.”

This made Amanda look up, a glint in her dark eyes. “I’m the monster. I - I killed Donnie.”

“You knew the victim?” Allison straightened up, leaned forward.

“We went to the same clinic. Both into the same shit.”

“No jury will convict you. Your situation… is a special case,” Will had given Allison a glance. Taking the hint, she scooted her chair back and went to leave.

“Anyone want coffee?”

Everyone but Amanda raised their hands and she left the room.

“Let’s wrap this up. She’s had enough,” the social worker announced.

“I can tell this is hard for you. But thank you for coming in. When you can, we would really appreciate another talk. It’s asking a lot from you but with your help, we can finally catch the Jigsaw Killer. And no one else has to suffer what you’ve had to.”

Amanda nodded, shakily said, “Sure,” and got to her feet to leave. 

“What was her trap?” Tapp asked, trying to piece together what the tears in her mouth indicated.

“Jigsaw called it the ‘Reverse Bear Trap’. Was going to rip her jaw open.”

“Jesus.”

“Just wait til you see the tape. Our victim here, Amanda Young, has a record. Served a sentence for possession. We’re looking into any connection with the victim that didn’t survive. Donnie Greco. Longer wrap sheet. Possession, dealing, grand theft. He was administered a paralytic and she had to cut into his bowels to find a key to escape.”

This poor woman, if this doesn’t fuck her up in the head, it’ll be a miracle.

“I need a vacation, Sing.”

“Don’t we all.” Tapp left the room, zooming with newfound excitement. It was a new break. Some good news, after all this time. He climbed the staircase two at a time and burst into his office, surprised to see Hoffman admiring the pictures of victims and the red yarn links on the corkboard.

“Tapp,” Hoffman greeted. “Got a minute?”

“Got five if it’s about the Jigsaw case. We’ve got a break.” He couldn’t help himself, allowing a cracked smile.

Hoffman raised an eyebrow. “Oh? Do tell?” 

“I’ll fill you in tomorrow. I gotta head to a crime scene.” Tapp reached for his coat and paused. “Don’t get too comfy, Hoffman, soon, the cavalry’s knocking on that son of a bitch’s door. And that’s you and Rigg and anyone else who’s free.” He left the man there, racing back to Sing.



Mark Hoffman

 

He entered Commander Grissom’s office, pausing at the doorway when he saw Will standing with her arms crossed, sullen. “You called?”

Grissom had a tired look on his face. “Sit, you two.”

They did. Mark kept his eyes straight ahead though the corner of his eye found traces of her red hair. It took great effort to not turn to enjoy the view in its entirety.

“Is this a performance review?” Hoffman tried to come off as humorous. Will’s leg twitched.

“Of sorts,” Grissom was calm and grim. “When was the last case you two worked together? Actually, worked together, that is.” Grissom allowed a pause as he pulled out a stack of files. “You both have signed off on a ton. Been looking good. But what case did you two actually solve?”

Mark tried to remember. He could recall their very first case. The fifty-second case they closed. Hell, he could remember the rare slow days where they flicked paperclips at each other and the long nights eating donuts while staking out suspects. Yet the most recent? It  had to either have been the one with the body in the greenhouse. Or was it the hanging in the church bell tower? 

That had been… since before Angie.

“Technically, our last assigned case where we were physically present at the crime scene was the murder of Seth Baxter. But due to my personal involvement in Baxter’s acquittal, I stepped down. It’s part of the ongoing Jigsaw case.”

Grissom nodded. “And you’ve refused to participate in anything involving a corpse if the pathologist found a puzzle piece cut into its flesh. Despite strong requests from the department.”

“There are plenty of other murders that still need attention. Just because Jigsaw is front page news doesn’t mean we should ignore the other victims.”

Mark could resist no longer and took in the shadows of weariness on her face and the way she kept her face passive despite pressing her fingernails into her thumbs as she tended to do when she was stressed. 

“In order to not cause a repeat to what happened to the failed conviction of Seth Baxter, I chose to step back and let those less involved lead the investigation. If the reason for this meeting is to order me to-,”

“We’re in a tight spot, Maddox. I cannot accept your resignation.” Grissom was tapping at a folded sheet of paper, likely, the resignation in question.

Hoffman felt as though his head was smacked with bricks. Never, as long as he knew her, had he thought Will would even consider quitting this job. 

A tightness compressed his throat and filled his gut with acid. She couldn’t leave. No, why would she do that? 

His mind was running wild with ideas on how to get her to change her mind. And fresh anger at himself boiled in his skull. How could he have let it get to this point?

You pushed her. You told her to get lost. Now you’re eating your words .

He had been lazy and unrushed with smoothing things over with her. It’ll sort itself out , he had told himself, not that concerned. He had been confident she would still be there for him, no matter how long he had her wait.

He had been arrogant.

She refused to meet his stare, though a swallow hinted she was feeling his scrutiny.

“You knew about this, Hoffman?” Grissom turned the spotlight onto him, eying him with a hint of awareness.

“News to me.”

“Look. This is not the highlight of my job, playing marriage counselor to partnerships that decided to get cozier than most, but you both need to figure this shit out. Not for myself but for this department. Maddox, this city needs cops like you. Now, more than ever.”

“I apologize,” her tone had that gentle but steady firmness that she tended to save for those who had authority over her but still wanted to express her displeasure, “But my decision is final.”

“We can negotiate your salary. What if I throw in a promotion, after Jigsaw’s caught?”

“It’s never been about the money.”

“So why are you leaving?” Hoffman interjected, trying to keep his breathing regular and his voice calm.

She turned to him, now, eyebrow raised. “I have personal matters I need to focus on.”

It was such a vague answer. The lack of intimacy was like a splash of ice water on his face.

“Well, you’ve given me two weeks. So I ask you close just one more case together.” Grissom pulled out of his drawer a folder, tossing it across to Will’s reach.

“All right.” She took the file and flipped it open. “Assault, burglarly. No body?” She raised an eyebrow.

“Technically, it was an unlawful termination of an unborn fetus,” Grissom growled. “Been getting pressure to close this one. You’ll recognize the victim.”

Will flipped through the pages, a picture of an attractive older woman smiled back. “Jill Tuck? The charity doctor?”

Grissom nodded. “She’s married to John Kramer, the humanitarian architect. Both wealthy, well connected. But after this, Kramer’s pulling out of his projects. He’s miserable, the Comissioner says, and apparently the Mayor is raining hell on him, shit rolls downhill, and here we are.”

Hoffman stiffened but remembered himself. His eyes darted to Will and Grissom. Neither looked concerned. They have no idea. Good . “So just another political case to make you look good?” The department needed a win, was what Grissom was saying, and they needed it fast to help murk the water so the public didn’t think they were incompetent.

Jigsaw’s making us look like idiots. 

“We’ll look into it. I can’t promise I’ll solve it in time before I move on.” She got to her feet. Mark did the same.

“You won’t be alone, you have your partner after all, Maddox. And Hoffman, a minute,” Grissom held him back. “And close the door behind you, Maddox.”

As soon as the door clicked shut, Grissom barked, “Get her to stay.”

“What can I do?” 

“Promise her the moon. Fuck her brains out. I don’t care how, just stop her from leaving.”

“She barely acknowledges my existence these days. If she wants to leave, nothing I say is going to change her mind.” Even if we were like we were, she never backed down once her mind was made up.

“I’ve tried everything to convince her but she won’t listen. Not even for Kerry.”

Made sense he was the last resort.

“You’ve got two weeks. You two have history. We’re already so stretched thin, we have patrols on a three-shift rotation. And now this fucking serial killer.” Grissom ran his fingers through his thinning hair, his fingers and mustache yellow from nicotine. “She’s planning on jumping ship to Quantico. That’s what Kerry told me.”

Now Mark understood. Strahm. That vulture . It added salt to the wound and now, Mark agreed with his boss. Will couldn’t go. Not to him .

“Not sure why she’s so intent, I offered her a temporary leave of absence. She said no. Get her to take it. If selling my soul would make a difference, I’d have tossed it yesterday. This city’s about to cave in on itself and we’re not ready.”

Normally, Mark would have told Grissom to fuck himself. But these days, he found himself humbled. With the shadow of the Jigsaw Killer, dangling his secret over his head, the moral high ground was beyond him. And Will, the last person he wanted - needed - was about to disappear? No, that, he would not accept.

But if she’s gone, it’ll be a hell of a lot easier to not get caught. Unless she joins the FBI, that is. And once the feds decide to start paying more attention to the Jigsaw Killer? 

Mark would be helpless, then, to protect himself.

He left Grissom, his decision made.

He went to her office, knocked on the door and let himself in. She was in her trench coat and wrapping a scarf around her neck, looking off guard by his presence. “I’ll wrap this case up on my own. You don’t have to join me.”

“That’s not happening, Will.” 

She narrowed her eyes.

“I’m Will now? Not Maddox?”

He waited a breath. “You’ve always been Will to me.”

She looked like she was about to laugh. “What do you want, Mark?” The way she called his name was full of bite, but even then, he thought it sounded hot. 

“Our last case. Let’s finish strong.”

“You feeling sentimental?” Her nostrils were flared. Her shoulders squared. It looked like she was ready for a fight. She was chewing gum, her jaw twitching. 

He cracked a smile. “Yes.”

Throwing her off guard, there was a break in her sneer as she turned away. “Why?”

Women always need to know why . He swallowed his pride. “Because I missed you.”

He liked how her back stiffened. He stepped closer and she turned on him, and he could see that her pupils had dilated. “You’re wearing the cologne,” she sounded incredulous as she trailed off.

He took her hand, squeezing it gently, his heart pounding. “Yeah.”

After a few seconds of her staring down at his hand, she pulled hers away, the brief softness gone. “This changes nothing.” She brushed by him and opened the door. “Come on, let’s get to work, then.”

“I’m driving.” 

She didn’t fight him on this, to his disappointment. But he took her willingness to work together as progress. The two of them marched side-by-side to the parking lot. 

The walk was long and quiet, but Will was the first to break it. “What happened to your wrist?”

He knew she was talking about the bruises. Fucker fought back and his chin contacted my watch last night. “Just clumsy.”

Two could play at this game. He smirked, pleased at the way her mouth crinkled in displeasure at being denied the details. They stepped outside, a blast of icy air slapping his face and stinging his ears. He hadn’t dressed for this, the morning having been misleading in warmth.

“Looks like you were handcuffed.” Crunch of her heel on the gravel. She wasn’t dressed for the field today, but the office. Her freckles had faded, likely because she hadn’t been outside as much as she used to.

“Maybe I was.” He couldn’t help but smile to himself, especially when she turned to appraise him. They had made it to his Crown Vic, he unlocking it and starting the car to warm up the engine. He hurriedly tossed in the backseat handfuls of the fast food wrappers and papers off the passenger seat so she could get in.

Hiss . The radio came to life. “Ten eighteen, shoplifter resisting arrest!” 

“Ten twenty-one, back up requested. Suspected Ten-fifty four.”

Looks like the case will have to wait . He was relieved, not sure how to approach this with John, sure that the man would not like knowing his wife’s case was covered by him. 

But he’d worry about it later, when he was off the clock.

It was never ending, now, another symptom of how swamped the department was. Mark decided they should respond, reaching to pick up the microphone.

Her hand shot out and grabbed his right hand and she pulled up the sleeve of his jacket. The bruises looked worse than they felt, a clear band of green and purple where his watch had been followed with what included a mean looking scrape from where the guy had scratched him. 

“Cuffs don’t leave marks this wide. Or break skin like this. You and I both know that,” she smirked and released him, reaching over to spin the heat dial. She was still familiar with his car and messed with his console with calm comfort. “You’ve also lost weight. And don’t stink of last night’s booze. And you look like you haven’t been sleeping much these nights.”

He narrowed his eyes. “You look like shit too.”

She was smiling. “Life has a way of doing that. But I’m glad you’ve quit drinking. Not sure what else you’re up to, but it’s an improvement.”

He put the car in reverse and pulled out of the parking spot aggressively. He flipped the lights and the car soared off the lot to respond to the shoplifter, waiting for the tingling of her touch to fade from his skin.

He had forgotten how easily she could find all the little details about him. It was one of the reasons he admired her. And feared that she would pick up on something that would put her in harm’s way.

“How about you? You quit smoking?”

She cleared her throat, the snap of her chewing gum more ferocious. She was unphased by his sharp turns and high speed. He still drove saner than she ever did. “Trying. On the patch. And gum.”

“I’m not the only one who smells better these days.”

“Fuck you.”

He laughed, low and soft, the atmosphere in his car warm and pleasant and fuck, he missed having her next to him.

Homeless children with torn clothes and gray faces were huddling together on the curb, shaking styrofoam cups. Mark turned a corner to see all the cars along the street permanently parked from their tires missing and their frames propped by concrete stretcher blocks and spray painted across.

“Fuck, is this Caroline street?” Will murmured, sitting up to absorb the carnage.

“Now just another part of the Crossroads. Businesses pulled out after the last riot and now it’s just another block down.”

“Jesus. That’s why Rigg looked beat up last week? I didn’t know they moved in this fast.”

“Shit’s fucked. Why Grissom’s practically licking your boots to stay.”

Awkward silence. “I have to go.”

“Can we be straight with each other Will?”

“When are you not? Sure.”

“Are you leaving because of us?”

She snorted. “Please. You couldn’t get rid of me if you tried.”

He smirked, relieved. “You just can’t get enough of me.”

Another awkward pause. He must have hit a nerve.

“It’s not about you, Mark. Though you certainly didn’t help,” she grumbled the last part. 

“So what gives?” He probably was overstepping, asking something so personal, when he wasn’t involved with her anymore. But after all we’ve gone through? Together? They were bound, like invisible chains to each other. He had closed doors in her face. But there was a part of each other that they would never be rid of. He dared to pry. “Is it some guy?”

“Ha!” Her reaction was forced and fast. He had pissed her off. “My father, Mark. That’s the guy.”

His heart relaxed back in his chest. Though he knew Strahm and her were starting something, this felt like a win. She had not staked a claim yet. “Oh. I heard he’s awake. Is he okay?”

“Yeah. He’s fine.”

“So why you jumping ship?” It was like negotiating with a toddler. “Maybe I can help with whatever it is you need to get done.”

“No.” Another fast response. This one hurt his pride but he kept his hand gripping the steering wheel and his eyes on the road. “I’m getting help elsewhere. But thank you.”

“It’s him, isn’t it?” He didn’t hold back the edge in his voice, the anger. 

“If you mean Peter Strahm, then yes.” She must have picked up on the mood. Yet she must have wanted to hurt him, after everything he had done to her. He would have acknowledged the fairness in it. But it still filled him with the desire to hit and break something. “I’m going off grid to do some personal investigative work to find the man who murdered my mother. Who took my father away from me for most of my life. I want him locked away. And Peter’s going to help me.”

“You should have told me,” he muttered. He pulled over, no longer in the mood to tackle some petty thief.

“You wanted nothing to do with me, remember?” Her voice was wavering and sharp.

She looked like she was about to cry. He took out a handkerchief and handed it to her. “You’re right. I’m sorry.”

She was sniffling. He could do nothing but sit there, knowing he was the reason she looked to be in so much pain.

“I know. I know this is all outside our control. That the world is so messed up. And we’re just trying to make sense of it. And I’m sorry Angelina is gone and Seth Baxter escaped punishment because of me. And I’m sorry now, that you’re ready to make up and that I’m not. Whatever you want from me, Mark, I can’t give you. I’m so tired. And I just want to be happy. I’m so tired of being alone.”

“I want that, too, Will.” He wrapped his arms around her, trying to squeeze the pain out of her, to promise that this wouldn’t happen again, but he kept his mouth shut. He knew better. All he could say was, “I’m sorry. For everything.”

“You have nothing to apologize for,” she whispered.

“I do. I have everything to apologize for. I’m an idiot.” He hesitated but decided to speak what was lingering in his mind. “Angie… wouldn’t have wanted this. I see that now.”

They sat there for long minutes, until his phone buzzed. He pulled away to check, a lump in his throat forming at the phone number that appeared. He flipped it and the text read, ‘Midnight’

He had almost forgotten. Tonight, he would need to meet John. For what, he could only imagine. 

“Who is it?” She was wiping her eyes, looking as though the cry session had helped calm her down.

“Rigg. Has to go out on a mission tonight. He needs me to tell Tracy, he doesn’t have time to explain.” He lied so easily to her and seeing her shaking like a leaf because of what he put her through, a rush of guilt gave him heartburn. 

“Strange, he should just send her a text, it shouldn’t take long,” Will muttered, wiping her tears and sniffling. If she wasn’t so upset, she probably would have detected his deception. 

Haven’t you already hurt her enough? 

He took a deep breath. “If the FBI can help you find the bastard, I get it. Whatever you want. Will, I’ll support you. Stay here. Or go. You don’t owe this department shit.”

She was hiccuping, surprised, and hope sparkled in her wet eyes. “Mark.”

“But if you want, I can help as well.” He knew he had no time to devote to seriously looking into it now, but he would try to make time. “Will, take that leave of absence. Take as much time as you need. But when you’re done catching the guy, what are you planning on doing next?”

She blinked. “I haven’t been thinking about that.”

The Will he knew would have never not come up with contingency plans. Just more evidence that Strahm was making her not think straight. “Take it from someone who’s burned one too many bridges. It’s a lot harder than just leaving a lane open, rebuilding what you’ve destroyed.”

“You’re right.” She nodded. “It’s hard for both sides.” She understood what he meant. She always did.

“Don’t give up on us, Will. Do what you need to do. But know that we’ll be waiting here for you. Me, especially.”

“Mark,” her mouth was agape, the words dying in her throat. “Don’t wait for me.”

He blinked. He would have said something cruel back to her. But he managed to grasp at those sentences and pull them back, deep inside him, where he could shove them into a box and lock it up. “I’ll wait, however long it takes. You’re the last person I have.” 

She turned away, shoulders raised, pain on her face. “I - I don’t think you understand. I’m in a relationship with Peter.” She didn’t say more but she didn’t need to. I’m in love with someone else. Not you. And this is final.

“Yeah. I figured. I know.” He leaned on the steering wheel, trying to not make it obvious he was holding onto it for support. His head spun. He never took rejection well. But for now, this had to be. Even if she wanted to get back together, he couldn’t be what she needed just yet. Not now, with his new night job.

But thinking that he was losing her, to that prick, he wouldn’t allow. 

You could kill him. Slit his throat and bury him and tomb him in cement. You’re already this deep in. Fucking Jigsaw could have another trap set aside. John finds fault in everyone. Wouldn’t be hard to find something that would motivate him to target Strahm.  

But he pushed it back in his box.  “You, of all people, deserve a shot at happiness.” He, too, didn’t need to say any more to her. She was reading his face, absorbing his meaning. 

And I’m not the same man I used to be, back when I was all yours. And now, it’s too late for me.  

He gave her one last smile, reaching over to brush the stream of tears off her cheek. She’s safe, if she’s away from this city. Away from Jigsaw. “And all I want from you now, is to stop crying so damn much. We’re at work, partner.”

“Asshole,” she had a small smile. “Friends?” She sometimes gave him a peak at the juvenile innocence she pretended she lost long ago.

“Friends Forever.” Til death do us part.

Notes:

A/N: Fuuuu I missed my Halloween update-goal and I'M SORRY. Sept-Oct is always a roller coaster of stuff that takes me away from all you lovely people. I had to cut this chapter in half and give you this because I just couldn't wait any longer. I hope it's up-to-snuff. Hard to write emotional scenes.

Totally listened to Setting Sun by Lord Huron for the vibes. Super sad and maybe too fluffy for the general flavor of this story but heck, it's such a ridiculously long-running monster of a fanfiction now, it's bound to evolve.

One of these days, I'll need to go back and fix some consistency errors. One day. Eventually.

Thanks so much for reading!

Chapter 45: Per-SAW: Sleepless in the City

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

John Kramer

 

He stood, adrenaline filling him, as he watched the video capture Amanda’s moment of taking off her headpiece.

She had done it. 

He had begun to have doubt that any of those he had chosen to rehabilitate would ever persevere. Yet she, Amanda Young, had been the first.

He felt a tickle in his throat. Coughing, he went to rewind the tape, the quality of the cameras in that room shoddy but enough to let him relive the moment.

Amanda, squeezing and pulling at scarlet intestines, finding the key, and scrambling to unlock her death sentence, ending with the head tossed scream she unleashed in silence.

Distant scraping footsteps had him turn off the television.

The detective had returned. 

The clock read ten minutes before midnight. Always punctual and obedient. John smiled and went to take the penlight at the table, the very penlight his oncologist had left at his hospital bedside during the very public medical screening that had taken place earlier that day.

Doctor Gordon.

John Kramer curled his mouth in disdain. He had a very special plan for the good doctor. It would still need work, but already John knew that a higher power out there would ensure vindication. Karma

While Gordon had humiliated and dehumanized John in front of the future generation of healers, he had no idea just how his actions would bear severe consequence.

For in the waiting room earlier that day, it had been fate for John to find himself sitting next to the very detective whose sights were set on convicting him.

“Sorry to disturb,” Detective David Tapp had been smooth and friendly while John read some gossip rag out of desperate boredom. “But how is Gordon? He any good?”

John had known before he had shown his badge or introduced himself that he was police. He had that same hard glint in his eye and square in his shoulder that Mark Hoffman had. There was a familiarity with violence and cruelty and a stoic resolve to stand up to it.

Admirable .

And the questions had been asked with the intent to determine if Gordon had any skills needed for a certain suspect he was hunting for.

“I hear Gordon’s not a surgeon.”

“Oh, he has conducted surgeries. Just not for me,” John had answered, knowing David had been fishing. “He does have some fascinating hobbies, though.”

“Do tell?”

John smiled. “He enjoys metalworking. He mentioned a fantastic clock he had designed.” Not a lie, but not a truth, either. The doctor had never told him any of this. John had just observed, from afar, while performing his reconnaissance in anticipation for a future test.

That sowed the seeds necessary for the detective. David had leaned back in his chair, looking deep in thought, lips pursed, and John could tell that there were cogs spinning in his head to put it all together.

“So what are we doing?” Mark broke through his thoughts, dressed in his black raincoat.

John reached over, took the pig masks and handed one to Mark. “We will be taking a man, tonight. Be prepared for resistance. He is five foot eleven. Three hundred pounds.” John would not have been able to take him down, least of all pick him up to carry him into the car. 

Mark went to retrieve the syringes, already familiar with John’s workshop. “Twenty milligrams?”

“Thirty. He will likely be… high strung.”

Mark took out the bottle of Diazepam and filled the syringes. There was tension, moreso than usual, and John waited for him to state what was on his mind. “I’ve been assigned to your wife’s case.”

This took him by surprise but he nodded as though the opposite. He didn’t correct that she was now his ex-wife. “So they’re finally looking into it?”

“Sorry it took this long.”

“Don’t be. You do not control the system. But know that she no longer needs justice. It has been resolved.”

“I’m assuming you don’t want this to become something?” The detective sounded weary, as though he was familiar with making investigations ‘resolve’ themselves.

“Perform your job, to the standard you always do. But know that when you find the party responsible for murdering my son, that I will not be anticipating a court date for conviction.”

The two of them left, Mark driving, while John looked out to the passing lights and cars speeding by.

“Turn here,” John whispered, their final destination in the industrial mall. Mark turned off his headlights and slowed to a crawl. The night was cool. The lights amber and bright. “We will need to stop here. Walk the rest of the way. Stick to the shadows.”

Mark killed the engine and the two left the car. Mark looked around, nervous, and John pulled the rubber mask over his head. The two of them, disguised, needed to walk around the warehouses and debris.

Paul Leahy, their target, would be found in his car, drinking and feeling sorry for himself. They could make out the red glow of his taillights. The man was making quite the ruckus. Wailing and letting out yelps, the muffled shatter of glass was reassuring. He was so wrapped up in self pity that he would likely not notice them as brief flashes in the car mirrors.

There was plenty of noise that night, despite the late hour. Sirens. The rumble of heating units echoed off the bricks as well as the hum of fans. But John heard Leahy’s agonies break through the white noise.

They were closing in now, staying low behind the car and just out of the mirror’s angles. As John poked his head to catch one last look at Leahy, he saw the man drag a shard of glass over his wrist.

Hot fury made John slam his hand against the trunk. How dare he, to his perfectly healthy body. He backed up to the dumpster to the left, crouching behind, waiting.

“Who’s there?!” the man, likey drunk, got out of the car. He was heavy breathing, studying the ground and back tires, looking confused.

Mark hurried around the vehicle as the man rounded to the trunk. 

With his back turned, John crept up and as soon as he turned to face him, John slammed the needle into his chest, missing his neck. 

“RAA-” The man picked John up as though he was a child and slammed him back first onto the trunk. John felt the wind knock out of him and a cough fit overtook him.

He turned to see Mark pulling the man back, trying to strangle him. But Leahy was stronger - enraged, and managed to turn the tables on Mark and was now pinning him. Leahy spun him once again, tossing Mark against the car.

“I’ll kill you!” Eyes only for Mark, finger pointed, and alcohol aiding his strength, the current double dose had done little to slow him down.

John forced himself off the trunk, pulled out the spare syringe, and plunged it once more into Leahy’s bulk. Finally, he sounded as though he was weakening, his voice a croak, but it seemed the man was a juggernaut, returning his violent attention back onto John.

He felt his back slam against the car again, pain rooting through his bones. 

“I’ll kill you!”

He was closing in. Growling. John stabbed him again, trying to squeeze as much tranquilizer into him. Finally, the man weakened and slumped to the ground.

“Kill you,” Leahy whispered, hands reaching out to the air before collapsing into stillness.

John was panting, taking the mask off so he could get fresh air. He looked to his partner, the man removing his mask, his face drenched in sweat. John wasn’t sure if he detected tears as well. 

They stood there, eyes locked, a newfound understanding between them, as though they were both wolves that had crossed paths, knowing the other was just as dangerous but choosing to not bare their teeth. 

In silence, Mark took the man by his ankles and pulled him. John went to bring the car forward, and the two of them took Paul Leahy to face his trial.

 

Mark Hoffman

 

It hurt to inhale. Leahy had really done a number on his neck and chest. He felt like his trachea had been crushed like a soda can.

But Mark did not complain. He figured this guy wouldn’t take kindly to any griping. But why’d he have to choose such a fatass for tonight? 

He pulled Leahy across the dirty concrete, the occasional shriek of a rat and the drip of foul water his cheerleaders. He looked to the razor wire cage. Fifty more feet. Just fifty more feet, and he’ll be done.

He needed to buy a wagon, for next time.

For a man dying of cancer, John had been productive. The cage was more a maze. Razor wire carefully walled and curled, like vines around him. The door would be just out of reach. Mark had studied the map drawn on John’ design bench, having the escape memorized, partly out of hope that he could decipher some hidden pattern in case he one day found himself waking up inside of it.

It dealt with a lot of twists and turns. And all routes led to dead ends. The only realistic solution would be to just barrel through the barbs and bee line to the exit door. It was cruel. But Mark didn’t reflect on it for long.

He returned to jerking the body backwards, finding all this labor cathartic. It was as though he was back to running three miles every morning, the exercise keeping his mind clear and his energy levels up - though the muscle soreness was getting to him. And he wasn’t the spry early-twenty-something year old he once was. His back aways hurt. Ibuprofen was his breakfast now.

He wanted to blame the exercise for why he didn’t feel despair after work. Maybe a part of him just liked this change in the mundanity. Maybe he was just sick, infected by John, and he just didn’t know it yet.

Or maybe it was because things were looking up with Will, after she agreed to take a temporary leave of absence instead of downright quitting.

They finally made it to the cage. Mark straightened his back and wiped the sweat off his brow, sighing and grimacing from the aches in his spine. He knelt over to remove Leahy’s clothes. Poor bastard. He knew this man’s background. Alcoholic. Lived alone. Divorced, wife left him years ago. And he just pushed everything in his life away except the bottle. And here they were.

The pity and regret he felt, for this man would suffer, was foreign to Mark. Maybe it was from respect that this guy had given them such a hard time, despite the full dose of sedative he had hit with.

Mark knew this wasn’t right. Kidnapping mentally ill people instead of violent criminals was not what he had expected. Mark resented John for tonight.

I got to get out of this. 

Yet John knew more than he let on, in ways that made Mark begin to question his own logic. What if this guy was rotten on the inside? And he went and hurt others, until we tested him?

That’s what John promised, and Mark hated the beginnings of trust he felt for his new keeper. If it wasn’t for John, he probably would not have faired well during Leahy’s capture. 

He still felt Leahy’s grip on his neck, squeezing him as if he was strangling a teddy bear, until his vision filled with splotches as John came through with the additional needle. The pain began to push away the pity.

Blackmail aside, John looked out for him. It made sense. John needed Mark more than Mark needed John.

He pulled Leahy’s pants down, took his knife and cut off the shirt, not bothering with fighting the torso for it. He walked out and closed the door, locking the chainlinked containment and went to the other room where John was looking at the peephole.

They had not conversated since the kidnapping and for once, it was Mark who felt a compulsion to break the silence. “I didn’t expect to feel any remorse.”

“The heart cannot be involved,” John whispered ominously. “Emotionally, there can be nothing there.”

Mark stepped closer, barely making out his words.

“It can never be personal.” Pale eyes looked up at him, intense and all knowing.

“Let’s go,” Mark chose to ignore John’s mystical moment. He had them often, seeming to go off on some tangent of philosophy at random times. He suspected it was the brain tumor. Mark just wanted to go home and sleep.

“No.” John pressed his hand to his chest. “You’re not done yet.” A hand reached and squeezed his shoulder, rubbing it - almost affectionately. “Tonight you will see the difference between killing,” John steered Mark to the barrel to sit, “and rehabilitation.”

Mark awkwardly obeyed, knowing it better to go along with what John instructed. Knowing how biblical he was to those who did not ‘follow his rules’, Mark leaned forward to stare at the peep hole. Leahy, in the distance, was beginning to rouse. 

He’s early , Mark surmised, again astounded by the older man’s vigor.

He knew he was becoming more culpable now. In this deep, and with Tapp breathing down John’s neck, Mark was next in line for the chopping block if they were ever caught. A feeling of debt owed was in the back of his mind, poking at his brain until he turned to John.

“There is another detective.” A part of him felt sick to his stomach, going down a road he knew would forever taint him. “You should be aware of. His name’s Tapp. He’s smart and he’s getting close.”

John gave no indication of pleasure or shock. “I know who he is.” John leaned against the wall, close to him, as if they were friends on a smoke break, catching up. “I need you to lead him to someone for me.” He took out of his pocket a pen in a ziploc bag, playing with it, clicking its built in flashlight. “A doctor. A healer in need of healing.” He placed the bag down on a barrel on his way out. 

Knowing better than to ask for more details, he retrieved the pen, noting the label imprinted on the plastic.

Lawrence Gordon, M.D. Oncology

He recognized the name, the man the current top of the suspect list for the case. Always one step ahead. Always, John was prepared. It wasn’t just the extra sedatives he brought that night. John could locate a dent in a single gear before they tested out one of their prototypes. He had this uncanny sixth sense that was beginning to creep Mark out.

“You look conflicted, Detective, like a man who has one more thing left to lose.”

He was certain he was still being followed but didn’t complain. It would take time to fully earn John’s trust. Once he did, he’d be able to outwit him.

For now, though, it was an impossibility. Mark hadn’t figured out what was it about John Kramer that brought out this, he begrudgingly admitted, brilliance. 

And it was this brilliance that scared Mark.

Unlike Rosello, he was unsure how to deal with him. He, in return, was watching John in hopes he would slip up. Give up the name of an accomplice. Mark suspected perhaps it was his wife that was the person who would release his dealings with Baxter if John ever disappeared. He wouldn’t know, for sure, until the morning.

“Five hours,” he muttered to himself when he checked his watch. Fuck. It looked like he would get an hour total of sleep. He sighed and returned to watching Paul Leahy in his razor wire trap.

 

Amanda Young

 

She returned, after giving yet another statement to the damn cops.

She was tired. All she wanted was to curl up and sleep. It was only two in the afternoon. But she had nothing else to do. When she sat down on her bed, admiring the crack in the wooden floor, sighing, she hadn’t expected to have a guest.

Amanda .”

She stiffened, the voice like sandpaper on her skin.

“Do not be afraid. Your life has just begun.”

She turned, dreading to see who it was.

The man looked haggard. Old. Like a hawk, eying a mouse. Yet there was something familiar about him. She just couldn’t pinpoint where she’d seen his face before.

“My name is John. I came here to personally extend my congratulations.”

So it was him.

She stood up, her fingers trembling. Her first instinct was to grab her bedside lamp and hurl it at his skull. The other was to run out of her apartment, screaming at the top of her lungs until she coughed blood. 

But for some reason, her limbs refused to move, as though he had cast a spell upon her. 

“What do you want?” She demanded, her voice still rasped from all the interviews she had been doing earlier.

“I want to talk.”

She narrowed her eyes. But she wanted to hear him out. She wanted to glimpse into the window of this maniac. She had played out what she would say to him, if she ever crossed his path. That he hadn’t broken her. That, if anything, his sick little game had just made her stronger.

“I’m so happy you passed, Amanda.”

This made the words freeze on her tongue. “What?”

He was smiling, teeth straight and clean. “I’ve waited so long. But I knew, the moment I chose you, that you would be the one.”

His words didn’t sound like that of a maniac. It sounded like that of her old English teacher, who had been one of the only adults to believe in her back when she was in school. “Are you going to hurt me?”

“No. I will not harm you. I merely wish to make you an offer.”

She cocked her head to the side. “What kind of offer?” She instinctively wondered if this was another test. Was he about to offer her drugs, to see if he cured her?

“Tell me, will you ever put poison in your body again?”

“No,” she whispered, now afraid, feeling as though his stare could bore holes into her. 

He nodded. “Though my method was… unconventional, I know it is effective. Tell me, what do you plan to do, now that you’re free of the prison that is your addiction?”

She blinked. “I don’t know. Get a job?” She said what she hoped he wanted to hear.

“What if I offer you an opportunity,” he leaned forward, sounding excited, “for a purpose greater than yourself?”

“I’d say you’re nuts,” she muttered.

He laughed. “Yes, I’m sure you still need time to process. But tell me, compared to your many trips to the Homeward Bound Clinic, have you craved heroin?”

Fuck no. I want nothing to do with those damn needles anymore. She shook her head. “Like you said. I took my life for granted. But not anymore, John.”

“I see promise in you, Amanda. I see great potential. You are a shining beacon of hope for the future. If I am to deliver a legacy before I die, I need you to help me.”

His kind words and gentle demeanor was not what she had expected of him. “Why me?”

“Because you are the first but you will not be the last. Together, we can make the world see how precious life is. Will you hear me out, Amanda?”

She took in a deep breath. Her world was spinning. This guy, the cops said was a psycho. But she knew the cops. And they were the psychos. They were the ones who locked away innocent people and ruined their lives.

The way the world was right now, it was all topsy-fucking-turvy. She gave him a sharp look.

What did she have to lose?

“All right, John, let’s talk.”



Will Maddox

 

“Mrs. Tuck,” Mark forced a smiled as he flipped the pages of his notepad.

“It’s Doctor Tuck. And I’m not married anymore.”

Will nodded, taking a step forward to shift the attention. “Sorry to hear that.”

Jill Tuck had a cold face. She was attractive in features but her dark eyes had a dull appearance, clear she had seen far too much and had little optimism for the future.

“And who are you?” Jill sharply stared at Mark, who had been eying the many posters hanging around the clinic walls.

“Detective Mark Hoffman and this is my partner, Detective Will Maddox. This is about the burglary reported last January.”

“Ah. Well, care to tell me why it’s taken ten months since the incident to finally sit down with one of you officers?”

“We’re very sorry, Dr. Tuck. But we’re here now. And we want to help.”

Jill seemed taken aback by Will’s words and lowered her eyes. “Fine. Come into my office. I can talk until my lunch break ends, then you’ll have to come back tomorrow. It’s busy.”

“Seems like it’s always busy,” Mark muttered as they pushed through crowds of twitching patients, some pulling at the skin on their faces while others shivered and scratched at their arms.

They reached the office and once the doors were closed Will’s urge to take a hot shower subsided. Unlike the waiting room, Jill’s office looked immaculate.

She noticed a picture on a filing cabinet behind the doctor’s desk, face down. Will made note, curious but politely sat at one of the two chairs across from Jill’s seat.

“Maybe i can save everyone’s time by telling you, I identified the perpetrator. And he hasn’t appeared in my clinic since, despite being a regular patient before all of this happened.”

“Expected, it’s not likely a criminal would try to get services after he robbed the place.”

“See, that’s the thing. Cecil Adams had already stolen from the clinic before. He still came, requiring detox weeks later, but he came back. I expected him to do so again.”

“Even after the…” Mark looked uncomfortable, his ears flushing. Will watched him, pointedly, bemused at how he would navigate around the topic, “incident with your unborn child.”

Jill closed her eyes for a moment and reopened them. “His name was Gideon.”

“We’re sorry for your loss, Dr. Tuck,” Will’s voice was gentle.

Jill turned to her, eyebrow furrowed. “Do you have children, Detective Maddox?”

Will swallowed. “No.”

“That explains how you can sit there, being so calm, yet have the gall to tell me you’re sorry for my loss. What good does your pity give? Gideon was everything to me. And my…” Jill looked away and reached for a tissue on her desk. “Sorry. It’s still hard.”

Will nodded, understanding. The pain needed an outlet. Will was very familiar with being that outlet. 

Mark sat up in his chair. “Jill, so you say a Cecil Adams was the one who attacked you.”

“It was an accident. But yes. He took five boxes of Methadone and two boxes of Buprenorphine. They’re detox agents we use for heroin abuse.”

“Is that a lot?”

“For one person? Very. It was out of character for Cecil to steal that many. The last time, he thought they would give the same level of high as something like oxycodone.”

“Do you think he was trying to get high off of what he stole?”

“Not really. I had thought he had been stealing them for a friend. Someone else.”

“Any idea who?”

Jill hesitated but eventually shook her head. “No. Can’t think of anyone. Cecil didn’t have friends. Only fellow drug users. Now, I have five minutes left to eat my lunch and get back out there. Please.” Jill stood up and held her hand out to the door, a half-polite, half-impatient gesture.

Will studied the woman, suspecting she was hiding something. Instead of directly asking, she thanked the doctor for her time.

Mark followed her out of the clinic. “So we need to find Cecil Adams?”

“Yeah. But I also think he had an accomplice that night.”

“Why?”

“The way Jill got. Sounded like she knew exactly who was with Cecil. Find it weird that she didn’t seem interested in us catching him?” 

“Yeah, thought it strange. She’s a strange woman.”

Will paused at the staircase by the front doors. The clinic entrance had a large foyer and trash collected along the hallway.

A glint of light caught Will’s eye and she smiled up at the familiar shine of a camera lens. “Think we’re lucky enough that they’ll still have the tapes from ten months ago?”

“Fuck, if it even still works, I’ll buy you a beer.”

“I’m feeling lucky, Mark.”



Mark Hoffman

 

When Mark stepped into the warehouse, he knew something was off.

“The shipment has arrived.”

He heard a woman’s voice.

He stayed quiet and in the shadows as he crept towards the main room where John stood in his black and red robe while a tall, thin woman studied the drill chair.

“Ah, Detective.” John had a softer demeanor, almost friendly, when he looked up at Mark’s entrance. 

Shit. It’s her.

Mark remmbered her face, back when her mouth had fresh gashes and she was a twitching mess. Amanda Young was her name. The first Jigsaw Survivor.

As usual, John pulled out a wild card, keeping Mark on his toes.

The woman turned and her curious face instantly darkened into dislike. She must have recognized him from the precinct.

“Who’s this?” Mark demanded, stepping closer, not one to feel intimidated by a woman a third his size. Mark studied her pale face and heated eyes. 

“Mark, this is Amanda. She will be joining our efforts. And Amanda, this is-,”

“Mark Hoffman. I know him. John. You didn’t tell me you were working with a dirty cop.”

Ah, so that’s it then.  

“It would make sense, though, how Jigsaw stays one step ahead of law enforcement after all this time,” he explained, a sense of pride washing over his apprehension. He was the reason they weren’t all in jail at this very moment.

This enraged her and the cold wariness burned into trembling rage. “No. You and your partner put me in jail on a bullshit charge.”

This was a turn for the worse. But Mark remained calm.

“Doubtful. My partner’s thorough.”

“Oh, he was. There was enough evidence that magically appeared to lock me up. For five years. You ruined my life, and got me charged for shit I didn’t even do!” She stepped forward, fists balled, and Mark prepared to grab her if she tried to throw a punch.

Ah, she’s referring to Matthews . Now it was all coming back and that tickle of familiarity she had been itching in his brain made sense. 

Five years ago. Back when he and Will were still dating. Back when he and Matthews were on their rampage season because Will had been off playing with the FBI. Grissom had creamed his pants over the arrest-rates they were pulling that summer.

She had been with some junkie and in the wrong place at the wrong time. She wasn’t innocent, not by a long shot. But Matthews had been on a bureaucratic booking spree. Pills were ‘found’ in pockets. Paperwork claimed as much. The department’s word against hers. And she lost the dice roll.

“Amanda, Mark serves our goals. He is crucial to our plans. Whatever slights you feel he is responsible for, I assure you, are from your past life. Like you, he is here because he believes in what we are doing. He, too, is finding redemption in our cause.”

Yeah, right . Mark was thankful John didn’t elaborate on exactly how he got involved. But it was obvious, with the glint in John’s eye, that he was intentionally withholding these details from her.

Amanda darted her gaze to John, wavering. “But John, you can’t trust a cop.”

“It’s as John says,” Mark tried to smooth things over. He didn’t want any bad blood. It would just make his current situation all the more worse. “I’m not your enemy.”

Her lip curled. “Yeah. Right. Fuck.” She turned sharply and stomped away.

Mark inwardly sighed. “What’s the meaning of this, John?”

John looked after her, silent for a long pause. “Mark, did you arrest Amanda?”

“Technically? I don’t remember. Either myself or my - colleague.”

“Your partner?”

Those hawk eyes honed in on him. Impulsive defensiveness pulled the name out of his throat. “Eric Matthews. He was my partner back then.” Just the idea of putting Will on this nutjob’s radar was one of the only things that still scared him.

“It amazes me. How you can take the freedom of another human being and not have their face forever branded in your memory. Yet Amanda remembers you.”

Mark waited for the man to elaborate. When he didn’t, anger began to boil up his throat. “Is the reason you called me here just to meet her? For what? Another thing to hold over my head?”

“To introduce you to a… colleague .”

“She seems unstable.”

“After the ordeal she has experienced, she is learning to live with enlightenment.”

“What do you mean?”

“I knew, the moment I saw her free herself from my trap, that she is special.” John had turned to his drawing table with a coughing fit and sat down, struggling to take a deep breath. “Detective, can you get me a glass of water, please?”

Mark narrowed his eyes. “Yeah.” He turned and went to the next room where the kitchenette resided. He took a glass from the cupboards, turned the faucet valve, letting it run to clear out the stagnant water.

He turned and kept his composure when Amanda stood inches away, as though trying to startle him.

“If John says you’re cool,” she crossed her arms, “then I’ll give you a chance, Detective .”

Already, she seemed to be imitating John. Mark could tell right away that this was a woman with a weak sense of identity. Someone who would have been picked up by a cult or con artist, if it hadn’t have been John.

Sure, Mark was a prisoner. But so was she.

She just didn’t realize it yet. 

“Let’s just make things clear,” she added, “I don’t trust you.”

“That makes two of us.”

She seemed to find that funny. With a smirk she reached over and took the glass from his hands. “I’ll take this to John. There’s a shipment of crates out back. John wants us to begin assembling something tonight.”

Already, she was calling the shots? Mark remained the observer, not planning on pushing back unless it was in his favor. 

But he already knew that Amanda complicated things.

He went to retrieve the crate. It was a cold night. In the run down, ghost town of an industrial mall, there were only rats to witness Mark as he shoved a dolly under an oversized crate, grunting as he forced it to tilt and carefully brought it back inside. 

Whatever was in there, it was fucking heavy.

It took him a while to bring it into the auxilary space where currently a prototype for a giant gear-driven rack and some torture chair were resting. John and Amanda were currently working on attaching drills on each side of the chair.

“Detective, you can leave that there. It is time to retrieve our next test subject.”

John had a book shelf full of binders, each with numbers neatly drawn in sharpie. There were seven of them. The first, had been opened and rested at a nearby workbench.

Mark could make out the distant photographs, black and whites of a young man. Mark moved the picture where an envelope with the bulk of a cassette tape and an address written over it gave him his next destination. 

Mark Wilson. The Cypher Room. 

Ah, he remembered that night, when John and him painted every square inch of that basement room with red painted numbers. It had given him a headache. The safe was already staged. The floor had plenty of broken glass. The antidote was in fridge. The flammable jelly was in the chem locker.

He turned to the next page, hoping this was the only task for the night.

When he saw a new headshot, this one an older scrawny man, Mark mentally grimaced.

Jeff Ridenhour. Bring him here before sunrise.

Why did John need these two tonight? This was ridiculous.

It would take all night to gather these two and stage them. 

Mark inwardly groaned but took the materials. Another night with no sleep. Great.

Notes:

A/N: Delays because of Christmas season but finally got a new pc so have more time behind a keyboard to get things progressing!

Chapter 46: Peri-SAW: Strahm Says It

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dr. Lawrence Gordon

 

These police officers were persistent. 

To his ire, they had been waiting in his office. Lawrence knew he would need to have a stern talking to his secretary.

“How can I help you gentlemen?” He had remained pleasant, smiling and with a jovial bravado despite the tension.

When they had shown him his penlight, claiming it was found at the scene of one of those heinous Jigsaw murders, Lawrence immediately conjured up the phone number to his lawyer. 

Yet the alibi, of all the time windows they had given him, had been the one secret he had been desperately trying to hide. He had clung to it, until he found himself in that miserable old building with the cheap Maxwell House coffee and being subjugated to witness a poor woman’s ramblings of murder, blood, screams, and terror. 

The one survivor who had made it. How horrifying of an ordeal. 

When his lawyer finally arrived, he had caved and agreed to give Carla’s identity. The shame he had felt had been suffocating. 

And after all of this, Detective Tapp had the audacity to imply he was akin to a child predator.

“The sewers run in these neighborhoods too, Doctor.”

He did not like the implications. The suspicion. They were groundless.

For some reason, this detective was adamant that he was the Jigsaw Killer. 

Inconceivable.

When he got out of the car and reached his door, he had to shake off all the stress from that day.

“Daddy!” Diana ran up to him and he went to scoop her up and pull her into a big hug.

“Honey!” He smiled, glad to see her. He intended to erase all of this nonsense about the Jigsaw Killer, Tapp, and everything. It was all over. He was clear.

Now, he could get on with his life in peace.

 

Mark Hoffman

 

“Told you I felt lucky,” Will grinned back at Mark as the security guard rubbed his bald head with a shy face.

“I couldn’t just erase the footage, not when I know you guys would likely want to see it. Kept it safe,” he explained. “Dr. Jill’s always been sweet. I hope you catch these two.”

“I believe we can identify the second suspect,” Will replied, “you did good, keeping this safe. Thank you.”

Mark had withheld the sneer of triumph as he recognized the small waif-like woman who was shivering and watching as Cecil Adams marched toward the clinic doors.

Amanda Young.

So she was a witness when John’s wife was attacked?

No, she was one of the perpetrators.

Mark did not know the full story but it was clear that the sudden death of his future child had taken a toll on John.

While staking out a future victim, some doctor in the rich side of town, John had been especially angry. “ He holds no appreciation for the life he’s been blessed. The child others would kill to have, alive and well, with them, he takes for granted.

This was a valuable piece of leverage, especially these days, when John gave Amanda the royal treatment and worked him like a dog.

It was the last day, and just in time, they were set to close.

But Mark wasn’t sure what to do with this evidence just yet.

“Well, it’s near the end of the day. And I’ve got a plane to catch early tomorrow,” Will murmured, checking her watch with a tired look. She looked back at Mark. “I’m satisfied. We have Cecil’s autopsy report. Can I leave the rest to you?”

He smiled, glad she made it easy for him. “What, you trusting me with paperwork?”

She wrinkled her nose. “Yeah, maybe not.”

“I’m just kidding. Come on, let me take you home. Need anything at your office?”

She shook her head. “No, I already cleared out.”

That felt like a punch to the gut but he pretended not to care as the two of them left the clinic towards his car. 

“Have you seen my glove? I thought I had it in your car last week.”

Mark kept a straight face. “Nope. Haven’t seen it.”

Will sighed. “Damn. It’s my favorite pair.”

Mark knew exactly what she was talking about, the small tan suede leather glove that he had found between the seat and door of the passenger side of his car the other day. “Sorry, Will, tough luck.”

She shrugged. “It’s fine. Just an excuse to go shopping.” She gave a rue smile. “Anyway. I’ll see you around?”

He didn’t want to rush her. They could stay in that car for the rest of their lives for all he cared.

But she would need to go. The more he clung, the more she’d repel. Mark had to coax her when the opportunity arose.

For now, he had to let her go.

“I also just realized,” Will added, “the perpetrator resembled Amanda Young. The resolution was poor but I think you should consider a Jigsaw angle to this.”

No doubt about it. She had to go.

She was too damn sharp for her own good.

“Yeah, I’ll let Kerry and the others know. You have a safe flight. You’ll be missed.”

She nodded and they rode in silence. Mark appreciated the sound of her sighing and knowing she was there, just within reach to touch.

But he doubted there would be any hug, any kiss, any lasting contact for their goodbye.

“Where you staying, while in San Diego?”

“Just a cheap motel for divorces and vagabonds.”

“Classy.” He was fishing, wondering if a certain male agent would be her roommate. 

“Don’t plan on staying there much. I’m hoping it won’t be for longer than a few weeks. There’s promise, based on the case file recovered. But it went cold so long ago, it’s going to take some time getting up to speed. But they never did run the fingerprints through modern databases. The FBI databases.” She didn’t elaborate but Mark could read between the lines.

FBI. So she was in direct contact with him , then. Likely working closely.

He squeezed the steering wheel to remember himself.

“If you jump ship permanently, you better come back for a proper send off.”

“Oh. Yeah.”

The surprise in her voice, as though she had not even considered leaving forever, put a smile on his lips. But there was hesitancy there. And Mark, especially knew, how things didn’t always go according to plan.

Despite having known of him for years, he didn’t know Strahm well and had no time to perform a decent reconnaissance of the agent.

But he knew enough with an internet search to know Strahm was a likeable man with an impressible resume. Mentions of his late wife. Collegiate athletic accomplishments. Mark didn’t like how shiny Strahm was compared to him. 

“I’m only a phone call away. If you need me, for something.”

The olive branch extended, Mark treasured it and intended to take her up on that offer. “Yeah, don’t go changing your number on me now.”

She laughed. “You’re not so bad that I have to memorize a new phone number.”

“Ouch.”

“It’s a compliment.”

“Sure.”

He reached her apartment, pulling up to the curb. “Good luck, Will.” It pained him to turn to her, keep his face pleasant. “I know you’ll close the case. Stay sharp out there.”

Her eyebrows turned up and a bittersweet smile blossomed on her face. “Oh, Mark.” She leaned forward and wrapped her arm around him, pulling him into a close hug. “I’ll miss you.”

He shut his eyes tight and desperately tried to take in every detail, to the scent of her shampoo to the warmth of her breasts pressed into his chest. He was going to miss her too. Damn it .

She pulled back and gave him one last smile before getting out of the car and waving him off.

He waited for her to get into her apartment building and he pulled away from the curb.

When he got home, the silence was deafening but also reassuring. 

It was his first night off in weeks. John hadn’t given him any instructions yet.

Amanda was his primary focus and John’s preoccupation with her gave Mark some breathing room.

He walked past the couch, where the grates of his air vents greeted him. He carefully unscrewed them with a quarter in his pocket and removed the box.

Opening it, at the very top was Will’s glove he had stowed away. He went to sit and go through his trinkets of her, these articles being all he had left of her now.

A napkin with her lipstick kissed when she had blotted her mouth years ago.

A handheld note in her girlish, flirty handwriting.

A lock of her hair, tied by twine, from years ago.

Bobby pins, hair ties, one of her socks. A bottle of nail polish she had left at his house, back when they lived together.

He sighed, the invasive fear that this was all it would ever be festering in his brain. He didn’t want that to happen.

And these days, he was learning how… easy it was to be in control.

That was the one good thing being forced to serve Jigsaw had taught him, was learning to be the puppet master to others. He was picking up on how some people were driven by their vices. Lust, greed, insecurity. John always found some ironic way to use it to test them and if they chose to succumb to their weakness, they would lose their right to live.

Supposedly, those who could suspend themselves of their preclinations would transcend to truly finding the means of cherishing their life.

In the future, Mark wanted to live his life, which he so cherished greatly.

He closed the box. First thing’s first. 

He needed to figure out a way to hold no possible tie to the Jigsaw Killer before he could get Will back. 

Someone else would have to take the fall, without a shadow of a doubt. It wasn’t an impossible feat. Mark was well versed at staging evidence and defining a case narrative to be within his favor. The resources were there.

It was John and Amanda he was worried about. John would be too smart and find his way to talk out of whatever conviction he had, not to mention the lawyers he likely could afford.

He figured Amanda could take the fall. The first survivor? Yeah, and so far the only survivor still. The latest two currently being tested - Mark suspected would die as well. But based on John’s track record, only Amanda had what it takes.

It would certainly convince a jury. 

Exhaustion came over him, making his eyes heavy. He needed to sleep.

He’d figure it out later. But first, he needed to crash.

But these days, sleep didn’t come, no matter how tired he got.

He sat on the couch and turned the TV on, not paying attention to the glowing screen.

His thoughts were currently digging up buried memories.

Knox, you look like hell.”

“Fuck you very much, pipsqueak.”

“Jesus, it’s nine in the morning. You can’t just drink here, Grissom will have your ass.”

“He won’t mind it, so long as you don’t make a big deal of it, boy.”

Knox had been hunched over his desk, gripping the lone picture frame he always kept on his desk, of his wife holding their infant son. “She’s leaving me, Mark.”

“Christ, I’m sorry.”

“Told me I’m not the man she fell in love with. That she was tired of being married but being alone. And that she’s afraid I’d get Timmy killed. The fucking nerve.” He had pressed his thumb and front finger into his eyelids, looking on the verge of breaking down, amidst the sea of detectives who paid him no mind out of respect.

“Maybe she’ll turn around. Marianne knows you love her.”

“That’s the thing, she said I never show it. And she wants a safe life out of the city. I can’t give her that.”

“There’s still a chance,” Mark had said back when he was younger and naive. “Just buy her some flowers. Take her out. Hell, I’ll watch Timmy.”

“No, I don’t think it’s going to be an easy fix. Not even if I had the cash to buy the biggest diamond earrings in the state. No, she’s done with me. And it’s for the best.” Knox leaned back in his chair, shoes on the desk, nose facing the ceiling, and he took another glug from the bottle. “She’ll keep Timmy safe. I can’t guarantee doing that anymore. Not with Rosello watching my back. I’m trapped, Mark. Trapped and fucked.” The phone began to rang.

Mark opened his eyes, realizing that noise was his cell phone alarm going off. It was John. It was time to get back to work.





 Peter Strahm

 

He flipped and kicked off the concrete wall, exhaling out of his nose as the bubbles geysered down his chin and he flew through the cold water. Fifty-six. Nine more .

The silence enveloped him with only the gentle rush of his limbs heard as he swung his hand out and exerted each stroke as though he was trying to outpace a shark.

Whenever he needed to escape his thoughts, he chose to outswim them.

Fifty-seven . He saw the black T marking the end of the lane and he flip turned once again. He noticed the person in the lane beside him had finished. The pool was likely closing soon. He needed to hurry up.

Lately, he had a lot on his mind.

And the one thing that had taken up all the real estate in his head was Will Maddox. 

She was arriving today, and he would have to break some news to her.

He still wasn’t sure if it was good or bad.

There had been fingerprints found at her childhood home that belonged to no one in the Maddox family. He had been running them through every database the FBI currently had.

And they finally got a hit.

Philip Rhodes. Born 1958. Long rap sheet. Served multiple sentences throughout his lifetime. Armed robberies, assault, grand theft. And he was currently serving a sentence in Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego since 1992 for second degree murder. 

Will would likely feel a wide range of emotions. Anger, at the incompetence of her hometown police department for never being the ones to identify his involvement. Disappointment, that there would be no arrests done at her hand. Hope, that all of this would be resolved as quickly as it had begun.

For Peter, he hated to admit that he felt only one emotion. Disappointment.

He knew it was wrong of him, wanting her to have stayed with him for much longer, if the reason was because her mother’s murderer was still out there and she was desperately trying to find him. 

Yet his personal feelings for her and wanting her close had complicated things.

Peter angrily flipped and kicked with all his might, flying down the lane before he rose up to begin stroking again. The flawed part of him considered delaying telling her.

It would be wrong. He knew this. 

But the man wasn’t going anywhere. He wanted to just spend more time with her. And with both their jobs, their schedules, and all the problems life kept throwing their way. And this damn Jigsaw Killer that would likely need her attention soon, he had very little legitimate reason to stay involved with her. He just needed time to convince her to join the FBI. 

He wasn’t proud of these thoughts. But he was so damn tired of feeling so damn alone.

No, this is for her own good.

He knew it was, because he had gotten a disturbing letter in the mail a few days ago.

No return address, all printed with no handwriting to be traced.

It had been to his damn home address, which had made his gut twist with anxiety.

Watch yourself, Special Agent.

Nothing particularly threatening. But it sure wasn’t a damn Christmas card. And there had been one more thing in the envelope. Peter had thought for a second a bug had gotten mailed to him.

But when he took it out his heart had stopped.

It had been three strands of copper hair. Peter had already put the pieces together.

It had to be Will’s. 

Peter felt the sharp cramp in his left calf and he ground his teeth as he forced himself to the edge of the pool and waited for the pain to subside. He had overdid it.

He took his goggles off, rubbed his eyes, coughing. 

Peter had no evidence for this. Even dusting the envelope and card for prints had born no worthwhile fruit. But he just knew who had sent that card.

The only other man who had the means of acquiring such an intimate part of her. And the motive to try to scare him.

As if that bastard could.

It only made Peter more determined to get Will away from him.




Will Maddox

 

Something was off with Peter Strahm. 

She wasn’t sure but he seemed more on edge than necessary, clicking his pen, glaring down at the yellowed paper of the case document. 

When he had picked her up, he had put his hand around her, asking her when the last time she got a hair cut was.

It had been a strange question.

Months ago, she answered. She rarely needed one because her hair took forever to show length. 

He then asked if she had noticed anything strange - anything at all.

But Peter never explained the reason behind these questions. Only that he was glad she was safe and hurriedly brought her to Quantico.

And then they had a brief debate on her sleeping arrangements.

“I have plenty of space, a private guest room. This isn’t a ploy,” Peter had added intensely, “I’m only concerned for your safety.”

Normally, Will would have pushed back. She would have kneejerked with anger at this sudden domineering and micromanaging.

But it was nice to have a man fawn over her for once.

After several half-hearted back and forths, Will decided it would be fine to stay at his house. She pushed down the nagging sense of discomfort at how she didn’t know exactly why Peter felt so concerned for her, finding herself also partially thrilled at being able to learn more about him.

And, she would only admit this to Allison and Lindsay, she was hoping something more would come out of this.

Despite his high strung ways, she still thought he had nice forearms and a strong jawline and she still had blood flowing in her veins and needs she hadn’t addressed in a long time.

And it wasn’t as though they weren’t romantically involved - but the long distance had made her feel at ease with no strings attached.

Now, there was a distinct, unspoken pressure. An expectation of moving forward with things. 

The fact that they were both in his dining room, the remnants of Chinese takeout shoved to the other end while folders, papers, and pictures covered the walnut table, and two glasses of well used glasses of red wine, this would have been Will’s ideal datenight.

That is, if the contents of the case file itself did not bring back such painful, horrifying memories of the worst moment of her life.

“Were they investigating your father’s business rival?” Peter flipped a page. “Yeah, looks like it. But the guy had an alibi.”

“The case had not been completely neglected. But they just ran out of angles to explore.” Truthfully, Will had no idea where to start. It was the first time she was seeing the autospy report, the neighbors’ witness statements, and the crime scene photos.

Seeing a picture of the blemishes across her mother’s corpse, her nude body on the gurney, had almost broken her.

And then there were the pictures that sparked memories long buried.

One particular one was her, wrapped in a blanket, crying while holding onto Bram who couldn’t even walk yet. And the pain clouding her mind at these recollections made it hard for her to make a confident decision on what strategy she should take.

“Hey,” Peter put his hand over hers and squeezed it. He felt warm. Comforting. He smelled of musk and leather. “Let’s take a break.”

“Yeah.” She wiped a tear that almost escaped her eye and got to her feet. “How about a walk around your beautiful neighborhood?”

He had a wide smile. “Love to.”

The night was surprisingly warm. The east coast had a warm front, the weatherman said. The night was full of mist and street lamps to illuminate the gated community. She could see her breath but as they walked the first street she needed to unbutton the top of her jacket and felt sweat begin to form.

“Surprisingly humid, for late November.” A trash can blocked her path and she stepped into the road to go around.

“That’s Virginia humidity, for you. You get used to it.” Strahm followed her.

The roar of a loud engine had her turn her head, blinded by the bright headlights. She felt herself being pulled from the edge of the sidewalk, pressed to Peter as a yellow sports car zoomed by, the two of them almost falling over into the grass.

“Asshole,” Peter muttered before releasing her. “Nobody obeys the speed limit here.”

She was blushing, his touch thrilling and the absence leaving her chilled. All of this brought a shiver up her spine and Peter went to take his coat off.

“No, I’m fine,” she reassured him and leaned into him, linking her arm around his elbow. She always had a soft spot for men who were quick to act. “I’ll warm up as we keep moving. Do you run here?”

“No, I’m more of an indoor athlete. Been swimming this winter.”
Maybe it was her long dry spell but a part of her began imagining him in swim trunks and she turned away to hide her pervy smile. 

Peter lived in a nice neighborhood. Manicured lawns, expensive cars in the driveways, and plenty of scenic trails to walk through. They reached a grand roofed deck built by a pond, a few ducks roosting at the water’s edge. The moon was almost full and there was an impressive amount of stars above.

“It’s so beautiful here,” Will sighed, staring out at the silver water and deep blue night. “I feel like I could stare out here forever.” She turned to Peter. “I admit I’m a little jealous. You can’t get this kind of peace and quiet unless you drive hours from the city, fighting traffic the entire time.”

“Well if you ever need a place to get away, you’re always welcome here, Will.” Peter rested his forearms against the rail and looked outward. “My house gets a little too quiet for my liking. It’s nice to have company. Especially when it’s someone as charming as you.”

He was a smooth talker and Will was not used to being on the receiving end of it. Her long term relationship with Mark, of course, had been rich and physical and full of ease. Mark had his strengths. But charisma wasn’t one of them.

And then she felt his hand on her cheek and she was being pulled into Peter, and he was leaning down to plant a gentle kiss on her mouth. It was chaste but had fired heat in her belly and she found herself throwing her arms around his neck and pressing upward into him, willing for this man who tasted different and nothing like Mark to help ease the rising pang of longing she had for him .

Peter happily obliged, hands running up her back and his tongue grazing her lower lip as they both grew rushed and heated with their mutual explorations. 

Help me forget, Peter , she silently thought. She wanted to forget about her past. Her mother, dead and gone forever. Her father, who lost so many years. Bram, who had to endure it all. Angie, taken too early. And Mark, who she loved and failed to help when he needed her.

But with Peter, he was the one who assured her he would be there. And she wanted, more than anything, to move on.

He went to pull from the kiss but she pouted, grabbing the collar of his shirt and pulling him down once more for a firm kiss that resulted in her nipping her teeth into his lower lip. He hissed in surprise, straightening to look down at her with heated curiosity.

“How deep do these woods go?” She had suggestion thick in her voice and her hand lowered down to his belt, his thigh, willing him to understand that she needed this.

“Acres.” He had caught on, suggestion in his smile.

She reached and grabbed the ends of his fingers, pulling him from the deck and towards the thick trees and brush. “Think we’ll run into anyone if we go in?”

“Not if we go deep enough,” he responded, a man lured by his loins.

She jogged, pulling him with giggles as he trotted behind her, holding onto her hand and they broke through the heavy twigs. Most of the leaves had gone already, but it was cold enough to drive the bugs away.

Her heart thudded with anticipation as they hiked over drying leaves and soon found a spot where a large tree rested and everywhere they turned they could barely make the distant lights houses. 

Like hormonal teenagers they took to each other, his hands running through her hair while she moaned into his mouth and pulled out his shirt from his pants, sliding them onto his chest.

He let out a gasp of surprise from her cold hands but instead returned the favor by squeezing his fingers under her waistband and gripping her bare butt as if he was determining if a peach was ripe enough. 

He picked her up and pushed her into the tree, tasting the nape of her neck while she looked up to the stars and the branches overhead, losing herself to the feeling of the cool air and Peter’s hot kisses. 

“We don’t have to rush if you don’t want to,” he whispered and she laughed.

“Peter, I dragged you here. Do you want to stop?”

He smirked back at her. “Not particularly.”

“Good, because I’m too horny to stop.” She reached to lift his shirt to admire the subtle abs running down his stomach and dropped to her knees to kiss and lick each groove, drunk with his physique. 

He let out sighs that melted into gasps when she dragged her teeth down to the patch of hair that rose from his groin. Her hands were running up his legs, across the firmness that pressed through his jeans, and she proceeded to unbuckle his belt, struggling to unbutton his pants.

He helped her, breathing heavy, his features barely visible in the dark when she looked up at him. He was a silhouette amongst the stars and she preferred it that way, finding this anonymity exciting, new, and distracting. 

“Fuck, Will,” he cursed when she pressed her lips and gently prodded his boner through his underwear, enjoying the noises he made and the twitching she caused with her touch. 

“You’re so hard, Peter, so hard and hot,” she spoke low and slow, freeing his member so she could run her tongue up from the base to the hilt.

She took him all in her mouth and began suck his head, squeezing the rest of him with her free hand and began to fill herself with him, getting him slick and wet with her spit.

After long seconds he put his hand on her head and pushed her off of him. “You’re going to make me cum if you keep doing that, Will.” He pulled her sharply up to her feet, spun her around to face the tree and went to pull her yoga pants down. 

She leaned against the dense bark, bending down as she braced the cold and then felt the warm slickness of his tongue run against her womanhood. She hummed in pleasure, loving the feeling of how his fingers dug into her ass and his eager lapping of up and down her lips, his fingers dancing around her clit.

She was wet and wanting, whining with soft mewls. “Peter, please, fuck me, I need your cock inside of me.”

He stopped his teasing and got to his feet, another pause having her turn to see why.

The faint glint of a metallic wrapper and the crinkle of plastic and she watched as he carefully rolled the condom onto his dick, spat in his hand and began to lubricate himself. 

“Always prepared?” She teased, not able to see his face for a response but felt him grab her hair and pull her head to face the tree.

“Only when you’re in town, Will,” he responded, but his tone had little humor in it. He eased on pulling her hair, running his fingers down the small of her back. “I can’t believe it’s finally happened. I can’t believe it.” He sidestepped her legs apart with his, widening her as he dragged the tip of his cock to her opening.

“Have you always wanted to fuck me?” Her stomach was tingling, licking her lips, eagerly waiting for him to fill her. 

“Ever since I saw you in that tight little red dress, all those years ago.” He pushed himself into her for a moment but did not force it. It had been a while, for her and probably for him as well. He seemed the type of guy to not sleep around. “And when you’d drink from a straw or pack a banana for lunch, it was fucking painful to watch and do nothing.”

She smiled, remembering the occasional glances she thought she’d imagine. She lowered her head and pressed herself onto him, feeling him go deeper, and he pushed her butt forward. “Nuh-uh, princess, you’re going to have to wait a bit, know what it’s like to have something so close but just out of reach.”

“But I want it,” she whined, pouting, turning to him.

“Then say please,” he pulled her shirt up and lazily grabbed a breast, squeezing it and pulling at a nipple.

She winced at the sharp pleasure. “Please, Peter, please.”

He made a noise of approval before he began pushing into her again. She let out a cry when he continued farther in than she was ready for, stretching her out, twitching and burning inside of her. 

“You okay?” He sounded concerned.

She let out a gasping, “Don’t stop!” And he continued to push until he was fully inside of her. She felt as though electricity was pulsing up her spine and it soon melded into Peter’s thrusts that were slow and rhythmic, methodical as he was. He had somehow found just the right spot and kept punching his dick at it, overwhelming her.

“Oh, Peter,” she let out his name as a thank you as she orgasmed.

He continued his pounding, the sounds of their panting and wet flesh slapping broke the quiet night and Will could barely feel her legs as she clung to the tree and felt Peter drive into her and unravel her. 

She was sopping wet, her juices slicking down her thighs while Peter pulled at her breasts, let out deep masculine growls, with words escaping his mouth, such as, “Will, fuck.”, “You’re mine,” and “Your pussy’s so tight, you drive me crazy.”

He had to pause every so often, not to catch his breath, but to refrain from cuming too soon. “Not gonna finish,” he whispered, “I’m not done with you yet.”

His dirty talk spiced her mood and accelerated her already heightened arousal, and she tried to match his thrusts, grinding her hips against his, he kept hitting just that right spot that she couldn’t think - only feel - and he let out a final ragged grunt and pushed himself all the way inside of her in finality and she could feel him thick and twitching inside of her.

When it was all done, they were both panting, her knees shaking and he leaning over her, hands pressed against the tree as they caught their breath. He leaned down to kiss her neck and she turned awkwardly to kiss him back.

“I love you, Will,” Peter said.

Will was buzzing from the wild sex and knew those words meant more than she could register. But she didn’t realize what she said until she heard them leave her lips, “I love you too.” She couldn’t pull those words back and knew it was too late, but it was said. And she almost believed it.

Notes:

A/N: FINALLY! Work has me going all over the place these days, been trying to build a good buffer to keep updates somewhat consistent? Hope you like the smut, know some of y'all have been patient with the whole Strahm/Maddox arc. And our poor boy Hoffman here, gotta descend deeper into movie lore. Hope you all had a good holiday and new year! Let's make 2024 a solid one.

Chapter 47: Peri-SAW: Time to Retire

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

Steven Sing

 

Steven wanted to catch the Jigsaw Killer. Of course he did.

But he couldn’t hold a candle to the level of obsession Tapp had begun to exhibit. Steven was sure it was because they hadn’t made much progress. No break in the case, no new leads since Amanda Young, and now that Dr. Gordon was no longer a suspect Tapp was now inconsolable. 

“Tapp, come on, it’s time to take a break.” He had tried to coax his partner with coffee, donuts, beer, hell, if strippers and blow would have worked, Steven would have tried that as well. 

For the past two days, Tapp had been watching Amanda Young’s game tape. 

Hello, Amanda. You don’t know me but I know you .”

The shrill winding of the VCR followed by a recap.

Hello, Amanda. You don’t know me…

It was starting to not sound like words anymore, only noises that melded together into an unrecognizable soup. 

Yore mowth temp herman ant leer ipt ohpane .”

Clark and Terrance walked through the room, heading out for the day.

“I’ll catch you guys down there,” Steven called out, eager to take a break.

Tapp, still, engrossed in the video, paid them no mind.

“Tapp. We’re heading down to the grill. Grab a beer. Want to come?”

“I don’t think so. Thanks anyway.”

“You know I always ask,” he watched his partner carefully. When was the last time he went home? Got some sleep? 

Even though Tapp was a career cop, he never let himself get to this level of hyper-obsession. 

Eats in this tomb hack off yore dead seoul mate .”

Whispery sounds with their meaning lost to squeak of the rewind.

“Tapp. I don’t mean this to be disrespectful. Maybe you should find yourself a girlfriend.”

The small smile broke through and Steven took that as a win. He playfully pushed Tapp as the smile grew. But he didn’t turn or break focus.

Instead, the high pitched squeal of the VCR rewinding was his response.

Fine. Let him get it out of his system. 

After all these years of knowing David Tapp, Steven knew it was futile to try to get in the way when he got this way. But it seemed worse, now. Unlike Rosello, whom Tapp had maintained a surrendering acceptance and still kept a sleep schedule while pursuing, the Jigsaw Killer was like some thorn in Tapp’s eye he couldn’t get out no matter how hard he rubbed at it. 

One of these days, he’s going to snap.

Steven tried not to worry too much but he felt at a loss on how to prevent it. Tapp rarely listened to him when it came to advice or guidance. The age gap between them severely hindered that dynamic. To him, Steven Sing would always be the rookie of the year. His professional ‘kid’. 

He turned to leave, wanting to throw back some pilsners and pass out in his bed.

“Wait-wait-wait-Sing!”

His feet froze to the floor. He wanted to whine but he grimaced and turned. “What?”

“Get back here.” Tapp waved wildly. Sing begrudgingly went back to the screen.

The tape had been paused. In the background. Graffiti. Immediately it tickled Sing’s memory banks.

“There,” Tapp took a pencil and pointed it at the screen. “Remember one hundred eighteenth street?”

“Wait, that’s -,” the memories flooded in. The explosions. The gang war. “K2K. Their territory was only about four blocks.”

“Now listen to this. You hear that?” Tapp held his finger up to hush him.

The volume raised and Steven could hear it. The faint ring of a fire alarm. And it all clicked for him, Tapp waiting with an eager grin.

“We gotta check the records for all fire emergencies that occurred there in the last two weeks of Amanda Young’s trap. Go, right now! Come on, Sing!” Tapp was all teeth with joy as Steven sprinted out of the office to get to Public Records. 

Tapp, you brilliant bastard, you did it again!

It didn’t take long to pull up the reports. “A fire alarm went off in the rear wing of 213 Stygian Street. An old listing, used to be a mannequin factory.” They poured over the maps, drawing boundaries. They could walk in right now. Except. 

“Think we have enough for a warrant, though?” It was late on a Friday night. The judge would be pissed, especially on all this thin circumstancial evidence.

But it was the only lead they had in weeks.

“Who said anything about a warrant?”

Steven felt his stomach flip. “Right now?” This wasn’t like Tapp. He was careful. He followed the rules.

“Why not?” Tapp got to his feet and grabbed his coat, already out the door before Steven could protest.

He quickly followed. Tapp never steered him wrong. Not in the twenty years of working together. “Yeah. Why not?”

So they drove off to the abandoned mannequin factory.

Tapp gripped the steering wheel and stared intently, not sparing a single word. The sun was setting fast these days and as they pulled up to the building, they were surrounded by pitch black.

“At least we have the cover of darkness,” Tapp whispered as he flipped off his headlights. 

“Yeah,” Steven felt this ominous dread squeezing his throat. “So will anyone else.”

Tapp pulled over a block away, parked, and they crept to their mark. 

Steven kept looking over his shoulder, not liking this idea the closer they got. No back up. We didn’t have time to tell anyone where we were going. This is reckless. Tapp’s acting reckless, and I’m just going with it. 

But they were too late to turn back now.

Already, Tapp had busted the lock and slid open the door. The high pitched creak of rusted metal announced their presence. 

Steven hoped no one was home. He cocked the shotgun in his hands, his safety blanket as he eyed his corners. Tapp took point, holding his pistol outward and led them up the stairs. Sing stayed at his six, making sure no boogeymen burst out from the shadows as their steps creaked under rotted wood and old steel. 

Tapp was panting and they reached the upper level where it was clear someone lived there. Coffee mugs were left out and the faint smell of tea and grease hit Steven’s nose. 

“I got you.”

He spun at this, seeing Tapp approach the K2K tag where a computer screen was left unattended.

Security cameras. Great, he got us on film . The four shots were for each entrance. He hoped the guy hadn’t noticed them waltz in.

So where is he?

Tapp gestured for him to follow deeper, past chainlink partitions, dusty shelves, and what looked like functional tools. The lights were on. Somebody had just been home.

Sheets covered various tables.

Tapp pointed to one and whisked off the drape.

What looked like some kid’s diorama project was shown, two human-like dolls dead in some bathroom.

“What the hell is this?” Tapp whispered as they locked eyes in a mutual, ‘ what the fuck ’ moment. And that’s when they saw it.

Another red drape, this one, looking as though it covered the profile of a mannequin.

Or a human.

Steven trained his sight on the head shape.

Tapp carefully reached over and pulled it off.

The familiar red eyed puppet looked back at them, grinning mockingly.

Both stood paralyzed as Steven processed what he was seeing. This was the Jigsaw puppet. They got him. They finally got him.

“Holy shit,” Tapp muttered as he saw the hideous pig mask beside the doll. 

They leaned over to study the evidence when they heard the faint flutter of fabric followed by a “Mmmph!”

Steven felt his heart slam out of his chest as he pointed his gun at the writhing figure underneath the cloth.

“Fuck!” Tapp was frozen as Steven hurried over, dread trailing its cold fingers down his spine.

Together, they pulled back the blanket to find - a man, gagged, and collared. 

“Hellmee!” He was sweating, trembling, and Steven quickly scanned for a way to release the man.

And then the distant groan of a motor had both cops snap their weapons to the noise.

The elevator. Shit!

It looked like their host was returning at the worst time.

“Wait, Sing.”

“What?”

 “Let’s see what he’s gonna do.”

“What?! We fucking got him.”

“We don’t know what he looks like. Let’s see what he’s gonna do,” Tapp was whispering, desperate.

“No fucking way! Fuck that, I’m gonna take him!” Sing was done with this case. He was done with the gruesome tortures, the unrecognizable corpses, and murderous psychopaths. He would shoot this fucker as soon as his elevator got to their level. His finger twitched on the trigger.

“Mmmmph!” The trapped man flailed while Tapp argued with him.

“Sing! Come on, Sing!”

As the elevator continued its motion, Steven lost his resolve. “Fuck, fine! Shit!”

In the end, he always let Tapp call the shots. This wouldn’t be different. They both threw the sheet back over the victim, the puppet, the doll house, and then they ran off to hide.

“Hellme! Plee! Huhuhuh…”

Awake already, Jeff? I need more powerful tranquilizers next time. Don’t cry. I’ve given your life a purpose .”

Steven’s chest tightened with anger. Fucking bastard . He and Tapp nodded at each other and burst through as the perp monologued.

“You’re a test subject for something greater than yourself.”

“Freeze! Police!”

“Hold it right there, don’t move!”

“Put your fucking hands in the air.”

The man was wearing a black robe, like a grim reaper, black gloved hands slowly rising, and then - 

He jerked to the side and the sound of a motor exploded with the high pitched whine of machinery.

Steven already knew shit just got real. Drills. There are fucking drills pointed at the guy’s neck. Steven jumped forward to stop them.

“Now you’ll make your choice. In twenty seconds, the life of this man will end.”

“Shut up and get down here,” Tapp ordered.

“Turn it off,” Steven had the shotgun and knew he had all the bargaining power. This was no negotiation. The man kept his face lowered, hood covering his face like a dark phantom. The grim reaper.

“SING! Stop that thing, I’m taking this bastard down.” Immediately, he tossed the shotgun over to Tapp and hurried to save the man who was screaming in his gag while the high pitched whine of the drills closed into the sides of his neck. 

Chaos gripped his throat as he tried to understand what was making this torture chair work. “How do you turn it off?!”

“Tell him how to stop it, asshole!”

“One key will unlock it.”

“Where is it?!”

“It’s in the box.”

Fuck’s sake . “What box?!” But he saw the box and tore it open, his eyes bulging when he saw that it was a fat bundle of keys, tens of them, and all looking the same. “FUCK!” He strated shakily trying to insert each key into the lock at the victim’s neck, the first two not even going in all the way. “Which key! Which key!”

“Tell him which key it is!”

“Time is running out,” the perp’s voice was low and arrogant. Mocking. It was pissing Sing off.

“Get down here right now, asshole!”

Fuck the key’s not working. The drill. Get the drill to stop. He ran over, trying to find a weak point to disconnect the drill. But it was on there, welded, bolted. It wasn’t going anywhere. The whine just kept going. Sing returned to trying each key.

“What’s more important to you, officer? Arresting me, or the life of another human being?”

This was a monster. And the keys were getting nowhere. 

“Tapp!” Sing called out to his senior, his partner. “Tapp!”

“Get down on your knees!”

“Jesus!” This man needed help. Sing needed help. “Help me out here! Tapp! There’s a lot of keys here!”

But Tapp was out of reach, grabbing Jigsaw and dragging him down to his knees. “You sick bastard,” Tapp shouted, lost in his anger.

Yes, I’m sick, officer. Sick from the disease eating away at me inside. Sick of people who don’t appreciate their blessings. Sick of those who scoff at the suffering of others .”

The drills were less than an inch from kissing the man’s skin. Fuck it. Sing took out his revolver, pointed it at the drill, shut his eyes tight and squeezed the trigger.

The explosion followed with a high pitched whine as the drilling ceased and he took that as a good sign. He went to the other, shooting it.

“Sick of it all…”

He had heard the sound of gurgling and he thought at first that Tapp had made Jigsaw make that noise. But when he looked up and saw the burst of blood and Tapp, clutching his neck, he burst forward.

“TAPP!”

Jigsaw jumped away and began running. Sing aimed and shot at his back but missed. No, no no! He shot again, rushing over to Tapp who was clutching his throat. “Tapp, shit!” He knelt down, trying to assess the injury, now regretting not telling anyone back at the precinct where they were going. Cell phone, where’s my cell phone ?

Tapp turned and pulled the fallen shotgun and thrust it into Sing, determination in his face as he made insistent noises to continue forward.

Sing wouldn’t argue with him. They couldn’t let him get away. Not when they had made it this far. “I’ll be back. I’m going to be back. Okay?”

Tapp nodded and Sing gave chase.

He ran down the stairs, keeping his weapon trained forward as he tried to see through the steam and fog. He cocked the gun and tried to remember all his training.

And then he turned the corner and saw the wisp of black and red cloth. “FREEZE! OR I’LL SHOOT!” And saw no compliance. So he took the shot.

The man collapsed forward. Sing sighed in relief. Even if he was dead, at least they got  him.

He stepped forward.

But something didn’t feel right.

He kept going, wondering why there was no blood. He wondered if the man was still alive. He brushed some cobwebs away and took another step forward.

He felt a strange pull on his clothing. The hairs on his neck stood.

He thought he heard a click and looked upward.

The explosion of four shotguns echoed throughout the warehouse.



Mark Hoffman

 

Steven Sing’s wake was scheduled for late morning. He arrived at the monastery, noticing the groups of relatives who wore all white. The women wore flowers in their ears. Arm sleeve bands of black marked the mourning. Chinese customs, Mark figured and went to join the gathering of fellow policemen, wearing their formal uniforms or suits of black. 

He half-expected to take his shoes off at the threshold of the temple but was relieved to see no one else had. An older woman was wailing, looking like Sing’s grandmother, and she was being soothed by other relatives.

Tapp looked like hell. The bandages were bound to his neck. He hadn’t shaved in days and was sitting at the front, staring at the casket. Mark approached him. “Tapp, I’m sorry.”

The man, who had once been his enemy, turned in the chair and looked at him with bloodshot eyes. “Yeah. Me too. No good,” his voice was ragged and rough, his vocal cords would likely never recover. He turned to bury his face in his hands, hunched over, shoulders shaking. “My fault.”

Seeing the old man so beaten down gave Mark a haunting of Knox. He put a comforting hand on the man’s shoulder, squeezing it.

He remembered when Knox had been in the hospital and the crushing feeling of responsibility for being the cause. 

Sing should not have died that day in John’s warehouse.

John had told him what had happened, the news just another reminder of his descent into this madness. Mark had done everything he could to resist the urge to deck John Kramer. He had simply clenched his teeth together. His jaw was still tender a few days later and he occasionally tasted blood. He hadn’t been able to eat much since..

What did Sing do, John? What did he do that was so wrong?”

“He made his choice. He chose pride and obsession over his life. I must do what is necessary to continue our work, detective. Your colleague’s death… was avoidable, if he had chosen to value the life of his partner over his obsession with catching me, perhaps he would still be alive today.”

It was a weak excuse. Mark knew this but there was little he could do, except face the facts. Sing had died too damn young. He had been one of the good cops. 

“Might as well pop some champagne, just another dirty cop off the streets is music to my ears, ” Amanda had sneered. Mark had done everything he could to refrain from backhanding the skinny bitch where she stood. She had no idea what kind of man Sing had been.

He wasn’t like most. Yet he was the first to die.

Mark knew he would not be the last.

Mark sat behind all the other cops. Allison Kerry and Eric Matthews, despite their falling out, had sat together, though there was no back rubbing or hand holding between them. 

Daniel Rigg  took a seat next to him. “Damn shame. That Jigsaw bastard will have what’s coming to him. Forensics is all over the warehouse. We’ll have him by the balls soon and he’ll answer for what he did to Sing.”

Mark nodded in agreement, letting himself escape into the fantasy that he was still one of the good ones. “Let’s fry the sonofabitch.” He wanted Jigsaw to die, as much as any one of them. Maybe even more. At least Mark had the comfort knowing that John eventually would, within a year or two. The cancer would do it’s job, at least. Every day, John’s coughing fits occurred more often and lasted longer.

Allison had turned and was looking in the far back of the church. Mark followed her gaze and his anger softened briefly before returning even hotter.

Will had entered the church but right behind her was Special Agent Lindsay Perez. And then Special Agent Peter Strahm.

The three went to the far front, Will giving him a solemn nod in acknowledgment before joining Kerry’s row. 

Mark would not have cared so much, had Strahm kept his hand off her lower back as he guided her to her seat. The way she leaned into him was subtle but clear to Mark. They were a lot closer than Will had described.

A lot can happen in a few months.

And Mark just realized how long it had been since he had last seen her. A twinge of longing struck but he blinked it away.

He tried to shift his focus to the Chinese woman who had arrived at the podium, beginning the memorial.

“Thank you all for coming.”

Yet nothing else mattered, his vision tunneling to just her and Strahm. She was looking up toward Strahm and he leaning his ear to her lips and she whispered something that would receive a reassuring rub of the shoulder and a sympathetic frown. He would whisper something back, their heads touching.

This was an intimate exchange and Mark already had dark ideas on what they had done together. He clenched his tender jaw and took in a deep breath.

“The heart cannot be involved. You must learn to suspend your anger. With a clear head, you can deliver justice. But lost in rage, you are just a slave to revenge.”

John’s words somehow broke through his fury and brought a deep calm within him. He would not let this go. But he needed to wait.

This was not the time or place to get emotional. He would compartmentalize and remember this for later.

He promised himself Strahm would pay for every touch, kiss, and whatever else he dared do with his woman two-fold. Mark promised himself it would be worth every second of waiting.

He wondered what kind of trap would be worthy of Strahm. It needed fit the crime and the person. John would have come up with something poetic in irony. Amanda would have just leaned to what inflicted more pain.

All Mark could think of was rigging an automatic turret and unloading it into Strahm’s chest. But Mark knew he needed to come up with something better.

What kind of man is Peter Strahm?

He could feel Rigg eyeballing him and back to Will but thankfully didn’t bring it up.

The ceremony was long. Incense filled the air. A metallic chime filled the room.

A young, pretty woman went to the podium, face stern. “Steven was the best older brother a girl could ask for. When we were kids and first came to this country, I had a hard time making friends. Steven would always take me to the neighbor’s house and knock on the door, asking if anyone had a girl I could play with. He always walked me to school. He was just that kind of brother.” She sobbed and wiped her tears with a tissue. Mark felt a pit in his stomach, his heart aching for Angelina. “Steven was top of his class in high school. He had his choice of colleges and internships. When he became a police officer, I asked him, why? It was so dangerous. And the pay is not good.”

Chuckles came from the region where Sing’s colleagues sat and she looked at them with a blank expression that showed she had not intended to joke. The group awkwardly quieted down.

“He said it was because he knew it was his purpose to help people.” She sniffled but Mark felt oddly proud of her for pushing through. “He said the world needed more people willing to work jobs that provide a service to others. I know Steven would have no regrets.”

One of his family let out a louder wail and finally, the woman broke down. “I hope to see you in the next life, Steven.” She stepped down, going into the arms of another young man who looked like a twin to Sing. 

Mark wondered if Sing would have preferred it this way, though. Mark knew had he been able to die in Angie’s place, he would have.

Tapp slowly made it to the podium.

The room was dead silent and Tapp cleared his throat, taking out of his jacket a folded up sheet of paper.

“Sing was a good man. And one hell of a cop. He lived,” Tapp’s voice cracked and the raised edges of the paper trembled on the podium, “he lived to serve others. He cared for his fellow man. And woman.” Tapp cleared his throat. “I take responsibility for what happened that night. And whatever it takes, I will see to it Jigsaw faces justice for what he did.” Tapp paused again, sobbing, and slammed a fist down onto the podium.

Even Hoffman could tell, bringing up Sing’s killer at his wake was not a good call. And Tapp was in no condition to provide memoriam. 

The room had gone tense and still, as though frozen in time. 

And then she stood up, as he knew she would, and went up to put a hand on Tapp’s arm, hug him, and send him down.

Will always seemed to know how to do the right thing at the right time. Mark felt his jaw relax as he watched her at the podium.

“Steven,” Will had to think for a moment, “was the one who always made a fresh pot of coffee in the morning, even though he was primarily a tea drinker.” Mark raised an eyebrow at this piece of information he never knew. She sighed. “Steven would also keep extra gloves and hats in his desk in case one of us forgot it and had a patrol scheduled in the cold. And he loved beer tasting with friends and colleagues. He was one hell of a golfer. And he always looked out for us. And, ironically, he was a fan of Billy Joel. I still remember him singing, ‘Only the Good Die Young’ while on stakeouts. He once asked me why were the lyrics so true? I didn’t know the answer until now.” She looked down, a bitter smile on her lips. “It’s because only the good put others ahead of their own safety. That’s a quality of an admirable person. Sing was a good man. He touched all our lives and made the world a little better while he was in it. Now that he’s passed there will be something missing in our hearts. But we will keep his memory alive and treasure his legacy of compassion to others. Rest in peace, Steven.”

The rest of the memorial had blended into the similar griefs.

Everyone had gone to pay their respects to the parents and siblings. The grandparents. The aunts, uncles, cousins. It was a large family and all of them wore expressions of suffering and pain.

Mark couldn’t help but regularly relocate where Will had gone, always surrounded by others and providing a comforting hand to Sing’s relatives. She seemed to be one of the more effective ones as Sing’s sister even smiled through tears and pulled Will into a hug.

Now is not the time to approach her . Mark knew better than to try.

All of this, and for what, John? Tthis should not have gone down. And yet he would continue returning to serve Jigsaw after this. 

Will’s speech echoed in his thoughts. “ The good put others ahead of their own safety.”

He knew he was no good. Because in the end, he didn’t want to go to jail. And he would have to accept the fact that more would die to ensure that.

He chose to stay back and observe while the rest of the police force had each gone to express their condolences. 

After more time, Will broke down in tears at something one of Sing’s younger relatives had said. It looked like they had been familiar with each other. Mark had not realized Will had known Sing that well. Maybe he just never paid attention. He wanted to step forward and comfort her.

But it was Strahm who took Will’s hand, provided a protective presence, and it was Strahm who would steer Will to leave.

Mark stepped forward, wanting to follow them. But not here . There were too many people and it was broad daylight. 

But it was clear his message to Strahm had gone ignored and that was unacceptable. 



Allison Kerry

 

“You’ll lead the Serial Killer Task Force,” Grissom announced when she had gone to his office that morning.

“What about Tapp?”

Grissom let out a throaty scoff. “Tapp is out.”

She blinked, not registering. “On leave?”

“Permanently. He’s being forced to retire.”

“Grissom, it’s Tapp.”

“I know damn well who it is,” her supervisor glared up at her, looking exhausted. “He violated protocol, broke in without a warrant, and got Sing killed. And he’s been unhinged since. I’m not happy making this call, but it needed to be done. He has been in long enough for his pension. We’ll still give it to him. But he’s no longer got a badge or a gun.”

“Yeah, right,” Allison put a hand on her hip. “You think you’ll stop him?”

“Doesn’t matter what I think he’ll do, I just know he’s not going to stain our reputation with whatever he does.”

“Since when did you give a damn about reputation?”

“Since the mayor and the media have been up my ass about catching this goddamn Jigsaw Killer.” Grissom slammed his fist on the desk. “So it’s on you, Kerry. Catch him. I want results, ASAP.” She left the office before Grissom threw a chair.

She had never seen Grissom so worked up. But she understood.

Everyone had thought the world of Steven Sing.

He used to swing by my office every morning, often to tease her on the latest football updates. She was a Ravens fan and he a dirty Steelers fan.

Her eyes watered at the realization there would be no more shit talking sports ever again. It would be too painful. Damn it, Sing.

She went to her office, sighing and needing to talk to someone for comfort.

She took her phone and dialed.

“Hey, Ally,” Lindsay’s voice always fixed whatever bad mood plagued her.

“Linds,” Allison bit her lip, grasping for something to say. “Just got assigned to take Tapp’s place.”

“Ah, business call then,” she could practically hear her rueful smile. “I figured Tapp would have been at least put on admin leave. Jigsaw’s been front page for weeks now. You need FBI?”

“Yeah. Whatever you can spare our way.”

“Well, I’ll need to run it by my supervisor. Not sure if I can fly up there, budget cuts screwing everybody. But if you need to use our databases, I’ll be sure to run whatever prints, DNA, or whatever through. Strahm won’t be much help, by the way. He’s taken leave. He’s accumulated so many PTO days, he won’t be back in months.”

“Yeah, I know Will’s gone about the same time. Those love birds.”

“Tell me about it. Every time I see them it’s like watching a pair of newlyweds. Well, I got to go. Talk to you later, Ally.”

“Take care, hon.”

Allison knew she would need to get details from Tapp. Looking at her watch, figuring, hell it was five o’clock somewhere, she grabbed her jacket and left work to the nearest liquor store.

She knew Tapp was partial to Hennessy, figuring a permanent retirement warranted the pricey purchase. 

She had visited Tapp’s apartment once, back when he went through his divorce and needed help moving into it. She noted there was a warning for late rent stuck to his door and her alarm bells began to go off. She knocked, firm.

“Tapp, it’s Kerry. Open up, old man, I’ve got a gift for you.”

She counted to ten and pounded the door again. She began to feel antsy. Her immediate thought was Tapp had done something catastrophic to himself and she was about to call in a wellness check on him when the door opened.

“Yeah?” Gravelly voice, like sandpaper on slate. Tapp was in a bathrobe and stale PJs, looking worse than back at Sing’s memorial service. 

She held out the brown bag. “I’m sorry to hear about your retirement.”

He looked at her gift and stepped aside, waving her in. 

The place looked like it was at the beginning stage of being uncared for. Tapp was normally a neat, simple guy. But the stacks of pizza boxes and empty beer bottles were expected. The gun resting on the kitchen counter didn’t phase her at all either.

“I hope you’re the one stepping into the Jigsaw case, then.”

She nodded, grimacing, not wanting to bring that up. “Yeah.”

“Good. I told Grissom it better be you if he knew what was good for him.” 

When she stepped into the living room her heart sank. The walls were littered with images. Pictures, red string, and newspaper clippings. It looked like the work of an insane person. And he had begun to write in permanent marker shorthand notes on the bare walls. That’ll piss off his landlord.

“What’s this, Tapp?” 

He flicked his fingers in a ‘come hither’ gesture and she handed him the bottle. He looked at it, letting out a whistle and a wide grin. “You’re a doll, Kerry. Come on, lemme pour you a drink.”

“Sure.” She took a seat at the bar stool underneath his island counter, waiting as he scrubbed and rinsed out two shot glasses that had been left beside the sink. 

Things were going well, so far,

She looked around, taking in the stack of unopened mail with the bold red stamps of OVERDUE on the envelopes next to the blackened cluster of bananas that looked several weeks old.

“You should keep your eyes on that doctor,” Tapp handed her a drink.

She raised an eyebrow. “Gordon?”

“Yeah. It’s him. Has to be.”

“He has an alibi.”

“Could have paid the girl off. Or we got the time frame wrong.”

But they had established when the victims were missing and where they likely were taken. Gordon’s alibi checked out. Solid. 

“Did you see Gordon, that night?”

Tapp’s glittering eyes dimmed and he bowed his head. “Couldn’t get a good look at his face. Just saw a glimpse of his neck. White guy. Old enough to have some sag in the neck. That’s all. But I know it’s him. And I can help catch him. I may be off the force but I’m still a good pair of hands.”

She waited for him to take the first drink and then she followed, wincing at the burning sweetness of the brandy.

“Tapp,” she bit her lip and decided to risk it, “I think you should consider hitting the brakes.”

“Hm?” The warmth of his smile had cooled. “Is that so?”

“Tapp, I’m here as a friend. Of you and Sing.”

Tapp had turned away, shame in his grimace, shoulders raised. She pressed on.

“Tapp, you can’t be involved in this case anymore. It’s against the rules.”

“Damn it, since when did you care about the damn rules?”

She looked down at her fingers clutching the shot class and looked up at him with new resolve. True, she hadn’t always been the best example. But Sing had cared about the rules. And once, Tapp had as well. Now that the responsibility of catching Jigsaw was all on her, she had to be a better cop. For Sing and Tap and everyone else who’s suffered, I can’t let it all be in vain. “You broke in without a warrant. No back up. It’s clear you want to catch him. I do too. But you have to step back and let the rest of us take it.”

“I can help.”

“No,” she shook her head, just now realizing that she too blamed Tapp for what happened to Sing, and she looked at this man she had always respected and now saw him as a haggard old shell that wouldn’t let things go. Grissom made the right call. Tapp needed to retire. “I’m sorry, Tapp, but it’s time to step back. If not for me, then for Sing.”

“You - you don’t know what Sing would have wanted. None of you knew him, not like me.”

“That may be but I’m sure Sing would want you to not get in any more trouble than you are already.”

He scoffed and turned. “Maybe you should go, Kerry. But know that I’ll stop Jigsaw, one way or the other. With or without your help. You all think Gordon’s not involved. But he is.”

She knew they were both grieving, in their own way. But she felt anger, then, hot and in control of her tongue. “You seriously think you can take this all on by yourself? You never listen, Tapp. Not to me or Sing. And that’s what’s getting us all killed.”

She stormed out, slamming the door behind her, hot tears burning her cheeks.

 

Notes:

A/N: RIP Sing, you were one of the good ones.

Chapter 48: Peri-SAW: Angry and Apathetic

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Adam Faulkner-Stanheight

 

Fucking punk-ass vegan bitch . Adam reminisced his latest romantic failure, lit a cigarette, wondering when the hell his next client would arrive. It was cold as fuck and he was starving. He only had two dollars and fifteen cents to his name and rent had been due yesterday.

“You the photographer?”

“About fucking time,” Adam turned, seeing the man with the bandage over his throat. “Joe said you needed a tail with lights. Got the cash?”

“Yeah. Half now, half after I get my photos.” Bob, that was his name, supposedly. Adam didn’t ask questions. He never cared enough to. He only cared about the thick envelope full of bills and he took it and eagerly counted the cash. Eight hundred, all there. It’s pay day, baby!

A folded up piece of notebook paper with the guy’s home and work addresses were included.

“All right. I’ll get your pics. See you next week, here, same place.”

“Be careful. This man’s dangerous.”

Adam raised an eyebrow. He hadn’t signed up for playing James Bond here. But he needed the money. “Alright. Noted.”

He left ‘Bob’ and walked back to his apartment to get his camera. It was midday Monday, and doctors liked to work on Mondays. It was time for a trip to the hospital.

 

First, he needed to lay eyes on the actual target. Doctor Gordon was just a name and if Adam started taking the wrong pictures of the wrong guy, there went his rent money. His stomach growled as he leaned against the hospital wall just outside of the Oncology wing, pretending he was someone waiting for a patient, just some son of a rich old geezer who had one too many cigars and top shelf scotch and was now suffering liver failure - but don’t worry, he’s got two donors lined up to keep his overpriced dinosaur ass walking this earth to step on all us poor little people…

Adam had to remember himself and return to his actual job. He often came up with stories for his targets. He didn’t give a damn about them, not really, but he sure got bored with all the stake outs. 

And when he couldn’t smoke, it made his mind get all disorganized and twisted. Fucking hospitals and their no smoking policies.

Thankfully none of the nurses paid him any mind. They were all busy, running around, caring for the sick who had health insurance.

He perked up and his thoughts silenced when out of the double doors a tall blond man walked by, white lab coat whipped by the speed, an entourage of younger looking doctors shadowing him. 

“Doctor Gordon,” an attractive Asian woman was at his side, looking up at him with a big smile, “For renal medullary carcinoma, what is needed to regulate the hypoxic stress response in the sickle cell trait?”

So this was Gordon? He looked like a DILF larping Grey’s Anatomy.

Ah, but those were the ones with the wildest kinks. All that religious repression and daddy issues.

Adam quickly turned to keep his back to the man and decided now was the time to leave. He knew who he would need to keep through his lens now.

He sighed and decided to walk around, see if he could score on a free meal. He’d need to find out when Gordon got off work. 

If only it wasn’t so damn cold outside.



Amanda Young

 

Everything she was, was because of John.

For months she took in every lesson he gave and tried to learn just a fraction of the brilliance he shared to her. He had given her the tools to thrive and thrive she did.

She could now calculate torque with gear ratios, knew the amount of tension required to dislocate - but not tear out - an average male’s arm. She knew how to predict one game’s time based on the body weight of their target to make sure the game would be fair when they experienced blood loss to fill up a beaker on a pressure sensor. And more importantly, she now knew that everything she experienced would soon be shared with others who were in dire need. 

She believed John and what he represented.

She was currently sketching a design for her own trap - something to symbolize what they were. It would rip a person’s ribs outwards, spreading them like angel’s wings, and she hoped John would be pleased when she showed it to him. They were angels of death, deliverers of truth.

In the next room she heard coughing and jumped to her feet. These days, John suffered terrible coughing fits that wouldn’t stop. She walked in on her master hunched over the workbench, hand over his mouth, hacking.

“John, we should get you some oxygen.”

“No. Not yet.” 

She knew he was putting this off, not for any practical reason but pride.

He didn’t want to accept that he was dying, even now.

He had lost weight but still was able to walk around. But the tumor in his brain, it was likely growing still.

Amanda wished there was something more she could do for him. Anything.

But all she could do was serve as his apprentice, learn as much as possible.

Because one day, she would have to do this alone.

“Amanda, soon we will need to begin our next game.”

“I’m ready, John.”

He looked up at her, nodding. “I will retrieve Doctor Gordon. And you will need to acquire Adam. Will you need the detective’s help?”

She wrinkled her nose and had a sour taste in her mouth. “No. I’ve got this on my own. Don’t bother with the oaf, Adam looked light enough.”

John nodded and went to leave. Amanda would have suggested Mark go with him - to make sure he was fine - but she didn’t trust Mark Hoffman as far as she could throw him. Which was not far. 

 

Adam Faulkner-Stanheight lived in the southside of the city, a worn down building with a broken elevator and smelled like mold. Not the worst she’d seen and still miles better than where she came from, but she felt she could sense the soul of a person by the environment they lived in.

She waited at a crooked table by the mail boxes, planning to play it cool when Adam finally left to go do his voyeuristic freelance work, as she had seen him do many times before.

Like clockwork, he came downstairs a quarter after seven, his camera slung around his neck. She tried to keep her had down and walk by him.

“Really rockstar.” He was looking right at her, the faintest passing smile on his lips.

She paused, feeling his attention, nervously looking behind her in hopes he had been referring to someone else. She did the best thing she could do, which was awkwardly walk away.

“Sorry, your hair. It’s very… rockstar. I really like it.”

She had made it to the stairs but now, she had to look at him. She waited for him to continue. He had no idea. So why was he talking to her? She went to turn away when he didn’t speak again.

But then he did.

“Speaking of rockstar, I’ve been instructed to hand these out. They don’t completely suck as far as buddy bands go.” He held out a folded up poster, some underground punk band it looked like, and she was beginning to feel curiosity uncoil in her chest.

Why was he so nice to her? This wasn’t making things easier.

“Do you live here?”

He had an earnestness about him that made her sad. “Just visiting.” She turned to leave.

“I’ll see you there!”

This was not the personality she was expecting from him. He liked her, more than the other people he walked by every day.

She had cut her hair, hoping it would have made it easier to work for John. But now, she regretted the decision.

“Look - I’m not gonna see you there, am I?”

Despite what she needed to do, she felt herself liking him. “Probably not.” She forced a smile, hoping he would leave.

“Can I take your picture?”

She couldn’t help but be amused and let it show. She didn’t laugh but she was close to. And nodded. She would be taking his camera, later, so it didn’t matter.

“Hold on.” He aimed his lens and the flash of the camera blinded her temporarily. 

“Thanks. See you - later.” 

He had a sweetness about him that Amanda forgot existed in people. She continued up the stairs and looked behind her, Adam having turned away to greet some neighbors who were trying to get home.

“Ladies! Want to go to a show tonight? Only five bucks!” He mouthed to her as he left, “they’ll be there,” humor in his eye.

She smiled back and lost sight of him.

She turned and walked up the stairs, knowing what door she needed to lockpick. Her backpack felt heavy, even though the only things inside were robes, the pig mask, several syringes, and a gun. 

Getting in his apartment was easy enough. 

The place was sparse and smelled of sharp, acidic chemicals. She paused to see a door with red light glowing around the cracks. His red room. 

She knew better than to disturb it, not wanting Adam to catch on that someone was in his house when he got home. 

She donned the robe and pig mask and hid in the closet and waited.

It would be many long hours before he came back. 

While she waited, she wondered what Adam’s friend’s band would have sounded like. But she pushed it away as a sense of regret washed over her. No. She had to be strong. John needed to test him. He was worthy to be saved.

She knew this would work out. Maybe, if Adam won the game, he would be taken in by John like her.

This gave her renewed resolve and she eagerly waited for Adam to come home.



Peter Strahm

 

He was enjoying having a woman in the house.

Will was also an early riser and the two of them would start off their morning routines meeting in the kitchen for coffee. She would be dressed in running gear and he would go to his gym to lift weights or swim. Come back. Have breakfast. Begin work. 

It felt like they were a couple on a vacation. He was in heaven.

Will had a high libido and he was more than happy to accommodate her needs. 

Every morning he woke to her face in his bed, he knew he wanted to that for the rest of his life.

“Hi, sir, this is Detective Wilhelmina Maddox, I called yesterday inquiring on historical documents related to a crime back in eighty-one.” Will was on the phone, the two of them going over the same pictures of her childhood, the same names of witnesses or persons of interest who were either dead or in retirement homes now, and again, trying to see if they had missed something.

His study was covered with carefully arranged documents and a corkboard was hanging to track the timeline. Will was sitting cross-legged on the carpet, cell to ear, trying to look up a license plate number.

He couldn’t help but admire the view, her lowrise yoga pants letting him appreciate the soft skin as her shirt rode up.

“Yes, sir, it is,” she went on her knees and reached over for a sheet of paper, “a red Honda Civic, EZ9738. Yes, back in eighty-one. Thanks. Yes, please call me back if you have any record found.” She hung up and sighed, turning to him.

“Any luck?” He handed a fresh cup of coffee to her.

“No. We’re getting nowhere, Peter.” She sounded exasperated as she took a loud sip.

He knew now was the time to bring it up. “Well, I’ve got good news.” He loved the way she lit up. “Prints are back. We have a match.”

“Finally! With who?” She jumped to her feet, bouncing, looking ready to burst.

“Philip Rhodes.”

“Do we have a location?”

“San Diego. He’s been locked up for the past five years.”

“What are we waiting for?” She got to her feet, phone in hand, eager and hungry.

He smiled but was swallowing back the bitter taste of melancholy. Things had just started feeling wonderful. 

But he couldn’t deny the hope in her eye and the glow on her face being beautiful to see. 

“Yes, hello?” Will had dialed the phone again. “Can I get the next flight to San Diego? From the DC area or Richmond. Whichever is faster.” She looked at him, grinning.

This wasn’t the end of things. It was only the beginning.

Peter decided then, that when they closed this case, he would marry her.



John Kramer

 

The drug relaxed him and made him sink into the floor.. The dark was filled with only the distant breathing of the two men echo off the bathroom. The room was cold and damp but thankfully John had gotten used to the smell of rot, blood, and excrement that clung to the tiles like mold.

In the direction where Doctor Gordon lay, the rustle of clothing followed by his distant confused groans brought John’s focus to sharpen. And so, the game begins.

“Hello?” He called out gently, at first. The rattle of chains. The grunt of surprise. More jingling of metal. “Hello?! Help!”

John’s heart was chemically slowed but he could feel his blood quicken slightly despite it. He kept himself still.

Gordon had stopped trying to pull the chains. He was breathing, loud and deliberate, likely forcing himself to calm down. An intelligent man, always in control.

Only now, it must have been terrible for him, to find himself completely out of control. The scrape and scuffle of a man trying to orient himself in pitch black and the defeated sigh were the last thing before another long period of silence.

And then, on the other side of the room, the sound of water splashing, coughing, sputtering, and then the distinct whoosh of the bathtub plunger being removed with the gurgle of water draining had John holding back a tsk of disappointment.

The key was in the bathtub. And Adam, it seemed, unsurprisingly, was too panicked to notice it. It was likely going to slip down the drain. The boy was brash and driven by his emotions. A lost cause.

More splashing. Coughing. “Help! Someone help me!”

Gordon moved.

“Is someone there? Hey! Shit, I’m probably dead.”

“You’re not dead.” 

“Who’s that?” 

“No point in yelling, I already tried it.”

“Turn on the lights!”

“I would if I could.”

“What the fuck is going on! What is going on? Where am I?”

“I don’t know yet.”

“What is that smell?!”

“Shh! Hang on a second, I think I found something.”

John could see the lights through his eyelids but he resisted the urge to wince. 

“Holy shit!” The sound of Adam gagging followed by his screams filled the bathroom. “HEEEELP!”

Adam had gone into full panic.

“No one can hear you,” Gordon sounded defeated. 

This was the Doctor Gordon John knew. A man resigned to his fate. A man who did not realize just how much he was turning his back on, to appease his more immediate urges. John hoped after all of this, he would make the man see the error of his ways.

If Gordon survived, this would prove useful to John in the future. Having a medical doctor who would aid him had boundless opportunity and potential. So John was rooting for him, despite his sins.

“What the fuck is this!”

“Calm down, just calm down. Are you hurt?”

“I don’t know - yeah!”

“What’s our name?”

“My name is Very Fucking Confused, what’s your name?! What’s going on here!”

Gordon sounded annoyed. “My name is Lawrence Gordon, I’m a doctor. I just woke up here, just like you.”

John could visualize every moment. From Adam trying to force his foot through the chains with a grunt to Gordon rolling his eyes and become even more aggravated by Adam’s juvenile behavior.

“Recognize him?”

“No.”

“Well, do you have any idea how you got here?”

“No.”

“What was the last thing you remember?”

“Nothing. I went to bed in my shithole apartment and woke up in an actual shithole. So what about you, huh?”

“Well, there’s… there’s not much to tell, really. I was on my way home from work and uh, I don’t remember anything else.”

“First dead body I’ve ever seen. Look different in real life. They don’t move.”

“From the looks of these chains, someone didn’t want us to go very far either.”

“Can you see any scars?”

“What?”

“This is what they do man, they kidnap you and drug you and before you know it, you’re in a bathtub and your kidneys are on eBay.”

John could already tell this would be an amusing game, at least.

“No one has taken your kidneys,” Gordon’s voice held disdain. John sympathized, Adam would not have been his preferred cell mate either.

“How can you tell from way over there?”

“Because you’d either be in terrible agony or you’d be dead by now. Trust me.”

“What are you, a surgeon?”

“Yeah.” Gordon sighed. “So you gonna tell me your name, or what?”

“Adam.”

They continued to exchange pleasantries. It was both fascinating and mundane how the two interacted. Never would their paths have crossed if not for John. Two completely different universes, colliding.

“Use your shirt.”

They had finally found their tapes and needed the cassette player in his hand. He felt the damp slap of the fabric on his arm and the eventual pull of the device from his fingers.

And then he heard his own voice. “Rise and shine, Adam. You’re probably wondering where you are. I’ll tell you where you might be. You might be in the room that you die in. Up until now, you simply sat in the shadows, watching others live out their lives. But what do voyeurs see when they look into the mirror? Now, I see you as a strange mix of someone angry and yet apathetic. But mostly just pathetic. So are you going to watch yourself die today, Adam? Or do something about it?”

“I don’t get it.”

Of course you don’t. 

“Throw me the player.”

“No, you throw me your tape.”

More back and forth. Griping. Adam just complained, but Gordon kept his calm until he finally conceded to Adam.

“Doctor Gordon, this is your wake up call. Every day of your life, you have given people the news that they are going to die soon. Now you will be the cause of death. Your aim in this game is to kill Adam. You have until six on the clock to do it. There’s a man in the room with you. When there’s that much poison in your blood the only thing left to do is shoot yourself.” John heard himself cough on the tape. “There are ways to win this hidden all around you. Just remember, ‘x’ marks the spot for the treasure. If you do not kill Adam by six, then Alison and Diana will die, Doctor Gordon. And I’ll leave you in this room to rot. Let the game begin.”



Mark Hoffman

 

He entered the break room, needing a cup of coffee. Seeing Kerry and Matthews, clearly in the midst of an argument, he stopped in the doorway and immediately turned to leave.

“Hoffman,” Matthews called out, “hang on.”

Kerry had her hands on her hips, biting her lip, looking furious. 

Matthews took out a cigarette. “I need to get out of here. You have lunch yet?” 

“I can eat.”

“Good, you drive, I’ll pay. But keep it cheap.”

“Larry’s, then.”

The city was gray and dark. A light rain kept everything wet and cold. Being a Tuesday, the two of them were the only ones in the bar that early afternoon. But Mark was in a decent mood. He got this way, now, when there was a game actively happening. He couldn’t remember the last time he felt so alive, and powerful. He checked his watch, wondering who would be the survivor, if any would. He’d look at the tapes, later.

He wondered about the one subject, Zep. He didn’t understand why John had chosen him to be included in the game. The guy seemed like he valued his life. “Inferiority Complex,” John had explained, yet didn’t as he usually did. But Mark knew better than to argue. He had knocked the guy out when he got home from work, injected him with the poison, left the envelope on his bedside table, and tucked him into his bed with an alarm at exactly 2:30 p.m., per John’s instructions.

The bathroom trap was the most elaborate puzzle John had conjured up yet. Hell, the man made a damn diorama for it. Mark’s money was on the doctor surviving.

“She’s dead to me,” Matthews grumbled and Mark pretended to be interested in this discussion.

“Kerry?”

“We’ve been over for a while now. She was the one who ended everything. She ruined my marriage. Then she went and cut me off, leaving me in my shitty apartment paying alimony. My son hates me, now that he thinks he’s some bigshot criminal. Teenagers. Kid’s been busted for shoplifting, not grand theft auto. I had to bail him out and all he does is bitch about how I abandoned him. If he only knew how much money I pay to his mother, he’d shut his trap.” Matthews took another puff and waved at Larry to bring him another beer.

Mark kept his thoughts to himself. You cheated on your wife, Matthews. You did this to yourself. Lately, Matthews was getting on his nerves. He was always whining. Taking everything he has for granted. Mark was beginning to sound like John and he wasn’t sure if it was a bad thing anymore.

Everyone around Mark were beginning to look like lost souls, in need of a rude awakening. 

“You know what that bitch wanted from me?” Matthews turned, watching him in the corner of his eye. “To join the Serial Killer Task Force. Fuck that.”

Mark blinked. He didn’t like how hard Kerry was going, now that she was in charge of the Jigsaw investigation. So far, the task force included Fisk, Kerry, and himself. Budget cuts and cops transferring to other departments en masse after Jigsaw demonstrated he wasn’t afraid to kill them had been good for Mark’s anonymity. It was likely Jigsaw would go free, at least for the time being. He would possibly join the ranks of the few notorious but elusive. Zodiac. Golden State. With John pulling the strings, Mark knew it was possible. Mark still needed an out - a way to escape and return to his life. 

For now, Mark was confident John would ensure he would elude the police, at least as long as he was living and had his mental faculties. But when the cancer finally won, it would be just him and Amanda. 

Mark already knew it was likely he’d need to kill Amanda Young if he wanted his secret safe. 

 

“I want nothing to do with Jigsaw. All I got left is the skin on my back. I don’t want to go like Sing, my head blown off. Or Tapp, off his rocker,” Matthews muttered, watching the TVs above the bar.

Mark silently agreed. So long as everyone kept their distance from getting in John’s way, no one else should get hurt. “You don’t have to worry, I’ll get Kerry off your back.”

“No need, I told her to piss off. She won’t be coming back for my help anytime soon.”

You sure about that? Mark had a sinking suspicion that Kerry was going to do everything she could to take Jigsaw down. She was like Will. A workaholic who was good at her job. And catching Jigsaw was now that job.

“Yeah. Hopefully, I don’t ever get on Jigsaw’s shitlist, maybe I’ll be able to see retirement and just go live in an van down by the river. Got nothing else going for me.”

Matthews had an uncanny talent of taking Mark’s already standard glum mood and making him feel downright sad. 

“Shit, at last shoot for an RV.”

“Yeah, and a harem of Swedish supermodels. Why not? Shoot for the moon, eh, Hoffman?”

“That’s the spirit.”

 

Amanda Young

 

Amanda was still developing her first game. It would be hers. To design, to choose who would participate, everything. John trusted her with this and she needed it to be done right.

She already knew who would be the star of the show. The very cop who put her on this path. Who, ironically, was the cause of her meeting John.

Eric Matthews . The corrupt bastard that framed her. 

She would have added Hoffman too, if he wasn’t off limits. Despite how much she tried to convince John he was bad news, John refused to back down.

“Detective Hoffman will be true to our cause. He is an ally. He will help but he will not play your game, Amanda.”

“Why’s he untested?”

“He will face his test in due time. At my discretion. He is not yours to test, Amanda.”

She trusted John would be sure Mark Hoffman would receive his test. She had to believe he would take care of it. 

But at least Matthews was hers.

And she would make sure that he would face what he had done, with as many people as possible.

John encouraged her to think big. And the one thing she could do to really scare the piss out of Matthews would be either putting him in a room full of people he framed and imprisoned. Or someone he cared about. She wasn’t sure how John would feel about using Matthews’ kid. He was fourteen. And even though he was that bastard’s flesh and blood, Amanda bore no hard feelings for him. It wasn’t his fault his old man was a piece of work. 

Her father was a piece of trash, too.

When the game would go down, Amanda would be there, to make sure the rules would be followed. She could make sure the boy wouldn’t get hurt. 

John would say to try to empathize with the subject. To walk in their shoes. She hated the idea of trying to pretend she was Eric Matthews but she admitted it was helpful. She was following him, these days, seeing that he liked to smoke a lot. Whenever he answered teh phone, he looked bitter and angry. He looked bitter all the time. It made Amanda happy, at least, to know what a miserable life he was living.

Matthews didn’t care about himself. She doubted he’d have incentive to fight for his life if he was in the trap. 

Hoffman had warned them that it was likely some detective named Allison Kerry, who would be capable of catching the Jigsaw Killer. And John and him conspired on ways to remain undetected by the police. Apparently, Kerry and Matthews had history. And if Matthews got involved, Hoffman suggested it would rattle Kerry and make her slip up. 

It was a maze, trying to understand John’s grand designs. She was barely keeping up with the logistics for a house that poisoned everyone inside. She would have to act like she was stuck, like them, and John would watch from the cameras. 

As she stared down at the floor plans to the house that John was currently underneath for the game with the doctor and Adam, her thoughts returned to the night she had kidnapped him.

“Can I take your picture?”

She sighed. Thinking on it was pointless. He’d either pass or fail. Live or die. Those were the rules. 

She just hoped Adam had what it takes to survive. 

The door creaked as it slid open. Amanda turned, seeing Hoffman enter the warehouse. She turned to pointedly ignore him. 

“Any word from John?”

“Seeing as it’s only been eight hours, and John had already explained it was timed for twenty-four hours, you tell me, Detective.” She turned to him, a sneer on her mouth.

Hoffman watched her, cool and calm. “I’m asking, in case something went wrong and John needs our help.”

She scoffed. As if he wanted to help John. She knew he was there because John was blackmailing him. “He’s fine. Zep has been doing his part, calling in every hour.” She held up the burner phone, her lifeline to John for the time being, and Zep the narrator as he relayed what he saw on the surveillance screens. “They found the saws. They found the box. But no one’s dead yet.”

Hoffman nodded. “I just came by to see how things were. If John needs me, you know how to find me.” He turned to leave and Amanda was thrilled.

He always put her in a sour mood. Every time she saw his stupid face with his fat lips and dumb expression, she wanted to punch him in the face. 

If she could find a way to really fuck with him, it would be one of the few joys in her life. 

The phone rang. She picked it up, not saying a word, waiting.

“Adam pretended to smoke a poisoned cigarette. It looks like he got electrocuted. They were trying to fool us.” Then, a cough. “When can I get the antidote? Please.”

Amanda pressed her mouth tight and hung up, refusing to feel guilty. John chose Zep for a reason. He didn’t appreciate life, like she had. But John could save him, so long as he followed the rules.

The rules. Follow the rules. John knows best.

Yet Amanda couldn’t help but feel herself rooting, deep in her heart, for Adam to make it. Of all the people to survive, please let it be him.

She imagined him joining John and her. Maybe he would be a part of what they were. It was a hope that warmed her and gave her comfort as she continued to her sketches.

 

Notes:

A/N: What a wild world we live in. Work has me by the throat and I always feel bad when these chapters take longer to come out. Hopefully I'll get out of this slump soon. Lately, been trying to learn to not let my real-life job take over, that it's not my entire life, but it gets hard sometimes. I like what I do for a living but I also really like writing fics too! TT_TT I hope you enjoy this chapter!

Chapter 49: Peri-SAW: Tapp to the Entity

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

 

“Why am I not needed for the next game?”

He knew the underlying hypocrisy in his taking offense in being left out. He had maintained a begrudging attitude throughout his tenure since he started as John’s apprentice. But he had grown to expect at least the decency of being trusted to be involved in every aspect of John’s work. Was he not the very first of John’s helpers? The one who served John from the very beginning? Being sidelined, and replaced by that woman of all people, was downright insulting.

“You have work to do here, keeping watch over the warehouse. The rack needs greasing. The glass coffin needs to be filled. We also need more supplies, the list is on the refrigerator.”

Mark narrowed his eyes and pulled his mouth back in a sneer. He wanted to protest. John was looking at him with cool indifference.

“Are these tasks beneath you, Mark?” John already seemed to have expected Mark’s anger and responded with a calculated smile. “Normally, you take all my orders with the same stoicism, regardless of what they were.”

“Amanda’s not someone you can count on. She’ll slip. It’s putting you at risk.”

The aging blue eyes softened, as if he understood. “She will learn. As you have. As you still are .”

“You’re implying I’m still a novice.”

“No. You are not a novice. But you are still headstrong. You are still allowing your heart to be involved. I’ve told you from the very beginning that the heart cannot be involved. There can be no emotion. You must disengage from personal feelings with this work, Mark.”

Mark clenched his jaw, trying to calm himself down. He had a good handle on his temper. A damn good handle on it. But for John, it wasn’t enough. It was never enough. 

This damn feeling.

In the back of his mind, shoved deep - yet still there, padding its scabby fingertips under his skull, was the ugly nostalgia that conjured memories of his father.

He would never tell him, never admit it out loud, but John reminded him so much of him. The way he would seem to always know more - the way he would always have this shadow of disappointment in his gaze that pierced through Mark’s confidence. And the brilliance - the uncanny instinct of looking at a machine or gadget and simply knowing the best way to manipulate it to perform what he needed it to - It made Mark feel as though a kid again, helping his old man out with changing the oil or being the tool gopher when the plumbing went out. Desperately trying to prove to him that he could help. That he knew what he was doing.

It’s just like that.

“You should be helping Amanda, not seeing her as your enemy.”

Mark withheld a scoff. He would never find anything redeemable about that junkie. 

“Do my methods show promise, Mark? Is that why you want to be more involved?”

How the hell does he always seem to hit the nail on the head, every time? “ Can’t deny the statistics. This past year we’ve seen the biggest drop in violent crimes since the sixties.” His inbox tower was half the size it normally was. He couldn’t remember the last time the first floor had every desk manned with well rested, groomed, and practically whistling cops. He had seen the holding cells only housing the random wino. Grissom even smiled - in spite of the fact the city was being terrorized by a single vigilante. 

The Metropolitan Police Department, despite struggling to catch Jigsaw, were overall in a better place now that all the scum of the city hid and stayed well behaved in hopes of not capturing Jigsaw’s attentions.

“Do you find this work goes hand-in-hand with your profession, Detective?”

Mark had begun to blur the lines of separation between his honorable, real life and this shadowy world. He had grown more accustom to each late night venture through the rusted remains of the Gideon Meatpacking Plant. He practically craved it when he was stuck in his office, filing reports or giving Kerry another fake lead to chase down. A part of him felt the twist of triumph when he watched her get the reinvigorated spark in her eye as she steeled herself.

“We’ll catch him, this time, Hoffman. I can feel it.”

If she only knew.

He should have felt guilt but he could only detect the exhilaration from pulling everyone’s strings. They were so blind. How could they not see what was right in front of him?

Maybe they were just that good.

And they were just shit.

He had long ago lost that fire he still saw in his coworkers. It used to bother him, that numbness and coldness that had come when Angie was killed and Seth Baxter walked free. Catching criminals had never felt the same after that. It always felt as though he was just pretending to stop the evil in the world, playing a sick charade where he would throw the perp in prison to watch as the justice system would open the doors wide open with a grin.

You’re free to go, have a nice day.

Mark no longer felt fulfilled with being a cop. 

Now, he lived for the only true solution to end crime.

He lived for trap building. He always thought about the newest design he wanted to create. He thought of the most ironic and poetic torments he would inflict on his subjects - all to force them to dwell deep into what they had done and come face to face with their true selves. Their hideous, evil selves.

He enjoyed hunting these societal leeches. To him, it was euphoric. It was almost as good as sex.

Almost.

To him, stalking a future test subject was thrilling, like foreplay. There was something empowering about knowing the person would soon be in his grasp, helpless and at his mercy, and that anticipation for pleasure had replaced his nightly whisky binges and self-pity parties.

He found his control again, and it was because of John. John had shown him how to reclaim his life. John had given him his purpose back. John had restored his control. Control of those who hurt others. Control of who would face justice.

“For I see passion in you now, Mark. Perhaps I will consider your involvement in the next few games. There will be plenty more soon.”

There was not quite a passion for John’s method, but Mark had grown to respect it. Even see a need for it. And Mark had given too much of himself, sacrificed so much, to see it handed over to some junkie trash. If Amanda wore Jigsaw’s mantle, the reputation John and Mark had carefully cultivated in striking fear in those who dared tried to harm others would be tarnished. 

“She’s a loose cannon.”

“And you are an oak. Amanda is only beginning to get her feet wet. But in the end,we are all in this together. You will need Amanda as much as she will need you.”

“I doubt that. And what about you? Who do you need?”

John smiled. “Time.” The answer hung in the air, suffocating the conversation. Mark bowed his head, feeling like an asshole. John’s cancer always smacked Mark when he least expected it, often forgetting that he was doomed. But John was forgiving, placing a hand on his shoulder. “Take this as a chance for a break.”

“I’ll check my phone every day. You know I don’t keep it on all the time, though.”

“A wise decision. No, go about your business, detective.”

“John?” A woman’s voice - not the piteous muffle of Amanda but more authoritative, mature.  Mark turned to see Jill Tuck, looking wide eyed at the two men, confused, moving the large fabric bag in both her hands in front of her. She cocked her head to the side. “Aren’t you that Detective? What are you doing here?” 

“Do not fear, Jill, he knows. He is on our side.”

Her eyes flashed to John. “Oh. How are you feeling?” She stepped forward, unzipping her bag and pulling out the stethoscope. She was already touching John’s face, prodding his lymph nodes. 

“Jill. You know how I feel about your visits.” John did not push the woman away, instead simply watching her with a softer expression. 

Mark chose to walk away, not one for trying to get involved and taking the obvious hint that Jill had no intention to acknowledge him. But when he left the room and went to turn the corner, he kept himself within hearing distance, the curiosity too strong to resist.

“Is he…?”

“If you are here to simply check on me, then please proceed. But I will have no discussion on my current business. I’m not happy you’re here.”

“Well, someone’s got to check on you. When was the last time you saw a doctor?”

“That is my business.”

“Damn it, John, don’t be like that. I’m here. Let me help.”

“You are not just here to help. So say what you came here to say.”

“Fine. Art called, he’s still trying to get you to sell.”

“Well he can wait when I’m dead and the estate distributes what was mine. You’ll soon have control of my assets. Then you can sell to your new lover as much of my possessions as you’d like.”

“John, please.”

“I think you’ve seen enough. Now please get out.”

Mark wouldn’t learn anything from eavesdropping. The pain in Jill Tuck’s voice and their interaction hung heavy and that maniacal nostalgic monster eagerly pattered its fingertips like it was trying to play a painful piano. Only now, he was reminded of Will.

He pushed it away as he thought of the glass coffin. How the hell was he going to fill that thing up? Would a glass supplier ask too many questions? Would it be prudent to clean out the thrift stores? He’d look real weird, buying up every odd drinkware he could get his hands on. 

He’d have to figure it out.



David Tapp

 

“Sing. I’m so close, Sing, we’ll get that bastard.” David promised his partner, staring intently through his telescope at his vantage point across the street from Lawrence Gordon’s apartment. The room was getting cluttered. He had ransacked it from some dopeheads and was staying there, even with the lack of heated water and the faint smell of piss. 

“Gordon’s up to something. But where is he? Haven’t seen him, Sing. But someone’s in his house with his wife. Who is he, Sing? Maybe Mrs. Gordon is getting back at Dr. Gordon?”

“Does Dr. Gordon know you’re at home with his wife? I know you know something. What are you doing in there? Waiting for the doctor? I’m waiting for the doctor too. Hmm.”

Tapp, he’s getting away. I’ll be right back.

David flinched, the memory a sharp pain that physically churned his spine and slapped his sense. I should have never let you go.”

“Who said anything about a warrant, Sing?”

“Damn foolish.” He slapped himself, the pain helping him stay grounded. The memories were strong. Sometimes, they made him forget where he was.

“You want to go right now?”

“Why not?”

“I should have never let you go.” He was panting, his heart pounding, sweat pouring down his temples. His cheeks.

I’ll be back, okay? I’ll be back.”

Jigsaw. Lawrence Gordon. This was all because of him. Damn him. “Had you… had you on your knees.” Tapp was now sitting on the couch, digging through the piles of documents on the coffee table. “You’re running. You’re running. You’re running scared because we had you. I’m going to close this case. Ram close it.”

A framed picture of Sing and him, what felt like a lifetime ago, back when he was still a fresh-faced rookie, along with the others of the Serial Killer Task Force, back when Rosello was the worst of their problems. Sing. I’m so sorry.

“Right, Sing? Right? We’re gonna close it, Sing.” His eyes were beginning to burn. His throat felt as though someone was gripping it and squeezing his airways closed.

This was our case, from the very beginning. You and me, we were always the ones to close the case.

“We’re gonna close it, Sing. I promise.”



Zep Hindle

 

His chest was burning. The poison. He wanted to hurry. But he couldn’t rush things. It had to be at six. Six was when he would receive the antidote, one way or the other.

His fall back, if Gordon failed to kill Adam, was going to be ugly. But he reassured himself, gripping the gun on the table as he stared intently at the screens that witnessed more griping between the two players, that he would go through with it.

The distant whimpers of the little girl and the woman made Zep cringe. But he shook it off. No. It wasn’t fair. But life wasn’t fair. And he wasn’t about to let himself get killed because of someone else.

Especially someone as insufferable as Lawrence Gordon.

The wife and kid were collateral. But that’s what Jigsaw wanted. And Jigsaw had him by the balls with that damn antidote.

“So what’s it going to be, doctor?” He muttered as he glared hatefully into the monitor as it went black. They had turned the lights off only to turn them back on again.

And then Lawrence tossed him a cigarette. The lighter.

And the dumb kid lit it up.

After some long seconds, Adam began to convulse. 

Zep’s heart skipped with excitement. Yes. He was going to be free. He was going to be fucking free.

Adam collapsed, lying on the tiles, very dead.

Gordon looked to the camera, waving his arms, clearly trying to communicate that the deed was done.

Zep pumped his fist in victory. So that was it. He got to his feet, eagerly waiting for his burner cell phone to go off to tell him where the antidote would be.

But then Adam started twitching. Spasming. Seizing.

He couldn’t hear what was going on between the two - it was only video, not audio - but he could tell Adam was very much alive.

It took Zep several seconds of staring, fuming, until he realized that they had just tried to lie to him.

It could have been a stroke of genius, Zep admitted, if it had fooled Jigsaw.

But somehow, it failed. Adam looked angry and was shouting at Gordon. More fighting.

Zep leaned back in his chair, letting out a sigh that erupted into another coughing fit.

He looked at the clock. Three more hours left. 

He narrowed his eyes. Come on, Gordon. Don’t you want your family to live? At least your daughter? 

But he wouldn’t be surprised if Gordon just let them die. He was barely a man, cheating on his wife with med students and looking down at his patients like they were cadavers to analyze.

But Zep was counting on him. Otherwise, he’d have to do some terrible things to stay alive. But he was ready for it.

 

John Kramer

 

“Did you hear what I said? Get this thing off me! Get it off!”

“Stop acting!”

John knew they would have tried to cheat. Connecting the piping to a remote controlled switch to a circuit with a 1200 Volt battery connected in the next room had been a good contingency. He held the remote in his other hand, hidden from both of them, having to press the engagement button with the meat of his hand. But it worked.

While they were bickering, Adam’s voice grew with apprehension. “I remember everything now. I remember how I got here.”

Hearing this young man, who normally had walked the streets with such rebellious attitude reduced to a whiny, snivelling brat had been expected. The kid had witheld details, likely not trusting the doctor. John could make predictions. He was confident Adam would die. But the doctor was coming around. Now, it was dependent on whether Zep would keep with his role.

John was not concerned, though, as he had Amanda who was waiting back at the Gideon Meatpacking Plant for his message at exactly an hour after the game completed. If he failed to call her, she would come with Mark to clean up whatever mess had been left here.

Amanda was approaching a level of maturity that left John with no further need to manage every aspect of these games. She had proven capable of taking subjects on her own. She had demonstrated a creativity with the schematics she had prepared. She had been a faithful student and loyal follower. Soon, she would be running her own trials.

As for Mark, he still needed to be tethered on a leash, as was clear with his lack of enthusiasm whenever John instructed him or made suggestions on how to improve his traps. Mark was far more independent. This made him more dangerous. 

Whenever John made suggestions on how Mark’s future traps could be improved upon, there was a hint of arrogance in the concealed snear and glitter of his reproach. Mark clearly believed he knew better than John and had no desire for any of John’s advice. This made John conclude he would need to be set free of the burden of game master. 

John wanted Amanda to take on the crown of Jigsaw. Mark would still remain a resource for her. If she wished to use him. One day, John hoped she would learn to not let her emotions get in the way of their calling and work together. One day, John would like to imagine Mark would see past his own ego for their work. 

But that day would likely be after John was gone. For now, Amanda despised Mark Hoffman. And Mark Hoffman detested everyone. But perhaps one day they would work together. Perhaps. 

Now if Doctor Gordon passed his test? If something caused Amanda to no longer be trusted? John would need to recalibrate. It was unmistakeable the detective had the most potential out of all of John’s chosen. Ultimately, John needed his heir to be the one to have the highest probability of succeeding. 

Yet Mark Hoffman had made it clear that he wanted nothing to do with Jigsaw’s legacy - or so he said. Over the long months, John witnessed the detective grow. He become more invested in caring for the traps. It was Hoffman who would run his hands over the dusty contraptions John had shelved long ago. John had watched the young man quietly wipe down and fiddle with old cogs and motors, treasuring John’s old work with a fondness that warmed his heart. He was as meticulous with preserving their armory of machinery as he would if they were his own personal guns.

Compared to Amanda, Mark was indeed a worthy competitor for the crown. He was quick thinking, methodical, and level headed - for the most part. And his original traps were far more ambitious. Powerful and with a hateful vigor. Machine gun turrets, entire rooms cultivated to be claustrophobic gas chambers, themed and satirical scenarios that were mocking and cruel, John admitted there was a strong brilliance to the detective’s vision.

He also would immediatly point out potential risks, such as knowing when one of their subjects had experience defending themselves or if they were likely able to put up a good fight in a struggle.

With John, Mark had begun to share his thoughts and ideas more. There was a trust underneath the ice. The man was capable of building machinery that Amanda could never dream of. Amanda tried all her might, but many of her traps were mere imitations - strongly inspired from John’s past creations. The Angel Trap - was simply her own personal rendition of the Reverse Bear Trap, but shifted down to the torso. She tried for the grander contraptions but the prototypes always failed. Her latest frustration was a shotgun collar, which still remained on the workbench, the contact initiator still not connecting to the pulse reader properly. 

The latest work Mark had been proposing, a room that crushed the subject if they refused to enter John’s long forgotten glass coffin, was both a mechanical challenge that John found fascinating and resourceful in ensuring his old work would not go to waste. And Mark had already proved its function, showing John first hand the walls close in until they pressed into the corpse of a pig, pancaking the carcass flat.

Yes, Mark would be a strong candidate.

If it weren’t for his clear bloodlust and his inability to separate his need for dominance and power in the equation, John would have selected him. But John witnessed the unnecessary way Mark handled the unconscious subjects. He treated them as if they were sacks of dirt, throwing them around, and once, kicking the ribs of one of them for no legitimate reason. Mark had a darkness within him that would be dangerous if unleashed. It revealed its ugliness here and there.

And lately, more frequently.

It was Amanda, who still had a heart. Albeit she let it rule her more than John would have liked.

My wife ,” Gordon moaned, John’s attention returning to the game. He heard the distant beeps of the buttons and his pitiful weeping.

“Lawrence, please, it’ll be okay.”

John grew bored of the self-pity and returned to his thoughts. He wondered if it was something personal for Mark that made him behave more cruel lately. The man desperately clung to his privacy and John did not feel it necessary to intrude. But John had picked up on his heightened anger whenever Amanda tried to goad him with details on his career. His partner, it seemed, was an especially tense subject. Amanda wanted Eric Matthews tested. Mark would often straighten when the topic was raised, narrow his eyes, and calmly refute hat his partner would not be involved. 

Something about this tickled John’s curiosity. Mark’s behavior was not likely a loyalty to his department. He had handed over David Tapp and Steven Sing on a silver platter without batting an eye simply because they were getting too close. And Eric Matthews, when called by name, had not raised too much of a concern.

It had been when Amanda brought up the word ‘ partner’ that Mark would shift.

The phone rang again.

John knew it was about time for the game to reach its climax.

He restored his attention to his subjects.

“Hello?” Gordon’s voice trembled. His breathing was heard, rapid, nervous.

The silence in the room allowed for John to just barely make out the words of his wife, Allison Gordon.

“You failed.” A loud noise erupted through the speaker. John made out the screams and a gun shot. So chaos it is. He wondered if Allison Gordon had decided to take matters into her own hands. He had no doubt she would have done what was necessary to keep herself and her daughter alive.

They had never been intended to be harmed.

More gunshots. Another man’s voice distantly broke through.

John did not recognize the voice but he had heard the distinct, “Freeze,” that had been declared. A part of him worried it was the police. But Hoffman would have ensured they would not have interfered. So who was it?

“Ally?! Ally! Hello?”Gordon was crying into the phone. More gun shots popped, muffled, and John’s thoughts drifted to popcorn.

Jill would make popcorn late at night, the sound waking him up. It used to annoy him but now he felt nothing but a grave nostalgia. Jill. Gideon.

“Lawrence!” Adam was braying while Gordon broke down. The doctor was sobbing, clutching his chains, wailing.

“FUCK THIS SHIT!” 

“Lawrence, calm down, there must be a way out of this.”

“I can’t be calm! My family neds me! God! Lawrence! No! Oh my god, what are you doing?!”

John wished he could turn his head and watch what was unfolding. He heard the rip of fabric. The metallic clang of the hacksaw against the ceramic tiles. 

And then he heard the screams, muffled, but clearly from Gordon.

“WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!”

John heard the sound of heavy breathing, rapid repetitive movement, and the wet slick slicing of flesh.

John felt triumphance fill his veins and drive the urge for his fingers twitch. He had done it. Doctor Gordon woke up. And he chose to live.



Peter Strahm

 

He was staring intently out the windshield, gripping the steering wheel, forcing himself to breathe long, deep breaths through his nose. She was leaning against the passenger door, clearly dying to escape the car and from him.

Cool it, Peter. 

He had to reel in his hot temper before he said something he regretted. Things were finally going well.

“I don’t like it,” he fumed, finally turning to her. He traced the worry in her eyes and wished they could have still stayed in their hotel bed instead of being at some prison parking lot.

“I don’t want Rhodes to clam up, Peter. You know I can get men to talk better on my own.”

And that was the problem. It was dangerous for her to go into the prison as a lone visitor. He wasn’t worried about her physical well being. He was more concerned for her mental health. Facing the man who had so viciously traumatized her and her family, was something he would have never advised to any patient of his. It would reopen wounds and potentially result in fresh trauma. He had explaind all this to her and she had waved his concern away.

He was starting to understand just how stubborn Will could be. And this irked him. 

“I need to do this, Peter. And I need you. You are crucial and have been such valuable help. But for this part, I want to face him alone. Please, understand.” Her lashes fluttered and her mouth pulled into a familiar plead that would normally make his heart melt.

He wouldn’t let it this time. He refused. “I think it’s best if I go in and you stay here. It would be a simple negotiation. He would have no idea of your involvement. I’m sure he’d be interested if I can negotiate some benefits if he confesses. A cell with a better view. Garbage picking privileges.”

She shook her head and now she looked angry. “This is my case, Peter. I need to be involved with everything.”

She had dug her heels in and Peter knew better than to push her. But he felt like a bull facing the red cape, no matter how much he snorted and stomped, he’d never get what he wanted charging head on.

“Fine. But promise me if it starts becoming too much for you, come straight back. I’ll be right here if you need me.” He quickly added, “I know you’ve got this. I’m just worried.”

She looked relieved. “Thanks, sometimes, it throws me off how -,” her face flushed with embarrassment and she looked away, “supportive you are.”

This felt like a victory strike for him but he refrained from bursting out into a grin.

He could tell when he was being compared to her past relationships in a good way. The petty part of him liked it when he came out on top. 

He watched her disappear into the visitor wing and leaned back into his seat to rest his eyes. Their fight had been going on since breakfast. Back and forth, he had tried to talk her out of going in there. He was still worried.

He knew he was projecting his own insecurities onto her.

Will was not Jessica. She would not shatter at the slightest inconvenience. She was strong. And he was not the same man he was back then. He had neglected Jessica and left her alone. This time, he would pay close attention to the signs that were right in front of his face. He would make a point to be there for Will, no matter what and where.

He would do right by her and treasure her. He sighed and turned to grab his briefcase nestled under the back seats. The ring case was there. He took it out to admire the brilliance of the diamond, knowing it would be enough to wow her.

But will she say yes?

He kept it on him, just in case there was some magical moment. The right time. But he knew it was very unlikely that would happen that day. Or that week. 

After we confirm its Rhodes, maybe then. When we close this case. He had considered the standard ring in champagne, sunset dockside, or top of the mountain gesture, and all seemed grand - but when would they be the right time?

He knew there was the slightest possibility that he was going too fast. That she was not ready. But he trusted his instincts and felt Will would say yes when he asked. 

They weren’t getting any younger.

Though somewhat arrogant, he knew he was a catch. And Will was, too. He hadn’t met another woman in all these years that just felt right to him.

He still imagined that American dream ending. Beautiful wife, cute kids, piicket fence, baseball, and apple pie. A happy life. And they were still able to achieve that - it could still work.

His FBI career was rewarding but he still came home to an empty house and the quiet sometimes suffocated him. 

He wanted a family and he would happily step out of the field to have that. He could go into consulting. He knew Will could give up the dangers of being a city cop, too. He just needed to give it a little more time to convince her.

He imagined a life with no more serial killers. No more needing to examine the rotting carcasses of brutalized innocents. No more crime scene photos of blood splatter or some demented ritual to analyze. No more recordings of deranged lunatics torturing young girls for their sick kicks to study and empathize with. No more having to dive into the twisted perspectives of the cruelest psyches of humanity to solve another case. 

He was tired of having to intimately absorb and step into the shoes of such monsters.

He imagined a simple, good life. The smell of chicken roasting when he walked through the front door after a long day in the office. Will, hair down, greeting him at the door. The noise of young kids and maybe a dog barking to fill the air. Safety. Peace. Weekends coaching sports games. Always going to sleep in a warm bed.

He wanted all of that, and more.

The hard part was the wait. 

But she’s worth it, Peter knew.

David Tapp

 

He chased after Jigsaw, his heart pounding in his ears. He wouldn’t get away. Not this time. So it hadn’t been Doctor Gordon. He could admit when he was wrong. And he would make everything right. 

I’ll avenge you, Sing. We’re so close to making that bastard pay!

Jigsaw was just out of his reach. David swore at him when they had been racing throughout the city. He wished he still had his issued vehicle for the lights and eight cylinder engine. The perp drove like a lunatic and David was just barely keeping up. They narrowly  missed a pedestrian and a few collisions during the ordeal.

Now, they were at some abandoned house. The piece of shit was quick and knew exactly where to go. Down some ladders. Turning sharp corners. It took David every ounce of energy to keep up with him.

These knees just aren’t what they used to be.

He wished Sing was here with him.

“I’m gonna kill you, you sick asshole!”

He was now just a stone throw away from the guy. He leaped forward to tackle him. And he went down.

But then he jumped back up, so Tapp lurched, getting a good grip on the bastard. He threw him against the wall and began pummeling, fist contacting the back of his neck, his kidney region, wanting more than anything to make this fucker hurt.

But somehow, the guy slipped out of his reach and then the explosive bang of the gun and Tapp felt the sharp stab in his chest. All his rage, his energy, fizzled into nothing. He gasped, trying to breathe.

Just the wind knocked out of me.

But he looked down, seeing the blood down his shirt. He looked up, seeing Jigsaw, the sharp nosed beady eyed face still holding the gun. His gun.

Tapp felt the world pull him to the ground. He was so tired. And now, Jigsaw was gone and he was alone in this dark room.

Sing, I guess I’ll be seeing you now, Tapp thought as the cold darkness closed in on him.

 

Wilhelmina Maddox

 

The harsh buzz made Will blink. The slide of the door followed by the thunk of metal as the barred barrier moved filled the tense atmosphere. She followed him as he approached their visitor booth. He wore orange prison garb. Philip Rhodes was a gaunt and short old thing with stubble and cold eyes that were almost as pale as snow. He was missing some teeth which he showed to her with a wide smile.

“What’s a pretty little thing like you visiting this old timer for?”

Throughout her decades in the police force, she had smiled through interviews to get what she wanted. She had smiled when a man tried to play the victim after beating his two children to death. She had smiled shortly after a suspect had thrown a punch at her face, pretending she forgave and only cared about him confessing than her own feelings.

Smiling often got her what she needed for her work.

But no matter how important she knew it was to play this the right way, she just couldn’t bear to smile. Not when it was for the man who murdered her mother.

And she knew it was him, as soon as he had walked through that door. 

“Well, what’d’you want? You one of my kids? I got no money. So what is it?”

Words failed her. He had aged well, his features identical to that night. She had seen him through the crack of her closet door, hands clasped to her mouth, as he stepped, staring at her empty bed. Bram’s cries had been nonstop in the other room. And when he left, the sound of the gun had cracked.

“You deaf?”

Will now regretted telling Peter to wait in the car. “My name is Wilhelmina Maddox. And your fingerprints were found at the scene of a crime over twenty years ago.” She held out her badge. “I’m here to ask you some questions.”

Recognition sparked in his eyes before the man recovered. He squinted and rubbed his bald head. “Maddox. Ma-ddox. That name rings a bell.” His eyes darted to her face, looking caged but malicious. “I knew a redhead, once, looked kind of like you. She’s dead, now.”

Her blood drained from her face. “How did she die?”

The man began to smile. “Information ain’t cheap.”

“There’s little I can offer, Mr. Rhodes. But I do have friends. Friends that can make your life a little easier here.”

“Call me Phil. And I think that would be dandy,” he put a hand on the glass, “so why you want to know? I saw that badge ain’t local. You’ve come a long way, girl cop.”

She nodded, familiar with this game. “I have my reasons. We have enough to submit to the DA and you will go to court.” The anger was always boiling deep underneath the surface of her spirit but she did everything she could to hold it back. She needed him to confess. And confessions were always easier with honey. “Now, it’s looking like murder in the second degree. Armed robbery. Battery. The family needs closure and it looks like it’s finally going to happen. But I’d like to hear your side of the story.”

He let out a laugh. “You’re the family, aren’t you? Yeah, that tough-girl with hard eyes is trying too hard. I know your city’s got that psycho out right now. And you’re wasting time on some petty burglary gone wrong? No, I'm putting the pieces together. This is personal, isn’t it?”

She leaned back, letting out a huff. In the end, he had the upper hand and he knew it. “It is.” She quickly added, “you’re sharp, Phil.” Play the friend. Build rapport. She needed to remember her training. She could do this. She could get this man to talk.

“Heh, you’re one of them charming cops. If this was just an interrogation room, I’d ask for some cigarettes and a coke. Maybe a blow job, with those pretty lips.” Rhodes looked to the guard at his back and smirked. “Oh well. Information’s got to cut it. Information is gold. What’s your first name again, Maddox?”

“Wilhelmina.”

“Hell of a name. German?”

She nodded, “It was my grandmother’s.” She gave pieces of herself up. Chum for the shark. “Let me be honest, Phil, it’s like you said. It’s personal.”

“Yeah, I know. I already have an idea. That hair. Those freckles. It was your mom, huh? That girl I shot up, who had that crying baby? Was that baby you?”

“Yes.” She wouldn’t bring up Bram if she could help it. 

“Thought it was a boy’s room, there were dinosaurs on the walls. Lots of blue.”

His memory was sharp. He wanted her to know this. “My parents were forward-thinking with gender roles.”

“What?”

“They thought it was fine for me. They wanted a boy. So what happened, that night?”

“Well, not sure what to tell ya. It was a hard call. I didn’t mean to do her in. It just happened.”

He was eying her with a careful reproach now as if at any moment, he was expecting a punch to the face. It was a futile fear, though it made Will remember to unclench the fist she held at her knee, out of sight of the glass.

“Please tell me how it happened.”

“You really want to know?”

“I wouldn’t be here otherwise.”

The man sighed, rubbed his face. “Dear God.” He shut his eyes for a long while as if praying. “There isn’t much for a man to have here, but religion is one of those things. I’m a saved man, now, and I know this is a test from the lord himself.”

Will raised an eyebrow, examining his blink rate and the rise and fall of his chest. His behavior had changed and this set off the alarm in her mind to be wary of deception. He was being too forthcoming, but iut was all wrong. But she played along. 

“Do you have something you’d like to unburden yourself with me?”

He nodded. “Oh, yes. I have a lot.”

“I’m all ears.”

“That night. It was supposed to be an easy score. Family’s out of town, my guy said. So it would be quick. In and out.”

He was storytelling. The fish was this big.

“Apparently, the intel was wrong. Man of the house was out. But the wife and kid was still there. I figured I could still get things done. The woman was tiny. If she even woke up, I’d just knock her out and move on. But things got out of hand.” He was rapping his fingers on the countertop. “But then, she tried to fight. She had gotten the phone and had called the cops. And she had a mouth on her.”

Will swallowed, keeping her shoulders squared. “So what did you do?”

He smirked. “You want the rest, get me transferred to a nicer prison. One of them fancy ones you give to the rich. With ping pong tables. And golf.”

“I’ll see what I can do. But I can’t make any promises.”

“When you can, I’ll spill all the terrible things me and my partner did to your mother, kid, but til then,” he slammed his fist on the table suddenly and got to his feet, spitting on the floor. “I’m done here.”

The abrupt end and the loud smack of his fist jumbled her thoughts and she struggled to register what was happening. She had only remembered him from that night. And he said… “Wait! Who was your accomplice?”

He ignored her and nodded to the guard to let him leave.

“Mr. Rhodes!” A wave of desperation hit her and she pressed her hands against the glass. “Phil! Tell me!”

The man ignored her as she stared at the sliding grated door as the air filled with the harsh buzz.

She was left to gawk until the guard behind her cleared his throat. She turned, cheeks burning, and stalked out of visitation.

This rarely happened to her. She usually got them to open up. What went wrong?

She knew what went wrong.

She had let her true feelings be shown. And unlike back in the interrogation room, where she had a partner to let her walk out for a break and shift attention, she had been on her own. 

Damn it. She had tried to hold it all back but she just couldn’t completely disassociate and allow herself to charm him. She wasn’t sure if she ever could. The next time she talked to him, she needed to come up with a different plan.

When she got back to the car, sitting glumly in the passenger seat, Peter let her wallow for a few long seconds.

“Didn’t work?”

She nodded.

“I told you.”

This was not what she had wanted, needed, nor expected at that moment. She wanted to turn to him and tell him to fuck off. She suddenly felt so alone.

He put a hand on hers, squeezing it against her lap. “Sorry. That’s not what I meant.”

But it was too late. She had felt that petty jab and her ears were ringing with the callousness of it. The ego he had was more important to him than comforting her.

She thought of Mark, knowing how he would have pulled her into a hug in silent comfort. A part of her felt sudden revulsion. Why was she thinking about Mark? No, she was over reacting. 

Or am I? She always seemed to find herself with men who made her feel so small. But Peter was different. He was supposed to be different. Maybe this was normal? And all this time what she kept thinking on how a guy was supposed to make her feel - was just an unattainable standard?

“You hungry?”

“No,” she whispered, needing a drink. “Just take me back to the hotel. I have a headache.” She kept her eyes staring out the window until she blinked away the tears.




Notes:

A/N: Oh my god, it was April when I last updated. I am terrible and I have been so slow with the updates. Not just slow - astronomically bungled. I hope this chapter's length makes up for it. It took a while to proof-read. This year's been extremely busy in the work-department. My full-time job is pretty demanding this year. I have an old grump for a boss. But I'm starting a new project in a few months and I will be FREE of him! In theory, it should free me up to write more! Because I'll be spending more time enjoying my full time job which means I don't finish the work week drained and actually have some creative energy and vision.

Part of my delays is the complete absence of ideas. I have a few I jot down. But when it's time to spill it on paper, the inspiration is sucked out. But I found my wind at least for this chapter - I'll try to post more soon! I'm struggling with how to make Strahm more likeable - more undertsandable - but also I miss Hoffman and Will being together with some angst, drama, comfort, and a bit of smut thrown about.

I have not forgotten this fic. I don't like leaving things undone and I already put a pin on one fanfiction. So I got to finish this one, strong and done well! So here's to more updates, more imagination, and I'm grateful to all of you for reading and for all your kind messages throughout this long running fic's lifespan. Thank you!

Chapter 50: Peri-SAW: Can't Control Himself

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dr. Lawrence Gordon

 

He still smelled burnt bacon and there was always that pain that shocked through his system in throbbing blitzes. The adrenaline had receded. The dizziness almost pulled him into the darkness, but the sudden splash of water had him open his eyes to stare into the face of a haunting old man. Death himself.

“Congratulations, Doctor Gordon, you survived.”

He could not conjure words or thoughts and simply fell back asleep.

Voices filled his dreams, one deep and gruff, the other whispery like silk.

“So it’s done?” A wide figure stood over him, another one of Death’s cronies.

“Yes. He did well.”

“So what do you want me to do with him?”

“Take him back to our workshop. We will need to care for him until he is ready to go home.”

“You sure you want us to keep him? He’ll see too much.”

“Let me worry about that.”

“Fine.”  He felt hands under his armpits hoisting him up, roughly, a grunt rumbled nearby. He felt as though he was flying.

“Careful, Detective,” the old man’s voice pulled him back to consciousness. “Treat him with the respect he deserves. Unlike the others, he has shown he has what it takes.”

“Fine.”

Why? Why could he not simply sleep? His body was damaged. He would be dead soon. So just let me sleep, he prayed.

“I’m no doctor, but won’t he need a blood transfusion? He feels cold.”

“That he will. Amanda has prepared for this.”

“Diana?” Gordon muttered and he stopped flying. The woman’s name had sounded like Diana to him.

“Where’s the wife and kid?”

“Amanda is checking in on them as we speak.”

“So they made it? Was wondering about that, after I saw Zepp in the room. So what’s the logic there, the kid not appreciate life? Didn’t know you wanted to start bringing in test subjects so young.”

Gordon tried to yell out. How dare they . He knew they were talking about his daughter. How dare they involve her.

“Zepp’s… behavior was not anticipated. An unfortunate diversion from my expectation.”

“So you didn’t think the kid was in danger? Could have fooled me.”

“I assure you, Detective, I have no intention of harming children.”

“Then why involve the kid at all? Why not just knock her out until the game is over and drop her off at the fire station?”

Gordon was too weak to scream but he still felt fear. 

Is Diana and Ally okay? Please, God, let them be okay.

“When will you learn to trust me, Detective?”

“You and I both know that all of this went down and almost got out of control.”

“But in the end, every piece fell into place.”

“Next time, John, I don’t want kids involved.”

“Detective, there are many subjects who are parents. And the only way to break some out of their own mental prison is to remind them that they are responsible for those too weak and still not ready for the cruelty of the world.”

As the thick and strong arms dragged him away from death’s whispery voice, he heard his carrier mutter under his breath, low and thick, “hypocritical bastard.”

The exhaustion was too great for Lawrence, so he let the sleep come - pulling him into its deep quiet.

 

Allison Kerry 

 

“How do you plan on approaching this?” Hoffman asked her as they studied Diana Gordon through the one way mirror. Kerry sighed. 

Another survivor. Thank God.

She wasn’t ready to face this one. A mother and her daughter. Her husband, still missing. They would have questions. Demand answers. And Kerry would not be able to offer much.

Jigsaw was still at large, that damn puppet’s face always plastered on news outlets.

Jigsaw still at large. MPD incompetent.

Her own portrait would be shown, smiling dumbly through the screen while the spokesman would loudly vocalize the building anger of the public. The storm was growing. The mob had begun to sharpen their pitchforks. 

“The lead of the investigation, Detective Allison Kerry, clearly is outside her depth and needs to step down for someone more capable. After the retirement of Lead Detective David Tapp, the MPD Homicide Department has been fumbling about trying to fill the void. This city continues to live in fear as this crazed serial killer walks among us. Who will be the next caught in one of this monster’s sadistic traps? A petition for Detective Kerry to step down has been gaining public attention.”

“Kerry.” Hoffman put a hand on her shoulder and she jolted. Blinking, briefly disoriented, she realized he was watching her with pity in his eyes. “When was the last time you slept?”

“I should be asking you that,” she muttered, knowing she shared the same thick bags and dark shadows under her eyes as Hoffman wore these days. She could not rest. The guilt would keep her awake. How could she ever relax knowing she was the one responsible for catching the bastard? 

And she was failing.

She wouldn’t rest until Jigsaw was caught. But it was just her, Hoffman, and Fisk. Matthews stayed in his basement ‘office’, sulking and smoking, refusing to step up. Apparently, the commissioner and director of the FBI had a pissing match, so they wouldn’t send Lindsay or Strahm anytime soon. And Will. Will was off trying to solve some dead case, Strahm in tow, while an active case continued to mow victims down.

“If you need, I’ll take point,” Hoffman offered. 

At least she had Hoffman. 

“I’ve got this, but thanks. Back me up. She’ll probably ask about her husband. You can explain about the child victim advocate process.”

“Yeah. This is a lucky break,” he added, the faintest turn of his lip more forced than genuine. “We’ll get him, Kerry.”

She nodded, relieved, glad he had become so helpful and involved with this one. She regretted all the times she had side-eyed his work, now appreciating his presence in this hell more than anything else.

“Hey,” Fisk entered the observer’s room. “We’re ready. I’ll be in here recording.”

“I’ll wave you in if I need you,” Kerry called over her shoulder as she and Hoffman left to enter the adjacent room.

Alison Gordon was hugging herself, curled forward over the table, defensive and exhausted. When Kerry and Hoffman entered she jolted up with doe eyes before softening in relief.

“Sorry to keep you waiting, Alison,” Kerry gently smiled. “I’m Detective Allison Kerry. This is Detective Mark Hoffman. Thank you for seeing us.”

“Yeah. I want to help. Lawrence is still out there. Please, find him.”

She kept the grimness from her face. It was unlikely Dr. Gordon was still alive. “We’ll do everything we can to bring him home.”

“I saw his face.” Alison Gordon volunteered, jaw clenched. “I recognized the freak. He works at my husband’s hospital. I don’t remember his name. But he was an orderly.”

Hoffman was scribbling the notes down. “Mrs. Gordon, can you start from the beginning? How far back do you remember when you and your daughter were kidnapped?”

“Lawrence had just left for work.” Her face twisted and she shut her eyes, a sob escaping her lips. “And then Diana screamed. When I got to her room, the man was standing over her, covered in a bedsheet. He grabbed her.” Tears burst and streamed down her cheeks. Kerry slide a box of tissues towards her, waiting for her to collect herself. Alison Gordon took a tissue and wiped her face, shoulders shaking as she moaned into the paper.

Hoffman continued to write in his notebook next to her, focused intently on his writing. He was avoiding Mrs. Gordon’s eyes.

Now’s not the time to be awkward, Hoffman.

“I tried to fight him. But he had a gun. I should have stopped him. But I couldn’t make myself move fast enough.”

“You did the right thing,” Kerry put a hand out, gently touching the woman’s balled fist. “You and your daughter are safe now.”

“When he grabbed Diana, what did you do?” Hoffman softly asked, keeping the conversation focused.

“He put the gun to Diana’s head, told me to be quiet. Or he would shoot her. He had me tie her to the bed. And gag her. And then to tie my feet. Then he bound my wrists. He kept us gagged there for hours. He had a cell phone and it would ring every so often.”

“What did he say?”

“Just yes or no - I couldn’t figure out but I think he was getting instructions. And then he took out of her closet all these monitors. Oh, god, he had been in our house and somehow stored all this equipment without any of us knowing. How?” Diana was rubbing her temple, her emotions growing hot with anger. “That bastard. You have to stop him.”

Kerry looked to Hoffman who was turning to the mirror, giving one distinct nod. She knew Fisk was likely calling in for all available bodies to head over to the Angel of Mercy Hospital to begin the hunt for the orderly.

“We will. Can you go over what he was doing? His behavior? What did he tell you? Anything will help.”

“He kept saying Lawrence’s time was running out. That he was waiting for a phone call. He was so cruel. He told me he was going to kill him. And - oh, god,” her eyes brightened with recollection. “Another man - a cop - he broke in. He saved us. How could I forget?”

Kerry blinked, confused. She looked to Hoffman who flipped pages back, also looking thrown off. “Sorry, another man? That was not in the initial report you told the officer on scene.”

“No - I - I’m so sorry - I - no, I don’t remember everything when I first spoke to the officer who arrived. But I assumed you already knew - he came in with his gun. He called himself police - and he helped us. A-are you saying that was someone else?”

“Well - it may just be a detail we’re not tracking yet,” Kerry tried to soothe. “But we had not received report of a second man from the arriving officer on the scene.” She looked to Hoffman who shook his head as he flipped through the pages of the report.

“I’m sorry, I - I don’t recall what I told him.”

Kerry was not surprised. The ordeal had happened only hours ago. She was still in shock. The fact she was sitting across from her and able to share anything was short of impressive endurance on the woman’s part. “Take a breath, Mrs. Gordon. It’s okay. Nice and easy. You and your daughter are safe now.” She waited for the woman to collect herself, allowing the clock on the wall to tick peacefully by. “When did this second man appear?”

“When I tried to take the gun from the bastard.”

“Let’s focus on that,” Hoffman suggested, “Elaborate. You,” he flipped back and read aloud, “Managed to free yourself and catch him off-guard. Before or after did the second man arrive?.”

“Well,” Mrs. Gordon sighed. “I had loosened my bindings. But then I heard him in the other room. Jigsaw.” 

“Did he claim to be Jigsaw?” Hoffman interrupted, his calm holding a glimmer of curiosity.

“No,” Mrs. Gordon bit her lip. “But it’s him, isn’t it? Who else could he be?”

“We’re still trying to figure that out. He could be an accomplice. Though this is an unprecedented case. You and your daughter are now the third and fourth survivors-,”

“That we know of,” Hoffman calmly added. Kerry threw him a warning glance, not wanting to terrify the poor woman any further or complicate the questioning.

“Oh, God. Do you think Lawrence is dead?”

“There’s still hope,” Hoffman softly comforted, surprisingly tactful. “The sooner we know everything you know, the better his chances.”

“Right. Right. Sorry. Well, Jigsaw - the man - he was angry. He was in the other room and constantly shouting at his screens. And I think he was sick. He coughed all the time. I heard the gun getting loaded. And I knew our time was running out. I tried to untie Diana but the knots were too tight. I could hear him getting ready to come out. So I pretended to still be tied. And then Jigsaw - he came out of the room. And he went to me. Told me Lawrence’s ‘time was up’. He said he ‘had to do what he had to do’. He had a phone that he had been calling Lawrence with and I was supposed to tell him he failed. He had already told me that he would kill me if Lawrence failed. So I knew I had nothing to lose.” She wiped another tear. “So when I told Lawrence he failed, I grabbed Jigsaw’s gun as fast as I could.”

“That was brave,” Hoffman encouraged her to continue.

“I managed to get it out of his grasp. I pointed the gun at him. I needed Diana. That was all I cared about. But - it’s all a blur. He pushed me down. He was so strong - I couldn’t hold onto the gun. But then I heard a crash. And then the other man attacked him.” The light danced from the gloss of her eyes, lips parted as she whispered, “Yes, I can see the cop’s face right now. Clearly. He was a black man. Older. He burst into the room, fought with Jigsaw. The gun went off. And Jigsaw was gone and the man chased him.” She was trembling, eyes distant, as if she was trapped in her memories. 

“Any other features? Scars, tattoos?”

Mrs. Gordon blinked. “Yes. He had a terrible voice. And I saw his neck. He had a terrible scar on it. Like he had his throat slit.”

Kerry and Hoffman shot alarmed glances at each other. Kerry knew immediately who it was.

“If you saw a picture of the man, would you be able to identify him?” Hoffman got to his feet. 

“Yes. He saved us. I don’t know if he’s one of the good guys, but to me, he was an angel.”

Hoffman stepped out, shortly coming back with a framed photograph. Kerry recognized the picture of David Tapp, the very same placard normally hung on the wall of fallen heroes outside the breakroom. 

“That’s him! Oh my god, so he is a cop? Thank God he was there.” Alison Gordon was smiling, shining, and Kerry felt her eyes burn in gratitude.

Thanks, Tapp.

But that left some new problems. What happened to him? And where is he now?

 

“Gordon’s neighbor’s here,” Fisk announced, looking uncertain at Kerry and Hoffman who were gathering their notes after Alison Gordon had left. “But we need someone at the hospital. They’re not giving us anything on their staff without a warrant.”

“You kidding me?” Kerry sighed, her head throbbing. “You’d think they’d want to not get in our way trying to catch the prick.”

“Hospitals always get cagey when it involves releasing records. They brought out their lawyers.”

“Christ.”

“Kerry, go. Fisk and I’ve got this,” Hoffman stepped forward. “I’ll have Grissom get that warrant faxed over. It’s now,” he checked his watch, “Sunday morning - Judge is probably getting out of church.”

Kerry bit her lip, not wanting to leave to play politician.

Hoffman must have recognized her hesitation, adding, “I know Tapp will be most forthcoming with you, out of us three.”

“You think he’s still out there?”

He paused for half a second. “He’s a survivor. He’s probably ready to gloat to us on how two steps ahead he’s been. Grissom will lose his shit.” Kerry’s gut flipped at the slight twitch of Hoffman’s mouth. She felt as though he was lying. But maybe he didn’t want to share a more pessimistic outlook with her. Maybe it was just the fifth cup of coffee she had before the interviews playing tricks with her mind. 

It’s probably their bad blood. They just hate each other. That’s all that’s about. 

“I’ll head over then.”

“Try to bring Matthews,” Hoffman added, “It’s not safe going alone.”

She let out a breath of dark humor. “Yeah, if he’ll go.”

 

Amanda Young

She pulled her sleeves over her wrists, insecure at the slight bulge from the bandages. John would be angry when he saw. But she had gotten nervous, thinking about Adam. His face, his smile, his kindness. She needed the pain to remind her of who she was and what she deserved.

John needed her and she couldn’t let him down. But the silence -  the thoughts - she needed to get her mind focused on the bite of the blade and the rush of adrenaline with the heavy beat of her heart to drown out the thoughts in her head.

The second guesses. They kept trying to worm their doubts.

What is this is wrong?

No, it wasn’t. It couldn’t be.

A noise announced their return. She quickly looked around to make sure everything was put away and hidden and then went to them. 

When she saw Hoffman and John enter with the doctor in the wheel barrow, she snapped to action. She had prepared a recovery station for the blood transfusions. She had prepared two beds. “John,” she wanted to throw her arms around him, but chose to grab his robe and wrap his shoulders with it. “I’ll get you some water. Are there any other survivors?” He was shivering, still in his underwear, damp and looking sickly.

“No.” John’s answer smacked into her and caused her to freeze in shock.

He didn’t make it? She stood frozen to the concrete while John and Hoffman went about their business not noticing her upset. 

“Where’s the painkillers?” Hoffman interjected and for once she was relieved to see him. His stupid face filled her with renewed anger. Anger was good. Anger gave her strength.

“No.” John held his hand out and planted it on the doctor’s shoulder. “Let him work through the pain. This is part of his rehabilitation. To face the suffering and to triumph over it.”

“He needs a blood bag if he’s going to work through anything. Amazing he’s made it this long.”

John nodded. “That, we better be quick with. Amanda, if you please.” 

Amanda led them to the nook far from the majority of surgical steel and aluminum shelving and pulled open the makeshift curtain held up by rusted wire tied to the hooks bolted to the walls. Cameras were pointed over the setting, in case Gordon found himself strong enough to try escape. But it would be unlikely, considering the leather straps that were attached to the hospital bed. She went to the minifridge where the blood packs were stored. 

Behind her, she heard Hoffman grunt to lift Gordon onto the bed as the doctor let out a low moan, whispering, “Ally? Diana? …who are you people?”

Amanda blinked, and blurted out, “They’re fine. Your neighbors are with them. And the police are with them.” She darted her gaze to Hoffman and he nodded with a grim frown. He understood the problem with that. Police meant Gordon wouldn’t be dropped off until they were gone. Hoffman would take care of the police. He’s good for that, Amanda hated to admit. That’s all he’s good for, though.

“You can help by bringing John some water before you leave,” she was trying to not come off as hateful as she sounded, per John’s request for her to try to be more civil with the cop, but it came out full of venom anyway.

He turned, expression wickedly amused, and stepped toward her. 

For a split second, Amanda felt a wave of fear, wondering what he would do.

“A glass of water would be appreciated, Detective, thank you.”

A slight smirk lifted his lips and he brushed by her as he left. He had seen her terror and knew he had won this silent spar. “Hiss all you want, you’re all bark,” he muttered under his breath so only she could hear. Her face burned and her balled up fists trembled at her sides. 

“Amanda, please, Doctor Gordon needs to be our top priority.”

She turned, feeling mildly hurt that John did not acknowledge how difficult Hoffman was, but smiled. “Of course, John.” She brought the blood pack and hung it above the nearby intravaneous pole.

Doctor Gordon looked like he was in a bad spot. He was pale. Sweating. Gray shadows lined his eyes and face. “Adam. We need to save Adam. Please.”

She felt the blood drain from her face. Adam was still down in that basement bathroom. And he will stay there. She cleared her throat and tried to push the thoughts away. “So what’s the plan with him?” This was the first survivor John had ever brought back here. That meant something. She wanted to hear him out before she jumped to conclusions, but she was nervous and impatient. Was this going to be another one of John’s selected? Another Hoffman to compete for John’s attention and affection? Another man to get in the way?

“We will ensure he makes it through this. He will die if we do not intervene.”

“Why him?” Amanda blurted out before thinking. “Why not leave him to figure it out on his own?”

“The game is over. He won. It is only fair to give him a chance to recover from his injury.” John carefully took a needle and pressed it into Gordon’s inner arm, aligning the metal to the vein. Amanda tapped her foot, impatient, arms folded until he finally added, “He could be of use.”

Amanda half wondered if this was because he was an oncologist, able to care for John as the cancer progressed. It had to be. “What about Adam?”

“He had the key. And he lost it. He should have been more careful.”

“How did he lose the key?”

“Who knows?” He sounded unconcerned. Amanda’s heartbeat quickened.

“He’ll starve.”

“He knew the rules, Amanda. He lost the game and must now suffer the consequences.”

She blinked, surprised by John’s callousness. “But all the others - theirs was a quick death. So why make Adam suffer? This is -,”

“Torture?” John looked up at her with a small smile. “Pain?”

“Yes, John. Shouldn’t we…”

“We are not murderers, Amanda. Adam still has a chance. With enough… willpower… he still has the means of escaping his prison.”

She suddenly felt a rush of hope. “Like how?”

“Amanda, can you please boil some water and return with some antiseptic?” John  chose to ignore her question, engrossed in studying the stump of Gordon’s leg, paying her no further mind.

She pursed her lips together, wanting to snap at him but held it back. “Yes, John,” she left him, heading towards their kitchenette, a makeshift breakroom of a propane stove, sink, and refrigerator. 

Hoffman was there, hunched over the wooden counter, staring off in the distance. He turned at the sound of her approach but said nothing. She suddenly didn’t want to start a fight with him. He was the only other. And as they locked eyes she recognized that indignant fire that she felt burning in her heart. We were here first. And now there’s an intruder in our midst.

“What else does he need?” Hoffman had three bottled waters in his arms, the plastic frosting from the humidity.

“Antiseptic. Boiled water.” She loudly dug through the shelves for the giant pot and put it in the industrial sink, blasting the faucet to drown out the intrusions of her own inner dialogue.

What’s John planning?

Will he let him go?

What if he talks?

He’s seen all our faces. If he talks, they’ll all get screwed.

There’s no way around it. He needs to go.

The pot was full so she stopped the water. A steady drip echoed in the room. 

“He can’t leave here. Not until we’re sure he’s going to keep his mouth shut.” Hoffman, who rarely spoke first, broke the silence and was rummaging at the shelves above the fridge, pulling out a bottle of iodine. She turned to him, watching him, silently agreeing.

“John knows what he’s doing.” She wanted to believe this, but this was the first time she felt so insecure about it. She had not expected Gordon to live. Or Adam, for that matter. And yet…

“Let’s hope so. Otherwise, it’s back to prison.”

She smirked. “Yeah, well, did it once. I can handle it. But how about you? Cops don’t last long behind bars. A lot of payback comes their way.” The idea of him getting a beat down made her feel giddy. “I hear they’re extra nice to pretty boys like you, too.”

He narrowed his eyes. “That won’t happen. I’m not going to jail.”

She scoffed. “Big talk. But I bet you’re all talk. What, you’d rather die first before letting them arrest you? Go out, guns blazing?”

He smirked back. “Guess we’ll see, won’t we.”

“See, this is why I don’t trust you.” She pulled up the pot and carefully placed it over the propane stove, turned on the gas, and waited for the click of the flint to ignite the flame. “I know you cops are close. I thought you’d look out for each other, at least. But not you. You’d stab ‘em in the back without flinching, huh?”

“If it means staying out of prison, yes.” His tone held menace, laced with a hidden message in his sneer. If I can kill my friends easily, imagine what I can do with my enemies. 

“If you’re not attached to your precious fellow cops, then there’s little you can do to gripe when it’s time to test Eric Matthews.”

Hoffman rolled his eyes. “You and Matthews. You’re obsessed.”

“He’s the reason my life went to shit. In fact, so are you.” She allowed herself that last bite, to be honest with him. Her eyes stung and she stared intensely into the pot of water as bubbles began to form. “You’re lucky John likes you.”

“Didn’t John teach you that the ‘heart cannot be involved’?”

She let out a low laugh. “That’s your lesson. Me? I’ve got other demons. It was your heart that got you into this.”

“Then what’s your lesson?”

She had no idea. John never explicitly told her what she could not do. Only that she had to give every ounce of herself to him. But she knew the catalyst had been her addiction. But her lesson? She was still searching for it. She swallowed, thinking how cold it must be down there, in that dark, dank bathroom, where no one can hear you scream. What lesson would Adam learn? And what was she supposed to learn from any of this? “That’s none of your business.”

 

Mark Hoffman

He got home, his neck and shoulders tight and sore, ready to collapse on his bed. He had six more hours until he had to wake up for work. He smiled to himself, thankful for the reprieve. Now that one of John’s most elaborate games was finished, the old man now had his prized survivor to focus on. Mark enjoyed a noticeable lack of orders or instructions. That meant he had less oversight. Finally. 

Kerry and Fisk had sent him home - the three of them were rotating shifts, now focusing on interviews and waiting on forensics to return with lab results. This would take weeks of waiting. Hoffman was thankful for it.

He wouldn’t try to bring up the lack of workload to either John or Kerry and instead spent the day nodding off at his desk and his night finishing the latest traps. He even had the time to clean up the workshop before leaving. He turned off his burner phone, and slunk away before anyone remembered to throw one final order at him.

He had locked the door to his apartment, eyes scanning for anything amiss. He could never be too careful these days. Though he was sure Amanda didn’t know where he lived, he always expected John to have a means of finishing off Mark when he was no longer useful.

He knew too much. He knew this. 

But he also knew John more, now, and was ready for any violation of his home. The door knob had a distinct scratch he left so if not properly rotated in the right position, he would know someone had tried to come into his apartment. There were a couple of detail markers he looked for - hair subtly stuck to the foyer drawers that would fall off if someone tried to stick their nose in his things. The healthy coating of dust on the walnut surface made him feel relaxed. He had purposely neglected deep cleaning his place these days, not wiping down furniture or the floors, scanning for any unrecognizable tracks.

He looked at the corner of the living room, where, hidden behind the books and DVDs, was his camera, recording perpetually while he was gone. He went to it, brushing aside the books, taking out the cable from the far back, and plugging it into his TV.

He grabbed the remote, turning the TV on, and turned to study the environment. The magazines were kept neatly arranged on the coffee table. The couch and recliner were as unused as he had left them. Blankets neatly folded. The kitchen, also unused, save for the lone shot glass by the sink. He hadn’t remembered the last time he ate at home. Normally, it was a can of tuna at the workshop or instant ramen when he was moonlighting. At work, he just ordered fast food or opted for the donuts in the break room. 

Despite the options being grossly unhealthy, he had lost a notable amount of weight, working for John. He would likely skip a meal tonight, opting for extra sleep instead. He fast forwarded the recording, watching as the light from the window being the only change as the entire day sped through in front of his eyes with static jaggedly crossing the screen. Satisfied that no one had come into his home, he decided to let his guard down and relax.

He got ready for bed. He showered, brushed his teeth, threw on sweats, and sat on his bed with a grunt of relief. In his nightstand drawer, was his main cell phone. He turned it on and let it process and wake up as he prepared to wind down. He got under the covers, his muscles aching as he sank into the mattress. He flipped open the cell phone and saw the single voicemail notification. His stomach flipped, worry a wave that took away his moment of peace.He hesitated, wondering what bad news or misfortune he’d have to confront when he checked the inbox but finally held down the 1 button and braced himself. 

You have… one… new message.”

“Hey, Mark.” Her voice broke though and all his anxiety evaporated. He sat up, ear pressed against the receiver, eagerly savoring every decibel of her voice. “ Just calling because -,” her voice trailed off, hesitation thick. And he recognized this inherent need, calling to him, pleading. His heart was skipping. “ Not to sound corny here but I miss you. Hope you’re well. Gimme a call sometime. We can catch up. Later.”

He should call her back. But it was three in the morning here. It wasn’t a good time.

What time was it in California right now? Midnight?

His phone clicked, followed by, “ To replay, press one.” 

Mark felt warm and euphoric. She missed him. She needed him. A sudden wave of pride swelled in his chest and he smirked to himself. Strahm not cutting it for you, Will? He immediately replayed the recording.

Hey, Mark, just calling because… Not to sound corny here but I miss you. I hope you’re well. Gimme a call sometime. We can catch up. Later.”

He had his eyes closed, pretending the audio was crisp and clean, as if she was sitting right next to him and not hundreds of miles away. He pretended she was resting her cheek right against his shoulder, saying this just below his ear. 

He pressed the 1 button again. “ Hey, Mark, just calling because… Not to sound corny here but I miss you. ” Her voice, by itself, reminded him how insufficient it was. He needed more of her. Where’s the box?

He kept listening to her voice, replaying the message, and went to retrieve his mementos of her. The box of all the treasures he had collected, ever since he had first met her. “I hope you’re well. Gimme a call sometime. We can catch up. Later.”

He had an old lipstick tube, the faded brass cylinder completely spent and for some reason, she had stopped using that color after she had tossed it in the waste bin by his desk in the summer of ‘89. Fired Up in the faded label declared the color. 

Hey, Mark, just calling…”

An old hair tie, satin and bright green, another symbol of that decade that she would always wear in her hair or around her wrist to control that crazy hair when she had gone through lazy periods of not taming it in the morning. Back then, she always wore her hair wild, all glamrock and crazy.

...Not to sound corny here…”

Old movie ticket stubs, of Beetlejuice and Rambo. The Silence of the Lambs and E.T. They used to go to the theaters Friday nights. He could practically smell the popcorn and cigarettes, blended with her shampoo and strawberry body spray.

“I miss you.”

Her hand written notes, mostly work reminders to him. 

Don’t forget - Grissom’s work anniversary. 

Don’t forget - bug spray tomorrow!   

Always for him. He smiled at one of her notes. One of a poorly drawn caricature of a cartoon man with steam blowing out of his ears, an arrow crudely pointed with HOFFMAN labeling the hothead. The eyes weren’t focused and the drool had been inaccurate. He used to hate that thing. But now, he smiled, his fingers continuing further into the box, pushing away the innocent contents, pausing as it brushed against the soft fabric.

“…I hope you’re well…”

It had been one of those weeks she bummed at his house, leaving her clothes all over the place, never tracking what she had brought or left at home. She had always been a hurricane with her laundry. The black laced thong was something he had known would have crossed the line - but he hadn’t been able to resist when it had greeted him under the sheets back then. She never asked for it back. She never even noticed .

Gimme a call sometime. We can catch up later.”

He felt his pants tighten and he closed the box, holding the lacy fabric in between his fingers, knowing he couldn’t control himself tonight.

 

Notes:

A/N: So much filler - went to a metal festival and it revitalized all my love for the dark and brutal of the 90s-00s. Feeling inspired, hopefully the words will flow red with glory!

Chapter 51: Peri-SAW: The Dragon In The Basement

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Eric Matthews

“Danny,” he felt awkward as his son glared down at the menu. “What looks good?”

“This is a tourist trap, Eric,” Daniel Matthews scoffed, pushing the sticky menu away from him. “It’s like you forget I was born and raised in this city? I’m a little old for Spacca Nappoli’s.”

Damn, his lungs felt like they were shrinking in his chest. He needed a cigarette. “Well, excuse me for liking their deep dish.”

His son hadn’t looked him in the eye since he picked him up that morning. When did that happen? Eric remembered just holding the kid in his palm, the tyke just a crying little guy. Where had the years gone? And why did Daniel hate him so damn much all of a sudden?

Daniel used to always annoy him with questions. When can we go to the park, Dad? Want to play? When are you coming home? Why do you always work so much? Matthews used to hate it - but now he wanted more than anything to have that version of his son back.

“Seriously, this is such a waste of time,” Daniel muttered, glaring at another table, of a couple and their daughter, who was celebrating her birthday with an embarrassed smile as the wait staff sang out of tune while holding a cake with candles lit. 

“Well, you’re stuck with me for the rest of the weekend. If your goal is to make it as unbearable and awkward as possible, you win,” Eric sighed, taking his beer and taking a long drink from it. 

“Jeeze, thanks, Dad ,” Eric folded his arms, leaned back, trying to act all cocky and cool. “It’s not like I asked to be here either.”

Eric grit his teeth but took a deep breath. He needed to be better, at least with Daniel. He was becoming a young man now. He had to set a better example. He knew he had been absolute shit for most of the kid’s life. Jane reminded him, every time they spoke. But Eric was trying now. He really was.

“How about a museum?”

Daniel suddenly gave him a wry smile. “You really want to waste time staring at some old guy’s lame paintings?”

“I don’t know. What do you like these days? Still into dinosaurs?” Eric noted his son’s track suit. Every so often he pulled out his cell phone, as though he was expecting an important phone call.

“Not since I was ten.”

“I could look and see if there’s any tickets for a game today.”

“Don’t bother, I’d rather not see us lose to the Dodgers in real life.”

“Well, I don’t know, we could catch a movie?” Movies were easy. You didn’t have to talk. Only now, the local theater recently banned smoking. He couldn’t last two hours without a smoke break these days. He’d have to step out, leaving Daniel alone.

“I guess. We could see House of Wax.”

Eric raised an eyebrow. “What’s it rated?”

Daniel rolled his eyes and sighed. “Nevermind.”

Eric felt his stomach flip. “Wait - wait, I just want to know.”

“R,” Daniel muttered, soft and defeated.

He knew he was losing him and he doubted he’d find another thing that would get his son interested. “Well, if you just don’t tell your mom, maybe we can.”

Daniel looked at him, for the first time, eyes heavy with distrust. Underneath that calloused look there was a faint twinkle of hope. “Yeah?”

“It’s all fake effects anyway. You sure you’re up for it, though?” Eric had heard some of the boys at the office say it was a standard slasher flick - though he hadn’t paid much attention to the latest trailers. He barely watched TV anymore. 

“I mean, yeah, I’m up for it.” Daniel was now leaning forward, the faintest of smiles emerging, the boy’s features had changed. From cherub softness to sharp angles, his adult face was emerging, larger and stronger. Eric recognized the face his son was growing into and it felt as though he was looking in a time-traveling mirror. It was only Jane’s eyes that marked the difference. Beautiful, but cold with betrayal.

And then that familiar breeze of regret blew by him, sucking the air out of his lungs and reminding him on just how much he had lost.

“Then it’s settled. We’ll check it out after we eat. Any ideas on how to kill time while we wait?”

“There’s that new arcade that opened up,” Daniel added again, and Eric smiled with a nod.

“Sounds like a plan.”

 

Will Maddox

“How the hell’ve you been, Freckles?” Homie Martinez had transformed from the young, fit, handsome twenty-something year old into a bald muffin-shaped middle aged man. Despite the clear years of stress-eating, the charming gleam in his warm smile set her nerves at ease and brought a smile to Will’s face.

“Homie,” she came in to shake his calloused hand, noting the cigarette stains on his fingers and graying mustache. “I see you’ve made Captain. That’s fantastic.”

“Shaved off a few years of my life getting there. Wouldn’t recommend it. Cost me my hair and alimony.” He laughed, a slight wheeze in his throat. “And look at this guy. Is this your partner, Freckles? Tall, dark, and handsome. Man, wouldn’t want to cross you with him as your shadow.”

“Special Agent Peter Strahm,” Peter shook hands, eyebrows furrowed but smile wide. It was his natural state, Will knew. Probing, masked polite. “Will’s told me a lot about you. It’s nice to put a face to the name.”

“Well, wish I had a picture on hand on how I used to be. I had the ladies lining up back in the day, before marriage and divorce had its way with me.” He laughed and Will smiled with good humor despite the underlying awkwardness of the tense news. She had liked Homie’s wife, Ysabel. She wondered what had happened. 

“Sorry to hear about it,” her voice holding the faintest hint of the overwhelming empathy that swelled inside her. Out of all the experiences in her life, heartbreak was one of the worst. She refused to think about him. Not while working.

“Don’t worry, we both just grew apart. It happens to most of us.” Homie’s demeanor dampened briefly, with the subtle squint of his gaze. He was always a sharp one, having taught her how to keep an eye out for the right curl of the lip or shift in posture to detect when someone was on the brink of a juicy secret. “How is Frank?” He tried to sound light but Will knew there was an edge to his question. She remembered the many rumors that buzzed about her marriage, back when she was a rookie. 

Will cleared her throat. “We also - divorced.” She kept her face a smooth canvas, devoid of reflecting the memory of Frank’s blackened, shriveled corpse on the steel table.

His stare softened into relief. “Well, good for you. I didn’t like how Frank treated you. A man should treat his woman with respect, right FBI? Good riddance.”

“Will deserves so much more,” Strahm agreed, becoming warmer to the officer as he turned to throw her a look that was all knowing and gentle with compassion. Will felt her cheeks flushed, folding her arms, glad for the distraction of the snow globe of a roller coaster on Homie’s desk. It looked like it was from the Mission Bay boardwalk but Will couldn’t be sure.

“So how’s out east, Freckles?”

“Cold. Rains all the time. And busy.”

“I hear. The Jigsaw Killer, that guy’s such a clown. Total gringo theatrics. Impractical. You’d think he’d slip with all the Why haven't you guys caught him yet?”

She bit her lip, wanting to defend the Metropolitan Police Department. “Sadly, he’s one of the smart ones. He’s a clown that knows what he’s doing.”

“The FBI helping you? Like in the Heart Stealer Case?”

Will blinked. “You know about that?”

Homie beamed. “Of course. I try to keep up with the current news. Especially when one of our own hits nationwide news. You’re famous around here, Freckles. You gotta tell me how it all went down tonight over drinks. So you working the Jigsaw case, too?”

“The FBI are not involved yet,” Strahm was using his political voice, strong in tone but vague in words. “We have faith in the Metropolitan Police Department’s abilities. The Jigsaw Killer will not likely be operating for long.”

“That’s good. I hear some of the shit he pulls, at least on this side of the border, would make you lose your lunch.”

“It does remind me of working cases here. I still get nightmares about that face skinning case, back when I was a rookie.”

“Yeah, that was a rough one, for me too. That shit will haunt me forever.” 

“Face skinning?” Strahm asked, politely, his lip curled in anticipated disgust. Martinez’s gaze grew distant at the memory. Will, too, grimaced to herself.

“A method of torture the cartel performs,“ Will would not go into detail and hoped Strahm wouldn’t inquire. She hated the memory - the stretched out leather that had been a young man’s face, cleanly peeled off and stitched to a soccer ball. Nearby his maggot-bloated body had been found. The face had been removed pre-mortem. Apparently, the ball had been reported to be kicked around by the neighborhood kids until someone realized what was wrong. One of those kids had been the victim’s son.

She felt Strahm’s gaze, curious and probing. She knew he would ask about this later. Her time at the San Diego Police Department had been riddled with pain and longing. She had kept her life to herself as much as possible. Not even Mark had known the gorey details. He never pushed for them, always sensitive to her need to cling to the pieces of her past that were hers and hers alone. But Will knew Peter would pry. Peter liked to push her, despite how much it pissed her off. Maybe it was some psychological method to help her ‘grow’ as he’d like to lecture she needed to do more of. She trusted he knew what was best for her, mentally. It was his area of expertise, after all. 

She chose to change the subject. “So you still in Homicide?”

“Nope, went to Narcotics. I was tired of the crime scenes. Too many kids. Made me think of my little Jose.”

“I don’t blame you. But I remember you said you hated rubbing elbows with the DEA.”

Martinez chuckled. “I changed. Comes with being a father. Though some days, it’s hard to see how pissy feds can get. No offense, FBI.”

Strahm acted in good humor, a smirk on his mouth. “None taken.””

“So what brings you here, Freckles? You FBI now?”

“Sorry to disappoint. We’re not here for official business. I’m on leave, investigating a personal case.”

Martinez looked unsurprised. He already knew. “Your parents?”

She nodded, lips pulled tight. “Word gets out fast.”

“You know how it is here. Can’t keep secrets, especially if you flash a badge at one of the prisons. Warden and the Comissioner go to the same country club. Glad you brought some back up, though. FBI. It’ll help. You know how it is. ”

“Sorry, tell me how it is here, exactly.” Peter stepped forward, voice holding a hint of authority and challenge. Will winced. He held himself as though he could face anything and win. When she first met him, she thought it was heroic. But this was one wall he could not make crumble, no matter how hard he blew at it. He was an idealist. But Will had learned early on how the real world worked.

“Probably not a good place for that,” Will gave a warning mutter.

“You’ll tell me later, then?” He had lowered his voice, but in front of Homie, it was unlikely they’d pass anything between just the two of them.

Another personality trait Will had begun to be irked by - was Peter’s aggressive need to be involved in every detail and aspect of her life, past and present. He had insisted on coming here, despite her protest. He didn’t like not knowing. Maybe it was also this feeling of being left out - of Will’s comfort and familiarity in this place that made Peter feel like an outsider. But sometimes, she wished he would let her take the lead. 

Hoffman and I would at least take turns, that familiar childish whine in the back of her head reminded her but she shoved it down, trying to remember she had a crime to solve. Past partnerships were just that, the past. Constantly comparing one man with another wouldn’t accomplish anything. She put a hand on Peter’s arm and shook her head, hoping he’d back down. His nostrils flared. He was unhappy. She knew this. But now was not the time.

Will regretted keeping her personal business to herself at that moment. She should have told him before they got there. For now, he’d have to just trust her and let her take the lead. Eyes and ears were all around. She knew it had been dangerous coming here - but sometimes the seriousness did not weigh heavy on her, until she found herself swimming in it all again to realize too late she was in chum filled waters. 

“Is it overstepping if I ask for your help, Homie?”

“Not at all, Freckles. Not for an old partner. You know Gomez brings you up still? You broke his heart when you left. After that, he stopped caring who he pissed off. The man’s gone martyr on us.” Home got to his feet, his chair squeaking. “Come on, I’ll take you to his desk. You’ll make his week when he sees you.” 

Will and Peter followed Homie through the building’s clean and well kept halls. She remembered the Spanish trabadillo, the historical tile floors, and the large windows that teased the bright blue sky crosshatched with palm and eucalyptus leaves surrounding the building. The familiar smell of the janitor’s preference for lemon scented cleaner and burnt coffee hit her with strong nostalgic waves that briefly jerked her back to her youth.

They went down to the basement. This made Will’s eyebrow rise. What did Gomez do? Banishment to the evidence storage unit located in the dank basement was reserved for those who pissed off the wrong people but had done nothing to justify dismissal. 

The faint jazz music and the masculine voice humming along made her smile. Javier Gomez was bent over a file cabinet, pulling up bundles of folders and tossing them on the desk behind him with a sigh. He froze and straightened at the sight of his visitors.

Wide eyes squinted. “Maddox?” His surprise melted into warmth and he walked over and threw his arms around her in a tight hug. “Will Maddox? Is that you?”

She hugged the stocky man, patting his back, letting out an exaggerated grunt as he squeezed her tightly. He always hugged like a bear and he still used the same aftershave she remembered. “Gomez, still listening to Weather Report?”

“They’ll make a comeback, I know it. Beats that weird punk arthouse shit you would insist I try. Broken glass for two minutes straight is not music.”

“Says you,” she laughed, so happy he remembered her. She bit her lip, taking in the lines around his eyes and the hint of glaucoma clouding his pupils. He was now in his sixties. He had been one of the good ones. He had inspired her to become a police officer. He had been her mentor, when she first started off. And he had been assigned lead detective of her mother’s homicide, back when she was fourteen. 

“Sorry, have we met?”

“No. Special Agent Peter Strahm.” Peter and Gomez shook hands, sizing each other up, though Gomez had a tired and vulnerable smile while Peter remained stoic and guarded. 

“Will, you FBI now?”

“No.”

“Not yet,” Peter was playful. “She’s currently being recruited.”

“Not a bad gig. Good pension. Where in the FBI, Mr. Strahm?”

“Behavioral Sciences.”

“Oh,” Gomez’s jovial demeanor stiffened. “I’m sorry to hear that.”

Peter nodded, an understanding between them. “Someone’s got to do it.”

Gomez nodded. “Welcome to my humble office. It’s all mine. The view is terrible but the air conditioning is top notch. And, well, let me address the elephant in the room - yes, I’ve been left in the dungeon. Locked in and key tossed away.”

“What happened, Gomez?” Will asked, incredulous. “You always loved being in the field.”

“It’s not so bad. Safer down here. And, more important to our leadership, away from the press. This is all because I embarrassed Dragna back in ‘96 one fateful charity. He was bragging about some case we had just closed. A case I was on. I knew it had been handled poorly. So I… pointed it out. Dragna didn’t like that, one bit. Made him look bad in front of his golfing friends. Also, it didn’t matter. Turns out he made Comissioner the following year. Should have thought of that, before running my mouth. Oh well, live and learn. I couldn’t up and move. Couldn’t do that to the wife and kids. Besides, it let me focus more on my home life. I woodwork now.”

“Oh, Gomez, you tried to take on Dragna?” Will knew Chet Dragna had been trouble. Everyone had known this. He was a major reason she had left California.

“I don’t like bullies. And I wanted him to know he couldn’t always get away with things. Well, my retirement is in six months. Joke’s on him. He couldn’t break me. Because despite how dirty this establishment is, I sleep good every night, knowing I do my best. And in the end, that’s all we can do.”

“Proud of you.” Will smiled, hiding the sadness she felt for him. Javier had always been a bit goofy and eccentric. But he was a good cop. A kind man. And a person who truly wanted to help.

“It warms my heart to see you, looking like the lean, mean, fighting machine I remember you as. A little gray in the temples, but makes you look wiser. And - check this out.” Gomez turned and went to a nearby chunk of corkboard, held up by twine to some old metal cabinets. Old newspaper clippings were attached, some of Gomez’s earlier accomplishments. But others, caught her eye:

METROPOLITAN POLICE TEAM UP WITH FBI TO CATCH HEART STEALER.

HEART STEALER RESCUE

DETECTIVE LIEUTENANT WILHELMINA MADDOX RECEIVES AWARD FOR DEDICATION TO SERVICE, CLOSING RECORD NUMBER CASES

TONI ROSELLO, DEAD

“I had no idea the Union-Tribune published these stories.”

“Some were from the Times or smaller news outlets,” Gomez explained. “I admit, I look you up every couple of years, wanting to see whether or not you’ve made Comissioner or not.”

Will resisted the urge to laugh, not sure if Gomez was serious. She had once told Gomez she planned on making Comissioner before she hit fifty. But that was back when she was in her early twenties - thinking it would be possible, because she would work and work until she achieved it.

She was now forty, and she was only Detective Sergeant. She hoped she’d make Captain, at least. But she wasn’t political enough to ever dream of being appointed Comissioner. 

“I never knew you were shooting for Comissioner,” Strahm quietly stated, his tone low and stern. 

“You never asked,” she responded, suddenly finding a flame in her chest ignite. She still had plenty of years ahead of her and she knew there was still a lot she could do when she returned. And then it hit her. She wanted to return to work. Seeing everyone, milling about, the familiar yet distant faces made her pine for her friends and colleagues. “I’m honored, Gomez, that you kept track of all of this. Thank you.”

“I’m happy to see you’re doing great things, Will. I knew you made the right call back then.”

She nodded, swallowing. She still felt the guilt, knowing she had abandoned him when she transferred twenty odd years ago. 

“So what can I do for you? Are you here just for old times sake? Could have spared you the stress of dealing with those goons up topside and just called me. Let me treat you to a good meal. Maria would love to see you, and you two can catch up.”

“That sounds lovely. But I am here for a case.”

Attention sharpened in the old man’s gaze. “Oh? What kind of work?” There was a knowing tone, a tremor. And Will hesitated.

The case,” Homie interjected, knowing why both she and Javier froze. “Her mother.”

“I always wondered when you would try. You used to talk about wanting to close it. But Dragna always made your life difficult when you started poking around.”

“He made all our lives difficult, Javier. Don’t feel bad. He’d never let me work my mother’s case.”

“Maybe it was because the case is personal. And your objectivity would be in question,” Strahm suggested.

“No,” Homie, Gomez, and Will all promptly responded in unison, their voice caught together in a distinct truth. 

Strahm blinked, nodded. “I see.”

“Dragna has always been weird about this specific case,” Will explained.

“How so?” 

“Well, first, he assigned it to me. Back when I was a rookie without a partner. And already completely swamped with patrol duties,” Gomez responded, old anger rising in his voice.

Strahm blinked. “No senior detectives available?” 

Homie cleared his throat and shuffled around, looking away. Will knew it was from the shame of their department.

“That’s part of the mystery of my mother’s murder. Out of all the cases I’ve seen investigated by this department - I always felt like this case was getting buried or mishandled. I know Gomez tried everything he could to solve it - I know you did, Gomez - but it was too much for one person. I know he wasn’t getting the proper support.

“They didn’t even have forensics available to analyze the evidence,” Will added, nostrils flaring at the memory. “Gomez had to sweep the crime scene, deliver the evidence, and - always - the labs would never take the time to look at it.”

“I’m sorry, Will. I should have done something different. I just don’t know what.” There was true remorse in his voice. But Will never held it against him - never Gomez. But the department? Hell yes . Something fishy had been going on and not knowing had driven Will mad in the past. It was what made her know before she graduated high school that she would be a cop. And she tried with everything she had to solve it - until Dragna had her in his sights - so she had simply given up and fled the state. 

Gomez bowed his head in shame, his older voice gravelly. “I made that promise to you, back when you were still a kid. That I’d catch them. But then they classified it as a cold case and took me off.” 

“Strange. What did IA say about this?”

Will snorted. “IA concluded the investigation was being operated within the resources and capabilities based on the current funding and expertise of the task force. Just political nonsense to try to milk for a higher budget the next fiscal year. When Gomez told me they were going to stop investigating, I was a senior in high school. So when I graduated, I signed up and went to the police academy. Got hired on. The rest is history.”

“If there’s some conspiracy to bury your mother’s case, how were you hired here?”

“See, that’s the thing - I almost wasn’t. Dragna personally denied my application.”

“Why?”

“At first, I thought it was a discrimination case,” Will said, “But he hired other women police officers. With lower scores and performance reports across the board. It didn’t make sense.

“Until I went over his head.” Gomez added, “He was only Captain Dragna back then, and even back then he thought he was too important to have his commands overruled. I threatened to go to the press. That got IA’s attention. After that, it took an IA investigation to conclude that Will was being unfairly discriminated against. Her resume had all requirements and was well above and beyond her competitors. Best marksman in her class. She was top performer of the female division. No negative marks. So they agreed and she was hired. That pissed Dragna off real good,” he chuckled, scratching his head. “And Will requested being assigned the cold cases. That, really made Dragna’s ears start to smoke.”

“Normally, detectives try to avoid taking on cold cases. You would think a volunteer would be given free reign,” Strahm commented.

“I agree,” Homie piped in. “It was odd, how Dragna seems to have it in for Will.”

“I was told I was not experienced enough to handle the cold cases. And after promotion to Detective, I was still denied. I still tried to get access to the cold case files - volunteered to take it on during my off duty hours - but was always stonewalled.”

“So how’d you get the files now, if the department blacklisted you?” Strahm seemed furious, now, for Will. But his question held apprehension, as if he had caught her doing something she shouldn’t have.

She narrowed her eyes. “Hoffman.”

“Oh, that was the gentleman who called me. Mark Hoffman?” Homie looked surprised. “He didn’t say he knew you..”

“Yeah. He’s my partner back at MPD. If not for me, why’d you help him?”

There was a shift in Homie’s demeanor, as if he looked uncomfortable. Even nervous. “I knew his older partner, Knox.”

Will nodded, a rush of excitement followed by a sobering wave of sadness filled her. “I knew Knox.” The world felt smaller that moment, as though their universes were more linked together than they had believed. This entire time, Martinez and Knox had known each other. 

Martinez sighed. “A shame what happened to him. Worked a case with him, back in - oh, ‘56? ‘57? No, ‘55. Loan shark ring that operated in thirty counties, from California to New York. Anyways - Hoffman requested the files - said their department has a high number of cold cases with break ins involving the murder of a female. Said your mother’s case had similar MO. He said he was studying nationwide cases from around the time yours took place, trying to find patterns in unsolved cases with a possible serial killer. Dragna approved, thought it would be good for press if we cooperated with your department. You guys are experts at dealing with them these days, so I sent him the files.”

Will beamed, proud of her partner. Mark always had a way of finding details when he set his mind to it. He had pulled through for her.

“Is there be a problem, our handling of these files that were transferred to another officer in her department?” Strahm, always methodical and responsible, sounded tense and on the edge of being angry. He had been angry about her acquiring the file, though she still didn’t understand why.

“Not legally, we’re all supposed to help each other, you see.” Gomez sighed. “But if he knew, he’d be pissed. But don’t worry, he’s too busy to micromanage every case file, I doubt he’ll find out.”

“Too late,” a voice made all heads whirl around.

Will swallowed but squared her shoulders. Chet Dragna stepped forth from the shadows, his yellow hair now silver and his still handsome square face was now heavily lined with age and stress. He was wearing his dress uniform, pressed and pristine, with a stern frown.

“Sir,” Homie straightened and Will felt the tension flood the room.

“Why are there civilians in our evidence room, Detective Lieutenant?”

“Not civilians, Captain,” Gomez reported, a lick of defiance in his voice, “You know Detective Sergeant Maddox and this is Special Agent Strahm, of the FBI.”

“May I see your credentials,” Dragna kept staring at Will as they both showed their badges. Dragna took both and looked at them closely and for a long drawn out pause. 

“You’ve come a long way, Maddox. Your city’s metropolitan borders are far from here. Several thousands of miles, I believe. Not quite your territory.”

“And my territory, Captain?” Strahm stepped in, nostrils flared, standing eye-to-eye to Dragna. 

“Yes, thank you for reminding me. May I ask why the Federal Government is in my basement?”

She looked up at him, knowing it was futile to waste trying to smooth things over. They were busted. She had hoped they could avoid him. 

How did I forget this is how it is? Dragna - the Dragon as she used to secretly call him - could make her feel both small and pathetic at the same time. Dragna had always been a man she had feared and had once desperately wished for his approval. She used to think he just didn’t like her because of some preconceived notions she could one day change.Thankfully, she did not have expecatitons like that anymore. He was just a prick. “I am independently investigating the murder of Josephine Maddox and the assault of Jules Maddox back in 1981.”

He did not look taken aback but he closed his eyes for a brief moment. “And you are wasting tax dollars by disturbing my men on a case that is not under your jurisdiction because…?”

“These are public records,” she shoved back the insecurities that built in her chest. “I’m simply asking for your cooperation.”

Dragna looked down at her, narrowing his eyes. “Have you submitted the FOIA request?”

“That’s why I’m here,” Will kept locking eyes with him, forcing herself to keep tough in this. “I’m just here to file for LCH access.”

“I’m sure that’s all you’re here for. You’d do best to watch yourself, Maddox. I warned you, twenty years ago, what would happen if you got in the way of the good work this department does. That warning still stands.”

“I’m aware.” But twenty years ago, I was young, dumb, and scared of you. “I intend to follow policy every step of the way. You don’t need to worry.” She even gave him a smile, knowing he would hate that. “And I’ll be sure to not waste your men’s time doing so.”

“Be sure that you do.” He turned to leave. “I won’t hesitate to make your life a living hell if you become a nuisance again, Maddox. Out of good faith, I’m not having you escorted off the premises.”

“There’s no need for the hostility,” Strahm added, glaring as he eyed the man up and down. “We’re simply trying to give a family who lost a loved one closure.”

“I understand, Special Agent. And I hope you do find closure, Maddox. I hope you find it and live with it, for the rest of your days.”

“Uh, Dragna - sorry, but I think we have a two o’clock we need to keep,” Martinez stepped forward, giving a pained smile to Will. 

“That, we do. Best of luck,” his voice was dismissive as he turned to leave, Martinez nodded a farewell as he left with Dragna.

Will sighed as Peter muttered, “He’s pleasant.”

“At least he’s letting it go,” she muttered. “For now.”

“Well, it’s not like he’s got much to stand on if he tried to just kick you out for trying to access public record the right way. But it’s clear he’s no friend to us,” Peter’s eyes held question and curiosity. “Care to explain?”

“Maybe later.” Will did not want to dive into the memories. “Let’s just do what we need to get in and get out. I’ll explain later.”

Notes:

A/N: This was a hard one to write through - Will's backstory has always kind of been this convoluted knotball that I'm still working on unraveling right. Don't worry, she and Hoffman will be back on their adventures. Can you tell Strahm's starting to wear out his welcome?

In the meantime, hope Eric Matthews' opening angst can help feed your SAW canon needs.

Chapter 52: Peri-SAW: Willful Reasons

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dr. Lawrence Gordon

Lawrence blinked, his vision blurred as he struggled to make sense of his surroundings. The pain was a white-hot fire coursing through his body, each heartbeat a hammer blow against his shattered nerves.

And then, as his eyes adjusted to the dim light of the warehouse, he saw them. The old man from before, who had splashed water on his face, was watching him with a small grin. 

“Good morning, Doctor Gordon.”

Behind him stood a thin and beady-eyed woman, her face stoic with indifference.

“My name is John. You’ve survived my game, Doctor Gordon,” John’s voice cut through the silence like a knife, his words heavy with meaning. “You’ve been reborn, given a second chance at life. Do you understand?”

Lawrence nodded, his mind racing as he struggled to find a way out of this nightmare. He was lightheaded but knew he had to play along, to placate Jigsaw and his accomplices long enough to find an opportunity to escape.

“Of course, John,” Lawrence croaked, his voice low and gravel-like as the pain threatened to overwhelm him. “I’m… grateful for the chance to start anew.”

As he spoke, Lawrence cast a sidelong glance at the woman, his mind working overtime to devise a plan. He needed to gain their trust, to convince them that he was no threat, that he was willing to cooperate if it meant securing his freedom.

“I fear,” he spoke with careful measurement, “that my recovery will require more than what this warehouse can offer. I need medical attention. Proper care for my amputated leg.”

The woman’s eyebrow arched in skepticism, her eyes narrowing as she regarded Lawrence with suspicion. “And what exactly do you need that we can’t provide, doctor ?” she asked, her voice laced with a hint of menace.

His mind raced as he searched for an answer, a way to convince these people that he needed to leave. “I need… specialized equipment,” he improvised, his words coming in a rush. “Well, I appear to be stable. But how long has it been? Days?” He had no idea but it was unlikely he would be able to reattach the foot if it was over twelve hours. “Surgery to ligate my blood vessels. The wound needs to be cleaned to remove debris and contaminants. And the pain.” He winced as another throb struck through him. “I need to go to a hospital where they have the resources to properly care for me.”

The woman scoffed, her eyes cold and unyielding. “We have everything you need right here, doctor,” she spat, her voice dripping with contempt. “You’re not going anywhere.”

His heart sank. John turned to the woman. “Amanda, you can go. I will call for you if you are needed.”

Amanda begrudgingly nodded and stalked off. 

“Forgive her, Doctor, she’s still learning. It is not easy, what we do.” John reached over and took a cloth from a bowl of water, wrung it, and dabbed Lawerence’s brow.

“What about Adam?” Lawrence asked, remembering his cellmate. “Did he make it?”

“I’m afraid not.”

“Really?”

“The rules were clear. There was to be only one survivor.” 

Gordon leaned back into the pillow, unsure of what lay in store for him next. He said promised he would come back for him. But if Adam was gone, there wasn’t much of a point. And honestly, Gordon wanted nothing to do with that bathroom ever again.

“What are you going to do with me?”

“Let us focus on healing, Doctor. Once you’re in the proper… condition… you will be free to go.”

Lawrence swallowed back fear as John smiled at him with a cold humor that filled his stomach with shards of ice. And as he stared into the sallow cheeks, the sharp gauntness of his face, and the lines that had creased deeper since he last saw him, that was when Lawrence knew.

“You’re one of my patients,” he whispered, suddenly wide awake, and trembling. “Y-you’re…” He said his name was John. What was his last name? Damn it, Lawrence, why do you remember he has a frontal lobe tumor but not his damn last name? Inoperable, due to the late stage colon cancer. Lawrence remembered the x-rays. The MRI scans.

“Yes, you know me. And now, I’m sure you will remember me from now on.”

What was that jingle I would conjure up whenever he called with questions? It was that TV show. Seinfeld. Right. His name reminded me of Seinfeld. Because it’s… KRAMER.

“I will, John Kramer.” Lawrence was relieved when Jigsaw nodded, a vindication in the curl of his lip.

“Yes. Now you remember. Appreciate that all life is so precious and fragile. When you return to yours, your family, your practice, I’m sure you will give those around you the appreciation they deserve.” The left side of his face must have been numb. When he spoke, his facial expression was less pronounced, as expected with his late stage.

“You should be resting, John,” Lawrence let the doctor in him take over. “When was the last time you’ve been examined by a physician?”

“There’s no need to fret over my condition, doctor. It’s too late for me. But not for you. Now. We have to address an unpleasant topic on… disinfectant.”

Gordon followed his captor’s gaze down to the stump of his leg and already he knew what was needed to be done. The gauze was a temporary fix but he would need extensive antiseptic and antibiotics. “This should be done at the hospital.”

“Normally, I would agree. But we are not done talking.” John got up and slowly made his way to a metal cabinet, a coughing fit filling the silence. “And we have everything a hospital provides. And you, of all people, will know what is needed to be done and soon.”

Gordon leaned back, sighing. “Let’s be frank here. What do you intend to do with me?”

John laughed and pulled out a bottle of what looked like rubbing alcohol. This made Lawerence begin to sweat. He was no stranger to the pain of others. But his amputated foot meant damaged nerves. This would be truly an agonizing process when John decided it was time to apply the antiseptic to his stump. 

“Frankly, I intend to keep you alive and set you free. And what do you intend to do when you leave here?”

He thought about it. “I want to see my wife and daughter.” Was Diana all right? Would Alison forgive him? He wanted to make things right with her. To start over. And as John studied him, he knew he would have to give little to the police. If John let him go. “I just want to go back to my life.”

John nodded. “Your past life is gone. You gave up your pound of flesh in that bathroom. I know you will not take this second chance for granted. You have awoken. Reborn.” He returned to his bedside, placing the bottle on the surgical table, and lowering the lamp to illuminate both their faces better. “You have experienced my method of rehabilitation close and personal. You know its powerful result. What I have shown you, I intend to show to others. Other lost souls, defeated by the world and burdening those around them. Since we’re being candid with each other, I must tell you that my work will continue. Even after I’m gone. And I am looking for others to carry on my work.”

Lawrence’s eyes widened, wondering if this was how John had pulled the other two to do his bidding. Amanda, he vaguely remembered now, had been a survivor as well. The first, back at the police department. And the other - what was his name again?

“Others, with great skill and resources,” John finished, waiting for Lawrence to respond. 

“So you want me to join you?” The old Lawrence Gordon would have scoffed. He would have thought this man insane. He is . And yet Lawrence no longer felt that emptiness he had carried within him, this feeling of complete apathetic detachment to the world. Lawrence felt more alive in that moment than any memory could conjure. He smelled the strong acrid chemicals, and heard the gentle whoosh of the industrial fans overhead and the electric click of the light bulbs. And even though his leg was hacked off and the pain was a direct onslaught that never eased, he still was buzzing with the relief of being alive.

“Your skills as a medical professional will help prolong my life and allow our more elaborate methods to be implemented.”

Lawrence’s head was spinning. “You want me to help you kidnap people? Chain them in dark rooms and force them to solve elaborate puzzles? Am I to lie on the floor pretending to be a corpse while observing them?”

John was smiling, amused. “No, nothing of that sort. But I need to know you are someone I can call upon when you are needed.”

“I… I’ll need to think about it. I don’t know what I can do until I can go back and see my family.” He would agree with this maniac, just to be let go. He’d promise him the moon at this point. But he had to show a little resistance. To be convincing.

John nodded. “You will have all the time in the world to think, Doctor.” John turned and took a rag. “Now, it’s time to brace yourself. Would you like something to bite down on? This will be… a great deal for you.”

Lawrence nodded. “Please.”

John got up and retrieved a piece of leather and put it in Lawrence’s mouth. He clamped down, the leather oily and firm in his mouth. He watched as John soaked the rag in rubbing alcohol.

“This will sting a bit.” And then John hoisted Lawrence’s thigh around one arm and began pressing onto the stump hard.

Lawrence let out a deep gasp, trying to contain himself but completely helpless to the hypersensitive area being ravaged by the alcohol. A scream seared through his clenched teeth and echoed off the concrete.

 

Amanda Young

It had been five days. She knew he had access to water. But the idea of him, hungry, in the dark, slowly starving to death haunted Amanda. It had kept her up at night. She had tried to distract herself from these thoughts.

She paced the dimly lit room, her heart heavy with the weight of her mentor’s command.

“You will leave him to suffer the consequences.”

John Kramer forbade her from releasing Adam. She had asked in passing, to just let him go. It had been foolish, she knew, and he had not earned it. But she had a moment of weakness. She wanted the guy to not suffer anymore.

She glanced at the clock on the wall, its ticking echoing like a death knell in the silence that hung heavy in the air. Five days. Five days of agony, of despair, in the dark, not knowing whether the next minute he would finally cease to feel the delirium and hunger gnawing his stomach.

Amanda’s fingers clenched into fists at her sides, her nails biting into her palms as she fought against the urge to defy her mentor’s orders. She couldn’t bear to think of his pain echoing through the empty corners of her consciousness any longer.

But she was not a murderer, not really. She was an apprentice to Jigsaw, and Jigsaw never killed anyone. What about mercy? But even she had her limits. As the hours dragged on, she would occasionally go down to the bathroom, just to press her ear against the door. 

Adam had persisted in screams and cries for the first day, non-stop, a maddening guttural horror that haunted her nightmares. But now, it was all quiet. She found herself teetering on the edge of a moral precipice, torn between her loyalty to John and her sense of humanity.

When she returned to try to get some sleep, Mark Hoffman’s presence greeted her, a storm cloud casting a shadow over her already troubled mind. The air suddenly thickened as though full of smoke.

“You know, Amanda,” Hoffman sneered, voice dripping with disdain, “if you had any guts, you’d put the poor bastard out of his misery instead of slinking down and feeling sorry for him. But I guess that’s asking too much from a coward like you.”

She clenched her jaw in anger, her fists trembling at her sides as she fought to maintain her composure. She wanted to just swing her fist and break the fucker’s nose. “At least I feel sorry, unlike you, Hoffman,” she shot back, her voice cold and venomous. “You heartless prick.”

He smirked. “What do I care about some asshole? Maybe you just don’t have it in you for this kind of work.”

But even as they traded insults, Amanda knew Hoffman’s words held a grain of truth. She couldn’t shake the feeling that she was betraying John by having these… weak feelings.

It had been months since the voice in the back of her mind began reminding her that there was always a way to make the pain go away. Always a way to just not think about it. But all her dealers were dead. And John will know if I start using again . And she had beaten her addiction. She had a way of getting around that itch in her arms and that twitch in her fingers whenever she thought of that sweet, warm, euphoria that used to slide into her veins like the gentle bite of velcro. She dug out her box of supplies, careful to not make a sound, and kept casting nervous eyes at the shadows and corners in case John or Hoffman were watching. Her new fixation, that same puncture of the skin, that same rush of adrenaline, was now released with the slow and methodical press and drag of the blade into her flesh. The bite was eye-watering but it helped still her mind and gave her that brief reprieve she so desperately needed. Afterward, after bandaging her wrists, she tried to go back to sleep.

More hours passed, she lay in bed and unable to sleep, and when she finally heard Hoffman’s footsteps announce his departure, she got back up and finally decided on what she would do.

She went back to the bathroom. She went, opened the sliding door, and approached Adam. One step and pause. Another. Her hands trembled with a mixture of fear and desperation, the burden of her actions bearing down like a bolder, reflected with each thump in her chest. Along each step into the dark, dank bathroom, her resolve wavered, her mind short-circuited with doubt and self-loathing, but still, she pressed onward.

When she reached him and knelt to touch his skin, he felt cold but when she put her fingers under his nose, he was still breathing. Her heart sank. 

“Adam,” she whispered, her eyes glistening with tears. He jerked to consciousness, her flashlight beam revealing delirium as he looked at her, not recognizing who she was.

She felt another wave of grief as she bowed her head in shame. “Here.” She pulled him off the bathroom wall. “I can help you.” She dug out of her pocket the plastic bag. “I’m gonna free you,” she whispered as she pulled the bag over his face and head, wrapping it around his throat tightly. 

He suddenly jerked and began to fight her. But he was weak. The sound of his grunts and moans echoed in her ears like a symphony of despair. As she tightened the plastic she felt something inside her snap, the fragile thread of sanity severed as she kept the bag in her grip, waiting for Adam to stop flailing against her like a suffocating fish in the darkness. Each gasp made her sob. The flashlight’s beam had pointed right at his face, the bag pressed against him, the eyes wide and watching her.

She let out a low cry. At that moment, Adam’s life slipped away beneath her hands and he relaxed in her arms. A whirlwind of emotion swirled around her like a hurricane in the night. She was no Jigsaw, no master of saving humanity from its deplorableness, but a common murderer, driven by her demons to commit this act. And yet, even as she accepted the darkness that lurked within her, a part of her clung to the hope that this was the right way. This was saving Adam. This was helping him. This was her way. 

Eventually, she released him and let his heavy body slump down to the cold tiles. With a cry of anguish, she pulled away, her body wracked with grief as she stared into the darkness, knowing this was what she was. A broken soul lost, forever condemned.

They all were. 

She pressed her palms into her eyes and let out a guttural wail, letting the echo of her voice swallow her whole.



Mark Hoffman

“Want some?”’

Hoffman turned, seeing the outstretched cardboard cup full of soggy french fries, following the delicate hand he recognized as soon as he saw the slight crookedness in the middle finger from when she dislocated it from punching a perp in the jaw and the heirloom gold ring that had once been her mother’s. 

“Will?” He asked, confused, realizing he was in his car, and she was sitting there chewing on junk food and giving him a curious eyebrow raise.

“Yeah? Everything all right? You got to stay sharp, now, Mark. The perp’s due to make a move any minute now.” She thrust her chin forward and Hoffman turned to the hazy distance. It was a foggy night, in some unknown part of the city. He tried to squint to see where they were surveilling. 

“Remind me again what we’re doing?”

She laughed. “Geeze, I told you to get some sleep last night. It’s Jigsaw, remember? Our informant says he and his lackeys are supposed to make a move around this time.”

His heart skipped. “I thought you were in San Diego?”

“What are you talking about? Seriously, you’re making me worried.” She turned, wiped her greasy fingers on her pants, and pressed the back of her fingers onto his forehead. They were ice cold. He smelled smoke.

“You’re burning up, Mark. Shit, I think you’re sick.”

He was close to her, so close he could see the flecks of amber in her irises. He was burning up. He felt as though his insides were on fire.

“Yeah, must be.” He didn’t understand but only knew that she shouldn’t be there. She should not be looking for Jigsaw.

“Do you wish you could turn back time?”

He was sweating. Roasting. She was glowing.

“Every damn day.”

“Why?” she whispered and that smell of burning grew stronger.

He couldn’t find the words to explain. Maybe it was because it was her. Maybe it was because if he started, he would have to explain more. And she would ask questions, as she always did.

“I don’t know.”

“You know.” And then she pulled out her gun and pointed it at him, eyes now aflame, and he felt himself heating up.

He looked down the barrel of her 9mm Smith & Wesson, the compact revolver she always kept on her, even if it meant putting it in an inner thigh holster if she went out in one of those skimpy dresses he enjoyed seeing her in, and he closed his eyes.

So this is it.

“How’s my aim, Mark?”

He opened his eyes.

They were standing at the gun range, his vision tinted with his safety glasses as he watched Will stand straight and tall while waiting for the marksmanship evaluation to begin. She had her hand against her holster, the weapon now secure at her hip.

“Three. Two. One. Live Fire.”

She quickly pulled her gun out of her holster and began shooting at the paper target down the range, emptying her magazine.

“Take.”

The whirl of the paper being wound back to where they stood and the clear shot of the bullets concentrated at the heart of the silhouette didn’t surprise him.

“Not bad,” he commented, though he knew he was about to come up next and didn’t like the idea of her besting him.

“Not good, either.” She turned to him, taking her hearing protection earmuffs off. “I always seem to miss.”

He smirked. “What are you talking about? You crushed it. You’re always so damn hard on yourself.”

“Still, I always miss what’s right in front of me.”

“Nobody’s perfect. But you try your best.”

“And you?”

“What about me?” He felt anger, then, a drop of sweat sliding from his brow down to his ear and then to the back of his head. His scalp prickled.

“Remember Rosello?”

“Yeah.”

“You promised you wouldn’t get in a situation like that again.”

He stepped forward and grabbed her, making sure she couldn’t raise her gun at him again. “What do you mean?”

There were tears in her eyes and he felt them on his face. Or was it sweat? “You know what I mean.” 

“What do you know?” His heart was racing. He squeezed her, willing for her to tell him it wasn’t what he thought. She didn’t know. She couldn’t know. Not ever.

He knew she would never understand - because he damn well didn’t.

There was pity in her frown. She nodded at his chest. “I know there’s nothing left to hit.”

He looked down at his chest to find bullet holes over his sternum. Blood was pouring out.

“I had to do this, Mark,” she stood over him as he sank to his knees. 

“No, you don’t. Please.” He was gasping for air. Why was he so damn hot? “I did what I had to.” He had hoped she would understand. Of everyone in the world he had left alive…

“We had everything, Mark.” Will was fading from his vision. “We were happy, once.”

But then I died,” Angelina’s voice broke through and soon the pain in his chest evaporated. He was now in the dark.

“Angie?” He called out, getting to his feet, and trying to feel his way through the darkness. “Will?”

“Mark,” his sister’s voice echoed around him. “What have you done?”

He began to pant. He needed water. Something to quench this thirst. “What I had to!”

“You didn’t need to get revenge. You could have let it go.” Angie’s voice contorted into a warped sob that made him cough with nausea. “I believed in you!”

“Baxter deserved what he got!” He screamed back, slamming back the grief and fear, instead, pulling up the anger. Anger was his best friend. Anger was reliable and always there when he needed it. “You both can’t understand - because you didn’t see yourself, brutalized on that bed! Your throat slit! The blood everywhere! You! Weren’t! There!” 

He threw a punch, blindly, wanting something to hurt. He hated everything. He wanted to hurt something. He wanted violence. He wanted to take all this anguish and torment and get it out of his body. 

“You’re right.” Will appeared, looking ghoulish, eyes black and skin white. She leaned down to whisper in his ear, “I don’t understand. I can’t understand, because I’m not a murderer like you.”

The high-pitched beep of the smoke detector jolted him awake and he swiftly grabbed the gun at his nightstand and pointed it at his bedroom door. The door was still closed but the alarm came from the kitchen.

Shit. He had left the oven on. He had been baking a frozen pizza and forgot about it. He hurried outward, the burning smoke making his eyes water. He turned the heat off, coughing, and began opening windows in the apartment. 

The dreams were getting worse. He sometimes had them - during the rare sleep sessions he was afforded. He always ignored them, though, thinking they were stress-related. Lately, he had been seeing Will appear in them. Probably because of the last phone call. And now Angie? He shook his head and tried to fan the smoke around. He needed water. And rest. He had been up for two days straight doing supply runs because Amanda was currently going through some emotional problems and John was either getting treatment or keeping himself glued to Gordon’s side. 

There had suddenly been a lull in trap building. John was getting worse. He lost a lot of weight these past weeks and coughed every time he spoke, so there had been no one to kidnap. No buildings to clean and renovate for some elaborate game. 

All this free time made Mark have nothing else to do but think and dream.

It was irrational to assume the dreams meant anything. But he was wary of his subconscious. He knew he couldn’t ignore it forever.

He needed to get out of this line of work.

But how? What could he do?

He clenched his jaw, his head pounding. It pained him to consider this but he had no other choice.

He needed to talk to John.




Lawrence Gordon

 

Lawrence looked up from his book, the curtains whisking aside with a gritty shriek from the metal curtain rod. 

John Kramer looked terrible. His skin hung on his gaunt cheeks from the sudden weight loss. He was shivering and suppressed a cough with his fingers. He gripped to his chest a thick folder.

“You should be resting,” he told the old man, finding with every passing day his sympathy becoming more genuine and less exaggerated. He knew, rationally, that this man was insane. But the human mind was adaptable and he found himself becoming comfortable being in the presence of his captor. 

Brain tumors have been known to cause delusions and rapid thought and behavior changes. Prefrontal lobe is responsible for impulse and emotional response. 

“Thank you for your concern, Doctor.” John took a seat at the chair placed beside Lawrence’s bed. “You’re a fast reader, I see,” John gestured to the new book Amanda had given Lawrence, with its thick binding, and the previous book John had given him just the day prior now resting on the table beside the bed.

“It’s easy to go through when you have… no distractions.” He had been careful with his words - not wanting to appear arrogant or hostile. He knew he came off that way, normally. “Thank you, for not restraining me to the bed.”

“You’re welcome. You’re not meant to be a prisoner here.” John was coughing again, hard and long. He held out with a shaky hand the folder. Lawrence took it, recognizing medical forms and a recent MRI scan. He saw the tumor, far larger than when he had first diagnosed John. It must be excruciating. 

“You will need surgery soon. The mass has increased by a third since I last saw you. The rate of growth must have increased inner cranial pressure. Are you experiencing headaches?”

John looked amused. “I experience pain everywhere, every moment. The real question should be what doesn’t hurt?”

“You should be staying at a hospital. Not here.”

“I go when it is unbearable. But I am running out of time. How long do you think I have, after seeing this?”

Lawrence swallowed, worried about the penalty for honesty. John’s cold eyes pulled the truth from his lips. “A few months, if best.” 

“That is not enough time. I need longer. A year, at least, before Amanda can continue my work.”

“How can you focus on your work at this stage?” Lawrence felt skeptical and amazed at John’s fortitude. Clearly, he believed in what he was doing. 

For two weeks, being in this man’s presence, Lawrence had begun to feel as though he was beside a force beyond his comprehension. John Kramer, in the face of excruciating agony and suffering, refused to bow. Most would be writhing in a hospital bed, unable to even formulate a sentence.

Lawrence admitted John was an impressive man.

“Have you heard of Dr. Finn Pederson?”

Lawrence blinked, surprised. “Yes, in fact, I’ve met him. Brilliant man.” And right away, he knew what this was about. “He’s been developing experimental treatments for various cancers. Have you been in contact with him?”

“I have contacted his foundation. I intend to try it.”

Lawrence felt alarm grip his throat. “What information do you have on it?”

John reached over, flipping the MRI scans to a pamphlet. 

The Pederson Project.

A second chance. 

Flipping through, not finding any true tangible explanation on method, licensure, or medical board approvals, immediately knew it was a scam.

“John,” Lawrence delicately said, “I would not waste your time and money on this.”

John watched him, carefully. “I have no other options. If there’s a chance for this-,”

“Where did you hear of this? Who are they? Was this recommended by your current oncologist?”

John shook his head, sighing. “No. Another cancer patient, in one of my group counseling sessions. He is cured. He is healthy when weeks ago, he had been as doomed as I am. I know it’s only begun human trials. I know it's radical and experimental. I know that means results are unpredictable. It’s not about the guarantee - it’s about the hope. You understand how important hope is.”

He did. He still clung to hope, to soon see Diana and Ally again.  

“Thank you, for your concern. I know you mean it, out of the goodness of your heart and your own professional integrity.” John coughed again, long and hard. “Because I will be leaving, I see no need to keep you here any further.”

Lawrence blinked, adrenaline pumping through his chest. “You mean-,”

John got up and left, to return with a strange device. Gordon recognized it as John played with the straps and buckles. A prosthetic leg. 

“I don’t believe the stump’s fully healed.”

“You will walk out of here, a new man, Doctor. I’m sure you can take care of your wound far better than if you remained here.”

John had a point. A very good point. He shouldn’t be getting caught up in the technicalities. He needed to just nod and agree - and be free.

John went down to Gordon’s lower extremities, placing the bandaged stump into the sheath, and fastening the straps. Stepping back, he smiled. “On your feet, Doctor Gordon.”

Lawrence sat up, eager to get out of bed. He gingerly lowered his good foot and then placed some weight onto the stump.

The pain was nowhere near as sharp as the fateful night he had severed his foot with that hacksaw. But it was strong and shot up his spine and behind his ears. 

“Amanda,” John called and immediately the sound of footsteps pattered up.

“Yes, John?”

“Please fetch Doctor Gordon his belongings. And some cash. I’m sure he’ll want to hail a taxi and head straight home when you drop him off at the safe drop location.”

Amanda’s eyes narrowed but she did not argue. She disappeared behind the curtain.

“Amanda fears you will go talking to the police. I trust you will not.”

“Why?” He knew it was foolish but his curiosity and wariness of what John planned on doing to him if he did filled his lungs with dread.

“In the end, your fingerprints are on the gun that shot Adam. And you remained here, willingly, while Adam died. But I know these are merely complications. I’m sure you would be vindicated. But as you ponder these choices, think on the man you are now, standing today. Think on who you were, before. Think of your family, and what option will maximize your time with them and what option will take your time to legal battles and court proceedings. I know you will make the right choice.”

The room became suffocating. Lawrence at first flared his nostrils, furious, but the rage quickly dampened with a lukewarm understanding. 

Sure, John was suggesting implicating Lawrence to keep him quiet. And yet - it was a weak kind of blackmail. Paper thin.

Does John really believe I’ll buy into what he’s selling?

Lawrence couldn’t think about it just yet. He just wanted to go see his family. 

“Is there a catch I’m missing?” Lawrence waited for John, who was wincing.

“No catch. Just know that in the future, I may call on you. But only for needs of grave importance. Now go. Amanda will show you the way out.”

Amanda appeared, wrenching the curtain apart, holding folded clothes and looking less than pleased.

Lawrence didn’t know what to say, other than, “Thank you.”




Mark Hoffman

 

“John. A word?” He had come straight to him, the man currently at his drawing table developing another trap design. 

“You’re here, even though we haven’t called you. Detective, that is quite out of character for you.”

“Where’s Amanda?”

“She went to her apartment. I told her to take time to rest.” John broke into a coughing fit.

She should be here in case you need her.

But he shoved the concern away from his thoughts. He came here for one reason.

“I want out.”

John paused and turned to him, eyebrow raised.

“I’ve served you long enough. I’ve done everything you’ve asked. What’s your price to let me go?”

John tilted his head back, watching him, face expressionless. “Detective, your services are still crucial to our work.”

“I’m risking everything affiliating with you. Soon, they’ll bring in the feds. It won’t be easy, after that, covering our tracks. How much longer are you going to use me?” He couldn’t keep the contempt out of his voice. “Your traps are always about choice. Where’s my choice?”

John began playing with his pencil, rotating it between his fingers and studying it. “You always have the choice to walk away, Detective. You can choose to walk out there and return to your life and pretend you were never a part of any of this.”

Mark felt a hit of adrenaline at the prospect but knew it would be foolish to hope. “You’d find a way to get back at me.”

“No. Unlike you, I’m not one for petty vengeance. So long as you do not get in my way, I have no reason to complicate things by letting your colleagues know how much you enjoy helping me.”

Hoffman kept his eyes from narrowing but he felt a tick in his eyelid. Yeah fucking right.

“I’m in this because you made me.”

“You’re in this because you chose to involve yourself with me. With Seth Baxter, you used my name for your dirty work. I simply returned the favor.” John smiled cruelly. “So you want to be done? Fine. Go. Amanda and I will continue our work. And you have ensured it would not be in your best interest to turn on us. I think we’ve learned to… trust each other.”

There’s plenty to implicate me, now. Hoffman knew this as well as John. “So this could be it, right now, then? I can walk out of here?”

John nodded. “Yes. You always were able to. Yet you kept coming back. I doubt you truly thought you had no choice in that?”

Hoffman stared at John for a long while, feeling played. “From day one you made it clear that I needed to help you.”

“No. I made it clear that if you turned me in, I would reveal what you did to Seth Baxter. And then I told you I would show you a form of rehabilitation that would be far better than your criminal justice system could ever deliver. And you witnessed it, first hand.”

Mark swallowed, feeling like an insect having its wings torn apart under John’s all-knowing gaze. Yes, Mark knew John’s method was the most effective. Pain. Violence. Punishment. These were the tools that forced the scum of the earth on their knees. The crime rates in the city justified what he had done. What they had done.

“What will you do now?” John’s rasped voice gave Hoffman pause. “Go back to arresting the same criminals who never learn their lesson? To watch the Seth Baxters leave prison as quickly as they went in?”

Mark clenched his fist. “I just want my life back.”

“Yes, you had a good life, once. Parents. A loving sister. A promising career. Colleagues who were like your family. But then what happened?”

Mark glared at the man. 

“Your parents were killed by drug addicts. Your sister was murdered by a convicted felon. Your department is riddled with corruption like that of Eric Matthews. You, too, were tainted by that corruption. And so you spent late nights at bars, drinking to forget. You pushed away the last people in your life. Your friends. Your partner-,”

“This is none of your business.” Mark stepped forward, fists balled, feeling dangerously close to lashing out. 

“Is this why you want to abandon everything we’ve done? For Will ?”

His feet became frozen to the floor. “What?” Mark’s tongue had become cement in his mouth and his heart skipped in fear.

“Beautiful woman. I find her to be one of the only peace officers left that I’d consider admirable. And ironically, she thinks the world of you. It seems she always has. When do you think she’ll return from her leave of absence? Soon, it must be, for you to want to run away from all of this.” 

How did John find out about her? He had been careful. Damn it!

“Imagine what she would think of you if she knew what your new hobby was?”

His eyes widened as John began to smile widely.

“Yes, Detective, I know about your partner. I know she’s all you have left. You worry about her knowing what you do. What would she do, if she knew who you truly are?”

“Never mention her name,” Mark took steps quickly toward John, ready to grab him by the neck. He’d kill him. He’d kill him now and there if he did something to her.

“Is she in a trap?”

“I intend her no harm. She is currently safe, as far as I know. Still in California, for now.”

“If you think I’m going to let you put her in one of your-,”

“I have no need to test her. She cherishes her life and she is not one of your corrupt colleagues trying to stop our work.” John tilted his head. “It would be inconvenient to try to test her. She does not fit into my design.”

“Who else knows about her?”

“No one else.”

“Even Amanda?” Mark clenched his jaw. That psycho bitch would love a chance to get back at him. And Will was the way. 

“Amanda knows nothing of her. I do not intend to let her know.”

“Talk is cheap.” He needed John to understand, this was one of his lines. “If you so much as walk down the same street as her and I find out?” Mark immediately thought of the only person John likely had any compassion for left. “Your ex-wife. An eye for an eye.”

Now it was John’s turn to show a spark in his gaze. He cocked his head to the side, sizing Mark. “So you will come after Jill, is that what you’re saying?”

“Won’t happen, so long as Will’s out of this.”

They matched stares, sizing each other up. John sighed. “Even now, you don’t see the big picture, Mark.”

“And that is?”

“ If you truly despised our work, you would have turned yourself in and faced the consequences long ago. Yet here you are, griping at me like a juvenile with a chip on his shoulder, whining because your girlfriend might find out what you do at night.”

Mark’s face burned. “You forced me. You said you would let my department know-,”

“If I were to disappear, I would have ensured your involvement would have been relayed, yes. But you followed me because you wanted to explore my methods. Be honest with yourself. You… want to be involved in my work.”

Mark swallowed, knowing but refusing to admit it, that this was true.

“If you simply walked out of here I will not stop you. You can go back to your… life. Go, return to chasing down criminals who steal, rape, and kill, and return to the futility of being underpaid, overwhelmed, and watch as those around you suffer at the hands of those you could not stop. I know how much it pleases you, knowing how powerless you were back then. I know you will continue to ensure Jigsaw is not caught, for it’s in your best interest he remains free. And I will continue testing the fabric of humanity without you.”

“That’s the problem, John. This can’t keep going on. Some people will stop at nothing to catch you. And I won’t be able to slow them down for long.” Mark flared his nostrils, scowling. “You think being constantly chased by the cops will help you with your work? Hiding, here, in the shadows like a common criminal. It’s inefficient. Doesn’t that get in the way of your plans to change the world, John?”

“Bit by bit, our actions affect those around us. And they, too, will spread our truth. Tell me, ever since the news started identifying the crimes our test subjects committed and how Jigsaw targets those in need of rehabilitation, has there been a notable change in your day job? Murder rates have dropped to the lowest this city has seen in decades. There are websites where people ask us to ‘test’ those who have brought pain and suffering to others. We are teaching the world a harsh lesson, but it is a lesson that is long overdue.”

“It’s not going to change the laws. You and I both know they’ll stop at nothing. They’ll bring the feds, soon. It’s only a matter of time.”

“Society demands a blood price, as the laws were meant for. The price we pay is to have the public enjoy the illusion of Jigsaw being apprehended. The system does not work. But society needs to believe it does. It is merely part of the process. In time, the world will understand that what we are doing is for the greater good. One day, I will be caught by the police. And that day is soon. But it will not be the end of my legacy. Society will one day see my legacy as the most effective. Opinions will change. Your partner, if eased in, may also see reason.

Mark doubted it. Yet now, the faint ripple of hope broke through his fear.

“I’ve seen your ex-wife visit lately. Does she know what you do?”

John did not take his inquiry poorly, which was good. As John tended to do, he nodded with a knowing smile, as if he completely understood why Mark even asked. “She has known since my first victim. At first, she reacted… as expected. But now, she understands.”

The ripple grew into waves. “She’s fine with it?”

John inhaled deeply but coughed violently before he could take in the full breath. Mark reached for the nearest glass of water, handing it off to John, waiting patiently for the man to recover.

“It took her time. But when she saw how Amanda changed, she finally saw. Jill had tried with all her heart - to heal the world. After all her years of trying and failing to fix others, she soon realized that my method was the last hope for humanity we had. And for your precious Will, she will see that too, one day. Being someone who has fought as hard to live life the right way, it would not be impossible for her to understand. But there is something else that concerns me.”

“What?”

“Where your priorities will lie if she were to not understand.”

And that was exactly what Mark was afraid of. 

“You can help her understand, Detective.”

“How?”

John had a knowing smile. “There will be a game.”

“I said she won’t-,”

“No, not for her. A game for you.”

Mark’s attention was piqued but sharp with wariness. “I don’t need to be tested.”

“No, you are not the true subject. But your presence in the game will be crucial.”

“Like Amanda’s game is?” Mark knew Amanda had been planning a trap with Eric Matthews soon. One that would christen her standing as John’s successor. 

“You will design one, after Amanda’s. Take everything I’ve taught you and create an opportunity for yourself to be free of all suspicion. Architect the game so you remain as the hero, saving your colleagues. Ensure you can never be under suspicion once it’s done.”

This thrilled Mark. He swallowed, his mind spinning with the possibilities, already several ideas coming into his mind. “Would I have complete control?”

“It would be your game completely. To mold and shape. Show me you have what it takes to support Amanda when I am gone. Behind the scenes. Shielded from the public. So you can continue our work but be immune to any suspicion. It will be challenging. But I know you are capable of succeeding.” John coughed again, long and hard. “Detective, when I die, will you help Amanda?”

Mark opened his mouth, immediately out of a need to protest but stopped. He regained his composure. “Amanda is reckless.”

“She has nothing else to distract her. She is devoted.”

“And what about me? Haven’t I devoted enough to you?”

John raised an eyebrow, looking genuinely surprised. “You want more responsibility? Yet you came here, demanding I set you free.”

He got him there. Mark felt confused, as John often made him feel. 

“It’s like you said. Your method gives results.” Mark had a whole list of people he would teach John’s methods to. He needed John’s resources, his property, and his wealth. His legacy . He needed everything to be able to get the job done. 

“I will consider this,” John answered, “You have strengths Amanda lacks. I think together, you both would be unstoppable.”

That’s never going to happen.

“I want you to think on this, while I’m gone.”

“Where are you going?”

“Mexico.”

Mark raised an eyebrow. “Why?”

“Treatment. I hope to heal. Who knows,” John had an almost gentleness in his smile. “Perhaps there won’t be a need for a successor anytime soon.”

Mark’s curiosity was pushing him to ask for more details. But John shook his head, as though reading his mind. 

“Now go, Detective. I’ll call you when I return from my trip. Amanda will maintain the equipment. Consider this a vacation.”

Notes:

A/N: A lot of character development I tried to force - hopefully it was smooth? Trying to also move along the plot - a lot of details to squeeze in and try to continue that evolution of the whole "Will would absolutely not be a fan of Jigsaw EVER" to "mayyybe she'd at least get why Jigsaw does it what he does".

The latest news on that united healthcare CEO totally makes SAW 6 hit different, doesn't it?

Some more headcanons: John goes to Mexico after this conversation, for the treatment, but also prepares to stay indefinitely if Mark actually tries to abandon Jigsaw work. Amanda was given orders to keep an eye on the news and Mark and snitch to John if Mark betrays him, which then John would continue to chill in Mexico if that was the case.

Chapter 53: Peri-SAW: Honeymoonset

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Mark Hoffman

He picked up the phone, the dial tone warm in his ear. His mind was buzzing with the full eight hours of sleep had had last night. He was sitting at his office desk, stomach full of a hot cup of coffee while the second cup steamed at his desk. Before him, the open case file he had just received from his connection back in San Diego blared up at him and filled him with an almost giddy glee. He had a reason to call her. It would be early for her, though. Nine in the morning here, he mused, figuring she could have already been up. 

He dialed her number.

“Hello?” Her voice, broken with sleep, filled his veins with excitement. 

“Sorry, did I wake you?”

“Yeah - but - it’s fine, you beat my alarm by ten minutes. Hang on.” He heard her pull away from the phone, muttering as a male voice sounded, tired and unhappy. Mark’s stomach tightened, knowing who she was with, his head starting to hurt as he grit his teeth. After some rustle and fumbling, her voice returned. “Sorry, about that. Hey - everything okay?”

“Peachy.” He was struck with a moment of word loss. He missed her. He loved hearing the sound of her voice. He wanted her to come back to him. All these thoughts did not make it past his throat. Instead, he cleared it. “Just returning your phone call.”

“Yeah. Sorry about that,” she sounded regretful, and he did not like that. “Probably a bit sappy. I was feeling kind of vulnerable is all.”

Don’t regret missing me, Will. Please.

“Anything I can help with? Sorry I couldn’t find a better time to call. How’s the case?” Work had always been their baseline. It was their tether to each other. He bit his lip, wishing he could tell her about his other work. The long nights. The machines he could create now. The imagination he always had - unleashed and alive, erected with blades of steel and complex designs that stank of grease and diesel, that hungered for blood. 

She had always been the person he could confide in. But not anymore. Not with that.

“Honestly, we’ve been stuck. Dead ends everywhere. It’s driving me crazy.”

He leaned back in his office, his heart skipping. So he could be of help with what he found. “Yeah? I’m sorry to hear that. None of your old connections helping?”

“Well, you know how it is. They can’t even if they wanted to. I’ve got to be careful - a lot of people I’ve pissed off decades ago still remember me. So what I can get isn't much. Every case file that’s unsealed just has vague descriptions. No follow up interviews. It’s the strangest thing, it’s as if they intentionally wanted to leave this case cold. I even pulled other crimes that occurred and were investigated at around the same time. Similar cases, all with a lot more detail. Same investigators, so it wasn’t like some new guy on his first case. This can’t be accidental. It feels like back when -,” she paused, no longer speaking.

Mark smiled to himself, knowing she was about to bring up Rosello and everything that had happened back then. “Always trust your instinct, Will.”

“Yeah. Did you ever find out anything? I know you offered. No pressure, I know you’re busy with the Jigsaw case.”

“Actually,” he was looking down at the photograph of the man, Ethan Kotroff, a grainy photo but supposedly taken at a gas station near the Maddox residence prior to the murder. Beside him was Philip Rhodes. All evidence, from San Diego. All from his source - with the warning to not let it trace back to him. A friend of Knox is a friend of mine. I trust your discretion. “I have something. I was planning on mailing it first thing when the post office opens.”

“Really? What?” Her excitement he could practically taste. 

“Well, they had some POI’s sealed. I called for a favor over at LA with an old colleague. He happened to know a guy who sent them to me.”

“I can’t wait for snail mail on this one.”

“You near a fax?”

“Yes! Hang on.” He heard her ask Strahm for the number. After relaying it Hoffman wrote it down. 

“I’ll send it over.”

“Mark, thank you!” She sounded wide awake. Happy. His throat burned.

“Least I can do. After everything. Hope you can close your mom’s case soon. Get that closure.” So you can hurry and come back. He swallowed. “I need you here , Will.”

Silence on the other end. 

He quickly added, “ We need you here.”

“Right,” there was that tone of relief in her voice. “The Jigsaw case?”

He bit his lip. He still felt it wasn’t quite time yet. But Kerry and Fisk were at their wit’s end. He knew Kerry was constantly begging Will to come back. And he needed her, back with him, and not with Peter fucking Strahm. 

Now, he knew he had what it took to keep her and his evening activities separate. He had it all well under control now. It all fell into place, when he came to terms with the fact that Jigsaw would not go away. Jigsaw would never be captured. And he knew Will, inside and out, and though she was always one to never let things go, he had a couple of ideas in how to satisfy and silence all her probing curiosities soon. He knew she would be devastated if someone she had trusted and cared about ended up being the Jigsaw killer. And I know someone who can fit that role.

It would devastate her. But Mark would be there to pick her back up and to keep her by his side. It would be a game of his own design. 

John had ignited a newfound fire in Mark. Designing his own game? Knowing how John could make a person completely change who they were, what they believed in, and everything they thought they understood gave Mark hope he could do the same. If he did it right, there was nothing that could stop him. A game that would absolve any future suspicion being shed upon him.

He still needed to come up with the right game. A game that established a water-tight alibi for himself and nailed a scapegoat that couldn’t worm his way out of the blame. Mark smiled, savoring the idea of the man who would take the blame and would eventually die being known as the Jigsaw Killer instead of him.

Strahm would be perfect to take the fall. How ironic, the brilliant behavioral profiler, decorated FBI Special Agent Peter Strahm, the Jigsaw Killer. Will would be devastated, but not for long once Mark arrived with a sympathetic shoulder to cry on. She would lose confidence in her own abilities to trust - and she would doubt any future suspicions she would have in him.

The Jigsaw case would then be closed. And then, he could continue the games. There would always be copycats, after all. Mark was sure any future investigations would always blame a copycat. After all, Jigsaw’s influence was undeniable. If the evidence against Strahm was irrefutable, even the copycats would be his fault. Most importantly, no suspicion would ever fall on Mark Hoffman, the lead investigator, who would continue to lock away the scum who deserved imprisonment, always trying to clean up the Jigsaw plague that just could never truly die. Already, criminals feared the shadows - feared Jigsaw. And knowing that even if the “true” Jigsaw died, that there would always be copycat vigilantes, would finally snuff out the real plague of criminals in his city. 

To become the lead investigator, it would mean having to make the current lead step down. Mark would find a way to have Kerry forced to resign - but not in a way that would harm her reputation. But she would need to be tested and become a survivor. Mark knew Amanda had been eager to prepare for her trap - and she had once brought up Allison Kerry as being someone Eric Matthews would care for and a good candidate for the future trap he would face. Mark could no longer protect her from Amanda’s attention but when the time was right - he knew Kerry would survive. It was who she was. She didn’t fit John’s typical test subjects. Amanda clearly wanted to use the games for her own petty revenge.

Mark understood this, but he would not allow it. John, though still calling the shots, was becoming too weak to closely supervise them. Mark could see that soon, the decision on who would take the mantle was going to be made. He was sure it would be him. He was the better candidate. The stronger one.

The biggest problem was Amanda. She was the biggest liability, with her erratic mood swings and clear fragileness. And possibly Jill Tuck, since she knew who he was and his role. Mark just had to wait for the cancer to take out John. And he would clean house.

If you are good at anticipating human nature, then you leave nothing to chance.

“Mark?”

“Sorry - can you say that again?”

“I said, is this about the Jigsaw case?”

“Yeah. And other things.” He wanted it all. He could have it all. “The coffee’s been shit since you left.”

She laughed. “You seriously better not be implying I’m only missed for being the guy that brewed the coffee every morning.”

“Well, there’s also doing my paperwork for me.”

“Next time I see you, I’m gonna slug you.”

“Don’t threaten me with a good time.” He smiled, for the first time in a while, believing everything would work out just fine in the end. 

We need to go, Will,” the voice on the phone, muffled but clearly that of Strahm, broke their moment. 

“Peter,” Will sounded frustrated. The pit of Mark’s stomach churned, not wanting the phone call to end. 

But more voices on the line, Strahm, grumbling, “ how do you know you can trust this lead?” to other discouraging barrages, were something Hoffman immediately latched onto.

They have been taking a lot longer to wrap up a case that should have been cut and dry for Will. It can’t just be the SDPD getting in the way. Mark could smell a mile away when a cop was getting kneecapped. It was his specialty, after all.

“Sorry, Mark, I need to hang up.” 

“I’ll fax them over now.”

“Thank you,” relief in her tone to him. But when she spoke to Strahm, it was clear she was exasperated. This was comforting to him. 

His consolation prize. Until she returned to him.

“Anytime. Know I’ve got your back, Will.”

 

Peter Strahm

The Gas Lamp district pulsated with a life of its own, a living, breathing entity fueled by neon glowing signs and abuzz with crowds of young people, drunk and milling about in the late night. Beneath the flickering streetlights, Peter was currently eating a fish taco while Will pretended to study the drink menu at one of the outdoor patios, warming themselves under the gas heaters erect around them, blending into the crowd. They were undercover, a couple out on the town. Will was shivering in her black leather jacket. Peter was sweating and considering offering his jacket to her.

“I’ll have a coffee please,” she told the waiter who looked disappointed. She opted for a soft drink and returned the drink menu to him.

She looked tired and had been acting cold with him. He wasn’t sure why, though he suspected it had something to do with her damn partner. Hoffman, always a thorn in my side. But when he had read over her shoulder that morning while she was texting, mostly to Kerry, it was about missing a friend that had died around this time of the year.

Ever since Hoffman called her that morning, his nerves were wound tight. 

He was frustrated she wouldn’t confide in him. They had made such progress - and it felt like they were going backwards now. He was right there and ready to hear every thought and hurt she carried with her. He was growing impatient with her emotional distance.

It made him feel as though she only opened up to him when she wanted him physically. Am I just a lustful distraction, nothing more? He was not opposed to casual hookups but with Will, he wanted more. He hoped she did, too. But days like these, he felt doubt tug at the back of his mind, filling him with worry.

Returning to the present, Peter had his eyes fixed on the target building looming through the chaos of the streets. Beside him, Will, exuded a quiet intensity, her gaze flickering back and forth to the same building, her focus transfixed.

“He’s in there, Peter, I can feel it.”

Peter nodded, his throat tight. They were stalking their latest lead. Things were accelerating, faster than he had thought they would. Though he had been dragging his feet, trying to spend as much time with Will as he could, she had made headways with the case. But it wasn’t from their trip to the San Diego Police Department. The public records had returned nothing of note. Will insisted the SDPD were withholding details. She blamed Dragna and insisted something leaning more to the ramblings of a conspiracy theorist. For Peter, he felt she was grasping at shadows and straws. 

“We don’t know his connection. We should approach this delicately,” he suggested. 

“It’s the only lead we’ve got,” she snapped, clearly frustrated.

Peter inhaled through his nose and bit his tongue. He understood she was tired of the delays. But he, too, was feeling unhappy with the current situation. He felt the trepidation of the end approaching - she would eventually return back to her life. They would have to maintain a long distance relationship soon, and he dreaded that separation.

He did not want this case to be closed so quickly - even though he knew how important it was to her.

He had hoped they would have simply made some phone calls and asked a few witnesses, not chase down and stalk a potential suspect without backup.

The latest theory was that the Maddox residence had not been targeted for a simple burglary - but an organized hit. They were now on the hunt for some connection to Jules Maddox’s vacuum business - her father’s business that had been a small retailer that distributed various models and vacuum accessories. Apparently, their target had been a frequent customer. The connection had been random but the coincidence could not be ignored.

The motive was still, to be determined.

 Ethan Kotroff, the man who - supposedly - had been an associate of Philip Rhodes, had been in the documents Hoffman had faxed over.

Another, whom Will was still trying to process, had been Jules Maddox. It was clear the information had upset her - and Peter had done everything he could to help her mentally prepare for that confrontation. But for now, they would distract any emotional upset by focusing on Kotroff.

Peter knew this should have been seen as a blessing. He was playing a dangerous game, allowing his personal feelings for Will to cloud his judgment, to slow the progress of the investigation. And yet, every time he looked at her, every time he felt the warmth of her smile, he couldn’t bring himself to push her away, to risk losing her after everything was done.

Lately, Will had mentioned Hoffman in passing, a sign of her becoming more comfortable with Peter to confide in him. It made him both reassured she felt she could trust Peter more but also uncomfortable, hearing such details about her past lover. The psychiatrist in him could not refuse or silence her, taking it all in like a train wreck he would dissect later. The man in him flared with rage at the thought of another knowing and experiencing Will in ways he had yet to explore. 

Her gaze would go distant as she recounted tales of days gone by, her voice tinged with nostalgia and resignation. Twenty years of partnership was a great wall Peter had to climb. She spoke of late nights taking out suspects, of heart-pounding chases through the city streets, years of trust, growth, and eventually disintegration. These were her most precious moments. Of finding someone she thought she could be with to only find out he had been smoke and daggers. And beneath the surface, beneath the veneer of camaraderie and trust, Will spoke of a darkness lurking. That distant gaze would then grow hungry, and that was when Peter began to feel the competitive urge heat his insides.

She mentioned off-hand the time Hoffman had saved her life when she had confronted, alone, some pimp suspected in a string of prostitute murders back when she was a rookie. And his quick thinking and unwavering courage had pulled her from sudden death. And yet, she described how he had almost beaten the man to death, and how his loss of control worried her still.

She spoke of the white lies, the dodgy secrets, the many nights of drinking and the abusive words he had said to her after the death of his sister. Yet this darkness had existed before Angelina Acomb’s murder. 

She told of his past serving Toni Rosello, of which Peter had known already, but of the hunch she had that he had done far worse. She spoke of her dead husband, Frank Griffin, and the strange circumstances of his death. How Griffin’s body had been found on a property owned by Rosello. How there was something still about Frank Griffin’s death that bothered her, despite all these years.

Decades later, she still turned a blind eye to the whispers and rumors that followed Hoffman wherever he went, of destroying evidence and falsifying records, dismissing them as idle gossip of jealous colleagues and bitter rivals. 

Even in the present, Peter recognized a bias in how she described him, clearly still placing her unwavering trust that Mark Hoffman was a good man. 

Peter Strahm concluded Mark Hoffman was far from a good man and now Peter had nothing but doubts on Will’s ability to identify danger. Nothing she had described had redeemed or brought a glimmer of hope in Peter’s assessment in Hoffman’s character. The more he delved into the depths of Hoffman’s psyche, the more lost he became, until it felt like he was drowning in a sea of uncertainty, his every instinct screaming at him to run, to flee from the darkness that threatened to consume him.

This was why Peter was prepared for danger that night, expecting this to be some trap. He would not put it past Hoffman to hurt Will. The man was a sociopath. He was sure of it. High functioning, of course, but clearly concealing antisocial personality traits that endangered Will’s wellbeing.

What exactly was Mark Hoffman up to, to willingly turn over the object of his affections so willingly? Especially after the veiled threats mailed to Peter’s house. Paranoia gripped him and he suspected Will’s need to close this case made her ignore the potential mislead this could be. But he kept it to himself, for now. 

She had become distant with him, avoiding eye contact and stiffening when he would take her hand or put an arm around her. She had retreated into strictly business and he was wondering where he had messed things up. This had begun shortly after their first visit with Rhodes.

Being a trained psychiatrist, he wanted her to explain why. But while they waited at the airport and flew from Virginia to California, she had changed the subject every time he dared broach it. 

“Let’s focus on finding Kotroff and getting Rhodes to talk,” she had said when he had asked her if she was upset with him.

Though Peter would have liked to pretend they were having a romantic dinner in the party district of San Diego, all he could taste of his meal was the bitter knowing that the case would make leaps and bounds now. He couldn’t stop Will from accelerating ahead, but he was beginning to develop a wariness that she wasn’t thinking clearly. She wasn’t seeing the big picture. 

This is the danger with investigating a case you’re personally involved in.

“Look,” Will pointed at the man exiting the nightclub. He looked stringy and mean, bald and old, with a distinct gold chain and an unfortunately unbuttoned satin shirt. But it was Kotroff. The man was steering a drunk down an alley and Will got to her feet, throwing cash onto the table and didn’t wait for Peter as she ran across the street in pursuit.

“Fuck,” Peter muttered under his breath as he moved to keep up with her speed. When they reached the mouth of the alley he grabbed her by the arm. “Wait!”

She turned, furious, turning to ensure their target was still in sight. “What are we waiting for?”

“We don’t have a plan. What are you going to do? Arrest him?” They had no jurisdiction. Their badges would mean nothing in this. 

“No. Just follow.” She tried to wrench herself out of his grasp but he held on, squeezing her forearm firmly.

“He literally will notice.” Peter watched as the man turned the corner with his accomplice. “Okay, now, follow.”

She snapped, “You don’t need to lecture me. Christ.” And she increased the pace. They moved in silence through the labyrinth of Gaslamp, their footsteps damp from the leaking dumpsters. With each step, they drew closer to their quarry, until they rounded a corner.

Just because Ethan Kotroff’s profile mentioned he had been a partner to Philip Rhodes’ in the vacuum repair store that had been a money laundering cover, didn’t mean Kotroff had anything to do with her mother’s murder.

It was a loose angle. A desperate prayer for her.

It wasn’t worth her throwing herself into this.

Yet she left him as she chased after this man. And to what? Confront him? 

But when he reached her she was keeping herself low and behind a billboard that advertised burritos and restaurant hours. She jumped to her feet, whirling and pulled him by the sleeve and into a sudden kiss.

He paused, confused, but let himself get swept up into the feel of her warm lips and felt her panting, and just as quickly as she had initiated the kiss, she pushed him off. 

“He almost caught us,” she explained, smirking. “He and the other guy just went into that bar. Let’s go.”

His cheeks burned and felt embarrassed with how effortless she made him both dizzy and used.

The place was called the Devil’s Den, a real dive in the forgotten part of town, far from the warm glow of Gaslamp. A bit on the nose, Strahm internally cringed, not enjoying the ambiance of this place. They entered the grungy biker bar, the air thickening with the scent of stale beer and cigarette smoke, mingling with the distant echoes of gravelly laughter and the blare of heavy metal. The walls were adorned with faded posters of long-gone rock bands and yellowed newspaper clippings, telling tales of wild nights of a fading era.

The patrons were a mismatch of leather-clad old folks and the occasional sore-thumb young person who looked more scared than tough, huddling around scarred tables and battered barstools.

Peter found the heavy weight of his gun at his hip a comfort, recognizing that many in the bar were also packing. 

Will went to the bar and took a seat, two stools away from their target. Peter could now see his eyes, eyes that could have once been bright with the fire of youth but were now dim with age, haunted by memories too dark to name. They flickered like dying embers beneath heavy brows and furrowed as they approached with the heavy knowledge that he knew who they were and why they were there. 

“Two Blue Moons,” Will told the grizzly bartender who nodded and popped open two bottles and handed them over. She handed one frosted bottle to Peter and the two went to another table that gave them access to both the front door and Kotroff. She was bristled with anticipation, her determination palpable in the air.

“Will,” Peter leaned in to whisper against her ear, “you need to be careful. This could be dangerous. We don’t know what he’s capable of.”

But her eyes flashed with frustration, her patience wearing thin. “I didn’t come this far to back down now, Peter,” she shot back, her voice tinged with irritation. “We need to confront him, to finally get some answers.”

Peter’s heart sank as he watched her resolve harden, unwavering in the face of danger. He knew that she was right, that they couldn’t let Kotroff slip through their fingers, but a part of him couldn’t shake the feeling of dread that gnawed at his insides.

“We can’t just rush in this blindly, Will,” he insisted, his voice tinged with desperation. His eyes locked onto Kotroff for a brief moment before he looked back at her. “We need a plan, a strategy. We need to think this through.”

But she was already moving, turning off the stool as she made her way across the bar, her eyes locked on Kotroff like a predator closing in on its prey. Peter cursed under his breath, torn between his duty to protect Will and his fear of what lay ahead. He grabbed her arm, pulling her back.

Kotroff had been watching them and picked up immediately that they were a threat. He calmly got to his feet and went deeper into the bar, towards the restrooms and vanished among the crowd. Peter knew the guy would probably slip out of another exit. He would be long gone.

Will turned to him, eyes blazing with anger and disappointment. “Why are you constantly doing this? Slowing me down? It’s like you’re trying to sabotage this investigation.”

Peter opened his mouth to protest, to explain himself, but his words were caught in his throat, choked by the weight of his guilt. And suddenly, recognition glinted in her eyes.

“That’s what this is, isn’t it?”

“It’s not like that.”

“But you have been actively making it more difficult to close this case. Why?”

He pressed his lips together, not wanting to bring this out. Casual bar goers were looking up from their drinks in curiosity at their bickering. The music in the bar was loud but this was not the place to have this discussion. His hesitation had Will fold her hand and turn away from him.

“I need to clear my head. Don’t wait for me. I’ll just get a taxi back to the room.”

He watched her leave, knowing he had lost more than just their suspect. He had lost her trust, her faith in him shattered like glass upon the unforgiving pavement.

 

Will Maddox

Will wandered the bustling streets, each footstep heavy with the weight of her disappointment. Everywhere she looked, she saw couples wrapped in each other’s arms, laughter and joy bubbling up around her like a fountain of youth. But for her, there was only emptiness, a vacuum sucking her downwards into a doom spiral.

Her phone vibrated in her pocket and she expected it to be Peter to only double take when she saw Mark’s name on the caller ID. Mark was always there for her when she needed him most. Unlike Peter, Mark would not have physically stopped her from going. 

He would have whined about it later, sure, but they always caught the bad guy in the end. She was not happy with the progress of their latest case. Now, as his voice filled her ear, Will felt a flood of conflicting emotions wash over her like a tidal wave.

“Hey, Will,” Mark’s voice greeted her, warm and familiar. “Now a good time?”

“Sure.”

“Yeah?” He must have detected her upset. “What’s wrong?”

Will swallowed hard, the lump in her throat threatening to choke her. She just wanted to bury her face into his broad chest and cry. “I miss you, Mark,” she confessed, her voice barely above a whisper. “I know if you were here with me, we would have caught the guy by now.”

Mark’s response was immediate, his tone laced with a mixture of longing and regret. “I know, Will. I wish I could be there with you, too.”

As they spoke, Will felt a surge of need course through her veins, a hunger that could never be satisfied by mere words alone. She wanted more than anything to reach out and touch him, to hold him in her arms. To smell the soap on his skin. To bask in the warmth of him and to forget about San Diego, her parents, everything. He always made it so easy to forget about the bad things in her life.

“I miss you, too, Will,” Mark admitted and it both rattled and excited her. She felt hot tears trickle down her face. 

“Damn it, Hoffman,” she sobbed and finally stopped to lean against the bricks of a building that had a couple of drunks smoking, not paying her any mind. 

“That’s not the first time I’ve heard you curse my name in vain.”

She couldn’t help but laugh as his voice caressed her ear. She shivered, from the cold night and from hearing his words. “I’m sure it won’t be the last.” She bit her lip. “But despite how often you’ve pissed me off, you’re one of the only men in my life worth trusting.” The only one, she realized, and this made her feel at a loss.

She nervously waited in the long pause, wondering how he would take this bombshell.

“So, Will,” Mark began, his tone suddenly calm and casual. “Are you telling me you still trust me these days?”

“Of course. I mean,” she wondered where this was coming from, “you’re always on my side. Thank you, by the way. For finding about Kotroff. That list you faxed, it’s the only thing we’ve had to go on for weeks now.”

“I didn’t want to rock the boat between you and… Strahm.” There was a bite in him saying the name. “But I’m glad I can still be of use to you.”

Will quickly tried to shift the subject. “Of course. You’re one hell of a cop.”

“Random question. Why am I one of the only men you think is trustworthy?”

She raised an eyebrow. “What do you mean?”

“Nothing. But you brought it up. It’s one of those things I’ve always wondered about you, Will. You’re a lot more trusting than me. Always has been. Why me?”

Despite the strange line of questioning, she suddenly lost all need to cry. It was a good distraction. Philosophical. Rarely did Mark get all deep like this. She walked a few more steps as she thought about this. “You’ve never lied to me, Mark. You tell me how it is and always have been, since the day we met.”

“Well I hope I don’t disappoint you.”

“I don’t think you will. Unlike everyone else, you’ve always been… true to me.”

Mark was silent on the phone for long seconds, and then he asked, “but what about forgiveness, Will?”

So that’s what this is about. She felt a surge of compassion. “Mark, all water under the bridge. I forgive you. You weren’t in the right mind back then. It was… such a mess.” Thinking about Angelina made her bow her head in shame. “I, too, did a lot back then that deserved it.”

“No, you didn’t. I know I was a bastard back then. But you always gave me another shot. I can’t tell you how much it means to me, having someone who can do that. Forgive me, that is.”

Her breath caught in her throat, the weight of Mark’s words settling heavy in her chest. “Well, forgiveness isn’t always easy,” she admitted, her voice barely above a whisper. She remembered Angelina and how she wished more than anything for Mark to forgive her. How she wished she could forgive herself. “But it’s what the world needs more of.”

There was a pause on the other end, stretching for what felt like an eternity. And then, Mark spoke again, his voice low and measured, each word dripping with a heaviness that felt intense and dark.

“What about justice, Will?”

“What about it?”

“We’ve devoted our lives to it. But it rarely happens. But what if there was a way to dispense it - but it took doing some unforgivable things?”

“Mark, are you drunk?” She bit her lip, worried. He had been so good lately. Ally had mentioned in passing just yesterday he never stank of late night drinking these days. 

“You know how we always put guys away for them to walk off on technicalities all the time. Like what happened with Seth Baxter.” He said the man’s name with an edge, but it was impressive he could say it at all with the emotional restraint he was showing.

“Not to sound kooky, but I sometimes think it was an act of God that Seth Baxter met his end with Jigsaw,” she offered up that intimate thought, knowing it made her less of a good person for believing it. “And I do wish cosmic justice operated like that more often.”

“Do you think Jigsaw’s inherently evil, then? Or an act of God?”

Will’s heart pounded in her chest, the weight of his words crashing down on her like a tidal wave. She knew what he was asking, what he was implying, and the thought sent a frigid current to course through her veins. 

“I… I don’t know, Mark,” she confessed, her voice trembling with uncertainty and worry. What are you implying, Mark? “I guess it would depend on the circumstances. But generally, yes, he’s evil. It’s not just Seth Baxters he targets. And vigilante justice is not true justice. Remember when that dad snapped after his daughter was raped? He went and beat two teenaged boys to death - one was the culprit. But the other wasn’t even there.”

“But someone as refined as the Jigsaw Killer - he doesn’t make mistakes like that. It’s methodical. It’s careful. So far all the victims of the Jigsaw Killer - I hate to admit, I don’t lose sleep over their deaths. If there was some vigilante out there, only killing the scum out there, wouldn’t the world be a better place?”

“In a perfect world, the perfect vigilante, sure. But -,”

“So would arresting this perfect vigilante in itself be a disservice to the public? To justice?”

She bit her lip, not sure what to say. But she just felt like it was wrong to even humor the idea. “Our job is to enforce the law Mark. And the law says we can’t go around killing who we think are bad people.”

“You know the law isn’t always right. What if, Will,” Mark’s voice was soft yet insistent, a razor-sharp blade cutting through the layers of her certainty, leaving her feeling exposed and vulnerable, “someone you trusted did what they did for the right reasons? Would you still arrest them?”

“It’s not just about intentions, Mark,” she was beginning to feel frustrated. “It’s about accountability. No one is above the law, no matter what their reasons may be.”

But he wasn’t finished, his questions coming like rapid-fire bullets, each one hitting with precision. “So what about justice, Will? Is it just enforcing the law? Aren’t laws just a set of rules made by a group of people, rules that can be changed at any moment? And the foundation of having a means for dispensing justice, in itself, is to protect society as a whole? Even despite what the law says?”

Will’s brow furrowed as she struggled to find an answer. “Justice… it’s complicated, Mark.” She finally admitted with resignation. “It’s not always black and white. Sometimes, it’s a matter of perspective, of interpretation.”

Mark’s chuckle was low and knowing. “Perspective. Morality, too, is subjective, wouldn’t you agree? What’s right for one person may be wrong for another. And who’s to say which is which?” 

Will heard the ring of a phone, which didn’t make any sense. Though she was on Mark’s cell phone, the ringtone was not his landline.

“Is that… another cell phone?” Was someone with him? Will felt this sudden anxiety that the other phone belonged to a woman.

“I need to go, Will. We’ll talk again soon.” The click and silence ended the call, leaving Will alone on the sidewalk, staring down at the CALL ENDED that shined up on her Nokia. 

Notes:

A/N: This year has cut me at the ankles and I crawl back here, to you all, with humble appreciate to you readers who are so patient and understanding. I'm struggling to balance my creative hobbies (this) and all the adult responsibilities and job-related burdens that keep sucking out every drop of inspiration I have. I'm trying to get things back on track. If I did not have to worry about bills, I'd happily just write til eternity. But that's okay, that just makes these moments so precious and golden, and this overwhelming sense of accomplishment for completing one measly chapter is something I will cherish.

I am wrecked. I used to love my career - but these days, I'm being forced from my electronics and computers and forced to now stare at spreadsheets of part numbers and costs and and guide people who make a ton more money than me to do basic things like show up to meetings and organize their lives. FUCK. I come home, a slug, a lowly tired slug, who barely has the capacity to heat up ramen. But hopefully the increased sunlight will help restore me.

Enough self pity. I bounce between edgy flowery writing to just raw tell it as I think sort of style. I don't really like how this chapter turned out, but I hope it's something you all will like.

Chapter 54: Peri-SAW: Skills and Fire

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Amanda Young

 

John was quiet as they drove to the airport. He stared out at the airplanes taking off as she pulled the rental car over, parking it in the return lane. She knew he was disappointed with the entire ordeal.

He had come here, hoping to cure his cancer.

But he would return, with even less time left than he had when he had first landed.

He hardly blinked, lips pursed, the solemnity filling the air with a thick tension that made it hard for her to breathe.

She sighed. “Come on, John.”

They exited the car and gathered their belongings, entered the airport, and made their way through the terminal.

John had a tendency to stop and stare at whatever captured his fancy. She was used to this, and would have indulged him if they weren’t running late. Security was tight these days - and sometimes John forgot that they needed to wait in long lines through TSA when most of his life travelers would  just walk up the gate at your leisure. 

“John,” she went back to him, wondering what had captured his interest this time.

It was a Hudson shop with a table of the newest bestselling book, towered with some loser’s face grinning dumbly up at them.

S.U.R.V.I.V.E.

My Story of Overcoming Jigsaw

Amanda raised an eyebrow, not recognizing the man.

Bobby Dagen? We never dealt with a guy with that name. And certainly no survivor. John always keeps track of the survivors.

“Is he..?”

“No,” John whispered, his voice restored with a heat that made Amanda surprisingly relieved. Even though she didn’t like him angry it was a reprieve from his hollow depression he had been wallowing in all morning. John reached over and picked up a book and went to purchase it. Amanda looked around nervously, always expecting some cop to be there, ready to arrest them. Thankfully, no one paid them any attention.

John kept his nose planted deeply in the pages of that book. Even through security, the TSA agent had to remind him he couldn’t carry the book through the metal detector when he begrudgingly surrendered it to the luggage conveyor. As soon as he was past the security checkpoint he carried his belongings and planted himself at a corner seat by the windows at their gate, returning to reading his book.

Amanda sighed and sank into the chair beside him, pulling her hoodie over her head, pursing her lips in boredom. She should have gotten a book as well. Or at least some gum. But she didn’t like paying the airport fees, preferring to hold onto her cash until she absolutely needed to spend it. She dug out of her bag her notebook and flipped the pages, knowing she would likely be journaling or at least sketching out some ideas for the next game.

Her game.

She had been thinking it through. This was her moment. Her first entry into John’s role. She would be the game master and she knew exactly how it would go down.

Eric Matthews would be integral to this. He had been one of the most crooked cops in the past decade. It was he who had helped create who she was today. And it was only poetically fair to have him face the monster she now was.

And she would have a front row seat, like John did when he tested Gordon. 

What would scare the shit out of Eric Matthews?

She knew Matthews had a son. He would likely be the motivation to keep Matthews compliant. She tried to imagine the kid, locked away in a room, while Matthews went insane trying to find him. There was guilt, involving someone so young, whose only crime was being related to a bastard. She didn’t want to hurt him. And John, too, drew the line with minors. But they would use him somehow.

She closed her eyes, pretending - to her personal disgust - that she was Eric Matthews. All she had was her kid. And what would be the worst thing that could happen to that kid - without maiming or killing him - that would have been completely Matthews’ fault in the first place?

Imagine if his kid had to be locked in a room with all the innocent people he framed and locked away?

Inspiration struck and she opened her eyes. 

Trapped, your only precious child, surrounded by all the people you locked away. People who were locked away from crimes you lied about. And they all want payback. Who could blame them?

The stakes had to be greater - an element of desperation was needed. A time limit always fried all rationale and made people nasty. Yet they would have to work together, despite it all.

Poison. They could be exposed to poison. And the cure is what everyone is trying to get.

She turned to John, wanting to talk to him about it. He didn’t acknowledge her stares. Biting her lip, she felt antsy and needed something else to do. 

“John.”

He looked up from his book, his stare of fury at what he was reading.

“Can I use your phone?”

He dug through his pocket and handed it to her, without question, and planted his nose back into the pages of what would likely be fueling his rants for the next few weeks.

At least it’s distracting him from Pederson.

She pressed through his address book, noting each number was separated by letters and numbers that made no sense. Normally, she’d jump at the opportunity to decrypt John’s brilliance, but she was tired.

“Which numer is that asshole’s?”

John gave her a look that hit her like a disappointed father. “You will need to clarify who that is.”

She sighed. “You know. Him . The,” she lowered her voice and only mouthed, “detective.” She could never be too careful, even if they were in a completely different country.

John took the phone, found the number, and pressed the green call button. “I hope you will start referring to each other by name or at least a less offensive moniker.”

“What does he call me?”

“I’d rather not say. It’s crude.”

She gave him a look, sometimes forgetting that John was a whole generation older than her and more sensitive to a few curse words. “For you, John, I’ll just call him knuckle dragger then.”

“Hm.” His face remained relaxed but the glint in his eye came and went as quickly as it arrived but to Amanda it was a triumph to have amused John.

The phone dialed and then she heard his ugly voice call in.

“Yeah?”

“I need you to go to your office records,” she didn’t bother with a greeting, “I need everything you’ve got on every person Matthews locked away - unfairly.”

“That’s a tall order you’re asking,” he growled. “You expect it by the time you land?”

“Yeah,” she liked telling him what to do. It felt right. “It shouldn’t be too hard, you were his partner in most of those specific cases, I bet. Like mine. Remember?”

“I’ll get you the paperwork. How’s John?”

“Fine. We’re expecting to land at nine thirty, your time.”

“You need a ride?”

She scoffed. “No, we’re fine. Just leave what you find on my desk.” She hung up the phone, impressed with herself for not throwing an extra ‘fuck you very much’ at the end of it. Maybe she was growing up.

 

Mark Hoffman

 

It had been several months since Mark found himself in a bar. The familiar smell of stale beer and cigarettes made both his mouth water and his head throb in anticipation of a hangover. Rigg was sitting at a table, off to the side and back in the corner, looking out at him. The brick walls behind him were cracked and faded, like roots of a rotten tree worming through the concrete. 

Rigg held a hand up when he saw Hoffman.

Mark nodded and joined him, noting the man had only finished half a pint. 

“Hey, Hoffman. Thanks for coming.”

“Yeah. Had some time off. You okay?”

Rigg looked uncomfortable, his lip curled in a forced smile. “You know. Just need to blow off some steam. Not a lot going on at work these days.”

“So go home.”

“In a little bit. The renovations are still ongoing.”

He understood that was code for: Tracy was giving him hell.

“Next round’s on me, then,” Mark offered and the waiter came to take their drink orders. Mark opted for a beer, knowing he’d need to keep his head clear for the next four hours. John was due to land and would be expecting a certain guest down in the bathroom. The files he had copied and collected for Amanda were currently in his trunk. Along with his latest creation.

The mechanism John specifically asked to have ready and operational was the Bowel Shredder, the gears greased and ready to be christened in fresh blood.

John’s anticipated guest was Henry Kessler, the man who had convinced John to go to Mexico. Finding him had been easy. The man had a record - a typical conman who preferred petty theft, social security fraud, and was currently on parole. He would get off his shift at the newspaper stand downtown and head back to his apartment. There, Mark would drop in on him,  pick him up and take him to have a little chat with John. 

“Women. Am I right?” Rigg gave a joking grin and took a drink. The waiter arrived and placed Mark’s drink on the table, the golden liquid foamed invitingly like butterscotch. Mark took the glass, savoring the taste. 

He couldn’t remember the last time he sat down and had a drink. The taste threw him off for a second, bitter and rich. It made him think of comfortable times, leaning back in his leather recliner, with the game on in the background. He couldn’t remember the last time he had a night like that. Years, long before Jigsaw. Before Will and him fell out. Before… “Can’t live with them,” he gave a good natured smile to his friend.

“Can’t live without them,” Rigg finished, sighing. “Fuck, Hoff, Tracy’s everything. But why is she always riding my ass?”

I can think of a couple of reasons. But he kept them to himself. Lately, Rigg had been working late nights, choosing to spend his free time working out or being useful at work instead of going home to his wife. Like Kerry, Rigg was taking the Jigsaw case personally, and his frustration in their department getting nowhere was clear on his face.

Before, Mark would have commended his work ethic. He would have thought it was an admirable trait to have. 

But now, Rigg was replaying the same tapes that Tapp and Sing had poured over. Though Mark was sure there was nothing there that could put him at risk, he still feared that he had missed something. Something that someone would find. And that was the one thing Hoffman could not allow. 

The man needs to realize that there’s more important things in his life than trying to catch the Jigsaw killer.

“Have you thought of taking some time off? Taking her on a trip somewhere?”

“She’d like that. But I couldn’t leave you guys like that. Maybe after Jigsaw’s captured.”

He’s obsessed. It’s all he talks about now.

“Well, not that I’m an expert on marriage, but I know some quality time is a good approach. Women love that. Buy her flowers. Take her out. Talk to her about whatever she wants. Try to look interested.”

“Yeah. That’s what she’s saying. But. I don’t know.” Rigg took a swig of his drink. “She wants to talk about a lot of things I just can’t.”

“Like?”

“Like moving. Transferring to the suburbs. Maybe trying for kids. She doesn’t want to stay in the city anymore. She wants to get away from all of this. The news freaks her out. She’s scared.”

“That’s understandable.” But should not be a problem for her, so long as she values her life.

“Yeah. I don’t know, we just started renovating that condo. All the money will be a waste if we just up and leave. In this economy, we’d be lucky to break even if we sell.”

“Yeah. But what’s more important? Money? Or your marriage?”

“It’s not that cut and dry,” Rigg grumbled.

Isn’t it?

“It’s hard,” Mark opted as the response. “But take it from me, you don’t want to lose her. You should show her how much she means to you.” While you still can.

Rigg looked up at him, now, with an almost piteous look that Mark didn’t appreciate. “You’re right, Hoff. You know, you need a vacation too.”

“I’m fine.”

“Don’t act like you’re not throwing everything you’ve got to catch this guy. We all see it.” Rigg patted Mark on the shoulder. “And Kerry? She’s doing what she can. But it’s not enough. I want to help. Ease the burden, you know? Carry my weight.”

“You pull plenty,” he growled back. “I’ll let you know if I need help. But don’t think you’re not contributing.”

Rigg backed down, thankfully. “Just say the word, Hoff, I’m your guy. I’ll do whatever it takes to catch that sick bastard.”

That’s what I’m afraid of, Mark thought, keeping his face still.

 

(Power of Will)

 

Henry Kessler was easy enough to tail. The man drove slow and safe, signaling every turn and not driving with any indication of paranoia.

From what John had explained, the guy had been the first to lure John into that cancer treatment scam. Amanda had filled him in, begrudgingly, on the details that John had been too ashamed to say himself while she had prepared for her trip to Mexico to join him.

They went to his fucking cancer support group. That’s how John got into this mess. I heard Gordon had warned him against treatment. Hell, his insurance company denied him. But who wouldn’t try a miracle treatment, if there was a shred of hope? So John needs help teaching those fuckers a lesson. So I’m going to Mexico. John says you’re in charge. If you’re bored, there’s plenty of traps to work on. I’ve been trying to fix this problem with the Death Mask’s timer not triggering the clamp when the timer finishes. Also, there’s this razor box John needs plexiglass and steel sheets for. Schematics are on the prep table. You’ve got our numbers. Don’t burn the place down. Oh, and John says no tests here until he’s back. You think you can handle that? Or should I speak slower?”

She had been surprisingly less hostile, but more distracted and scared. This made Mark concerned for John but he knew better than to try to involve himself and take the sudden trip to Mexico. Despite Amanda’s faults, she would die for John. This was the only reassurance to Mark’s nerves that if things went wrong in Mexico and he wasn’t there to help, that they would either come back in peace or both die.

It had been a fleeting hope.

So he would keep things running stateside until they got back.

Kessler parked his car in the apartment complex lot and got out of the car. In the last two nights, he had opted for the same route down the secluded walkway where a tall fence separated him from the view of any fellow residents who were looking out their windows. Mark had come back earlier that week to confirm there were no cameras. 

He parked a healthy distance away, killed the engine, and pulled on the pig mask.

It had begun to snow.

This made it hard for Mark to stay quiet, his feet crunching into the frost. But he could follow the fresh footprints, Kessler being the only person walking home. It was two in the morning. Only hooligans and the boogeyman were out this late.

He tried to walk faster to close the gap. Kessler was already halfway to the apartment lobby. This would mean his window of opportunity was vanishing. It had to be tonight. 

“Who’s there?!” Kessler had stopped and spun around. The man must have heard Hoffman’s footsteps. 

Hoffman, thankfully, had hidden behind the bushes and vines growing along the wooden fence, staying nestled in the brittle leaves and shadows. He waited for Kessler to shake off what he thought was paranoia and continue his walk back home.

It wouldn’t be likely he would get to the man close enough to grab him. Plus, Kessler was one of the largest test subjects he’d had to subdue so far. This was why Hoffman brought out his new toy. A special purchase he had made, after Paul Leahy had knocked the breath out of him.

The tranquilizer gun was light and easy to aim. He had practiced in the storage wing of the Gideon Meatpacking Plant, using the frozen pig carcasses that remained frostbitten in the freezers as targets.

He shot twice, to be sure.

“Agh!” Kessler had flinched at the first shot, reaching for his back, the dart likely penetrating the meat of his shoulder, but already collapsing down on his knees from the fast acting sedative.

He slumped over into the snow, out cold.

Hoffman quickly went over to the man and took in a sharp breath in mental preparation. This guy was big. He’d have to drag him several hundred feet to his car.

Better get started.

 

(Power of Will)

 

“John, you need to rest,” Amanda’s voice was, for the first time, a welcome to hear. Hoffman pulled away from sharpening a steel plate, going to the entranceway where Amanda was holding two backpacks and John was leaning against the doorway, looking ready to collapse.

Hoffman quickly stepped forward and took John’s arm around his shoulder.

“Get the chair,” he ordered Amanda, who thankfully didn’t argue. She dropped the bags and came back with the wheelchair.

“No,” John tried to resist, “I am perfectly capable of stand-” he coughed, violently, and Mark felt the sudden drop of body weight against him. John had pushed himself, too hard, it seemed. Despite his frailty, the man was still very heavy to support.

Mark and Amanda eased John into the chair, Amanda pulling from the attached oxygen canister the mask for John to breathe from.

John squinted his eyes, resistant, but eventually surrendering to his fate. He breathed deep from the concentrated air, looking up at Mark.

“Did you see to our guest?”

“He’s waiting for you downstairs.”

“Good.” John coughed again. “Good. I want to speak to him.”

“Take your time. He’s not going anywhere.”

“Good. Then tomorrow,” John breathlessly added, “We will discuss the next steps to begin Amanda’s trap.”

Mark raised an eyebrow while Amanda’s face lit up with a triumphant smile. 

“You’re not wasting any time.”

“My time’s run out,” John whispered, and as he looked up at Mark, there was a resolution in the lines of his face that was a vacuum of acceptance. “There is still much to do.”

Mark waited for John to regain his strength and he pushed off from the wheelchair. “I’m dying, but I can still stand. Especially for our guest. Amanda. You may go. Be prepared to explain what you plan on doing for your first game over breakfast.”

Amanda nodded, eyes electric and jittery with eagerness as she left them.

“Come, detective, let us have a little chat with Henry.”

“What about the masks?” Hoffman had wondered what John had in store for Henry.

“No. There is no need. It will be a short game, I’m sure.”

They walked, slowly, for John’s pace was limited and there were moments where John coughed, sweat beaded his forehead, but he pressed on.

Mark understood why John did so, as a means to defy with all his might, for however long he could, that the end was near.

He could not decipher his emotions, which ranged from painstaking glee to a daunting chill of uncertainty.

“Detective, when I die, what will you do?”

Mark stiffened. “I’ll continue to do what I’ve been doing. Work MPD. Keep an eye on any evidence that points to us. Keep the investigation off our backs.”

“Will you work with Amanda?”

“I doubt she would want to,” he responded, pausing at the bathroom door. 

“And if she did?”

Then she’d have to go. “We would come to an understanding.” Mark slid the door open. He flipped the light switch.

Each overhead fixture exploded in piercing white light.

The shadow, suspended by his wrists above his head, floating like a great shadowed chandelier, greeted them.

Henry Kessler was gagged, writhing, making muffled moans and cries, turning his head, and staring at them with wide eyes.

John stepped towards him, a wraith with glittering stare full of loathing, a cruel smile growing on his thin lips. “Where is your scar… Henry?”

Henry pulled at his chains, biceps flexed, screaming. 

“Thank you, Detective. For locating my fellow cancer patient.” Hoffman took that as his cue, going to the corner of the room to retrieve the bowel shredder, fastening it on the man’s shoulders, tightening the belt straps, firmly. “Out of all the men to cheat, you picked John Kramer?” Hoffman couldn’t help but smirk. “I mean, I call that,” what do the kids say these days? He went to undue the gag, “epic bad luck.”

“Please,” Henry begged, “John please. Please don’t kill me.”

“That’s the last thing you should be worried about. Now I want to play a game.”

Mark flipped the switch to the blade sweeper box and stepped back as the whirl of the motor grew. The way John made it sound, it was unlikely Henry would survive this trap.

“You preyed upon the vulnerable, promising them salvation, while you pocketed away the scraps of their desperation. Gutless. Now, this device contains the key to your redemption. But first, you need to show some guts.

Mark thought this would be an especially painful one for a subject to experience. The trap had a force sensor, detecting the man’s body weight from the wrist straps he was suspended in. As the blades cut into him, his intestines would begin to fall. He had to curl and do sit ups with his legs to enable more of his insides to come out. At the right weight reduction, the mechanical fasteners strapped to his wrists would release and he would fall. And thus, survive.

The blades began to slice and then the screams began, echoing off the moldy tiles of the bathroom. The man threw his feet up, trying to kick John, who had stepped back just in time. He let out a scream in pain as the blades started slicing into his lower stomach, his kick having curved his torso to angle the blades to have easy purchase to his flesh.

He didn’t even wait to hear the rules.

Blood poured down his jeans and Henry’s eyes were shut tight. And then he kicked again, to Hoffman’s amazement.

“ARGGH!” Henry screamed, as if he could not have foreseen this happening again to him. Maybe he was not thinking clearly, terror driving the fight or flight instinct and resulting in the immediate ripping open of the lower abdomen. 

Already, the skin had been torn out, the intestines appearing and beginning to fall out.

John stood, watching, unmoved, as Henry flailed and screamed, each jerk and kick becoming slower and weaker. Until finally, Henry stilled with only the gentle trickle of blood dripping down his feet and onto the tile floor. Not enough flesh had been sacrificed.

“I recommend lowering the body before it begins to rot,” John advised and Hoffman went to remove the device and went to the wall where the chains had been fastened to suspend Henry. Hoffman untwisted the locking mechanism and the chain flew from his hand, up the pulley on the ceiling and Henry fell in a meaty thump that echoed with the metallic clang of chains.

“This game was different. How did you know it would be so short?”

“I’ve told you,” John answered, “when you anticipate human behavior. It leaves nothing to chance. A man who preys upon those who are dying, can never have valued his own life.”

Hoffman wondered if he would ever develop that uncanny skill. He hoped so.

 

(Power of Will)

 

“Hoffman, where the hell have you been?”

“Sorry,” he responded, “My battery died. Didn’t realize til I woke up.” It was six in the morning. He hadn’t slept, having spent the rest of the evening dragging Henry Kessler’s body to the corner of the meatpacking plant where barrels of hydrofluoric acid were stored in cases where John needed specific test subjects to disappear. But for now, the body was suspended in the freezer, along with dozens of pig carcasses.

Normally, John found it fitting to leave their subjects in their traps for the police to find. 

But the bathroom trap was not a location they wanted the police to learn of. And though they left the remains of Adam Faulkner-Stanheight there, it took weeks of sprinkling lye over his rotting body to finally make the smell bearable. The underground tunnel systems that connected the Gideon Meatpacking plant with various other properties John himself had purchased were a protected secret that Hoffman knew the Metropolitan Police Department had no idea about.

And Henry Kessler, a man seen with John Kramer in multiple support group meetings and coffee shops, had to have no trace of having any trace to Jigsaw.

This would not be a game that the police should ever know about.

“Well, get over here. We have another survivor. We’ve already interviewed him.”

“Who?”

“The doctor that went missing months ago. Gordon.”

Shit.

“I’ll be right over there.” Hoffman had been on his bed, freshly showered, eager to get to bed, when he turned on his phone. Looks like I’ll have to sleep during my lunch break. 

He got up to put on a fresh suit and went to work.

When he got there, a news van was parallel parked right outside the front. 

Double shit.

He parked and got out of the car, dodging ice patches, passing the many officers who seemed to be abuzz with excitement.

He went to the interrogation rooms, really wishing he had time for a cup of coffee.

“Hoffman!” Fisk called out to him, wide eyed, and like a goddamn guardian angel, held up two cups of coffee. He handed one over to Hoffman and led him to the right room. “There you are. Kerry’s already started the interview.”

“Guess I’ll join them,” Hoffman braced himself, knowing Gordon was not ready for this.

 

Lawrence Gordon

 

When the door opened, Lawrence had to clench his jaw to prevent it from flying open.

Him?!

“Hoffman, there you are,” Detective Kerry gave a nod. “Dr. Lawrence, this is Detective Mark Hoffman. He’s second in command for the Jigsaw Serial Killer Task Force. He’s been working on this case since the very beginning.”

“Pleasure to meet you,” Hoffman held out his hand and Lawrence, dumbly, took it, still trying to determine if he was dreaming.

Not dreaming. Nightmare.

But now he understood why John Kramer had let him go, despite knowing who he was. He has eyes and ears in his own investigation.

Lawrence had felt like a punch to the gut at realizing that if he had spilled the beans on what he knew, he would be endangering himself and his family. Never had he felt more relieved for leaning towards caution until that moment when the police asked for details.

He had given them nothing so far.

“So, Doctor,” Hoffman opened the manila folder, as if he needed a moment to get caught up on the facts and evidence. As if he has no idea what this was about. What he did to me. “Your trap was reported… in six weeks.”

“Yes.” He now didn’t dare to add anything, sweat beginning to drip down his back. He kept his hands on his knees, firm, to help with the shaking.

His stump hurt and he wanted to ice it, more than anything.

Detective Kerry is looking at me funny. Oh, god. I bet I look suspicious right now.

“Can you start from the very beginning? Of your experience?”

“I…” the words clung to the inside of his lungs, refusing to escape.

“I know this is hard,” Hoffman leaned forward, eyes intent, “so feel free to take your time. Know that any information you give will be helpful. Don’t be shy.”

Kerry had turned to him, looking confused but Gordon let his shoulders relax. He took that as permission to not try to lie.

“I woke up in a bathroom,” he began. “I was chained to the wall.”



Will Maddox

 

Will looked around nervously as she picked the lock. The hall stretched out like a dark maw, gaping and hungry, but empty of any teeth. Not a soul was out and about. Only the muffled shouting of a woman and the occasional shatter of glass sounded around her. 

The slender tools felt delicate in her hands and though she had practiced often on the trainer locks back at MPD, she was struggling to find that sweet spot, where the resistance gave and let her rotate the instrument and press deeper into the keyhole. And when it finally reached the end, that moment where the tension wrench could go no further, she sighed in relief at the sound of the tumbler clicking and eagerly pushed the door open with a satisfying creak.

Ethan Kotroff lived in a rundown studio apartment right on the border of Mexico. And he had just driven off for his nightly routine of barhopping and womanizing. She didn’t expect him to return any time soon but she would need to get in and out fast. 

Will still remembered Otay Mesa back in her early years but a lot had changed since then. Her rental car stood out like a glossy white thumb in the parking lot where the nicest car was ten years old with doors painted a different color from the rest of its body.

She had come here alone, the clearly lone gringa who drew stares from anyone she was near.

She knew it was dangerous but she wasn’t stupid. She had left Allison and Lindsay voicemails, letting them know that if she didn’t call in to confirm her safety in a few hours, to raise the alarm and get help to this location.

Peter, though, believed she was visiting her father. She knew he wouldn’t approve. But she couldn’t tell him. 

Their warm, intense relationship had fallen apart as quickly as it had ignited, like flash paper.

She had told Peter she was visiting her father and brother. Which wouldn’t be a complete lie as she would go to them after she went through Kotroff’s personal effects.

She closed the door behind her and started exploring the apartment. He lived like a slob. Empty beer bottles were strewn on the floor and on every surface. A bong rested on the coffee table. Foil with what looked like heroin burned into the sheet metal and that familiar chemical burn stench in the air would mean she’d need to take a shower as soon as she left. She put on her gloves, not wanting to risk skin contact with anything dangerous.

Sloppily hung nudes of busy women, some in impressively flexible poses, were tacked onto the walls.

The air was stale, as if old fast food had been left out to petrify and ash trays were never emptied in this space.

She kept the lights off, taking her flashlight off her belt and shined it to the ground. Stepping over the oily rag and filthy carpet, she let herself absorb her environment.

Though it was unlikely for Kotroff to have any receipts or statements left on the kitchen counter that proclaimed his guilt, she tried to find any use for the crumpled gas station receipts and junk mail. Her eyes landed on the torn up pieces of paper by the telephone and shined her light over them.

Initials, phone numbers and shorthand notes were left in a cluttered pile.. D.E. 555-3498. Whore 210 - 4203. She gingerly flipped through, stopping when she found P.R. 859-9980.

Taking her cell phone, she held it and took a picture. Not finding anything else of note in the kitchen she made herself to the stained bed. 

The nightstand drawers held condoms, a gun, a crack pipe, and an envelope.

Taking the envelope she looked inside to see polaroids, letters, and pictures. Most were of women in the expected style Kotroff preferred of clotheless and highly sexualized. Some had a younger Kotroff, but nothing that kept her attention. Until she saw one that made her pause. For a moment, it felt as though she was looking at a black and white nude of herself. But then her face burned when she realized why she felt confused. Is that… my mother? The image was grainy and not clear. She shook her head, not believing it. No. She’d never hook up with this scumbag.

She sifted through the letters, rapidly, wanting the yawning terror to subside. 

Most were yellowed and faded with age. Will didn’t understand how so many women seemed to find this guy charming enough to write love notes to but then she found a crisp white envelope stamped PRISONER’S LETTER EXAMINED. The postage was dated to just weeks ago.

Her pulse quickened as she pulled out the contents. Four pages.

  1.  

Cute redhead paid me a visit. Remember the job back in 81? That bitch you shagged, the one with the fat tits we had to deal with? It’s her daughter. She’s a cop. Keep a lookout. 

She raised her phone and tried to take a picture but the image captured was grainy and illegible. She cursed. She had a notepad in her back pocket and began copying the letters down. But it would take a while. She returned to the picture of the nude woman and took a snapshot of her phone.

She could have simply taken them, but she wanted to not leave a trace. 

Would he even notice? She knew he would. So she bit the bullet and began writing, fast.

After she had finished jotting down the first two pages, jumping at the sound of the neighbors’ turning their TV on or slamming the door too loud, she kept her eye trained at the window, able to see the empty assigned parking spot where Kotroff used. 

And when she reached the last page her heart sank.

Of all the damn luck.

Kotroff’s gray sedan pulled into the spot. She looked down, not sure whether it would be worth it to simply take the letter and risk tipping the perp off that someone had broken into his apartment. 

But she didn’t trust her memory to simply recall every important detail of the letter. She needed every word. Every detail.

She opted to simply take the last page, folding it into her inner jacket breast pocket and returning the rest of the letter back into its envelope and keeping it as close to its original position as she had found it.

And she quickly made her way to the front door, locking the knob and closing it behind her.

The stairs. There was only one staircase in this building.

There were no elevators. She bit her lip and went towards the opposite end of the hall, leaning at the farthest door, hoping the dim light wouldn’t bring attention to her hair color and pretended she was on the phone.

She heard footsteps. Looking up, she saw Kotroff who walked with the slight off-balance and the dazed expression of a man who preferred a liquid dinner. A heavily made up woman with fishnet stockings was with him, leaning against him as she managed to stay on her high heeled pumps while they giggled, oblivious of anyone else but each other. She turned away.

“Si. Si. Abuela, lo siento. No. Iré a la iglesia mañana, lo prometo.” Will used to say the exact same line when she was undercover, twenty years ago in her rookie years when she served with SDPD. It was all the Spanish she knew, and her accent sounded atrociously comical.

Hopefully it still works, she prayed.

The man paid her no mind and she heard him unlock his door and slam it shut.

She immediately power walked down the hall, trying to keep her footsteps muffled, turned the corner, and made it to the stairs.

As soon as she felt the cool night air hit her face she let out a sigh of relief. She was at her car and dug in her pocket for the keys.

“How’s your Dad, Will?”

She jumped, hand at her hip for her gun, and let out a gasp when the man in the shadows stepped forward.

She had missed him there. “Peter?”

“What the hell are you doing?” He looked furious. He stepped towards her and grabbed her wrist, keeping it at her hip.

“I-,” his grip was tight and she was speechless by the rage contorting his face. 

“This is illegal, Will. You know that. We have no jurisdiction here. We have no warrant. What’s worse, you could have been killed.”

She looked around anxiously. “Can we discuss this later? Somewhere more private?” She leaned in with a whisper, hoping they weren’t drawing a crowd.

“I don’t know, Will, can we? You’ve been shutting me out every time we have a chance to discuss this. I know you’re frustrated with the delays but you can’t just go pulling this shit here. This could ruin both our careers, don’t you understand?”

She forced herself free from his grasp but he grabbed her wrist. 

“I’m not done.”

“Yeah, you are. Look what you’re doing, how did you know I was here? Were you following me?”

Peter’s face held traces of a sneer mixed with the contorted anger. “What if I was? You were acting strange lately, I was concerned for our safety.”

“I can take care of myself, Peter,” Will put her hand to her chest, newfound courage arising. She had been here, before, many times in the past. Her entire life, men had always felt they had to protect her - even if it meant stopping her from doing her job. And now, in the most important case of her life, Peter was just like the others.

“Really? Because you sure have a funny way of doing so.”

His sarcasm set her over the edge. She knew she was too angry to be calm and rational about this. But Peter was suffocating her. She let out a harsh sigh. “I can’t with you. You know what? We’re done. Just - leave me alone. Stop worrying about me. I’ll be fine.” She tried to pull her wrist away but he tightened his grip on her. “Let go, Peter.”

His strength was beginning to hurt her. His nostrils flared and it was clear he wasn’t going to listen to her. “We’re done? Just like that?” For the first time she saw something almost dangerous in how he looked down at her. “We’re not done until I say we’re done.” He put his arms around her, possessively, and pulled her into a tight hug. “You’re just stressed. Tired. You’re not thinking clearly. I know I’ve made things difficult for you. I’m sorry. Let’s just get some sleep. We’ll talk things over tomorrow.”

Now she was pissed. “Get off of me.” She tried to pull out of his grip but he was too strong. He had her, and she had let him, because despite how pissed she was, she trusted him. But now a newfound anxiety filled her with that distant nostalgia that was more terror than rumination.

Not this again. “I said get off me.”

“Will, please,” he kept her in his hug, as though he could force forgiveness by squeezing it into her. She stiffened but let him, hoping it would be enough. But then he pulled back to give himself room to lean down and kiss her. His mouth pressed into hers, firm and demanding, and she bit his lip with all her might and when he withdrew she threw her weight into the slap that struck his face. 

“That was uncalled for,” he snapped, wiping the blood on his lip. Her face burned with anger in response.

It’s usually six months in when people start to show their true colors.

She should have known better. When it came to men, she sure knew how to pick them.

Peter stood before her, heat and anger burning in his scowl. There was a hint of concern but something more. She recognized it immediately.

It was a need to have the upper hand. To control her.

She had seen it plenty of times in the past. She remembered how Frank hated it when she made the call to anything that went on in her life.

And here she was, dealing with the same shit all over again.

I’m so goddamn tired of men trying to tell me how to live my life.

It was like she brought out this behavior in them, like a pheromone.

But she was done with dealing with it and learned from her trainwreck of a marriage. “Go away, Peter.”

He stepped toward her but she quickly reached for her gun, not withdrawing it but ready to. She didn’t want to use it. But he was taller than her. And the adrenaline coursing through her made her senses sharp and ready.

“What are you doing, Will?” Peter wiped his mouth again, a trail of pink on his lips.

“You should be asking yourself that question. Back off. Or I will defend myself.”

This would be a messy scene. Already there was a nearby bystander walking their dog, observing curiously. But she wouldn’t go down like this again. And god DAMN IT why did it have to be him that went this way? 

“You’re being irrational.”

“No. You of all people should know…” but the words froze on her tongue. Of course he had known. He knew every part of her. He had been her damn therapist, and now Will felt like an idiot. A damn fool. The ethical violation should have been a clear red flag, damnit.

“I know you’re afraid. I’m sorry. I will not hurt you. I just lost my temper. I’m sorry.”

She shook her head. “I can’t believe I thought you were…” she didn’t finish her sentence, just the thought brought tears to her eyes. 

My friend. Someone I could trust - to be with.  

“Just stay the fuck away from me, Peter.”

“Will, it’s not-,” when he took the step towards her she took the gun out of the holster, keeping it trained to the ground, holding it in both hands. “Will, calm down.”

“Oh, shut the fuck up Peter and get in your car. Or I’ll make a bigger deal out of this than it needs to be.”

He straightened his wide eyes narrowing. The chill in his stare and the sudden passivity in his face only heightened her nerves. He straightened up. “You’re making a big mistake.”

“No. I’m fixing the big mistake I made when I fucked you.” She took a step back towards her car. 

“Will, you’re experiencing an emotional crisis.”

“Oh, save it. You’re the crisis.” She had to do everything she could to keep her voice level and her breathing steady. She was trying so hard to keep things together. But she was currently back to the night she jumped out that window. She was just about to jump over the edge. No, he will not be a repeat of that.

“Will-,”

“GO!” She screamed and this made Peter flinch. His shoulders slumped for a second before he rounded them. 

“Fine. I’ll go. But when you've calmed down, call me. You’re being emotional. And I get that. So I’ll be at the hotel. Your things are still there.” He finally got into his car and left.

“Don’t wait up for me,” she called back. He didn’t turn back.

As soon as his car left the parking lot she finally cried. Tears, hot and bitter, poured down her cheeks. I’m just so tired of this. So damn tired of all this.

“Lady? You okay? Need me to call the cops?” The man with his dog came up, looking uncertain and worried.

“No. I’ve got it. I’m a cop. I’ll be fine. Please, go about your day. I’m just leaving now.” She got into her car and drove off.

She continued down the five, heading north, heading back to the motel. Despite her mind spinning and her throat closing up another sensation weighed in her chest, and made her crave a cigarette. She felt that nervousness rise, adrenaline opening up her blood vessels as her heart started a sprint.

I could really use a drink, right about now.

She checked her rearview mirror, noticing the headlights behind her. Familiar - not because she recognized the car, but because it struck her with that deja vu sensation.

She took a right turn. 

The car copied her.

She took a sharp U-turn and slammed her foot on the gas, blasting down the street, expecting the car to not follow and to then laugh at her own paranoia.

The car squealed behind her, sharply turning and speeding up to stay riding her bumper.

Damn it. 

It was too dark to see who it was, only the silhouette of two men and the white lights shined bright. 

Whoever was driving behind her had skill. She had always aced her Emergency Vehicle Operations evaluations but her pursuer seemed to match her skills and maneuvers well. She needed to find a speed trap to pull a cop. She’d likely get a ticket but she’d explain. She swerved and crossed multiple lanes, now in a wide stretch of the highway. She still knew the roads like the back of her hand and recalled the preferred places for patrol cars to park as they waited for particular speeders, undetected. California drivers always went at least ten over but even the most laid back trapper would have to take chase at a sedan screaming down at 120 mph on the five. 

The car behind her still kept close, and easier than her puny rental sedan. 

They have a better engine. She could have sworn it was a Charger. 

She saw the familiar patrol car, parked under streetlights and flashed by him. The car remained.

What the hell? The fucker taking a nap or something?!

She tried to zig zag between another set of drivers to avoid her tail but the follower continued. 

When she passed another squad car and realized there would be no comfort in flashing red and blue lights, that's when she realized.

It’s one of them.

She was being tailed by someone who must have given the heads up for any patrol to stand back. So it’s an unmarked car.

She slowed her driving at a red light. And she squinted in the rearview mirror, trying to decipher the two men who were behind her. A car in the opposite direction drove by, their headlights shining a spotlight directly over their faces. 

She recognized them. Her face slackened. Her shoulders slumped. 

When I thought I could not be disappointed anymore.

She took her phone out and dialed the number she still remembered.

“Hi Freckles.”

“Homie. How are you and Dragna on this lovely evening?”

“I think you should pull over, Will. We need to talk.”

“Fine.” She hung up. When the light turned green she pulled over in front of a grocery store, finding the milling about late night shoppers and the many parking street lights comforting. She hoped there were cameras. But even then, it’s not like the department couldn’t just make them ‘disappear’ after the fact. Not like cameras always captured what you needed them to.

She got out of the car, keeping her hands visible, recognizing how her counterparts also held themselves with the familiar stance to reach for their weapons at the drop of a hat if they needed to.

“You’ve worn out your welcome, Maddox,” Dragna spoke first, shaking his head. “I think it’s time you get out of town. Before things get messy.”

“Listen to him, Will.”

“This,” Will shook her head and gestured with her hand, “only makes it clear to me my mother's case wasn’t just a random crime.”

“It was,” Dragna spat. “Random and insignificant. And you, coming here, digging up insignificant shit is only going to make life difficult for my department.”

“Why?”

“Because you, Detective Lieutenant, have a reputation that would be the media’s wet dream. And elections are coming up.”

“Right. Can’t have your image ruined. Because that’s what only matters for you,” she always despised him but at this moment, she wanted to run up and start wailing her fists into his nose.

“You’re quite the investigator, Will, but we’ve got you for breaking in without a warrant. For burglary. Hell, battery and domestic violence, from that little spat with your FBI boyfriend.”

She bit the inside of her cheek, tasting blood. “How long have you been following me?”

“Long enough. Your mother’s death was unfortunate. And know that Philip Rhodes is locked away for a long time. He killed your mother. Know that he will never be allowed out of prison. You have my word.”

She squinted at him. “Can you prove it?”

Dragna smiled, the grin of a snake to a mouse. “Did you not find sufficient evidence in Kotroff’s residence?”

She blinked. “Why? It wasn’t her resisting the burglary. Why did he kill her then?”

Dragna inhaled, exasperated. “Because bad things happen to good people. Because she was in the wrong place at the wrong time. People die. I know you were a good girl and miss your mommy. But remember, you still have a father. A brother.” He said this, with that predatory grin that whispered, I can take them all away, with the wave of a hand.

“Will, please,” Martinez sighed. “Think about Gomez.”

What?” Will raised an eyebrow. “What about Gomez?”

“Leave and I will allow Gomez to retire and keep his pension. Don’t, and Gomez will be dragged through the dirt.”

“That’s the worst you can do?” She almost laughed. “What’s he got to do with this? And what about you, Homie? When did you start licking Chet’s boots so good?”

“Enough. I know you’ve always been loyal to a fault. And that’s just the start. You’ve got plenty of people here, Will. I have not forgotten your brother. Bram, isn’t it? And your father, Jules. He was once a respected member of the community, before your mother’s death. They had a large insurance settlement after what happened. It’s how your family was able to stay afloat, all these years. A shame if there was a lot of focus in auditing how the Maddox family managed the many businesses Jules ran. I’m sure my friend at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration would be more than happy to perform some audits to ensure your affairs were properly maintained. A college drop out dealing with the emotional burdens of a comatose father, an aunt with Alzheimer’s, and a negligent sister, must have struggled. But you know how the IRS and DTFA can be. How easy it would be, in another light, to see it as just another guy trying to cheat the system for some easy money.”

Hot anger flared and she stepped forward.

“Will, easy,” Homie held a hand out, another hand on the gun at his hip. “You can’t win this, you know this. Just go home. Leave like you did, before. No drama. No problem.”

Her heart pounded in her chest. Again. This was all happening all over again. Only now, she wasn’t a scared young rookie. And she was still in a losing game.

DAMN IT!

“Fine. I’ll go.” She hated herself for the burning resentment she felt to her family, for being the reason she could never not know what happened to her mother.

“I would say you’re smart, but if you were, you would have known better than to come back. We better not have to continue this conversation again. I will not be as lenient a third time.” Chet Dragna had a triumphant smirk. Will swallowed back the blood that came from her chewing her cheeks.

One day. I don’t know when. I don’t know how. But you’ll pay, Dragna.

 

(Power of Will)

 

“Will? When did you land in San Diego? Wait, are you okay? Your eyes look like…” Bram stopped, knowing better than to ask. She wouldn’t have told him. He reached down and took the bag from her. “Come in, Dad’s asleep, but he’ll be so happy to see you in the morning.”

She stepped into her childhood home. The home with the same 70’s wallpaper and shaggy carpet. The same wooden paneling and the kitschy figurines of deer her mother liked to collect. The same place where she grew up and where her whole life changed forever.

She expected more pain to return to this place but she found herself feeling a delayed numbed sadness that barely penetrated the skin. “Sorry for dropping in on short notice.”

She hadn’t told them she had been frequenting the area for months now. How long was it? Ten months now? Almost a whole year, and still she had no answers. No truth.

But the last page of Philip Rhodes’ letter was burning in her pocket. 

“I’m pretty tired so I’m just going to turn in. But I’ll explain everything tomorrow, okay Bram?”

“Yeah, sure thing.” Bram kissed her on the cheek and put an arm around her in a shallow hug. “This is your home, too. Always will be.”

She nodded and made her way to her bedroom.

The same bedroom where she had cowered, in the closet, while she heard her baby brother’s wails and her mother’s screams. And then the gunshots. Pop pop pop.

She tossed her bag on the bed and went to the bathroom to brush her teeth and wash her face. She looked like a mess with bags under her eyes and it was clear she was losing too much weight. Her face looked gaunt and older. Or am I just getting older? 

The familiar lines that formed reminded her that she wasn’t the spry young twenty-something anymore, but a woman in her mid forties who had seen and experienced everything life could throw at her. 

She sighed. Maybe she was losing her edge. Maybe she never had one to begin with.

It was two in the morning. She got ready for bed and tried to fall asleep. But her mind was reeling with Peter, Philip Rhodes, Ethan Kotroff, and how she felt as though she was stuck in limbo. She thought of her department. When was the last time she actually spoke to Allison? God knows how Eric was holding up. And Mark.

She sat up, defeated, knowing she would likely not get much sleep tonight. She took her cell phone off the charger and took it to the back patio, where the same outdoor furniture since she could remember resided for her to sit on. The gas powered fire pit she used to roast marshmallows on still worked. She turned the dial and let the click of the flint and the burst of orange flames warm her. She sank back into the old cushions and wicker frame of the rattan lounger and let her eyes train onto the flames as she threw tempted glances at her cell phone screen, struggling to determine whether or not it would be a good idea to call him.

It’s 11:15 over there. Still fairly early.

Fuck it.

She dialed his number and nervously waited for the ringing to end.

“Will?”

She closed her eyes, relieved he answered.

“Hey, Mark. How’s the weather back home?”

“What’s wrong?”

“What makes you think something' s wrong?”

“Your voice gets husky when you’ve been crying.”

She let out a low laugh, forcefully, hoping it would come off as jubilant or carefree.

“That bad, huh?”

“Not bad, in fact, kind of sexy.”

“I’m hanging up.”

“I’m teasing, don’t hang up. Need to talk?”

She pursed her lips. He always could read her so well. “Mm, it’s a long story. I don’t want to keep you up.”

“Well, it just so happens my schedule’s freed up and I can’t sleep. I want to hear it.”

She loved the way he made her feel safe and heard. The fleeting thought that this was another thing for her not to believe - that he, too, would unveil himself to be just another asshole had come and gone.

No. She knew Hoffman for too long. They were family. He was one of her dearest friends. But the fact that they were once more made her hesitate.

“I broke up with Peter.”

There was a pause.

“Can’t say I’m particularly disappointed by this. But I’m sorry you’re hurting. Want me to beat his ass?”

She couldn’t help but laugh a little. “No. But thanks.”

“He’s a tool, his loss.” His words made her heart skip. How had she not noticed the complete relief lifting her spirits as though she had been buried alive and for the first time in years had broken free and was tasting fresh air for the first time? 

“It was a bit messy.”

“Hopefully not as messy as us back then?”

“Well.” She remembered when Mark had told her to leave him, back when he had blamed her for everything. He had been drunk. She had been crying. Larry had pretended he had something to do in his office and left the bar unsupervised for their sake. It had been the worst night of her life in recent memory. Until tonight.  “Let’s just say I saw Peter’s true colors. And they weren’t pretty.”

“Like I said. Guy’s a tool. Saw it a mile away.”

She bowed her head. “Did you?”

“Those feds always like to think they’re better than regular cops. I’ve never liked him.”

“I could tell.”

“What about your mother’s case?”

“Uh,” she paused, her cheek stinging as she poked her tongue at the open wound. “Still ongoing.”

“Hmm,” he didn’t like her response. “I can tell when you’re hiding something. What is it?”

She exhaled sharply. “It’s not looking like it’s going to work out.”

“How come? What’s the lead you both are chasing? Or is Strahm not backing you up now that you’re both over?”

“Actually,” she wiped the streaks of tears off her cheeks, “this whole time, he was getting in the way. On purpose.”

A long silence followed with Hoffman’s voice dark and furious. “That’s fucked. Why the fuck was he doing that?”

“Hell if I know.” She had a hunch but wouldn’t say.

“Fucking FBI. Probably some weird political power play. Feds are always useless. Well, I’ve got your back. Got anything you need done?”

“I - uh… well… it’s not just him that got in the way. Let’s just say I got told to leave town or else tonight.”

“Are you in danger?” His voice quickly turned to concern. “Where are you?”

“I’m fine. It was just a warning. Not a - swim with the fishes warning - but the cops here told me they’ll come after Bram and Dad. So I’m going to leave… soon.”

“Just like that? Jesus, what kind of show does San Diego run?”

“You know. Typical corruption. Choose your crime syndicate. I’m pretty sure the commissioner's working with the Russian mob. And my family’s involved. And…” she wanted to add her mother’s involvement but couldn’t. “Well. I may try to come back when the heat dies down. But I don’t know. I’m just… it’s a lot. I’m barely holding it in, to be honest.”

Hoffman’s breathing was soft on the speaker. It was comforting to her, to hear him there.

“We’ll get through this. I know you’ll get through this. Tell me. You find anything? Must be good, whatever it is, if it got them to chase you off.”

“Oh,” the letter had slipped her mind. “Let me fill you in.” She explained in a low voice what she had accomplished that day while returning to her room to grab the notebook, the letter, and pour herself a well deserved glass of brandy from her father’s stash. When she returned to the fireplace she was speaking louder and fast. “Let me read it to you.”

“I’m listening.”

She took a healthy swig first, then squinted in the dim light at her own handwriting, having been rushed and her normally legible letters were reduced to chicken scratch. 

 

“‘ E. 

Cute redhead paid me a visit. Remember the job back in 81?That bitch you shagged, the one with the fat tits we had to deal with? It’s her daughter. She’s a cop. Keep a lookout. 

I forget her name but she was asking a lot of questions that would make J nervous. Remember J took good care of us back then. Took us fishing out on the lake. If we keep J happy, the good deal won’t end. I’ll be out soon. It’s what’s keeping me going in this crapshoot. Is that payout when I’m finally out.

Send me some good shit, won’t you? Gets boring as hell here. Fuck, I’d ask you to score me some mags. Some with a-,’” Will felt her face blush.

“What?” Mark’s voice merely made her embarrassment worse.

“You know, just classy literature right here.”

“Since when were you so delicate?”

“I’m not - ugh, fine.” She continued, “ ‘Some with a firecrotch and freckles. That babe got the blood flowing in me if you know what I mean.’”

“Where’s this guy incarcerated at?”

“Don’t worry about that now. ‘ Brought back memories. Back when we painted houses. Cleaned gutters. Those were the days. Sometimes, I wonder why J hasn’t visited. But I’m sure it’s for good reason. Well, it seems like mother like daughter. I’m gonna keep an eye out for word from J. You do the same. Peace. P.’

“So we need to find out who ‘J’ is.”

“And why the SDPD doesn’t want me to look into it.”

“So your mother. She sounds involved. Could have known too much. Mob?”

“There’s not much of that here. But it’s not cartel. But it’s definitely organized.”

“I’m familiar with painting houses. But cleaning the gutters?”

“I’m not sure. But plenty of rabbit holes to dive through.”

“Willmee?” 

Will stiffened and looked up. Her father stood before her, a dark shadow, her heart pounding in her ears from the sudden surprise.

Willmee?” Hoffman sounded incredulous. “Who’s that?”

“My father. I need to go.” She hung up before hearing Hoffman respond. “Hey Dad, sorry, did I wake you?”

“No, I was just getting some water. I didn’t know you were home. What a nice surprise.” he smiled, but he was watching her with hyper focus. His pale blue eyes glowed despite the darkness. 

“Sorry, I should have called.”

“Don’t apologize Willme. I’m just happy to have everyone back under the same roof.” 

“Yeah. Almost everyone,” Will replied, holding back the emotion that threatened to make her cry. “I miss Mom.”

His eyes softened. “She sure was something, wasn’t she?” He sat next to her. “You look so much like her, you know? Last I remember, you were this little tyke. Barely a teenager. And now, you’re older than when I…” he covered his face, sniffling. “So much time, gone.”

She turned to her Dad, the pain something she couldn’t run away from now. “Yeah.” She had hoped a good night’s sleep would have made it easier to handle this reunion. She didn’t know what to do. “You know, I became a cop because I wanted to find the men who did this to her.”

Her father nodded. “Bram told me that. But Willmee…” he hesitated, “don’t you have a life to go back to?”

She blinked, confused. “I do, but I also have a life here too. And I’m here now.”

“Why?”

“What do you mean ‘why’? Because I can be and now I can finally find who killed mom. Don’t you want me to find that out? To find out who hurt you?”

“But why do you feel like it’s your responsibility? Let the police here handle that.”

“Dad, did Bram not explain -” she let out a sigh. “I used to work SDPD.”

“Really?” There was a sudden shift in his tone, almost anger.

Damn it. She knew it was unrealistic to expect her little brother to have filled him in. But explaining it all now just felt too damn hard. “Yes, Dad. And they didn’t do shit for her. For you. And they won’t.”

They sat in a long silence, until finally, her father was the first to speak. “Wilmee, you’re tired. Let’s go to bed and talk about it in the morning.”

And she found herself relieved he was sparing her any questions. Any prying. She was thankful for him, always able to match her need to simply push off the discomfort and focus on the actions right in front of you.

“Thanks Dad, see you in the morning, then.” She leaned in to give him a quick hug, got up and went to her room.

“Sleep well, Wilhelmina.”

Notes:

A/N: This was a long one, 21 pages according to google docs. I think I'm finally getting some motivation back. Now it's just a matter of time. This summer has been one of the busiest of my life. And this year as a whole has had a lot of struggle for my loved ones. I hope this story can bring some enjoyment to others. Thank you for reading~